Discussion Locked

Extremely Stupid MIT Student wears fake bomb into airport

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

news of the ODD! Happy Friday

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070921/ap_on_re_us/fake_bomb_15

http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=3635225&page=1

MIT has apparently lowered their standards. This ID10T wore a tshirt with an actual circuit board on the outside into an airport. And was carrying a lump of play-doh.

Doh!

I'm sorry if this sounds mean but maybe police should have 'culled the herd'. I can't believe how dumb this person is. I think she must have eaten something to trigger 'mad cow disease'

This act in itself would be mean if I didn't really think she was a low grade moron. And she claimed was 'art'. I guess the police could have claimed it was finishing the 'artwork' by taking her out with deadly force.

Wait! I know, maybe it was a scientific experiment, to determine how many people in the media / internet call her stupid! I guess I would have been more impressed if she'd invented an invisibility field to hide the bomb; or perhaps a deflector shield to keep away all the comments people are bound to say about how dumb she is :)

And all her friends were 'She didn't mean anything' I guess our security should depend on us holding up lines for hours while police consult vague groups of 'friends' to 'see if this person would actually have or setoff a {insert one:} [bomb]|[bioweapon]|[gun]'

This is almost as bad as programmers putting in code that can buffer overflow.
Hactro NOT reclaimed! :)

51 replies

by dr dij

For the rest of her life, people will be pointing and whispering -- "there's the dumb &*^*& who faked a bomb and plastic explosive at an airport!!"

I doubt she'd get secret clearance now and I doubt, no matter how well she does at MIT people will take her seriously or hire her for a serious job, fund research, etc. I'm even thinking she'll flunk out of MIT

What was she thinking? Apparently she wasn't, probably 'hard of thinking' as they say politely.

by absolutely

She already got into MIT. Now, she's set
the record for closest to getting shot by
airport security for terrorism, but
surviving unharmed. She'll go far in life.

You, Dr Dij, are the one who
is "probably 'hard of thinking' as they say
politely."

by big ole jack

She'll probably be put on the terrorist watchlist by the dept of homeland security or end up spending some time in the looney bin having her stupid noggin examined for psychiatric issues. There has got to be something seriously effed up about a person who fakes a bomb in an airport and considers it "art". Not to get political or anything, but this kind crap is typical of pinko ultra-liberal morons from Berzerkely University and now the disease has spread to MIT and soon Harvard and Yale will follow suit. If I were her, I'd simply go jump off a cliff because I doubt there is a single place in this country that would hire her after such an idiotic stunt. She may as well pack up her bags and move to the middle east where they welcome such fanatic nuts who love to strap bombs on, whether fake or real, but real preferred.

by big ole jack

I wouldn't be surprised if her folks were behind her stupid little stunt. Crap like this no longer flies as we are not in the 1960s', contrary to what some of those old time hippie parents think. People get shot for such stupidity and rightfully so. Had this been in NYC's JFK airport, given our direct connection to 9/11 and our heightened terror level, the NYPD and the TSA would have turned her into swiss cheese with their M-16s' and Glocks. The cops in MA have better restraint, but I tell you from experience that our cops would have blown her stupid ass away first and ask questions later because they don't play that crap.

by mjd420nova

I got a close look at the "circuit board" she had and I actually have a few of them myself. They are prototype boards or called super strips, used to design and test circuit designs before actually making a PCB. Now the play-doh was really stupid, as that could actually be mistaken for plastic explosive. I'll really bet that set the TSA people running, AWAY. The flagrant display of it would have given any knowledgable person a real laugh in spite of the obvious inplications of what it COULD be.

by dr dij

and you well could wire a bomb with one.

Make pretty much anything you want.

Of course some bombers would want to hide the bomb but in banks they open their vest to show the wires and dynamite.

