Government Technology
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by hopefulcoder
who is gonna use some crap like ODF...Doc rules...and with microsoft standardising its own format soon...it will be the survival of the fittest...The same govts will be under fire once jobs get scarce due to free code
Some of you may be old enough to remember the Paul Simon
song ?50 ways to leave your lover?. The chorus went something like this:
?You just slip out
the back, Jack
Make a new plan, Stan
You don?t need to be coy, Roy
Just get yourself free
Hop on the bus, Gus
You don?t need to discuss much
Just drop off the key, Lee
And get yourself free.?
Unfortunately in this day and age, leaving your lover just
might be easier than leaving your vendor, particularly if you have developed a
relationship over time and their product or products are intertwined throughout
your organization and infrastructure. This is something that vendors that are
trying to woo you often gloss over when they are offering you a competing
product at a bargain price. I had a vendor in my office just the other day, and
they were telling me just how easy it would be to transition from their competitor's
product to their own. It sounded so simple and elegant, and they assured me
that they would ?be there for me? to help me through the transition. Right. And
if I believe that, I should have ?all-day sucker? tattooed on my forehead.
The fact of the matter is that making a significant change
in a product that is in use in your organization can be more difficult to
extricate yourself from than a tar pit?particularly if it means a big loss of revenue
to a vendor. A perfect example is the state of Massachusetts' attempt to go with
an open document format. Clearly, Microsoft did not want that happening. But
this is certainly not limited to Microsoft. Any indication to a vendor that
they may be replaced can scale from verbal protests, to lawsuits to having your
service cut off. So, if you are considering such a shift, you'll need to do a
lot of careful planning.
The first place to start is with your contract (if you have
one) with the particular vendor you now want to replace. We often tend to gloss
over terms and conditions when signing on the dotted line, but those can come
back to haunt you when it?s time to say goodbye. So get out the magnifying
glass and make friends with your general counsel to get their opinion on any
gotchas that may be buried in the contract.
Second, do a thorough in-house analysis of the reach of the
particular product or products that you want to sunset. Don?t be myopic in your
evaluation by just looking at your department. You need to comb the entire
organization not once, but numerous times, to make sure that you know who could
be affected by the change.
Third, determine if the transition is going to be an all-at-once
transition or a phased transition. This can depend on a number of variables,
including the type of product or services being let go/introduced as well as
funding streams, organizational preparedness, the size of the undertaking, etc.
If it truly is going to be an all-at-once transition, you need to try and keep
things quiet to avoid pre-emptive strikes by your soon-to-be-spurned lover and
feel confident that you have the power to deal with any retaliation or
disruption that might arise from an unhappy provider. Here are a few tips:
Even with careful planning, this kind of change can be
challenging at the least, and nightmarish at the worst. However, your planning
efforts should pay dividends in the success of the project. Thorough planning should
mitigate the worst problems (and something always seems to crop up that is
problematic), while lack of planning can get you into hot water real fast.
How long will the process take? It depends on the scope and
how intertwined the product is in your organization's operations. Some things
can be done practically overnight and remain almost totally transparent to
users, while other times, it can take years to finally rid yourself of the last
vestiges of a vendor. The good news is that when you are done, you don?t have
to pay alimony?or maybe you do. How closely did you read your terms and
conditions?
by chaz chance#
Guilt Trip them!
The best way to dump a supplier is to make it their fault.
Working for a supplier of products with a minor IT element, and having been dumped by a customer, I have learned a thing or two in this area.
First, invent a list of things that the product was never meant to do, and accuse your supplier of selling you a defective product because it can't do them. Refer to meetings (preferably ones that you know were not minuted) where you recall telling the supplier that you needed these business critical functions and how they promised that you would get them.
Demand that the supplier provide you with a detailed plan of how they will get you the missing functions. At every meeting add another item to the list of "promised" functions.
Talk about a reduction of payments, proportional to the value of the missing functions. Give a percentage that is wildly out of proportion.
If your contract is valuable to the supplier (and why would you be worried about terminating it if it isn't) then they will start jumping through hoops to keep you on board. Remember, at this point it appears that they are in the wrong. Okay, they are beginning to see you as an unreasonable customer, but that generally makes them work that much harder to satisfy you. It also plants the seed in their mind that maybe they would be better off without you.
Now that you have them jumping through hoops, it is time to look at any data that they hold which you can't do without. Is there anything that is held in proprietry formats, or in their databases that you access remotely? Perhaps a specific way that a program operates that will make life easier if you know it? Talk to your new supplier, who will have a list of things that will make the transition much easier.
Demand that a copy of all data is kept on your systems, along with full documentation of formats and protocols etc. for "disaster recovery" purposes. Set a very tight schedule for when this is to happen so as to avoid having to sign non-disclosure agreements.
If you already signed a non-disclosure agreement, get them to sign a waver so that you can have the information "independently analysed". Perhaps this is because "a customer" of yours is making demands. Site some obscure piece of legislation that you have to obey.
Bombard them with emails demanding progress reports, but respond to as few of their emails as you can. Avoid answering most of their telephone calls, and when you do talk to them, start by asking them why they haven't delivered some item that you have never discussed before. This will put them on the defensive before they get to tell you their message. Then take everything they say out of context, interpreting it in as negative a manner as possible. If there is anything they are resisting giving you, reply that it shows how inadequate they are that they are incapable of doing the simplest thing.
If they actually succeed in providing some of the things on your list, get upset because now you have adjusted your systems to deal with the lack, and their changes have made everything worse.
Finally, when your new supplier is all set up and ready to go, tell the old one how disappointed you are with them, and cut off all further communication. If neccessary, talk about the financial and legal ramifications of them forcing you to terminate the relationship.
They will almost be glad to see you go.
Job's a good 'un.
Now that I re-read this, it does remind me of an ex-lover...
?Hablas espa?ol?
Raise your
hand if your web site is multi-lingual.
My guess is you probably do not have your hand raised right now. In fact, you are probably thinking that it
is hard enough providing new services and maintaining existing English language
web sites with your staff and budget, let alone have to maintain a foreign
language version.
Yet if you
look at population trends across the US you will find an ever increasing
non-English speaking or English as a second language population than ever before. Now I do not want to get into a debate over
whether or not immigrants should be forced to learn English or whether creating
alternative language web sites is ?catering? to a particular population, but
the fact of the matter is that many of our tax paying citizens cannot take
advantage of our web services because they cannot read English. (For the record, I unfortunately do not
speak Spanish as my parents chose to stress English in the household as opposed
to Spanish or German which was native to them ? just in case someone thinks I
am on a bully pulpit here).
For those
organizations that have deemed it a good idea to do web site translation, many
have run into the same problems:
1.
Translation services are expensive.
Particularly if you are going to keep your foreign language web site as
current as your English language web site.
2. Translation software is not
quite there yet and a great deal of information can get ?lost in translation?
or garbled by software translation tools that depending on them solely for
translation is an invitation for embarrassment.
3. There is often more
than one predominant foreign language in an area that justifies translation so
which do you choose? (Go back to the expensive part if you are asking why you
have to choose).
4. Maintaining multiple websites is time
consuming and you are short staffed as it is.
5. Your web staff is not
multilingual either.
So what is
the answer here? How can we solve the
problem of having our website magically become the tower of Babel or the
universal translator ? open to all who may come to read or interact with
it? I wish I could tell you I had the
answer. But I don?t have one. However I do have some suggestions on how we
can move in the right direction.
Here goes:
First, we need to decouple web design from
content creation. In far too many organizations,
these two concepts are synonymous. Our
web sites need to be designed in such a manner that content in any language can
be plugged in as an object and the site will maintain its look and feel.
Secondly,
we can say the same for our web applications.
Areas in these applications which contain text should be variables that
can be filled with the appropriate language text without breaking the
application.
Thirdly,
when making the decision to make your web site multi-lingual, it is not an all
or none proposition. Take those areas
that are most informative/valuable and start with those when determining cost
to do the work.
Fourth, I
think we are failing to take advantage of our high schools, community colleges
and universities in regards to bilingual students who could, as part of
internships or coursework, provide translation services for us.
Fifth, I
think there is money going untapped to assist with foreign language translation
? we just lack the resources to sit down and go looking for it.
Lastly, it
has to be a priority of senior management for this to happen, or the foreign
language constituency needs to be vocal enough to make it an issue for them ?
or it won?t get done.
If this is
not an issue for you now, it may very well become so in the near future. Doing some of the things above (such as
decoupling content from design) makes for a better and more maintainable web
site in the present and gets us better prepared to go multi-lingual. If you are having success (or not) in any of
these areas, I would like to hear about it as I have many eager colleagues that
might be able to benefit from your experiences. If you have discovered the magic translation bullet, please let
me know!
Okay. If I'm the guvamint, I have a social responsibility to genuinely consider how to communicate with my non-English speaking citizenry. If I'm private (profit or non), I'm going to plug this increase to my base, recurring operating costs and try to figure the hard or soft return on this 'investment'. '..it has to be a priority of senior management for this to happen, or the foreign language constituency needs to be vocal enough to make it an issue for them.." bingo! I think this won't happen until enough highly visible individuals or entities take the leap and 'raise the bar' so to speak for others to rise to. Oh yes, if someone can figure out how to make this a win-win (e.g., think global constituents and customers who have money to spend or influence to wield like multi-national market enterprises do, etc.)
Bubba
by realtime_msc
Absolutely Positively!
Aside from the obvious that some companies might get foreign sales, many people don't realize how many business exec's are here from a foreign country doing business. Having a website in a second language definately OPENS the door to these business decision makers EVEN if they do speak a little or enough english.
Most people feel more comfortable speaking their native tounge and finding a website that is 'speaking' to them might just give you the edge over the competition by having them contact you & to get your foot in their door.
My 2cents ;)
by tdoug77
by tdoug77
by snoopdoug
by r_uscp
Once upon a time ago in the Pen Age, if one wanted to discourage unmeaningful content, he simply asked the potential author to type it. That ensured that the information was of such import that it warranted the motivation and energy to craft a document. Now I am not too keen about turning back the clock on some of our newest technologies, rather the answer seems to me to be to impose certain communication standards. Interaction with your managers and peers should establish these if not already gleaned from trial and error. I particularly liked the response where the person implemented the fluff solution, but failed to use it.
Quite frequently, the cc: list is a self-deluding ego booster. When we know who the authors are, quickly trigger the delete key. Eventually, they'll get the message. In the meantime and in preparation for the next communication, sugget a smoke signal.
I have been in several disaster
planning sessions recently in which it has been stressed that you need to
define who your ?key personnel? are in the event of an emergency. I began to think about how organizations have
thinned themselves down over the recent years in the name of ?doing more with
less? or ?being lean and mean? that you have to wonder who IS NOT key
personnel?
