Discussion Locked

Fred Thompson on Iran, the British, the War On Terror, the UN, and. . .. .

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

By Fred Thompson [i](Verbatim and without comment from me)[/i]

Oil prices fell. The stock market rose. Video images of smiling British soldiers with Iranian President Ahmadinejad were everywhere. So were pictures of the 15 freed hostages embracing family members back home. The relief over the return of the Brits was so tremendous; you could almost hear birds singing.

Maybe it's because military action won't be needed or maybe it's just because the ordeal won't drag on and on, but the world is breathing easier now. A lot of folks are happy. The problem, as I see it, is that Ahmadinejad seems to be the happiest.

And why shouldn't he be? He has shown the world that his forces can kidnap British citizens, subject them to brutal psychological tactics to coerce phony confessions, finagle the release of a high-ranking Iranian terror coordinator in Iraq, utterly trash the Geneva conventions and suffer absolutely no consequences.

The UN Security Council summoned its vaunted multilateral greatness to issue a swift statement of sincere uneasiness. The EU, which has pressured Britain to rely on Europeans for mutual defense instead of the US, wouldn't even discuss economic sanctions that might disrupt their holidays. Even NATO was AWOL.

Tony Blair doesn't appear to be in much of a mood for celebrating. I don't know how he could be, given the troubling spectacle of British soldiers shake the hand of their kidnapper as a condition of release. In the old days, they would have kissed his ring -- but wearing Iranian suits and carrying swag more appropriate to a Hollywood awards ceremony may have been as embarrassing. Ironically, Blair's options are fewer by the day as his own party moves to mothball the British fleet, once the fear of pirates and tyrants the world over.

Some in the West seem part of Iran's propaganda war; claiming that the release of the hostages was a victory that proves the Iranian dictatorship can be reasoned with. To misrepresent unpunished piracy as a victory is as Orwellian as the congressional mandate banning use of the term "the global war on terror." What are we ? Reuters?

Ahmadinejad must be particularly pleased to see "deep thinking" journalists making the case that American actions in Iraq were the true cause of the kidnappings. To believe this, all you have to do is ignore the history of the Iranian Revolution, which has been in the extortion business ever since it took power. Between the 1979 American embassy crisis in Tehran and the seizure of Israeli soldiers last year by Iran's Hezbollah proxies, there have been more than a hundred other examples.

If you include the imprisonment of pro-Democracy dissidents and non-Shi'a Muslim minorities within Iran, the number reaches easily into the tens of thousands. The dwindling and persecuted Christian population of Iran, I suspect, found little joy in Ahmadinejad's explanation that he was freeing his victims as an "Easter gift."

It is critical that we see this incident as part of a long pattern of behavior -- that will continue as long as the current leadership is in power. More importantly, it will escalate unimaginably if Iran achieves nuclear status, and with it the ability to hold millions rather than individuals hostage.

I have no idea if Ahmadinejad and those who put him in power really believe the Shi'a Twelver doctrine that they can spur the messiah to return by triggering Armageddon. You have to admit, though, that the possibility that they look forward to entering paradise as martyrs would make them a whole lot scarier as a nuclear power than the USSR ever was.

There is hope, though. The Iranian people are not an anti-Western horde. They're an educated and freedom-loving people for the most part, and reformers there have been begging us for support and sanctions that would weaken the ruling theocracy. Instead, they've just seen the Iranian dictatorship successfully bully the West into impotent submission. This is not a good thing.

We need to understand this and use every means at our disposal, starting with serious and painful international sanctions, to prevent Iran's rulers from becoming the nuclear-armed blackmailers they want to be. Unfortunately, we are hearing demands that we abandon the people of the Middle East who have stood up to Islamo-fascism because they believed us when we said we would support them.

If we retreat precipitously, the price for that betrayal will be paid first in blood and freedom by the Iranian people, the Kurds, the Afghanis, the secular Lebanese, the moderates in Pakistan and the Iraqis themselves. And America's word may never be trusted again.

Right now, the pirate Ahmadinejad is clearly more confident about the outcome of the Global War on Terror than we are. That ought to give us pause.

39 replies

by sn53

We are still on the road to war.

Because we failed to act the war will be longer and bloodier for us when we finally do act.

