Discussion Locked

Great IT Training companies - the stuff of dreams?

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi all,

I was wondering if there's such a thing as an honest IT training company. After following the debate on Joskos and the James Thornton Group, I've pretty much lost all faith in private providers. Can anyone restore it?

22 replies

by dan powers

I've taken a good hand full of technical training calsses
during my career. A couple that come to mind is the
SharePoint and MOM training that I took at a majoe
training institute in town. Both classes were a 2 day sales
pitch. I learned almost nothing and the expierence was
complete garbage.

Then in the summer last year I took VMWare taining at the
same training institute. This time though VMWare flew in
thier own trainer.

"Was I going to get the same mind numbing instructor just
reading me pages from the book?"

No, not this time. VMWare had a great source of material
that they expected the class to read on their own. The
class was full of labs and excersises. The instructor not
only knew the product, he had well indepth knowledge of
many technology platforms. IT was by far the best
training I had recieved.

So I look back on those eariler classes and wonder... Was
it the training facility and the mind numbing instructor?
Or was it the sales pitch material Mirosoft was trying to
beat into my head?

My experience has told me good training is few and far
between. In the end nothing can replace the larning
process I like to call trial and error on my own...

by pgm554

I have had traing classes from Novell and M$ that went from great and informative,to "Are you effing kidding me?".

It isn't all bad and it isn't all good.

by kyser soze

I got my MCT certification along with my MCSE in NT 4.0 before realizing that training was just a revenue stream for MS and many trianging companies are money churns. My IIS class covered maybe 25% of what was needed to get the cert, the rest was up to me. I guess that is all $1000 was worth to them. I enjoyed training and was told that it was the only Cert that would never expire becasue we were learning teaching techniques that could be applied to any subject. This held true even after MS changed the rules. I have trained users at every job I have had, but the only MOC job offer I had promised $50K/year, until we got down to the fine print. Then it changed to $35K base,with pay raises for every NEW class you became certified to teach, capping at 50K and one time bonuses for every new class after that.It was in 2000, so the numbers might not be correct, but I seem to remember 10 new classes to get to 50K. How well could you know a subject learning 10 new technologies in a year? I was told that I only need to stay one chapter ahead of the students.I did not take the job, MS changed the MCT rules and I have let all my Certs slide since then. I have been constantly employed, improving my pay with every new position.I still train, but ony in areas I use and am knowledgeable in. The best training I have received have been from people who used and knew the product. So I would say that the specialized training was good, and the general training companies are poor. Most are money churns with no real concern about helping their students beyond lightening their wallets.

by susan.wiebenga

I typically read and enjoy the dicussions, but do not respond. But as an IT Trainer and professional educator I felt I should respond to this posting. Several of the comments posted are right on target. The best trainers as those that have indepth experience using the technology. They are better able to show the students how to use the app in real life and answer the questions that students have that are not necessarily in the manuals.

Often what happens in the trainig field, especially in technical training, a person who is an expert technically will be expected to conduct training since they are the expert. Unfortunately being a technical expert does not mean you can be an effective trainer. It is a completely different skill set. Not everyone can teach. That is why in the public educational system teachers are required to have extensive training to prepare them for teaching in a classroom, typically a 4 year degree focused on all aspects of being a quality instructor/teacher. This is a hot topic of discussion in the training and adult education field. Should the industry develop some type of formally recognized trainer certification? There are several out there, but they typically just require you to attend a certain amount of training or a specific course. They do not measure the individuals ability to actually teach a class.

The best thing I can recommend when looking for quality IT/techincal training is to research the vendors you are interested in using. Ask them to provide instructor bios which should include not only their technical experience, but their teaching experience. Also ask your counterparts to recommend good instructors and vendors.

by menopausal

When I wanted to break into IT 'officially' after learning support on the job for a small company, I went to Techskills. They charge too much and basically try to upsell everyone into a 5 or 6 cert track, when logic would tell you just start with one or two.
But, the training they offered was decent. You could choose to actually learn the subject or just memorize the exams-- I chose to learn.
I would only recommend it for someone who wanted the self-study. Why it was better than just buying the book: the labs were well-written, as a beginner I didn't have enough hardware to just break stuff of my own, and I got well-chosen study materials. I benefitted from the online classes as much as any book, and I'm usually a book learner.

