Discussion Locked

Free Software Hurts Innovation?

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK, this guy is at it again. From apparently the same author as "Penguin Suicide Bombers" comes a piece about how FOSS eventually hurts knowledge creation and creativity. Seems counterintuitive.

Freedom From Intellingence
The Real Meaning of "Free Software"
http://www.theobjectiveobserver.com/articles/technology04.shtml

Is there a valid point in there somewhere? The one that comes to mind for me is newspapers. If everyone creates news and distributes it for free on the Internet, then it effectively kills newspapers which is what is happening today. Seems like a similar argument is being made here but for all authors, artists and other creative folk.

28 replies

by danlm

I read the news every day on the Internet, but I still buy a news paper every day also.

Where you can read about an event on the internet, you can save the headline of the event with a news paper. First man on the moon, jfk being shot, mlk being shot, Nixon resigns, 911, .... Those are front page events that alot of people want to keep... As reminders of how bad things can get or how good things can be.

They said that electronic books would kill the hard cover book, not so. I still give away to the library all my books that I buy after I have completed reading them.

They just have to learn to compete by offering a better product, thats all.

And I apologize, I didn't read the article. I seen your point about news papers and had to reply. I will read the article though, because I have seen a couple of these types of articles pop up lately and I don't think I read the one you posted yet.

Dan

For all I read, and I read constantly... Every day. I can't spell worth crap...

by hal 9000

Actually the Closed Source Movement is the one Stifling Knowledge, Creation and Creativity. Closed Source is constantly lagging behind software development and dragging the entire industry back to at best last years offerings but mostly back top last decades Software.

It is Open Source or Free Software that is driving development in new things and it is the one creating knowledge and creativity.

Just how many Commercial Pay for Software applications are currently available for 64 Bit Architecture? Then look at how long 64 Bit CPU's and M'Boards have been available and you'll see just how flawed the argument actually is.

The major Software Houses are the ones with a vested interest in not changing as they have too much tied up in previously developed Technologies and can not afford to scrap what they currently have to develop new Technologies. They have become Big Cumbersome Tunelvissioned enterprises who can not move quickly to adapt to new Technological Developments as they become available and eventually 5 years after the Hardware is developed they offer a Piece Meal product to take advantage of what is almost absolute technology about to be replaced with New Technology like 126 Bit Architecture they push out a pile of nonworking poorly written product that only encourages the Masses not to adopt the newer Technologies.

In PC look at the move from 8 to 16 Bit and then to 32 Bit Software architecture and then compare that to the half arsed attempts to develop 64 Bit Software, with no idea of what will come latter.

Col

by bizzo

There were so many flaws in that article I had to use an elevator just to get to the end of it.

I just think the guy has something against open source. His other articles are just as bad.

"Standing on the shoulders of giants" obviously means nothing to him.

by nicknielsen

The author started with a fanboy premise, used a flawed definition and proceeded down a snide street to an elementary conclusion.

I even laughed in a couple of places. Considering how much choice consumers actually have in the software installed on new PCs, this pair of sentences needed a screen wipe warning: [i]With or without free software, consumers have always had a choice of what software to use. The fact that the majority of them tend to choose a particular software vendor who will remain nameless, [cough] Microsoft, is beside the point.[/i]

by smoupre

OK, I agree the article is flawed but how is it flawed relative to the basic premise which is that copyright works for everything else so why is it bad for software. What is unique about software? I can't think of anything.

by bizzo

They work to protect the author/designer/inventor from people stealing their ideas.

Copyright does work for software, Microsoft and Apple are making millions from it. But there are people trying to remove their stronghold on software and OSs. Hence Open Source and GNU Licensing.

When you buy a PC with windows on it, it's full of bloatware, you have no choice, it just is. You buy a PC and put Linux on it, you remove yourself from Microsoft's stronghold, if that's what you want to do, and it's free. That's the choice.

GNU Licensing and Open Source allow developers to build on what is already there, improve it, and throw it back into the public domain, where the next developer can do the same. That's where the freedom comes in.

By the way, are you the blogger? It's just this is the second one of their articles you posted here.

by tony hopkinson

Is it the right to copy something, or is it the right to claim something is yours.

If you were to copy my code to fill in a listbox from a database connection, have you violated a copyright?

Which bits of a piece of software constitute the IP?

As for the argument that copyright doesn't harm innovation, I recomend pop charts and daytime tv, no better proof of the stifling effect can be found.

