Fighting a futile war
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by neon samurai
True, I'm not saying that indavidually everyone is now ruled by there own terror. I'm saying that overall, the US has become a nation governed by terror. "It's to protect you from terrorists" is still very powerful justification for most anything the polititions want to do. Searches the border, phone and data channel taps, warrentless search, new forms of national ID with worse security than the old forms.. and on.. and on..
I agree that any group or indavidual intentionaly harming others by terror tactics, gorrilla tactics or head on confrontation needs to be stopped. I just think there is a line between protecting the people of your nation from a real threat and protecting the interests of the polititions based on an over inflated threat perception.
Before it was commie's.. oh noes.. there's a commie under everyone's bed.. get your pitch forks and torches.. This same red scare hysteria seems to have been repackaged under the latest hype brand name and just look at all the new policy it's been used to justify.
If the goal of terrorism is to change how your target lives in reaction to there fear of you then it seems too have been very successful.
(I was happily surprised to see that the border search went quick and easy after reading some of the stories)
I think one of the best resonses I've seen is at the end of the Penn and Teller's BS episode on "Ground Zero" (dunt.. dunt.. daaa). They end the show by looking at a few mock up moddels of what the new twin towers should look like. They look at what has actually been preposed then look at there own suggestions; a tower fo pizza and a tower of beef. The last one they look at is the "what we should really do after giving it some serious though" and it's a mock up of the two towers; just as they where, "business as usual". That is freaking brilliant; business as usual, towers rebuilt, moving on, you terrorists where a passing itch.
I am glad that many indaviduals continue to leave there houses unafraid such as yourself though. The correct response really is just that.
by notsochiguy
This is just my opinion, but watching Hillary through the years (starting with her decision not to divorce Bill...a strategic move if ever there was one) is like watching Anakin Skywalker in Episodes I-III of Star Wars after having already watched IV-VI.
You know exactly how things are going to play out, and see all of the tell tale signs along the way...and you wonder why none of the other characters see it.
Simply put: she is the most brazenly obvious power-hungry person I've ever set two eyes upon in my lifetime. Equal parts of Lex Luthor and Londo from Babylon 5 rolled into one. If she is elected, I'll know the Mayans were right (2012 being the end of the next Presidential term and all). ;)
As for McCain, disability has ZERO to do with performance. As I recall, FDR was in a wheelchair, and he's probably in the discussion for greatest American president (I don't think he was, personally, but I can see someone making valid arguments for it).
Anyone bringing that up, as opposed to age or overall health (like you said, totally legit), is going for a low blow.
by neon samurai
I read it too mean "should I then come across the pond and treat Charlton Heston like a british criminal since what he does in the US would be against the law in England". Now, I don't know if your example accounted for possession of hadn granades being against the law in one home and not in the other.
I think closer would be saying that if the US felt that there neighbour was threatening them that they should too the regional police instead of taking there baseball bat over too there neighbour's house.
If his meaning is that he should be justified in comeing over too the US and shooting Mr Heston (definately in bad taste if he'd died from a gun shot wound) then that is what the US did. Granted, nations don't always have a policing third party to involve. I don't remember the details clearly enough to say if the US had first called for UN involvement in there defense. I do remember "we're going to go over to his house and pound him, who's with us?" - and that's where the WMD come in.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
You're right on the money there. I'd love to catch that in reruns.
Sitcom, when as rich as Barney Miller, can't be beat. Unfortunately, there are too few of those around. :(
by boxfiddler Hot topic
"Simply put: she is the most brazenly obvious power-hungry person I've ever set two eyes upon in my lifetime."
Nail, head.
Bingo.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by ic-it
That would only document the standard.
Objectives are always set though.
Part of the military frustration is that we fought for many years to get control/respect back to the military. On a simplified explanation - This was to put things back on course i.e. the Commander in Chief would discuss scenarios with his Chief of Staffs, Objectives and plans (note: scenario planning is always being conducted and revised)would be established, and then the military would be able to conduct the operation without second guessing and interference.
This methodology was broken when the decision was made to press forward with the planning and execution of the War in Iraq. Had the military planners concerns been followed, nothing would have happened until Afganistain was secured.
by jiminpa
I'm not going to beat a dead horse with the WMD's I will take for granted from reading my previous posts you know where I stand. Iraq was also known to harbor terrorists both from Al-Qaeda as well as other anti-US groups. Iraq had no intention of assisting us in the caputre of any of the terrorist groups/individual who were plotting against us and our allies and while not a good reason on its own, when you add the fact that he was committing genecide to the mix you start to have some pretty good reasons to invade.
I am disgusted with the UN security council because I really don't believe the United States should have been the point nation. It should have been a collective effort after Iraq chose to ignore the final resolution given by the counsel.
