Discussion Locked

Flashback to 2007 to a prediction about Iraq:

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Barack Obama in 2007:

[i]Democratic presidential hopeful Sen. Barack Obama, in a speech in Iowa Wednesday, called for the immediate drawdown of U.S. combat troops in Iraq. Under the Illinois senator's plan, combat brigades would immediately begin withdrawing one or two brigades at a time, with a complete withdrawal by the end of 2008, CNN reported. "Let me be clear: There is no military solution in Iraq, and there never was. The best way to protect our security and to pressure Iraq's leaders to resolve their civil war is to immediately begin to remove our combat troops," Obama said in his speech. Not in six months or one year -- now. Obama reminded his audience in Clinton, Iowa, that he opposed the war in Iraq "from the beginning." [/i]

http://www.upi.com/Top_News/2007/09/12/Obama_Withdraw_from_Iraq_immediately/UPI-50171189629808/

A question I asked in 2007:

[i]"How would a Democrat President handle the [i]war against terrorism[/i] - including the war in Iraq, the tensions with Iran, Homeland Security, Middle-East policy, border security, etc.?[/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=228957&messageID=2273676

My answer in 2007:

[i]..... a Democrat president would do little or nothing different.

There will be no pullout of Iraq, regardless of who wins the White House in 2008, Democrat or Republican. U.S. troops will remain a formidable force in Iraq until the Iraqis are fully capable of defending themselves against their hostile neighbors and terrorist factions within their own borders - regardless of how long it might take. Even then, the U.S. will maintain a very strong presence. We will not turn our backs on the Iraqis.

All of the anti-Bush and anti-Iraq war rants are all political. And the Democrat's ranting the loudest all know it. The Democrats, however, should one of them win the White House, will absolutely destroy their own (his/her own) credibility as a result. This goes likewise for the Democrats in Congress who will, with a small fringe exception, go along with the war. And the war against radical Islam will continue. In fact, I believe it will actually escalate, but perhaps in ways unnoticed by the general public.

I wonder what all the Democrats out there will think if one of their candidates wins, but continues the very policy he/she continually campaigned against. Just like President Bush said quite a few years ago, the war that was started on his watch will continue through future administrations. And they all know it to be true. The Democrats have done a grave disservice to all involved for not publicly stating what they know privately, and especially for publicly saying just the opposite, all for political expediency.

I almost hope a Democrat DOES win the White House in 2008 just so I can be proven right. (Mark this message for future reference.) [/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=228957&messageID=2277932

In 2008, President Bush set the stage for a reduction of a significant number of troops by the end of 2010 - but not ALL troops:

[i]Iraq and the U.S. are near an agreement on all American combat troops leaving Iraq by October 2010, with the last personnel out three years after that, two Iraqi officials told The Associated Press on Thursday..... [/i]

http://www.militarytimes.com/news/2008/08/ap_timeline_080708/

And today:

http://www.mcclatchydc.com/227/story/62930.html

Just like I predicted, [i]..... a Democrat president would do little or nothing different. [/i]

I wonder what all of the people who supported Obama's [i]immediate drawdown of U.S. combat troops in Iraq[/i] are thinking today? I know the answer, however, and it's exactly like I said in 2007.

Edit:

By the way, did Barack Obama [i][b]LIE[/i][/b]?

And worth repeating:

[i]As a disclaimer, I'm of the firm belief that the attacks directed at President Bush are 99.9% political, and only .1% substance. I'm also a firm believer that "those in the know" realize the dangerous world in which we live, the real threat Radical Islam (and Iran) poses, the "state of war" Iran is actually waging against the USA, etc., and ANY Democrat president would do little or nothing different.[/i]

In my opinion, the way President Bush was treated by Democrats and their partners in the media is one of the most shameful things I've ever witnessed.

53 replies

by thechas

I am still undecided about the Presidency of Barak Obama. While I support some of the stances and direction he is steering the political landscape toward, there are others that trouble me. I was very pleased to at least here the call to move toward a balanced budget.

