Discussion Locked

Have I been spammed, scammed, or just conned?

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I receive emails from http://www.arcamax.com with jokes, news in brief and various offers.

Today I took up this offer:

http://registrysmart.com/?hop=arcapub

and downloaded the software: "RegistrySmart."

It scanned various areas of my computer and found 391 problems. So I clicked on "Fix Problems" and received a message that in order to fix the problems I would have to register and pay for the software online.

So I paid for the software -- for three computers -- and the whole price was reasonable.

HOWEVER having once paid for the software, the alleged problems miraculously disappeared and a fresh scan revealed no problems. I do not think all those 391 problems could have been fixed in the twinkling of an eye.

So my question is: could all those problems have actually been fixed in a split second, or was I simply conned?

22 replies

by tony hopkinson

it should have at least taken a back up of your registry. In fact the thing should have an undo.
A good one will also have a registry file of the changes it made.
If it hasn't done either or both of those two things, it's crap anyway, if it has a bit of checking should reveal the differences (if any).

Personally I'm always really wary of that method of generating sales. Too many scammers like it.

by jardinier

it does indeed have a backup with the option to restore from any given backup. I can see from the times that it has apparently made a back-up of each scan I have run, including the initial one.

It shows no problems now so I will leave well-enough alone. Perhaps I will try a scan in a few weeks or so and see if it detects any new errors.

Normally I wouldn't dream of downloading this kind of software, but I have been getting stuff from arcamax.com for a long time without any problems.

A pleasing feature of this program RegistrySmart is that there is only a one-off payment, with live updates which are (hopefully) free.

by tig2

Try CCleaner. It is completely free, has an intuitive GUI, and can be downloaded from www.ccleaner.com.

I have used this tool for a number of years and love it because in addition to registry fix, it will clear out any other thing that is fragmented or a cookie. I install it as a matter of course to any pc I configure.

I have to agree with Tony. The sales approach is somewhat suspect. But proves that even IT folk can be taken in. Hopefully, the tool will provide you with what you need.

by deepsand

widely distributed by a plethora of affilates.

However, it would hardly be my registry tool of 1st choice; I prefer one that gives me more detailed info. re. the "problem," gives more choices as how do deal with each "problem," including my manually editing the Registry, and rates the "problems" re. how safe it is to alter the Registry entries in question.

Registry Smart simply provides a list of "problems," and gives one the choice of doing nothing or trusting it to properly "fix" them. Without it's telling me [i]what[/i] it's going to do, e.g. delete the entry, cut the sub-string, change the entry, etc., I'm not about to give it permission to do anything.

Furthermore, I have a strong dislike for any application that tries to install itself in the Startup Registry entry without asking me for permission; Spy Bot Search & Destroy caught Registry Smart trying to do just that!

Bottom line, Registry Smart is a product for "dummies," with no offense intended.

by jardinier

Message received and understood. There is an uninstall option. Because I am not in front of the particular computer at this moment, I cannot check if it is in Add/Remove programs but will do so later.

I have been hesitant to use any registry fix software and only downloaded RegistrySmart because of my long and happy association with arcamax.com

by jardinier

It was listed in Add/Remove programs and has been removed from my computer except for one shared file. I am always wary about deleting these no-longer-used-by-any-other-application shared files, but would welcome your advice on this.

Thank you.

by deepsand

It's been my experience that well behaved, which of course includes being well designed, un-install programs can be trusted to not mis-represent a needed "shared" file as being unneeded.

In the case of programs in which you have insufficient trust, such that you suspect that their intent is nefarious to the point of perhaps deliberately corrupting your system if you attempt to remove them, by tricking you into removing a needed .dll, you can always try the following:

1) Make a note of the name of the .dll in question;
2) Tell the un-install program to [i]not[/i] remove it; and
3) After the un-install has completed, search your drive(s) for the location(s) of said .dll.

Now, it is important to note that there are, with respect to un-installs, 2 different usages of "remove." One means to delete the file, while the other means to un-register it, i.e. to remove record of it's existence from the Registry Hive. Unfortunately, un-install progams rarely make that distinction in the massages provided you.

If the "removal" that you declined was the latter kind, then no harm has been done; at worst, the Registry now contains as useless entry.

If the "removal" was the former, then you can, at your pleasure, try renaming the physical file, so that it becomes unaccessible to any application that needs it, and watch for undesirable effects. If you observe one or more applications now consistently failing, particularly if they give an explicit error message relating to the file in question, then you need only rename said file to its original name. Again, if the file is in truth not needed, there is no real harm in having it around; the only cost is the disk space that it occupies.

by jardinier

I will do just that.

