Discussion Locked

Flakey recognition of USB 2.0 ports

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a IDE to USB adapter to allow me to easily connect ordinary HDs via the USB port without needing additional enclosures. Every time I connect it to my target machine on any of the available 4 USB 2.0 ports, I get the dreaded "This device could run faster if connected to a USB 2.0 enabled port". When I click on the bubble, it shows that it IS connected to a USB Enhanced controller. Not sure how to get XP to properly recognize this device as USB 2.0. I have confirmed this by doing a 50mb file copy from a HD using the device to an internal HD and it crawls like a USB 1.1 connection would.

Hardware: AMD XP 1800+, 512mb ram, ECS K7S5A Pro 5.0 motherboard (latest BIOS) with 4 USB 2.0 rear ports, SIS AGP card, etc.
Software: Recent bare install of XP Pro SP2 with latest updates, latest chipset drivers, etc. (this is a test machine and I was about to make an image of it)

Here's what I've tried in troublshooting this problem:

- Connected this adapter to another XP machine and it's properly recognized as USB 2.0, so there's nothing wrong with the adapter
- Connected other USB 2.0 devices (a USB thumb drive) to this machine and it's properly recognized in any port, so there's nothing wrong with the USB ports in the target machine
- Checked BIOS settings. PNP O/S is set to Y and USB to Enabled.

Tough to figure this one...

20 replies

by blackcurrant

Hi

I'm wondering if you have any other USB devices connected (apart from mouse/keyboard) which might be interfering with it. Also, have you made sure that when you do connect it, there is nothing else connected to the same USB Hub (as shown in Device Manager).

Good luck

by danno3

To answer 1: Sorry, should have mentioned that there are NO other USB devices connected and the mouse/keyboard are standard PS/2. This is a virgin install of XP Pro with SP2 and latest updates.

Answer 2: As I originally stated, this is XP Pro with SP2 and latest updates (which includes this fix). Please reread my post - another USB 2 device already works on this machine.

Answer 1 gave me an idea to try the opposite of normal troubleshooting (remove other USB devices). With another USB 2 device that's recognized properly (the thumb drive), I plugged in the IDE to USB adapter - same problem. The other way around - IDE adapter 1st, not recognized as USB 2, thumb drive was properly recognized.

Still no solution yet...

by thechas

I suspect a firmware issue in your IDE to USB adapter.

They may have an error in the code that handles backwards compatibility for USB 1.1 ports.

Check with the device manufacture for a firmware update or recall.

Chas

by danno3

Please reread my posts. I mentioned that USB 2.0 capability isn't being properly detected, only for this device, not other USB 2 devices (e.g. a thumb drive). It still gets detected, but only with crawling USB 1.1 speed.

by danno3

Answer 3: In my original post, I mentioned that when I plugged in this IDE to USB adapter to another machine, USB 2 capability is properly detected, but not in the target machine.

by thechas

I still say it is a firm-ware issue.

The fact that the adapter works on another system, and other USB 2 devices work on your system actually reinforces a firm-ware conflict.

There are 2 ways to prove if it is firm-ware or some strange system problem.

1. Try this adapter on another IDENTICAL PC. If it works there, you have a driver issue or a corrupt system file.

2. Install a USB 2 card with a different manufactures controller chip in your PC. If the adapter works on the new controller, it is a firm-ware conflict between the adapter and your USB controller. If the adapter works the same way with a different controller, it is a driver / system file issue.

One other possibility is that your USB ports do not provide enough power for the adapter to run in USB 2.0 mode. Connecting the adapter through a powered USB 2.0 hub would prove or disprove this.

As a side note, Microsoft and most PC experts advise setting the Plug and Play OS switch in the BIOS to No.

Chas

by danno3

Thanks for clarifying your response. I don't have another identical PC available, so I'll have to try one of your other suggestions. I hadn't thought about power usage.

It does have it's own power source (AC plug) and it provides 3 connectors, a power plug and data cable adapter for the HD and a USB connector.

