Discussion Locked

Freedom of speech is nonexisten here on TR from what I see.

0 helpful
461 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

461 replies

by deepsand

then go to "View All Posts."

My post, in Reply to messageID=2242060, is [u]invisible[/u].

Then, in [u]either[/u] view, try to find my reply to my above said post.

by jdclyde

not sure about the all view option, but in the normal screen, it just keeps going and going an .....

by deepsand

On IE, it's completely cloaked, with only the blank lines to hint at the presence of "something."

by deepsand

This, I assume, is from personal experience.

As I've not yet had the pleasure, I'll defer judgement.

by skirsch

Not to add to an incredibly stupid argument, and I'm sure this has been brought up already - I simply don't have time enough or care to read 400+ replies to idiocy.

You DO NOT have the right to free speech on this site, no matter what you think. This site is owned and operated privately by CNET and TechRepublic and you use its services only after having the opportunity to view the Terms of Usage agreement (http://www.cnetnetworks.com/editorial/terms.html?tag=tr.ft.co).

Even if you were to pay for the use of TechRepublic you would not have the right to free speech.

And since you're not smart enough to read ToA's/ToU's and EULA's, I figure your not smart enough to read the Constitution either:
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

CONGRESS shall make no law - not that Companies, or Persons can make no law, or rule. Not that your freedom of speech is protected uniformly no matter what by the constitution -- simply that CONGRESS shall make no law. Now who is the liberal, Mr I-want-blanket-immunity-from-my-own-vocal-idiocy.

And, as for the Terms of Usage from CNET:
"We have the right, but not the obligation, to take any of the following actions in our sole discretion at any time and for any reason without giving you any prior notice:

1. Restrict, suspend, or terminate your access to all or any part of our Services;
2. Change, suspend, or discontinue all or any part of our Services;
3. Refuse, move, or remove any material that you submit to our sites for any reason;
4. Refuse, move, or remove any content that is available on our sites;
5. Deactivate or delete your accounts and all related information and files in your account;
6. Establish general practices and limits concerning use of our sites."

"Without limiting the foregoing, you agree that you will not use our sites to take any of the following actions:

1. Defame, abuse, harass, stalk, threaten, or otherwise violate the legal right of others;
2. Publish, post, upload, e-mail, distribute, or disseminate (collectively, "Transmit") any inappropriate, profane, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, or unlawful content;
3. Transmit files that contain viruses, corrupted files, or any other similar software or programs that may damage or adversely affect the operation of another person's computer, our sites, any software or hardware, or telecommunications equipment;
4. Advertise or offer to sell any goods or services for any commercial purpose unless you have our written consent to do so;
5. Transmit surveys, contests, pyramid schemes, spam, unsolicited advertising or promotional materials, or chain letters;
6. Download any file that you know or reasonably should know cannot be legally obtained in such manner;
7. Falsify or delete any author attributions, legal or other proper notices or proprietary designations or labels of the origin or the source of software or other material;
8. Restrict or inhibit any other user from using and enjoying any public area within our sites;
9. Collect or store personal information about other end users;
10. Interfere with or disrupt our sites, servers, or networks;
11. Impersonate any person or entity, including, but not limited to, a CNET Networks representative, or falsely state or otherwise misrepresent your affiliation with a person or entity;
12. Forge headers or manipulate identifiers or other data in order to disguise the origin of any content transmitted through our sites or to manipulate your presence on our sites;
13. Take any action that imposes an unreasonably or disproportionately large load on our infrastructure;
14. Engage in any illegal activities."

Any prolonged arguing on your part when you, of your own free will, chose to use these services and therefor entered into a binding legal agreement with CNET and its subsidiaries does, indeed, show the extreme level of ignorance you hold towards not just persons of another race, or nationality, or economic means - whatever your grievance might be - but also your level of ignorance simply concerning your own daily actions.

YOU broke the rules YOU agreed to. This is not a liberal/conservative debate or even a racial equality debate. You chose to come to this site to defame others, no matter how much of a "informative" package on visa's and business practices you believe you wrapped said defamation in.

Yes, people can choose not to read it, but you can also chose not to use the services of a site that restricts your ability to express your way of thinking, and your political/economic and/or global views - via an agreement you willingly signed. YOU entered into this agreement of your own free will, YOU chose to use free services provided by a profit minded company, and YOU have the ability to exit from said contract if you wish.

