Discussion Locked

Heads you win, tails I lose - all based on a false premise

0 helpful
391 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Global warming will destroy the planet. No, on second thought, since the global warming claim has been debunked, it's now climate change. Therefore, when it should be cold, but it gets colder; and when it should be warm, but it gets warmer; then that's proof of man-made climate change. And when it should be warm, but it get colder; and when it should be cold, but it gets warmer; then that's also proof of man-made climate change. In other words, regardless of what happens, it's proof of man-made global warming and/or climate change. Heads you win, tails I lose. How convenient!

And it's all based on the premise that the global temperature and climate patterns are static - even though the history of the globe shows that global temperatures and climate patterns are dynamic.

One word describes the whole issue: Lunacy.

Three words: Lunacy run amok.

Three different words: Lunacy with power.

Two words: Be careful.

Three words: Be VERY careful.

I've said it for years, and I maintain the same position: The notion that human activity is affecting the global temperature and/or climate patterns is the biggest lie perpetrated in the history of mankind. Okay, I'll admit, some of the historical religious claims might come close. But then again, what's the difference?

391 replies

by oz_media

[i]" since the global warming claim has been debunked, it's now climate change"[/i]

They are the same thing. A sales rep is now called an account manager. An old age pensioner is now called a senior citizen. This doesn't mean sales reps were proven false old old age pensioners no longer exist.

[i]"Therefore, when it should be cold, but it gets colder; and when it should be warm, but it gets warmer; then that's proof of man-made climate change."[/i]

According to whom?

[i]"proof of man-made global warming and/or climate change[/i]

Again, who says man MADE climate change?

[i]And it's all based on the premise that the global temperature and climate patterns are static -[/i]

And once again, according to whom?

What kind of right wing rant blog do you find such things mentioned?

Look at any conclusions based on scientific study and I have yet to see any of this mentioned.

What's wrong, that old horse doesn't have enough bullets in it for you yet?

by maxwell edison

..... snow for the Olympics.

Too much or too little, it's all proof of man-made global warming and/or climate change.

P.S. Move it to Colorado. We have plenty of snow! (And it could have happened in 1976.)

by oz_media

Athletes have all said they prefer it soft on Cyress as opposed to a hard pack. The events there, are freestyle and snowboard.

They have made plenty of snow and it will be just fine, of course someone will lose and complain but goes without saying, regardless of snow condistions.

The issue is that Cyrpess itself has little snow on normal runs, which, from a Vancouver viewpoint makes it look bare.

I was up on New Years eve, having drinks and hanging out with a local team (not Olympiads...yet) and there was plenty of snow, with more being made.

As for your reply, I'll just assume, as I did anyway, that there is no such solid proof of your assertions at all, perhaps a few nubags like Gore but nothign substantial.

It's nice to see you around again, even if it was just to flog that same old bag of a mare.

by .martin.

it is always going to be, no matter what we say.

really it is something kept alive by the governments of the world to scare us. :p

by oz_media

despite that fact that the most active scientists agree, and have done all along, that the Earth naturally cools and warms (hasn't anyone even watched the Planet Earth series)the causes of that natural warming and cooling over the Earth;s history are shown to be due to factors that our industrial and private emissions increase.

Thus, it's not a matter of IF, because anyone with half a brain cell know it IS.

It's a matter of us shortening the natural time frame of such evolution. The problem is due to gases and Earth core evolution that we farm for resources and expel at a greater rate than is naturally ocurring.

by deadly ernest

than human industry. Having said that, yes, we should clean up our act to minimise what effect we do have with our industry, but there's no way we can have the sort of significant impact the climate change priests claim.

by deadly ernest

humans do have an effect on the climate, such an effect it comes to two tenths of nothing - and all the money being spent on treating climate change will have even less effect, except on the personal bank accounts of the fraudsters working the scams.

The world has been warming up for over ten thousand years, the evidence is there, yet according to the fraudsters it all started just over two hundred years ago. Just a couple of years after a major volcanic eruption caused wide spread famine because the volcanic cloud it blasted into the upper atmosphere dropped the average temperature around the world by several degrees. And the world has been warming up again since, hmm, sounds about what a natural rebalance would do.

In the last 2,000 years, the seas have retreated, due to water being turned to Arctic and Antarctic ice as the world cooled a bit, yet that's not visible to those who push the human caused climate change religion.

by oz_media

I don't know what 'science' you are referring to but aything I've seen here atributed it to the earliest formations of the Earth itself.

You have to remember, the US is very reluctant to teach science, as it conflict with religion and the US is still a very religious country compared to most others, therefore Americans find such topics incredibly hard to fathom. All they see is one radical politician arguing with another.

With over two dozen US TV channels on my tube, not one focuses on science or Earth's creation and evolution. With cable and satellite becoming more mainstream ,it helps but it still isn't quite there yet.

To Americans, I am not taking a shot at you per se, you don't have any control over your exposure to such things. Just like war news, world news etc., it is simply doled out very carefully to the public audience.

by deadly ernest

started because some one noticed that the old records of weather information around the world showed a slight, but fairly regular rise, starting just over two hundred years ago. They correlated this with the Industrial revolution and said the temperature rise was due solely to man and the industrial revolution. Mind you, they totally missed the fact that regular recording of weather and temperature information at land based weather stations had only just started at the time their source statistics start, and they never tried to correlate it with the many centuries of older weather and temperature information available from maritime logs.

Since the global warming scare has started, some senior climatologists started gathering the older maritime log information into a database and found out that the temperatures today aren't as warm as they were three hundred years back. They started running models and found a significant drop in temps in the early 1800s when a major out of season freeze across the whole or Europe caused widespread famine - they now call the event 'The Year Without Summer.' Further investigation showed a major volcanic eruption in Indonesia several months before that. The modelling of the whole of Earth weather patterns shows that what's likely happened is a huge cloud of volcanic ash went into the upper atmosphere and messed things up real bad for about a year - it took that long to break up fully. The result was a drop in average temperatures of several degrees world wide. Naturally, the world is now returning to what it called normal before that.

None of the people who do the actual studies of world wide climate support the human caused climate change religion, and they have tonnes of evidence to prove it wrong. But the supporters, and all the really big ones get a financial gain out of supporting it, push that all aside as it doesn't suit their belief structure on this issue.

by jackofalltech

Years ago, a magazine (I think it was Scientific American but I'm not sure) published an article with a visual comparison of CO2 producers: Volcanos was a 1" square, all the trees and plants in the world was a square around 1/8" and all humans was just a dot.

Since the entire population of the planet could fit inside Texas, it's ludicrous to think we could have such an impact on the whole planet.

by oz_media

People will jump on board and send tens of thousands of American husbands and wives to die in a war becaus ethey are told that they are facing imminent doom from 'supposed' WMD's.

When science all over the world focuses on a naturally ocurring fact that is being increased by our emissions, they shrug it off. "NO WAY, I am riding a bike or eating locally grown foods!" But that same person will gladly wish their spouse well and watch them go to a foreign war on a whim ?!

Certainly shows a clever and well considered thought pattern.

by oz_media

About as 'simplistic' as one could be.

You only referenced one emission/factor, one that is naturally expelled by a trillion+ different sources.

Your analogy also ignores CO2 naturally expelled through the ocean, Google it if you don't get info on TV. And carbon Monoxide, not dioxide, that does more harn to us daily as we live and sleep, which would also be reduced with a little awareness from people.

What I find ludicous is that people dismiss being envinronmentally aware period, merely because they don't buy the climate change facts. In turn they are ignoring the immediate impacts on their own health.

by oz_media

Warning: Lyrics may be offense to those with a stick up their arse.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJynygnjMC0

Excerpt your post brough to mind.