Before anyone jumps all over me again, I realize there were no WMD's in Iraq. I think that point has been conceded and can be dropped but Iraq did nothing to help their case in proving they had none prior to the invasion.
by jiminpa
I do not believe that as an American we have the right to do any of that.
It doesn't matter what type of government is in place when we leave, if the peolpe do not continue to fight to be free they will never remain free.
by jdclyde
And the way our own media covers events, I wouldn't have been surprised if you thought all Americans are walking around, looking over their shoulders constantly looking for terrorists.
A happy middle ground should be reached.
If there is a nation that is hosting training camps, put them on notice and level the camps, each and everytime they are found. (listening Syria?)
If we find evidence that the CIA really is selling drugs to pay for wars, it should be a capital offense.
We should know who comes into the country, if you have gotten yourself on a list, you will be watched, as well you should.
There are organizations out there that will not go away if ignored, as the British painfully found out.
by $$$$$$$$$$
1. Saddam -- done
2. WMD -- done
3. Be greeted as liberators -- not doable
Conclusion: Get out.
PS Not rocket science.
by jdclyde
I was almost afraid to read your post, in case you were defending Hilary. It would have been a sad day for me.
With all the clear evidence about her, it amazes me that otherwise intellegent people can support her. And ANYONE that vote for her because she sometimes shares a bed with an ex-president is a retard.
by neon samurai
The people responsible for the twin towers attack where extremists from Afganistan, why is the US not there still if it's so important to those who lost there lives in the trade centre?
Tirany must be stopped where possible but that doesn't meant you get to invade a country then say "sorry, we really had no good reason but hey, the ends justify the means right?"
by puppybreath
Yes and no.
We are the target of Islamic jihadists.
We need to hunt them down and kill them, and kill those who would help them.
THAT is why we are in Iraq.
by neon samurai
I don't take anything the media tells me as the final word regardless of nation. Your right though, some of it is justified; the happy medium is the part that remains missing.
(sidenote, I was in Orlando at Orange Lake for a week.. I can see why people retire there)
by jdclyde
"Stop or I shall say stop again!"
"If the UN is the answer, it was a dumb question".
by jiminpa
They hit us first... They started it.
;)
by ic-it
That is why we are still in Iraq.
We went into Afghanistan to react to their training camps and Taliban control that provided a base for the Islamic jihadists.
There was no serious presence in Iraq and certainly less so than in other areas at the time.
There was a presence of Al Qaeda in Iraq, how serious... we don't know.
We *do* know that Saddam was supporting Hamas and also the martyr's brigade to the tune of $25K US per suicide bomber to the suicide bomber's family. That's more than a palestinian can hope to make in a lifetime and therefore a serious incentive.
It is also worth noting that Syria's military technology made a quantum leap since the Iraq war started.
by ic-it
and also that there were other nations and/or rich families also doing the same. The targets were not in the US, but could indeed include US citizens. I guess what I am saying is that these factors did not distinguish a reason for going into Iraq any more than going into Saudia Arabia, Lybia, Lebanon, Palistinian lands et al. And job 1 was and should have stayed with Afghanistan and Bin Laden.
Finish job one and then go play in Iraq. It may not have been justified then either, however our troops would have been much better off.
Very true Syria is benifiting from being a closer nation to Israel (or is being setup as a firing range rather than Iran) :-)
by jamesrl
We know exactly how much Al Qaeda was involved in Saddam's time. They had a camp. In the northern Kurdish area where Saddam's forces dare not go. Where Saddam's planes and helicopters were prohibited from flying.
Yes there were a few meetings. But Bin Laden hated Saddam because he Saddam was a SECULARIST. Saddam was not for a rise in power by the mullahs, they wanted him overthrown. Bin Laden was Saddam's enemy. There are many Bin Laden quotes where he wished him gone. Saddam only became a Muslim when it suited his purpose, like when he sought to rally muslims against the US.
James
by maecuff
by $$$$$$$$$$
No?
Unctuous.
[i]And no, I don't need any other reason.[/i]
I do, and it was easy to say that then. The reasons most Americans, and most of Congress, approved the invasion [b]are lies[/b]. We KNOW that now, but they were discovered gradually enough, many people still aren't calling them lies.
