Gun Talk
Scummy is looking, and I figured it would be better to discuss here instead of at the end of an existing 300+ discussion. :D
Started here:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=311557&messageID=3105087
After Hours
Scummy is looking, and I figured it would be better to discuss here instead of at the end of an existing 300+ discussion. :D
Started here:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=311557&messageID=3105087
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
Glock is great for carry, because it is so light weight and safety, but not so great at actually using more than the one or two shot in self defense.
Looking at 45's:
Smith had a compact that was VERY nice to shoot, not sure what it is going for these days.
Kimber makes a VERY nice product, and it is what many use in competition shooting. They START around $800 and that price can double pretty quickly.
I guess it really depends on what you are using it for. If just looking for a nice affordable system, Springfield is always a contender. Now that the 1911 patent is open, everyone is putting out a cheap version, though. [b] Note, the 1911 is NOT a recommended carry handgun, because it is NOT as stable unless you don't carry one in the chamber.[/b] It has been known to discharge, even with the hammer NOT pulled back.
I do love my Sig.
However, I have read a few things online about even cops changing to the Springfield XD ACP due to problems with other guns and accidental discharge.
I would need to look around a bit to find it.
by jdclyde
it is an issue with the 1911 design.
If looking to use at the range, I would go price up round first. Many calibers you just can't afford to "plink" with. Advantage 357 so you can shoot the 38s.
by oz_media
It all depends on how scared you are. If you are simply weary of those around you, a glock should be fine...glockenspiel that is.
If not the Ruger SR-556 may be enough if you are really scared of your neighbours and that shifty old lady that's always thumbing through coupons at Safeway. (Why does HER cart always have 4 good wheels, huh?)
If you fear drive by's and have to hide below window level at home in order to feel safe or if you are being kept down by the man and need to pop a cap in the po-po, maybe an RPG would fit the bill.
I havent had any cause of worry or concern here. The knives and sh!t is from habit, and decor.
The guns are for recreation -- although 2 neighbors that saw me with the gun case spoke to me recently. Both say that they will run over to see me if one is needed :D
So now I am doing community service as well :D
Hmm, now how to get them to pay me for it ?:|
by jdclyde
by puppybreath
by jdclyde
Just read your Bio. Don't forget to add "Redistribute my work ETHIC not my income".
:D
by jdclyde
or is that browneye? :0
'plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink' reload
'plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink' reload
'plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink''plink' reload
by jdclyde
it is not nearly as satisfying to shoot. I would rather shoot 50 shots from a 38 than 500 from a 22.
Also, with the 22, people tend to start just pulling the trigger quickly (out of boredom) and are actually practicing shooting poorly.
the only rapid fire that I can do is with a .22
+ the kids can shoot it -- if their mother allows it at least.
Sometimes, I just wanna rapid fire, that was the main choice behind this gun (and it was cheap). Now I gotta find a clip that will hold 50 rounds, instead of only the 10 that I find around here :(
That is what prompted the vegas show, well along with other reasons.
yeah, it is weak, I have shot .22's several times before. Only good for a few minutes and a quick urge to just open up.
by ontheropes
by jdclyde
and you get get them in normal or target loads.
by jamesrl
look it over.
by jdclyde
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
by seanferd
that is impressive.
However, I dont like the feel of the glock when shooting it.
by jdclyde
had the model 27, (.40 cal)
First shot was fine.
Double tap, second shot was about three inches high.
Triple tap, third shot was about a foot high.
I traded it in, and got my Sig P239 (.357)
http://www.remtek.com/arms/sig/model/239/239.htm
I love it.
by apotheon
I had no idea there was a firearms discussion here until I noticed this incoming link to my off-TR personal Weblog. You've come dangerously close to taking my name in vain.
. . . but seriously, thanks for the link. Otherwise, I wouldn't have known this discussion was going on.
by tink!
sometime soon. LOL. (Can't let you guys have all the fun!) My hubby bought mine for me for Mother's Day. Whee! It's a Bersa Thunder 380 semi-auto.
