First, let me provide a little context. I have never heard of Joskos and the James Thornton Group; nor could I find anything about the referenced debate.
I do not present courses leading to vendor product certifications; and I have no relationships with any said vendors.
I am an instructor of courses on requirements, quality and testing, software acquisition and outsourcing, project management, metrics, and process improvement.
I present training directly for clients through my own company and in public and in-house settings for several well-known companies that are in the business of presenting training. I am a published book and articles author and frequent featured speaker at leading conferences.
Oh, yes, and I've also done a whole of lot real work too, from the most technical systems programming through business requirements and management roles.
Now, let me share a somewhat different perspective from the other end of the classroom.
As someone who does have content knowledge, as opposed to the typical class attendee who by definition is attending because they don't have such knowledge, I have observed speakers and teachers whom I feel are presenting negligible (and sometimes downright incorrect) content. Yes, it happens; but what I find more appalling is how frequently the attendees don't recognize the presenter's content paucity and actually give them high evaluation scores.
Sadly, too, attendees often fail to appreciate presenters who provide keen insights rather than merely rehashing the same old same old.
Attendee perceptions can reflect many factors besides content. For instance, a number of years ago, I found my own course evaluations went down when I stopped showing Dilbert cartoons, after I became aware that doing so violated Scott Adams' copyright.
I have no idea what the facts were that Urban Pauper was reacting to, but I suspect there may be at least one other side to the story.
Regardless, characterizing it as an honesty issue and then implying that all training companies are dishonest seem grossly unfair and unsupportably judgmental overgeneralizations.