On the withdrawal of troops from Iraq, I don't know if President Obama was naive, pandering, or consciously lying when he spoke about immediately pulling the troops out of Iraq. Besides, the country cannot handle the increased unemployment that would be the result of bringing the troops home right now.

I do know that the nomination process for both state-wide elections and the Presidency is at best shameful. Regardless of a candidates actual political stance, they need to shift way to far to the Left or the Right in order to win the proper endorsements, primaries, and the nomination. Then, they have to move toward the center to win the general election. It may be in the best interest of the country to move the nomination process back to the political deal makers and out of the sight of the electorate.

As to GWB, my opposition was mainly personal and stayed private until some peer started vehemently supporting the preemptive invasion of Iraq in this forum. IMHO, the press treated GWB much fairer and better than he deserved.

On Iran, even 7 years ago, Iran was a greater threat to the US than Iraq ever was. I would have supported invading Iran. Although, I think we should have brought Afghanistan to at least the same level of self governance that we expect to leave Iraq with before opening up a second front. Even if GWB had the courage to invade Iran, the political cost (globally, not just in the US) for the United States would have been very high. But yes, it will not be long before we are forced to deal with Iran.

I think GWB and the Republican Party has earned every negative remark and comment thrown their way. Turning their backs to the working people of the United States earned them the losses they suffered in the 2008 election cycle.

Chas

by maxwell edison

Are you serious?

If he were to tax [i]the rich[/i] 100 percent of their income, he'd still only get 50 percent of what he's spending.

Fiscal irresponsibility doesn't begin to define what he - and the Democrat Congress - are doing.

by tonythetiger

[i]If he were to tax the rich 100 percent of their income, he'd still only get 50 percent of what he's spending.[/i]

because most of them would get the hell out of Dodge before he got the chance!

However, I am loathe to criticize his course of action too loudly... not because I agree with it, but because of what will happen because of it.A quote by a Japanese admiral Isoroku Yamamoto, comes to mind :)

by maxwell edison

You [i]don't know if President Obama was naive, pandering, or consciously lying when he spoke about immediately pulling the troops out of Iraq. [/i]

But you acknowledge that he was either, [i]naive, pandering, or consciously lying[/i].

Is that right?

by thechas

Just my personal supposition here.

I do think that President Obama's calls for a swift complete withdrawal from Iraq during the campaign were predominately naivete with a bit of pandering.

I actually applaud the decision to withdraw the troops in a phased and conscious effort.

I don't have a problem if President Obama shifted his plan on the advice of the military commanders directly involved in the war effort.

Now, if it were to be determined that he knew all along that he was not even going to attempt to withdraw the troops quickly, that would be a different situation.

I don't hold fixed positions with the same regard that you do. I prefer that my leaders and managers be open minded and willing to alter course to follow what is the best path for the nation or the company. At the same time, it is not always best to follow the easy path.

I take a lot of flack from my coworkers when I either express support or do not openly complain about management decisions. Most of the complaints from people at work are based on not wanting to accept the changing world and business climate we are in.

Chas

by maxwell edison

[i]of bringing the troops home right now.[/i]

Where'd that come from?

These troops weren't drafted. They won't come home and enter the private sector. They'll stay in the military - and do what they want to do.

by thechas

I don't know if anyone can come up with the actual numbers, but significant numbers of the troops would head directly back to the private sector.

The National Guard members and the reservists would be the first back. In many instances, their return would directly send someone else to the unemployment line.

Next would be the troops who were held in the service by the stop loss program. Followed by the troops nearing the end of their enlistments. How many would be allowed or encouraged to reenlist with no major military action in process?

Of course, since many of the troops will be shifted to Afghanistan to mop up the mess that grew there, there will not be as many troops heading back to the private sector as there might have been.

Chas

by thechas

Based on nothing more than the past history of the region that Iraq is in, I make the following prediction.

It does not matter if the US troops leave Iraq tomorrow, in 2011, or in 2020, within 10 years of when our troops leave Iraq, Iraq will descend into a civil war that will make the US civil war look like a Sunday school picnic.

If the world is fortunate, the Kurds will have the wisdom to stay as removed from the conflict as possible and the strength to pick up the pieces and run the country.