"It's Saturday afternoon at last, it's what you've waited for all week
Relax and put the feet up, turn the footy on TV
You're expecting Vern and Bluey round, they'll probably stay all night
A coupla mates and a coupla beers - aw, Christ, this is the life

Well, here they are already, you just heard the car door slam
You wedge yourself out of your chair, get up to let 'em in
But it's some wanker that you've never met, with a briefcase in his hand
Some prlck just out of Bible school, who thinks he's God's right hand"

Ahh, Kevin Bloody Wilson, his albums are fantastic.

Halleluiah, Hallelujah, Hallelujah

by Member 25348569

Global Warming refers to the entire planet. I think that the give away is the "Global" bit but I might be overestimating my readership here.

Climate Change refers to the local EFFECT of that global change. The concept was introduced in an attempt to stop those who don't want to do anything about GW to justify their inaction by saying "Hey! it was warmer yesterday."

Just thought I'd clear that one up for you.

:)

by oz_media

Neil, now that's no fair.

As far as global awareness here, your out of luck.

All in all, a pretty clever bunch but sometimes it takes even the clever people two years to realize that you can use an AM radio in the afternoon.

by deadly ernest

Climate Change as the last set of long term records show that the 'deadly and dangerous rising global temperatures' they were scaring people with have dropped in the last ten years and are now lower than when they hit the panic button. Thus, Global Warming, which ISN"T happening any more, is now Climate Change. It seems all those human cause factors that caused the globe to warm up are now causing it to cool down. Hmmm, no wonder the top world climatologists disagree with these people and their Human Cause Climate Change religion.

Yes, humans contribute to the climate and environmental factors, always have, just as the birds and the ants, and the monkeys do. But not enough to have significant effect. That will, of course, change should a nuclear war happen and we get a nuclear winter, but it's got to be about that bad for us to beat out the volcanoes or the oceans or the sun - which are the top three climate change makers.

Hell, the English coast is now some miles inland of where it was when Big Julie landed there about two thousand years ago, the ocean has withdrawn that much, due to increased polar cap ice.

by Member 25348569

You've posted stuff that is so easily verifiable and yet you choose to post no links.

We do agree on one part of what you said and that is the climate-maker is the Sun. It is the only real source of energy for climate and weather. What is is, now we have satellites, is extremely measurable. The oceans - size and position - modify the effect of the Sun's energy.

You demonstrate a willful ignorance that matches the best American Conservative. Volcanoes, even including catastrophic eruptions such as Krakatoa and Pinatubo, have relatively little effect and ALL of that is cooling and ALL of that short-lived. The amount of CO2 put out by all the volcanoes that erupted last year is a fraction of that produced by human activity.

As to your contention that the Earth isn't warming - NASA have released figures showing the decade that has just ended was the warmest on record.

The English coast is, like any other sea coast, mutable by changes in currents, wind patterns and the lifting or sinking of the land. The sea level hasn't changed to the extent that you're implying. Quote your sources, please.

I'm not sure why I bother to post

by jck

I think we'd be better off having a global thermonuclear war right now.

At least then it couldn't be debunked that radiation kills without bias.

by oz_media

They are results of the same effects focused on at different points in time. IN case you are unaware, it is a fact that the Earth has warmed and cooled over many billions of years, so cooling becomes warming, and so on.

In the 1970s there was increasing awareness that estimates of global temperatures showed cooling since 1945.

Of those scientific papers considering climate trends over the 21st century, only 10% inclined towards future cooling, while most papers predicted future warming. Such theories are based on two entirely different sets of data focused on different objectives but relate to the same phenomena.

So once again we see how taking a very small sample of fact and blowing it out as news, has resulted in people's ignirance and dismissal of science.

As for polar ice caps, Canada is an excellent example of how the Arctic is changing. Glaciers are melting rapidly, sea levels are rising and sea temperatures are changing. Even just 1 or two degrees shift off of the natural warming cycle of the ocean
is attributed to tsunami's and floods.

In my lifetime, the rivers in BC have gone from being overly flooded from the snow melt to unable to maintain the salmon spawning cycle. From a base perspective that would illustrate both cooling and warming cycles, however one has created the other and both can be attributed to the same factors of climate change.

by jck

Elementary school science teaches us basic things which apply to global warming to show it's plausibility and that there is no debunking of it:

A) When carbon dioxide is not consumed, it builds up in the atmosphere.

B) CO2 levels in ice core samples show that within the past 120 years (since the industrial age began) that CO2 levels have risen than during any period in the previous 400k year period.

(http://cdiac.ornl.gov/trends/co2/contents.htm)

C) If the percentage of land mass with active vegitation on the planet (which consumes the CO2) is decreasing, therefore less CO2 is converted to O2.

D) Global surface temperatures have increased about 0.74?C (plus or minus 0.18?C) since the late-19th century, and the linear trend for the past 50 years of 0.13?C (plus or minus 0.03?C) per decade is nearly twice that for the past 100 years. The warming has not been globally uniform. Some areas (including parts of the southeastern U.S. and parts of the North Atlantic) have, in fact, cooled slightly over the last century. The recent warmth has been greatest over North America and Eurasia between 40 and 70?N. Lastly, seven of the eight warmest years on record have occurred since 2001 and the 10 warmest years have all occurred since 1995.

(http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/climate/globalwarming.html#q3)

It's pretty rudimentary and easy to see that the data shown to be reailty leads to global warming being a fact.

Just because guys like Maxwell can't understand that global warming causes climate change, i.e.- more dramatic pattern shifts, climactic events, etc., I refuse to argue the point any longer.

Especially since he and others like him can give no plausible evidence to conclusively contradict the scientific facts that exist through scientific study and measurement.

I wish you luck, though. You are aspiring to do what I have given up on: educating those who are unwilling to learn.

by maxwell edison

Unlike you, jck, I don't try to misrepresent my expertise on the issue by citing, what you call, [i]Elementary school science[/i]. There's nothing elementary about the argument, and to suggest as much is the epitome of ignorance. In fact, most of the cited [i]science[/i] is so far above the ability of most people to comprehend or understand that they simply have to decide on whom to believe.

You're a lefty Democrat and you espouse their collectivist agenda. It stands to reason that their big government control and collectivist [i]solutions[/i] to [i]climate change[/i] would appeal to you.

Moreover, it's not a scientific issue. It's a political issue.

No, jck, I don't believe you; I don't believe Neil; I don't believe the IPCC; I don't believe the UN; I don't believe the Democrats; I don't believe Al Gore; and I don't believe the NASA scientist, James Hansen, who's made a career out of making alarmist predictions, none of which have come true. You and Neil are in bed with all those people, and none of them have ANY credibility as far as I'm concerned. And as more time goes by, the less credibility they have.

I believe the following:

[i]"Global warming is a hoax."[/i]

- Bill Gray, Emeritus Professor of Atmospheric Science at Colorado State University; M.S. in meteorology from the University of Chicago, Ph.D. in geophysical sciences.

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2003040068_warming05.html

[i]".....evidence from my group's government-funded research that suggests global warming is mostly natural, and that the climate system is quite insensitive to humanity's greenhouse gas emissions and aerosol pollution."[/i]

-Dr. Roy W. Spencer, Ph.D. in meteorology from the University of Wisconsin-Madison; Principal Research Scientist at the University of Alabama in Huntsville; Senior Scientist for Climate Studies at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center.

http://www.drroyspencer.com/global-warming-natural-or-manmade/

[i]"First, nonscientists generally do not want to bother with understanding the science. Claims of consensus relieve policy types, environmental advocates, and politicians of any need to do so. Such claims also serve to intimidate the public and even scientists - especially those outside the area of climate dynamics.

Secondly, given that the question of human attribution largely cannot be resolved, its use in promoting visions of disaster constitutes nothing so much as a bait-and-switch scam. That is an inauspicious beginning to what Mr. Gore claims is not a political issue but a "moral" crusade.