I don't think we need to train TSA people in circuit analysis so they can determine if a weird looking board is a bomb?

by w2ktechman

But maybe she was trying to make a statement?
Ok, for the most part, keeping it visable was a good idea, but she executed this in very poor taste. The play dough was just plain stupid. The wires would have been an overdo as well.
Honestly, WTF was she thinking (or not)? Without the play dough though, they probably would have only detained her shortly. Without the wires, they probably would not have even had their guns out.
Oh Well, another career ruined due to stupidity.
She should kill herself now, or just start walking the streets!

by danlm

Was raise her hands immodestly when she was told to. And offered no resistance. They were ready to blow her away.

She quite obviously recognized what might happen wearing that as a fashion statement and was prepared to give up instantly. That was planned by her to make a statement. I have no idea what it might be, but art was not it.

Dan

by big ole jack

And I wouldn't be surprised if she got that idiotic idea from some socialist minded libturd professor in her university. Seems like those ivy league colleges have a bone to pick with our national security and are always finding new and stupid ways of making political statements. Case in point... Columbia University in NYC has asked the Iranian psycho of a president to make a speech at their campus. If that isn't socialist anti-American liberalism at work, then I don't know what is? MIT, Yale, and Harvard are no different.

by dr dij

I really think anyone who would do this is a low-grade moron. I don't think she had any lofty motives. And even if she speaks I don't really want to hear anything she says. Kind of like muting ads on TV. Toxic if you listen to them.

by bshaw400

I don't recall any mention of peaceniking in her "art" display. In any event, she just demonstrates stupidity and I don't think even the Ivy leagues would condone or agree with what she did.
Now you might get the NAACP to put forth some right to free speech or demonstration kind of stuff but that really applies to ALL idiots like the KKK, militias, NRA, and other rightwing ninnies just like their left-winged lamer brethren. But that belongs on another post.

by thechas

Many brilliant scientists and engineers are very inept when it comes to social situations.

Looking at the pictures, I can see the art and signs of someone who may be socially inept.

Anyone with electronics training would readily recognize the "device" as a "Proto-Board" with no components. The outfit would make for a great Halloween or April Fools Day gag at an electronics school or company.

That said, no one with any degree of social "smarts" would wear it out in public let alone at an airport.

I suspect that rather than an engineer or scientist, she will end up as an artist.

Chas

by dr dij

with wires and LEDs, components could have been soldered to the wire connections and hidden on the other side.

I don't think we have to give TSA checkers a course in circuit board analysis.

by thechas

Don't get me wrong, I think the TSA acted properly and did the right thing.

My point was that the proto board on her shirt would look pretty darn menacing to most people, but an engineer would not get excited about it.

Perhaps I work with too many eccentric engineers, but I could see a number of them performing similar feets of social stupidity.

Chas

by tig2

Of the debate- Was Maplethorpe's photography pornographic? Or art? And in that debate, we were discussing black and white, homosexually focused photography in the then potentially explosive world of religious freedom (my way) versus the world of liberalism (your way sucks, mine is better).

This idiot should have known better than to take her "art" into the public eye of intolerance against anything that even remotely looks terroristic. I don't give a rip about her motivations, I care deeply that her "free-spiritedness" could have reasonably caused panic. It obviously caused a great deal of concern.

And I don't really give a rip if it was a circuit board or a breadboard (yes, I am that old). The FACT is that most folks don't know the difference.

I sincerely hope she spends the rest of her life asking people if they "want fries with that?"

by dr dij

was that public money was used for something that people didn't agree with.

I thought his exhibit was stupid but have no problem with stupid people paying the full cost of the exhibit to go see it. Inatead there is an assinine subsidy of 'art' while people are hungry and need social services.

by absolutely

"The REAL Maplethorpe obscenity was that public money was used for something that [b]people didn't agree with[/b]."

Art is a matter of very personal taste. Wouldn't it also be obscene, even if those people [b]did agree[/b] with the subject of the art? Or is there a double standard I don't know about?

by jdclyde

in actual function between the circuit board and the breadboard other than one is integrated into the board. both could have lead to the same results with a lead running to whatever is behind the board or under her shirt.

guess we need to insist she take off her shirt? ]:)

by locrian_lyric

but even *I* have enough sense to think twice about doing anything THAT ludicrous.