If the world is not fortunate, Iran will take control of at least half of Iraq.

Chas

by thechas

Max,

I am not one who agrees with the concept of the ends justifying the means. Nor, do I generally accept that the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

While I do hope for their sakes that the people of Iraq are able sustain a strong democracy, the odds are stacked against them.

The history of the region and the friction between the Sunni and Shite factions do not bode well for long term stability in Iraq.

Chas

by thechas

Max, you have been pontificating your view of the world and US politics in this forum for about 7 years now.

What do you have to show for your efforts?

While you may have shored up the beliefs of a few wavering conservatives, you have also fostered the resolve of those who do not agree with you.

You are never going to bring about the change that you believe the United States and the world needs from postings to the faithful in this limited forum.

If you want to make change you desire happen, YOU need to take the bull by the horns and run for at least state-wide if not national office.

Only by running for office can you get your ideas out to a wide enough audience to even effect the political debate in the US.

So Max, are you up to working to make your desired changes happen?

Or, are you just wind and fluff?

Chas

by maxwell edison

Please, Chas. Why the insults? Look in the mirror, my friend.

If I recall, you had an epiphany a few years back that led you to make an extreme left-turn. Well, you got what you wanted - and then some. Well done.

Wind and fluff should not accuse another of the same.

By the way, I couldn't get elected - because I'd be unwilling to buy votes with taxpayer dollars.

by maxwell edison

.....has gone farther to the left than it has in the last four decades.

You got what you wanted, Chas.

As to what I plan to do - you have absolutely no idea. But you, on the other hand, are probably relishing in the extreme left turn we've seen.

But your smug reply speaks for itself.

P.S. I'm reminded of that old saying, [i]Be careful what you ask for. You just might get it.[/i]

Well, Chas, you got just what you asked for. You're to blame for the outcome, not me.

by maxwell edison

Put our past differences aside, and consider nothing more than this simple question.

How can one person make the biggest difference?

First of all, [i]making a difference[/i] is subjective. Your [i]difference[/i], for example, is probably different than my [i]difference[/i].

The answer to my own question:

As Mahatmas Gandhi said, become the change you see in the world. Or in American speak, walk the talk.

I ask for nothing except for the freedom to determine my own outcome and to take responsibility for my own life. What's wrong with that? Really, Chas, what's wrong with that? The way I see it, people want to deny me that very basic freedom because they prefer a collectivist agenda. They infringe on me, not the other way around. And I'm called selfish because all I want is to take responsibility for my own life. How warped is that?

I could never get elected to public office. I wouldn't play the game; I wouldn't pander; I wouldn't promise payment in exchange for a vote - a vote at another citizen's expense. That's what these people do. I wouldn't do it. I wouldn't lie. I wouldn't mislead. And I wouldn't get elected.

If I ran for elected office I would either have to compromise my principles in order to get elected, or stick to them and lose in a landslide.

But I get the feeling that you see me in a negative light because of those things. Why is that? And in your opinion, how could I best make a difference? (But it would be my [i]difference[/i], not yours.)

by thechas

Max,

One does not need to compomise their principles or ideals to run for office.

My point is that this is a limited forum and for the most part you are only preaching to a small choir that share your views.

If your goal is to change the direction of US government policy and the political system, you need to move to a broader audiance.

Unfortunatley, to get the broadest exposure, you would need to run as a Republican candidate for a state-wide office. While I may think you fit the bill as an extordinary candidate that should get full news coverage reguardless of what party you ran under, the local and national press ignore third parties unless there is a chance they can act as a spoiler in the election.

I agree that you would face a very difficult campaign. Only you can determine if bringing your ideas and ideals out into a broad public forum is worth the costs.

You can post to the TR forums all that you want and it will never bring about any change to US society. A news column, a blog, or even a show on talk radio will not bring your ideals out into open public discussion like a political campaign would.

Now, I suppose you could support and even work for a candidate that supports your views. But, would that be enough to bring forth the change you seek?

