Discussion Locked

Have you tried any of the Windows Vista betas?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A new TechRepublic poll asks, "Have you tried any of the beta versions of Windows Vista?

Yes, I have installed it and used it
No, but I plan to try it before Vista is released
No, and I have no plans to try it"

Have you tried any of the Vista betas, and if so what is your impression of the next version of Windows?

18 replies

by pdickey043

Hi there,
I've been in the managed beta for Vista since November 2005. In the beginning, I would install it play with it for a few hours, then go back to my XP drive. But ever since about build 5308 or 5342, I've been running Vista as my day-to-day Operating System.
Aside from the usual Program incompatibilities that you should expect, and some of the hardware incompatibilities, it's a decent OS. If you use Virtual CD/DVD Drives (Daemon Tools, Alcohol 120%, etc) then right now it's not for you. They don't work properly (if at all) in Vista. And your older hardware may or may not work on Vista.
Ultimately, I'll end up back on XP for a while after Vista RTM's. But at the earliest that I can, I'll be buying a copy (or getting it through a MSDN subscription).
Patrick.

by michael l hereid sr

Having been on the beta team since July of 2005-it has only been since about May that the os has installed all my hardware and since that time Vista has been my main operating system.
With RC1 Vista shows me that by the time it goes RTM will be a fantastic os.
Michael L Hereid Sr

by j.g.camp

Doesn't support Riser Card 56K modem on a SiS735 ECS K7S5A motherboard. Doesn't support a D-Link DWL-520+ wireless card. I have no use for Vista, I don't see any reason why I would pay $ 399 suggested retail price for Vista Ultimate. It was a waste of time to install for me. Thanks God another downloaded the dvd, otherwise I wouldn't have known firsthand how it's marginally an alternative to XP. Eye Candy, XP can be themed with Style XP for a majority of what Vista is about and use far less resources.

I have a question though, you say program and hardware incompatibilities should be expected and that it's decent as an OS. Vista should be at least an XP equivalent in the beta stages in my opinion. 5 years to develop, come on now ? I switched to Ubuntu Linux as my day to day and am happier with it.

by w2ktechman

and I still think that I am fine with XP, and have no plans to switch. I may change my mind in a few years, but after playing with Vista, I have been moving to SUSE Linux. Gotten good at usage, still learning administration

by techsajan

I have installed RC1 built 5600 - its quite impressive and i am very much intrested to use it in future as well - i have to test more but i feel built 5600 is remarkbly improved compared to various other beta release of Vista

by angela.weber

I received the Windows Vista Beta 2 cd and installed it after completely reimaging my pc so I could start with a clean slate. I have since wiped my pc clean again and put Windows XP back on. The newest RC version just arrived in the mail but the packaging has not been touched. I have not determined if my dislike for the new Windows is a result of it still being in beta form or if I just personally dislike the environment all together. All I know is as of right now, I cannot stand Windows Vista.

The requirements alone are unbelievable. All properties and services seem to open in browser-like windows, which open within eachother so you find yourself constantly using the back and forward buttons. New system restore points cannot be created using the System Restore service, rather, one must go to System Properties and use the System Restore tab. All windows dim to allow any newly prompted operation to be accepted by you (which can ultimately be disabled but not as easily as one would think). Internet Explorer 7 does not enable you to right-click on a tab to save it as a favorite (may be small but still annoying). All user folders are renamed to exclude the "My" prefix one has come to expect. The only security software publicly available for the Vista beta is PC-cillin. Hardly any drivers are available or compatible with the Vista environment. If more than a handful of Internet windows and/or tabs are open at one time, the pc goes so slow that ending processes seems to resolve nothing...

I could probably keep going but did not have the beta on my pc long enough to fully experience it all. There are some nice features as well but not enough to make me leave XP anytime soon.

by w2ktechman

Yes, there are a lot of HW that do not work. But some that dont from a clean install, will on an upgrade.
Vista can use many of XP drivers, but in a clean install, they cannot install. In an upgrade, the system installs them fine. I found this out on an HP tc4200 tablet edition, and on a HP/Compaq NC6000.
But I agree, Vista is not worth my time still. And it isnt as much of the things that you mention, it is that everything that MS said is better in Vista, does not seem to be, just harder to find, and more pages in wizards

by angela.weber

I agree completely. However, I was so determined to get Vista working properly (assuming all flaws were my fault) that I switched from XP to Vista multiple times. I generally wipe my pc clean every six months or so, backing up all important data and files, so it wasn't as if I did it all for the Vista upgrade. Anyway... First, I wiped my pc clean and installed the original XP operating system via the restore disks. After all was done, I installed a clean version of Vista (which took two attempts since the graphics card was not reading/installing properly and everything looked as if I was in a Windows 98 safe mode environment). Since I still felt the upgrade was not right, I eventually wiped my pc clean again and this time performed an upgrade from XP to Vista, but only after installing updates and rebooting numerous times. Once all seemed to be as it should, I found myself barely satisfied. I gave it about a week and then decided to go back to XP, which I never thought I'd be so happy to see again. So, there's nothing wrong with Vista, (especially since it is still in the development stage) but there is very little attracting me to it that XP is lacking.

