Discussion Locked

Free Cellphone!!!!!

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

If you qualify. https://www.safelinkwireless.com

I saw this add on the TV last night. What are your thoughts about giving away a free cellphone to eligible persons for "emergency" use. In Massachusetts you get 80 minutes a month. It looks like you can go buy Tracphone minute cards and add them to the phone as well.

I am kind of on the fence about this. Wouldn't it be best to charge them a nominal fee say $5 bucks a month, that way tax payers don't have to front the entire cost?

I'm all for providing necessary services, but cellphones are still a convenience. Or am I wrong?

37 replies

by mschenkel

Seems like it could be a pretty good idea in the sense it makes a nice "home" for phones which might otherwise end up in the trash.

by ontheropes

Five bucks a month might not seem like much to a lot of people but speaking as one who has been on a very tight budget, for what seems like forever, five bucks can make the difference between having some hot soup and not eating. I'd rather eat and take my chances that I wouldn't need an emergency phone.

Put a fee on it and the people the program is supposed to help probably wouldn't get it.

by cmiller5400

Been there, done that. Have the bumper sticker, tee shirt and coffee mug. :)

I guess my main point is that is a cell phone considered a convenience or a necessity these days?

by ganyssa

pay phones have been removed on the assumption that 'everyone has a cell phone.'

Even the emergency call boxes on Michigan highways have become 'Call 911 from your cell phone' from the signs that I've noticed.

I'm not sure if they're exactly a necessity, but the inconvenience of not having a cell phone is becoming greater as time goes by.

by ontheropes

I asked him why he needed that and he just looked at me like I was stupid. He has to have a number where he can be reached by different agenices, possible employers and a way to call friends of his if he needs a ride across town or is in desperate need of shelter. Does he 'need' his phone? He thinks he does. He's got one of those pay as you go Tracphones and I have his number on my cellphone just in case I come across an odd job that he can handle.

Having a cell phone definitely makes his life easier.

by w2ktechman

When I tried dropping my service to an emergency only service a few years ago, it was going to cost me $15 a month for a maximum of 10 minutes a month, $2 a minute after that. I canceled the phone instead.
80 minutes a month + rollover minutes for an emergency phone seems a bit extreme. How long does an average 911 call take??

by cmiller5400

Most of the 911 calls that I have made are less than 2 minutes; 1 of those is spent navigating the computerized menu of the State Police computer and holding for a person, then asking for the town that you need the service in... The next is telling the actual town FD, PD etc, where the issue is and what the issue is.

The real kicker is that cellphone companies don't charge you for 911 calls. And even a phone that has been deactivated can still call 911.

by w2ktechman

I can see giving them a phone (preferably one that is being recycled but still works fine), and maybe 30 minutes with no features (like rollover, etc.)a month + 911.
But this seems to go a bit overboard in my mind. How many emergencies does someone have every month that requires the taxpayers to pay for it?

by ontheropes

that it's a fully featured phone able to recieve as well as place calls, not just for emergencies. If you were near destitute would you be able to use a fully featured telephone more vs. a limited services phone? Of course. You could call about jobs and any number of other things.

Should the government, any government local or nation-wide, pay for it? I don't think so but then nobody ever asks me before spending my money. At least that's what it feels like. I don't think that having a cell phone is a 'right'.

What do I know? What about free smoke detectors? Are those necessary? Who's paying for those giveaways?

by notsochiguy

...Crime Connect Cellular, it is safe to say that I'm not too keen on a program like this.

"Hello, and thank you for calling Government Sponsored Crime Phone.
For a pay-for-da-booty call, press one.
For a drug deal, press two.
For a quick shout out, press three.
For a contract hit, press four."

I'd be curious to see if anyone would accept these phones if they were handed out with the understanding that they were government property, and as such, were subject to random monitoring without notice.

If I had my druthers, I'd rather the tax money go to vans and drivers to cart people around to various job fairs and interviews (along with a better method of job search assistance...what they have in Illinois is pretty pathetic, from my experience).

Just my 2 cents.

by oz_media

They are simply charging you an access fee for having a phone attatched to their network.

However, you can take any old phone and dial 911 with it without having a provider. At least you can in Canada, it would only make sense to have the same stateside.

by cmiller5400

There was a story not too long ago about a cellphone that called 911 quite a bit. No one was on the other end, and they couldn't locate it. I can't find the link now, but will post it if I find it.

by hal 9000

The Public Infrastructure here, things like working Public Phones cost a lot of money to provide initially and then to keep working. If for instance a Government was responsible for making sure that there where sufficient Public Phones available it would probably be cheaper to give away Free Cell Phones and a few minutes per month than to provide the necessary Public Phones in the more remote locations. You know the ones that are easy to Vandalize because there is no Security around 24/7.