We can't carry, but it's nice to have in the house for protection. He wanted me to get a .38 revolver, but I just didn't like the look or feel of those. The Bersa fits nicely in my hand.
Have fun with whichever one you choose Scummy!
by jdclyde
I have a few compound bows with some nice cutter heads at various places in my house, as well as a golf club in every room.
The firearms have always been locked up. Didn't want to take the chance with young boys in the house. Been looking at the bed safes to keep my SIG in though.
The way the state is getting worse and worse, so is the neighborhood. What was a nice quiet neighborhood a few years back, thanks to foreclosures, several families of lowlifes have moved into the area. They prove that while "All men are created equal", so have clearly not lived up to their potential.
Edit to add: as for personal protection, I am still a big fan of the wheel guns. In that life and death situation there is less that CAN go wrong.
"When seconds count, cops are only minutes away."
by w2ktechman
from swords to daggers to axes to box cutters. I can get to a blade in 3 seconds if need be from anywhere inside.
The guns keep locked. For now.
I dont need to worry about kids yet -- however I have had kids there several times (supervised mostly) but who knows in the future.
by tink!
but I'm REALLY rusty atm. I finally got some new arrows, but I still can't shoot consistently straight!
The guns are all tucked away in closets. I have a knife in the headboard for quick access.
These people haven't jumped all over you about this.
"This is the on-button?"
by jdclyde
That Tammy mentioned this in the community newsletter last night.
Maybe that is what kept the "what does this have to do with Tech" people at bay?
by apotheon
The Bersa is basically a low-price knock-off of the Walther PPK. It's a good design (and it happens to be the traditional James Bond gun).
I have a Kel-Tec P32 (.32 ACP) -- which I use as my summer CCW -- and a Glock 22 (.40 S&W) for my handgun collection at the moment. My SigO has a Walther P22 (.22 LR). They're all pretty good.
Later today, it looks like we're taking the P22 and my new Ruger 10/22 (.22 LR semi-auto rifle) out for some plinking. This weekend -- probably Friday, actually -- I'm getting together with a bunch of friends for some Independence Day weekend shooting. I expect my 10/22 and her P22 to get a serious workout that day.
Yes, you need to go shooting. You've got a lot of catching up to do. Ahem.
I just like to see good people do more shooting and exercise their rights to own and use the tools of self-defense, really. I think it makes the world a better place.
by jdclyde
yeah, you just need to play sometimes. By bud and I each have ruger Mark II's. We tried the two handed shooting. Instead of twice the damage, you end up hitting the target half as much because of the way your eyes focus.
We would then get tricky and start shooting thumb tacks at 20 feet.
I shot in the 22 league for a year, took first in my division. B-) Second division down, the first division was all the people that had made their own pistols.
From scratch? Lockwork, rifling -- even the itty-bitty #6 screws?
by jdclyde
first, in PPC competition, they are almost ALWAYS wheel guns. Semi's are used in the defensive competitions where speed is more important than accuracy.
They buy bulk barrel, that makes a "Bull" barrel look small. (they buy it with whatever twist ratio they want).
They then take a pistol, often a smith, and use that for the base. Springs/pins replaced/manufactured/modified themselves.
As the bullet only needs to travel 50 feet and go through a piece of paper, they also custom make their own rounds, that are specific to each pistol. depending on the brand of powder used, amount of powder used, and what lead round is used, they get amazingly accurate.
When you score their targets, the center is knocked out. You count the 9's you can see, and everything else is assumed to be a 10. Many of them will average 99%, while shooting all stock, I average about a 93%.
30 shots per target gives a possible 300 points. Four targets a night, for 15 weeks.
4 x 300 x 15 / actual total score gives you your percentage.