I wish it were not so.

by tony hopkinson

There were two options, sacrifice the hostages immediately or make their captors aware of what we would be willing to give up to get them back.

They had something we wanted, how they got it, is a moot point until the situation was resolved.

This was a standard dictatorship publicity stunt, it will have far more more domestic impact in Iran, than it will over here.

Ahmadinejad doesn't give a crap what we think of him, to keep his mindless jingoistic, nationalist, agenda going he needed a pre-emptive strike against the impact of sanctions etc for his nuclear adventures.

As for the anti-western horde comment, I just laughed my balls off, what an imbecile.

The only reason Iran turned from a friend to an enemy is we actively blocked their right to self determination and when they surmounted that difficulty, we punished them for it. Sheesh, we even armed our great friend Saddam Hussein against them.

What possible reason have the Iranian people got to like us?

'America's word to be trusted', only a total halfwit would trust a country's word.
Any country's !

The only thing they should believe in and trust is to do is to act in our own self interest, any other policy would mean they aren't fit to lead my dog to a bone, far less a country.

by maxwell edison

Fred Thompson suggested, [i]"There is hope, though. The Iranian people are not an anti-Western horde. They're an educated and freedom-loving people for the most part, and reformers there have been begging us for support and sanctions that would weaken the ruling theocracy."[/i]

To which you replied, [i]As for the anti-western horde comment, I just laughed my balls off, what an imbecile.[/i]

What do you think Fred Thompson meant by his suggestion, and what did you mean by yours? On what do you differ and/or disagree. And please be specific.

by jamesrl

1) The current president does not have the power over his country that an American president does. And the country knows it. The ruling council of mullahs can over rule anything he does.

2) He won the presidency in a suprise, by campaigning as a moderate. He changed his spots back after winning.

3) Many older Iranians hated the Shah, but not the US. During the 90s there was a lowering of tensions and a move to improve relations, sponsored by the Iranian leadership, which the current Iranian president has mostly undone. But once he is gone....

4)Iran has a limited democracy, has a fair record of higher education and women's rights, at least compared to other regimes in the region. Its the leadership which has caused the issues, not the people.

James

by tony hopkinson

Any Iranian who's begging for western intervention, has no power, no mandate, no majority and no legitimacy.

If they had those things they wouldn't have to beg would they, unless of course they are cowards who want us to quietly shuffle them into a power they don't deserve and are incapable of holding.

They have nothing, are nothing and deserve nothing, until they get off their knees and fight for it.

Who gave america it's liberty? No one, did they?. Who gave the british people the vote?, the magna carta?, repealing of divine right? No one.
We took it from the dead bodies of those who denied us what we saw as our right.

Ask yourself this.
How much did your fight against the british for your independence, help in making you viable when you won it? What welded such a disparate collection of varied cultures and backgrounds, into your current society?

Clue 1
It was something you had in common.

Clue 2
It wasn't anything to do with begging the British Empire to please please please and pretty please give me it, blubber, whiffle, sniffle, whine.

Begging, sheesh.

History is a useful thing...

by maxwell edison

.....that well over half of Iran's population is quite young, under 30 range, and that they do indeed yearn for a life out from under the ruling theocracy, preferring some semblance of a free and open society, and that they are absolutely ripe for a major revolution to overthrow the existing ruling class. I could be wrong, but that's my impression. Do you have any thoughts in this regard?

And it was with this basis in mind when I interpreted Fred Thompson comments, [i]"There is hope, though. The Iranian people are not an anti-Western horde. They're an educated and freedom-loving people for the most part, and reformers there have been begging us for support and sanctions that would weaken the ruling theocracy."[/i]

So I really don't know what Tony Hopkinson is talking about. (Or perhaps he doesn't know himself!)

by delbertpgh

Certainly the current Iranian president will never be an American buddy, but one decade is not like the last, especially in Iran. A lot of Iranians were educated in the U.S. and remember it fondly. Many more are interested in a more free and modern life than they can get under the theocracy. They are a proud and nationalistic bunch, and Ahmadinejad seems to know how to ring their patriotic bells. It's an act that is hard to keep going. He'll fall. One reason we don't have to get too excited about the kidnapping is that he will face an election or term limit and be gone some day. (Pretty much why I don't feel so apocalyptic about Bush.)