Lastly, there is a clear attempt to establish truth not by scientific methods but by perpetual repetition. An earlier attempt at this was accompanied by tragedy. Perhaps Marx was right. This time around we may have farce - if we're lucky.[/i]

-Richard S. Lindzen,Professor of Atmospheric Science at MIT.

http://globalwarminghoax.wordpress.com/2006/10/26/richard-lindzen-no-global-warming/

[i]"Yet I am totally convinced there is no scientific basis for any of it.... Global Warming: It is a hoax. It is bad science. It is high-jacking public policy. It is the greatest scam in history."[/i]

-John Coleman, founder of the weather channel.

http://www.kusi.com/weather/colemanscorner/38574742.html

I could go on.......

I won't debate you either, jck, because you're nothing but a lefty Democrat collectivist in search of justification for your desired end conclusion. But I'd give 1000-1 odds on any of those guys in a debate against you and your [i]Elementary school science[/i].

Okay, jck, you may now return to your Democratic Party talking points.

P.S. Did you know that James Hansen has declined to participate in numerous public debates with Bill Gray on the issue of man-made global warming and climate change?

P.P.S. Speaking of [i]Elementary school science[/i], it's absolutely shameful that SO MANY elementary schools have - and still are - showing Al Gore's propaganda [i]An Inconvenient Truth[/i] in the classrooms and presenting it as scientific fact. There's your [i]Elementary school science[/i], jck, as it's being presented today.

by oz_media

As important as it is to most of the world, Americans have other important issues to face. Such as keeping their health care to those that can afford it, fighting wars in other nations and a fear of cowtowing to anyone else's ideas and concepts unless they can prove it was their own and thus should rightly enforce it globally. It's a typical grade school mentality resulting from a lack of awareness.

Nothing new.

by deadly ernest

same stuff I'm refering to here and I lost all that info in a hard drive crash several months ago. It can all be easily checked via a search on Google and wiki, meaning you can get a lot more information as you look.

Year without a summer - mount Tambora

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer

and another on longer term temperatures

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temperature_record_of_the_past_1000_years

and a few more links found in a quick google search

http://www.oism.org/pproject/s33p36.htm

look at the first graph on the link above, interesting temperatures.

http://www.john-daly.com/hockey/hockey.htm

on solar responsibility, below

http://www.co2science.org/articles/V7/N4/EDIT.php

http://climateaudit.org/2007/10/14/sargasso-sea-do18/

http://wattsupwiththat.com/2008/02/19/january-2008-4-sources-say-globally-cooler-in-the-past-12-months/

http://www.worldclimatereport.com/index.php/2007/03/16/the-coming-global-cooling/

About the English coast,

quote

Day 3: Start the day with an invigorating walk around: Richborough Roman Fort: Explore the site of the first Roman landing in Britain at a site now over two miles from the sea!

end quote

from;

http://elmfieldfarmcottages.wordpress.com/category/recommended-places/page/2/

This isn't where I first read about the coastal change, but I can't find the news article, which I think was originally a BBC one.

Or, you can look up the old very long threads on the global warming cult and follow the numerous links in them.

by oz_media

Reading teh sources of your information, it shines a great light on how you come up with these absurd ideas all the time.

It appears that you'll believe what you want to believe, without questioning your sources. As long as they comply with your personal beliefs they are valid.

But when you actually look at yoru sources, they are incredible in too many ways.

by tink!

Keep it up y'all, it's quite educational. :D

I've grown up listening to Earth Day presentations and "We must save the Earth" propaganda. Some I agree with, such as recycling and replanting. Climate change? Of course we have an effect, everything on the Earth will affect the environment around it. Is it enough to be panicked about? Nah.

It is understandable and logical to deal with local smog and pollution, but to say the icebergs in Antarctica are our concern because of what we do? That seems like we're stretching ourselves a bit out there too far.

by oz_media

That's about the only SWINDLE I see in the awareness focus.

Yes, there are some worthy recylceables, such as paper products, which are easily and cost effectively recycled as new products.

Plastics? It causes more emissions, costs three times the money to recucle.

There was a Penn & Teller Bulls*t episode on recycling.

They actually convinced a whole block of people to recycle using 12 (yes TWELVE) different types of recycling bins by convincing them how neccessary it was. Some people buy into anything they think may help.

But for the most part, those same people don't shop or consider recycling when making purchases to begin with. We just need to be wiser in the use ofd our resources.

If we don't over create it due to our own gluttony to begin with, then there's less to waste.

Such as that stupid, bottled water trend.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SC3CZBDz7Wg

Talking of bottled water trend, the clip above shows a guy all for recylcing, standing 20' from his own home and drinking bottled water! I suppose he doesn't have a glass or a tap in his house.

The one woman cracks me up, when asked how she felt about using 8 different bins for different products, including sanitary napkins, soiled toilet paper etc. Her comments are that she thinks it's a great idea and that it has always bothered her to think that someone else has to sort it all out. :D

Man there are some really 'kin stupid people on this planet, we should just drown them all like too many puppies on a farm.

Let's be more resourceful and reduce our emissions, but its the radicals that take it to extremes, in both directions that result in nothing really being done as they make themselves look so extreme nobody believes it anymore.

It's exactly the same as politics. Two extremes cancelling out the reality of an issue.

by tony hopkinson

but essentially our economies are based on mass production. Obviously effective mass production means you'll saturate the market, so the two accepted ways of keeping the economy going are to make things that don't last and to convince us to buy more of them, in case they break.

Attack consumerism though and you'll be labelled as a damn commie real quick.

If we stay planet bound, and don't end up being chased by someone who looks like Dennis Hopper. One day there will be no such thing as waste...

It's practice, and a growing market.

UK has just introduced legislation that all shops that sell more than next to no dry cell batteries a week, must provide a collection bin for dead ones. Considering the toxic crap in them, recycling isn't the only benefit, though I suspect we'll actually expend more energy and generate more pollution at the moment transporting them for procesing than we will anything else...

by dmambo

The real question is not whether climate change is happening, it's whether we can adapt to it successfully. If oceans rise or fall, if plant species fail or become invasive, if ozone is depleted and UV rays become stronger, can our societies still thrive?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

can everything below us on the food chain? Upon which we fully depend for our existence.
In strictly physical terms, that is.

by oz_media

Again, we have since found proof of the Earth's changes over millions of years.

They have been looking at ice cores for more than 200 years and those core samples show carbon monoxide context predating the ice age. Mineral samples taken from the Himalaya's, which were once the sea floor before being thrust thousands of feet in the air, show similar activity dating back billions of years.

Though todays tchnological and scientific analysis processes are able to determine far more than a core sampled 200 years ago would, this 200 year study stuff is simply hogwash.

Try changing the channel or reading someone else's book. You'd be amazed and what conclusive evidence of teh Earth's patterns is there and how imminent such effects are. The balance being a very fine line is easily tipped and thus teh natural effects expediated with the additional emissions man creates in the millions of tonnes per year.

by deadly ernest

religious fervour is based on. What man does is a pin prick compared to a significant volcanic eruption.

by Member 25348569

OK, Ernest, here's what you do.

You go and find links to the gaseous output of volcanoes over the last few hundred years. I'll let you include Krakatoa, no problem. You can even have Tambora! Then you find yourself a few links to the CO2 production by Man but, because I'm fair, you limit that to the burning of fossil fuels and to cement production.

Then you compare the two.

Then, because you aren't going to be able to do anything else, you STFU about volcanoes.

Neil :)

Then we can move on...

by oz_media

When you get your facts straight, try again.

Then again, based on your ridiculous analogy and conclusion, what is one more drop when the glass is already full?

by oz_media

As the moon's distance from Earth changes gravitational pull, which creates our ocean tides. Then, especially considering your comments, the moon has a very significant effect on the overall balance of life and change on Earth as well.

by deadly ernest

the big issue with the current debate is the amount of effect humans have had, and will have, with their daily activities, and if all the BS is worth the money they want to throw at it in the hopes it will go away.

by oz_media

take the one tonne challenge, it costs nothing and reduces personal emissions up to a tonne per year. That's significaant when widespread and best of all, it's free and you get healthier in the process.