The fact of the matter is, we have
trimmed most of the human redundancy out of our organizations. Don?t think so? How many times have you been told that something can?t be done
because a particular individual is sick or on vacation? If a job function cannot be performed
because someone is gone, then perhaps we have trimmed too far.
Now before the words ?cross training?
spill out of your mouth, keep in mind that many (should I say most?) of us have
enough of our OWN work to do without having to take on someone else?s work as
well in the event that they are out?
Now I am not against being a team player, and certainly cross training
is an important concept in the work place, yet I often think it is overused as
an excuse to not add additional personnel.
This wave of staff thinning in
order to stay competitive can and will show itself to be extremely self
defeating during an epidemic or pandemic.
Should the worst case predictions come true, many of our ?key? personnel
won?t be around to depend on and there are few backups to be found. Compound this with our ?just in time?
economy and you can imagine the dire consequences.
This is particularly true in the IT
area where staff has been thinned to the point that preventive maintenance is
wishful thinking and proactive is a thing of the past. Reactive is the operative word because there
are not enough people to go around to do all that needs to be done. Something has to give and that tends to be
preventive maintenance and customer service.
This is a particular problem for
most organizations who see ?technology? and IT as their way of surviving in
disaster/pandemic situations. Data
centers work in ?lights out? mode for only so long before something needs human
attention. Where will the humans be to
remedy the situation? The same goes for
outsourcing. If a pandemic truly hits
the world, do you think any SLAs with a company in another country are going to
be worth the paper it is written on?
My point to all of this is that
increased staffing (and funding) makes us better prepared to withstand
adversity just as a few pounds of extra fat can mean the difference between
life and death for a person that is ill.
Given that pandemic flu planning is becoming more and more prevalent, I
think this is a perfect opportunity to make the case that additional staff and
funding are not only appropriate but necessary to be truly prepared for such a
disaster.
Lastly, please understand that
there is a difference between adequately staffed and a bureaucracy. I?m not championing for the times where
organizations had so many people that they ?created? layers of work for people
to do to justify their employment. I
just believe there is a happy medium between fat and thin and most of us are
way too far on the lean side. I also
believe that this leanness has reached the point where it is bad for business
and has left us vulnerable. We live in
a society that is far more dependent on others than the last society that had
to deal with an epidemic/pandemic. Despite
our advances in medicine and technology, I believe we are more fragile as
organizations and societies. I think it
is well past time that we do some fattening up. Now if we could only get those that control the purse strings to
listen.
by chipmicro
Hear, hear! This situation will only get worse, as set forth in the article. I do wonder, though, if there is another factor at work that complements the thinning. We have gradually pared-down the 'response time' (whatever the definition of that is within individual organizations) for functions of both human and computer systems to the point where research and/or double-checking cannot be done before performing an action. To further drive this, a lot of IT leadership seems to be focused on going ahead and saying, "Yes," without first considering whether it is wise to do so. In my opinion, this is how data breaches and other problems of the sort happen, and it is only getting worse. How many organizations have driven things like access to sensitive data so hard that human, "Something seems fishy here," intervention can't take place for the benefit of access permissions within the hour? What about our systems that drive response time so hard that encryption of data is seen as an unnecessary time demand, so native data is used so the CEO doesn't have to wait two minutes for their report?
In IT, we need to be able to say, "No," sometimes to requests for additional speed until the technologies can be shaken-down and hardened, and that permission needs to be used to provide robustness, rather than rapidity. 'Can' should never be more important that 'should', and the officers of organizations need to understand that what they read in glossy ads may or may not apply to their business processes, or might add an element of uncertainty to the security or protection of data. Ordering IT to increase the pace and remove layers of complexity between users and data, regardless of its effect, may indeed make a CEO or CIO popular with the user community - but it may also get their picture in articles and disaster recovery post-mortems in the 'unfortunate lessons learned that should have been learned a long time ago' section.
This is the IT-orientation of the time honored adage of the craftsman to measure twice and cut once.
I just finished reading an article in INFOWORLD that more
and more technology professionals are headed back to school to obtain their MBAs
in order to advance/enhance their careers by better understanding business. In
some circles, the three letters M, B, A are a requirement for a C-level
position, and while I will never say that going back to school is a bad idea (I
received my MBA when Bon Jovi?s ?Livin? On a Prayer? was topping the charts), there
are ways to learn your ?business? without ever leaving your company?s front
door. In fact, some of these methods might be more effective than getting your
degree--depending on whether you wish to stay with your organization for the
long haul.
The first method is by volunteering to document, in detail,
a department?s business processes. Hey,
you were going to do extra work by going to school anyway, right? So
putting in some extra time in the office for a project like this can be
considered your ?homework.? I have never had a department turn down the offer
for someone to do business process documentation for them, but if you encounter
resistance, explain that it is to better understand their business so that you
can help them make better IT decisions.
You need to do this in chunks and set the expectation that
it is going to take awhile (I assume you are undertaking this task alone, as
professional development), and you should start with the top-level management
of the department you choose. Personally, I would choose the department that is
at the core of your organization?s reason for existence and work out from
there.
Get a broad overview from senior management of what they do
and why, and of course, get their permission to interview the rest of their
staff in-depth, ending up at the lowest level in that department. Build your
picture of what they do, and why, from the bottom up, until you have worked
your way back up to senior management.
If done right, not only will you provide a valuable service
to them, you will begin to meet more people in the organization (thus
increasing your visibility), learn their language, and begin to understand how
and why things get done the way they do in your organization. You will also
learn the politics of your organization, which in some ways is your most
important lesson of all. For all of what they can teach you at Carnegie Mellon
or Walden University, politics is mostly learned through experience.
Do this well (while still performing your regular job
duties) and you might be surprised at the knowledge you attain and where that
might take you. After all, opportunity is often three-quarters of the effort of
obtaining new responsibilities and positions.
The article also mentioned five skills for the global
economy that are important:
All of these skills can be garnered through a variety of
methods, besides obtaining your MBA. In fact, obtaining your MBA probably won?t
provide more than 2 or 3 of them. I do think all are important, but also would
like to put my own spin on the last one. I think it is extremely important for
anyone seeking to enhance their career to work on their own ENGLISH language
and COMMUNICATIONS skills. In fact, besides independent thinking in the list
above, I think it is the single most important skill to develop if you seek an
effective career in management. I have written about this before in Soft Skills in a Hard World.
Lastly, I mentioned multiple methods of career improvement
without leaving the comfort of your office (well maybe just for a short time). These
include professional certifications such as in project management, ITIL, ISO, COBIT,
or Certified Public Manager Programs; attending professional development
academies, joining professional organizations--just to name a few.
Our biggest challenge to professional growth and career
advancement/enhancement is usually ourselves and our limited time. Learning new
skills is work and takes commitment. Making that commitment to do the work, whether
you choose formal or informal education, is key. Nothing and no one can stop
you from bettering yourself and advancing your career except YOU. This is truly
a situation where ?if there is a will there is a way.? Anything else is just
excuses and/or whining. Tough choices and sacrifices usually accompany the
decision, but the extra work does pay off in the long run -- that I am sure of.
My blog this week is a bit of a rant and a little bipolar, based on some recent procurement discussions I have had. The first part of my rant revolves around the question "who else is using it?" in relation to a product. The answer I want to scream is: "Who cares!"
Now I know that there is some value in knowing who is using a product, but I think that this dimension is often taken a bit too far. My organization is not NASA, UPS, Fed Ex, IBM, or Lockheed Martin. There is nothing about my organization that resembles in any fashion, those organizations. So does it really matter to me that they are using a certain product? NO! They certainly have 10 to 100 times the staff that I have to dedicate to ANY product, so success in their organization with a product cannot be extrapolated to mean success in my organization. Conversely, the particular circumstance behind a failed implementation probably has nothing in common with my organization either.
You may be saying, ah, but you should be looking at how the product works in organizations similar to your own. While I will admit that this is a better comparison, unless I know the exact details of another organization's implementation, the mere fact that it is using a product is about as meaningful to me as knowing what temperature they keep the inside of their buildings. All of this is to say that unless you are finding out who is using the product so you can call them and get the particulars, the comparison is almost meaningless. So, the next vendor that cites 10 Fortune 500 companies that are using a product to me is going to get an earful.
Also, regarding knowing who is using a product to determine the vendor?s viability ? is that really a good measure of its value or one that just makes us feel good? Some research needs to go into this. We all know of vendors who have had lots of clients that have gone belly up; and I know I am not the only one who has seen the potential in the product of a smaller company and adopted it in spite of its not having a large customer base and been successful. So I wonder about the true viability of this measure.
Now, still related to procurement and evaluation, is the issue of a product's being "feature rich." To this day, I use the Microsoft Office Suite as the perfect example of a product which is so feature-rich that its richness takes away from its usability. I contend that the majority of users who have MS Office installed barely use five percent of the product?s functionality. But, by golly, the features sure need to be there just in case somebody might need them. Thus we get products that are big and bloated, and expensive, because features are what companies use to compete with one another. Whose fault is that? Probably ours, because when we go through the evaluation process, we often reward feature-richness with higher scores, whether or not the feature is practical in our own environment.
This argument also begs the question, "Are feature-richness and ease-of-use two concepts that are diametrically opposed?" My answer to that is no, but feature richness can and often does lead down the road to complexity, which in turn erodes ease of use. Using a broad, broad brush, let me paint the typical user as someone who doesn?t want to read instructions, does not have time or inclination to attend training, and often blames IT, the computer, and the software for their inability to do something. This translates to "the product and anyone associated with it sucks because I can?t make it do what I want it to do."
This mentality, while it may be a gross generalization, calls for a customer requirement of ease-of-use and intuitiveness that most manufacturers do not cater to. They don't, because the people who are often doing the product evaluations DO know how to use the products to a much greater extent than the typical user, and they look at feature-richness as a way to separate them. Don?t look so shamefaced; I have been guilty of it too.
So what is the answer here? For product development, it means that when determining the detailed requirement specifications for a product, one not only needs to look at what has to be accomplished, but how often the action/task is performed. Those tasks/actions that get performed the most, better be the ones that are the most intuitive and well thought out.
For product evaluation, while it is good to keep in mind the features we would like to see our user population use, it is best to be realistic and put the most weight on the features they are most likely to use. It would also not hurt to get their opinion or include them as part of the evaluation team.
Lastly, don?t be afraid of the little guy, or open source, or the like. If a product is promising and you can give it a good shake out and feel strongly that you can make it work, it?s ok to be the Lone Ranger. Tonto will come along soon enough.