The information available to Bush, and the Senate Intelligence Committee, was not just different, but [b]opposite[/b] the conclusions presented to the world as "the best intelligence available to us" at that time.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]Iraq is not stable, if we leave, it will fall to Iran as S. Vietnam fell to N Vietnam. Unlike 'nam, such a course of events will create the reunion of a historical empire, run by a madman who will posess a large chunk of a resource that is vital to the world, and be within striking distance of having the majority of that resource at his control.[/i]
His "madness" is greatly exaggerated, from what I read. His wish for Israel to be blasted off the map, for example, is a mistranslation of his criticism of the [b]current, "Zionist" regime[/b] in Israel, a characterization shared by most Israelis, IIUC. And A. didn't wish Israel off the map, he is excited for some hawkish Zionists to turn over power to more moderate Israeli leaders in the next election, to put the current leaders in the past. Not wipe the nation off the map. Please, do not believe everything Rupert Murdoch tells you.
said something I can agree with.
You cannot give someone their freedom, they have to take it. If they don't fight for it they don't deserve it.
But if you accept this point of view then our governments are lying to us , or they are f'ing stupid. Probably both...
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]I do believe when you see a rabid dog, you have it put down.[/i]
He's not a rabid dog, just as much as you're a banana.
want us to enter further under US influence..
understandable desire, however, wwi, wwii, Suez, Northern Ireland. Falklands.......
by boxfiddler Hot topic
but not a mindless fool! ;)
Though in fairness I suppose I must admit to the occasional foolish moment.
by jiminpa
The point about the government lying and being f'ing stupid (regardless of party) is a point I can agree on.
:)
by nicknielsen
[i]America and its allies should have cut and run two to three years ago. I feel sure that this would have resulted in less bloodshed and loss of lives in the long run.[/i]
Have you been following the news? Do you remember stories about Sunni and Shiite warlords, gangs, death squads, and extensive civilian deaths and disappearances? Do you want more of this?
As I understand the political objective in Iraq, the US is working to restore order and unite all Iraqis against outside agents from both Iran and al-Qaida and create a stable political structure where the rule of law is paramount. I hope it works, but I'm not sure it can be done. If it can, I believe the US will be able to pull out without extensive further bloodshed. If the allies cut and run before such a structure is in place, I think we will see something to rival the killing fields not only from increased sectarian violence, but from incursions by Syria and Iran.
Think what you will of the regimes and leaders, but until 2003 the Middle East was relatively stable. The United States, by its wrongful and stupid invasion of Iraq, has destabilized the region and is now obligated to make its best attempt to return political stability to the region. We shouldn't have gone in in the first place, but because made the mess, it's our job to clean it up if at all possible.
Edit: correction
by nicknielsen
by jdclyde
to prove.
That is one can of worms they don't ever want opened because they are as deep (if not deeper) than the "other" party.
by jiminpa
by nicknielsen
by puppybreath
"No dictator is going to knowingly allow armed fanatics in his country lest they attempt to overthrow him. :
Can you please provide a list of the dictators that you've discussed this scenario with? Can you come up with at least one scenario where this wouldn't be true? I can.
This type of comment is as bad as the conservatives telling you exactly what Gore would have done if he'd been in office. If there's no way to back up what you're stating, then don't bother stating it.
It may be your opinion and you're still entitled to it no matter how wrong you are, but at least admit it's only an opinion based on very few facts.
by nicknielsen
Saddam did his best to suppress dissent for the entirety of his rule in Iraq. Do you honestly believe he would have knowingly allowed al-Qaida to operate in his country?
Links:
http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/MDE14/010/1999/en
http://www.fas.org/news/iraq/2000/02/iraq99.htm
If good sense was common, we wouldn't need a name for it.
Yes Saddam was secular, as secular as any man who had a version of the Koran written in his own blood.
But the fact remains that hatred of the common enemy of the west in general and the USA in particular is a common, uniting force.
Saddam hid his airforce in Iran during the first gulf war, and shipped much into syria prior to the invasion this time around.
NOTHING unites people more quickly or readily than a common enemy.
by puppybreath
But still possible. My point was that he was stating an opinion as fact.
With all of the stupid decisions made by world leaders in the past few years, it's unwise to determine that a leader won't take a particular course of action strictly on the basis that it would go against their principles or ideals.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by jdclyde
means nothing, as long as they are only Iraqis, didn't you get the memo?
We SHOULD allow a warlord to come in and make the place even worse than it was, so people like Julian can sit back in a few years and gloat about how things are worse and not better. Would you really deprive him of the gleefulness of watching the slaughter?
by jardinier
And yes the Iraqi deaths have reached the hundreds of thousands.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_conflict_in_Iraq_since_2003
But they are only RACIST TERM REMOVED so who really cares?
Message was edited by: Beth Blakely
by jdclyde
Don't dream to reflect your admitted bigotry upon me.
And what exactly do you think will happen if all forces pull out today like your whining should happen? Total slaughter. As for your little link, very nice.
