Discussion Locked

Gartner says IT must oursource by 2010

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

So Gartner Group, the folks that brought you the Y2K scare, say that by 2010 you must oursource or your will die.

Here is a summary:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/05/27/_gartner_outsourcing/

What do you think?

34 replies

by cg it

Gartner is basically saying that companies can not afford to employ knowledgeable computer tech support personnel and if they want to be competitive, they need to move their tech support help to outsourcing so that the minimum wage earner can try and solve computer tech problems by reading off of a piece of paper put together by the knowledgable tech support guys.

I dunno about anyone else, but consumers would rather call their friends, talk to their pet dog, anyone but the help desk or tech support people of the companies they bought their products and software from.

Maybe if companies offered a decent salary to tech support guys who know what they are doing, but not a salary that will break the bank like during the Dot Com boom, customer service, product service, and tech support wouldn't have to be outsourced.

by the admiral

Garner also said that there was going to be a 75% increase in storage marketshare in 2000. It turned out to be only 5%.

So depending on how hard up a company is, they will follow the drum and go bankrupt. Or they can do what Extreme Networks did and cancel their outsourcing agreement and bring their call center back to the US and is happy about doing so.

I think Gartner Group needs to be outsourced, since most if not all of their information is flawed.

by tony hopkinson

parrot what certain vendors want in market speak. Why don't they look at the real cost of outsourcing instead of just looking at manning ? We'd all be better off if the just STFU. As soon as you get into a competive market the only way you can distinguish yourself from your competitors is with good customer service, not cheap. I'll pay for good customer service, course I'm still waiting to see it in mainstream IT. If the main vendors performance on this front is anything to go by, I'll be waiting a lot longer as well.

by kevaburg

It seems to me that this company called Gartner has a lot of work to do. Out-sourcing for alot of companies is a good idea for the long term, but short-term statistics form the basis of long-term predictions for these guys.

The people that run Gartner are the people whose votes count. What needs to happen is for someone to provide real-time numbers for real-time problems and then to collate them in a manner that normal people can understand.

Maybe Gartner does need to be outsourced, but most of all their ideas do!!!!

by hwyman

I run a small IT department for a company of 75 -100.

We outsource our CISCO maintenance and programming for customizing our software. For every instance over 23 years of IT experience I have never seen outsourcing that was financially beneficial to anyone but the vendor.

It always costs much more, and is usually the first thing to get cut when companies scale back their costs. I have seen companies save millions bringing call centers back in house, and much more by hiring a single employee to avoid 184 dollar per hour contract costs of outsourcing, not to mention paying for travel expenses.

There may be exceptions when outsourcing is cheaper, but it is the exception and not the rule.

just my thoughts...

by itconsultant818

I agree that Gartner is known for exagerating, but i dont think outsourcing is bad. Offshoring, yes, I think is bad for the USA worker-- good for china and india, but bad for us. Outsourcing on the other hand, if its outsourced to more efficient american companies who can provide the service more cheaply than a bloated it dept, can be a good thing. it can force the lazy IT dept network administrator to stop surfin the web and blogs all day and start justifying his job.

by dilbert-tom

There are some functions that might be best outsourced, for example Payroll (which has sensitive data about workers, which is best processed offsite - and requires frequent 'generic' updates, such as tax changes, which can be more efficient for a specialized service company to provide).
Core business software, however, should be maintained by a staff that will specialize in the customization of a businesses software to provide competitive advantage - the key is to develop business knowledge in the technical staff, so that they can relate to the requirements most effectively.

by tony hopkinson

Outsourcing in itself isn't a bad thing. Payroll is a good example. What went wrong was people looked at outsourcing in terms of the manning reduction, and promptly realised that this could easily be applied with much more 'benefit' to more signifcant aspects of the business.

To my mind only a complete half wit would sell off the core skills in their business, it cost's a lot to buy them back and you can't operate without them.

Any set of established IT (or any other, even management) personnel is more valuable in the place that they are. The skill set is at most fifty percent of their value, in most cases in house knowledge is a much greater productivity gain.

by tonythetiger

Just this past friday, to be exact. One of our drives in our array died. Not a biggie (as long as we don't lose another before the first one is replaced).

So I call Dell tech support. Give them the service tag number - yes, still under warranty - please wait (not even any lame music!) then a guy with a thick accent (Arabic?, Indian?, Greek? not sure) answers and I really have a difficult time understanding him. The fourth time through I gathered that he wanted me to go into array manager and check the drive, then he wanted me to pull the drive, reboot, and reinsert the drive. "No, we may not reboot production servers in the middle of the day", I told him. He then asked when a good time to reboot would be. Not particularly wanting any overtime, I said "Look, this happenned once before, about 2 years ago and they just sent someone out to replace the drive. He pulled the drive out, removed the caddy and put it on a new drive, inserted it, and it took over from there by itself, so I'll save you some trouble: Ship me a drive and I'll change it myself." I then hear him typing, I guess he was checking out the history of this server, then he says OK, and verifies the address, etc.