CopyRight is called copyright, because it's where you assign the right to copy to a publishing house, it is not, never was and never will be designed to protect the author, it was designed to enable the distributor.

It's not that software is different it's that the media is. Copyright right laws were formulated for priniting presses, not hard drives and pens.

Besides if you like copyright you must like the GPL, it is a copyright.

by nicknielsen

It protects the creator of a work by preventing indiscriminate duplication of that work without due compensation.

The flaw is in the author's reasoning that releasing software under an open license such as the GPL or CC will somehow stifle innovation.

by charliespencer

"Besides if you like copyright you must like the GPL, it is a copyright."

I like being able to choose my licensing model, to be able to charge as much (or as little) as I want, to be able to choose whether I want to release all, some, or none of the source code for my app. I don't like anyone telling me I shouldn't expect payment for the work I did. If I want to charge for it, that should be my choice and not someone else's mandate. I don't want anyone else to profit from my work without my receiving as large (or small) a percentage as I care to charge.

If no one wants to pay my price for my product, they are not obligated to buy or use it and are free to develop their own. I don't think either model harms development. If it's all about 'choice', why limit my choices in licensing and protection?

by tony hopkinson

make something more valuable, so you can charge a higher price for it.

Not in itself a bad thing, I might add.

Copyrighting code though is a nonsense, that it like copyrighting a novel by laying claim to the alphabet.

by charliespencer

Last time I looked it wasn't illegal to make or sell only a limited number of a product, or to charge whatever I want for it. Just so long as I'm not taking actions to prevent someone from offering a competitive product, what's the damage?

Whether I copyright the code or not, I'm not obligated to provide the code to an application I've developed from scratch.

by j-mart

Because financial gain is not the reason
for FOSS but the authors are presenting
their creation, warts and all for their
peers to scrutinise, what greater incentive
to produce good and innovative work. Who
wants to place a load of rubbish out there
to be serverely torn apart by your peers.
On the other hand being a cog buried in the
corporate wheel feeling unappreciated
churning out the same old dribble may not
produce your best work

by pweegar1

If this were the case, why isn't there better free software available NOW? Take openoffice for example. What a pile of crap that is. It looks and acts like a bunch of amateurs created it. I tried to print a 2 page spreadheet yesterday. The second page ends up being half way down the page. YUCK. Opened the same file in Excel, it worked perfect.

Without MS pouring the millions of dollars into office, openoffice wouldn't even exist.

Sorry, when I create a piece of software, not only do I want to feel good about it, I want to get PAID for my efforts. This it feels good crap doesn't pay the bills.

Sorry, I can't get behind the feel good belief that FOSS encourages innovation. So far it hasn't.

by nicknielsen

So based on one failed operation in one program in a software suite, the entire suite is a piece of crap, therefore FOSS does not innovate?

Do you mind if I critique your output? I know it's a piece of crap. Why? Well, you see, M$ tells us it's impossible to write error-free software. Therefore, by extension, [u]you[/u] as a developer cannot possibly write error-free software. Now, since any software with errors in it is a piece of crap, everything you write is a piece of crap. QED

Ain't logic great?

I'd much rather use OpenOffice than MS Office. It's lighter on system resources, the default file formats take up much less space than MS formats, I can save in MS format if required, and I don't have to contribute to the Steve Ballmer retirement fund.

by neon samurai

"If this where the case.."

Microsoft is just over 30 years old and Windows is around the 30 year mark. Windows starts in the 80s.

The Linux kernel starts around 1991 and most distros heard of today are much newer with the exception of grandaddy Slackware and grammy GNU.

I'd say it's pretty impressive that Linux and OS based on it have evolved into a viable replacement for Windows in such a short time given the resources available to Microsoft.

For open office, we should maybe compaire Office at that same point in it's life. How old is OpenOffice and how was Office when it was the same age? Are you critisising OpenOffice for not handling XLS as well as Excel does? I also use my Windows VM for working with XLS in Excel since only MS can play with MS best.

Ok, you point out OpenOffice which has lots of maturing to do still. How about all the other FOSS programs that are above and beyond alternatives? Maybe comparing to StarOffice or the Novell version of OpenOffice would help since they, like Office, both have direct financial support and direction. There are also many examples of FOSS programs without comparible alternatives, ask some of the Apache users. Across all my platforms, I use Firefox and Thunderbird.. both FOSS.. both great at what they do.