Some company came up with the slogan.." (.....the name of their computer).. the computer people use". This company has a significant, but small proportion of the market. Their users tend to be fiercely loyal to the product. But, they are still only a niche of the overall personal computer market. An interesting question is, did this company intentionally decide to settle for a smaller proportion of the market and maintain the interface to which their users are so loyal and are willing to pay a premium for? And, if so, does it mean that in order to achieve that level of "user-friendliness" in technology that the cost of development and maintenance will always push the end price for user to a level not affordable by the masses?
"'Nnnnn", the computer people use."
Bubba
Consider also that "marquee" customers sometimes use or endorse a product after the vendor makes them an offer they can't refuse....high-end support, implementation handholding, bargain pricing, feature input, all the above, etc. The vendor can't make these offers to no-names and stay in business.
by twohills
To get the full picture on ITIL, I like this site for the balancing view www.itilskeptic.org Not everyone will agree with such a skeptical view but it is nice to hear boths sides of any story :-)
Performance Evaluations/Appraisals: Do you love them, hate
them, need them, want them? To be honest with you, I?m a bit schizophrenic
about them, because all of the above apply to me.
I love them when they are meaningful, well prepared, well
thought out, and presented in a fashion that encourages true dialogue regarding
personal and career growth.
I hate them when they are meaningless, thoughtlessly put
together, based on a poor instrument, and presented in a mechanical fashion, as
if read by a machine.
I need them because they are (or should be ) the vehicle
that drives my employees' growth in my organization and set down clearly in
writing what my expectations are for them.
I want them because ? hmm let me rephrase that--I want a
well-prepared one because feedback is important to all of us.
So you see, (and I am sure I am not alone), I have a ton of
mixed emotions regarding the subject. A performance evaluation can be a
horrendous experience (regardless of the rating) if done poorly or with
disregard, or it can be a completely empowering situation for both the
supervisor and the employee, if done correctly. So given this setup, let?s talk
about the primary issues one at a time, starting with:
The instrument: Performance
evaluations are usually form-based with specific instructions on how the evaluation
is supposed to be done. It is usually created by the HR department, and
generally, they allow very little leeway on modifying it. This being the case,
the instrument can be a tremendous asset in guiding you through the process or
it can be such a hindrance to the process that it acts as a barrier to creating
something that is meaningful for your employees. Some instruments are highly
structured while others are just sets of guidelines for the supervisor/appraiser
to follow. In this case, I like my instruments medium-rare, with just the right
amount of structure while giving me some flexibility to tailor things to fit
the job description of the person I am evaluating. To me, the ideal instrument
blends just the right amount of measurability with some room for
judgment/subjectivity. Remember the ?plays nice with others? category from your
old report card? I think that kind of subjectivity needs to be included. Others
may disagree.
Preparation: Performance
evaluations should not be a surprise nor should anything on them be news to the
employee. The employee should have a hand in what they will be measured on and
it should not change without their knowledge. And as far as actually sitting
down to prepare it, it is not a race, no matter how many you have to prepare. Doing
one haphazardly will result in a poorly-prepared appraisal and a bad session. My
favorite technique is to have employees prepare their own, and then you can sit
down with them and do a comparison. While this is NOT a negotiation session, the
opportunity to explain your reasoning results in a learning process for both
parties, and scores can be adjusted per your prerogative should you deem to do
so. My experience has been that most employees are harder on themselves than I
am, so there is always room for good discussion.
Presentation: One
hour minimum ? period. You can?t have a healthy dialogue that is meaningful in
less time without feeling rushed (for both parties). Additionally, it?s neither
a funeral nor a carnival, no matter how you rated your subordinate. I have seen
supervisors who looked like death warmed over as they called in an employee who
they were going to give a less than stellar appraisal to and then turn around
and look like they won a million bucks when calling in their next employee who
happened to be a star. Keep an even demeanor and be casual, but correct: you
don?t want to make a joke out of the situation--just enough joviality to take
the edge off a potentially stressful situation. Also, don?t be a machine gun
and rattle through the appraisal at a high pace just to get it over with. MEANINGFUL is what you are striving for.
Lastly is privacy. No one wants their strengths and weaknesses discussed where
others can hear. If you are cube-bound, go find a conference room to reserve
for the day. If you are lucky enough to live in a fair-weather state, and there
is a fountain or park nearby that can offer you some privacy and a pleasant
setting at the same time--use it! Even if you are not cube-bound, finding
somewhere other than your office removes the stigma of being called to the
?boss's? office, if your staff do not already frequent there.
And, I almost forgot: Earlier, I said that the appraisal
should not be a surprise because the subordinate helped create it. But, it
should also not be a surprise because you are already communicating how an
employee is doing on a regular basis. If performance-appraisal day is the only
day of the year that your employees are getting feedback from you, you are
doing something wrong. Additionally, let?s hope your behavior on a daily basis
is consistent with your appraisal. If you are telling Jim ?great job!? everyday
and then reaming him out during the appraisal, you have got your wires crossed
somewhere and you had better re-evaluate your own performance.
Now that you have some guidelines, feel free to carry on your
love-hate relationship with performance appraisals--know I will.
It looks like such a benign statement: Please identify the essential personnel in your
organization/department/unit. This is usually one of the first tasks in any
continuity of operations plan (COOP). However, getting people to agree on who
is essential (as well as your essential functions) is anything but benign. The
first pass at something like this has nearly everyone in the organization being
listed as essential. After all, if they were not essential, why are they
employed?
Needless to say, this can be a daunting task. However, it
can and does get even more difficult when your COOP must be useful not for just
a few days or weeks, but several months at a time. This is exactly what you
have to plan for when adjusting your COOP for a pandemic flu event.
With such a long period to account for, the issue of identifying
your organization?s essential functions and personnel becomes magnified--particularly
so, in government. Why? Many governmental organizations exist to manage
processes that may be suspended during times of crisis.
Let?s take education as an example. There are some who argue
that if a pandemic flu event occurs, then social distancing becomes a top
priority; thus, any functions that require people to gather should be suspended.
This leads some to say that in a pandemic flu event, all schools will be
closed. If that is the case, who becomes essential personnel? Teachers?
Probably not. Custodians? Doubtful. Principals? Possibly. Superintendents?
Likely. Administrative staff? Some.
As you can see, this list is probably quite different than
the list in a school system?s typical COOP.
The same can be applied to a body/organization which
regulates an activity that a governor or mayor may deem non-essential during a
flu event. After all, if the majority of the population is staying at home, are
parking attendants essential personnel?
This can be a hard pill to swallow for many, as it might
make it seem that their job or organization is not important. Furthermore, this
may prevent them from creating a realistic long term COOP, and that is exactly
what we do not want to happen.
Therefore, as one begins this type of planning, it is
important to stress that the planning is being done for an extreme
circumstance, not normal life. Few will argue that education of our youth
is not important, but for a limited amount of time and for the sake of health
and safety, it may be that education is considered ?non ? essential.?
Getting your organization in this frame of mind when doing
COOP for an extended period is extremely important. The consequences of not
doing so end up being a COOP that is not based on the ?reality? of that kind of
situation, and/or the squandering of precious resources that in actuality will
never be used. A few days ago, California
proposed a 400-million-dollar investment in pandemic flu and disaster
preparedness--by far the largest amount any state in the U.S. has devoted to
the cause, health experts have said.
How much of that money will be used to purchase remote
access capabilities for personnel who will never need it? See my point? On the
other hand, some organizations will see this as a one-time source of funding
and will try to make a strong case in order to acquire systems/capabilities they
could never afford before, thus eating away at dollars better spent elsewhere. Sad
but true.
The moral of this story is that when doing a COOP for a
pandemic flu or similar event, the organization as a whole needs to take a real
hard look at itself in the mirror and realize that what they see may not be to
their liking in regards to importance in a time of crisis. So as many of you
begin this planning process, don?t be afraid to ask the $100,000 question: Is
there anything we do that is so important that it can?t be suspended for a three
or four month period of time without causing severe consequences to the
population we serve? The answers to that question will lead you to your essential
functions. The essential personnel will fall out from there. Good Luck!
by bork blatt
Reminds me of a Dilbert cartoon (too old for me to link directly to the site):
The pointy-haired boss announces over the intercom that there is a storm warning, and all non-essential personnel may go home.
In the next panel he is looking out of the window into the parking lot with binoculars, and says to himself "This will be the easiest round of layoffs ever!"
Funny stuff - but this is probably what is going through people's minds when this type of exercise comes up.
by b_sen
This debate is also well valid for situations where staff turnover is high. My present company is seeing a vast migration to "greener pastures" due to stagnant pay and internal politics. Every fortnight or so, management has to re-draw the reporting structure, and revise project schedules.
A COOP in this instance would not only have to be constatly updated, but at some point in time once all the domain-rich experienced staff leave, invalid. Unless we have freshers being designated COOP's after a few weeks of training, it can happen :-)
Well.. in reality almost no one individual is (or should be) absolutely essential to any organization. Otherwise, that organization is operating on very thin ice. Additionally, most real emergency operation situations don't happen at convenient times or when the "essential" personnel are all on site. To throw another (possible semantical) wrench into the issue, "essential" really has to be situational. In the school enterprise, the most important role of that organization in a hurricane may be to provide safe shelter to the community. Bring on the maintenance crew and possible even the food service staff. If the school is a private institution, especially a college or university, in an extended facility closure (bird flu?) the IT staff and on-line instructors may become critical in keeping some revenue generating operations going or the "business" may collapse.
So.. maybe question should be, with a twist, what is "essential" to do in what situation, and, crosstrain, crosstrain, crosstrain.
Bubba
by mandrake64
I work in the steel industry and am part of a small automation support team.
If I were looking at a COOP I would be assigning priority to personnel based on the necessity of their involvement in maintaining the status quo of a system. Forget development, forget capital project support, just concentrate on day to day operations.
Start with making a list of how long a system could be left running without intervention for various components, say database, backups, log file clearing, filesystem free space, etc...
Some apps could fall over within a day, some after a week and some months down the track. So you then decide how much of the maintenance of a system is really essential. You'd be surprised how automated you can make this process with a little planning and how much seemingly essential maintenance can be dropped.
Also automate the system notificaitons as much as possible. Make the problems come to you rather than forcing you to look for them.
We've run our systems with only half the team available for support and still survived. Try it sometime.
by mandrake64
I work in the steel industry and am part of a small automation support team.
If I were looking at a COOP I would be assigning priority to personnel based on the necessity of their involvement in maintaining the status quo of a system. Forget development, forget capital project support, just concentrate on day to day operations.
Start with making a list of how long a system could be left running without intervention for various components, say database, backups, log file clearing, filesystem free space, etc...
Some apps could fall over within a day, some after a week and some months down the track. So you then decide how much of the maintenance of a system is really essential. You'd be surprised how automated you can make this process with a little planning and how much seemingly essential maintenance can be dropped.
Also automate the system notifications as much as possible. Make the problems come to you rather than forcing you to look for them.