Going into the last round I knew I was not a match for the top division, so I calculated what I needed to lower my average from 93% to 90.9% which takes me from the bottom of the first to the top of the second. B-)
Needed 378 points out of 1200 possible, so I went in and got that on the first target and a half, and put the rest of the rounds in the head (zero points). One first place trophy, thankyouverymuch! :D
by lizzie_b
but I have known several officers who carried them as a matter of personal preference.
In the 25+ years I've been involved with firearms, including six years in the business, I've never seen a *verified* report of an unintentional discharge involving an *undamaged* 1911 that didn't involve a finger on the trigger. If information has come to light that I've missed, I would love to know about it. I've seen lots of unverified, third-hand and "I read it somewhere" and "everybody knows" reports, but nothing that could be confirmed.
You finally working, not knocking over 7-11s with what you know?
The worser it gets, the more I review plans.
Starbucks has fewer cameras
by lizzie_b
the only thing the 7-11s have to fear is if I get into management. I can run any business into the ground.
Yes, I'm employed. It even involves having intelligence, experience and insight and I'm working with computers instead of calling people up at random during their dinner and asking them questions about their detergent and which commercials they like.
It's part-time, but it will cover expenses. There will not be any money for games, toys and hobbies - not until I'm out of debt.
It's temporary, but if I'm careful I'll be out of debt well before the appointment ends. At which time, I'll have enough current quarters in with SSA that I can apply for permanent disability.
If I do my job well enough, I may be able to get a second one-year appointment. That would be very good, since it's likely to take three years, a lawyer and two hearings before a judge to get the disability assessment.
It's not so much money that I will lose my qualification for the patient assistance program that provides my gabapentin - which would otherwise be costing me over $2000 per month and without which I can't work. Or drive. Or walk. Or stand. Or sit. The gabapentin is relieving the neuropathic pain well enough that I will certainly be able to reduce the amount of morphine I have to take and may be able to eliminate it entirely.
It's a telecommuting job, so I don't have the extremely disabling task of driving to and from work. That feature of the job also means much lower gasoline and auto maintenance expenses.
It also came with a very broad, far-reaching NDA, so I don't have to talk about my work at parties.
In other words, it's about the best deal I could have asked for. It came through in time; I'm enjoying the work, which is sometimes very challenging; it's enough money to live on without losing what few benefits poverty has granted me and it has self-directed, extremely flexible requirements for work time - which means I can go out back and make holes whenever I feel the need.
I feel beyond lucky; I feel as though I've been blessed.
It's gonna get worser before it gets betterer. This is an excellent time to have plans, most particularly intelligent, well-considered plans with resources supporting them. It's a bit late to start making plans, however. We has met the enemy and he are winning.
by jdclyde
but the potential for it came from a smith that I know and trust unconditionally on all matters of firearms. I would not poo poo anyone for carrying one, but his word is good enough for me.
As a carry firearm, I would ALWAYS opt for a wheel gun. Most likely a 5 shot .357.
None of my current firearms were purchased for personal protection.
"In the business". Security?
Do you have a 1911?
by lizzie_b
There has been a lot of disagreement on this issue among owners, dealers, smiths, manufacturers and "The Experts".
There's a common belief in the industry that handguns where the safety doesn't lock or block the firing pin are inherently more prone to unintentional discharges. The theory goes that if the handgun is dropped or is hit hard enough, the firing pin may be driven forward into the primer of the chambered cartridge, causing it to fire. The other thought is that if the handgun is "condition one" - round in the chamber, hammer cocked - and is dropped so it strikes the hammer, it can force the hammer off the sear, causing the gun to fire. The 1911 design was/is believed to be particularly susceptible to this.
The first scenario is very unlikely - the amount of energy needed to overcome the resistance of the firing pin spring and still strike the primer with enough force to compress the cup against the anvil is fairly high compared to the amount of energy you can actually impart to the firing pin by an indirect strike.