The thing is, it is not the first time some stupid art student(s) have done something like this.

Do you remember those idiots at NYU who placed backpacks all over the NY city subways as an "art project"?

by dr dij

but I really think she's unhinged. I doubt she'll succeed at MIT. They probably think things thru carefully before they do them.

Would you want to be:
1) a room-mate with this person?
2) be in a lecture room with her?
3) have her helping you around the lab?

She sounds like Bart Simpson's dumb sister. (Not Lisa or Maggie)

by jdclyde

except for the militia members that also join the NRA, (who CAN be quite insane) it is not a radical nut group, and it has ALWAYS advocated for tougher enforcement of existing laws.

Learn a little about them before you show your ignorance.

by absolutely

"...it is not a radical nut group, and it has ALWAYS advocated for tougher enforcement of existing laws."

Their views are outside the mainstream. That doesn't make them nuts, but "fringe" might be a fair term to apply. Also, when they make news, it's very often to oppose some especially lame-brain paragraph of a misguided gun control law, but the news coverage also tends to be brief, and thus to portray them merely as "opposing gun control". I think the NRA performs a very important function, protecting the 2nd Amendment, which in turn helps keep the other Amendments from being entirely nullified by the collectivist vote-mongers. But, I also recognize that they appear a bit wacko, until you own a gun and study gun control laws.

by jmgarvin

So, originally, it was stated that she was wearing a block of playdough and a circuit board...now it seems she was just wearing a circuit board, no block of playdough.

To make matters worse, Boston has a reputation for not being up on things:
http://www.boston.com/news/globe/ideas/brainiac/2007/01/attack_of_the_m.html
http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/01/31/boston.bombscare/index.html

I think it was a matter of the TSA and local police over reacting, again, over something that was obviously nothing.

To me this proves that the TSA and local police are doing nothing to hinder or stop terrorism, and maybe...just maybe are actually helping the terrorist by playing into their stupid game.

by tig2

None of the reports I read indicated that she was doing anything with the playdough except holding it in her hand. None of the stories that I read indicated that there was a block of anything strapped to her.

The country needs to figure out what it wants. The TSA is over-zealous and that is a bad thing. They aren't zealous enough, it's a bad thing. Heaven forbid that anything happen- they will take the first fall.

Either way, the stunt was stupid. To me, it is the moral equivalent of screaming "fire" in a crowded room- something illegal, by the way.

Only in retrospect do we know that the situation was nothing of importance. At the time, I will bet that there were some scared people.

I find the conclusion that the police and TSA are helping terrorists interesting and am curious as to how you arrived at it. I know that in Israel a prospective passenger is monitored quite closely while in the terminal. They make no secret of this and state that they are trying to keep things safer. It appears to work.

Boston Logan has the dubious distinction of being the point of origin for the 9/11 flights. I would hazard a guess that they haven't had much of a sense of humour for the past 6 years.

by absolutely

should they not have called a bomb squad on the double, as soon as they detained the suspect? Isn't the car ride to jail inherently inconsistent with the suspicion of a bomb [b]on her person[/b]? I guess they already knew by then that her device did nothing more than light some LEDs. But then, the way I see it, from the moment they determined that her putty was mere Play-Doh they knew that her work was in fact just art and not an attempted imitation of a bomb, ie not a "hoax" but a misunderstanding -- on their part.

An "average" cop probably was an "average" high school student, something the "average" MIT student knows absolutely nothing about. Since high school, she's learned even more beyond the 3 R's. It's no easier for her to know what is and isn't common knowledge to those cops than it is for one of them to wake up knowing five years of electronic engineering. We should excuse her for over-estimating the average person's intelligence and not presume to consider her anything other than innocent, unless and until proven so lawfully.

by jmgarvin

1) The TSA has played into what the terrorist want, restrictions on our freedoms.