[i][b]"[u]accuracy of the information[/u] available on different types of casualties varies greatly."[/b][/i]
It also does not [i](very contently)[/i] show the difference between the forces fighting in Iraq and the death squads taking out Iraqi citizens. A number that WILL skyrocket when we are not there.
[i]"The word "casualties" in its most general sense includes the injured as well as the dead. "[/i]
The numbers are not credible for many reasons.
First, not confirmed AND reported by groups that have a vested interest in intentionally overstating stats, gives out numbers only others that also WANT high numbers will use. That would be you.
Second, putting all injuries and deaths into the same stat also goes towards distorting the stats, quite intentionally again.
Third, if the insurgent vs citizen deaths were separate, it would show WHY we are still there, and where the rising death tolls are coming from.
You ether do not care about the slaughter that WILL happen if we pull out now, or you WANT it? There is no way you can think if we pull out, everyone in the middle east will live in love and harmony.
Once the government has their army and police forces strong enough to defend it's sell, then is the time to let them do just that.
by jardinier
I said America and its allies should have cut and run [b][u]two to three years ago.[/b][/u]I feel sure that this would have resulted in less bloodshed and loss of lives in the long run.
There WOULD have been less blood shed if they had done this 2 - 3 years ago.
As for the present situation, I think Bush only sent in extra troops in a desperate attempt to save face. Did the blood stop flowing then? Of course not.
The argument that is is America's job to clean up the mess it started is only valid if the allies working with Iraqi soldiers are in fact able to clean up the mess.
In the current situation the number of deaths of allied servicemen, Iraqi soldiers and Iraqi citizens continues to escalate.
by nicknielsen
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]You both, and the others, will go on about this interminably until you differently sort life, death, and faith. Until you do, you rise no higher than do the squads.[/i]
We deal less effectively than we desire, with what we identify as our problems, as we lump "our way" and "their way" into a non-negotiable, The Way, as if all pursue the same form of happiness.
How much of that did you intend to say?
How much did I miss?
I steal time for this from, now, endocrine function and structure, test looming.
To JD was easy. To you, as usual, will take a bit.
Your "prove" to him, and non-negotiability to me, look to be good starters. I'm looking real hard also at your "as if".
You spent appreciably more than a split second on your surmise. You put it well and thoughtfully. I can work with it.
Some adjustments...
"Pursue," for example, would take no object. The non-negotiable sees to that. Make it v.i. and try.
"The way" reminds me of how I remember Lao Tzu leaving the city. The guard at the gate implored of him to set down his wisdom in words before he left. So he sets down and writes the Do, saying those who say do not know and those who know do not say, he said.
"The Way" is like that. The definite article makes it, well, definitive. Non-negotiability does not admit of its own definition. This also leaves "prove" out in the cold.
Do I prove anything by that? I try to be solicitous of how desirous you are of facts and their chain of custody. Not. I'm being sarcastic on both counts.
So how can we "possibly hope to accomplish" the extraordinary, the non-negotiable "without presenting evidence"?
Well, if non-negotiable it cannot be accomplished. It is, perversely, fait accomplis. It is, then, a mandate, wouldn't you think?
How then can you "miss" the mandate that you are?
What a mess. Notice, though, that I ask.
by jdclyde
not quite sure how you intended that, as a complement or sarcasm....
Was there something I wasn't clear on?
by $$$$$$$$$$
I do not have any weapons of mass destruction.
Neither did Saddam Hussein.
Uh-oh, now I'm worried.
/sarcasm
by $$$$$$$$$$
He's gotten on my case a couple of times about spouting off about things I can't prove.
I notice that neither you nor jardinier have cited the sources, nor even quoted numbers: 594,000 war-related Iraqi deaths would be jardinier's number, IIRC, and jdclyde's would be in the range 50,000 - 60,000. But I'm only guessing, about your figures as much as I am about santeewelding's intended meanings. With santeewelding, I think he is deliberately terse, to force us to think about our assumptions as precondition of making out his comments. With you two, you're just leaving out facts, and I'm filling in what I've read elsewhere, which fits your respective positions.
I just don't understand why you'd argue with somebody, without presenting evidence. What can you possibly hope to accomplish this way?
by $$$$$$$$$$
You were clear, your clarity a matter of simple observation. The fondness part was only a remark.
I also have wondered critically about casualty reportage.
Although you interleaved your piece with understandable grit, you spelled out my concerns with a one, two, three.
Thank you. Jardinier may also, if he can get past the grit.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by jdclyde
as for AB, I didn't provide numbers, just questioned the different numbers julian had pointed to.
