Discussion Locked

Exchange 5.5 and RAID Configuration

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am responsible for setting up a new dual pentium server with Windows NT 4.0 and its primary function will be an Exchange Server (version 5.5). I am using a mirrored RAID configuration for the boot and system files and a RAID 5 configuration of four disks for exchange (all using ultr2 LVDS SCSI disks).
My question relates to setting up the stripe sizes. I can set a stripe size on the hardware RAID of 2-128KB. I know that if the applications perform mostly sequential reads, a larger stripe size provides better performance. Whereas a smaller stripe size performs better if the applications perform random read requests more often.
I am not sure what type of processing to expect from Exchange server (sequential or random). Secondly, I am not sure if it will even make a difference at all on the size of the stripe on the hardware side. When I load NT 4.0 server and initially create and format the partition on the RAID 5 drive, what is the relationship between the hardware stripe size and how the drive is formated? Secondly, if the hardware stripe size is a factor in performance in this situation, can you tell me what the optimal stripe size should be for the RAID 5 array and is there an optimal or recommended size for the NT 4.0 NOS on a mirrored set? Thanks for any help you can give.
leo.kreifels@nelinc.ang.af.mil

5 replies

by wirejockey

I'll have to make this short, first I recommend the following book; "Managing Microsoft Exchange Server", by Paul Robichaux and published by O'Reilly. Chapter 18 explains Exchange performance. I haven't found anything specifically about the size of the stripe, and it does not mention sequential or random read/write requests specifically, but I assume they are sequential because Exchange/NT manages read/writes with a disk I/O queue. Here are some excerpts from this chapter. "How do you choose the RAID level that's right for you? If the I/O mix is 30-50% read operations (the range where Exchange typically operates), then RAID 0+1 is from 65-80% more efficient than RAID-5." In a RAID Level table it talks about Read Performance Characteristics: RAID-5 "Short reads (those less than the RAID chunk size) can be handled in the same amount of time as a single read operation. Longer reads take proportionally longer." This may help, but get the book. Good Luck!

by splash4500

I guess I didn't give it enough Tech points. If I was going to buy a book to get the answer or recommendation, I wouldn't have asked the question...

by ewing bettles

If you have access to Microsoft Technet, there is an excellent white paper titled "BackOffice Server 4.5 on Windows 2000 Server Performance Characterization" that provides some very good hardware/software performance tips. This paper recommends setting an 8k or 16k stripe set for RAID5 configurations, with the NTFS file system residing on the RAID5 volume being formatted with a 16k allocation size.

I have an exchange server in my organization that I have configured using a hardware RAID controller (HP NetRAID 3Si) and Ultra2 LVDS SCSI disks (as you've stated for your config). 2 drives are configured RAID1 for the system files, 2 other drives are RAID1 for Exchange transaction logging, 5 drives are RAID5 for the Information Store and Public Folders, and one Global Hot Spare. The RAID5 array is configured with a 16k stripe size and all volumes are configured with 16k allocation units. This configuration provides verifiably good performance. Other config stats:

Dual Processor Pentium 450 XEON
3Gb RAM
1500 Active Exchange Mailboxes

Hope this helps, -Ewing

by splash4500

Thanks Ewing,
The white paper is excellent. It was definitely a big help as was your response. I didn't realize the points I assign to the question go to the one with the acceptable answer. I guess I should have assigned more points to this one. Anyway, thanks again
splash4500

This discussion is closed to new replies.