2) The government is SO focused on narrow little security points, that you could probably smuggle a nuclear weapon through the Port of Oakland, and nobody would be the wiser.

3) Baggage throwers aren't checked throughly and neither are packages going on planes, just passengers....How hard would it be to find a midget or 5 willing to hijack a plane or blow it up?

I know it sounds silly, but think about it...

4) We are ignoring the realities. Sure, we pull granny aside and pat her down, but what is that really doing?

by danlm

You seem quick to point out all of the problems, how about pointing out what you think should be done?

You have ignored the fact that they have placed various geiger counters at the ports and around major cities. And that they are developing and deploying more powerful portable ones to make it easier to place them where they are most needed.

So, again. What would you do? you seem quick to critisize, but very slow to offer solutions. Which doesnt supprize me in the least, but that is besides the point.

Dan

by jmgarvin

1) Drop the TSA and offer real airport security or go back to the moderate security we once had. Don't play games and call it security.

What I'm talking about here is confiscating water bottle, frisking old ladies, or making a mother drink her own breast milk is NOT security.

What is security? Well, we wouldn't put up with it, but how about TARGETING those that would most likely hijack planes...I donno, call me crazy, but a 7 year old most probably SHOULDN'T be on the do not fly list and labeled a "potential threat."

2) A little bit of lead goes a long way to making those geiger counters useless. So, how about we actually INSPECT more cargo? How about we hire people that are WELL TRAINED (and well paid) to check what is coming into our country. How about actually making an attempt to see what's coming into our country?

3) Baggage throwers aren't checked throughly and neither are packages going on planes, just passengers....How hard would it be to find a midget or 5 willing to hijack a plane or blow it up?

So, how do we fix it? How about background checks for the baggage throwers. How about checking the baggage of those that actually might want to blow up the plane rather than the 80 year old woman or 7 year old kid?

The ultimate solution is to put the onus on the shippers and airlines, rather than on the government...when was the last time the government ever ran right.

by danlm

[i]What I'm talking about here is confiscating water bottle, frisking old ladies, or making a mother drink her own breast milk is NOT security.[/i]
Yes or no, was this security put in place BECAUSE there was a security threat discovered via liquids. Or don't you think that counts? You are ignoring something that actually happened because of inconvenience. Stupid, moronic.
[i]2) A little bit of lead goes a long way to making those Geiger counters useless. So, how about we actually INSPECT more cargo? How about we hire people that are WELL TRAINED (and well paid) to check what is coming into our country. How about actually making an attempt to see what's coming into our country?[/i]

Ok brain boy, how do you inspect the THOUSANDS of containers of cargo? You willing to pay the price for higher goods? You now offer a solution that can cause goods to rot on the peers and at the airports. Shortage of goods caused by security delays. Destruction of food products due to them rotting because of your security precautions. You first bitch and moan because you are stopped and searched at the airport, but you want all goods checked which would cause shortages nation wide.

[i]3) Baggage throwers aren't checked thoroughly and neither are packages going on planes, just passengers....How hard would it be to find a midget or 5 willing to hijack a plane or blow it up?[/i]
You actualy said something that made sence. Blows my mind.

What goes around comes around. I find as many holes in your arguments as you find in the security that is in place. You think the government needs to do better. I think you do also. Your solutions are not practical or doable. You ignore what is working, why some was put in place. And offer conflicting solutions.

Think again, your solutions have caused the following problems.
1). There has been a loss of lives because of liquid explosives that are now being smuggled onto planes without being checked. Duuu, how many lives lost because you don't like being searched.
2). Your searching of all goods entering the country has caused the following problems.
a). Delivery of food products has been held at the border for inspection on each shipment to the point there are now food shortages nation wide.
b). Imported medicines are no longer getting to market and various sickness's have now reached epidemic stage. Again because of the amount of detail security inspections at the ports.
c). Raw materials that are required for manufacturing are no longer making it to the factories on time for products to produced. There are now shortages of all kinds of products nation wide and it has now effected the nations economy because of exports. We no longer can export because we can no longer produce enough products for our own population. Again due to these materials sitting on the doc to be inspected in a detail fashion.
d). Unemployment is now in double digits due to factories closing their doors due to a shortage of raw materials. This has caused a run on the food kitchens which can not feed this influx of people. Again, because there is a shortage of food products. And damn, again. Because the food is rotting on the docs.