I have never heard reliable breakdown of the stats, and so refuse to quote them.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]I have never heard reliable breakdown of the stats, and so refuse to quote them.[/i]
Do you consider the US gov records incomplete also, not just the ones from the [European, if memory serves] private/academic study? I think that's what I read, and I'm suddenly more interested in what else you have to say. If so, would you mind explaining why you find those inadequate, and same for those of the source providing the much higher estimate? The deficiencies you note above all appear legitimate. Knowing to which stud[y|ies] each applies could be a great help in turning this into a much more useful conversation.
you want to affirm here that all the atrocities you mentioned in your initial post happned to an octigenarian and the student who wanted to read out some names ?
Sorry, that I do not believe.
by puppybreath
I was referring to the measures being promoted to counter terrorism.
You know the ones that apply to everybody because the terrorists don't walk about with being neon I'm a terrorists signs on their heads.
The UK is heading towards a police state faster than you guys, the anti-terrorism legislation is so 'useful'.
Last month it was being used by a local town council to see if a child lived in the correct area to automatically have a 'right' to go to a particular school.
Atrocious but not an atrocity if you see what I mean. The cure is rapidlt getting to be worse than the disease.
What went on at Abu Grhaib was an atrocity, Guantanamo is an atrocity, Belmarsh is an atrocity. OK no one got beheaded, but whether something is defined as atrocious is subjective view point based on relative conditions. After all being simply executed, might be better than certain alternatives.
You should also remember that as westerners we put a much higher (at least in public) value on life and freedom than other societies.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]Do I prove anything by that? I try to be solicitous of how desirous you are of facts and their chain of custody. Not. I'm being sarcastic on both counts.
...
How then can you "miss" the mandate that you are?[/i]
What the heck are you saying?
by $$$$$$$$$$
I'd be interested in what you have to say about how the subjects raised here so far are related to energy policies, being discussed meanwhile in other threads.
Meta-analysis of others' arguments is helpful. The quality of it leaves me wanting some content of your own.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]You know the ones that apply to everybody because the terrorists don't walk about with being neon I'm a terrorists signs on their heads.[/i]
Let's be sure to forget that those who willingly comply are, by definition, not our problem. Therefore, new laws are worthless, and improved enforcement is the [b]only[/b] sensible approach. It's so much [b]effort[/b] to do things sensibly, though, so sod it.
Unfortunately there is no such perfect law that is good for 100% cases with 100% accuracy. Also I do not think we could treat terrorism with the existing laws. Lawsa re always adapted and updated, the world is moving/changing.
Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo were/are abominable, but at least in the Abu Ghraib case the ones abusing the system paid for their abuse. The administration also gets some heat for Guantanamo, it is not like they are doing whatever they want.
Allow me to still believe that we are talking about exceptions, and that 99.99% of the people in Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib, were not arested for picking flowers.
Of course we theoreticaly value humanity and rspect human life but should we do that by sacrificing ourselfes ? Where is the limit ?
by jdclyde
Bush and the Republicans are going to want to down play the stats, because it makes them look "less bad". [i]yes, because they don't "look good" either way.
Pelosi and the Democrats are going to want to play up the stats, becuase it makes Bush look even worse.
Globally, depending on which side of the fence, the same thing is going on. Journalists in the Middle East are lying cockroaches that have been shown to throw stuffed animals into scences to try to make a more powerful picture. There have also been cases where the same distruaght woman will be seen greeving after an attack, time after time. Weapons are removed and fake bodies are added because they realize how easy it is to manipulate Westerners with strong visuals. Sorry, I don't have the link right now, but I am sure with how much you keep up on things AB, that I am not saying anything new to you.
The idea of throwing injuries in with deaths and counting them all as casualties is another intentional effort to distort the numbers.
The most important point, who is killing who, when, and why. If most of the killing is by the death squads NOW against Iraqi citizens, it would show a greater NEED for us to be there, not LESS of a need to be there.
US casualties are countable because we have the bodies. Insurgents are not because they hide the bodies (after taking a lot of pictures) and then TELL us a number that we are suppose to just believe?
just a few quick links from both pro and anti. when you can go from 600,000 to 150,000 TOTAL violent deaths, it shows a real detatch from reality.
http://www.campaigniran.org/casmii/index.php?q=node/4094
Rush broadcast, bringing up a good point, regardless of what you think about him.
http://mediamatters.org/items/200702230005
[i]"body counts create propaganda opportunities and even provide an incentive for the enemy to raise the toll by killing bystanders."[/i]
http://news.nationaljournal.com/articles/databomb/sidebar.htm
Talking about the "surveys" to determine Iraqi casualties. minimum of 733,158 to a maximum of 1,446,063. hmmm, that sounds accurate?
http://www.opinion.co.uk/Newsroom_details.aspx?NewsId=78
http://news.nationaljournal.com/articles/databomb/index.htm
[b]
So AB, what is YOUR take on this? What numbers do you believe, and why?