We've run our systems with only half the team available for support and still survived. Try it sometime.
by wrlang
No disaster recovery/business continuity person with any experience would ask this question.
It implies that businesses hire nonessential people. While individual opinion may say that some people are nonessential, in a well managed organization everyone is essential over the annual business process.
The question to ask is WHEN do people?s business functions become essential, or when do they start to take priority.
WHEN does development become essential to maintain the business and satisfy customer needs?
WHEN do Sales, AP, or AR affect cash flow in such a way that it negatively impacts the business?
WHEN does a business incur regulatory penalties for the lack of a business function and will those penalties be less than the cost of mitigating them?
Properly framed questions need no explanation, they stand on their own.
These questions take the guess work out of everything, they need no change of mindset on behalf of business managers, they eliminate the mistaken idea that some people are nonessential, and they allow you to create an efficient recovery or COOP plan.
by glemby
Of course you will get dissent if you approach the issue form the 'who' point of view. The real issue, and the point of entry for a sensible BCP/COOP is to look at your most important business functions and the activities that are required to keep them running. When you analyse the factors that put those activities and functions at risk, you will see that there are some 'single person dependencies'. These are where the risks lie and are the issues that need to be addressed. Train others, identify outside resources who could stand in if required, do everything you can (or can afford to!) to ensure you are covered.
This way, you can avoid the emotional 'essential person' tag that just gets people worried and clouds any assessment they may be required to make.
When you are looking for an operating system to run your
mission critical systems on, you look for an OS that is stable, manageable,
secure, scalable, and can perform when called upon. That being the case, there
is little mystery as to why Linux has made inroads into the server rooms of
many organizations.
The desktop however is an entirely different matter
altogether. People define a good desktop OS as one that is attractive, easy to
use, and runs their favorite applications. This has been where Linux has
struggled. Even with Gnome and KDE and the various other flavors of GUI that
have been placed on top of Linux, it has had to work hard to get to the point
where it was comparable to a Windows XP desktop. However, the work was
beginning to pay off and companies like Red Hat and Novell were driving things
forward as Microsoft made incremental changes to its flagship OS since Windows
2000. Most of these changes were not ground-breaking, and if the desktop OS
space were a horse race, you could feel Linux beginning to close on the
frontrunner OS in terms of features and functionality.
But as Microsoft has watched Linux creep into the server
room (mostly supplanting UNIX rather than Windows) someone at MS must have
decided that they were not going to give an inch in the desktop space without a
fight. Thus, we have the impending release of Windows Vista.
From a sneak peak demonstration and hands-on with Microsoft
Vista last week, all I have to say is that if MS comes through and all the
functions and features that were shown and described to me turn out to be
reliable--Microsoft has raised the bar in desktop computing. The session I had
with Vista was the first time in a very long time that I have left an MS OS
demo with the feeling that I want that OS running on my
desktop.
I am a skeptic though, and the proof will be in the pudding
when it is released, but if it operates reliably in real-world environments,
then MS will have set a new standard for desktop computing.
If you have read my columns long enough, you know then that
this pains me to a certain degree as I have always felt that competition is a
good thing, and I have been a Linux advocate for quite some time. But the Linux
community is going to have to its work cut out for it even more after Vista
debuts.
So what is so great about Vista? The look and feel of the OS;
its new security model; additional group policy objects; new ability to deploy
a single OS image over a variety of hardware; the ability to take advantage of
existing hardware in new ways; and many other features set this OS apart. It is
not your old XP with a new face. Because I saw a build that has not been
released to the public yet, I can?t go into many specifics, but suffice it to
say that it is definitely an improvement over XP and 2000.
So is there anything that troubles me about the new OS? Of
course! The new scripting system has me worried. While it may prove to be a
very powerful tool, I am still gun shy about malicious scripts that may get
unleashed on my OS. While MS states that this is the most secure Windows ever
and it has been built with security in mind, history tells me to be cautious
here. Again, any conclusions can?t be drawn until the OS is released and
adopted by the masses to find out its true strengths and weaknesses. I hope
this won?t be a weakness, but it is the first place I might expect to see
problems.
The other thing that bothers me a little is not technical in
nature at all, but it?s about innovation. The new SideBar and Gadgets and
search functionality of Vista (at least to me) scream Google Desktop. Yes it is
a little slicker than Google Desktop, but clearly it seems to be inspired by
it. This always leads me back to the whole argument about taking third-party
products and implementing them in the OS. Wasn?t there a lawsuit about that?
Something about antitrust? Silly me, I thought that it might have meant
something.
Despite all that, I believe Microsoft has a winner on its
hands with Vista, and unlike XP, where organizations had to be convinced that
the upgrade from Windows 2000 was worth the trouble, I see organizations moving
to Vista fairly quickly.
So for those predicting that this was to be the year where
Linux makes some inroads at the corporate desktop level, I say the opportunity has
been missed and the bar has been raised. In my opinion, MS is making a
statement with Vista that it owns the desktop and plans to keep it that way for
quite some time. Only time will tell if Vista is all that it is cracked up to
be, but if it comes close, it will find a home on my machines.
by jaqui
by seckel109
Right.
And if you believe that I have a bridge in lower New York State I'll let you have cheap.
by thestorys
by ratcatzdogz
I downloaded that vista ISO and loaded it on my test system, and it is crap! the GUI is a copy of linux and mac os it's so blouted it dam near fills a 40 gig drive it needs a high end video card and a gig of ram to run with any speed. Can you realy see compays realey putting out that kind of MONEY to upgrade all there deaktops to vista when 2000 has all the featuers that they need to do there jobs with out a load of garbage to get in the way and at no extra and unessary cost, this is insane! industry will not upgrade just for the the hell-of-it you must give them a cost efective resone, if not they will stay with win 2000, because it dose all they need to do
ps I tried to run HALO on the vista ISO and it would not load, It did not reconise it as windows
by jgmsys9
"The other thing that bothers me a little is not technical in
nature at all, but it?s about innovation. The new SideBar and Gadgets and
search functionality of Vista (at least to me) scream Google Desktop. Yes it is
a little slicker than Google Desktop, but clearly it seems to be inspired by
it. This always leads me back to the whole argument about taking third-party
products and implementing them in the OS. Wasn?t there a lawsuit about that?
Something about antitrust? Silly me, I thought that it might have meant
something."
Ah yes, but in order to mean something, that implies that Microsoft actually learns from its mistakes, which it clearly does not.
by democratte
Google desktop :(
It can't be that bad :( But I suppose we'll live with it eventually.
I believe that the world will be divided between the
aristotechnocrats who wear penguins on their shirts, and the rest of us
who are just plain bloody grateful that our techno-tools work, and are
enslaved to Microsoft, until one day things change.
The first signs of change will be permanent peace in the Middle East,
then universal brotherhood, then the end of articles like <a
href=?http://www.lushforlife.com/more.php?id=200&title=Windows%20%3Ci%3EVista%3C/i%3E%20Delayed...%20%3Ci%3EAgain%3C/i%3E?>link-heret</a>
by democratte
by ratcatzdogz
by ratcatzdogz
Greetings,
Remember facsimile
documents (faxes) in the days before email? Sometimes you could receive dozens
of them a day and they all seemed so important ? yet they all shared something
in common that helped us prioritize them ? a cover sheet. On the cover sheet
there usually was an indicator to let the recipient know how to handle the document from
Urgent, FYI ? No Action Required, For Review ? Action required, Please Comment, to Please Reply.
Although faxes have become
scarce in this day and age, we can use these same indicators in our SUBJECT line
of our emails to make our recipients life a bit less stressful. When managing
an inbox that fills on a rapid basis, it would please the recipient to no end to
be able to glance at your subject heading and know at a glance how to handle
it. This goes double for someone who is managing their mail via a hand-held
device like a Blackberry. Try to incorporate this courtesy into your emailing
habits and make someone a little less stressed. If we are lucky, enough of us
will do it that it will become common practice and we will all work a little bit
more efficiently.
Lastly, over use of URGENT or PRIORITY will get you the opposite effect. Remember the little boy who cried wolf? Nuff said.
by bethmrogers
by lbull
Great idea! Seems so easy I wished I had thought of that myself. As for the comment on the read receipts, make your computer reply "no receipt" to every message that comes in. Go to Tools > Options > Preferences > Email preferences > Tracking options > then check never send a read receipt. You can choose always send a read receipt, never send a receipt, or ask me before sending. This has really saved my (email) life, because I get a lot of email.
by lbull
Great idea! Seems so easy I wished I had thought of that myself. As for the comment on the read receipts, make your computer reply "no receipt" to every message that comes in. Go to Tools > Options > Preferences > Email preferences > Tracking options > then check never send a read receipt. You can choose always send a read receipt, never send a receipt, or ask me before sending. This has really saved my (email) life, because I get a lot of email.
by lonelywind
I had a manager once, he was responding to complaints from fellow workers that they didn't have time to sort through their e-mail. He asked our department to state in the subject line what was being requested - the result was that most in our department took to putting most, if not all, of the entire message in the subject line. This resulted in subject lines that, often times, exceeded the display capabilities in both the Inbox listing, and within the message template itself. In order to read the subject, you had to click within the subject line, and drag the mouse past the end so it would scroll over.
This was several years before I transferred to our IS department, and to this day, I still get e-mails from my old department formatted in this manner. That, or half of the text would be in the subject line, and the other half in the text itself; this presents problems when we try to copy the text from the message body, in order to paste it into the text field within our trouble ticket system. People should ensure that, if they are typing critical text in the Subject, that they also include that within the body of the message.
Moral of the story: This is a good idea, but can be taken to the extreme, which causes other problems as well.
This is so true within the government. I would have to say after seeing message stats on our current exchange that 75% of email is less than 50k in size and usually a quick coming to lunch, or let's grab coffee! People loose sight of the importance of email as a business communication tool and inundate it with useless mail.
It certainly is a practice that I will encourage others to use.
by philip.russo
I like the idea. So does anybody know how to set this up as a default in New Message for Outlook [as in the options supplied on a fax sheet and one gets ticked]?
There would more likley be compliance if it could be a default.
In my opinion;
The real trick is to take the time to get to know your Outlook Express thoroughly.
Take your time and read "Every Page " carefully. You'd be amazed at what you can do.
There is nothing I loath more than those indicator " >>>" lines that keep showing up with pass-ons.
I go to great lengths to removed them.
Regardless of whatever else I do. I always leave a hint in the subject line Title as to what this will contain.
This makes life a lot easier for the recipient.
My other beef is that most of these E-Mail are just forwarded with all addresses and information included.
This is something I never do.
To protect my friends and contacts, I do a copy/paste of the part I want to send.
The I send it to all my friends through the BCC method [Blind Carbon Copy].
The main receiver is then called Recipient and the address is mine.
So I get a copy of what I sent and whom I've sent it to.