Good answers. Real good answers. Remind me not to ask you for any advise. Your conflicting, and will cause me to be out of work and starving in a very short time. Or dead because you have allowed explosives to be smuggled onto the plane I was taking to find a job in some other country that don't have people like you running it.

Dan

by danlm

TSA reacted properly. It's easy to disguise things to look innocent.

I would have blown her stupid a$$ away if she moved if I was them. And so would have they. She deserved all of the ridicule and abuse she is getting. She should be made to pay a fine for the cost's incurred because of her stupid stunt.

What a moron. And your comments are starting me to wonder about you also.

Dan

by danlm

Your quick to critisize, be ready to be critized. I ripped your arguments apart point by point. You didn't even have the ability to counter my points. Which says you never thought out your solutions in the first place. Which is why I found it so easy to find fault with them.

Your link is irrelevant to the thread. I?m not even going to bother with it.

Dan

Dan

by danlm

roflmao, it just took clarification on both our parts to see it

;o). Works for me.

Dan

by danlm

But most likely true.

Can you hear the granny's at tea afterwards.

Oh honey, he had such STRONG hands... I thought I would wet myself I was so excited.

roflmao, god... That is just wrong.

Dan

by danlm

I starting laffing as I read your post and thats the first thing that came to my mind.

You know granny wouldn't want to swear, so that was the first thing that came to mind about her description.

Lol, again. I'm sorry.

Dan

by jmgarvin

1) The threat was identified as MIDDLE EASTERN MEN planning an attack using liquids. What is really irritating is that I can buy liquid inside the terminal...So what if one of my buddies is working there and slips me some fuel and bleach? Now, I bring it on the plane in water bottles, it's perfectly fine to do that..

Pointless security that isn't protecting anyone.

2) We inspect less than 1% of the cargo coming into the country. How about either inspecting 0% or at least a sample size that is statistically relevant?

"1). There has been a loss of lives because of liquid explosives that are now being smuggled onto planes without being checked. Duuu, how many lives lost because you don't like being searched."

I could already do it. Confiscating water bottles at security is doing NOTHING to stop me from bringing a bomb onto the plane. It's not hard to get a job INSIDE the airport, and then once inside hand my buddies simple cleaner chemicals to make a bomb.

So easy, a caveman could do it.

"2). Your searching of all goods entering the country has caused the following problems."

No it hasn't. My stance is that statistically what we are searching is not relevant so it should be 0% or a statistically relevant amount of cargo.

"a). Delivery of food products has been held at the border for inspection on each shipment to the point there are now food shortages nation wide."

Oh please. We produce so much food here it's silly...who cares if we export a bomb with our food sources.

"b). Imported medicines are no longer getting to market and various sickness's have now reached epidemic stage. Again because of the amount of detail security inspections at the ports."

Oh please again..
A) We could produce them here is needed
B) Triage containers

"c). Raw materials that are required for manufacturing are no longer making it to the factories on time for products to produced. There are now shortages of all kinds of products nation wide and it has now effected the nations economy because of exports. We no longer can export because we can no longer produce enough products for our own population. Again due to these materials sitting on the doc to be inspected in a detail fashion."

Then why can't I bring on water to a plane? If I bring anything into the country, why not water on a plane?

"d). Unemployment is now in double digits due to factories closing their doors due to a shortage of raw materials. This has caused a run on the food kitchens which can not feed this influx of people. Again, because there is a shortage of food products. And damn, again. Because the food is rotting on the docs."

Uh, there is VERY little manufacturing in the US anymore. I highly DOUBT this would put unemployment into the double digits.

