Discussion Locked

FireFox users are not happy campers.

0 helpful
77 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

June 08, 2005

Firefox Users Sound Off: Fix Those Bugs!

Even ardent Firefox fans can experience problems with their favorite browser. What are these bugs, and what can you do about them?

By Mitch Wagner InternetWeek

Use Firefox for a while, and you're almost certain to become an evangelist for the software, telling your co-workers and friends how great it is and urging them to switch. And should anyone dare to criticize your new favorite browser, you're going to get defensive.
But just between us (and the 800 million people who have Internet access), you have to admit: Firefox has bugs. Why shouldn't it? It's not magic ? it's real-world software. These significant usability issues and problems must be addressed if it's going to become a serious, long-term challenger to Internet Explorer, and not just a fad.

To first find out what these problems were, we asked people familiar with Firefox to tell us their pet peeves. We started at home with the TechWeb Pipelines editors, many of whom have at least a year's experience using the browser. And we asked readers to help. TechWeb Pipelines Editor Scot Finnie put out a call for Firefox problems in his Scot's Newsletter, and Reviews Editor Barbara Krasnoff asked for the same in the Desktop Pipeline Newsletter. All told, we received about 200 responses.

The results? In short, Firefox users cited problems with extensions, performance slowdowns, patches and updates, and incompatibilities with some Web sites. Printing was also a problem for some users.

Some complained they often have a problem re-starting the browser after shutting it down. And several mentioned that members of the Firefox community can sometimes have a bad attitude, blaming the user when a user comes to them with a bug report.

Here's a rundown of some of the most-mentioned issues:

Extensions: Biggest Blessing And Biggest Curse
Firefox's extendable architecture is both the browser's biggest benefit, and the source of its biggest problems.

The benefit comes because the core browser itself is lean and ? at least when it's working right ? fast. When you first download and install Firefox, the software provides only the basics for HTML rendering, saving bookmarks, and tabbed browsing. Many users are content with this plain-vanilla approach. But if you want more, you can have it: There are hundreds of plug-in extensions to refine your browser tab behavior, customize the user interface, and even play Tetris or check on the weather.

The problem: Some extensions are incompatible with others, or are buggy. This creates problems with Firefox performance.

"Every problem I've had with Firefox has been due to extensions," said user Bob Schuchman. "Often, the order in which they are installed makes a difference." Schuchman said his favorite extension is Tabbrowser Extensions, which modifies browser behavior (Note: Throughout this article, we'll link to extensions we think are useful, but we won't link to extensions that appear to be buggy or otherwise harmful).

Schuchman continued, "Even the author admits that he can't fix it any more and the Mozilla people warn against using it. Just today I've uninstalled it and tried to find extensions that will take the place of the features I was using. Not all of them are available."

He added, "The extensions just don't get the attention that Firefox itself does. I don't know what the solution to this problem is, but I agree that something has to be done to vet extensions better than what is being done now. Maybe the answer is including the most important ones in basic Firefox, especially those related to tabbed browsing ? the most important feature as far as I'm concerned."

Schuchman's e-mail suggests a solution to the extension problem: The core Firefox development team should be devoting significant resources to testing extensions for bugs, security holes, and compatibility with Firefox and with other extensions. Extensions that pass the tests would receive certification, and users looking for stability would be able to limit their Firefox use to just those extensions. More adventurous users could continue to try out new, untested extensions as soon as they come down the pike.

Moreover, the Firefox developers should offer an alternative to the bare-bones approach to installation. There are some plug-ins and extensions that most users will want to use, and Firefox developers ought to offer a download with those utilities pre-installed. We can argue over what the Deluxe Firefox should include, but we can start the list with Java, Apple QuickTime, Macromedia Flash, and Adobe Acrobat. Not all users will want these, but the overwhelming majority will, and users who don't want them would continue to have the option of using bare-naked Firefox as it is now.

Think you have problems with extensions? Here's how to diagnose the problem and fix it.
[v]http://www.internetweek.com/technology/164301397[/v]

One problem I struggled with even as I researched this article: No standard way to uninstall extensions.
Or, rather, there is a standard way to uninstall extensions, and developers adhere to that standard almost all the time. It's that "almost" that's the source of the problem.

The normal way to uninstall extensions is to click the Tools menu, select Extensions, select the extension you want to get rid of, then click "Uninstall."