These then are just some of the things I've done to maintain the confidentiality and trust that my friends and colleagues have placed in me.
Just a few tricks I thought I'd Pass along.
It's all there, all we have to do is read it in options and tools.
Warmest Regards
Aaron ;)
by eyesak
by marguerite13
When mail comes into Outlook, as soon as I read it, I make sure the subject is relevant. If not, I change what is written in the subject to make it sensible. Then close the email and it will ask if you want to save changes. Say yes to accept the changes.
I've asked users to use the Bcc: when sending to groups of people. I explained the whole spam thing to them, they just don't get it. Some garbage that is sent around has hundreds of email addresses just waiting to be harvested by spam king and queens.
by problemsolversolutionseeker
Someone mentioned the Read Receipt situation. I worked with someone that did that to everyone. I accidentally figured out how to deal with this; although it is not the most politic way, it worked for me, and eliminated a constantly annoying situation.
Read the email from that person in preview mode; then delete it. I forgot exactly what happened on his end, but he came running over and wanted to know why I was not reading his email. When I quoted the email verbatim, he was a bit mystified.
I kept doing this until he turned the read receipt off!
(This was in Outlook.)
by rjulien
Welcome to the reality that
This is alwasy exacerbated in the type of environment where the workforce is bound by contracting process. Where there are no contractual bindings to force progress (yes, I mean the government). Where staff decisions are made not on capability or work ethic, but on whether they work for the prime company or not.
This has all led to the staff, even those who are reliable and strong performers, pushing off deadlines. Often just because they are retasked with the "crisis de jour", or because your task gets buried in the stack of other critical things they have on their plate.
This is where the unfortunate adage of the "the squeaky wheel" comes into play. But even that is a very fine balancing act. If you push too hard, staff will either start ignoring you, or worse yet, leave and go elsewhere.
The reality for most managers is that you either end up doing too much of the work yourself to the detriment of other tasks, you get your own special cadre whom you begin to overtask, or you join the parade as well.
Unfortunately, we can all guess which happens most often.
by martinjl1
Here's how we handle working with different sections that we have no control over. First we draft up a policy letter, which cleary states what will be done with a timeline. Next, we take the the drafted policy letter, along with any necessary references and submit it to the CEO. Once he or she signs it, the letter becomes a powerfull tool that can be used to track progress and accuracy of work.
by chaz chance#
So you have trouble managing your projects? Well boo hoo!
Why don't you ask your boss for a less demanding role, one
you can cope with.
These "resources" you talk so glibly about, are
PEOPLE. They need to be teated like
people, not like some tool that you can switch on and off at will. Each ones needs are individual to them, and
you need to know and take into account the needs of each and every one of them. None of your your strategies take into
account this most important fact.
I work for a company with a huge (70%) research
element. That means that most of the
people engaged on any of my projects are senior to me on the company tree, and
can make things very awkward for me if they don?t like the work I ask them to
do. That means that people skills -
surely a must for any project manager - are particularly important. Its all very well "holding people
accountable" but that doesn't make them want to work for you next
time. If you want your resources to
care about the work they are doing for you, you have to care about them and not
treat them like automata, or animals that are punished for failure.
Knowing your people is key to success. It takes less time to get to know them than
it does to chase them or to ?hold them accountable. Picking the right person for a task is about more than choosing
the best qualified. Some examples from
my own experience:
Richard the physicist can do more work in 60 seconds with
his eyes closed than I can in an hour with mine open. Loves puzzles. Don?t give
him anything that is not highly challenging if you want it done this year.
Davina the systems engineer never works on Sundays, and has
family in London so welcomes assignments there.
Kevin the senior hardware engineer bitterly dislikes having
been ?relocated? to Glasgow, and refuses work more than a hundred miles south
of there. He can be persuaded if the
job involves some time spent in Derby, where he has family.
Tarsem has a big family get-together for 2 weeks in
September, but only finds out the date at the last moment. For my pre-rainy season job I always make
sure that there is sufficient flexibility to work around that.
Jim the contracting electronics specialist likes to
talk. You have to stop, give him your
total attention, and actively listen for as long as he needs. Then he returns to work and completes your
job faster and with fewer errors than anybody else in the company, ahead of any
other ?high priority? tasks.
My people always do that little bit extra for me, even on
the less enjoyable jobs, because they know that I try to make the work fit in
with their emotional and spiritual needs, and I treat them with respect.
And even if it?s the first time they work with me, I have gained a
reputation that frequently sets up their expectations in advance. My line manager complements my on how most
of my projects are under budget and always (yes ? always) on time.
If you think you have a future in project management, better
learn some human engineering. It?s the
most valuable skill you can have.
by catfish182
I am actually finishing up a project where this has been helpful. BUT i have to agree that you have to know the people you have first. I have 3 guys from my company out with me on a computer deployment. The company that hired us also have me 4 guys also. 3 of the guys from the host company, to me, are lazy. Does that mean they are lazy? Not really but for our standards they are. Anyway I have to take into account that I am going to get a certain amount of work output from these 3 guys. I can not expect them to go above and beyond. (it would be nice but i know better). When I assign them work i look at what jobs i can give them that they can do and do in a timly manner and allow my guys the ability to work at thier pace.
Knowing the people you work with and understanding them is the key.
I was reading a few posts to one of my latest blogs (I read
all of them by the way ? even if I often don?t have time to reply), and I am
sometimes disheartened by the negativity of people?s responses?not toward me or
my posting, but to their job situations. If you comb the TR discussions or any
board where people can comment, you can find a lot of hostility and pent-up
frustration. Partly, this is a function of this kind of medium?in that people?s
responses are a way of venting in a safe place. However, I think there is more
to it than that.
First, there is the fact that working in a support function
(which IT typically is in most organizations) is very challenging. You have to
try to meet the needs of everyone, and for the most part, attempt to keep your
customers happy. Customers, by the way, who are stressed, as overworked as you
are, and often have no clue about or desire to learn more about the technology
tools provided to them.
Second, your work is often involved in/with organizational
change ? which is one of the hardest tasks to perform.
Third, if you go by many of the posts, decent managers are
few and hard to find. (I happen to think there are plenty of good ones as well,
but few write about them).
Now, given that I have just supplied you with three excuses
for why you might have a bad/negative attitude toward your IT job and some
objects of blame for it, I am going to say that our attitudes are our own
responsibility. What we bring to work, how we approach our work, and how our
work affects us is a function of our own personalities and personal choices
that we make every day.
Let me give you some examples of what I mean. I knew someone
who liked to grab every last minute of sleep he possibly could before waking
up, and when the clock went off he entered a frenzy: shower, mess with the
hair, shave, take care of a pet, and blow out the door as if his hair was on
fire. He would grab breakfast on the way to work and build ZERO flexibility
into his schedule so that any delay caused him extreme stress. Needless to say,
when he actually arrived at work, this frenzied mood stayed with him throughout
the day. While he was extremely effective at his job, he was not a happy person
at work.
Another person I know worked in a non-managerial support
function in an organization. She performed her job well, but was overly
concerned with the performance and decision making of management in her
organization. And while the concerns were legitimate, she did not have the power
to change things.
In both of these situations, much of the individual?s job
stress was self inflicted. For the first person, all it took was getting up 30
minutes early to change how he approached the work day. Suddenly, the day
didn?t start as a crisis, and he had a major attitude change. The change was
somewhat forced upon him by a spouse, but over time he came to see the wisdom
of this shift.
The second individual failed to realize that the thing she
was stressing about the most simply was not in her job description or pay
grade. While workplace stupidity can be aggravating, it is also pretty common,
and it's something you need to be able to deal with. That?s not to say that you
can?t attempt to change your organization for the better, but keep in mind what
YOUR responsibilities are and don?t sweat the things you can't control. Do your
job as well as you are allowed to do so.
I know another individual (me) who worked for an
organization that paid him well to perform a task but then placed every road
block possible in the way. This organizational ineptitude did not keep me from
successfully performing the task. I worked my tail off to accomplish the
objective, but during the time I was working on it I was extremely unhappy. I
finished the task on time and on budget, and then got the heck out.
In our jobs, we often fail to take a reality check of our
situation and to step back and examine things as an outside observer. Is the
situation at work truly intolerable, and whose fault is it really? How much of
your misery is contributed by yourself? Only you can control your attitude and
emotions and how you react to situations.
We also box ourselves into situations that, in fact, we have
the power to change, but we may not have the guts to do so. Many people stay in
bad work situations for many years hoping for a miraculous change or because
they feel that their circumstances prevent them from leaving. In fact, we
usually create our own jail.
I went unemployed for nine months at the height of one of
our nation?s worse job recessions primarily because I limited my job search to
my hometown or somewhere nearby because of family. I had also just built a new house a few years before and didn?t
want to leave it. But you know what? No one wants to live with a miserably
depressed person simply for the sake of staying in one place. I could have had
other jobs during that time - had I had the conviction to move. Eventually, I
came to my senses and realized that hard decisions had to be made and that some
changes were going to have to be made in order for life to get back to normal.
While it was hard to do, I left my new home, my friends, my extended family,
and my wife and I relocated in order for me to find the kind of job I wanted.
It wasn?t easy ? but life goes on, and we are doing better now career-wise than
we ever have.
All of this is to say that we have a great deal of control
in shaping our realities. If you hate your job, try to rationally determine
why. It may be you, it may be the job, and it may be a combination of things.
Figure out what they are and DO something
about it, whether that is changing personal habits, getting training, going
back to school, talking with your boss, seeking counseling, moving on to
another opportunity, or even a new line of work. Just don?t suffer due to
inertia or fear.
Lastly, there is no such thing as the perfect job.
Even if you are in one of those situations in which your work is also your
passion, there will be things that make you want to scream. That?s why it?s
called work and that is why they pay you for it. So take a deep breath, make
some private time, and do a self assessment. It?s a healthy thing to do and it
keeps you growing, both personally and professionally.
by jack-m
You present a reasoned, well thought out and well expressed synopsis of the work environment we live in and some of the changes we can make to improve our attitudes toward our daily work experience. In a perfect world everything you suggest would be great. Unfortunately we don't live in Utopia and often can't see the forest for the trees.
We can't change the attitudes and work habits of those technology users we support. About all we can do is make the best of the situation. Since we can't always meet their needs we can choose to meet the needs of the specific job that involves us with those we work with and for.
We can't change the work habits of our peers and it's pointless to try. To suggest to a peer that he get up a little earlier in order to make his day, and attitude that day, more serene is presumptuous of any of us. We don't know why he's always coming in at the last minute, harried and rushing. We can only deal with it as best we can.
Someone who stresses over things beyond their control are often people simply looking for a more orderly and efficient workplace and believe they have the answer. Often they only have a part of the picture and can't understand why their ideas for improvement are rebuffed.