Here the Government owned Telco produced a Vandal Proof Public Phone and they tested these quite severely. Then they released 2 for Public Use in the worst area in the city amid much Press and Public Fanfare. They insisted that these phones where impossible to Vandalize and they probably may have been if they had of survived more than the first night. Apparently no one thought about the entire Phone Booth being stolen which is what happened with the above case. So when the press arrived the next day to use the Public Phones they found some bolts sticking out of the footpath and no Phone Booth.

Now I know that I'm perverse but I thought that was funny. The idiot thing though is that if they had not of gone to all the trouble of dragging the Press there in all likelihood the people responsible wouldn't have stolen the Phone Booths as they where given a challenge to prove the Pollies incorrect and this was broadcast on State News at the very least. It was actually probably on National News the first day and defiantly on the second day when the entire things had been stolen. :D

So if that is the case where this is going on it makes a lot of sense to save money by using the cheaper option that is now available.

Col

by oz_media

YOU mean like those ones I saw in magazines from teh olden days, where you had to put money in them and they were in big glass booths on the sidewalk?

WOW, you've seen one of them?

Seriously though, my cell was dead one day and I decided to find a payphone, good luck with that. I actually just ended up asking a lady walking by if I could use her cell phone for a quick local call and she was happy to help.

by hal 9000

I only feel Homeless I do actually have a home even if I'm hardly ever there. :(

But I'm probably the opposite I hate Cell Phones with a vengeance probably because I had to carry a pager all the time many years ago and it wasn't a Convenience for me though it may have been for others who wanted me to fix their stuff. Today I'm selectively deaf when it comes to Cell Phones and while I do carry one I'm flat out using it more than once every 3 or so months. I hate the things as they are just a updated pager that I see as an attempt to ruin any free time I may get. My Daughter in Law thinks that I'm [b]Weird[/b] for not having multiple Cell Phones just like her but honestly I draw the line at having one phone charger in the car let alone 2 or more.

I don't want to carry a Camera or MP3 Player with me all the time though I must admit that one of the new ones with a GPS in it may prove useful if it is as good as the GPS I have fitted in the car.

Col

by boxfiddler Hot topic

thinks you're weird for sake of perversity. That cell phone thing of yours? Just a symptom. :D :D :D

by hal 9000

But some of my customers are really Weird. I have to go out tomorrow to look at a 18 month old NB that I supplied that isn't reliably sending Copies of E-Mails.

Apparently if Attachments are included some recipients can open them and some can not and then the next day a person who could open something can no longer open any new E-Mails from this guy.

This person also can not tell the Difference between Outlook and Outlook Express and constantly calls one the other and so on so I'm totally confused. I guess that instead of spending hours trying to sort out what is happening here I'll find that he has just messed up a setting hopefully.

Though this is the same guy who insisted that he had all of his Install Disc's and then handed me his phone when I asked what Model it was, I did however say that [b]Black[/b] wasn't a Model but the color of the phone. :D

But I suppose I shouldn't complain too much at least he hasn't hit me with any I Pod Problems yet. Before taking on this company I had never so much as looked at an I Pod and I'm almost an Expert on them. :(

Col

by the scummy one

are they used for different things or something? Or is it that she cannot pass up[ a deal when she sees one? If the latter, keep her away from the phone stores (and electronics stores altogether) (well, all stores and online as well).

by hal 9000

Besides she's the wife of [b]SWMBO[/b] son so I'm defiantly not responsible for her. :D

I stopped referring to him as our son 20 years ago and I see no reason to change that position. :)

Col ]:)

by oz_media

In Vancouver they have places to take your old cell phone to, where they hand them out to hookers and women living on the streets for emergency use.

Sure the phones are not new, but I can't remember the last time i actually PAID for a new phone, they are ALWAYS free if you tell them you want ot switch to a new provider to qualify for a free phone.

I get a new one every year, without changing my contract or signing a new multiyear contract. Just a new phone mailed out to me each December, January.

The government paying for these phones would cost next to nothing, for mere fractions of a tax payer's penny.

If they offered them with contracts, they'd have a street value (even if just $10) and would be pawned, stolen traded for drugs etc. If free and with no value, its simply a phone.

by the scummy one

here are a little more details

"Lifeline Benefits

Lifeline Assistance is part of a program that was created by the government to provide discounted or free telephone service to income-eligible consumers. To help bring you this important benefit, SafeLink Wireless is proud to offer Lifeline Service. Through our Lifeline Service you will receive FREE cellular service, a FREE cell phone, and FREE Minutes every month! SafeLink Wireless Service does not cost anything ? there are no contracts, no recurring fees and no monthly charges.