But pshaw! Who needs that hogwash? Health, personal responsibilty, won't make any difference. Sorry, heard the broken record too many times to have patience with the likes of you.

There is no hope that, in your lifetime or several others, you will ever gather more relevant or acuurate information than David Suzuki.
http://www.davidsuzuki.org/default.asp

by tony hopkinson

is farming.....

Either animal husbandry or us killing off natural habitats for food and resources.

Taking a wild guess here, but you still haven't done as I suggested and read James Gleick's Chaos yet have you.

Give it a go, no climate change or anti-religious stuff in it, and it's a very readable book.

At the end of it you should come to the conclusion that neither the treehuggers nor the moneyhuggers are right.

by geek3001

I get the feeling that a lot of people seem to think that human generated global climate change is an either/or proposition. Either we have an effect and are responsible for the changes or we don't.

I wish that more people would consider that there are several factors involved, each of which contributes to the overall scheme of things. These factors even vary from day to day, making it hard to figure out their contribution accurately. And to further complicate things, we're still learning about events that could have an impact on global climate change. The picture we have of how climate systems work is rather fuzzy and will remain so for quite some time.

A lot of the factors that affect global climate change are things we can't control, as shown by very long term climatic history. It happened before and it will happen again, and there will be die backs of various scales.

The big issue is whether human changes in the environment are large enough to cause problems when combined with other changes. Saying that the impact of humans is too small to have any effect is as bad as saying that they are the sole cause of global climate change. All you would need to disprove either side is one example to the contrary.

We do have examples where human changes to the environment have had regional impacts. Acid rain is one example that is well documented. At the same time, acid rain can also be generated by volcanoes, wildfires, asteroid strikes and rotting organic matter. The natural sources may be bigger but our addition to the problem is something that is ADDED to the overall scheme of things in places that are close to where we live.

Does that small percentage make a difference? You could ask people living downwind of coal fired power plants that have scrubbers on them, like those in the North East US. Or you could ask people in Japan who have to deal with acid rain created by unscrubbed coal fired power plants in China.

by deadly ernest

what's involved knows and agrees that humans do have an impact, just as every living thing has an impact. The problem is the people, most of whom have a very vested financial interest in pushing the line, that humans are the MAJOR factor in climate change, and can thus have a significant impact if they spend enough money to change the way the human impact is - and they get big payouts for pushing that line by being employed in high paid cushy jobs, etc.

The truth of the matter is the human impact is not the biggest impact, but one of the smallest, and that's where the first bone of contention lies. Instead of being something like 60% of the problem, human effort is more like 6%. And no one knows enough to give a realistic evaluation.

The second bone of contention is the argument about paying people in other organisations to change the level of human impact, and the cost involved in that. Not a smart thing to do, unless you want to waste money and give it to con artists.

The third bone of contention is what do they use as measures of the impact involved, and are they reliable. So many people want to cut things out of what's measured as it gives them a bigger slice of the money bucket being offered.

The fourth bone of contention is the way those pushing this whole issue are saying that you can have different rules for different countries and it's perfectly OK. Yet they get to decide what category a country belongs in. So developing countries with a need for a growing population like Canada, the USA, and Australia are being hit with the same rules to comply with as fully developed countries with a hundred times the population density like France, Belgium, etc. Again, it all comes down to the money bag those behind the Human cause claim are pushing for.

by maxwell edison

And also how the whole global warming and/or climate change lie will lead to even MORE out of control spending. ([i]Investing[/i] in alternative energy sources equals more out of control spending.)

by ic-it

by short sighted people. Is it now politically correct to only think in terms of the short term. That strikes me as they may have given up on there being a future due to their own immediate greed/satisfaction.

by oz_media

Global warming is climate change.

If you think it's a lie, you really have no place offering an opinion until you gain an education not supplied directly by the GOP, but I suppose any money THEY spend is okay by you.

You propose to be so open minded and all seeing, however you simply refuse to accept any facts supported elsewhere unless they are also supported by your personal political and constitutional preferences.

And you don't like it when I say you are hypocritical? Try making some sense, once in a while anyway.

by tony hopkinson

It is a political issue.

So given that if it's valid for you to quote 'scientists' who bolster your political opinion, why is it wrong for those who hold a diffrent one to quote 'scientists' who bolster theirs?

Personally I'll attack your politics, the 'scientists' who support my position are talking out of their arse as much as the ones who do yours.

No control, no repeatable results, no evidence the model matches the actuality, not science, none of it. Abstract models that correlate to nothing and carefully filtered statistics, is all it is.

Might as well get a definitive answer off an astrologer, or by having your bumps felt.

by maxwell edison

[i]".....why is it wrong for those who hold a different one to quote 'scientists' who bolster theirs[/i]"

It's not wrong in the scientific realm, because that's what science is all about. But it is wrong in the political realm because it proves there is no consensus, as is so often claimed, and that no conclusion and/or subsequent solution should be reached until there is a REAL consensus.

Would you support spending public dollars - AND denying individual liberty - on mining green cheese from the moon if half (or more) of the scientists question the very existance of green cheese on the moon?

by tony hopkinson

Offer me a chance to go up and there and make green cheese, I'd take it.

Not as facetious as it sounds that. A 'low cost' means of getting in and out of the gravity well, jobs, spin off tech, support..

Similar with combating "global warming". there's money, jobs, wealth and power in it. No less valid in effect than what we are doing now. The real change would be who's got the power and the wealth. That's the political/ecomomic fight.

I'm a socialist, I don't believe that individual liberty has innate primacy over communal, never have, never will.

I don't argue that we should break away from the consumerist approach because the weather is bad, I argue it because it's Malthusian, and I'm long term sort of bloke.

by oz_media

I didn't think you would be able to pull up that fricking individual liberty crap in this thread but somehow you found it.

Your last card in any thread has always been that it's a matter of individual liberty. Then you pull out the fife and bang your drum and tell great tales of America's, once mighty, founders and blah, blah....blech!

Get over it, we are living in the 21st century, not the 18th. Did you ever think that, just like Nostradamus and the Mayans, they really didn't have a frickin' clue where the world would be in 200 years and couldn't possibly set out a reasonable guideline for the country's future? Christ, they barely knew where they were and who they faced, they only just realized the world wasn't flat, they were one gene ahead of calling guns 'fire-sticks', how the hell would they know about life and global cooperation in the 21st century?

And you wonder why I pull out the Sam the American Eagle vids?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kDA9NbPAK8o

by maxwell edison

[i]....shops that sell more than next to no dry cell batteries a week, must provide a collection bin for dead ones."[/i]

I think that's a great idea. I'd save my dead batteries to deposit into such a collection bin.

You do make a good point, however; "[i]though I suspect we'll actually expend more energy and generate more pollution at the moment transporting them for procesing than we will anything else... [/i]"

There's always balance and trade-off

by tony hopkinson

At the moment people get paid for mining, and processing the raw materials, transporting them processing them, manufacturing the product, transporting that, selling it, managing that entire effort.

Dead batteries get disposed of in landfills, leaking toxic crap back into the food chain, there's a bit of money in that not a lot.

So legislating this way, the increase to the retail is basically one bin. Someones got to make them, sell them, deliver them, manage that. Someones going to collect them, recycle them for re-uable material and sell that.

So it makes green sense to a limited extent and economically given recycled material is competitive, against the current sources.

It's an approach both sides can live with.

Regulating that all batteries must be rechargeable, banning battery powered items, or enforcing some sort of standard on longevity, would be much more effective in terms of the real problem and about as popular as loony cheese.

If we can do something and not make things worse I'm all for it. I like trees, but not enough to hug them. I like money but not enough to be a slave to it.

by jackofalltech

I'm going to ignore the non-relevant and just focus on the fact that you completely ignored the science I mentioned.

The only scientists who still promote MMGW are either govt paid or have a vested, self-interest in the results.

by oz_media

That certainly isn't the case here.