About your quandary to move/not to move etc. there are often factors involved such as kids settled in a school, a partner with a good job who doesn't want to relocate, family obligations such as elderly parents, disabled siblings or children that make it impossible to just get up and go. No matter how sensible it might be otherwise.
" Do your job as well as you are allowed to do so." IMHO the best line in your blog. Whether it applies to what we do for a living or what we do to live.
JackM
by jack-m
You present a reasoned, well thought out and well expressed synopsis of the work environment we live in and some of the changes we can make to improve our attitudes toward our daily work experience. In a perfect world everything you suggest would be great. Unfortunately we don't live in Utopia and often can't see the forest for the trees.
We can't change the attitudes and work habits of those technology users we support. About all we can do is make the best of the situation. Since we can't always meet their needs we can choose to meet the needs of the specific job that involves us with those we work with and for.
We can't change the work habits of our peers and it's pointless to try. To suggest to a peer that he get up a little earlier in order to make his day, and attitude that day, more serene is presumptuous of any of us. We don't know why he's always coming in at the last minute, harried and rushing. We can only deal with it as best we can.
Someone who stresses over things beyond their control are often people simply looking for a more orderly and efficient workplace and believe they have the answer. Often they only have a part of the picture and can't understand why their ideas for improvement are rebuffed.
About your quandary to move/not to move etc. there are often factors involved such as kids settled in a school, a partner with a good job who doesn't want to relocate, family obligations such as elderly parents, disabled siblings or children that make it impossible to just get up and go. No matter how sensible it might be otherwise.
" Do your job as well as you are allowed to do so." IMHO the best line in your blog. Whether it applies to what we do for a living or what we do to live.
JackM
by mcandalor
There are a lot of similarities between your career and mine. I think people lose site of the forest after a while and only see those trees. Is there a way to regain focus? Nine months of unemployment sure works. I've benn in the same situation and did end up relocating. And, like you,
weareby karen mac
I agree with most of what you are saying, and with parts of what JackM is saying. While we cannot change a peer (such as getting him to get out of bed earlier so that he's less frenzied during the day) and we cannot change the demands of our clients, we CAN change our reaction to it. We each have to reassess ourselves and how we react to certain stimuli and if we don't like what we see, change it. If the changes are more than you can make on your own the get help. People too often say "I can't change my job because of ..." (fill in the blanks). I say we can change it. We just need to decide what's most important to us. For nine months, wanting to stay near family was most important to you. Eventually, though, priorities changed and making a living became more important. I certainly understand the dilemma. I'm undergoing a similar dilemma now. I will spend the next few weeks figuring out what's important to me and make a decision - do I stay or do I go. Only I can make that decision. Thanks for the reminder, Ramon.
by gwhittaker
As I read your post, I was reminded of the small scrap of paper taped to my door under "Information Systems" and my name... the quote on it from D. Stuart Briscoe blesses me daily, and many others as well who may not have considered their jobs in this light. It reads:
When you check in to work tomorrow morning, say to the Lord, "Here I am, Lord, uniquely gifted with skill, time and energy graciously provided by you. I recognize this. And I believe that you have me where you want me, which means that this particular job that I thought last week was a real bummer is, in actual fact, a high calling, and I am going to live and work today as if that is exactly what it is."
by whomever123
I just want to say I agree with you whole-heartedly about the moving thing to find the job you want. I had to move from the big city where I grew up at a time 13 years ago when there weren't any jobs in my field. And all the jobs I was applying for were all contract jobs, and everyone was all bidding on the same contracts, and saying we'll call you if we get the contract. I ended up moving to a much smaller city, an 8 hour drive away. I got a secure job. Maybe not the greatest pay but it was comparable to what I was making before. But it was secure and is a union job. No more looking for another job every 2 years, which I found stressful while raising a family.
What really bugs me is when people in this town gripe to me that I work for this organization and wonder how I got the job. And why they can't get on with the organization. What they fail to realize are the sacrifices I had to make to get this job. Leaving my hometown of 30 years, which was scary, and make a fresh start. What they fail to realize is that I couldn't get the exact same job with a similar organization in my own home town. That I had to move, was the key. So these people whine and complain cause they can't get a good job here in their own home town, with their degrees, etc. And I am surprised how many people prefer to whine and complain rather than consider moving. I suggest they go up North maybe where all the jobs are, and they won't even consider it. So where are their priorities? I just feel they shouldn't whine and complain to me about it if they won't consider all their options like I had to, and make some hard decisions, which I didn't want to make, but had to if I wanted a job at that time.
Anyways, that's my beef. Thanx for posting this blog as I find it very helpful. And I will have to consider trying to get up earlier in the morning thing, so I'm not so stressed by the time I get here!
by wet&webbed
I'm in the process of leaving a job I mostly love in an organization I love. However, the place is in a budget crunch and I've had to take a hard look at how I will (or won't) fit in in the future. Even though management has assured me that my job is safe, I've survived five layoffs in my work life mostly by taking a very hard look at what's really going on. All I can conclude is despite what management says, the signs are not in my favor.
I think the hardest part for me is facing up to the fact that my skills will no longer be needed and all the contributions I've made will be gone. In other words, I've worked for a place for eight years and when I'm gone, there will be no trace of me. It's a small death. But life moves on and so must I. I've re-read Herman Hesse's Siddhartha. There's a passage where Siddhartha sits by a river and realizes that no matter what the river moves on and that everyone moves with it.
by smyth.david
Your article is very sensible. Whatever the situation, one has control of one thing: your own reaction to it. Well, your own public reaction to it, at least - we might react internally one way, but getting control of that and responding in a controlled manner is our choice.
I have done what you suggested - relocated to seek opportunity and so on. However, you have lost sight of three things: the older you get, the harder that is, and the less opportunities there are. And, if you make a sub optimal choice somewhere, it becomes harder to recover.
Eventually, the reassessment you suggest may lead to one outcome, being "I have to make the best of it." The focus then becomes on how to do that. The professional advice I was given was to stop caring about the outcome and stop doing the best damned job you can despite the roadblocks. Give the advice on what should be done, keep a record of it, then do what you are told despite knowing it won't produce the best outcome or even the outcome wanted. Focus on the other things in you life. Implementing this is awfully hard and I have not achieved it! It's not good advice for a young person, either; the younger you are, the more applicable is Ramon's solution.
The third thing you have not mentioned is the thing we all want out of work; respect. I think that is the thing for which the people you mention are crying out.
by shaggydan
I work as a technician at Edwards AFB, I used to work in the commercial world up until 4 years ago when I joined the civil service. What is frustrating for me is the huge difference in management styles between civil service and the "real world", in the real world a manager/supervisor/boss is responsible for providing their troops with the tools, training, time, and manpower to do their jobs and accomplish their daily workload, not so with civil service management, civil service management tells us what to do and by the way we don't have the tools, training, time, and manpower to provide you. If civil service managers were held accountable for troop morale and employee turnover I'm sure this attitude would change.
by johngpmp
I think gwhittaker has the correct focus and a great quote. I believe that God has given us are skills and the ability to hone our skills. Although we may not like our job, unless we are being asked to do something illegal or unethical, we are blessed with our jobs.
I have been a rut for a long while and starting hating my job, but quotes like gwhittaker has will help focus you. Also I found volunteering or going back to school may help a person?s attitude. They are still doing the same job, but they have other outlets and possibly other future career opportunities. Here are a few ideas:
. Help create web pages for your church or social group.
. Go back and get a degree
. Get a certification (project management ? PMP or a Microsoft )
. If you have a dream job?see if you can learn the job at your church or social group.
. Teach a class for your local community adult education
by nconst
A wise mentor of mine once said told me of the three elements to a job.
Job, Location and Compensation. (Great Job/Job Satisfaction, Short Commute, and $$$)
If you have all three, Home Run! (I doubt you are even reading this)
Two out of three - you stay,
One out of three - look for another job.
Comments anyone??
by lbain
by it cowgirl
Excellent Blog! I have been all those persons you mentioned in your article. I too hyave had to move away from my new home and family to the other side of the country. Luckily, my other half followed a year later because of the lack of jobs in our home area. Renting here allows me to keep my home and go for visits and vacation.
It seems many of us are in the same boat!
I was unemployed for three years sitting on the fence as you were. No regrets for the move, and I have grown alot technically because of my decision. I am really happy with the posibilities in the new job.
Now, self assessment is something I am doing fairly often on both the professional and personal levels. You are right it is a constant growing process and it helps to guide and mold your relationships (professional and personal) as well as your actions and reactions to others. Finally your own decisions are a result of these growing experiences and introspect.
Thanks for taking the time to blog this.
by wescrock
First off... GREAT blog... kind of just what I needed right
now.
\
Second... I match a lot of this "to the T." I?m a 20 yr. old
student here in California
and home for the summer... I am currently working in the IT dept. at a huge
agricultural company in the IT dept. Although just a summer intern, I always
strive to better the work environment and streamline unnecessary processes as
well as learn all that I can. This isn?t my first job in the IT field either.
This job is a great opportunity and I have learned a lot here.... I even built
my first server!!!
My problem though... is my boss... The head of the IT dept is totally inept to
the tech world. He hinders projects and spews out vocabulary jargon that none
of the rest in the dept., have ever heard... and sometimes, he doesn?t even
know the definitions (I've asked him what one word he rattled off was... and he
couldn?t give me a half decent definition.) He sits alone in an office separated
from the rest and is totally disconnected from us. I don?t think anyone in the
entire company is satisfied with him... and he sits on yahoo messenger all day
(until, under the command of the CFO, it was blocked by our server
administrator.) He criticizes in such a destructive manor as well... It kind
of hurts sometimes... but I just think about what he said... and think about
how no body like how he does his job... and I think "well... everyone else
is satisfied with my work... so whatever..."
all together, I can't wait to go back to school... get out of my parents house
again, and start my normal job back up again... but we have a new manager at my
old job who I haven?t worked with before... so we'll see how it goes... I hear
mixed reactions...
Wish me luck,
Wes
by cesmoi85
I do agree with your overall assessment of one's work outlook and one's accountability to the "work environment.' However, I must say that it is not the work that we do, but the work environment and the management of our work. I work in the IT healthcare and I must say that I am constantly working under crisis management and constantly putting out fires that adds alot of stress to my job. And, I find this a pattern in the IT healthcare world. It comes to a point that the staff become burned out from the lack of foresight at the management level. I believe It is the staff responsibility as well as management to improve the work environment or as I see where I work staff continues to quit. They can not keep workers for more than a year. Information Technology is often involved in process analysis and improvement, but fail to analyze their processes and improve their processes. Instead, I hear constantly that "we are too busy."
by jtnieves
by jrapoport
A truly well-thought out piece of work regarding the kind of issues that we make DR plans for; however, those people not involved or only peripherally involved with IT do not see the value of planning for disasters or pandemics until the event occurs and then they want solutions. Some employers just do not grasp the importance of spending some money now to insure business continuity and a workable DR plan that works because the money could be better used elsewhere in their minds. It is up to IT professionals to explain and teach non-IT management the importance of having equipment in place for these and other kinds of disasters in order for businesses to be able to continue in disastrous times.
