As always, the media spins all kinds of garbage and people are used to simply buying into what the media spins, yay north America.
In 1975, the Japanese manufacturer's scared the crap out of North american manufacturer's with the Honda Civic.
America's response was pathetic at best, Pinto, Chevette, Omni, Horizon et all. Complete garbage utility boxes. Lee Iacoca saved Chrysler by building all models with identical parts. A $9,000.00 compact omni had teh same suspension, motor, drive train as a $17,000.00 K-Car or a $45,000.00 LeBaron. Same cars, different body's.
People found that no matter what they spent, they got a POS good for 5 years. the Civic and Tercel were easily 10 year cars.
Then there was the Pinto (where media comes into it). The pinto was a decent build actually with good motor options, thogh with large displacement still. A small, 4-cylinder was a 2300cc! Pinto had an issue with a FEW cars being in rear end accidents and the tanks caught fire or exploded if low on gas.
This trashed the reputation for that car too, even though it was quickly rectified by moving the tank, all future pinto's were avoided. So the media spun the wind out of compacts as death traps. Nobody bought them unless strictly for budgetary reasons.
By the late 80's compact car repitation in North America was that they were garbage, but the media kept people away from buying Japanese too, they were still 'the enemy' to North america's car manufacturing, which employed so many North Americans. Unions were strong and they pushed the "buy American" mantra through the media too.
So now, all you can get in a compact car from North Americans, is a disposable POS.
They were forced to meet consumer demand for CHEAP garbage for the young, starter family or housewife needing a part time runabout car.
In the meantime European engineers were forced in the opposite direction, building highly efficient and long lasting models, but the consumer was prepared to pay more for these 'super compacts' that had engines capable of getting thier HP to the road. but out here they were just far too expensive, and local builders were meeting a cheap consumer's demand.
That has been perpetuated, 'compacts are cheap, gutless and don't last'.
Anyone in Europe will prove that to be garbage in no time.
Just look at the product options in th eUK compared to out here. Out here, Ford makes a few compact models, very limited, poorly fitted interiors etc. They look like stripped out econoboxes. Ford in the UK, makes a line of 10 different compact models, all with several engine options (teh largest beign near to America's smallest) and with a lot more horsepower and fuel efficiency that most North American cars of greater cost.
We just have cheap consumers that are scared to follow the European or Japanese lead in fear that we become obsolete and can no longer feel like the leaders even though it has been decades since we actually were.
Just like The Buggles sang on North America's very first MTV music video ever played, "Video killed the radio star", but in this case, "Media killed the compact car" :D