Check the Suzuki Foundation ,Canada's most active conservationist society, no government padding there in fact he personally backed out to stop the two being even remotely connected because he did get funding to explore other geo fields.

As for Man Made global warming, get over it, nobody believes man actually MADE global warming. Those facts are decades old and a result of a lacking scientific focus id the US...which is not an anti US rant, it is a proven fact due to strong religious faith taking precedence in American culture.

by jackofalltech

of not using the name of my Lord in that way?

I do not slander the names of any religious leaders such as Buddha or Mohammed or Shiva, none of whom died for me so I would appreciate it as a personal favor. Thanks.

by Member 25348569

Well surely God, Buddha, Mohammed or Shiva are all reckoned to be big enough to look after themselves (except for Buddha of course but I don't reckon he'd have cared much). What's a poor atheist to do without offending SOMEONE?

Look, you can't ALL be right so some of you are demonstrably deluded and, in that case, your Deity is fair game. (In my estimation, you're ALL deluded but that's for another day).

If there is a God and He's yours, Santee is in for a serious afterlife kicking. I mean, you've got a whole COMMANDMENT against it. That's a tenth of your Holy Commands. If there isn't or He's somebody elses then it hardly matters, does it? Win-win for you.

:)

Sorry, but I'm in a bad mood...

by jackofalltech

I was not making any comparisons or valuations, just stating my position and asking a favor. Whether I'm right or not is irrelevant.

by santeewelding

But only as personal courtesy to you.

Your presence here is too great a plus for me to risk diminishing in any way.

by Member 25348569

in my old age.

Neil :)

Anyway, I never upset people who might - just might - have the inside track to someone who can fling thunderbolts.

Well, not upset them as much as I could...

So I SERIOUSLY do not want to piss off anyone who worships Zeus!

by deadly ernest

one thing that distorts a lot of this discussion is people wanting to limit the total effects to things like CO2 and CFC emissions and only them, when the whole issue is much wider.

From the following web sites:

http://environment.about.com/od/greenhouseeffect/a/volcano-gas.htm

quote

Furthermore, some scientists believe that spectacular volcanic eruptions, like that of Mt. St. Helens in 1980 and Mt. Pinatubo in 1991, actually lead to short-term global cooling, not warming, as sulfur dioxide (SO2), ash and other particles in the air and stratosphere reflect some solar energy instead of letting it into Earth?s atmosphere. SO2, which converts to sulfuric acid aerosol when it hits the stratosphere, can linger there for as long as seven years and can exercise a cooling effect long after a volcanic eruption has taken place.

Scientists tracking the effects of the major 1991 eruption of the Philippines? Mt. Pinatubo found that the overall effect of the blast was to cool the surface of the Earth globally by some 0.5 degrees Celsius a year later, even though rising human greenhouse gas emissions and an El Nino event (a warm water current which periodically flows along the coast of Ecuador and Peru in South America) caused some surface warming during the 1991-1993 study period.

end quote

http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/1997/of97-262/of97-262.html

quote

Gases from volcanoes give rise to numerous impacts on climate, the environment, and people. U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) scientists are inventorying gas emissions at many of the almost 70 active volcanoes in the United States. This effort helps build a better understanding of the dynamic processes at work on the Earth's surface and is contributing important new information on how volcanic emissions affect global change.

....

Ash column generated by the eruption of Mount Pinatubo, a volcano in the Philippines Luzon volcanic arc, on June 12, 1991. The climactic eruption of Mount Pinatubo occurred three days later on June 15, 1991, and was one of the largest eruptions of this century. The climactic event lasted about 9 hours and erupted over a cubic mile of rock material. It injected a 20- million ton sulfur dioxide cloud into the stratosphere to an altitude of more than 20 miles. The climactic Pinatubo cloud was the largest sulfur dioxide cloud ever observed in the stratosphere since the beginning of such observations by satellites in 1978. It caused what is believed to be the largest aerosol disturbance of the stratosphere this century, although smaller than the estimated disturbances from the eruptions of Tambora in 1815 and Krakatau in 1883. Sulfate aerosol formed in the stratosphere from sulfur dioxide in the Pinatubo cloud increased the reflection of radiation from the Sun back into space. Consequently, the Earth's surface cooled in the three years following the eruption, by as much as 1.3 degrees ( Fahrenheit scale) at the height of the effect. The sulfate aerosols also accelerated chemical reactions that, together with increased stratospheric chlorine levels from man-made chlorofluorocarbon (CFC) pollution, destroyed ozone and led to the lowest ozone levels ever recorded to date in the stratosphere.

Scientists now know that the "smoke" from volcanoes, once attributed by poets to be from Vulcan's forge, is actually volcanic gas, and an important agent of global change.
........

Large, explosive volcanic eruptions inject water vapor (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2), sulfur dioxide (SO2), hydrogen chloride (HCl), hydrogen fluoride (HF) and ash (pulverized rock and pumice) into the stratosphere to heights of 10-20 miles above the Earth's surface. The most significant impacts from these injections come from the conversion of sulfur dioxide to sulfuric acid (H2SO4), which condenses rapidly in the stratosphere to form fine sulfate aerosols. The aerosols increase the reflection of radiation from the Sun back into space and thus cool the Earth's lower atmosphere or troposphere; however, they also absorb heat radiated up from the Earth, thereby warming the stratosphere. Several eruptions during the past century have caused a decline in the average temperature at the Earth's surface of up to half a degree (Fahrenheit scale) for periods of one to three years. The sulfate aerosols also promote complex chemical reactions on their surfaces that alter chlorine and nitrogen chemical species in the stratosphere. This effect, together with increased stratospheric chlorine levels from chlorofluorocarbon pollution, generates chlorine monoxide (ClO), which destroys ozone (O3). As the aerosols grow and coagulate, they settle down into the upper troposphere where they serve as nuclei for cirrus clouds and further modify the Earth's radiation balance. Most of the hydrogen chloride (HCl) and hydrogen fluoride (HF) are dissolved in water droplets in the eruption cloud and quickly fall to the ground as acid rain. The injected ash also falls rapidly from the stratosphere; most of it is removed within several days to a few weeks. Finally, explosive volcanic eruptions release the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide and thus provide a deep source of carbon for biogeochemical cycles. (figure modified from Richard Turco in American Geophysical Union Special Report: Volcanism and Climate Change, May 1992).

end quote

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980_eruption_of_Mount_St._Helens

quote

An eruption column rose 80,000 feet (24,400 m) into the atmosphere and deposited ash in 11 U.S. states.[2] At the same time, snow, ice, and several entire glaciers on the volcano melted, forming a series of large lahars (volcanic mudslides) that reached as far as the Columbia River, nearly fifty miles (eighty kilometers) to the south. Less severe outbursts continued into the next day only to be followed by other large but not as destructive eruptions later in 1980.
...............

During the nine hours of vigorous eruptive activity, about 540 million tons of ash fell over an area of more than 22,000 square miles (60,000 km?)
.............
Energy release: 24 megatons thermal energy (7 by blast, rest through release of heat)

end quote

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Tambora

quote

In 1812, Mount Tambora became highly active, with its eruptive peak in the catastrophic explosive event of April 1815.[14] The magnitude was seven on the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI) scale, with a total tephra ejecta volume of 1.6 ? 1011 cubic metres (160 cubic kilometers or 38 cubic miles).[14] It was an explosive central vent eruption with pyroclastic flows and a caldera collapse, causing tsunamis and extensive land and property damage. It created a long-term effect on global climate. This activity ceased on 15 July 1815
.....................

All vegetation on the island was destroyed. Uprooted trees, mixed with pumice ash, washed into the sea and formed rafts of up to 5 kilometres (3.1 mi) across.[2] One pumice raft was found in the Indian Ocean, near Calcutta on 1 and 3 October 1815.[4] Clouds of thick ash still covered the summit on 23 April. Explosions ceased on 15 July, although smoke emissions were still observed as late as 23 August. Flames and rumbling aftershocks were reported in August 1819, four years after the event.

