Discussion Locked

Groupwise or Exchange

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello!

I'm looking for some advice and opinions.

I currently look after a Netware 5 LAN for about 130 users. We are hoping to implement a new groupware solution within the next 9 months. However I am not sure whether I should pursue Groupwise or Exchange. All of our desktops currently run Windows95, Office 97, Pegasus mail for email and CaLANdar by the Learning Company for scheduling.

In the past I would have opted to go for Groupwise without thinking about it but after attending recent Microsoft Technet seminars and seeing Windows 2000 Server and Outlook 2000 I now fear for the future of Netware, Groupwise and maybe even Novell. I am not saying that Windows 2000 Server and Outlokk 2000 are better products than Netware 5.1 and Groupwise but it is only a matter of time before Microsoft get it right and I have a strong feeling they will do that within the next five years.

The introduction of a groupware product can mean introducing a whole new working culture to an organisation. I fear that if I

15 replies

by budnelson

If you can ignore Microsoft's legendary security holes (even in W2K), both products have their plusses and minuses. If you believe the Microsoft hype that Novell will not be around in the future than you should art least listen to some Novell hype for balance. Novell has some products that are flat-out the best in the industry - Border Manager , NDS.

by bgeary

After supporting groupwise and exchange, I prefer groupwise as an out-of-the-box platform.

I think that exchange and outlook are easier for developing applications that tie into your e-mail system (i.e things like a help desk request form).

Ifyou are already using NDS, then the groupwise move is even easier. As for Novell going away, I wouldn't worry about that for a few more years. Microsoft has to take Active Directory to platforms beyond Windows 2000 to even begin to threaten NDS. While it could happen within a few years, I don't think it will go away before then.

by bmedcalf

I have done just about any combination that you can think of and I have found that it is usually eaiser to use the mail platform that matches you network IE: Novell network then GroupWise and NT then Exchange. There always seems to be that gray areawhen you cross platform about where the user gets their rights from,their user name or some other minor issue. In keeping with in one platform there is no question who is incharge. But If you go cross platform do your homework before you start thereare lots of widgets out there to help you in the migration.

by joelpbanks

I live in a GW 5.2 world... we are seriously considering scraping Netware (a ton of servers throughout the world) and Exchange. Primarily due to a number of unusual quircks, such as; one end-user created a new rule that deleted email older than 180days. It populated the rule base for the corporate server and everyone lost their 180+ mail.

by ben low

I agree with bgeary@earthlink.net on the basis if you are on NDS, you can start to deploy GroupWise easily. The main issue here is to look into your REAL needs than the technology hypes. If you are looking for e-mail with the support for scheduling, workflow application and you wish to maintain your administrative control over messaging requirements, I would suggest to stay with GroupWise and Novell.
I do understand the fear of wrong investment but putting all your money on Windows 2000 and Exchange 2000 is not the right move yet. It will take another three to four years before everything is right for Windows 2000 Server deployment. One piece of advice, maintain your investment on NDS if you are looking to migrate to Windows 2000 platform. I hope this is helpful for you.

by ole_ethernets

I work for a government agency, which is part of a total State Network. We use NetWare 5.0, and Groupwise 5.5, with Windows NT clients. We also use Groupwise WebAccess with an Internet Agent, as well as external synchronization to other State AgencyGroupwise Systems. A few months ago, a few other agencies decided to go with Exchange and scrap Groupwise. We kept our Groupwise 5.5. For one thing, the other agency was never able to successfully migrate users old groupwise mail back into the new Exchange system. Then, it was not but a couple of Months later that we started receiving email messages from all over with-in our Groupwise system. The Melissa and Love letter virus hit the Exchange agencies which had scrapped Groupwise, both times. The Virus had no effect on our Groupwise 5.5 system, as we do not even install the MS Outlook/MS script extensions on our NT4.0 desktops.
In addition we have now installed an excellent 3rd party product called BisCom, FaxCom, for a fax server. It snaps into NetWare NDS really well, but does utilize an NT server for the application faxing part. It uses a Groupwise Gateway, which imulates the faxing system into the Groupwise Mail and Clients. It is so simple to set up, and most of all, you are notmonopolized into using one single brand for everything. It is also available for NT networks. At any rate, it is not a Microsoft product. Contrary to popular "marketing" trends and rumors, there are other systems out there.
I find it interesting that even in the event of a virus crisis, Microsoft gains publicity, which in turn makes it more the "in" thing. Our Director is real glad we decided to keep Groupwise and not follow quite yet. As virus's spread and hackers find more and more ways to play with Microsoft products, NetWare may not be out of the woods just yet. Good luck to you! It is never easy trying to decide which way to go.

This discussion is closed to new replies.