I was expecting to get the drive today (because of the holiday) but in fact it arrived at 10:45 am on Friday! less than 3 hours after the call! (Not bad for being 40 miles from the nearest interstate :)) Less than five minutes after that (it took me two to find the box cutter), the array was rebuilding.

I was impressed by the speed of service, but was not pleased with how many times we had to go over things because I couldn't understand his particular version of English. I wonder how many others have this problem. I was persistent, because the server is critical, but I wonder what goes through a home user's mind when they come across this. Are they persistent as well? do they just say to heck with it and ask their local geek for help? Do they let the computer company know that they are dissatisfied? What?

by joetechsupport

Another monthly GartnerFlash on CD delivered to your desk for $x000 US per year with a nice naugahyde carrybag. When a CIO wants to 'Do Something', they pay Gartner to write a study saying it's a good idea. If it blows up, it's not the CIO's fault. Gartner also write studies telling CIOs to do what other CIOs are already doing, which they could find out for themselves if they read the CIO magazines on their desks.

I've seen Gartner play both sides of the fence on outsourcing and "server consolidation," if anyone remembers that. Combine more of your functions / applications on fewer servers to lower administration costs (lay off staff). Of course it didn't work for $h1t, as we told them, having exchange, printing and files on the same box so the company and Gartner changed their "minds".

by dafe2

We just went through the same thing..........for the same reason(s)............with the same results!

by akalinowski

I wonder what MBA moron thought that one up...

Anyone who has to deal w/ servers knows two things are key, avoid single point of failures and have redundancy

Consolidating onto fewer servers goes against good practice!

As far as outsourcing goes....I do see that being possible, but there are many places where specialized software is needed, and some it-in-a-box company will most likely not cut it

by joetechsupport

Strategic Management stays clear and high above the lower abyssal plains of technical rationale.

Goto Gartner mailing address, find fat-man or woman smoking cee-gar fumbling with indecipherable wireless toy.

That actually is why they decided not to outsource the helpdesk and tech support, that is the honest truth. The Executive Secretaries would not accept a lowered level of service for them and the Executives. The company could and did care less about the 30 branches, 1500 users and millions of customers they represented.

As I said, but in a different way, everytime "we" wanted to do something big, expensive, controversial or risky, it would have a Gartner Stamp of Approval. For a Gartner Price, of course. We were Gartner Subscribers.

The concept of consulting with outside sources is not a bad one, but these big firms like Gartner, the "new" Anderson, etc, are remarkably shallow- I've read Garters' work- the "employee" and "management" versions. Their evidence is hearsay and they don't even give references: "Other firms do this" Why? What are the specifics? How is it or not applicable to our case? They don't offer anything new except for acronyms and jargon.

The conclusions & forecasting well, I leave that to you.

Using consultants of that low calibre without consulting your own shows that you don't believe that your own staff know their field and have vision.

If a CIO/VP/manager believes that, a consulting report about a new system is not the only issue at hand.

Re Y2K: It was done well but had nothing to do with Gartner IMO. The industry realized the date codes had the potential for real problems. Tests proved this. The industry acted. Success resulted. Now people say it was hype because nothing blew up because everything was fixed?

The lesson learnt from Y2K in this "theory", is next time you see a problem on the horizon, put your head in the sand. The problem will go away. Idiots.

by garion11

Outsourcing doesn't necessarily mean a job loss (unless its going to India or China). Outsourcing can just be contracting out to local IT companies and the in house IS department will act as consultants for the company. I don't think its as stable as working in house for a company but an IT Professional has a lot more options on what kind of jobs he/she wants to do.

by zen37

...And there is no way we can offer the kind of service an in-house team can offer.

I use to work for a big paper manufacturer as a member of the In-House team and i knew every single nook and screw of that network, you wanted something done, i could tell you in minutes whether it could, how, when, and how much.

Now, as a consultant, i have more than 6 networks to support, each with its own particularities, specialties and reasons for being. I cannot keep everything in mind. We are 3 specialist working on those networks, i cannot keep track of every request, done to every network and changes done to it. I need time to analyse, re-analyse and re-check everything even before they can ask for something.

If you infrastructure is stable, strong and never or rarely changes, then outsourcing is definatly something you should look at. But if your infrastructure is growing, changing or need to be extremly flexible, forget about outsourcing. It will only slow things down.