It is nice to have a product with a proven good record by an IT person.

by deepsand

don't be surprised if, upon using a different Registry tool, it uncovers and removes the entries that you left behind in caution!

by jbpovall

Hi bought this program yesterday and I am trying to get it reversed. The price was quoted as $29, quite far into the buying process After downloading what I thought was a free trial, I then scanned my computer, and YES I also had 391 problems that could be fixed in an instant if I paid $29, I paid $29 dollors and got a receipts for the total $49.85.Not sure where the extra amount came from? The error I really wanted fixing (the keyword to this error led me to registrysmart) was not fixed. I have no proof of the quote of $29 unless I try and download it again, and go the process and wait for it to pop up again (I have tried and it wont work- it knows who I am)
The reply I received to my query urged me to link them to my computer for remote assistance (a cold day in hell!), and download another package (error killer from their member website). Unfortunately not for free only the scam is free. Why pay again for error killer when I have just paid $49 for Registrysmart??

by jardinier

I am always suspicious of registry editing software, but I purchased from worldstart.com a product called "Spring Cleaning." I have just checked and this item is currently available at worldstart.com for $US 12.97 (plus $US 6 for international shipping)

This program restored to full functionality Internet Explorer 6 which had become unusable on two computers running 98 SE.

This website offers specials every Saturday at heavily discounted prices. I notice that you don't live in the USA. However for Americans it is a steal with FREE SHIPPING AND DELIVERY and a 60-day money back guarantee if you are not satisfied with the software for any reason at all.

It is worth signing up for the Saturday specials email. Products are usually considerably less than half normal retail price, and cost for international shipping is just $6 per item.

While it is not feasible for me to return any software I don't like because of the cost of postage, I still come out way ahead if even one third of the programs I order are useful to me.

by jbpovall

Thanks for the tip.
Click Bank have confirmed my payment for Registrysmart will be refunded in full!
Hopefully the refund will show up within 5 working days! So far so good. Great to know mistakes can be rectified!

by shellbot

i know nothing about this kind of stuff..and if you got a great deal..hey cool.

But if security and privacy and everything is so importnant, why do people always try and go for the cheapest option..?

yes go ahead and laugh at me if you want..but last night i purchased my Symantec package which was due to expire form a free trial that came with my lappy.

60 euros..seems to do the trick..updates for the year..now..i would spend 60 euros going for dinner on a friday night, or to the pub for an evening..heck..a pair of shoes sets me back 60 or so..so to me the security of my prescious beautiful lappy is worth 60 euros to me..

its kinda like people moaning to pay to go to the dentist to fix a cavity, but then spend the same amount on drinks the enxt night...

any thoughts?

by jdclyde

The thing that really amazes me are the popup screens that warn that you are infected, so buy their product to clean it.

ummm, no.

I do not, nor should ANYONE, trust a popup screen warning of infections.

Just like I don't buy things from hellimarketers that cold-call me. Sorry.

Nor do I give out information to vendors that want to know what kind of firewall we use. duh.

by skinsman61

as per the site of ccleaner

"I thought the software was free. Why am I being asked to pay?
The software is free. You are paying for the convenience of having all of these programs in a single location, the online help, and live customer support. You will have access to this for the term of your membership.
"
What a Rip OFF!!!!

by chaz15

You do not have to give any donation. Any donation is entirely voluntary, and you can certainly download CCleaner FREE!!

It is an EXCELLENT and HIGHLY RECOMMENDED tool for cleaning up unwanted temporary files many of which also track your computer usage.

by skinsman61

after installing the free download and it scanned, every 30 seconds it kept popping up a message saying my computer registry was severly corrupt in order to fix i had to go to www.registrycleanerxp.com and purchase it Immediately
what a bogus program they should be shut down

by jardinier

I may have posted this before, but here goes anyhow. There was a program called Reg Cure which scanned the computer and found something like 300 problems. But in order to fix the problems I had to pay for it online.

Great -- it "fixed" the problems. But I think perhaps the vendor was not counting on me doing another scan immediately afterwards. I forget the figures now, but after finding and fixing say 300 problems, it found about 150 new problems (these figures are only approximations but you will get the general drift).

So it "fixed" those problems and I scanned again and a whole new bunch of problems were found. I had an email exchange with the software manufacturer which resulted in a refund of my money.

I think the program was completely bogus. I don't think it scanned anything at all but was programmed to "find" problems [i.e. create a completely fictitious report] in various categories.

Eventually I acquired a registry cleaner that actually works. It is "Spring Cleaning" by Allune Systems. It works on Windows and Mac (although I haven't yet tried it on Mac)

by chaz15

1. It adds ITSELF without your permission to the registry startup files. Even if you delete it from startup, it keeps adding itself to startup.
2. it Autoruns at frequent intervals.
3. It seems to generate a large number of FALSE positives at regular intervals even when registered.
4. It seems to fix all these problems INSTANTLY, very suspicious.
5. It may make SOME genuine repairs so may have SOME benefit. It is a shame about the other problems that detract from what could be a very good program!!!!

by enform1

Got RegistrySmart ~ a year ago. Has worked OK. Now however, it's saying it's time to renew and send more money! Don't recall anything about it being a subscription based program when we bought it, however it was awhile ago. On checking their site, don't see anything about this "fact" now and nothing about its purchase price. Went to a number of other Reg cleaner sites and found the same thing - Download a trial - Get a free scan, but no pricing! Why is that? I feel that if they won't tell you the price up front, it's a sign that you should be leery of their product. Not sure why I bought RegistrySmart in the first place, but think we were having a registry problem then and RS fixed it. So product may be legit, but their (and other Reg cleaner companies') marketing practices are questionable.

This discussion is closed to new replies.