I guess you heard about it. I know you do not consider this case as being a good example. I did. The turn of events unfortunately did not have a good outcome for the Irakis and for the troops, but again, this we could've not know at that time.
About my OWN life put in line, I was/am lucky not to be victim of a terrorist atack, and obviously if age and citizenship would require me to participate in a war I would do it.
Those arguments, and any other, bar none. It is the way.
I think you know what I was doing with "remember." So I worded it closely enough to the edge of what I was doing to entice your glee.
by jardinier
Hello Jeff.
I first heard that term in a TR discussion and I was shocked by the insensitivity towards the Iraqi people in general. So it was a case of an American member of TR who displayed the bigotry -- and sadly to say, other American members of TR used the term time and time again.
As this war has now entered its sixth year, it is of course impossible to remember everything that has been posted. However my recollection is that the first people who had anything nice to say about the Iraqi people were the TR members who actually served there. The names Mr Miami and Protius X come to mind.
As for me suggesting that the allies pull out now, I did not say such a thing. Would there be greater bloodshed if they do or if they don't? Who knows? That would be pure conjecture.
As for the figures I linked to, I was not suggesting that they were accurate but that they were condiderabley larger than the figure you mentioned, and which you did not source.
How pathetic of you to suggest that I would like to see a high number of deaths just to vindicate my opinion regarding pulling out?
And how fanciful of you to imagine that there could ever be "love and harmony" in the Middle East. If there ever was a hope for this, the illegal and bungled invasion of Iraq has surely destroyed that hope.
Message was edited by: Beth Blakely
Then we are all destroyed.
Everybody pack up their keyboards.
by $$$$$$$$$$
I have not seen any estimate as high as 700,000 or more. I'm shocked to see you quote 1,446,063.
The US gov does not have any method at all of estimating the number of deaths, so their numbers for non-Americans are totally worthless. They know they aren't counting all, and make no attempt to describe how many they miss. So, I don't see the estimate of total dead Iraqis as some negotiation, with the US numbers as a low-ball offer. Their stuff is just utter bunk.
As I think one Iraqi killed by US soldiers is one too many, I won't get into an argument for one particular methodology. We should leave Iraq ASAP, set our military strategy to that, not to arranging that country to George Walker Bush's liking, and we should apologize profusely as we do so.
We were catastrophically wrong.
I think even the neo-con estimates of dead Iraqis are more than 3,000, if you can get them to comment at all.
by jdclyde
[i]"America and its allies should have cut and run two to three years ago"[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=261909&messageID=2488043
How is that NOT to be taken as we should be out of there right now?
Did I ever say or even imply that there ever was or ever will be "love and harmony" in the Middle East? The entire region is a sh1thole, always has been, always will be.
Before we went into Iraq, people were gleefully killing each other for the crime of being the wrong flavor of Islam. If you can get a government that will not condone such a savage culture that at the same time is not just as savage, only towards the goal of their own power, how is that not a good thing?
As for your bigotted choice of words to use, there are a lot of words like that, and I choose not to use them either. I always try to judge people based on WHO they are, not WHAT they are, or where they are from. Do I have my own prejudices? Of course I do, but they are not based on something as stupid as the color of someones skin.
I have not advocated deserting the Iraqi people, which would leave them to be slaughtered by the death squads, you have.
How can you then try to claim that the people looking for a lasting resolution be the ones that don't care? I have consistently stated that IF we retreat now, there will be a region wide bloodbath, and it WOULD be our fault.
Dude, your talking yourself into a hole, and contradicting yourself on a regular basis.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]Do I prove anything by that?[/i]
I take a few moments to fathom what statement you intend make with your awkward arrangements of words. A split second after I see your point, I see through it.
by jdclyde
I only put the links out there as examples of how bad the numbers are, as well as the methods being used to come up with them.
It also showed the anti-bush people will always shoot high and the pro-bush are shooting low. I don't trust any of it. which was my point all along.
Yes, we need to GTFO of Iraq. Just can't create WORSE of a power vacume than we ALL READY HAVE, which would make a bad situation worse.
by jdclyde
http://www.newsmax.com/morris/obama_hillary_iraq/2008/05/05/93534.html
Yeah, newsmax is a "right leaning" publication, but he does bring up some good points.
Would be interested in AB and Neils opinions on this.
by notsochiguy
...that at least one of these two, though, would be at least willing to listen to 'people in the know', and take their professional & expert opinions into consideration. It may not change the outcome (pulling out of Iraq too soon to avoid power vacuum), but it could at least be the difference in pulling out by Valentine's Day 2009 and Valentine's Day 2010.