I know that our views differ as to the impact of the various laws and tax policies on our personal life. I don't see the cost of government as being too high in relation to the sevices provided. Nor do I think that environmental or zoning rules limit my freedom to do what I want. So long as the rules are applied evenly and fairly. Not to say that I agree with all governemnt spending or rules. Just that taken in their entirety, the balance is reasonable.

And yes, I do think that everyone should be held accountable for the choices they make.

Much as you may not like to admit it, even if we eliminated goverment, unions, professional associations, and all forms of group organizations, we would still be living in a collective society. With the exception of a very limited number of individuals who live "off the grid" we all rely on the efforts of others to survive.

Once we choose to form and be part of a civil society, we also accept that we will be called upon to support and fund projects and programs that we may not personally agree with. This works well as long as no individual or small group attempts to overtake the process and place their desires in front of other members needs.

Chas

by michael jay

"the real threat Radical Islam"

Of all the words you said those are the most important, and no one seems to pay it any mind.

Really, all they want is us dead. All of us, dead, and that scares me.

by jdclyde

the answer is "both".

He is held to almost no standards about his lies.

Side note, after his pull-out, there will still be 50k soldiers left behind.

by maxwell edison

Barack Obama is continuing the Bush plan - to every last detail - no changes, no exceptions. He even kept President Bush's Defense Secretary.

The guy is in WAY over his head. He has absolutely NO clue.

by santeewelding

You're full of your own crap.

I point to your reliance on "lie". Picked up then by JD. Used by some few others on TR as if this were a slam-dunk and you all knew what you were talking about. Compounding one thing after another. Compounding crap on crap.

Not to mention, "truth".

Get real, as if you could propound, "real".

Yeh. I know. You have no idea of what I'm talking about.

by maxwell edison

Clear and concise.

As to my reference to [i]lie[/i], it was an intentional play on the accusation of GWB's [i]lie[/i] about WMDs (which wasn't a lie, but rather, worst case, was being mistaken).

Nonetheless, if Barack Obama didn't [i]lie[/i], what was it? I refer you to this assessment by another TR peer, who wondered if [i]President Obama was naive, pandering, or consciously lying when he spoke about immediately pulling the troops out of Iraq. [/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=303035&messageID=3025320

I suppose it is one of the three. Which do you think it is?

By the way, that was a pretty accurate prediction, don't you think?

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=303035&messageID=3025246

by tony hopkinson

In 2007, he wasn't in power, he was the opposer of Bush policy.
Now he forms policy.
What are his options exactly?

Immediate pullout, militarily impossible.

Execute a plan to pull out asap, which was the previous adminstration's policy as well.

About face, nuke the place and add a new state to the US.

One we'd gone in, particularly in such a militarily unsupportable fashion, that then turned out to be politically unsupportable as well, what we have now , is always what were going to get.

Might as well predict that 2 + 2 = 4.

Thousands of lives, ended and thousands blighted to execute a few hundred for people who still don't know what freedom is, because they were given it instead of fighting for it.

Smoke screen Max....

They should be ashamed, if you are going to fight a war, you kill the enemy, not annoy them and then hamstring your people.

by puppybreath

If it IS militarily impossible, which BTW I also agree with, was he lying when he said,

"The best way to protect our security and to pressure Iraq's leaders to resolve their civil war is to immediately begin to remove our combat troops, not in six months or one year -- now." ?

If non-informed people like you and I know it's impossible, you'd have to assume that Obama knew it too. Sounds like he was lying to the public to me.

by tony hopkinson

As an uninformer person, I would have advised not to go in in the first place.
Let's face we are arguning about about the best way to salvage milk that has gone waaaaaaaaaay past the bridge.

by maxwell edison

I knew he couldn't have done it, that it was both politically and logistically impossible, but his supporters soaked up every one of his words - especially [i]immediate withdraw.[/i] I also knew (and still know) that the real war in which we're engaged transcends shallow political posturing.

It's really not surprising to me at all that President Obama is, for the most part, continuing with the policy and plans set in motion by the previous administration. It's also not surprising to me that he - and his adoring lapdogs in the media - are presenting it in such a way as though it's something new, that's it's his plan. What a crock of crap.

And those 50,000 troops that will stay in Iraq beyond 2011 will be there (in those numbers) for quite some time.