And since everyone wants everything done faster and faster these days...

by trlogin

A lot of the financial and pharma shops have two IT staffs -

One focused on the main systems and support - everything from keeping the mainframes running and backed up to the trading desktops. I know people who work for EDS and Perot Systems and love their jobs, they have access to all sorts of resources that are shared across all of their clients and they have *some* job security because they have a large number of clients in the metro area. In addition, a career path is not limited to that one engagement.

These shops have another, much smaller staff, responsible for the company critical apps. The people write, support, and improve the mission critical apps that are heart of a business. These guys are cleared to handle the kinds of sensitive data that companies do not feel comfortable outsourcing.

There are some issues but I see this as the way more businesses will go. So, I hate to admit it but I think Gartner may be right this time.

by montgomery gator

From what I have observed at my employer, outsourcing various software development projects resulted in products that had lower quality and missed deadline, sometimes by more than a year. We had a big multi-year project that was outsourced to an outside vendor (who will remain nameless), and they were a year behind schedule, so my company ended up taking the project back in-house to fix the mess they gave us.

The software system developed in-house, however, has been cheaper, better, and on time. Management here has learned the lesson the hard way. The only outsourcing projects that have worked well are a PeopleSoft implementation, because it was only 50% outsourced, with PeopleSoft consultants on site working with our people, and an equipment maintenance contract for our 500 or so sites away from the Home Office. The way I see it, outsourcing can work only if the vendor works closely with the client, and the vendor's people work on site with the client's people, instead of somewhere in Bangalore, Beijing, Bratislava, or Boston.

Gartner has been smoking some real bad crack, apparently. They do not see how the real world works outside of their ivory towers.

by coder_for_you

Well i have been workign with lot of medium size companies and for software consultants in past 2 years and what i ahve ever heard from them is

"Hi,
Amazing work. Customer service incredible. Work delivery very very good. I will recommend this company to anyone.
Hernando Correa"

"Excellent programmers!!! They were very understanding of changes and very flexible in working out the details of the project. I look forward to doing more work with these guys in the future!"

"The team was great to work with. To be honest, they were a breath of fresh air from some of the other coders I've worked with .
They communicated with me on a daily basis and spoke very good English. They understood my requirements. They also documented them so that there was no misunderstanding.
They were a little slow in delivering the product, but some of that was my fault as well as I had to go out of town several times during the project.
And they were also able to do a little piece of tricky coding that has saved us an immense amount of time.
I was very satisfied with the outcome and would highly recommend their work. In fact, I'll include them in my upcoming works."

and a lot more....

Well these clients of mine are from US, UK, Cyprus, Singapore and Malaysia.

Tehy ahve always rated us good for what we have done.

Teh only reason is we are prompt in our servcies, we know what we are doing and accept work only when we can do it for them on time.

Sometimes the programmers are nto able to estimate the projects or sometimes buyers are in such a hurry that u actually goof up things.

So before u actually give a project or take a project its always good to take into consideration the following things.

1. Have you earlier worked this team. If not , then if u like their profile then may be u can try giving them small projects which you think can eaisly be handled by them and is of about 6-7 days work at the max.

During the work if u like their approach u cna offload more.

This is the approach we work with and make us successful. Bcose if we r not satsified with buyers approach or if buyer buyer is nto satisfied with our appraoch we always have a place to discuss or nto to work further togetehr.

If we are comfirtable workign together then we do lot of projects together.

So i would say its the nature of the project, team and the appraoch which ahs been taken to do it, which matetrs most, not the place . u can always outsource work, pay less and be free and be assured u ll get good work. If u choose the right team.

May be try our servcies and u ll get the answer.

If u have any queries or commenst pls feel free to tell me . I ll be happy to answer them.

Pooja

by tony hopkinson

Selling the benefits of your company, because you are a good outsourcer and why you are I can live with. Using peer mail to spam me I can't. You shot yourself in the foot big time with that trick.

Hope you learn fromm your mistakes eh.

Oh and by the way, telling people what someone said about you ain't going to cut it. Give your customers a price reduction for successful recomendations is a lot better way of putting your 'excellence' where your mouth is.

by tony hopkinson

when you do have the capability to do them in house, is plain stupid. They are never going to be as good. You are either going to have to dot every i and cross every t before work starts and it will be out of date by the time you get it, or change control will crap all over your budget. Firms who do this sort of work survive on maintaining their relationship with you AFTER you've put your sphericals in their vice.