[b]Sidebars[/b]

Curing The Crash

Firefox has crashed, and now won't relaunch. What to do? Here's a simple solution.
[v]http://update.internetweek.com/cgi-bin4/DM/y/eoWU0GPPhz0G4X0DSaC0Eb[/v]

Locating Erring Extensions

Sometimes, a Firefox problem is in an extension that isn't behaving itself. Here's how to find out which one, and get rid of it.
[v]http://update.internetweek.com/cgi-bin4/DM/y/eoWU0GPPhz0G4X0DSaD0Ec[/v]

77 replies

by jaqui

this actually came up in the firefox development lists, the real source of the extention problem is that majority of extentions are 3rd party software, so the firefox group has zero control over them.

as for bugs, naturally no piece of code as complex as a browser is bug free.

by oz_media

And while I do agree with most of the article, it doesn't even address that the extensions are third party and not up to the dev team to debug.

BUT!!!!

It has a really good point in saying there should be "Certified" extensions that have been thoroughly tested, either by FF Dev or by a Dev test team that FF monitors and works with.

Moreso, these extensions woul dbe excellent if offred by a check box system and installed initially. Just check of your choices from the list of Authprozed extensions and either perform a web install of download all as one executable file. Almost like checking of custom install options.

THAT would be helpful especially in keeping NEW users hwo figure they'll give it a test run but don't realize they have to install all th eopther stuff manually. Then they run into FLASH and JAVA sites and even though it gives you an OPTION to install, they never work unless done separately.

This would work for new users! Just like IE, you get a package, but have aCHOICE what is installed.

by tagmarkman

Hey... this is the same argument I was having in another thread about Microsoft Windows. Third parties cause 80% of the problems. :)

Then the suggestion was to have certifications for Firefox... well Microsoft has a Windows Logo Program for their products (which requires a program to follow standard uninstall procedures or the Logo can be taken away.)

hmmm.... maybe we can learn something from M$. Maybe not volumes... but something.

by deepsand

It seems to be human nature to want to be able to hold a single party responsible for any given situation, perhaps so as to minimize the amount of effort needed to deal with such.

Still, it's refreshing to see that the alt-anything-other-than-MS zealots are now getting a taste of reality. Just wait until the 1st really serious FireFox specific worm/virus/trojan hits!

by jaqui

but since firefox also runs on linux, the vulnerability would probably come through windows and be for that specific version ;)

actually, there has been 4 security vulnerabilities since it was "officially" released.

strongly recommended to be running fully updated version.

the vulnerabilities actually affected the suite as well, it came from netscrapes gecko engine.

by hesperidae

Sure, there will be a FF specific worm/trojan/virus.
However the only people worrying about it will be
the same people who always have to worry about it.
It's a web browser, not a magic wand....

by oz_media

FF offers a couple of patches due to a handful of vulnerabilities and the MS junkies have a pyjama party.

Yet MS couldn't find enough server space to even place a text list of the security vulnerabilities found in IE (not to mention those that were never admitted to or fixed).

I don't use FF because I believe I will be more secure from threats with it anyway.

I use firefox because it's faster for me, a LOT faster, and NEVER picks up spyware and blocks all the pops up ads and those annoying half page overlaid ads and crap you get in IE.

Just for the cleanliness it's well worth the time, the features and extensions just make it all that much better than IE again.

by softcorp.us

The article does a pretty good job of pointing out where the FireFox team needs to focus the next few rounds of effort.

IMNSHO, the title of your post is fallacious and does not match the article's content. FireFox users ARE happy campers. I am VERY happy about what FireFox is and am not unhappy about what it is not (yet).

FireFox is great because:

- It is very good at suppressing pop-ups.
- It is less vulnerable to the current malware.
- It is not under assault by all of the Microsoft haters.
- It has tabs, a great usability feature.
- It runs very well on all of my systems: Windows, Linux, and MacOS.

by tagmarkman

Of course we are happy.

Are there bugs? Sure! Compare that to other browsers out there an your going to see a lot as well. If you start adding the third party add on used in other browsers you're going to a huge increase as well.

The problem isn't about the bugs, the problem is about getting them fixed or at least identifing them and letting the user know what they are so they can do something about it (work around or whatever).

by deepsand

There are those of us who, based on our knowledge, skills & experience, have expectations that are not greatly misaligned with reality.

