Discussion Locked

Frame-Relay vs. DSL vs. ?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have been using DSL for the last year with Netopia routers to provide Internet access and ATM tunnels between three offices. ISP problems have prompted us to look for other options -- we're one of those caught in the Zyan fiasco, among other things.

So I've spoken to a three companies that offer Frame Relay connections and/or T1 lines. We're too small to make a T1 feasible, but we would spend a premium over our current DSL costs for something more robust and secure. Best we can do without getting exorbitant, however, is a 128k Frame Relay, or possibly 192k.

So my question, having never used Frame Relay, is this: Will users notice a measurable difference in speed between our current DSL lines (generally 768k or 786k lines) and a 128k or 192k Frame Relay? The sales folks suggest that for our purposes, there might not be much of a difference. In theory I realize that might be true, but I'm looking for real-world experiences.

A second question concerns the network setup. I was thinking of having just one Internet port in the main office, and connecting the branch offices by WAN. With a major national provider with a good backbone (e.g., MCI), will users in the branch offices even notice that they're going through us for Internet access?

Anything I'm missing? Any other suggestions for building a cost-effective and reliable WAN? My fallback position is just to go with another DSL provider for all three offices, probably at 768k.

Specifics: We haveoffices in two states (big Western ones), with about 22 employees all told who might be using these connections at any one time. For email, we outsource it, getting POP mail from our webhosting service. Thanks in advance.

5 replies

by mckaytech

Excellent questions. My general sense of the situation is that 128k Frame Relay would probably work as well as 768k DSL for the situation you've described. What would really allow you to make the best decision would be a traffic study on your existing lines.

I currently support a system where 1500 users in 17 offices access the Internet through a single T-1 at the central office.
Performance is entirely satisfactory and we have not yet seen more than 45% utilization of the line capacity on the route to the Internet.

Where you want to be careful with either service is to look carefully not at the rated line speed but at the CIR (committed information rate). One of the marketing ploys we see is a data facility identified as a 128k frame (or DSL) but the CIR is only 15k and that is all the provider is contractually obligated to meet. Usually when you first sign up, you'll get actual speeds far in excess of the CIR but as the ISP signs up additional customers, their facilities become over-subscribed and the rate you get drops down towards the CIR.

Either way, I think the quality of the provider is far more important than the specific technology used. But I have a general sense that frame relay is the more stable and better-supported technology for businesses.

paul

by jonathanv_00

Thanks for the comments! Guess you win the magic prize. I think we're going to decide to stick with DSL for now, as only one company came close to the price we were looking for. It's between Verio and Megapath DSL. (Unfortunately, I don't think we're big enough to even justify a traffic analysis.)

Thanks again.

by madcateast

Check out http://www.yipes.com They offer fiber man, wan and net services from 1mb/s to 1 gb/s. The cost is said to be less than ?T? lines and based on native ethernet protocol. You will need to contact them to get more detailed information but their web site will show you their offerings.

by jonathanv_00

Thanks for your reply. While it doesn't answer the questions I had, it does give me another alternative to look at.

This discussion is closed to new replies.