Discussion Locked

HELP! University of Phoenix Degree.

0 helpful
203 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK, I am busting it all out here and asking for your help. Are you a hiring manager? Would you hire a UOP graduate? The reason I ask is that due to the UOPs misleading tactics, I was enrolled there and graduated with a BSIT, I have since graduation been employed as a Secretary...because no one hiring believes that UOP is anything more than a degree mill. Please tell me if your company would hire a UOP graduate. I want to get a start on some hard data so I can fight this legally....I want to prove they "sold" me a bogus degree.

Also in your opinion what could someone in my shoes do to improve their chance of getting into the IT field??

Thanks,

KarenM.
If you do not want your comments public, please email me at mintlatte@gmail.com

203 replies

by jdmercha

Centennial, CO? Been there, Fun place.

Anyway, I do believe that UOP is an accredited university and not just a diploma mill. Your prolem is that you are competeing against others with degrees from MIT, Cal Tech, CU. It's not that your degree is worthless it's just that their degree is worth more.

Given the choice of one person from UOP and anther from Colordao State, (all other things being equal) the CS person would win out. On the opther hand; Given a choice between a person from UOP and a HS grad with an A+ (or other certs), I'd take the UOP person.

You may be able to do what I did. I too have a worhtless BS, but I followed that up with an MS from a quality school. Try applying to grad school at the University of Colorado. Assuming you did well enough at UOP you should be able to get into UC. An MBA from UC will open many more doors.

by jmgarvin

I'd suggest getting your foot in the door with help desk jobs. Eat dirt for a year or two because in the IT industry at this point you need three things to get started:
1) A degree
2) Certs
3) Experience

You have the degree. You may or may not have the certs (I highly suggest getting at least one or two of the CompTIA certs, just to get in...They'll only set you back $150 each and will pay for themselves very quickly). However, without the experience, you aren't getting into IT (at this point).

So, find that crappy IT job...even if you have to move, and get the experience. Get some certs under you belt with the experience and in a couple of years you'll see that degree pay off.

On a side not UoP is not a degree mill, even Dr. John Bear agrees with that. However, if you are up against someone with a degree in CS, you'll probably lose. Why? Number 2 and Number 3 are against you.

After a little experience is on the resume, the degree is just a HR hurdle to jump to get you into the interview.

by papanovember

I agree that there are at least 4 things that I use to select applicants:
1. A 4 year Degree from an accredited college
2. Recent Certifications
3. Experience
4. Best Fit

When I say "Best Fit" I mean someone who will appear to be a team player. You can all the credentials in the world, but with the wrong attitude at interview time nothing will happen! Applicants that I hire have to fit with the team that I am hiring them for...as I am interested in what the applicant can do for my company and the team that I am hiring the applicant to supplement.

by too old for it

Here in Ohio you can't sneeze without hitting a college or university. UOP is here in Central Ohio too, and I'm not sure what they were thinking. I can think of a 2-year state college and 7 four-year university's (eight if you count the Branch of OU in Lancaster) within easy driving distance.

The problem is not so much that there are too many degreed people running around. The young ones left long ago for job markets that enjoy an economy. The old ones left IT for a career ont he business side.

The real problem is that industry has left Central Ohio, and along with it some 250,000 jobs in the past 5 years that will never be replaced.

The last straw for me was when the politicians cut school funding in order to attract new business to Ohio. To date that hasn't worked. Go figure.

by jimmie.kepler

We have Univ of Phoenix graduates and others doing bachelors and masters at U of P working in our IT department. It is a regionally accreditated school. Like so many schools, you get out what you put in. I have been in my current job doing computer support since 1999. I clearly recall back in 2002 when we had one opening we had 925 unsoliciated applicates and over 100 referals from company employees. We hired a young lady who had been referred two years earlier when we had a previous opening in the department. She had interviewed then and reinterviewed this time around. Competition is tough! My manager, who use to be a support analyst working with me, but now has made manager, then senior manager applied 8 times over six years just to get his foot in the door in IT. I know when I career transitioned to IT a decade ago, during a time of lots of IT jobs, I applied at over 100 companies, went to about 20 interviews and job fairs, before I got the first real IT job. I had many I went to school with when I retrained in community college and self studied for A+ who gave up or were not willing to take the lower level, entry level IT wages. My first IT position was about a 66% decrease from the last non IT position. I still am not making what I use to. But I am working in my dream job of computer support. I know many we hire are shocked they have to work so many hours, with so much stress, and with ungrateful customers. Many have trouble with basic things like getting to work on time, getting back from lunch on time, and following company policy. Too many just want to do their own thing. Competition is tough! If this is what you are to do never give up. I go to church with several that are self-employed doing support and work part time at places like Wal-Mart while they try to get their IT business of the ground. Never give up because - Competition is tough!

by jeffusa

Most of the time with these degrees it is just a status thing. Higher society has been using tactics like this for centuries to keep people behind. Honestly, if they don't want to talk to you because you have a UoP degree, I would move on. You would not want to work there anyways.