However, FF has so far been harvesting the low hanging fruit, which includes a significant portion of less than well seasoned users.

The former may be happy; but, many of the latter are not.

by softcorp.us

The only low-hanging fruit in this case are those people who have their head in the sand and are still using IE -- Is that what "deepsand" refers to? :-). Those people will easily be picked off by the viruses, trojan horses, and spyware. And, because they are so well-seasoned, they should be positively yummy...

I hope your sense of humor is as good as your rhetoric!

:-) :-) :-)

by deepsand

The "low hanging fruit" are those who downloaded FireFox not because their evaluation of its technical merits, but because its new, "cool," but most importantly, free.

In short, they are the most unsophisticated users.

As an analogy, they are those for whom a vehicle with an automatic tranmission best suits them, but insist on driving a stick shift.

by lathan_devers

I drive a standard tranmission because I can work on it if need be and save a thousand dollars or more. I use Firefox because of tabs, speed, and I can work on it if I choose. IE doesn't allow you to work on it. In fact, you can't even get it fixed! ;)

by oz_media

Forgive me jumping in Deepsand, but aren't ALL web browsers free?

Do you think perhaps FREE SOFTWARE junkies are trying it just because it is ALSO free, or do you think they already know that browsers are free?

Or was it just a slip?

by tagmarkman

If I learned anything in my life it's this:
(it all depends...)

I was never an IE lover coming from Linx, Mosaic, Internet Chamileon, Netscape, Opera, chain of browsers. I fell into using IE slowly and I neither liked it or disliked it. I saw very little innovation that improved my productivity but it was convenent which means a lot to me.

However, IE became dead to me when they started redirecting my typos to another page requiring me to type the whole thing in again because they though I might want to use their search engine. It wasn't the fear of security, or some power feature (although tabbed browsing was a HUGE bonus), or the browser wars, or even Microsoft themselves that forced me to seek this gem of an alternative... it was a productivity issue.

Sure, a lot of campers are not going to be happy but I am.

by deepsand

to have both made an informed choice and properly use the product.

The "low hanging fruit" lack such qualifications.

See my above post re. analogy to automatic vs manual transmissions and their suitability for certain drivers.

by tagmarkman

They certainly have targeted a lot of the low hanging fruit. That's a good start. It has worked so far and Microsoft has raised a worried eyebrow against someone taking their marketshare. For example, they have added tabbed browsing. It has certainly made more headway than Opera.

After FF gathers most of the low hanging fruit ( informed IT professionals, techies, Microsoft haters, "cool" jockeys, and fad jumpers, how does FF break into mainstream? And what type of effect will thay have on the program, market, and Internet?

by deepsand

Many industry pundits, while cheering FF on, realize that most of the easy pickings are now in hand, and have doubts re. its continued growth.

The general consensus seems to be that, absent a champion, such as a major corporation adopting and/or sponsoring it, its chances of going mainstream are small.

Also hindering it is the fact that so many web sites are IE centric, and the prospect of many quickly being remediated so as to be W3C compliant offers little hope.

by tagmarkman

Deepsand,
Those are certainly valid reasons but I think the biggest reason is the distribution method.. IE is included with the OS... (which is one reason why some sites are so IE centric)... (it is also one of the reasons why larger corporations tend to use IE)...

by toreador

I was unable to add a comment to something deepsand said so I am starting a new thread. I convinced management during a recent new PC rollout to allow me to install FF on them and remove the IE shortcut to try to force the users to use FF. Unfortunately this attempt to make their browsing experience more secure backfired when none of the users could access any of the internal websites. All of them were written to render IE perfectly but none of the other browsers were considered or tested so the great FF rollout of 2005 was a bust for me. I attempted to convince everyone to use IE for all internal web access but use FF for all external browsing but all I heard was this high pitched whining about having to use 2 apps to browse. At this point I think most of my users are back to exclusively using IE and all of my arguments fall on deaf ears. I tried to convince management to not allow the web admins to write webpages that are platform dependant but I was told no.
I am somewhat happy with FF, I do like the tabs and the mouse gestures alone make it worth using. If you are searching for speed, try Opera, it is smokin? fast!

by deepsand

And, it's not just browsers that are the issue.

As a rule, in all regards, people want a Swiss Army knife, rather than a well stocked, more versatile, more effective & efficient tool box.