I don't think we're smart enough to short-circuit the Iranian government and come up with anything that would make us happy. If we ever did succeed in destabilizing the government of those 60 million, sitting on the throat of the biggest oil shipping lane in the world, what would we do with it? Better to let it evolve on its own.

by tony hopkinson

Friend no, puppet yes.

That was one of the main reasons for the shahs downfall. Not even our help could prop him against his own people and we earned their contempt when we tried. We can't turn them into us, trying to, just p1sses them off and makes thing worse.
We wouldn't tolerate a reciprocal intervention in our affairs would we, so why should they?, Because we are the 'good guys' ?

by sn53

Tony wrote, "Not even our help could prop him against his own people..."

I believe this is untrue. Jimmah Carter withdrew our support from the Shah. Then Iran fell to the first of the Islamofascist regimes. We could have supported the Shah.

"and we earned their contempt when we tried."

I see the history differently than you do. We had a failure in Jimmah Carter. We paid for it. And so did the Iranian people. We are still paying for it today.

"We can't turn them into us, trying to, just p1sses them off and makes thing worse."

We can help them turn to small d democracy. It will benefit us in the long run.

by maxwell edison

Therefore, no nation should ever interfere in the internal affairs of another nation, or assist a weaker faction within that nation. Is that right? Does that sentiment apply equally and across-the-board to all nations, or just Iran?

by tony hopkinson

It's the idea of picking out a minority in another nation, saying they are right, devoting your resources to elevating them into power.
Then expecting them to stay grateful, not be changed by being in power and the extreme foolishness of believing they were what you thought they were when this crap started.

Saddam Hussein was a good guy, bin laden was a good guy, Sandanista was a good guy, Mugabe was a good guy, Molosovic was a good guy..

Are we learning anything here?
How about Jerry Adams, good guy or not?

Interfere as much as you feel the need, don't tell me it's for some noble reason though. Hussein was never a good guy, we tolerated him because he was more palatable than middle east under the rule of the soviets or an islamic theocracy.

Short term expediency always fails in the long term, as long as you understand and plan for that, fine, don't be dumb enough to expect world peace from chaos though.

by maxwell edison

(Or is it just you who's strange, Tony?)

You guys have raked Americans over the coals when we suggested we threw you guys out with our revolution, and you're quick to "remind us" that we couldn't have done it without help from the French.

And now you tell a weaker majority in Iran to do it all on their own, without anyone's help, just like we Americans did it.

(Not to mention the comparison is just down-right silly.)

You are indeed a strange guy, Tony. You have a strange way of thinking, and a strange way of spouting-off.

by tony hopkinson

The french didn't help you, they nothelped us.

If we hadn't been fighting them, it would have delayed independence perhaps even made it bloodless, if only because we could have devoted more resource to keeping you in check.
There again how much did our war against the french cause the issues that led to the fight for independence.

Why do you think we were taxing you without giving you representation. We needed the money and if we had allowed you representation you would have voted against it!

The war for independence is often described as the forge in which your nation was cast.

That's not and accident of vocabulary, it's manifestly true.

What other ex british possession has a constitution like yours?

So I'm only strange when you attribute contradictory ideas to me in order to avoid addressing ideas [b]I[/b] do put forward.

One of your regular habits when you are spouting off.

by maxwell edison

Should the rest of the world do nothing if Iran finally does develop a nuclear weapon, or comes |___| this close, or should it be stopped? And why?

by tony hopkinson

upgrade from trident, should the the pakistanis stop missile tests, should the US get behind nuclear disarmament and start with themselves to set an example.

The only deterrent against nuclear attack is nuclear attack! So what is a nation who you deny that 'safety' to, meant to think?

Personally I think we should persuade them to spend resources elsewhere, simply because they can't build enough bombs to safeguard themselves, so it's a waste of time.

We can keep ours because we can be trusted with them is obviously not an argument that's going to fly.
The desire to have a smaller world nuclear arsenal I agree with wholeheartedly.
However that is not the policy being pushed, that policy is every one else doesn't have them.
A CND committee chaired by Mother Teresa would realise that was un-appealing to any nation with a total IQ above zero.

by delbertpgh

The idea of proportional justice, that if we have nukes then others have an equal right to them, is just silly. There's a great reason Iran shouldn't have nuclear weapons: everybody else in the region would feel they need them to be safe. Once you have nukes in the hands of everybody from Arabia to Jordan, how long will it be before a question of somebody's national survival demands they use one? (Or some general decides he could use $100 million, and sells one to Bin Laden.)