OTOH, I'd really like it if it were fairly priced. A book, an online class, pre-written labs and the use of their hardware was NOT worth $1300/pop.

by zbatia

I don't know how many folks are living in MD, but I have RTEK 2000, The Internet Career training company, the company that from the first day (July 1993) tried to be honest to the bone. In 1999 we got the license form MD Higher Education commission and were eligible for funds for the folks who have no money for education but would like to obtain the professional-level knowledge in Computer Networking and Web Design areas. If you want to learn what happened next, point your browsers here:
http://www.rtek2000.com/Step5.html

In 1992, I have published an article at our web site (you can still find it here:
http://www.rtek2000.com/Good/Why_we_have_to_fight_with_hypes.pdf ) about the true value of certifications. It was a cry of one man in a desert. I've got many testimonials from people who thanked for the true words, but the whole certification industry was against it because the certifications mean money, money, money.

RTEK 2000 is probably only one of a kind company that does not afraid to say the true. Since 1993 we have trained quietly numerous IT professionals who are working now at various positions up to the CTO.

So, there are some (but not many) honest people. And, if you got familiar with two mentioned sources, you know who you have to blame for.

by Member 26444426

First, let me provide a little context. I have never heard of Joskos and the James Thornton Group; nor could I find anything about the referenced debate.

I do not present courses leading to vendor product certifications; and I have no relationships with any said vendors.

I am an instructor of courses on requirements, quality and testing, software acquisition and outsourcing, project management, metrics, and process improvement.

I present training directly for clients through my own company and in public and in-house settings for several well-known companies that are in the business of presenting training. I am a published book and articles author and frequent featured speaker at leading conferences.

Oh, yes, and I've also done a whole of lot real work too, from the most technical systems programming through business requirements and management roles.

Now, let me share a somewhat different perspective from the other end of the classroom.

As someone who does have content knowledge, as opposed to the typical class attendee who by definition is attending because they don't have such knowledge, I have observed speakers and teachers whom I feel are presenting negligible (and sometimes downright incorrect) content. Yes, it happens; but what I find more appalling is how frequently the attendees don't recognize the presenter's content paucity and actually give them high evaluation scores.

Sadly, too, attendees often fail to appreciate presenters who provide keen insights rather than merely rehashing the same old same old.

Attendee perceptions can reflect many factors besides content. For instance, a number of years ago, I found my own course evaluations went down when I stopped showing Dilbert cartoons, after I became aware that doing so violated Scott Adams' copyright.

I have no idea what the facts were that Urban Pauper was reacting to, but I suspect there may be at least one other side to the story.

Regardless, characterizing it as an honesty issue and then implying that all training companies are dishonest seem grossly unfair and unsupportably judgmental overgeneralizations.

by m.w.h.

It is not surprising to me that attendees give good evaluations for style rather than content. It happens everywhere all the way up to presidential elections. I also find it a stretch to expect novice attendees to be able to tell the difference between keen insights and rehashed material. If they knew the difference, they wouldn't need to attend your training.

by scott

I've been to many of the so called professional training companies, even participated in several in-house training classes where a "Professional" came to my workplace and put on a 2-day course. Some were good, many were just not worth the money paid... In my quest for training and skills upgrading, I came across a small company in St. George, UT... "LearnKey" (www.learnkey.com) that specalizes in self-paced training and can deliver in many different mediums (Video/CD/Intranet/Internet). They have thousands of interactive-multimedia courses that don't require you to have the software you want training on. You do it at your own pace and can start and stop as you need. Imagine the freedom to start a Windows Server 2003 Training Module at work then hop on a plane to Paris where once you are settled in your hotel room, you pick up right where you left off simply by inserting your CD or accessing the Internet. Some days I just don't have the time to dedicate 2 or 3 days to a outside training course but I do have a half an hour here or there that I can take advantage of. Oh, and the service at LearnKey is FANTASTIC... they are a small company that believes in you the customer. They are not like the big training companies that only want you money and never answer the phone when you call. I didn't mean to turn this in to a sales pitch, but after years of disappointment, I've finally found a solution that works for me and I'm excited about it.