They want the all-in-one with one-stop-shopping; the everything-in-the-universe-all-in-one-place-at-the-same-time thingy.

by jmgarvin

Usually when a user wants the swiss army app, I just give them the standard "I'll get right on that" and leave...

Users should probably have to take a basic computer course....I'm really surprised at the number of the younger generation that are STILL like their older counterparts.

by oz_media

I had a REALLY lazy user at one company some years back. I got him a pretty high-end box and pretty much set it up so he neednt leave his desk for ANY of his daily duties, except the personal ones of course(I have yet to get mine to wipe my bum, but I'm trying!). He ended up getting to the point that if his desktop was even hung for a moment, he'd get up and go home, while blaming me for his inability to work.

So....I agreed it was a bad build (by IBM on their desktop standards program...sure it was a bad build!), I said all that I had was a PII 400 that would have to do for now. Well apprently IBM had some real issues getting his old box sorted out (well I left it in the server room for two weeks and the elves didn't fix it). In the meantime, his current box did nothingbut allow him database access, web browsing and email,SLOWLY.

He was so flustered but couldn't justify taking all the time off work, so when I finally SURPRISED him with his new custom engineered box from IBM, saying they had their top engineers on it until they finaly found the problem, he was SO happy to have it back he never complained again and just fumbled through unless he had real problems.

NOTE: This was a nOOb with a near top of the line Intellistation that was a rocket and way more than he deserved anyway.

by oz_media

The FF extrension IEView allows you to open a spcific link in IE (View Page in IE from right click context menu).

I know people will decide to whine and it sounds like your world is really against some techie guy trying to impose some unknown software on them).

Perhaps even a NEW IMPROVED INTRANET could be introduced, next time you make a simple CSS change or something. Place a shortcut ondesktops to the NEw intranet, "a newlink" and just have it point to IE as the application.

All normal web browsing is done as always but with FF?

You could also get sneaky and change the IE shortcut open FF instead of IE. But that's just mean, something I'll have to try from time to time now that I think of it. :)

by ontheropes

Importing my FF bookmarks was painless. Seems faster. Time will tell.

Edited to add that my post posted in record time. Impressive.

by deepsand

Obviously, if your tools allow you to be sloppy, with no immediately obvious penalty, there's little incentive to produce a better result.

There is of course also the "cool" factor. Too many in positions of power are so taken with "cool" features that, even if the developer both knows that such requires the use of a non-compliant construct & is desirous of avoiding such, his use of such is mandated by the wishes of a superior.

by tagmarkman

When someone wants an all in one solution... I spell it out in time, quality, and cost... If they are willing to still go for it, then they probably need it (or something close to it).

I'm a nut when it comes to testing, so I probably wouldn't have deployed the FF solution until I put it though the ringer... But once I found that problem, I'd put pressure on the webmasters of the internal suite.

Most people simply won't use two tools that seem to do the same thing. It's counter productive to them. Even if they do, you are likely to get linked to an offline source of information and not be able to contain them anyway without locking it down at the proxy level.

by deepsand

My point was that many of the early adopters of FF are those who, in the context of the analogy, neither know how to drive and/or repair a stick shift nor need one.

These are those who did [b]not[/b] adopt FF for its technical merits, but because it's free, new, "cool" and/or not an MS product.

by systemsgod

Funny, but I see strengths in some of the things you mention as weaknesses (such as the "bare bones approach to installation") sorry, but sometimes less truly is more.

While I do see your point that FF isnt perfect, I still have to admit that these issues arent even close to being enough to make me run back to IE. FF may not be perfect, but, it is still a superior browser. MS knows it too: why do you think the next version of IE will include some features that FF already has?

by deepsand

Firstly, the post was clearly labeled as being a news article; at no time did I intimate that I was expressing my personal opinion(s).

Secondly, the article was about users' responses to problems that they encountered, not an appraisal of FFs merits.

As I've repeatedly noted above, a large portion of the early adoptors of FF are [b]not[/b] technically sophisticated, and did [b]not[/b] choose to try FF based on its merits.

As a result, many of them have unrealistic expectations of FF.

by systemsgod

The statements you make could just as easily be made about any other browser. Just because it's free doesn?t mean that everything will work straight out of the box or that improvements must be made. In fact, isn?t that why browsers have different rev's? They add improvements and fixes as they go along. In other words, the product is a work in progress. I don?t think you get that.