I mean, why listen to economists when talking about the economy, right? (and has ever a more telling statement been made about a candidate...and yet, people will still vote that way tomorrow...yowsers)
by jdclyde
then why haven't they already done so?
As members of congress, don't you think they already have access to all the information?
As presidential candidates, shouldn't they ALREADY be talking to "people in the know"?
As presidential candidates, should it really come as a surprise that they would be asked directly what they will do about Iraq as soon as they get in office? [i](argueably the biggest issue of the election for many)[/i]
that they haven't got a swift fix for 'unf***ing' Iraq?
Good job the opposition are politicians....
What if this, what if that. What if we hadn't gone in, what if we had thought about what might happen when we did.
Stay forever, until conditions are X, bug out now. There are no nice outcomes, there were never going to be any nice outcomes.
We swap the 'safety' of deployed troops now for potentially greater risks to them and our citizens in the future.
There was a big label on the Iraq war, it said this is gonna hurt.
I don't think we can pull out, and as for win, that depends on who judges and what victory conditions.
by ic-it
does all he can to cast doubt on the Dems and especially Hillary.
The scary part is that he does have a measure of intelligence, but is not to far removed from a "Rush" type of mis-information.
Obama does have a bit more detail on his web site and has spoken more eloquently on the subject. The speeches do not make it sound like a straight forward cut-n-run. I just hope that should one of them be elected they will not withdraw above all other considerations.
http://www.hillaryclinton.com/issues/iraq/
http://www.barackobama.com/issues/iraq/
by jdclyde
instead of the narrative about him personally?
What do YOU THINK about what DICK MORRIS wrote in the article.
It is an ugly and lazy habit to counter attack on a personal basis than to confront the ideas presented.
And yes, I stated up front that it was coming from "the right".
One of the things that has been notable about the Iraqis for most of their history is their sense of nationalism.
When you first invaded, the reason that the Americans were particularly disliked in Iraq was not due to religious fundamentalism but Iraqi nationalism. The heavy-handedness of the occupation contributed to the violent resistance to the United States but mainly it was an inevitable reaction against foreign military occupation.
Unfortunately, you hung on in there to bring Freedom And The Merican Way and nationalism wilted and sectarianism grew and we are now where we are. You f*cked up the country by invading it and then you f*cked up the peace.
Who is this Morris geezer - who obviously knows f*ck all about the place - inventing scenarios where Iran moves in? His sole intention, obviously, is to attempt to embarrass your equally ignorant politicians.
If Iran moves in when you move out, whose fault will it be? Other than staying in Iraq forever, how do you propose to stop it? More to the point, though, why do you think that Iran would be able to "move in". Hopefully, Iraq's nationalist pride hasn't been completely obliterated by your STUPIDITY in suppressing it - and splitting off Kurdistan (how dumb can you get?) - and they might just get their sh:t together if you sod off and leave them to it. Say sorry, get out, give them LOTS of money and don't tell them how to spend it and you just might be surprised.
Probably not, though, as you removed the secular head of state, suppressed nationalism and forced federalism onto Iraqis. Now the southern Shias will come under the influence of Iran, the Kurds will declare independence and end up at war with Turkey and the Sunni rump will end up in a postage stamp state.
Ah, I'm done rambling here. It's a TOTAL BALLS UP. I have no idea what will happen but it won't be good. It was SO OBVIOUS that the invasion was a mistake which has now been compounded by naively bad management.
I'm fed up with this subject and I'm fed up with dickheads like Bill O'Reilly - whoever HE is.
Good night.
Neil :(
by jdclyde
by $$$$$$$$$$
One recurring rationale for the continued large number of US soldiers in Iraq is [b]the Iraqis' failure[/b] to do things like "step up" and "defend themselves." I posit that, given the nationalism Dick Morris cites, in addition to the carrots already offered and given to Iraqis, the negative consequence of inaction that would provide the other half of effective motivation might be the possibility of having their country carved up by Syria, Iran, Turkey, and Kuwait.
Or, if they don't care, then neither should we. Unless, that is, we're only there for the oil.
They aren't defined by Bush, Brown, Bin Laden, Mickey mouse, Danger mouse , Allah, Vishnu or next door's cat.
They are mine. It someone wants to tell me they are too narrow or too wide, fair enough, sure as sh1t they aren't getting me to accept that they are wrong though.
Yes the law's were good enough. Terrorists by definition violate a multituide of them, no more were required.
The so called new laws were relaxations in what the state was allowed to do in order to fulfill it's mandate. In order to contraint the terrorists, they removed freedom from everyone.
If this doesn't work, they won't give them back, they'll take more. Every time they take more we'll have less 'legal' redress to exercise our so called freedom, at that point we become the target of the legislation. All of a sudden shouting nonsense at a politician becomes a crime.