by it generalist

Training classes provide you with a collaborative environment where you can ask questions to your instructor and share your thought with your peers. But of course, if you are at bad training center, there is not much you can do. I also believe in doing it your self if you really want to have good hands on experience. I recommend setting up your own virtual lab. Get a box with lots of processing power, RAM and a big hard drive and load it up with MS Virtual Server for free from microsoft.com. Most companies provide free trials and user guides for their products. Setup your own virtual lab, setup multiple PC/Servers, install trials on virtual PC/Servers, follow the instructions in user guide and go from there. If you get stuck on something, Google it and I bet you will find lots of good resources to help you get unstuck.

For Microsoft products, you can also try TechNet Microsoft virtual lab online at http://www.microsoft.com/technet/traincert/virtuallab/default.mspx

GOOD LUCK!

by zbatia

Sorry, bud, it sounds like an advertisement even if you "didn't mean".
In fact, there are many companies that offer CDs or DVDs with lectures/labs for about any topic in IT area:
-AppDev
-Career Academy
-CBT Direct
-CBT Nuggets
-CBT Planet
-CBT Vision
-Cisco Press
-Global Knowledge
-IPexpert
-LearnKey
-Logical Security
-MeasureUp
-Microsoft Press
-SkillSoft (Books24x7)
-Transcender
-Tech Train
-Vigilar

One thing that I agree with Scott is that @home training with a good product is the best choice if you can dedicate your time to the training and not being distracted by anything.

I personally, use the products from Career Academy and Logical Security (www.rtek2000.com/Online-Video-training.html) (discounted) but you may look at the other products and compare.

by it cowgirl

Even if you take a course/class, there is a large degree of self learning to know and understand the material sufficient to not only pass the exam, but actually perform the job duties which one learns from the exam. I have used Learn Key and found those excellent, as well as the Exam Cram/Cram Master series from Exam Force.

Also agree that a home lab or Sim Lab for hands on experience too.

by bbell

I am also a strong proponent of the VM/Self Learning approach. Training classes are good when you are just getting started, but you will find that a large number of the instructors just teach the material and have little hands-on experience.

A good book or training video and a PC with plenty of RAM should get you moving in the right direction.

My preference is a Mac or 64-bit windows with VMWare Player (Free). VMWare has A TON of pre-built virtual machines that are available to download free of charge. There are even 30-day trial copies of MS products if that's your fancy.

The Mac or 64-bit Windows is suggested because you will not run into the memory limitations that come with a 32-bit OS.

If I pay for 4GB of RAM, I want to be able to use the entire 4GB!

by unhappyuser

It can be a hit or a miss with these companies. One company that we've used a lot tries to use their instructors not only in the classroom but also out in the field. This gives the instructors a better understanding of issues that people may have. In classes where the instructor reads the book and teaches you what they've read I've gotten less out of that class. In classes where the instructors have book knowledge and have worked in the trenches, they can grasp the course much better and are able to provide a better learning atmosphere for their students.

Not a lot of companies do this and you may not have the luxury of driving 100+ miles, one way, every day for a week. Some people can set up their own labs and learn while others do better in a more structured environment. You need to find out what is best for you and follow that path. It may be a little of both or something that you haven't thought of yet. Asking here is a good start and I hope you find what you're looking for.

by aaronbutler

I've had mixed results with training as well. I've attended a few one and two day "seminars" that were quite useful introductions to a given subject. In each case, I took a look at the presenters ahead of time and made sure that they weren't simply salesmen working for the companies with related products. There's nothing wrong with seminars that have a few of the vendors there as well for you to gather more info, but if it's just a sales pitch, it's almost a complete waste of time, and CERTAINLY nothing I want to PAY for!