As for the second, I read the results of a series of tests (I'm sorry, I've forgotten who conducted them and in which magazine the results were published) where 1911s were cocked and dropped from increasing heights onto a concrete floor, in an attempt to find out how susceptible they were to a discharge due to sear release. IIRC, they were able to get the sear to release infrequently at drop heights between 30 and 35 feet - but it took a lot of tweaking to get the gun to fall from that height and hit in just the right spot.
Their conclusion was that the sensitivity of the 1911 to unintentional discharge was a myth.
Having said that, I consider that firearms that lock or block the firing pin are much safer as defense or carry arms. You really do want as much margin on the side of safety as you can get, period. One of the most important considerations in choosing a firearm for defense/carry is that you be comfortable with the weapon. That includes being confident that the firearm is as safe as possible - to shoot, to carry, to handle and to store.
I've never worked in security - except for that of my family and myself. I was a licensed dealer with a small retail store. I carried openly, at the request of the local police - 4" S&W in .357. I've carried other handguns, but settled on the wheelgun - it seemed to combine the best compromise among safety, accuracy and stopping power.
I sold a few 1911s but I never owned one myself. They're a great design with a noble history. But I personally think there are better choices for a carry gun.
Hmmm. The server is down for a couple of days for maintenance. I should go out back and make some holes. Somewhere between .355" and .360" in diameter, I think...
by jdclyde
Wonder if Soni would allow us to start a knife collection gallery?
And yes, one of the bows is right by my bed. Break in at night, and you will not be telling your friends about it tomorrow. So much worse than a bullet, just doesn't have the range.
by jdclyde
between buying the bow, getting it setup for you, and then getting fitted for arrows.
If you are lucky, you can pick up something used, but you would still need to get it setup and then arrows to your draw length.
Been taking my boys bow hunting for the last few years.
got several compound bows, but still like my old recurve best. the compounds are around the house, because you can't leave the recurve strug.
Was the difference between 7.62X51, a broadhead, and a five-gallon bucket of wet, cold sand.
One got it warm to the hand, but didn't make it through. The other left it cold, but came out the other side.
by ontheropes
1.5 seconds in 21 feet was only the average time in the instances I took part.
That means you get filleted sooner, too.
by jdclyde
police chiefs special? one of these snubbies?
http://www.snubnose.info/docs/Model_36.htm
http://www.thegunzone.com/sw36.html
nice.
Knives. Do you make them?
by ontheropes
You have to be within three feet of it to see it.
I've made knives before but don't have any of them left. My first one I shaped with a bench grinder and a bastard-file. I'd rather buy now. A great place to shop: http://www.ltspecpro.com/
I've got a lot of their stuff.
if someone puts a gun to your head at close range, you can move and out of the way and go after them before they can pull the trigger.
If you are the fight back type that is
Before you (speculate) about it.
Better, certify to teach how before you get your scrotum blown away.
by ontheropes
by jdclyde
the arrow has much greater mass, delivering much greater impact.
Never did the direct comparison myself but have read about it.
I HAVE done crude ballistic tests with the .357 though, that was cool. Box, lined with a trash bag, filled with newspapers stood on end, and then water was added. Interesting to see which rounds would penetrate further and the shape of the round. FMJ's go a lot further in, but do very little damage.
Hydroshocks and golden sabers are favs of mine.
by oz_media
but she didnt take the bait
was hoping for a BJ
but no, didnt go for it
by ontheropes
by boxfiddler Hot topic
so it is retained in memory
For all 360 spherical degrees?
I always managed to get shot half the time while I pulled off a requisite "move".
That's about your chances -- maybe half. Otherwise, accept that the first duty of a warrior is to accept his own death.
Try, for instance, sitting down in a chair, the muzzle to the back of your head. You dead, dude.
by ontheropes
by jdclyde
aren't we?
And yes, I am sure my boys like camping so much because they were conceived on a picnic table while camping.
All the while, you were instead on the receiving end at a lonely truckstop somewhere, huh? :D
by jdclyde
he does get shot in the head more than 50% of the time, but that is just another Saturday night at the truckstop, huh?