Bin Laden must be rolling about on the floor of his cave laughing at us.
Outright gibbering panic.
by nicknielsen
I just don't see a secular dictator with an extremely repressive record allowing religious fanatics who answer to somebody over whom he has no control to operate in his country.
Particularly given that the stated enemies of al-Qaida include not only the United States, but all non-Muslims as defined by Sayyid Qutb. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Qaeda
by $$$$$$$$$$
02:16
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nmNvIKrfqYc&feature=related
Then, at 08:07
"Complicated, but it isn't so black-and-white, Dave."
It's always the other person who "doesn't 'get it'."
Who do you think is missing what in this clip?
by $$$$$$$$$$
"100% accuracy" is not my point, it's your straw man.
Like Tony said, acts of terror have already been illegal, under several laws. The shortcoming was 100% in enforcement and prosecution of terrorists' activities, especially in August and early September 2001. New legislation is 100% irrelevant to the real failures of the United States government, and especially of the Bush administration. Bush and Condoleezza Rice ignored the director of the CIA for months after his inauguration until September 11. Bush chose to go on vacation for the entire month of August. Those are officially documented, uncontested facts. He has been overreacting ever since, and resting on the impression that 911 was a big "surprise." That's nonsense, and creating a police state won't change that, or make us safer.
George W. Bush has also repeatedly said that Osama bin Laden has said he wants to kill Americans, and we should believe him. Another thing bin Laden has said is that it's our involvement in the Middle East, not our freedoms and prosperity, that he hates. I say we should believe that, and protect our freedoms, and our prosperity better, by getting out of Iraq now, cutting all government funding of petroleum and Archer Daniels Midland, and letting the free market make us [b]efficiently-fermented[/b] ethanol fuel, then battery-operated cars. The problem is, right now, so much money is being exchanged between government and Fortune 500 or 1000, there is no free market.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]they both had a common enemy. And since politics makes strange bedfellows, it is possible that Saddam would allow them them to operate to help defeat that enemy with the idea that he could always remove them later.[/i]
OK, you've provided a general outline of a plausibility argument. Nothing more. Imagining yourself in the Vice President's position (the actual Decider), is that possibility enough for you to do anything more than look for solid information? Is that enough to treat a ghost story of a known liar (code-named "Curve Ball" ffs!) as such hard evidence?
by $$$$$$$$$$
never forget the fact that during the first gulf war, Iraq's airforce was sheltered in Iran.
Bitter enemies, but united against a more hated enemy.
it happens all the time.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by jdclyde
is the first step. Is he biased in his views? Sure, just like all the rest of what passes for journalists today.
I expected YOU to trash the ideas before you trashed the person. Or does that mean you can't trash the ideas, so you have to resort to going for the person in this case?
I am not defending Morris, and I have more than once said that yes, he IS a right leaning person, so there is no question of where he is coming from.
does not make his questions any less valid, except for the weak minded fools looking for excuses when reason won't do.
by jardinier
Two or three years ago DOES NOT mean NOW.
I have built this particular sandpit. I will let you other guys who like to sound off about nothing continue to play in it.
by notsochiguy
That, in my opinion, is the single reason why you will not hear candidates, EVER, firmly commit again to a plan of action during the course of an election.
Bush the elder, for all that he did well and for the manner in which he has carried himself, will always be remembered for that (it's generally the first sound bite anyone plays when discussing him).
I don't blame Bush for that...I blame the media. We live in a complex world. Contributing factors, stimuli and environments are in a constant state of flux. I could tell you today that my company will 'Always be a MSFT shop', but the moment a good sales pitch is made, we're off to Linux terminals and cloud computing. Was I intentionally lying, or was I making a statement based off what I knew to be true that moment? We all know the answer to that...but how would it get played by the media, in order to sell ad space, page hits, etc???
Further, I don't think the candidates have all of the information...at least not to the extent that the President does (nor should they...he's commander-in-chief, they are not). The aftermath of the vote to go into Iraq would seem to bear this to be at least partially true.
I will agree, though, that the candidates should already be talking to people that are knowledgeable about the various areas of impact...speak to generals/admirals, speak to leading scientists in various fields, and speak to economists.
Like I said, one candidate has openly stated that the experts can bugger off. I admire people that stick to their guns...but not when they don't at least take the time to talk to the gun shop owner about proper care and correct ammo for the guns.
by jdclyde
that sounds like a stupid position to take for someone that thinks it is so futile and has said only that we shouldn't be there right now.
Please do not confuse your lack of communication with my lack of comprehension.
Going for a record of how many posts you can get edited?
Sort by Trending