A moderate-sized tsunami struck the shores of various islands in the Indonesian archipelago on 10 April, with a height of up to 4 metres (13 ft) in Sanggar at around 10 p.m.[2] A tsunami of 1?2 m (3.3?6.6 ft) in height was reported in Besuki, East Java, before midnight, and one of 2 metres (6.6 ft) in height in the Molucca Islands. The total death-toll has been estimated at around 4,600 [20].

The eruption column reached the stratosphere, an altitude of more than 43 km (140,000 ft).[4] The coarser ash particles fell 1 to 2 weeks after the eruptions, but the finer ash particles stayed in the atmosphere from a few months up to a few years at an altitude of 10?30 km (33,000?98,000 ft).[2] Longitudinal winds spread these fine particles around the globe, creating optical phenomena. Prolonged and brilliantly colored sunsets and twilights were frequently seen in London, England between 28 June and 2 July 1815 and 3 September and 7 October 1815.[2] The glow of the twilight sky typically appeared orange or red near the horizon and purple or pink above.
...............

The 1815 eruption released sulfur into the stratosphere, causing a global climate anomaly. Different methods have estimated the ejected sulfur mass during the eruption: the petrological method; an optical depth measurement based on anatomical observations; and the polar ice core sulfate concentration method, using cores from Greenland and Antarctica. The figures vary depending on the method, ranging from 10 Tg S to 120 Tg S.[4]

In the spring and summer of 1816, a persistent dry fog was observed in the northeastern U.S. The fog reddened and dimmed the sunlight, such that sunspots were visible to the naked eye. Neither wind nor rainfall dispersed the "fog". It was identified as a stratospheric sulfate aerosol veil.[4] In summer 1816, countries in the Northern Hemisphere suffered extreme weather conditions, dubbed the Year Without a Summer.

end quote

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer

quote

As a result of the series of volcanic eruptions, crops in the above cited areas had been poor for several years; the final blow came in 1815 with the eruption of Tambora. In the United States, many historians cite the "Year Without a Summer" as a primary motivation for the western movement and rapid settlement of what is now western and central New York and the American Midwest. Many New Englanders were wiped out by the year, and tens of thousands struck out for the richer soil and better growing conditions of the Upper Midwest (then the Northwest Territory).

Europe, still recuperating from the Napoleonic Wars, suffered from food shortages. Food riots broke out in the United Kingdom and France and grain warehouses were looted. The violence was worst in landlocked Switzerland, where famine caused the government to declare a national emergency. Huge storms, abnormal rainfall with floodings of the major rivers of Europe (including the Rhine) are attributed to the event, as was the frost setting in during August 1816. A major typhus epidemic occurred in Ireland between 1816-19, precipitated by the famine caused by "The Year Without a Summer". It is estimated that 100,000 Irish perished during this period. A BBC documentary using figures compiled in Switzerland estimated that fatality rates in 1816 were twice that of average years, giving an approximate European fatality total of 200,000 deaths.

The eruption of Tambora also caused Hungary to experience brown snow. Italy experienced something similar, with red snow falling throughout the year. The cause of this is believed to have been volcanic ash in the atmosphere.

end quote
.............

In Summary

Major volcanic eruptions lower have such an effect on the climate that they lower the global temperature within months; and real big ones can cause world wide famine. They also throw mega tonnes of ash and crap into the atmosphere, along with a number of gases that cause significant chemical reactions in the atmosphere. As well as throwing mega tonnes of earth and rock around the nearby area, usually destroying everything within many miles. Put out huge levels of heat to affect the climate as well. And all this takes many months, usually years for it all to settle down again.

Around the world there are volcanic eruptions of varying sizes each year, and many cases of gas leakage, of a number of gases.

Unless we go about setting of a huge pile of nuclear explosions, humans will be hard pushed to have that sort of effect. And nothing humans do on a daily basis has that sort of effect.

Volcanoes have a much larger effect on the climate and overall environment than humans each year. Hell, we still haven't reached what the average global temperatures that existed prior to the 1815 Tambora eruption, despite all this (supposed) human caused global warming.

Anyway, when the biggest volcano in the world decides to clear its throat next, we won't have much to worry about as the scientists are split as to the results - some say it will just destroy North America, while others say it will destroy civilisation as we know it, due to the ash cloud and following famine. It's called the Yellowstone caldera, and it's in Wyoming.

.............

As I've always said, we should seek ways to eliminate pollution and reduce what effect we do have on the environment, but this BS making humans the bunny for everything that's changing is rubbish.

by Member 25348569

This is a thread about Global Warming and all you've done is cut-and-paste thirty-two column-feet about the COOLING affect of volcanic aerosols!

To quote from YOUR quote:

"Scientists tracking the effects of the major 1991 eruption of the Philippines? Mt. Pinatubo found that the overall effect of the blast was to [b]cool[/b] the surface of the Earth globally by some 0.5 degrees Celsius a year later, even though [b]rising human greenhouse gas emissions[/b] and an El Nino event (...) caused some [b]surface warming[/b] during the 1991-1993 study period."

To quote from your post:

"And all this takes many months, usually years for it all to settle down again."

So, pretty transient effects even from cataclysmic "once in a thousand years" blasts.

Volcanoes DO NOT put out "out huge levels of heat to affect the climate as well". As you, yourself posted St Helens put 24 megatonnes - I assume the equivalent of a 24 megatonne TNT blast - of combined heat and blast. That's around 1x10^17 Joules in total released over a few hours, admittedly with the first big bang only taking seconds. The Solar Constant is 1.3 kilowatt/m2 which means that the solar energy absorbed by the Earth is around 1.22x10^17 Joules per second. Every second.

And (yawn), the Yellowstone Caldera. If it goes pop in my lifetime then, yes, you can say "I told you so". If it doesn't...

by santeewelding

That caldera, has been rumbling with magnitude twos and threes for weeks, now.

Don't you be speaking that way about something that can throw lightning bolts even your way.

From where I am, I will be cursing you in death from under a mile of ash.

by Member 25348569

I'm sorry but the Yellowstone Caldera is nothing to do with me. OK, so you could possibly hold me partly responsible for Mt St. Helens but I haven't been NEAR Yellowstone.

Honest...

by deadly ernest

and down about volcanoes not having as much affect as humans. Well, they clearly have a bigger effect than humans do, and a quicker one; which is what that material points out. But, like a lot of the 'Humans Caused all the Climate Change' evangelists, you seem to have ignored what doesn't suit the point you're trying to make.

St Helens put out 24 megatons of THERMAL energy, as well as 540 million tons of ash, and those are just two of the many materials it put out. How that relates to joules, I don't know; the web page stats simply say Lateral Eruption - Energy Released - 24 megatons of thermal energy. Also, the pyroclastic flow covered 6 square miles with lava, up to 30 feet deep in places, that had a temperature of 1,300 degrees F, and that's additional to the heat put out by the lateral eruption. That's a huge amount of heat, however you try to manipulate it.

And yes, I read what I posted, I also read the rest of the web pages I listed. I did forget to include in the summary that many volcanic eruptions create devastating tsunamis:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsunami

quote

Due to the immense volumes of water and energy involved, tsunamis can devastate coastal regions. Casualties can be high because the waves move faster than humans can run.

Earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and other underwater explosions (detonations of nuclear devices at sea), landslides and other mass movements, bolide impacts, and other disturbances above or below water all have the potential to generate a tsunami.

end quote

It would take a couple of the biggest nuclear bombs together to do the equivalent damage of an eruption like St Helens.

by Member 25348569

THEN GO AND BLOODY FIND OUT.

"24 Megatons" is pretty much meaningless unless you can examine it in context.

That's my problem with you, your superficiality. You cut and paste from Wiki without having the slightest idea about the significance or otherwise of what you have posted.

As for "jumping up and down", yes. You were posting to me about the effects of volcanoes. I was posting to Santee and I don't have to keep it relevant to the on-line conversation between you and me but I do have to keep it relevant to my conversation with Santee. And I did.