In my last blog posting I received several comments both
publicly and privately suggesting that my advice was only (or mostly)
applicable to the young. For those of
you who did not read it, my advice in a nutshell was this: Only YOU are capable
of controlling your destiny, and although outside forces play a large role in
what you must deal with, ultimately it is your responsibility regarding how you
react to those forces. The part that
caused the most consternation among the aging or aged were my comments on
relocation as an option for getting out of a situation in which you hate your
job. To these individuals I say, ?Fear
not, for it is your wisdom that is most valuable?.
I am not sure how Webster defines wisdom, but my definition
is this: ?The ability to apply specific knowledge at the appropriate time, and
the ability to reach an answer faster due to experience?. Now, you don?t have to be ?old? per se to
have wisdom, but it generally goes hand in hand with the aging process. It is the edge one has by having lived and
learned and seen and done over and over again.
Don?t believe me? Put yourself
in this situation: You are a green recruit straight out of boot camp. You have excelled at all aspects and you are
the ?model? soldier. Suddenly you find
yourself knee deep in swamp water in the middle of the night, or creeping
through burnt out buildings in heat so hot that you can?t keep the sweat out of
your eyes. In both situations, the
enemy is lying in wait for you. Who do
you want leading your group of ten, a grizzled sergeant who has just completed
his 4th consecutive tour of combat duty or the green lieutenant
fresh out of officer candidate school?
In this instance, let us assume both have been trained superbly, so they
both have all the knowledge possible for the given situation. Personally, I want the sergeant in front of
me.
Now, while the everyday work place is usually not a life and
death situation, the same concepts apply.
Given the same level of knowledge, who do you want managing your
personnel or heading up your project teams?
Someone who has successfully done it before. In the example above, the sergeant is still alive after 4 tours
of duty. He is either incredibly lucky
or he has learned what it takes to stay alive through experience. He: (a) knows what to look for, (b) how to
react, (c) how not to be fooled, (d) knows what knowledge he was taught is
applicable for particular situations and when to apply it and what needs to be
ignored and (e) can function under extreme pressure. The lieutenant on the other hand, while having been ?taught? what
to do and has been told all of what the sergeant may ?know? still is at a
disadvantage. This is not to say that
he cannot excel in this situation (for many have and are) but that the
likelihood of success is higher with the sergeant.
?The baby boom generation is a demographic term for the
population born between 1946 and 1964. Data from the 2000 U.S. Census estimates
that the group that holds the ?boomer? moniker is made up of at least
82,826,479 individuals. The members of this group range from 41 to 59 years
old, which means this demographic behemoth will start leaving the workforce in
approximately five to ten years (people are working longer these days).? In previous articles I have mentioned that
workplaces need to begin to prepare for this ?knowledge drain? as the media has
called it. But the more I think about
it, the crisis to come is the result of the WISDOM drain caused by this
generation leaving the workforce.
This wisdom drain is entirely more difficult to replace than
pure knowledge and I believe companies will be clamoring for experienced
personnel to take their place. So
rather than age discrimination, I anticipate the reverse ? preferential
treatment for those with extensive experience ? particularly in management
positions. So tying back to my earlier
comments to my aging compatriots (and after all, who reading this blog is not
aging?) don?t worry so much about your age as much as your expertise. HOWEVER, if you have let your skills wither
and you are in a programming position and want to compete with young
programmers with better skills ? then all bets are off Skippy. The young guy is going to get the job. But if have kept up to date, are current in
the knowledge needed to compete in a particular field, you are at an advantage,
not at a disadvantage.
So in conclusion, and going back to my original
premise at the start of this posting as well as last week?s ? your destiny is
in your hands. If you are in a
situation where you hate your job and you have put yourself in a
non-competitive situation by letting your skills deteriorate, fix it! Sharpen those skills that have dulled. On the other hand, if you are still razor
sharp and your only issue is that your hair is gray or mostly gone (as in my
case) don?t let AGE be a major deciding factor in your decision-making. If a company in a state a thousand miles
away is looking for a quality individual and you have the credentials ? don?t
let age stop you from applying. And
while I won?t ignore the fact that some age discrimination does exist, your
experience will serve you well ? and even more so in the next 10 years.
by putchavn1
The definition posted is mostly OK but it can be refined. Deletions are within ( ) and additions are in CAPS.
?The ability to apply (specific) ALL knowledge ACQUIRED OVER TIME TO A SPECIFIC SITUATION at the appropriate time WITH SPEED AND CONFIDENCE, TO PRODUCE A DESIRABLE OUTCOME (and the ability to reach an answer faster due to experience?).
Explanation:
Applying "specific" knowledge just requries the knowledge of the "specific", not wisdom. Wisdom is required when the specific knowledge is not identified but the situation demands it.
Furthermore, wisdom has to be applied with speed and confidence. There is no scope for trial and error or doubt.
All this must necessarily lead to a desirable or superior outcome, just not any answer or outcome!
by mundomaga
Thank you for the encouragement for those of us who do not yet consider ourselves "over the hill" but rather sitting on top of the hill, contemplating now more than ever, what would be the next best move. As a 51-yr-old mother of 2, grandmother of 2, I am in the midst of a major vocation change, have returned to school & am looking fwd to spending the next 15 - ? yrs doing things "differently" from how I have done them for the past 25. Regarding relocation, I have accepted that in order to pursue my dreams of "settling down" with my own web technologies business, I will most likely have to relocate. Technological opportunities are simply more available in some areas than others. In reality, whether it is relocation or some other major life change, I think that the willingness to continue to make major changes is one of the factors that determines whether one is beginning a new phase of "right livelihood" or entering retirement.
Thanks again for the advice.
Darlene Mericle
by stephena
I defniitely agree with Ramon on his comments on wisdom, but I would like to add to it. Wisdom is definitely acquired by experience and time, but there is another way to gain wisdom with "lesser" effort (notice the quotations around the word lesser). Now, I?m going to talk a little bit about the Bible so for all of you who don?t believe in God or the Bible, or just don?t care to know, please hear me out! The Bible describes Solomon as the ?wisest man who ever lived?. During Solomon?s youth he became a King and God was going to grant him any wish he desired. Solomon, instead of asking for long life and riches for himself, he asked God for wisdom (that in itself required wisdom). God granted him this wish and made him the wisest man who ever lived (God also made him one of the richest because he asked for wisdom). Later on in his life Solomon wrote most of what makes up the book of Proverbs. His purpose in writing these proverbs was to share his wisdom with all who would listen. My encouragement to you is, even if you are not a believer, to study the book of Proverbs and apply its principles in your life and I guarantee you will be successful in whatever you do; career, school, marriage, etc? Studying the book of Proverbs is the easy part, which is why I used the word ?lesser? above, but applying these principles in your life is the challenging part. For those of you who don?t want to open up the Bible there is actually a great book written on Solomon?s wisdom and how to apply it. The book has an entrepreneurial spin to it but again, you can apply the principles to any part of your life. If you would like to know the title of the book I would be more than glad to email it to you. Just send me an email and I will respond with the title and author.
Steve
by blueknight
Good points Ramon. One trait that comes in handy in addition to wisdom is persistence. For those "older" individuals who find themselves looking for a job later in life like I did, do not be discouraged, though it is easy to allow yourself to be. Age discrimination is alive and well, but there are employers out there who recognize talent and the wisdom that comes with those years of experience. My previous position was eliminated as part of an attempt to cut costs and I was forced to seek employment at the age of 47. It would have been easy to allow myself to become discouraged after each interview that did not result in an offer -- especially considering how many positions I applied for. I knew things would turn out fine (it was a faith thing for me) and they did. I didn't know where I was going to be working until the Wednesday of my last week on the job, but a good job came through. That was 10 years ago. Here I am still enjoying my work after almost 40 years in IT, and I have no plans to retire yet.
My point is that if you find yourself having to look for a job late in life, market not only your skill set, but the wisdom you have gained over the years. Be of good courage and keep looking, your job is out there waiting for you to find it... it's just a matter of time. You be the one who decides when to "hang up your spurs."
For you younger folks, wisdom is not just gained by age, it is gained by experience "in the trenches" as well. Those of you who have gone through some particularly rough projects or situations will have gained some wisdom from that experience. You can excel in what you do when you apply that wisdom along with the skill set you have.
I was listening to NPR on the way home yesterday when they
aired a story regarding teenagers coming of age in this digital world and how
this is the first generation of children to have mastered current technology
before their parents did. It went on to describe all the horrible things that
kids can get exposed to without their parents being aware.
Now whose fault is this really? Are we to blame the
manufacturers of the new technology for the parents? inability to figure it out?
Of course not! Plain and simple, if parents don?t understand a technology
better than their children, it is their own fault - period. If we can
characterize a generation of children who have grown up in a digital world
without adult guidance, then let me also characterize these parents as the
first generation of parents that seem to wear ignorance as a badge of pride.
When I was growing up, I can?t ever recall an adult
declaring proudly that he couldn?t read or do math (they may have not been able to but they were not proud of it, even ashamed), yet I can't tell you the
number of times I have heard today?s adults say, ?I don?t know anything about
those computers and don?t want to know ? just make it do what I need it to do.?
I?m sure you have heard similar comments. What?s with this technology-ignorance
badge of honor that people seem to wear so proudly? I, frankly, have never
understood it nor understand why it is tolerated.
Now what in the world does this have to do with government
technology? Well, these same parents who can?t learn enough about the Internet
to keep young Billy or Suzy from frequenting porn sites come to work with
you/for you everyday!
And guess what? They wear that same technology-ignorance
badge proudly at work too! You deal with this everyday ? from top management to
the lowest person on the org chart. This phenomenon knows no boundaries! It?s
not a matter of education either, as Ph.D.s can demonstrate this trait as well
as someone without a high school diploma. Why, why, why is this allowed?
The answer is simple. Senior management doesn?t demand
technology competence of all employees (in fact, they are often the guiltiest),
and they also do not place a high priority on this competence; therefore, they
are reluctant to finance training and continuing education.
Let?s talk about technology competence. I do not expect
every individual in the workplace to know how to program in Java, but I would
like to have a basic expectation that they know how to maneuver quickly and
competently in the OS that they spend all day working in (Windows). They should
also be able to differentiate between the MS Office applications and know how
to use each at more than a rudimentary level.
Please note that I said I would like to have a basic expectation
because in reality I have the opposite. I am usually surprised when someone demonstrates
basic technology literacy. Sad but true.