That said, my favorite training by far have been from a company called Learning Tree International. They offer excellent 4 and 5 day courses which really delve into the subject matter, are all hands-on, and are taught by instructors who have a lot of real world experience AND have always been at least satisfactory teachers, and often excellent teachers. The class sizes are small and the instructors available for questions between class times. They don't have any official relationship with Microsoft or any other vendor, so they honestly relate the good AND bad of any product.

Let's face it, if you're taking a 5 day course on Exchange and you or your company are spending a few thousand on the course, you have obviously all ready decided to USE Exchange. You don't need a sales pitch - you need the honest truth of what does and doesn't work so you can go back and run a solid reliable Exchange organization! And that's what I've always gotten from Learning Tree.

by dpurwin

I agree with what aaron.bulter was saying about Learning Tree International. It is one of the two training providers that my company uses. The other, which I totally found to be worth every penny (Especially since my company paid) was Global Knowledge. The Cisco course that I took through them cost $3000 for 4 days, but WOW! Subnetting is so easy now, and I amaze older more experienced Network Engineers when I don't use a subnetting calculator.

Pros: Great training regimen.
Cons: Very expensive.

by locolobo

International Learning Tree, Global Knowledge cost more than I can afford. The other question I have had about them is how well can you learn a subject when it is crammed into your head in 3-5 days? I have a tendency to forget things unless they've been drilled into my head. After reading some of the comments here I may rethink that.

What I have done is taken courses at the local community colleges near by. The material is presented over 8-16 weeks usually so you have time to digest previous material as you move along. There also options to take some courses at your own pace. The cost is affordable if your employer isn't paying.

The quality does vary a lot. You'll see teachers that are great. You'll see teachers that stink. But if you apply yourself, you can at least get an intro to the subject.

by aaronbutler

I certainly understand LocoLobo's point about how much you can learn when it's crammed in over 3-5 days. My experience with it is this:

Have a lab set up at work. If you're going to take a course on Exchange 2003, have a lab (virtual or otherwise) set up with an AD and Exchange. Unless it's all ready set up in your production environment of course. THEN go take the course. Learning Tree gives you a great set of course notes, a hands-on exercise book (most of which you go through in class) and of course you have your own notes that you take as you go along. I suspect that Global Knowledge probably does something similar, though I haven't been there myself. The 4-5 days in the class is the BEGINNING of your learning. Be on time for each session, be awake (coffee in hand) and make notes of any questions you have as you go along. Then ask the questions during breaks. After the course is done and you're back in the office, go over your notes, do the exercises more in your environment there and really cement the knowledge. Most of the instructors I've had at Learning Tree also give you their e-mail address, so if you have questions as you go back through things, or find something you didn't understand, you can contact them. IF you can practice what you learned as soon as you get back, you'll end up with a huge gain in skills and knowledge from one course. If you can't practice it, and you aren't installing that software for another 6 months, you'll lose a lot. So finding the right training provider is half of the equation, taking the course at the right time is the other half.

by locolobo

Now that I think of it I have had 5 day training courses before(not IT). And your right, they worked best when I could come back to work, sit down if front of the instrument or equipment, and practice what I learned.

But the other times when I got back to work and had to jump right on something else for a few weeks, didn't work out so well.

by thetrainingbuzz

Hi Just wanted to follow up on your article about great IT Training Companies, I've worked for a few large IT Training companies for about 11 years in total now and wanted to give you a little bit of a heads up. I am in the process of starting up a Website called www.thetrainingbuzz.co.uk, I have built good relationships with what I feel are the best IT Training providers and I built up a large selection our training courses which we are reselling for the most highly reviewed providers. I would say remember you only get what you pay for, our training might be a little pricier than your average online course but your get the best tutor's in the UK.

Let me know your comments and if I can help in anyway just email or go to my website

Have a great day guys

Kraig Godden

by mikemagarelli

I've attended a bunch of trainings @ New Horizons and I will NEVER go back to them. A coworker recomended a company called CED Solutions to me and my experience with them has been nothing short of fantastic. They are inexpensive, a pleasure to deal with, the instructors are knowledgeable, they feed you, they put you up in a hotel, etc, etc, etc. I will definitely be returning to CED for any training I recieve.

This discussion is closed to new replies.