Your OP Title is correct, Freedom of speech IS nonexistent here on TechRepublic. Learn to education yourself, Learn to be aware of the full particulars of agreements your enter into, and finally, Learn to understand that Freedom of Speech is not a universally applicable rule of life - considering it as such would be a rather liberal view, wouldn't you say?

by jdclyde

But I would question how it is that someone that has been a member for a whole day would have that much invested in the site to care enough to write it?

Let me guess, a lurker that finally found something that pulled you off the fence? Everyone has that one key issue that sucks them in, was this yours?

[i](nothing wrong with lurkers, so please do not think that it was intended as some form of put-down.)

by skirsch

I'll admit I haven't used TechRepublic in a bit, and overall this is probably my 3rd account on the site, and I've used the site on and off for 5 years or so in total... when one tends to move around a lot as well as have a tendency to drop external hard drives and lose data without a lot of personal backups, you tend to lose old passwords/accounts pretty regularly :-p

by jdclyde

Let him put it to his own head?

Self serve is so much better in these modern days....

by jdclyde

she would have a killer recipe for making tequila shooters! :D mmmmmmmm, tequilaaaa....

[i]"tequila makes me fall down...."

by jdclyde

Lions! Feed him to the lions! [i](no, not the football team. even HE could take them....) :0

by wkpickett0154

I am always so amazed when folks can make some intelligent sentences but- due to not paying attention, lack of education- not sure- it's Drivel- 'talk foolishly' and write, as in write letters...wkpickett0154@comcast.net (Looking for intelligent life that wants to do, be, and have more, so we can create a better humanity going forward...)

by jdclyde

Does the person become a felon at the time of the act, or at the time he/she is caught and convicted?

Like O.J. Simpson, found not-guilty, (provided he really did it, ~cough cough~ ) would still be a felon despite not being a CONVICTED felon?

by deepsand

"Felon" has a specific legal definition; and, absent a conviction, one is not legally a felon.

Therefore, one can but presume that, given [u]all[/u] pertinent facts, a conviction could be obtained.

by maecuff

1. Put tequila of your choice in shot glass.

2. Drink shot

3. Repeat as necessary or until bottle is empty.

by jdclyde

sip or slam the shots?

lemon/salt or straight?

Two favorite brands?

it grosses my drinking partners out, but I sip it straight. mmmmmmmm, tequila...

by jdclyde

because you actually supported your statements, which is a CLASSIC newbie character flaw.

by maecuff

just slamming.

Salt and lemon? Waste of time.

Favorite brands? Cabo Wabo and Patron. Although Sauza Hornitos isn't bad and it's cheaper than the other two. Jose will do if there isn't anything else available.

by toms45

Talk about "taking the bait". WOW, Why Me Worry sure got all of you "hooked" into this decidedly non-technical discussion. BTW, WTF!
Did that offend? They're just letters....
Bet I can bait some of you, too!
Come on people, it's a TECHNICAL forum. Hit some the .alt.alt.alt sites if you really want some non-PC stuff.
Sorry to all who have taken this topic so seriously, but after reading a 100 or so, the light came on and I realized you'd all been snookered by this dude.
Have fun, laugh about it, forget about it...
Life goes on.

by deepsand

Bait? Very bad assumption on your part.

Judging from your Post History, I'd venture a guess that you've no clue re. the background of WMW. However, if you'd [b]first read[/b] this thread, you would have had one.

Snookered? Yes, you were.

by jdclyde

and never came across off-topic discussions? I thought it was just the noobies that thought to take it upon themselves to tell others how and where to post?

by aptechme

I was reading along and was about to post this exact message.
You're giving him what he wants.
Let the board admins shut him up, or just ignore him.

Peace, and have a great weekend all.

Edit* Before deepsand takes offence ;) thought I would clarify... I don't care where or how anyone posts, but I still think you were giving him what he wanted. No, I did not spend time looking over his post history.

by deepsand

I disagree with the contention that "we" gave him what he wanted. What he wanted was support from others and/or the means to continue with his offensive behavior.

He attained neither; and, in a manner which should make clear to him that he will not succeed in those regards.

May the Future be Kind.