I don't say that volcanoes don't have effects but they are pretty soon over in the great scheme of things. Only the largest eruptions, such as the Lake Toba blowout, have a significant impact on entire ecosystems. They don't happen very often, we can't prepare for them and there is nothing we can do to stop them if they do happen so they are IRRELEVANT.

by deadly ernest

1. The post order up to my last response was

Max - me - Oz - me - Oz - me - you - me - you

Now, at that point I did some quick research and copied a lot of stuff into my reply to your post in response to mine. I responded to that post, and not the exchange you had with Santee while I was preparing my response. So it's clear that Santee came into the situation AFTER, your post jumping up and down about the gases.

Your post I was responding to said:

quote

Do you READ your own posts?
This is a thread about Global Warming and all you've done is cut-and-paste thirty-two column-feet about the COOLING affect of volcanic aerosols!

end quote

It was your post titled 'One Last Try' where the CO2 and gases was brought into, my post prior to that was about the overall effect, not just the gases. You asked for some references, so I did a quick search and dug some out for you. And not all of what was in the post was about cooling either.

2. As to what a megaton of thermal energy is:

I don't care what it is in joules, I didn't do the stats, and I didn't ask for information on the stats. I simply found the information and provided it. It's clear they mean a lot of heat, and if you wish to know the exact detail, I suggest you go to the web page I quoted from, read it all, and follow up the references and other links on it - of which there are quite a few.

3. as to the Yellowstone Caldera

I don't think you are responsible, I don't expect it to go soon, but you never can tell. The best experts admit they'd only be guessing if they gave a figure, but they also say they don't expect it to be soon either. When it goes, it goes and there's damn all anyone can do about it at this time. Who knows, in a another fifty, or a hundred, years they may develop the technology to stop it blowing it's top.

.............

Overall, I don't expect you to change you position on the Climate Change situation, I don't expect to change mine either. But, if people make posts presenting as fact that all climate change, or the majority of climate change is caused by humans, then I'll post saying it's BS as the evidence available, when it's ALL examined, says just that.

by maxwell edison

..... has innate primacy over communal, then you must believe that individual liberty and freedom is bestowed upon people by other people, not something inherently gained (or bestowed by one's Creator).

Why would you want to presuppose - and allow - that other people have more power over you than you have over yourself? And by what power do you (or anyone) subjugate others to that fate? If a person doesn't own himself or herself, who does? And if a person does own himself or herself, then individual liberty trumps communal.

At least you admit to your socialist leanings and call it for what it is - unlike the so-called [i]progressives[/i] in the United States.

by maxwell edison

When I said, [i]Investing in alternative energy sources equals more out of control spending,[/i] I meant government investing - which is really nothing more than government spending. Governments spend; companies invest.

If ANY alternative energy source was feasible and viable, then tons of private investment dollars would flood that market.

Moreover, I believe it's the left who's short-sighted, because it's the left's social programs that have built up the massive debt that will be passed onto future generations. It's the short-term greed and self-satisfaction of you folks (leftists, progressives, collectivists, Democrats, socialists, etc.) who are compromising the long-term future of this country.

I asked my son a question not too long ago. I asked him what he would think if, upon my death, all of my personal debt was passed onto him, a debt for which he would be responsible - a $50,000 Visa bill, for example. He said, that would really suck, that it would just not be right. If it's wrong on an individual basis, I went on to ask, do you also think it's wrong on a national basis? Well guess what? Both are wrong.

Like I said - and it's worth repeating - I believe it's the left who's short-sighted, because it's the left's social programs that have built up the massive debt that will be passed onto future generations. It's the short-term greed and self-satisfaction of you folks (leftists, progressives, collectivists , Democrats, socialists, etc.) who are compromising the long-term future of this country.

by geek3001

You might want to take a closer look at your list of experts.

Bill Gray would have some credentials in the field, so he would be a good choice.

Dr. Roy W. Spencer, Ph.D. looks like a good choice at first glance. But the fact that he also believes in intelligent design takes away from his credibility.

Richard S. Lindzen seems to be an excellent choice as an atmospheric physicist at MIT. He would be the one on your list that I'd trust to critique climate change computer models. His biggest weakness is his belief that lung cancer is only weakly linked to smoking. (Of course, not all lung cancers are caused by smoking, which might be his approach. More information is required.)

John Coleman, alas, is a bad choice if you are looking for climate change experts. While he is the founder of the Weather Channel, it appears that his college training was in journalism and his professional background is that of a news weathercaster. Being a weathercaster might give you an edge over the average layman when it comes to climate change, but it does not make you an expert in the topic. If anything, it makes it more probable that he could do the same media grandstanding that he accuses Gore and others of doing.

Can you provide a few more expert references?

by maxwell edison

You provide the names of four [i]experts[/i] who make the global warming claim, and then we'll evaluate all eight together. Let's tear into all of them and find reasons to discredit them all. It's a typical ploy to discredit the person if their argument can't be refuted (employed by both sides of an argument, to be sure, but a tactic used much more by the left - especially with the mm gw/cc claim).

Nonetheless, ALL of the [i]experts[/i] on my list are exponentially more qualified than any of the politicians advancing the claim - especially Al Gore, the poster boy of global warming; and 99.99 percent of the people advancing the mm gw/cc notion are politicians, political activists, political pundits, or partisan voters - none of whom have one iota of qualifications.

We rarely - if ever - hear from of any [i]real[/i] experts. And when we do hear from them, they refuse to publicly debate the issue with other [i]experts[/i] who disagree. That, in itself, makes for bad science, considering the fact that peer reviews are a big part of science. Here's my theory and conclusion, says Scientist-A, who willingly offers it to Scientist-B to shoot holes in it. What are they afraid of? Why do you think James Hansen won't publicly debate Bill Grey? Because his so-called facts, figures, predictions, and conclusions will be torn to bits and he'll look like a total fool.

But if you want to set some rules for disqualification, how about if we discredit ANYONE who stands to gain financially by advancing and/or studying and/or implementing so-called solutions for the notion of mm gw/cc? Scientist John Doe, for example, stands to lose a million dollars a year in government grants for his department if the notion of mm gw/cc was debunked. I'd wager that that might eliminate almost all of them.

By the way, the reasons you'd discount Lindzen and Spencer are common arguments found on any number of leftist pro global warming Web sites. I've heard them before, many times over. Neil gave me the same reasons. But I've never seen anyone refute their facts and figures. And yes, Coleman is a weatherman, but he sure knows a lot more about it than you, me, Neil, jck, any politician, etc. And if you want to eliminate Spencer for the reason you cite, let's eliminate ANYONE who believes in God - scientist or otherwise.

Side note: How many IT [i]experts[/i] do we see around here who have neither a degree or any certifications related to IT, but yet they're very sharp and knowledgeable people?

by geek3001

I suspect that we could both find climate experts that have extremely solid credentials and could withstand reasonable scrutiny. I personally dislike the 'discredit the person ploy', be it in climate change, politics, or other topics. I would love to see actual statistics on which sides use the ploy in climate change discussions as well as in political races.

I'd agree that three of your four choices are exponentially more qualified than the politicians and other non-climate experts, and I won't play math games with fractional exponents. But then we are comparing experts versus spokespeople. At the same time, using your IT example of non-degreed, non-certed experts, I'd say that there are some spokespeople who are at least as knowledgeable as the news weathercaster. That would throw off your rhetorical 99.99 percent number.

As far as 'debating' climate change publicly, I'd be all for it as long as we're dealing with peer review facts. Too often public 'debates' devolve into less than civil arguments which can include name calling, unsubstantiated 'facts', misremembered 'facts' and the 'discredit the person ploy.' Ideally all sides should be able to present their facts, with references as to the studies that support them. They should then be able to critique the other side's facts, providing references that support their critique. The critiques could then be critiqued until all sides are satisfied that they have presented what needs to be said.