Any Minutes you do not use will roll-over. Features such as caller ID, call waiting and voicemail are all also included with your service. If you need additional Minutes, you can buy TracFone Airtime Cards at any TracFone retailer Walmart, Walgreens, Family Dollar, etc). SafeLink Airtime Cards will be available soon.

Your exact benefits, including the number of free Minutes you will receive, depend on the state you live in. Please enter your ZIP code to get the details for your state."

Rollover minutes, caller ID, call waiting and Vmail. There are no real restrictions aside from who they go to when handed out.

I didnt check multiple states, however as mentioned earlier, 80 minutes/month. So it is not a great plan, but it certainly isnt just for emergencies.

by oz_media

How many telemarketers, spam texts etc you'd get though? they MUST be selling numbers to sponsors in order to justify it. Kinda like teh old FREE INTERNET Access dumps that would banner ad your webpages and track all your surfing for market research projects.

by notsochiguy

...to programs like this. Battered women shelters, emergency phones for the homeless, etc. The phones are reconditioned for the purpose of calling 9-1-1 in the event of need.

A program like this I have no issue with at all. The one linked to in the original post, though, seems ripe for abuse.

Maybe I'm just overly skeptical, and have lived in the Chicago area far too long. ;)

by oz_media

If it SOUNDs to good to be true, chances are that it is.

I would assume that the contract is rife with invasive verbage that allows them to sell your number to advertisers, to have them send spam texts etc. to you aas often as they wish. I am sure the numbers woull dthen be sold to local telemarketing shops when the initial sponsors are done with them.

Kinda like that National Do Not Call list, scam.

by oz_media

Without paid airtime, it can still be used to dial 911. For this reason they collect and hand out used phones to the homless, hookers living on the streets etc. for emergencies.

by hal 9000

If these people are homeless how do they Charge the Phones?

Or more importantly who pays for the Electricity to Charge them?

Col

by the scummy one

80 min/month too :^0

Think of all of the SPAM that can be recieved in 80 minutes :D

Hmmm, maybe these phone #'s will be posted in a public forum somewhere? Since we are paying for it, might as well get the info. Then everyone can take turns spamming them :D

by oz_media

try and get personal privacy to adhere to a government owned/provided phone number. LOL.

by oz_media

In fact, they used to have a #811 service for retrieving your Shaw account info by cell phone, it has since been changed to a local or 1-800 number as there were too many misdials to 911.

I remember reading about one lady who had 811 prgramed in her phone, but programmed 911 by acccident. When she got through to the emergency operators she swore it was THEIR problem becuase SHE had her phone programmed to speed dial SHAW and she wasn't manually dialing the number.

by forum surfer

Any newer phone will still have 911 capabilities and location capabilities even with no activation. Why not give them those phones? Setting up drop boxes at fire department would be a no brainer. That way the only tax payer money used is in gathering and distribution? Then if they want it activated, that's on them.

by the scummy one

more spending of tax $$$'s that are not available to put us deeper in debt.

Just look around, several States are on the verge of bankruptcy, several govt. programs are on the verge as well. However new shlt passes to spend more of it???

We need to start kicking the shlt out of any politician who signs off on wasteful spending or programs such as this that are way too open.

by forum surfer

I was just suggesting a cheaper alternative with the same outcome.

I agree, government needs to do some deep budget cuts just like the rest of us. As do these upper level type people in upper management at large corporations. It's time to trim the fat. I'm not saying axe people, just spend conscientiously.

by hal 9000

It's very little and even then they get a [b]Deal[/b] from the suppliers who have to Tender every so often to retain the sales.

The companies virtually give away their products to be able to say that they have a Government Contract. :)

I see programs like this as [b]GREAT[/b] if nothing else you are not going to be mugged in the street for your Cell Phone as they will have no value if nothing else.

Col

by forum surfer

I once worked on the hardware procurement end for local government. Since I was a local government entity I wasn't bound by state contracts with vendors, but I did get the benefit of their pricing. While pricing was always cheaper than list, I found that alot of the time I could still shop around and get pc/server related stuff from small, independent vendors off of state contracts. I simply had to take the initiative to "bid out" whatever I was purchasing with multiple (3 or more) bids for anything over $1500. Or I could provide the state contract bid plus one other bid that beat it.

But yeah, most of the time stuff was cheaper. I got a peek at state ammo prices when I worked there. I practically cried when I saw they got target rounds for %50-%80 less than what I paid.

The way government pays for items makes a difference, too. Since large pc purchases were paid for at once, it often negated the savings a lease may offer since that was a yearly recurring cost. I did one analysis on purchasing 100 computers. IF I had to pay for them yearly over a three year payment, my lease payment was cheaper. But since I was paying in one lump sum, that one sum was cheaper than the total lease payments...not to mention the fact that I was able to recycle the equipment internally as opposed to returning it at the end of the lease.

This discussion is closed to new replies.