Another day, another dollar? :0
but please, for the last time -- stop including me in them!
You are a sic puppy, sic, sic, sic
by ontheropes
by oz_media
While there are many inert ones for sale online, low auction bids too, Syrians have tanks you can buy oline too,
You best bet for a great deal is to visit Iraq. They have guys that will give you one for free if you blow up an American tank. WHat the hell, you've got lots of tanks...and Americans, what's 4 when you consider the amount of fun it would be to fire one down the middle of a bust street?
Or yuo can just play Duke Nukem and forget all about these wars people have around teh world, and save all that money. In fact the US government should have just bought all the gun hungry Yankees a free copy to play instead of sending them off ot war, I know you need to cull the hedr from time to time but isn't an electric probe just a bit cheaper and more humane?
by jdclyde
by oz_media
I don't know how many times I've felt like that, "Just get the f out of my way, I have things to do and you are in my way, unnecessarily".
Yup, never stand between a father and his kids.
shoot at a real person just to do it. All us yankees just wait for the day to blow up peoples in other places. We cant wait to get flown to another country to unload our clips and play with heavy explosive materials. After all, we cant do it here, right??
So we gotta go and find another place to slaughter people for our own personal entertainment. And no, Duke Nukem will just not do. There is no recoil or satisfaction in bloody murder when there are no actual bodies laying around.
by jdclyde
in the movie Falling Down.... pretty cool... :D
by oz_media
Sure you can, in fact if EVERY Ddemocrat and EVER republican faced off, you would have a 50% improvement over the country you are in now. No matter who won, at least you'd no longer be so divided amongst yourselves. The Repubs can go die for their liberties while the dems can just hug each other and be happy it's all over, until Canada annexes the US and turns it into a giant provincial park.
there would be a lot of fighjting over which province gets to lay claim to the US,
"We don't want it, YOU take it!"
"NOOOO, YOU take it, I'm not falling for that scam!"
Eventually we'd force French Canadians to take it and fly their flag proudly, over top of their poutine and bagel shops.
"'ere you go, now you can separate, huh?"
"Ah, Tabernac, you didn't say it was the old USA! We don't want dis toilet all the world's weapons are aimed at us now!"
"No doot aboot it! Too bad, eh? Bet you wish you were 'ere now, eh, Jaques?"
by jdclyde
armed dude across the counter. took the pistol and then stomped a mudhole into the punkassbitch.
Was a gas station back in my early 20's. The fourth time he hit us, which is why I didn't just give him the money.
Put a dent in the side of one of the gas pumps with his head. :D
Would be amazed at some of the things that can be done before the reaction time to pull the trigger comes into play.
However, I have never been 'put to the test' in that regard, and would still not want to be. I do think, depending on positioning and if anyone was with me (and where they were) that I would at least try. Maybe get a free gun out of it too :D
by jdclyde
there are people afraid of getting caught that will kill the witness (you) after they get what they want. Has happened many times in the last decade, and becoming more frequent.
I made the choice to not be a victim. Once I took his pistol I could have just eliminated the threat, but beating him was so much more fun. I would bet I at least cracked a few of his ribs from putting the boots to him.
If it would have been my home instead of work, it would have been personal and been a very different outcome.
by jamesrl
You have to judge the individual you are faced with, the distance etc.
When I was doing Kung Fu, we did practise, and there were times even the most adept practitioners were caught out on occasion. The one that often did the trick was the gun in the back that was really a finger, with the actual gun held closer to the waist.
Personally, a few bucks in my wallet isn't worth the risk of getting hurt, but if I thought they meant to kill me anyway, I wouldn't hesitate to kill.
James
James
would assess the situation. First, try to determine if I thought I could do it at least safely enough for not only myself, but others around me. Second, it would depend on the threat at hand and how I perceive it at the moment.