Right now the nuclear club is fairly limited. It is good for the world if Iran does not have the bomb. It is good for Iran that it does not have the bomb. Having it would complicate its security in a short number of years.

Where Max and Sandy get unwise about this situation is, they think that by sending in our Air Force and blowing stuff up we can stop Iran. We can do so temporarily, but bombs have a way of coming back at you in the end, and I don't think attacks on Iran are going to make the Iranian people want to overthrow their idiot government. It is more likely to consolidate them in a national defense polity, and give Ahmadinejad political cover to get more extreme and eliminate his enemies. Remember how we circled our wagons around our dubious President following 9/11?

The problem for arms limitation is not the number of nukes in any arsenal. Virtually all the members of the current club are prevented from using them by their opponents' retaliatory potential. The problem is proliferation. Enrichment, which used to be too expensive and difficult, is now within most nations' economic and technical means. The main reason they don't do it is because they don't feel the need (and political pressure and rewards from the current members of the club.) If we create a world situation where the only way a minor nation can feel safe from us is to possess its own nuclear deterrent, then we have given up the game.

by maxwell edison

Jimmy Carter made a shambles of the United States middle-easy policy, he embarrassed the USA on the world stage, and he gave the impression that the USA was a paper tiger. And the ironic thing is, he thinks he's a friggin' expert because he negotiates with terrorists! He started it all by bending over for them. Jimmy Carter is, hands down, the absolute WORST president we've ever had. And he went from (arguably) the best "ex-president" to the WORST ex-president. The guy's a disaster, an embarrassment. a hindrance, a ...... okay, I'll say it, a traitor.

Jimmy Carter needs to STFU, sink quietly into retirement, and never be heard from again.

by sn53

Tony wrote, "Who gave America it's liberty?"

Only about 1/3rd of the people wanted independence. Less than that number were willing to fight for it or to support the fighters. And we had help. From France. Without the external help we would not likely have defeated the British.

So the Iranians who ask are likely to have our ear.

by tony hopkinson

eventually, you wouldn't be the nation you are now though. You'd be like Canada , Australia , New Zealand, India ....

The war of independence made you what you are, you can't give that to someone, you can't sell it, and you can't impose it.

The french helped you to to help themselves, it was a pragmatic decision. Probably one they regret more than the british do! :D

The french help you had was negligible compared to the resources we and they were putting out against each other. I don't make that big a thing out of their direct involvement, you shouldn't either.
If we hadn't been at war with them, then indeed independence might not have come at the time it did. You may have wrested it from us peacefully. As I said in reply to Maxwell, a lot of the issues with british rule were a direct result of our war with the french.
So without that war the impetus behind the desire for independence would have been nowhere near as powerful. So the french were a factor not a help.

by sn53

Tony said, "The war of independence made you what you are..."

Everything we do or fail to do has its impacts, not only on what we are but also on what we are likely to become.

"The french helped you to to help themselves, it was a pragmatic decision."

Granted. Most nations do not have friends, just common goals and interests.

"The french help you had was negligible compared to the resources we and they were putting out against each other. I don't make that big a thing out of their direct involvement, you shouldn't either."

Sometimes a small amount of help at the right time can make all of the difference. It is one of the few things the French have done that was right. Who knows, maybe they will get it right again some day. Maybe not.

by sn53

tony wrote, "Initially united by a desire to toss the english out and then control your own lives, you did something truly amazing. You carried the reason for wanting to toss us out (fairness basically) and made a constitution out of it, then made a brave attempt at protecting from future less reputable citizens who might follow."

The Declaration of Independence was a well crafted explanation of why we would fight to be independent of Britain. It invokes god and religion because people will fight for those concepts. And it worked.

The US Constitution was written long after. It does not invoke god or religion. It offers up a way to protect the people from democratic totalitarianism. It had its successes. Unfortunately every government has two tendencies that bode ill for the people. The first is the tendency toward mediocrity. The second is the acquisition and centralization of all power and authority to itself. This is where we are today. This is why I believe our grand experiment in self government has largely ended.

by deepsand

Far too many fail to grasp the concept of and the dangers inherent in tyrannies of the majority.