PS - Bear in mind that TR's staff makes no attempts to proactively identify & take action re. miscreants; rather, they react to incidents as they are reported by members.

by steffi28

You mean there are actually on topic discussions?? Damn why have I never wrote to any :p

by shellbot

don't worry about it...we only have one topic on our minds most the time anyways !

oh and BTW...the caffeine thread..that was taken WAY out of context..if i can just friggin reply to it now (in theory in know how, i just need need to get it to actually work)
i go try in a min

by steffi28

Your excuses don't work with me! I know your secret ;)

And that one topic, dare I ask what it is?? :p

by shellbot

I'm not going to tell you!! ]:)

Umm..ok..well..think about it for a few and see if you can guess. :)

Now..gotta go rip some testicles off someone..
why does it seem that everyone i work with is completely stupid??????? Dropped everything else and Busted my @ss doing an export as "high priority" and when i send it to the company i need to, get a reply from the Director saying we've not paid our contract fees for this year, so they won't touch it till we do..
I was mortified..and everyone here playing stupid..

grrrrrrr

by jdclyde

Don't you just hate it when some bean counter somewhere has left your a$$ to flap in the wind over something?

My company is industrial. Some of the plant equipment has a controller that is actually just a PC (that we didn't know about).

Well, the system died, so the plant is dead in the water. ~oh great~ "can't you fix this computer? Isn't that what you guys do?"

Sure, we can fix the computer, but of course the company that provides it will not provide the software to run the plant, but they WILL load a new system and send it out within a week. Only cost $6500, plus shipping. Oh, and because of past conflicts, we will need a check in-hand before we do anything..... ~wtf?~

Got to love it.... That is what kept me on the road over half of last week. After we get the system, it wouldn't friggen work! There was a bug in the software... ~grrrr~

"Oh, we don't do dial-in support anymore, we come in over the internet". fine and dandy, but there is no network run out to that building..... ~sigh~ I made a 150 foot patch cable and ran it over for the few hours they needed it, and then coiled it back up.

Was not, and am not, happy about that situation.

by nicknielsen

As much as the hack has been abused, I'm surprised it took this look to patch it.

But far be it from me to point fingers......

by deepsand

... that TR saw fit to devote resources, not to fixing any of the many problems that reduce the usability of this site, but to removing a functionality whose usage came, so far as I can tell, at no cost to them.

by absolutely

[i]How about not jumping on folks at all?
What purpose does it serve?[/i]

My question is not "What purpose...", but "[b]Whose[/b] purpose does it serve", just in general. I don't div a sham about the git here pig-piled, but in general, what's the point? Whose interests [b]are[/b] served, when we all waste our time thus?

by absolutely

You have said that you think WMW should be able to [b]say[/b] what he wants.

Quit your titty-baby whining about others who [b]say[/b] why they think TR was right to edit over his posts.

by absolutely

You're right. At least with this one, I detect less likelihood of being back-sassed than, ahem, with a certain other character on a certain other thread in which we showed that atheists did evolve from apes, and that zealous young Earth creationists have not.

by deepsand

TonyTheTiger?

He vacillates between what gives the appearance of being genuine curiosity & and clinging to tightly held beliefs.

by absolutely

His stance on a couple threads has been less Old Liberal than I had expected. I'm for challenging him on the claim that science teachers are over-emphasizing science. I recall that in "The Last Word ..." thread, he made reference to "hammering" some perspective or another toward science into young minds. I think that claim calls for verifiable documentation.

by deepsand

I'm hard pressed to recall anything that he's said that would have suggested "liberal" to be an apt description.

It's his "I don't know anything for certain, therefore [i]you[/i] [u]cannot[/u] know anything for certain, therefore all knowledge is relative" mantra that puzzles me.

by absolutely

Tony does seem to lean toward freedom, but it may just be that he leans away from the stupidest forms of wasteful government regulations, and because there are so friggin many of those I give him more credit than he deserves.

by tonythetiger

[i]Tony does seem to lean toward freedom, but it may just be that he leans away from the stupidest forms of wasteful government regulations, and because there are so friggin many of those I give him more credit than he deserves.[/i]

but I am curious as to what credit I am given that I don't deserve (I certainly don't want it if I haven't earned it).

and Sandy,

I often seek advice in my life's journeys. So I am confused by the comment.

by deepsand

If you will be more specific re. the comment in question, I'll be happy to try to clarify.

by absolutely

Tony: [i]...but I am curious as to what credit I am given that I don't deserve (I certainly don't want it if I haven't earned it).[/i]

Only you know if you deserve it, my agreement is of secondary importance at most, and I was presumptuous to reference the concept "credit". I apologize.

by nicknielsen

Pub food isn't bad at all. Of course, I've never been sober when I've eaten in a pub...

I think British cuisine never caught on in the US because of the names. No self-respecting American is going to eat "Toad in the hole," "Bangers and mash" or "Spotted Dick." Of course, some of use that have been there and had it do occasionally miss it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.