I know in some situations, I would do whatever I could to fight back, in others though, I may just decide not to. However it totally depends on many factors.
by lizzie_b
Given the quantity of armament that the Republicrats already have on hand and the fact that the Demmicans are just starting to stockpile arms - our Neighbors To The North would have to deal with a massively armed, even further than ever right-wing country.
Is that really what you want?
Oh. Just in case. ;-) :-) ;-) :D
It's a joke, people!
by lizzie_b
In the Personal Defense and Gun Safety Class, they told us that a determined person could close and grapple from 30 feet before the average untrained person could fire. Drugs and alcohol change the equation, sometimes drastically.
First rule of a gunfight: be somewhere else if at all possible.
by jamesrl
There are factors though that may change that. Is the weapon already cocked and pointed at your central body mass? Or is it in their pocket/holster/pants? Whats the lighting like, or the ambient noise?
The scenarios we practised were within 10 feet, but the person with the gun was ready, gun out and eyes on us. If the person was very close, it was easier to disarm them, at 10 feet they have time to react if they are already in an alert mode.
James
by jamesrl
...thirty years ago. They limit the amount of cash available by having a time lock safe to deposit excess large bills, and to get rolls of change or small bills. They limit the amount of cash in the register.
They now have lots of cameras. And they train their staff to be observant.
But then, and probably still now, they had a policy of submission - if someone robs the store, the cashier risks being fired if they resist.
I would say between the cameras, the trained staff and the little money, they try real hard to make it unattractive for robbers.
James
be more interested in finding an alternative out than rushing the person.
However, if the gun was within a few feet, I would surely try something to gain control of it.
by shasca
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
I was not intending to be overly defensive. I did some browsing and found I could not find quickly via google anything to back up the belief, so I explained where I got the information from. Was not buddies BSing over beer on a friday night.
As for your statement [i]"it seemed to combine the best compromise among safety, accuracy and stopping power."[/i].
Other than the 4" barrel, where is the compromise?
A revolver has less parts, so less chance of failure.
A revolver, if there is a misfire, only requires pulling the trigger again.
A revolver is simpler, so in an emergency situation is less apt to run into operational issues.
A .357 will give a serious attitude adjustment to anyone stupid enough to require such.
I have been looking at the .357 revolvers, as well as getting my CCW, and see it happening soon.
by apotheon
If it comes out the other side, you have to worry more about what's behind the guy attacking you. Trillions of dollars at least have been spent trying to design ammunition that enters a target, dumps all of its energy within the target, and doesn't come out the other side.
The whole reason for a hollowpoint round is to dump energy more quickly and efficiently, rather than just go through a target and leave a smaller hole. The more engery gets dumped while the bullet is still in the target, the more damage it actually does to the target.
Of course, having a pole through one's body should really give one pause, regardless of how much hydrostatic shock has or has not occurred within the body.
by apotheon
I do think "quiet". I think that government restrictions on safety devices like sound suppressors are among the stupidest examples of legislation I've ever encountered, and considering the stupidity of most legislation, that's really saying something.
I'm waiting for all these state firearms sovereignty laws to come into play. I want the manufacture and sale of suppressors to essentially stop being subject to federal regulation, so that safety equipment is no longer heavily restricted and taxed. I really don't like the idea of saving myself from a violent criminal breaking into my home only to suffer hearing loss because some idiot Congresscritter who thinks a barrel shroud is "the thing that goes up in the back" has seen too many damned movies.
by lizzie_b
I didn't get the impression that you were being defensive at all and I wanted to be sure that you didn't think I was on the attack here. The source you cited is as reliable as any you're likely to find. I wanted to present the information I had, in the hope you would find it at least interesting if not enlightening. There's a lot of differing opinion out there.
As for compromise:
There are a lot of elements that go into the decision as to which firearm to carry for your primary defensive weapon. Ease of handling, accuracy, stopping power, number of rounds, reliability, ease and speed of unholstering, weight, ease of retention, grip comfort and physical fit are all items that figure in to the equation.