As for "[i] I believe our grand experiment in self government has largely ended.
[/i]," need it be so?

Granted, there are many things that our Founders did not foresee, could not have foreseen; e.g., the holding of political office as an occupation, the need for a large standing armed force, the future of science & technology and the changes wrought by such, or the future developments of the nations of the world.

Does this mean that the ideal that they strived for is now so much further from reach than then that it is no longer striving for? I, for one, think not.

You said that "[i]Unfortunately every government has two tendencies that bode ill for the people[/i]" I submit that such is in fact facilitated by the people themselves, in that, for any number of reason, they do [i]not[/i] "throw the rascals out" as oft as they should. Might not this fundamental problem be addressed by way of a Constitutional Amendment setting Term Limits on, at the least, members of the House of Representatives?

by jamesrl

The Shah was a master of using the secret police, torture, repression of political freedom etc. He was evil.

He came to power in a coup d'etat, like Saddam, overthrowing an elected president. He had a secret police, had phony elections, used torture and assasinations. In many ways, the only difference is that he was more secular than Khomeni, who did had secret police, torture etc.

The taking of American hostages back at that time was a reaction against the Shah. But its been many years since.

There were signs before Armenjinidad's (sp?) win that the moderates in Iran were gaining strength and becoming more open to the west. But things have gone black since.

James

by sn53

james wrote, "How can you condemn Saddam and support the Shah?"

Pragmatic politics. We needed Iran in our war against the Soviet Union.

The issue was not whether or not we should have supported the Shah. The statement was made that it didn't matter. We could have supported him. President Carter "screwed the pooch" by withdrawing our support. Much that has occurred in the Middle East flows from Carter's failure.

by tony hopkinson

Support a Saddam because it suits you, then live with the b'stard afterwards.
Bin Laden used to be an ally of sorts didn't he?

The cornerstone of british foreign policy in reagrds to mainland europe for about nine hundred years was no strong foreigners in flanders. That was it, the hundred years war, french revolution, spanish civil war, two world wars..... All can be traced back in some part to the perfidious british. :D

Aside from the fact we are still here, doesn't sound like the best plan ever does it?

No you could not have propped up the Shah, any more you than you could have propped up Saddam. At some point it would no longer be in his interest to be propped or your interest to prop him up. That's not even considering the majority of his own people thought he was git.

You'd have dropped the Shah at the end of the cold war, he got supported mainly because he resisted russian influences into the middle east.

There are lots of advantages to democracy, none of mean natural allies, otherwise the Democrats and the Republicans would like each other wouldn't they? :D

by sn53

Tony wrote, "You pays your money you takes your chances... Support a Saddam because it suits you, then live with the b'stard afterwards."

Support him when you must. Depose him when he is a hindrance.

"Bin Laden used to be an ally of sorts didn't he?"

Was he? Do you mean because we financed and supplied the war against the Soviets in Afghanistan and there is evidence that he participated?

"Aside from the fact we are still here, doesn't sound like the best plan ever does it?"

I suppose it is a matter of perspective. Did you gain more than you lost?

"No you could not have propped up the Shah, any more you than you could have propped up Saddam."

We will have to agree to disagree. I believe we should have continued our support to the Shah. I think the unfolding history of the region would have been very different.

"At some point it would no longer be in his interest to be propped or your interest to prop him up."

Yeah? Okay. When the situation changes then we re-evaluate the situation.

"That's not even considering the majority of his own people thought he was git."

Do you think that matters?

"You'd have dropped the Shah at the end of the cold war, he got supported mainly because he resisted russian influences into the middle east."

Perhaps. The Islamists wanted him deposed because he was westernizing and liberalizing Iran. Who knows where that might have gone.

"There are lots of advantages to democracy, none of mean natural allies, otherwise the Democrats and the Republicans would like each other wouldn't they?"

I believe we are natural enemies. Our beliefs are opposed to one another.

by tony hopkinson

We are both democrats of a sort.
We can both have the same essential goals yet differ violently as to the means.

Why should we care if the the iranians thought the shah was a git, because now we are talking about helping those who think the current incumbent is a git. He is a git as well.

Go for pragmatism, I'm fine with it, just don't give me this crap about spreading the noble idea of democracy, you know it's a lie.