This would be good science but lousy theater. It might work best if the public 'debate' was done on a web page and a panel of 'neutral' experts discussed the strengths and weakness of the 'web' of evidence that was presented.

As far as disqualifying experts that have financial ties to advancing 'mm gc/cc', would that also apply to experts and non-experts that would lose millions if 'mm gc/cc' were proven to be true? The 'science' of the tobacco companies in regards to the hazards of smoking comes to mind.

Even with the disqualifications on both sides of the fence, I still suspect that we could find scientists who are ethical enough to desire accurate results.

As far as Lindzen and Spencer are concerned, I did a quick check of their credentials and found those 'oddities' mentioned. Not all of the mentions were on 'leftist' sites. And when it comes to Spencer's 'intelligent design' beliefs, you don't necessarily have to reject God if you believe in the theory of evolution. The Catholic church doesn't appear to have problems with the theory of evolution. And who are we to say that God didn't create evolution as a feedback mechanism for life?

by Member 25348569

Despite my - well known - belief in the irrationality of religious belief, I wouldn't discount any scientist who was a believer. I would, however, tend to look sceptically at a cooking recipe from a scientist who was a proponent of Intelligent Design. Anyone who can perform THAT level of delusional mental gymnastics is capable of being duplicitous about anything.

Now, I'm with Geek above. Unfortunately, the idea of "Public Debate" in the political arena has crossed the Pond and we now have "Presidential-Style" debates between our party leaders to look forward to. This, despite the fact that we don't have a President. Why should we want to compare the debating skills of our politicians and why, much more so, would we want to compare the [b]debating skills[/b] of our research scientists? It's their ability as a scientist that is important.

I believe in Man's contribution to climate change because I've read enough research papers and digests of same to convince me. Me. I've done it myself. It's important enough to me so I've taken the time to do it.

I'm also invoking Godwin's Law on you. You KNOW that you are not allowed to mention Al Gore in an argument on Climate Change.

I know you started it but GET OFF THIS THREAD!

:D

by geek3001

We may be contributing to the biomass problem through things like the Gulf of Mexico Dead Zone. Fertilizer runoff, excess erosion, concentrated animal wastes and human sewage sent into the Mississippi River Basin promote algae blooms that create massive fish kills. That, in turn, increases the amount of climate changing crud that goes into the atmosphere.

While algae blooms do happen naturally, we seem to be doing a 'better' job than nature in this area. It was predicted in 2000 that the number of dead zones around the world would double. Does anyone know whether that prediction came true?

by oz_media

ao you agree we a a contributing factor to the problem. We cannot control other contributing factors, but we CAN control US as a contributing factor.

But you feel that our contribution is natural and won't have any significant effect or change in the grand scheme of things. Hoever we are a contributing factor, but we are not a contributing factor.

Get real.

by oz_media

Your piping on about once it was cooling and then it was warming and now it's climate change simply demonstrates an ignorance of the subject matter.

Global cooling was a rapidly dismissed and unproven THEORY spewed by a hack many years ago. Even though it was quickly dismissed, the press went on to hype it up and rag it out, not science.

They then furthered their studies and proved that the Earth was actually warming at an increasing rate, greater than the natural warming and cooling seen ever before.
They speculated on reasons and eventually came up with conclusive evidence of the causes, measuring our own emissions wih natural emissions, they then proved that we have a significant impact on this natural cycle.

Global warming by definition means a change in climate, thus climate change.

So all of your nonsense and inaacurate comparrison, simply illustrates a man with an agenda. An unproven, unqualified and misunderstood or cleverly reworded agenda.

Not common sense, logic and fact.

by oz_media

Just like anything that becomes political, there are extremists on both sides and it clouds middle, reasonable ground to the point of inaction.

A lot like your lopsided GW focus, one nut on the right said this and on nut on the left said that, so therefore it's all a bunch of garbage.

by maxwell edison

..... the basis for everything I believe - call it a moral compass that guides me through life's issues. Assuming personal responsibility is diminished in ANY collectivist system. Why should anyone be denied the right to assume personal responsibility? Accepting personal responsibility is the side-effect of individual liberty. Moreover, I truly believe that a societal structure that places more emphasis on personal responsibility will be better - much better - than one with an emphasis on collectivism.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=325646&messageID=3242996&tag=content;leftCol

You mock it and make fun of it, and that's okay. It only shows, however, that you're less tolerant of others with a different set of ideals. But the bottom line remains the same: those who rest on the principle of individual liberty are MORE tolerant of others, and we're MORE willing to let others live their lives as they wish - and we have a clear and concise boundary; one's individual liberty is limited to the extent it infringes on that of another.

Mock away, Oz, and show your intolerance of those who believe differently than you. It's what you seemingly do best.

P.S. And please spare me the [i]selfish[/i] argument. You, of all people, really do know that I spend an enormous amount of personal time and money for the service and benefit of others. I volunteer it; collectivists, however, want to force it; but the former is a much better system.

by maxwell edison

..... thanks for chiming in.

Oz attacking Maxwell's character has been a TR staple for a long time. I'm sure we entertain many folks.

You don't hold back, and I have a skin of steel.

by maxwell edison

It has no bearing on who I really am or the destiny of my soul.

The politics of personal destruction is alive and well around the TR water cooler.

(P.S. I think I was within 20 miles. Yes, I did think about it, but time was a factor.)

by oz_media

You are so resevred and passive, sorry to be such an ogre to your open minded and consultative posts.

by deadly ernest

and a lot of non living things are contributing factors. The most significant factors are the non living things like the sun, volcanoes etc. What i contest is the claim that humans are the major factor and can have anything but an extremely minor effect by what they do short of a nuclear war.

The other thing I complain about is the BS being used by some con artists the scam money while they put all the blame on others.

by oz_media

I simply don't hang on to outdated dogma as my basis for determining personal reposibility.

If people were more responsible and didn't simply dimiss facts based on the media's questionable criteria, the problem would not have as much focus. As people refuse to accept any responsibility, as your initial post also displays, then other measures need to be taken.

Because pf what you or those who feel they live in the only free land feel, inaction has resulyed in a lack of progress.
Thus global government agreement wants to enforce such change on a multinational level.

If people just woke up and took personal reponsibility into their own hands, everyone, including industry, would be making effective changes.

However they are not.

by tonythetiger

What "facts"?

How about the indications that three of the last four warm-ups in the last half million years were warmer than this one, and with LESS CO2?

There is no proof that CO2, man made or not, is a significant contributor to climate change. In fact, there is MORE evidence to suggest that it is the warming which allows CO2 levels to rise. All the data shows that the temperature started rising BEFORE the CO2 levels did.

Some things just make sense. Warmer climates lead to more (and more active) animal life, which results in more CO2.

by geek3001

The economic factor comes into play on both sides of the fence. One side could make billions if they can convince people that humans have a major impact on climate change. The other side could lose billions if it can be shown that humans do have a major impact on climate change.

When it comes to the first bone of contention, the true human impact, even six percent can be a problem can be a problem if we're close to a cusp. If this impact is cumulative, it can build up fast. Then you have to factor in population growth.

We really need to know more about our impact in order to make informed decisions. And it needs to be 'honest' knowledge, not hyped up or toned down to meet some political/economic agenda.

Bone of contention two does bring up a good point. It could easily become a money pit and scam center. At the same time, human impact could be changed through economic incentives/disincentives and advertising. We would 'just' have to figure out which activity changes have the biggest bang for the buck and use advertising and economic incentives to promote them.

Bone of contention three, the measurement standards, could be solved by identifying every unit of measure that is applicable and coming up with reliable and low cost ways of measuring them. The additional data would be worth it in terms of knowledge.

Bone of contention four, different rules for different countries, is a tricky one. Rich countries can get an advantage over poor countries by demanding that the highest standards be met. Poor countries can get an advantage over rich countries by demanding that they get a break because they don't have the money or technology to meet the highest standards. In either case, the environment is not a winner.