Discussion Locked

Has anyone sold their inactive Windows licenses back to MS? Windows tax

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Was talking with one of my senior techs yesterday and he recently picked up a notebook that came bundled with Win7. He uses 'nix for the tasks it was needed for so he SOLD the preinstalled license back to Acer. As some may already know, they will buy back a licence if the computer is not booted and the EULA hasn't been accepted, an inactive license. usually only about $40-$50 but it's something. I had heard of this about 4 years ago but never really knew anyone who had done it, apparently they still do though.

I think that if it was common knowledge, it would flip a lot of common complaints upside down. People always complain they can't get the OS they want, preinstalled in a new machine, this would allow them to sell it back before activating, and they could then go ahead and wipe it and replace with whatever they want.

20 replies

by charliespencer

"People always complain they can't get the OS they want, preinstalled in a new machine, this would allow them to sell it back before activating, and they could then go ahead and wipe it and replace with whatever they want."

That still won't get them the OS they want pre-installed.

And what's with this 'tax' stuff? If people buy cars that come with brand of tires they don't want, nobody refers to a 'Goodyear tax'. Nobody refers to a 'Kellogg's tax' for that lousy toy they didn't ask for.

by aidemzo_adanac

People who complain that they can't buy a box at Future Shop without buying Windows, when they would rather use Linux, CAN. Just sell back the license and add Linux as you wish, you are not FORCED to buy Windows.

As for TAX, that is what the buyback term was deemed by users when it was first brought out.

by charliespencer

Do you mean that all taxes are dumb, or are you referring to a tax on being dumb?

Around here, we call the second one an 'education lottery'. It's a tax on people who don't understand statistics and odds.

by jck

I live in a state. I go work in another state. I have to pay tax on that income locally in that state, even though I did not benefit from the systems which my income pays for there...nor do I get to exercise my right to vote there.

Is that not dumb? Taxation without representation? Thought that was an infringement of my rights as a US citizen.

There are multitudes of others I could bring up, but...it'd take too long.

by jck

I'd rather sell my unused Windows XP Professional x64 CDs on eBay for $110 a piece rather than get $40-50 for them :)

by aidemzo_adanac

Most, if not all, of the retail store boxes come with a preinstalled HD image, no disks,.

Sure, I've bought boxes from a provider who dealt only in business builds that were unavailable at a retail outlet but provided direct from IBM, Compaq/HP, Toshiba etc. and always got a disk but that' snot the norm these days.

by jck

I bought a 10-pack of Microsoft Windows XP x64 Professional CDs with individual keys. $440 including shipping. I could probably sell all 10 for about $1200 now. But, I like XP too much. It's stable, runs what I want, and if I ever need a lot of money I'll sell my Taylor K20CE instead. I use it a lot less.

by aidemzo_adanac

It's a moot point though. The people who whine about a preinstalled OS are usually people who want to use some flavour of 'nix.
To expect a big box retailer to provide a customer's flavour of 'nix is simply insane, who the hell would do that? You can't drag it back to the store for software issues, as it is not supported the same way Windows is either. You have to consider the average home user buying one.

And if it WAS preinstalled with 'nix, which version, which build, from whom? It's going to be a nonstop bitch session about which distro is preinstalled and why, everyone has different reasons for choosing various 'nix distro's.
With MS they just install the latest, with 'nix you install the latest, from whom?

So anyone using 'nix would have NO TROUBLE AT ALL installing it to a brand new box with a blank drive. if it was an issue, they just accept the Windows license and happily click away.

While many complaints are that the OS is Windows preinstalled, there have been just as many asking why they can't just buy a PC from a major retailer with nothing installed and WHY they are forced to pay for the Windows license, well they aren't. Bulk Windows licenses are added for a pittance but the PC manufacturer's themselves will offer some form of rebate if you deny activation and want a clean drive instead.

I thought you'd put that together from my original post so your focus on semantics would be unnecessary.

by charliespencer

I suspect that vendors who offered Linux pre-installed would require retailers to offer the same support options as Window systems. I'm with you on all the other points about which distro.

I don't think I've heard too many people asking for a system with no OS at all. Most of those folks usually build a system from scratch and start with a blank drive.

by deadly ernest

some systems with Linux preinstalled, but they were all either very low end hardware or very high end hardware (mostly server level stuff) and only available via their on-line shop and NOT available at all through any local retail seller.

And there are many non tech people who would love a preloaded Linux or Unix system, but can't buy them at local shops.

by charliespencer

you benefit from the taxes paid by others in your state of residence, where you don't pay any taxes, where your vote affects those who do pay taxes in that state. If you lack representation it's because of your own personal choice. Your rights as a citizen include the right to move.

by jck

Since you seem to know, please tell me what taxes I haven't paid that a citizen is required to pay again?

Just so you know, I've paid every tax in this state (Florida) where I reside that a consumer/homeowner/employee can pay. I even paid "use tax" for items purchased from out of state that required it (because I'm honest).

Here in Florida, I've paid hotel taxes, gas taxes, property tax, millages that fund schools, etc.

So if anything, I paid taxes I shouldn't have to for supporting OTHER people. Millages for schools? I have no children. Why was I forced to pay that for over a decade as a homeowner??

I guess that's part of my rights as a citizen too...to pay for other peoples' responsibilities.

by jck

Dell actually offers Linux as an option on lots of systems. But, you don't see it pushed. Part of their "partnership" with Microsoft. No one wants to upset Ballmer the Hutt.

Most major store chains have sales people who will push what they know. And, that's Windows.

You often have to seek Linux, but it is there if you look at it from several places.

by jck

For the tax year 2012, I paid income taxes for 9 months in the other state. However because I was not resident there at the time of the election, I was not allowed to vote either in person or by mail-in ballot...even though I *was* resident at the time mail-in ballots were allowed.

Hence, I paid income tax in the other state and was not allowed to vote before the election by mail-in.

So, no one in that state paid any tax for me. I did it all myself. And, I was denied the right to vote early even after paying taxes for the majority of the year there.

Make sense now?

by charliespencer

You didn't pay any income tax in your state of residence, yet you voted there. Others in the state paid income tax but had to accept the vote of a non-taxpayer. If the state you work in is taxing you without representation, isn't your home state allowing you representation without taxation?

by jck

I didn't get to vote in Florida. You just assumed I did.

I paid taxes in Florida (both before I moved and after I came back). You just assumed I didn't.

Any more questions?

This discussion is closed to new replies.