You are arguing on passion and not reality. The problem is that Homeland Security is doing NOTHING for security...neither is the TSA or any of the other plans we've put in place since 9/11.

Either we do it for real or we don't do it at all...right now, it's just a waste of tax payer money.

by danlm

If you don't, then everyone should be searched. Because anyone can be a terrorist.

If you think profileing should be used, I am all for your position.

Dan

by danlm

[i]1) The threat was identified as MIDDLE EASTERN MEN planning an attack using liquids. What is really irritating is that I can buy liquid inside the terminal...So what if one of my buddies is working there and slips me some fuel and bleach? Now, I bring it on the plane in water bottles, it's perfectly fine to do that..[/i]

Your advocating profileing. Get ready for the law suits. If it stops one bomb, that is more then enough.

2) We inspect less than 1% of the cargo coming into the country. How about either inspecting 0% or at least a sample size that is statistically relevant?[/I]
Thank you for clarifying, I totally agree.

[i]1). There has been a loss of lives because of liquid explosives that are now being smuggled onto planes without being checked. Duuu, how many lives lost because you don't like being searched."

I could already do it. Confiscating water bottles at security is doing NOTHING to stop me from bringing a bomb onto the plane. It's not hard to get a job INSIDE the airport, and then once inside hand my buddies simple cleaner chemicals to make a bomb.

So easy, a caveman could do it.[/i]

I think it shows by the fact there has not been any more hijacking that what is in place is working. These percautions put in place are not just in this country. Why do you feel it is wrong then?

[i]"2). Your searching of all goods entering the country has caused the following problems."[/i]
Again, thank you for clarifying.

[i]c). Raw materials that are required for manufacturing are no longer making it to the factories on time for products to produced. There are now shortages of all kinds of products nation wide and it has now effected the nations economy because of exports. We no longer can export because we can no longer produce enough products for our own population. Again due to these materials sitting on the doc to be inspected in a detail fashion."

Then why can't I bring on water to a plane? If I bring anything into the country, why not water on a plane?[/i]

This actualy is an easy answer. Numbers and location. It is alot easier to siphon passengers through choke points for searching then it is at the various ports.

[i]"d). Unemployment is now in double digits due to factories closing their doors due to a shortage of raw materials. This has caused a run on the food kitchens which can not feed this influx of people. Again, because there is a shortage of food products. And damn, again. Because the food is rotting on the docs."

Uh, there is VERY little manufacturing in the US anymore. I highly DOUBT this would put unemployment into the double digits. [/i]

Im working, Im assuming you are working also? I live in Cleveland Ohio, sposidly one of the poorest cities in the nation. Looking out my window I see raw materials passing by every day in various trucks. There are jobs that would be lost.

[i]You are arguing on passion and not reality. The problem is that Homeland Security is doing NOTHING for security...neither is the TSA or any of the other plans we've put in place since 9/11. [/i]
I think you are also arguing on passion and not reality. You are missing the reality that these procedures now in place have saved lives. That TSA has done things right. Is there room for improvement, absolutely. But to chuck it all and start over is foolish. You work with what you have and make it better. Especially when we are dealign with the size of the logestics involved.

Dan

by tig2

I think that student should have her hide tanned- her little stunt was nothing more than ridiculous.

I haven't flown in years. The reason I refuse to fly is that I wear a prosthesis. And the TSA- while they will allow me to fly with it- also requires that I surrender it at check points.

Just so sorry, but I will not reach down the front of my blouse and publicly remove it for the purpose of handing it to someone to examine. Screw them. I can drive or stay home.

My intention is not to defend the TSA. My intention is to point out that the brainiac that came up with this scheme did way more harm than good.

by jmgarvin

The TSA (and most government run anything) is poorly run. Their SOP is vague and there is a total lack of decorum when it comes to picking out people.

It irritates me that every time I fly, *I* get inspected because of my laptop, or hdd, or memory stick, or cell phone, or head phones, but they let the guy making a delivery to the news stand just breeze by...wtf?

This discussion is closed to new replies.