What you just posted proves that beyond all doubt.

by sn53

Tony wrote, "Why should we care if the the iranians thought the shah was a git, because now we are talking about helping those who think the current incumbent is a git. He is a git as well."

Okay. We helped the Shah because it was in our interest to do so. We were fighting a war against the Soviet Union. Iran had an important place in that war. President Carter screwed it up.

"Go for pragmatism, I'm fine with it, just don't give me this crap about spreading the noble idea of democracy, you know it's a lie."

Why not both? There are times and places where spreading democracy is the right tool for solving the longer term problems. Are you aware that with sufficient practice it is possible to walk and chew gum at the same time?

"What you just posted proves that beyond all doubt."

Or maybe you just have not given the possibilities sufficient thought.

by tony hopkinson

How, when the pragmatic decision is to support a leader who isn't democratic?

So you can't always do both at the same time, so in those situations what do you sacrifice, short term self interest, or long term self interest?

by tony hopkinson

Well yes, a simple answer definitely not.

I'll say it again in small words

I would like Iran not to have nuclear weapons. I would like the UK not to have them. I would like the french not to have them. I would like the US not to have them. I would like everyone not to have them.

How do we achieve this?
Bomb Iran unless they give up their nuclear ambition.

Are we seeing a problem here?

You have people in your country openly talking about attacking them. They were doing that before the nuclear question came up. You have supported their opponents both foreign and domestic. You put them in the axis of evil. You are a nuclear power, the only defense is to become a nuclear power.

Don't give me the crap about they could trust you not to nuke them. Threat assessments in intelligence terms are always done on capability, not CURRENT intention.

So even if you were friendly to Iran, it would still be a 'sensible' thing to do.

If you were an iranian, what would your opinion be?

If the chinese deployed a real defense against nuclear attack and then told the US not to develop one, because it would upset the balance and you could trust them. What would your response be?

"Ok then"

And you call me a flake?

Get a reality check!

by tony hopkinson

though, certainly the war cost us our american posession. They still lost though. In some ways you could say we gave it up to win. May be if they had been less successful, that would have tied up more of our resources. Maybe the resources they spent in america, could have tipped teh balance for them.

Who can say?

I was simply saying that our war with france was the most significant part of the equation. and the fact it was a war is the biggest factor in what followed.

Initially united by a desire to toss the english out and then control your own lives, you did something truly amazing. You carried the reason for wanting to toss us out (fairness basically) and made a constitution out of it, then made a brave attempt at protecting from future less reputable citizens who might follow.

An effort someone who truly believes in fairness = rational, can only applaud.

by maxwell edison

He would "like" this and that, and I'm sure he would "like" for the whole world to join hands, sing kumbaya, and live in peace an harmony. Oh, isn't that nice? He would "like" all those things.

Get a clue, Tony. Regardless of how much you might "like" for it to happen, neither the US or the UK -- or any other current nuclear power -- will get rid of their nuclear weapons. Moreover, it's immaterial to the QUESTION as to whether or not the rest of the would should allow Iran to develop their own -- and YES, I do suggest that we (the rest of the world) are justified in "allowing" it to happen or not.

Neither the US or the UK has ever threatened to destroy another nation, as Iran has publicly done. Neither the US or the UK has officially denounced a whole nation of people just because of who they are. Neither the US or the UK has used nuclear weapons in an aggressive manner, something the current regime in Iran would, most likely, do -- perhaps even in downtown London. The ONLY argument idiots like you could possibly advance is the tired old argument that the USA used them to put an end to World War II, but you apply today's standards and the benefit of hindsight to advance your stupid arguments.

Moreover, Tony, regardless of how much you might "like" for it not to happen, the terrorist and radical wing of Islam will continue to kill people just because they won't conform to their first century view of the world -- something neither the US or the UK has done, regardless of how your warped mind will spin things to make us look like the bad guys. GET ANOTHER CLUE, Tony, there ARE bad people in the world, and it AIN'T US! You're a coward for not being willing to face a REAL threat; and your an idiot for trying to justify your warped view that the threat is really coming from the US or UK.

You're afraid to answer the question, Tony, because regardless of how you answer it you'll look like an idiot. So you dance around it spouting off about all the things you would "like". Let me ask you another question, Tony. Do you put on your red shoes and tap your heels together while wishing for all the things you would "like" to happen? Your wishful la-la land thinking shows how ignorant you really are.