Unrealistic expectations? How can anybody expect a new product to be perfect from day one? That makes no sense. If we expected the same from M$...well, we would still have a product plagued by security issues and other faults.

Kicking a dog because it's not a cow doesnt change anything. If you wanted a cow to start with you should buy a cow. Don't blame others because your dog isnt a cow; fix the issue by getting the cow you wanted all along. I know this must seem rather simple, but, in all truth it is.

by sonoffar

OK so let me step up and admit to the fact that I am one of those nasty low hanging types. I use FF and have used it for a couple of years.
Yes it's true, just as you pointed out it's FREE.
It also works better than IE, I can't tell you technecly why, it just does. It's cooler, it has lots of stuff I can try to use that I don't realy need. When I get it all set up it sometimes screws up. So what.
I've learned to re-install, remove, update, all kinds of stuff.
I have one hell of a good time learning, but I still reserve the right to complaine when it has a bug, and the developers say it's all my fault.
You and I both know that us low hangers are one of the insperations you high and lofty ones need to make FF better than it was and is. I think we will even take some of the credit for FF being hands down better than IE.
So love to hate us if you will, but keep in mind the squeaky wheel gets the grease, and low hanging fruit is always calling out to those with their noses in the air, "Bite me."
And it still has some bugs. So there!

by tagmarkman

I don't think deepsand hates anyone for choosing FF. He was saying that a niche of people choose it and it's not accepted in mainstream browsing as of yet. He was also saying that most people that choose FF choose it because of reasons other than technical. If that is the case, there is little reason for a large enterprise to make the FF move. It can be costly to those companies (for example: website compatibility).

His nose isn't in the air... but he might be looking down it.
:)

by softcorp.us

This post is not directed at you tagmarkman. It just hooks into the discussion here. :-)

[rant]
I don't think very many IE users chose IE for technical reasons. I don't think very many IE users chose IE at all. It simply came with their computer. It is of less than zero value to try to make a point about FireFox in this way. IE users don't get any credit for having "qualifications" or being "well seasoned" or "sophisticated" or "experienced". They might get credit for being "lazy" and "sheepish" however.

I would respect and appreciate reading analysis and critical research about FireFox here on TR. But, the rhetoric and hyperbole about FireFox in many places in this thread is simply worthless gibberish.

The facts are:

- The FireFox website claims 64 million downloads (www.getfirefox.com). This is hardly some kind of fad or niche. This is far beyond the "anything but Microsoft crowd" and the "low hanging fruit".

- FireFox is far less vulnerable to the current malware out there.

- FireFox works very well.

If corporations are not deserting IE for FireFox en masse, it proves nothing. I suspect they stick to IE for the same reasons that they stick with all of the other MS products. It is a professional risk to inject FireFox into an organization just like we used to say "nobody ever got fired for choosing IBM" in the old mainframe days. When IE fails, MS gets blamed. If FF fails, the brave Admin will be blamed.

--------------------

I'm no Microsoft and FF hater, or lover. I use Windows XP, MS Office, and FF without apology. I also use Linux and MacOS for certain things. I chose to drop IE, Outlook, and Outlook Express due to the outrageous security problems. I suspect that the vast majority of the 64 million FF downloads are for the same reason. Microsoft should be embarassed and ashamed that a bunch of people working for free can out-run their engineering teams.
[/rant]

Go FireFox team! Give 'em h*ll!

by deepsand

Given that Linux benefitted from IBM's endorsement, there is every reason to hope that FF will likewise gain a wider audience.

by tagmarkman

Thank you for not directing it at me :) I truely love FF...

Of the 800 million Internet users (64Million "downloads") is still a niche. I've downloaded FF at least 25 times - installing on different boxes, reinstall on another, etc..) My company alone has probably contributed several thousand downloads if not in the ten thousands...

I agree that most people are on IE because it's already avaliable (see some of my other posts) Although my company is very FF friendly, most of us still have IE on our boxes, because of something more complex than lazyness... compatibility... some of our clients are IE only shops and we need to interface with them. Luckly, this is becoming less frequent of and issue.

And yes... most stick with IE because of the professional risk at both the corporate level and at the personal admin level as you described.

I hope that FF can continue its trend and win more users and more technical professionals willing to invest their knowledge into it. But until I see OEMs distributing it with Windows, the acceptance will be limited. There is something to be said about providing tools to the lazy, sheepish, and uninformed :)

by deepsand

[b]All[/b] browsers are free?