That goes for a lot of outsourcing efforts as well, couse it's cheaper, it's a loss leader. Once you've got rid of all your people and or lost the knowledge to do it yourself, it's ghostbusters time.

by montgomery gator

The experiences I described where I work confirm exactly what you wrote, and is the reason management at my employer brought that major project back in-house, and other major projects that might have been outsourced are now done in-house. It does not matter where the outsourcer is based, offshore or inshore does not make a difference, outsourcing can result in a lot of problems, unless the outsourcer puts its contractors on-site, and they work closely with the company employees.

by gralfus

Outsourcing makes submanagers look like they are saving money by reducing headcount. This makes them look good, even if the overall cost to the company is greater in downtime, costs and time for training contractors, and other soft costs that are difficult to quantify. Because they can show a lower cost on paper, they are given kudos, despite having introduced a host of problems that can't be blamed on their decision (because they don't show up on anybody's expense report).

by tonythetiger

The consumers (or taxpayers) end up eating the extra cost, either directly, by paying someone else, or indirectly, by the value of their time.

by tony hopkinson

It's Mr Magoo in slow motion.
We can see Magoo, we can see the cliff he's heading towards, unfortunately all he can see is the ledger with next period profit figures in it.

by tony hopkinson

was as real as it got. It was so real people started extrapolating mass chaos and social breakdown from it. I did a lot of work on Y2k, just simple stuff like a batch identifier that was YYL999 and dad to be changed throughout three interconnected systems to CCYYL999, had me running around like a blue arsed fly.

Anybody out their still using cdates ? See you in 2015.

by joetechsupport

I worked a special midnight shift onsite with 20 others to make sure everything still worked. I'd seen 'The End of Days' Swarzenegger movie at 7PM before going in. I felt the atmosphere surreal, but nothing happened- because our programmers had already transferred our business DB to Oracle 6 months ago & changed the date format then.

Our old hardware which wasn't vulnerable was replaced a year before anyway. Everything still worked as it was -users, customers, techs agreed.

They could have kept the old hardware and software, recoding the database but this just would have saved money.

If the airlines, governments, insurance agencies etc had not repaired the information on everyone's policy or account would they would at least have have invalid dates and what a mess.

Operating hardware, like a 486 in a PC, microwave or some other appliance it may just keep running but that isn't a good way to bet and certainly not a solution if that appliance is in an airliner or a thermonuclear device.

by tony hopkinson

To me it coinciding with the bursting of the dotdom bubble and the failure of 3G et al is the only thing that's put in in a poor light.
A heck of a lot of good work was done. Just updating a sadly neglected inventory of assets had a substantial benefit where I was at the time.

by coder_for_you

SPamming is something i always disagree with. If someone is interested then one will always come to u for ur servcies. Thats the basic point.

I tried to mention the feedbacks for the reason that all oursourcers are not same. And there r people who are good. You can trust them.

You r right Pricing is an important factor when it comes to getting projects but its not always.
It is sometimes people fall into the trap bcose of low pricing and later the dveeloper realises that actually the price was too low for him to do the work and then the problems start.

So instead of providing price which is dirt cheap and with no servcies is not what we would prefer. Instead a price which is optimum and comes with a good servcies and quality work is the sole theme for us.

Its like a WIN-WIN situation for all.

by tony hopkinson

you might consider me subscribing to peermail as accepting you can send me a message detailing your services. Loosely you could even say that my subscription is for the benefit of my peers, however I feel that you violated the spirit of the thing.
I've helped several members with problems, in response to a request for information. I don't peermail them though with the potential of help for finiancial remuneration though.
If you want to advertise on TR, buy some space. If you want to start a thread with the benefits of your approach to outsourcing, there's a start thread link. You could now even start a Blog with your next outsourcing project.
No one is going to object to any of these things and even if they end up with no return at least you can look yourself in teh eye while taking a shave.

by tony hopkinson

There's no real difference between outsourcing and getting in your own contractor. It's the benefits of their resource versus paying a middle man. Indeed all outsourcing is, is a new name for purchasing 3rd party services. The key to that has always been, is this a standard service where I can use the market to get a good deal, or is it enough of a one off that you don't need continuity in terms of the required skills.
How things like help desk, corporate softare enginering or large IT infrastructure support gets past these proviso's does not compute.

by jmgarvin

The hype was a little over done and helped make the REAL work look like it was done for nothing.

Sure those old 486s had to go and you had to update tons of code, but because my home PC is fine, you must have done nothing...right?

The media didn't help with the insanity either...look at the nuts that moved to Taos and stocked up on 10 years worth of food and water (and guns)...

by tony hopkinson

hype was the thing that got a lot of business managers fingers out.

Also we got the film Strange Days out of it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.