So how is this going to change? Unless you have more tech
savvy senior management (they do exist ? I have seen a few) demand competence
of their employees and begin to fund training, the fix to this problem will be
through attrition. The younger generation will take their place in the
workforce, demanding that their workplace keep up with them, as well as making
their current co-workers look bad for not having learned anything. Only then
will people stop wearing that technology-ignorance badge so proudly.
So what does this mean to you in the short run? It means
that your users and decision makers need technology issues explained in plain
English. Mind you, I am not saying ?dumbed down? but phrased in such a way that
the basic concepts are easy to grasp. More importantly, they need to understand
how technology affects them as business users. Leave out the complicated
technical details when making a business case and talk about what benefits the
organization. Have the details in your back pocket to be able to demonstrate
you have done your homework, but make sure your message is one that is easily
understood.
It also means that we need to continue to fight for training
money because until we get everyone to a certain level of competence, the
technology tools we put in front of them will forever be underutilized. It also
can
mean that we stop giving them more than what they will use, if we are
brave enough to do so. What does this mean? Frankly, I am willing to debate
that the majority (that does not mean all) of typical business users could get
by with e-mail, a text editor with spell check (Wordpad with spell check, in
essence), and a basic spreadsheet program. In my opinion, the feature richness
of the MS Office suite goes unused by the majority of users. In fact, my gut
feeling is that 75 percent of the advanced features in all of the Office
applications go unused.
Given this hypothesis, one can then say that we are paying
an enormous amount for software that contains features that most will never
use. So perhaps we give them something less feature-rich and less costly
(StarOffice or Open Office anyone?) and give the power users the real Office
tools? Heresy, you say! We must have STANDARDS, after all, to ease support. Everyone
must use the same tools! If we had easier tools ? we might not need so much
support then would we? Hmmm.
In any case, if we are going to continue to provide MS
Office as a standard, we should at least get people trained to do more with it and
get the most out of our investment, right?
As for the children knowing more than their parents ? well,
what can I say? There are books and training available to anyone who might show
an interest. Also, having a child tutor a parent is not only possible, but
actually might give them something in common to talk about. But if parents are
content to let 12:00 AM blink on their VCRs or DVD players, or a if manager is
okay with someone still using a calculator with rolls of paper to do their
budgeting, then they only have themselves to blame.
by branimir
by kimballc
by kimballc
by kimballc
by crabbyabby86
Thank you. It's nice to see that some people still have sense, and that someone other than myself is getting sick of the ignorance.
As for the comment made whining about not having time to understand the stuff your child is getting into: suck it up. If you didn't expect to devote your life to your kids, maybe you shouldn't have kids. We're not asking you to become a tech guru, just know how to check up on your kids. Kinda like the parents whose kid loves soccer--they'd probably at least show up to their kid's games. Geez.
by leoofmars
I remember seeing movies on TV when I was a little tike -- movies probably made in the 1930's or 1940's -- in which older people were satired with regard to cutting-edge technology. Only then the cutting edge technology was the telephone and the oldsters would be shown yelling into the phone, because, after all, the person they were talking to was a long way away.
Kimbalc should stop yelling into the phone.
by mvarela
I agree that training is part of the issue. My experience in government is that "techies" usually have a training budget but most other areas struggle for training dollars. My technical position was moved into a non-technical division two years ago and now I have to beg for technical training to keep my skills up to date. Government does need to train all workers in technology that is pertinent to their jobs.
by kimballc
Come on Ramon...take off those IT Colored Glasses. You live in the center of this technology as I do...yet we have a large percentage of parents that are not PC literate because they work in environments that do not require it. There are many in the blue collar community that may use a scanner, read a CRT or LCD screen for information, yet do nothing more (if even that) than email in a Windows environment. Remember the games that were on computers to help Windows 3.1 users feel more comfortable with their "new-fangled" contraptions? These "trainees" are now in corporate and government management...maybe we did not do our jobs way back when!
These are the same parents who have children that are required to be proficient in computers to stay competitive with their school buddies. To them, a computer is a tool, a game machine, and tutor, rolled into one. They research projects, take tests that show their homework proficiency, etc. Many parents marvel at their children's ability, yet have no idea (and are even scared) of that monster sitting on the desk. Their employer has no need to ensure proficiency as their jobs do not dictate IT literacy. Their kids on the otherhand love to see what is out there...they are naturally curious...and that is when trouble begins.
Let's not chastise those that don't have the time, a professional need, or even desire to learn about the PC. Let's, as IT professionals, make it easy for parents to limit access to protect. But, let's not go on a Crusade touting parental PC Literacy as the savior of society...it is just one more cross-section of the world whereby family values are erroding.
by kimballc
by leoofmars
I'm glad to hear that your not yelling into the phone, Kimballc. I guess I feel strongly about this because my agency is about to implement SAP and despite protestations that it's much easier to use now, I fear for many of my users. Had they only learned to program their VCR's years ago, the coming implementation would probably be a lot easier on them and me.
Does anyone give users tests before they let them on new systems? Does anyone test for minimum PC proficiency before letting new employees through the door?
by crabbyabby86
kimballc. I think you missed my point. Apparently you are NOT one of the ignorant people this is really about, because you DO understand that "we're not asking you to become a tech guru, just know how to check up on your kids."
As for being out of line, hardly. Apparently you do devote yourself to your kids, but I meant the general 'you' that encompasses everyone. I'm sorry if you mistook it for a personal attack.
And no. I do not have kids. I was raised by people who are STILL yelling into the phone, literally, so I know better. Honestly, I can't imagine why any intelligent person would want to bear one more white, middle class brat. But that's just the opinion of one white, middle class brat who had more than her fair share of online stalkers by the age of 17. You want to know why I had stalkers? My parents put their badges of ignorance right over their "proud parent of an honor roll student" bumper sticker. Why, even though I do not want kids of my own, do I care about parents getting involved with their children? Mine weren't, and it hurt our whole family. It's as simple as that.
by kimballc
by mordacity
by stubby
Well thought out article but I have to disagree with your conclusions.
I don't, and have never fallen into the technically illiterate category for most things to do with gadgets but I don't understand chemistry, I can't do biology plus a million and one other things.
As I follow your analogy through, if I'm to have children (and I do), then I need to know everything about anything just to make sure my child doesn't stumble upon the cure for diabetes without running it past me first. I know I'm being extreme, but then this is ultimately where your conclusion would go .... my children will all too soon find out I'm fallible in the meantime I'll keep my god like status in the eyes of two of them. My eldest almost certainly, presuming he stays the course of his learning record to date, will far outstrip anything I know or do, but isn't that the one of the main points of being a parent ...? To get your child a better life, a better start, a better education - in short to know more than I do.
I know the day my son accepts his doctorate for Computer Science or finds a cure for something or a.n.other achievement I will be there going "I don't understand this modern stuff". In the meantime I will not denigrate those of my generation (or others) who don't know, I will thank my God that I am available to assist them and earn a living at it.
Have you attended a Web conference lately? Have you hosted a
Web conference? If you have, you know that attending and hosting one are two
different things entirely. Ever purchase a new technology and then immediately
get asked why you haven?t rolled it out? A colleague and I have had some ?fun?
lately dealing with the misplaced notion that once you purchase the capability
to do Web conferencing, it?s ?easy? to make one happen.
Like every other technology that we encounter, what looks so
simple to an observer is actually far more difficult than what meets the eye--typical
for our line of work. The same goes for hosting a Web conference (or
"webinar"). So before I turn this column into a rant, I'll try to
turn this into a primer for a successful Web conference.
First, what seems obvious, but what people tend to forget:
(a)
It takes planning to conduct a successful, productive
meeting/presentation. And I am talking about your typical face-to-face meeting--let
alone a Web conference. Disorganization and lack of planning is amplified
for a Web conference.
(b)
There are decisions and choices to be made depending on your
audience. Here are a few:
a.
Are all your participants going to be remote or will you have
some in person as well? If you have some in person, then you have the added
headache of making sure the room can hold all of your participants as well as
support your webinar--internet connectivity, screen, projector, audio, etc.
b.
Will all of your participants actually be in a building and
have internet connectivity or will some need to participate via cell phone from
their car or in an airport?
(c)
How technologically savvy are your participants? Are they
capable of and do they have PERMISSION to install your web client on their
machine? If they aren?t very savvy, can they manage well enough to participate
or will they need help?
(d)
Related to C above, will you be using a traditional phone
conference line for audio, VOIP exclusively, or a combination of the two? Note
that all Web conferencing products are not the same, and that some are not
capable of bridging a traditional voice call with VOIP participants.
e.
If you plan on using VOIP, does everyone have a DECENT headset
and a properly adjusted microphone? If not, you can get some bad results and
one person can effectively ruin a perfectly good conference.
Once the questions above are handled, you then get into the
logistics of the Web conference:
First, sending out the meeting notice WELL in advance of the
meeting in order to ensure that people have time to get the client installed;
they may need to get their IT department to do it for them.
Depending on your answer above, you may need to send out a voice
conference number and instructions on how to join your conference.
Preparing/receiving
electronic materials ahead of time: Web conferences tend to work best when
the materials being presented, whether they are documents, spreadsheets,
PowerPoint Presentations or video are provided and loaded prior to the
webinar?s start. Although most webinar/Web conferencing software will allow you
to load documents on the fly, it can take a while depending on the size of the
material and the speed of the connection, which can really interrupt the flow
of your meeting and make you look unprepared.
Here are some other
points to keep in mind:
As I said earlier, a webinar will amplify your lack of
preparation. Do you really have material that is worthy of a Web conference? If
the answer is no, perhaps a conference call will suffice?
Boring PowerPoint presentations are just as boring when
presented via Web conferencing software.
People that are running the conference have to know the Web
conferencing client and its capabilities. They must also be willing to ?touch?
the technology. You can?t will a Web conference into existence, and depending
on a secretary or administrative staff person makes it that much more
difficult.
If you are going to record a Web conference, let people know
ahead of time that they will be recorded and for what purpose.
Much of the Web conferencing software/services cannot
display more than half a dozen web cam images on the screen at the same time ?
no matter if all your participants have a camera.
Web conferencing can be an ideal way to bring people
together from distant locations. The tools available today have any amazing
variety of features and almost anything is possible. However, the most
sophisticated tool will not allow anyone wishing to host a Web conference to
shine, without the proper planning and knowledge. If your IT department implements
the technology for Web conferencing, you should create a protocol on the proper
use of the tool, provide tips for running a successful web conference, and provide
proper training for better use of the tool. Yes, there will be those that use
it as a way to extend their boring presentations to more people, but there also
will be those in your organization who take your advice to heart and make good
use of the tool/s you have provided. And that?s what we are after in the long
run!
Sort by Trending