That there may not be an explicit charge for a component of a bundled product does not mean that such component is provided free of any cost.

by deepsand

I concur that IE users are no more technically sophisticated then others, but that is beside the point.

Nor are the relative merits of any browser the issue here.

The issue is that a large portion of the early adoptors of FF, by virtue of their lack of technical expertise, have unrealistic expectations, and are responding to the problems that they've encountered in a manner dictated by such expectations.

by deepsand

The poor slob who really needs the power and/or knows how to best use it gets the hand-me-downs, while the a*sshole gets the screamer so that he can spend the day cehcking e-mails & IMing his squeeze.

Go figure.

by oz_media

I used to ALWAYS get the best box, I would pass on my old boxes to my 'superiors' (god I hate working for other people's companies!).

IF the boss wanted someone to have a new PC, entry level lets say, I would order the latest and greatest high end box (with a good gaming card for those 3-hour lunches with LAN games going) and then pass the old one down to a manager, take his box and pass it down etc. SO the shuffle was based on user ability and seniority.

I suppose that makes ME the a*sshole with the scanner that spent his day sending emails to England and playing LAN games for the day.

by deepsand

There's an old saying about the exception that proves the rule; your claim for such exemption has been approved.

The rule is the boss, with the latest & greatest box, loaded with a productivity suite that he's oblivious to, who spends most of his time giving the rest of the world "face time," while his secretary, er, administrative assistant spends her's on a 6 yr. old Win95 box, w/ 64 Meg., trying to do it all with only Wordpad.

by oz_media

It is bundled with 'doze. It is not a free download as it is tied in with 'doze as proprietary, but for those users it is free.

As for open source, I don't think too many linux users would be interested in IE if it was designed for Linux, do you?

So that market is irrelevant, really. MAC users enerally detest MS and IE too. So for the market segment they are working for, IE IS free. It's not separate MS software that you have to purchase and licence like Office or something. It's inclusive for Windows users, the target audience it is being pushed upon and the only audience it is designed to work for.

Others don't count as they don't qualify for the product it was designed to work with.

by deepsand

Despite the fact that MS bundles a lot of sh*t with the OS does'nt make any of it free, in any sense of the word. Were that the case, one could just as well make the argument that one was paying for the other components, and it was the OS that was free.

Furthermore, if all one wants is a single component, and the only way to obtain such is to buy the bundle, then the incremental cost of obtaining such component is the price of the bundle. That makes for a very expensive browser in this case.

Yes, I know that IE is so closely wedded to the OS that its use as a standalone is limited; but, such does not alter the cost of obtaining it.

And, there have been & are other browsers which are separately obtained at an expicitly stated price.

by oz_media

I work with companies that agree to give me free reign and increase efficiency throughout the organization. SO if the secretary NEEDS a PIV 3 GIG, she gets one. If a sales rep needs specific software to improve his day, he gets it.

It is then my job to see that all the staff are USING the product effectively and gaining the best productivity benefit from it.

At least that's where I apply in my IT world.

by deepsand

to implement an equitable allocation of resources.

Or, to be more precise, it is the beneficiaries of such allocation(s) who are fortunate.

by oz_media

People often ask how I get the oportunities I do. I don't GET opportunities, I either seize them or create them, it's not so bizarre a concept when you think about it.

"it is the beneficiaries of such allocation(s) who are fortunate."

Exactly, I am a good sales rep, I can propose ideas and close them. Proposals are one thing, closing a deal is another altogether. I find opportunities in companies with obvious needs where I have a solution. I create opportunities by approaching companies I can see have advertising issues, poor market visibility or cumbersome sysems.

It's not that unique, I'm not lucky or living in just the right place, it's just how I go about obtaining work that works for me.

But you realy hit the nail on the head, techs with ideas and techs that know better than those calling the shots need to learn how to assert themselves and gain control of what SHOULD be their domain.

by softcorp.us

Hello Oz...

This post is in reply to the above one from you and related to your many other posts in other discussions...

You are a good example for the vast majority of techs in developed countries whose careers are under assault by the offshoring to places like India. Those careers are gone for all of the reasons discussed elsewhere. But, different related careers such as what you are describing will never be offshored to India.

