I have 29 years experience in IT from the largest to smallest shops. I am currently an assistant director of a 20 person IT shop. I do not have a degree and my certifications are long out of date, the hardware and software they were on are in museums if anywhere.
During that 29 years, I have never been without at least 1 job, never fired, and always asked to stay for more money when I moved on.
Having said that, education is always worth more than what you pay for it. Once you have it, it can't be taken away from you. Jobs are transitory by nature. Even those you create for yourself. Bubbles come and go, and it is the nature of our business to change.
I recently went looking for a CIO to head up our shop. We advertized nationally to get good solid candidates. Everything but that came out of the woodwork.
The number one thing you have to have in business of all kinds, is critical thinking skills. Without them, no certification or degree is worth while. That is why we in industry rely so heavily on experience. If you have demonstrated your competence in anything from help desk to project management, we know you have the needed skills to go with what your resume says you know.
Without sucess being demonstrated, you are a book without a reader. Dead weight. We might take a chance on you if the job you are going for is not very advance, if you are very personable, if our employees recommend you, or if you are related to someone we trust and they speak up for you. So you generally have to start at the bottom, and work you way up, even if you have a degree, or advanced degree.
Having said all of that. When we were looking at candidates, we always valued an MBA over an MS. MS degrees are good for teaching and stepping stones to PhDs. MBA's on the other hand are useful in running departments, divisions, and working with upper management on strategic planning. Our field changes so fast that anything you learn in college will be obsolete before you can make use of it in the real world. But, if you get a BS, and get a job working as help desk, or as a pctech, then go on to get an MBA, you will rise in any organization that is interested in growing. Hopefully, your organization will also have tuition reimbursement so that the company you work for will help pay for the MBA. Certifications are a bit like degrees but are extremely transitory. Who would pay for a certification in "NT Network Admin" now? If you don't keep them up, then they are worthless.
That is the glass floor. We will always take experience over newbies, always take degrees over not having them, and the better the degree or certifications, the more likely you will be to get the job.
The glass wall is a little different. Without any degree I'm really locked into the industry (Defense, Communications, Healthcare, Education) where I have all my experience. Transfering to another sector of the economy would be a little rough. I would likely beat out any of you folks straight out of college, but to land a management role in a major manufacturing job would be tough. And any one with even a BS and a little experience in manufacturing would likely doom my chances.
The glass ceiling is really tough. That is internal as well as external. Several years ago, I was asked to perform some regression analysis on customer satisfaction. I created the processes and did the math (that was pretty deep) and got the results. I took them to the CEO and had to tell him: If you want answers, I can give them to you. If you want the answers certified, you'll have to get a PhD in math to do it. We did. His answers and mine were the same, but his had a PhD behind them.