by cap/

I tested Vista RC1 aswell as some of the Betas.
RC1 is more stable and works fine, but for me, This OS isn't worth the time and money yet.
The problems with incompatibility will eventually be fixed, but to get full advantage of the new features, you have to have a fearly new pc with a lot of ram (1G is the minimum to be able to run without to much problems).
Also, i like to have full control over what the OS system does and i miss that in Vista.
I will wait untill the retail version of Vista, some hotfixes and/or service packs are out, and then, i'll give it another try.
The only thing i liked about Vista was the Aero Glass effect, and that was not what i was waiting for, considering the hardware requirements.
For now, i'll stay with my XP and Suse for as long as i can.

by yobtaf

I have nothing against it and I will probably adopt it a year after it
comes out.

by sscgdl

yes, but because it was a clean installation, the windows vista didn't recognize all my hardware. And I can't find any drivers for this operating system.

by jfowler

I loaded the RC1 beta on a spare hard drive - a clean install in other words. There were no problems at all in loading both video & audio drivers for my current hardware (ATI 9700 / Creative X-Fi), but there the ease of use ended. I was unable to install printer drivers (HP 1315), though these kinds of issues will doubtless be less problematical in the final release version.
The "eye candy" is nice, but the newness wears off quickly. It is necessary to spend a LOT of time looking for things that are there, but that have been inexplicably moved (?!?).
My biggest gripe is with "Windows Mail" (Outlook Express by another name), specifically that there appears to be no way to display your contacts list as before, so you're left with a huge empty area at the lower left of the window. (If anybody has a fix for this, I'd LOVE to hear it.)
Obviously we're all going to be using this OS in the relatively near future, and it does have its plusses, security chief among them, but for my money it's far from a finished product at this time.
Bottom line? After spending maybe 4 or 5 hours in Windows Vista, I couldn't wait to get back into XP Pro.

by sean

Indeed I have tried the Vist RC1. I loaded it on a virtual machine (first time doing that) and it seemed to be very pretty - have to give Microsoft the credit for choosing some really cool graphics. Having just built a new computer, nothing fancy I was hoping it would really be able to take advantage of the 64bit OS. Surprise Surprise, the drivers for the sound dont work - or rather are non existant, the graphics card is already out of date for the TV options. Slightly annoying as well is that it wont load Office properly, and in fact has destroyed the whole virtual session to the point where I am going to have to start again.

I am very glad that I did not decide to replace XP with Vista, and am extremely grateful that VMWare as allowed its software to become freeware. All in all, it's fun to play with but don't rely on it yet.

by kiltie

Not only the beta, I will never even use the released product.

Why?

M$ completely lost my trust with WGA, so no go there, I do not trust companies that force users to install spyware and LIE about doing it afterwards.

Vista REQUIRES hardware upgrades in order to use it, that are far too prohibitive in cost. (M$ really should have designed a new OS to be HW independent, and to use the majority of machines now available, not those that will be around further down the road)

Vista is far too costly, M$ have always made this blunder of overpricing their SW, yes - so far they got away with it, but nowadays they are (or SHOULD be) beginning to realise how costly that mistake is, as they try and combat priacy.
I read a story once, that M$ did some market research on what price would be acceptable for the new upcoming Windows 98 system, and the research worked, so everything was geared up to release the OS at the price the market would bear. But Bill Gates overruled it, and 98 went on the market for over double that price. It still sold, dunno why.

So..... what is my solution to Vista?

Obviously, to "shop" elswhere

So I will

by michael l hereid sr

Not in my book-my granddaughters pc only needs a better video card and 256 more memory-total cost was $66-runs pretty good also.

by psmith

I purchased a new Dell laptop in October. I specifically purchased the correct hardware so that it would be Vista compatible. Shortly after I installed the lastest version of the Vista beta. It didn't work well at all. It didn't recognize most of my devices, including my DVD drive. The only think I could do successfully was connect to the internet. Dell had poor support for Vista, and I couldn't get any updated drivers. After strugling with it for two weeks, I ended up wiping my harddrive and reinstalling Windows XP Pro. I hope that the full release version is a lot better, because my experience was very negative.

by dark007

hp dv 6000 it come with vista ...
and it is working like a duck in the nile ...

This discussion is closed to new replies.