For me, I find the 9mm Browning Hi-Power with the Pachmayer grips fits my hand better, seems to have a better balance and is lighter than my Smith & Wesson with the Hogue monogrip. Two points for the Browning. The Hi-Power has 13 rounds, the S&W has 6. Another point for the Browning. I can reload the Hi-Power in 1/4 the time it takes to reload the S&W - one more to the Browning. Snap shooting, I'm a tad better with the Hi-Power and I can double-tap it. One more to the Browning. So that's five points in favor of the Hi-Power.
In theory, there's more to go wrong with a semi-auto than a wheelgun. It has more moving parts. Semi-autos are not really more complex, in my opinion - the timing on a revolver requires more precise manufacturing than an average quality semi-auto needs. I have never, ever - not in 25,000 rounds through the Hi-Power - had a mechanical failure or jam with factory ammunition. I have had occasional problems with handloads and commercial reloads, but never with new factory rounds.
I have had factory rounds jam revolvers - but not the S&W. Once the hand and its ratchet, along with the cylinder stop, start to wear, a full-power round can cause an indexing failure. I don't fully understand the mechanism of the jam, but it's happened to me several times with older wheelguns. I also had a customer come in with a Ruger .357 that had a jammed cylinder - the result of an overpowered handload he got from a friend. Trying to free up the cylinder on a jammed, loaded .357 is a bit of a tricky job.
I think the two come out about even here. Things can go wrong with either a semi-auto or a revolver. In both types, it can be prevented by proper maintenance and the use of good ammunition.
Back to the comparison and contrast:
The safety on my Hi-Power is damaged and unreliable. That means no Condition One or Two, ever. Four points to the S&W. Sure, Hi-Power has more rounds - but there's no comparison between the 9mm parabellum and the .357 Magnum for stopping power - even with Black Talons, which substantially out-performed every other 9mm round I tried. Yes, there are shooters who can be incredibly accurate with the 9mm under high-stress shooting conditions; who have the skill level and nerves to make every shot work for them. They can make effective use of the higher capacity weapons. I can't. I'm not that good. At least one, maybe two more points to the S&W. In a controlled shooting environment, the S&W is demonstrably more accurate than the Hi-Power. Another point to the S&W, even though under stress I'm slightly better with the Browning. So that's five or six points to the S&W.
What's left? Retention. I'm not big. I'm not strong. I'm not heavy. If the baddie grabs the gun barrel, can I keep control of it? If someone goes for the gun in the holster, can they get it?
With the Hogue Monogrip, I was able to keep control of the S&W much more readily than the Hi-Power. A friend of mine who was an FBI agent insisted on testing that with me - he outmassed me by about 60%. I found I had no chance of retaining control of the Browning against someone grabbing it, while with the Hogues on the S&W I could put up quite a struggle - and keep some chance of getting a shot off.
I have a Tex Shoemaker duty holster for the Smith and Wesson. It's got a good retention strap. With the strap snapped, the pistol can not be unholstered by an assailant facing me. They do have a chance if they're attacking from behind. I have no such holster for the Browning.
Those were the deciding factors. I had to have a firearm I could carry safely among customers. I had to have a firearm I had a chance of retaining in a confrontation. I had to have a firearm that could end a confrontation, right now, no question - as long as I did my job right.
The Hi-Power is far and away my favorite handgun. I like it much, much more than the Smith and Wesson. I personally would have preferred to carry the Browning as my primary. But in the face of a serious analysis, I had to go with the revolver.
When customers came in looking for advice on a defensive handgun, my primary recommendation was always to get a .357 and practice, practice, practice with it regularly. If the recoil is too powerful, use .38, .38+P and .38+P+ until you can cope with the full-power cartridge. I've seen a woman 5' tall and weighing 110 pounds (my mother) handle a 4" .357 comfortably. You don't have to be big and strong; you have to be taught.
Sorry. I talk too much...
by lizzie_b
Keep it up. I get horny when you talk like that.
Why, JD is probably thrashing on the floor about now.
Sort by Trending