Of course, what you're doing is very different from anything resembling sitting in a cube coding Java or C++ 12 hours a day. That is what those people have to understand and give up on. Those jobs are permanently gone or going to India. It is also why those people and their families are so desperate. They currently do not have the skill set that you do: Sales, advertising, marketing, management consulting (as distinguished from mere programming contracting). They are also not in the mind set for it.

by softcorp.us

"...The issue is that a large portion of the early adoptors of FF, by virtue of their lack of technical expertise, have unrealistic expectations, and are responding to the problems that they've encountered in a manner dictated by such expectations..."

I'm sure you are a fine fellow. But, I think this is complete nonsense.

by oz_media

Fair enough I can completely see WHAT you are trying to suggest, but it seems that you are very certain of what appears to be quite a stretch.

The way you say VERY confidently that "a large portion of the early adoptors of FF, by virtue of their lack of technical expertise, have unrealistic expectations, and are responding to the problems that they've encountered in a manner dictated by such expectations..."

This is a old statement for someone to try pushing by on TR, as I am sure you know and are prepared to support. Sorry to be a broken record, I know it's already been questioned, but it just seems a little 'fabricated'.

by psifiscout

I routinely use both IE and Firefox. Why, You may ask? Because Firefox has some capabilities that IE lacks and vice versa. I typically run across websites that fail to function with one or the other at times and when that happens I abandon the browser I am using (for the moment and try the other. I have found this to be a viable, functional way to get all around performance. The only hitch for some, might be the additional disk space required in loading both browsers, but with the low cost of disks these days it is hardly an excuse to not have both.

by oz_media

In case you don't already use it:

Try the Firefox extension called 'IE View', it eallows you to open specific links in IE from the right-click context menu.

If I run into a link to a site designed for IE only, I just right click the link and choose open in IE.

Then when that page has been viewed, I just close it and FF is still underneath. Just eases surfing.

Here's a link to the IE View Extension page:
https://addons.mozilla.org/extensions/moreinfo.php?application=firefox&id=35&vid=1179

by oz_media

These discussions are always about how a new upcoming browser compares to IE, when EVERYONE has been using IE for years already.

Well I have seen the OTHER side of it and the problems looking at IE are no different, except FAR more intrusive and annoying than the few little FF bugs.

I recently setup a computer at my mother's house, she is in her mid 60's now and has NEVER used a PC. She used the old typewriters and some punch card stuff working in an office in the 60's & 70's and was pretty much a typical British housewife after that, married and raising kids, the toughest job of all, kudos for mum!

Anyhow, she was pretty nervous and wondered if she'd be able to figure it out but has picked it up quite well, in a few weeks of self learning, some phone support from yours truly etc.

Naturally, as it is her first PC, an older hand-me-down from a neighbour running Win98, I was interested in having no ads inadvertently popup ad create confusion, security is an issue as she doesn't know how to stay up to date properly yet, clean spyware etc.

So I installed Firefox and that is her FIRST browser. I setup an old dialup acocunt for now that I was given years ago before my sat link, for her to learn how to email relatives in England and such, she's not a downloader or big gamer so connection speed s not an issue, just a bit of basic page surfing and email for now.

Okay, back to my point, sorry; due to my time restrictions when I was last over there last, I didn't have enough time to download and setup Java for her, and wanted to show her some basic online crosswords and games on Excite to get her used to the mouse. So I told her to try using IE for THOSE instances as the old JVM was installed on IE. I had three calls that afternoon, asking how to shut down all the extra screens on her task bar, stop the 'thngs' popping up everywhere and that IE was just too much bother to make it worthwhile. She got frustrated with trying to stay on th same page and just threw in the towel in IE.

I have since installed Java and she is a happy Firefox user.

So looking at the flipside to this argument, the swap for someone NOT familiar with IE (to go from FF to IE) was horrible.

If FF was out originally, before IE, and IE was a new product, I can confidently say that it would have NEVER taken flight. It is so annoying for someone who has used FF to see the horrors of IE and it is quickly dropped as the preferred browser.

In response to comments that only unaware users try FF, well I set it up for a new a user myself, so new in fact that she had never even tried IE before.

So while she is new to it, she INSTANTLY noticed what an intrusive pain in the arse IE was in comparisson and she can now talk from personal experience that FF is MUCH better for her, as a new user.

by der tommissar

I can't imagine the average firefox user being a happy camper. I mean, even if you exclude the whole "going out into the Big Blue Room" aspect, you still have bugs and sun and physical exertion and an utter lack of wifi and...