His [i]closing Guantanamo[/i] claim is another smoke and mirrors promise. At best, he'll simply close its current location on the Cuban island - but they'll simply open-up the same shop at a different location.

by tony hopkinson

But any real question has to be would 'quick' withdrawal have been more practical in 2007 that in 2009. Personally I doubt it.
If you want hold Mr Obama to what he said though, you have to be fair and hold Mr Bush to what he said as well...

As it turns out they were both talking out of their arses (along with Mr Blair).

Now if you want to have an argument about which ones farts smell better..

by jdclyde

He could evacuate in less than a year if he wanted, as he said he wanted, as he said he would DO.

by tony hopkinson

choice of phrasing. Your / well our forces would be extremely vulnerable.

When I was talking intant withdrawal, I meant full retreat.

Then there's goals and exit strategy. Set a firm date to leave, you are telling the opposition how long they have to hold out, or worse still go quiet, consolidate and tool up.

by av .

He left the country in a shambles. War, financial ruin, scams and scandals. Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld. No wonder Obama won. To be fair, the Democrats share in the blame, but the buck stops with GWB.

I don't think Obama lied, I would say he actually thought he could do it, unrealistic as it was. After all, he is OBAMA. He walks on water.

He started out saying he would have an immediate pullout in 2007, but by 2008 he added that he would listen to the generals on the ground. Sounds like what Bush did. Its really the only responsible thing to do. After all, we broke it, we bought it.

I do like that Obama will leave 50,000 troops in Iraq (surprise!), much to the dismay of some Dems.

AV

by maxwell edison

[i]Which farts smell better[/i]? LOL. That's a great analogy.

No, I don't presume to hold anyone to anything that's said in a political campaign - especially the Democrats. I'm actually saddened, however, to see how many voters initially bought into the pandering, they couldn't see it for what it really was, but then ignore it after the guy's - their guy's - elected. Come on, voters - admit you were lied to!

Actually, I give a bit of credit to Obama for not pulling the troops out immediately - as he promised. That would have been a terrible thing to do. He obviously listened to the military and foreigh affairs experts, he kept the previous defense secretary, he didn't replace any of the military commanders, and so on. And so far, I'd even give him a B on foreign affairs (it would be an A, but he's giving 900 million to Hamas!); but I give him a D - or closer to an F - on domestic issues.

In my opinion, when he had that first national defense briefing with the outgoing administration, he probably soiled his britches to learn what was really going on.

by jdclyde

As we will be starting up again in Afghanistan. Of course the anti-war part of Obama supporters are going to go nuts, but I think they will sit down and STFU because it is THEIR guy in office.

by thechas

On the subject of the renewed focus on the war against the Taliban in Afghanistan:

One of the many issues I had with the invasion of Iraq is that it diverted troops from what I still see as the real war on terror taking place in Afghanistan.

I also believe that at some point, we are going to have to deal with both Iran and Syria in order to achieve any level of peace in the world.

Chas

by maxwell edison

I've always maintained that we've not been engaged in two separate wars, one in Iraq and another in Afghanistan, but rather we were fighting on two fronts in the same war.

You said, [i]"I also believe that at some point, we are going to have to deal with both Iran and Syria in order to achieve any level of peace...."[/i]

I agree - something else I've said many times.

With 140,000 troops in Iraq right now, and 50,000 to remain for a long time, what better position to be in to [i]deal with both Iran and Syria[/i]?

We are firmly entrenched and have a significant presence in Iraq - with Clowns to the left of us (Syria), Jokers to the right (Iran).

In my further estimation, it was all part of the bigger plan in this ONE war.

by jdclyde

How would you think we CAN "deal with" Iran and Syria?

Do we attack them?

Do we ask them to play nice?

by maxwell edison

[i]How is this legal plunder to be identified? Quite simply. See if the law takes from some persons what belongs to them, and gives it to other persons to whom it does not belong. See if the law benefits one citizen at the expense of another by doing what the citizen himself cannot do without committing a crime.

Then abolish this law without delay, for it is not only an evil itself, but also it is a fertile source for further evils because it invites reprisals. If such a law - which may be an isolated case - is not abolished immediately, it will spread, multiply, and develop into a system.