With MS having billions of dollars available, why is there software not built to better standards? Without MS, many other office suites would still exist but OpenOffice is returning choice too the user slowly.

What license you choose for your software is your decision. You may want to do some more reading if you think FOSS is only about comptuer hippies feeling good. I'd recommend reading the papers available from Eric Raymond (search Eric Raymond catb). Cathedral and the Bazzar is one you should read along with world domination, hackers revenge and the other papers offered. Even if you think he's a nut job, he does clearly explain this whole FOSS thing in terms beyind "computer hippies are cool".

by j-mart

That is a personal choice you have made, doing it for the sheer joy and challenge is the personal choice of others. As I make regular use of many of of these offerings I definately have no complaints of the quality of these products.

In the case of Open Office, when I compare it to Microsoft Office, if they were both commercial offerings and for sale at a reasonable and fair price ( in my opinion MS Office should be cheaper ) I would purchase Open Office before I would consider MS Office.

Getting back on the point - Foss encourages inovation, taking one example, Vista, MS made many promisses of invovation when they released original specification, such as a new journalised file system and 3D desktop, where are they, Open Source has had both of these features for some time. With Vista we got absolutely no inovation just same old regurgitated rubbish.

Don't underestimate the power of one's ego, even if there is payment invoved, when one's name goes on a product no one likes to see their name on a load of rubbish and in the case of the FOSS product with no payment involved you can't even use the excuse "I was just doing what I was paid for" if the product is rubbish. For those involved in FOSS they definatly want to be known for their quality and inovative work.

by m61

...the copyleft movement come in? heck, i don't even know the difference between copyright and copyleft..just seen copyleft here and there...

by jaqui

Copyleft is a play on the word copyright and describes the practice of using copyright law to remove restrictions on distributing copies and modified versions of a work for others and requiring that the same freedoms be preserved in modified versions.

Which makes Tony's claim that the GNU-GPL is a form of CopyRight in error, it actually is a CopyLeft, in that it grants rights to copy and change the original work.

edit, typo

by m61

for clearing that up...sort of

i think i understand what 'copyleft' vs 'copyright' is now, but i'm not 100% sure i'll be able to spot the difference when i see it...

but at least i understand what copyleft is for the most part

by smoupre

I tagged the RSS when I found the first one.

The responses to this thing are not really showing any problems in logic despite the claims of flaws. So where are all the free and open books, music, movies, etc.? I can't figure out what makes software different that there is this movement to basically demonize copyrighted software. I mean, in music there is Pearl Jam right, but they still protect their brand and music. They don't let someone else create a derivative work that some other artist making money on without licensing to make sure they get their cut, right?

I guess it just makes coders out to be people that do not see their work as having any value.

by jaqui

but there are issues with copyleft still.
specially with getting acceptance for gpled software. The copyleft aspect gives the impression that even the output of, say, a word processor, has to be under the gpl.
[ it doesn't have that requirement, if you read carefully. ]

I think a conditional copyleft, which allows for proprietary code, as long as it does not require open source code, would be a better way to go. At least as pertains to getting a commercial software house to start supporting open source operating systems.

by jaqui

copyleft, grants rights free of charge
copyright restricts use.

when reading any license, if it gives you rights for copy, distribution, alteration, it is a copyleft license usually.
if it restricts you from any of the above uses, it is a copyright license. [ MS EULA for example ]

by tony hopkinson

it's purpose. If your business model is essentially product oriented, then safeguarding your right to the product is an obvious step.

This goes back to one of my earlier points though, it's the ease of copying that's causing many of the issues and this is where copyright legislation and the product concept behind it hasn't caught up.

You could copy a Van gogh if you wanted , but to make a convincing one would require great skill and enormous amount of effort for each copy.

You can copy Tony.exe to Palmetto.exe with almost no effort at all....

by charliespencer

I don't think the original article makes it's case very well. It looks like the author had a pre-determined conclusion and tried to argue up to it. I don't think the "support / customization" model will damage either future development or the "software as a product" model. I don't think it's necessary for ALL software to sold under the same license model.

His argument cuts both ways; it's not just the open source community that offers no-cost apps. Windows now includes many apps that used be purchased separately; that doesn't keep competing products from arising. Having Internet Explorer included for free killed Netscape, but it didn't stop development of FireFox. Having a free defrager in W doesn't stop Diskeeper from making and selling new apps. A free firewall don't keep others from selling similar security tools.

This discussion is closed to new replies.