Oh, you mean that figuratively. My bad.

I bet their 12th level Paladins could hack it, though.

by softcorp.us

"...I can't imagine the average firefox user being a happy camper..."

Have you ever used FireFox? What are YOUR experiences with FireFox?

I'm not defending FireFox. But, without some amplification on your part, it appears you are just being frivolous. The original "happy camper" moniker is frivolous. Most of this discussion is frivolous. Is that your point? If so, I really get it! :-)

by tagmarkman

It took me a moment to think of what you were talking about... and then it was funny :) LOL.

by softcorp.us

Thanks, tagmarkman!

I got part of it but did not fully appreciate Der Tommissar's post until I read yours. Very funny! :-D I guess there was just one too many nonsensical comments in this thread for me.

It is much better to be low hung than to be not hung at all...

:-)

by softcorp.us

Regarding:

"...The issue is that a large portion of the early adoptors of FF, by virtue of their lack of technical expertise, have unrealistic expectations, and are responding to the problems that they've encountered in a manner dictated by such expectations..."

It's been a few days...deepsand must not have been serious about this after all. Good thing. It would have been WORSE if he were serious :-).

I *HATE* having to be a jerk and call someone out on a series of over-puffed statements like that. On the other hand, I am not my brother's keeper.

Signed...

The Jerk

by oz_media

I have been called to task on comments dozens, if not hundreds, of times here. You simply cannot assert yourself in a forum built of technical minds without it being further considered or questioned.

While many of our off-topics are pure crap and just time killers, many also invoke a lot of thought and discuss some VERY interesting viewpoints. I think this is really what attracts many of us to TR.

It's not just a he said/she said forum and actually does create worthile discussion.

In short, I have no problem telling someone to prove themselves, god only knows how many times I've been asked to do it.

by deepsand

During the dot-com heyday, we generalists were ignored, at best; at worst, denigrated as useless relics of the past.

Now that that bubble's burst, we once more find ourselves appreciated, while the specialists benoan their plight.

by deepsand

As is the case with all freebies, many of those who downloaded FF are [b]not[/b] technically sophisticated.

by jcitizen

If you are referring to the series that Patrick McGoohan created,directed, and acted in during the '60s.

Was one of my all time favorite TV creations; in many catagories.

by ontheropes

I'm going to put it one my other two users computers so that they can test/run it too. My brief experience in one word? Fast!

by jdclyde

from FF2 to Opera. Used it for a while and then ended up on FF3.

There are just to many pages that do not load right in Opera that will in IE and FF, so I was switching to often.

There were other little things I didn't like, that escape me right now.

It is still loaded on my work system, but I do not use it anymore.

by ontheropes

I'm going to use it as my regular browser for awhile and give it a thorough test. FF3 started crashing on me yesterday and today and that irritates the hell out of me. Something that won't crash on me is likely to get my thumbs up.

I think I'll look up the old EL thread and see how long that takes to load.

by ukitin

HIGHLIGHTS!!!:
*32 new mobile phones that include the Opera
Mobile browser pre-installed were announced in 2nd Quarter 08, including the Samsung Omnia, the HTC Touch Pro and Motorola’s MOTO Q9e and MOTO
Z10.

*O2 Germany and debitel Germany signed agreements with Opera for operator branded versions of Opera Mini to power their mobile web initiatives.

*Opera announced that ASUSTeK Computer Inc., a leading manufacturer based in Taiwan, selected Opera Mobile 9.5 for upcoming Windows-based handsets.

*Opera signed an agreement with Philips Consumer Electronics, which will make the Opera Web browser available on a new range of connected TVs aimed at the mass consumer market.

***MOST IMPORTANT HIGHLIGht!!!:***
~~~Revenues from the Desktop segment increased 49% in 2Q08 compared to 2Q07, as global usage continues to grow.

~~~Growth in global usage of Opera Mini continues. For the month of June, 14.5 million unique users worldwide used Opera Mini to browse the Web. As of June 30, 2008, since launch, more than 28.1 billion Web pages have been viewed on Opera Mini, generating strong data traffic, and therefore revenues, for mobile operators
worldwide.

Would the companies allow crappy software on their devices when they are liable? I don't think so... So if what others say is true that Mozilla is the best, then why Opera?

This discussion is closed to new replies.