The person who profits from this law will complain bitterly, defending his acquired rights. He will claim that the state is obligated to protect and encourage his particular industry; that this procedure enriches the state because the protected industry is thus able to spend more and to pay higher wages to the poor workingmen.

Do not listen to this sophistry by vested interests. The acceptance of these arguments will build legal plunder into a whole system. In fact, this has already occurred. The present-day delusion is an attempt to enrich everyone at the expense of everyone else; to make plunder universal under the pretense of organizing it. [/i]

-Frederic Bastiat in [i]The Law[/i]

by maxwell edison

He was a libertarian during the French Revolution. He believed that the only purpose of government is to defend the right of an individual to life, liberty, and property. Sound familiar? Jefferson initially used the exact same phrase in the first draft of the Declaration of Independence, but later changed [i]property[/i] to read [i]pursuit of happiness[/i] instead. I think I would have preferred [i]property[/i].

[i]We cannot doubt that self-interest is the mainspring of human nature. It must be clearly understood that this word is used here to designate a universal, incontestable fact, resulting from the nature of man, and not an adverse judgment, as would be the word selfishness.[/i]
- Frederic Bastiat in [i]Economic Harmonies[/i]

His writings make for some interesting reading if you search for it.

We're losing the battle, Tony.

by tonythetiger

[i]We're losing the battle, Tony.[/i]

I think that when certain key groups' collective oxen get gored, they'll see the light.

by jdclyde

Enemies of President Bush have done everything to make Iraq a failure, right up to declaring it lost already. What is bad for the country is good for the political party out of power.

That is also why they have called for a public declaration of when the retreat should happen (immediately). It is moronic for anyone to think we should be broadcasting around the world what the military will do, and when they will do it. These people (including President Obama himself) have acted aggressively against the interests of ALL the countries in Iraq, and the Iraqi people.

As Max has pointed out, it is NO surprise that NObama is not following his promise to bring the troops home NOW. His own party is now nipping at his heals like jackals over the 50k that will be left behind. And re-deploying them to Afghanistan is NOT "bringing the troops home" like he said he would do.

by tony hopkinson

have put making the incumbents look bad at a higher priority than sorting the mess out out.

When your battle plan is to offer an islamic nation a hamburger and a bible at gun point, expect difficulties.

by tonythetiger

[i]Does a Positive Outcome Justify a Bad Idea?[/i]

on WHOSE idea it was :)

[i]While I do hope for their sakes that the people of Iraq are able sustain a strong democracy, the odds are stacked against them.
[/i]

Don't worry. We are no more going to leave Iraq than we are going to leave Germany or Japan.

by maxwell edison

I'm tooting my own horn.

(But only because apparently no one else saved that message for future reference, as I suggested. Maybe if I was wrong, someone would have.)

by jck

Wrong? About?

I didn't read your whole diatribe. I had work to do.

As for him not being able to take troops out (which is what I think you were on about), the Bush Administration [b]committed[/b] the United States (and Obama's administration) to a 36 month timetable.

If Obama pulled the troops out as fast as he'd like to have, he'd probably start a whole fuss with the new Iraqi government.

So, what do you want?

Us to start out on a bad foot with the new Iraqi government?

Or for Obama to uphold commitments that [b]your hero Dubya[/b] made?

You want Obama to piss off another Arab country and stick to his guns? Or keep the promises of a past administration and do what's right for America??

Your call. Tell me what you want.

No wait. Better yet, write Obama and tell him. His job is to care.

P.S.- If you keep things for your own self-love, I'm glad you didn't have a fecal fettish as a child and keep your old diapers around too. :^0

by thechas

There are a whole lot of "if then else" statements in any discussion on the future of both Iran and Syria.

If we develop sufficient alternate energy sources and the price of oil drops, we might be able to leverage some changes in either countries positions. Key word "MIGHT"!

If they take any covert or overt action that places our interests in danger, there are plenty of actions we can take short of an invasion.

My personal preference would be a series of both cruise missile and commando tactical strikes.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.