By the way, Tony. . . . .

To paraphrase you, [i]You have nothing, you are nothing, and you deserve nothing, until you get off your knees and fight for it.[/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=218107&messageID=2209932

by tony hopkinson

Who's posts are you reading?
I would like, I thought the tone indicated I don't expect.

How does my desire for nuclear disarmament stack up against your delusion that no one else should have them?

Come on shock me answer one question, or do I need to SHOUT to get past your fingers.

Iran shouldn't have a nuclear program, don't tell me why tell me HOW.

Oh, seeing as it's a simple question, give me answer that will last, longer than a presidential term.

by tony hopkinson

going to give up, postpone perhaps. The first thing to do after surviving having a gun stuck in your face, is to make sure it doesn't happen again.

The bomb is seen as away of doing that, course they could all just convert to christianity, eat at MacDonald's and concentrate on the pursuit of happiness instead I suppose.

La La La la

by sn53

Tony wrote, "How, when the pragmatic decision is to support a leader who isn't democratic?"

There is always more than one thing going on at the same time. We could encourage the undemocratic leader to become more democratic, for example.

And of course, we can be advance our short term interests in one place and in another place choose a longer-view approach.

"So you can't always do both at the same time,"

Or maybe you can. Always and never are difficult terms. The real world seldom contains always and never.

"so in those situations what do you sacrifice, short term self interest, or long term self interest?"

For many answers in life the answer is, it depends. Maybe one. Maybe the other. Possibly neither.

by sn53

deep wrote, "Far too many fail to grasp the concept of and the dangers inherent in tyrannies of the majority."

As a long term project I have taken on the enjoyable task of working through world history. I spent a year studying pre-history. Then a second year studying Greek history. In the first four months of my third year I studied Greek military history. Then I moved on to Roman history. I intend to spend two and one-half years there before I move on to Chinese history.

There is a common thread so far. People want governments that can protect them, first from external threats and then from their neighbors. Democracies have always ended in tyrannies. Republics tend to end the same way only the process takes longer.

The United States, through a combination of well educated men and happy circumstance, ended up with a form of government that slowed the accumulations of mediocrity and centralization. Unfortunately our success in WWII eliminated our natural fear of a strong central government. This, in my opinion was the turning point in our history. Since then we have experienced a steady accumulation of all powers at the federal level until today there are no activities that I can think of that are not regulated or taxed by the federal government. We are doomed. Maybe not today. Or tomorrow. But we are doomed.

"As for 'I believe our grand experiment in self government has largely ended.' need it be so?"

No. We could turn this around in a day if we wanted to. But we do not want to. More than one half of the American people receive direct cash payments from the Federal government. And about one-half of the people pay nearly all of the taxes. Many people receive benefits well in excess to what it costs them in taxes to receive. They are the people who will vote themselves ever greater sums from the public treasuries. They are now in the majority. And we few taxpayers who pay for most of the government services are in the minority.

We will flee with our money and our businesses. It is already happening. Sarbanes-Oxley has single-handedly eliminated the creation of new public companies in the US. We have created a monster that gets no news coverage.

"Does this mean that the ideal that they strived for is now so much further from reach than then that it is no longer striving for? I, for one, think not."

The pretty words are still in place. And there are no more free places remaining on the Earth where one might go to begin anew. I am a slave for five months out of the year. I work very hard for the benefit of others whom I do not know. And yet from the perspective of the government it is never enough. Politicians, who pay attention to the voters who have their hands out, always want more from me. And are willing to forgive all taxes from those who already pay almost nothing.

"Might not this fundamental problem be addressed by way of a Constitutional Amendment setting Term Limits on, at the least, members of the House of Representatives?"

Would term limits help? I think not. We might be better off selecting all of those in every community who have answered the call to jury duty, then randomly selecting 535 of them to serve as our representatives at the federal level, never to be selectable again. And we would have to eliminate the professional bureaucracies that have accrued so much power.

We would have to eliminate the source of much of the evil, the income tax. If we could replace the income tax with a consumption tax and eliminate the property tax we would have the chance of saving our Republican form of government. I do not believe it will happen.

It is a nice change to have the opportunity to discourse with you. If we can remain civil perhaps the nation can be saved.

This discussion is closed to new replies.