I tried plugging in an external USB drive and that device was properly recognized as USB 2 in the other machine. In this one, I got the dreaded "This device can perform faster...".

In Device Manager, I checked each USB Root Hub properties and they all show 500mA power avail per port and the actual power usage is:
- IDE adapter shows 96mA usage (externally powered).
- external USB drive shows 10mA usage (externally powered).
- thumb drive shows 100mA usage, yet it gets properly recognized as USB 2 (not externally powered)

None of the 3 above devices have updatable firmware that I'm aware of. If your assumption is correct about inadequate USB power, then Dev Mgr is giving bogus info.

I will try to get a hold of a USB controller and try that out (and of course, disable the USB controller on the board).

I'm only rating this unacceptable, so alternative answers can still be submitted. The system won't allow me to continue to receive answers otherwise. Your answer is the first one to be somewhat helpful.

BTW, I stated incorrectly the BIOS info. It's ACPI Aware O/S set to Y, not PNP O/S. Not sure if that's the same thing.

by hal 9000

It sounds as if you don't have the correct M'Board USB drivers installed. With many of the non Intel Chip Set M'Boards you need to install the Chip Set Drivers for that M'Board and all of them not just some of them. You'll find the correct USB Drivers at the bottom of this page

http://tinyurl.com/ocry7

Col

by hal 9000

If that's not the problem change the USB Lead as they do go bad particularly when they are constantly unplugged and plugged in.

by danno3

In my original post, I mentioned that I had the latest chipset drivers installed and yes, I got them from that site. Please note that the USB 2.0 drivers there are for Win2k only. XP already has drivers and besides, if that was the case, the thumb drive would not be recognized as USB 2.0.

by hal 9000

Well in that case you are stuck with the USB to IDE HDD Hardware causing the problem. What type of HDD do you have fitted to the enclosure?

If it's not one of the newest ones that could be the reason why it is coming up as a USB 1.1 or it could be the USB Lead have you tried changing the lead? After all a USB A to B lead is piratically nothing to buy new and may cure your problems very quickly.

The only other possibility is that you have an Incompatibility between the Chip Sets on the USB Controller and the USB converter that is causing the problem.

On the other computer that you are testing this on does it have an SIS USB Chip Set M'Board?

If it doesn't can you try this device with another USB SIS Chip Set M'Board and see if it does the same thing and only react as a 1.1 USB device?

Col

by danno3

A 120gb HD with UDMA 5 capability (recognized as EIDE/ATA 100 in BIOS) is fitted to the enclosure, and a 40gb HD recognized with same capabilities by XP and BIOS.

The lead for the adapter cannot be changed - its hardwired into the data connector. Besides, if the lead was the problem, it would also fail to get recognized as USB 2 in any system.

As you stated (and was stated earlier in Answer 4), incompatibility with chipset and the adapter appears to be the only possibility.

The other system I tested it on (successfully recognized as USB 2) was a Dell Dimension 8300 (with an Intel 875P chipset). I agree that testing it on another SiS chipset motherboard would be ideal, but I don't have one available.

by danno3

At this point, I don't think I'm going to get any other useful answers. It appears to be some strange incompatibility with the adapter to the SiS chipset. Since I don't have access to another like motherboard (and it's just not worth the time and expense), I'll just write this one off.

Thanks all for your help - Answer 4 (Chas) was the 1st one to suggest this.

by thechas

Hi,

I received your message.

Thank you for being conscientious about awarding points. A large number of peers who used to answer questions no longer do so as they were not getting enough feedback as to if their answers were of any help in relation to fixing problems.

The issues you see with the TR forum have been with us since before I first started answering questions. Another way that I have seen the points award handled is to post a new question awarding points to a specific peer. It is a clumsy work-around, but it does the job.

Back to your problem, SiS has made significant improvements in the compatibility of their chip-sets over the years, but they still have a number of quirks and bugs left to resolve.

If you do try a plug-in USB card, I recommend a name brand such as Adaptec or SIIG so there is a support path should any issues arise.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.