For someone like myself who has made themself something from nothing, it can be very hard to get a degree. Financial aid will cover you to go to school but they may not pay for your housing. How are you suppose to do good in school if you also have to work a fulltime job? Plus, another nasty thing I have seen is people would hit the limit for financial aid in their last year or two. What a joke!

by jim.zhong

I interviewed some fresh graduates with online degree and 4-year university for some entry level programmer positions. I have to say students with 4-year degree have better understanding of CS, better logical, reasoning, and programming skills. The students with 4-year university degree have gone through much tougher fundamental CS and science courses, and have had countless sleepless nights for the most basic computer programming, assembly, OS, network programming, etc :). Yeah, if you all remember how terrible but fun those are. For those people going after "Cert" with no real life experience, the "Cert" is worthless. It gets even worse if they don't have the solid education background.

by microb

I personally know of three individuals who have received MIS degrees from UOP. Without question I would say that they essentially "bought" their degree, as they do not even know much more than the basic essentials of programming or the tools and techniques necessary for IT projects. I know because they routinely come to me for guidance and information. In my eyes they have given all UOP graduates a very bad reputation. I have talked to others who share this belief. I also know a former UOP instructor of MCSE classes. He tells me he was not qualified to teach any of his classes, both in knowledge and certifications, and that he just taught from the book.

by fungus-among-us

but our agency did agree to "reimburse" a former co-worker if she received a degree and maintained a 3.25 (equivalent or higher) grade.

I'm assuming that we would hire, since we did agree to reimburse... they must have some form of accredidation (sp). The only problem was... the person taking the online courses, never did her own work... she asked the techs here to "help" her. I refused, but others didn't. Long story short, this person ended up being terminated for illegal/improper use of her work PC. I don't think she ever finished her program from UOP, and the last I heard, she was living with a 3 time loser, and his 7 kids from 4 different mothers. Don't know, but in her current situation, don't think a degree from UOP would have mattered anyway.

Good Luck in your pursuits.

by rferrer61

The case scenario you described is sad. We are talking about a person who was trying to get hired because the financial reward and not because the love for the IT field. Yes, 99% of the time, a person like the one you described , cheating the system, ends on the unemployment line.
I am an Assistant Manager and I have done some hiring for my team. I would hire a UOP graduate because I am just finishing a Master on IT/Management myself. The UOP course is very interactive and fills you with a lot of good information. The instructors keep you motivated and help you getting the latest information available in relation to the class you are taking. I learned a lot myself during the Master and I think is a good virtual environment. I was in class with people from abroad, from the Navy, from Lockheed Martin, from NASA, and met in class guys working on military missions. I respect the UOP graduates very much but of course, like everybody stated, previous experience and certifications also count.

Regards,

Roger

by nuskool

Hi,

I realized I was in the same situation you describe about halfway through with my A.S. degree from ITT Tech. I got a crappy job, about a year ago @$13/hr. I did my best and I just got a raise and promoted to Network Administrator, making what an entry level college grad makes (according to our school).

I am going to UOP for my BSIT because I believe there program is better than ITT Tech's BSISS (Information System Security).

I think getting into any CAREER is difficult at first and don't forget, there are people that have degree's from even crappier colleges with bad grades that will end up getting a job somewhere.

The reason I am going to Phoenix is because they are regionally accredited which will make it easier to get into a regular university for my masters, (as is stated above) impossible from ITT Tech.

You should be proud that you had the motivation to finish your degree and all you have to do now is get a job in the field suck it up for a year and market your experience. I will be happy to send you a copy of my resume if you'd like. I posted it on Monster and have gotten responses from Fandango and other big companies, but at this point I feel a loyalty to my boss.

Well, I'm off to my first day of school at UOP. I wish I had gone to L.A. Trade Tech and Transferred to USC but, you have to make the best of your situation.

P.S. I'm only 23 so excuse me if I'm ranting about myself but, I'm just trying to encourage you not to give up, the opportunities are out there, you just have to look.

by madtechgirl

I strongly suggest that you check the universities you're interested in for a Masters degree to see if a degree from UOP would qualify you for their program. Unless you get an online Masters degree from another degree mill the UOP degree may not get you anywhere. There are online degrees and community colleges that are accredited and have a much better reputation. I personally would not waste my money and time on UOP. (I'm a 20 year veteran in IT and a hiring manager, when I see UOP the resume goes straight to the trash.)

by jmgarvin

I've had bad experiences from grads from all kinds of different schools. Hell, even the "name brand" schools graduates some real losers. I graduated from a state funded school and I ran circles around a guy from Stanford. Which school is "better?"

School boils down to: You get out of it what you put into it.

by ahfs1

Each of us have a different story, but my associates from ITT was worth every penny. I have worked for two different companies since getting my degree and these weren't/aren't 'crappy' jobs.

Kent State will transfer ITT credits, but only tech, no requirements. I'm sure if you looked into it, you would find that there are college's and universities out there which will transfer your credits.

by too old for it

At the HR office, and after the personal interview: There is brick and mortar, covered in old ivy.

Then there is everything else.

by roger99a

The problem I see with UOP is their unethical use of spam email to market the company. And since this unethical behavior has been going on for years without end I would have to assume that there are serious ethical problems within the whole university.

by tandchuck

My company gave me a 10% pay raise each year that I was enrolled with UOP, paid 100% of my schooling, and gave me a $20,000 pay raise once I received my BSIT degree.
I believe what you put into your education program is what you can get out of it. I preached to the students that were riding the coat tails of others for their team assignment grades, that a degree may get you a job nterview but knowledge will get you a job.

by kmellentine

I knew that at the time since I was working for a small manufacturing business that the degree would nto be important to them, and it was not.
But it also didn't help me get my feet in any doors. FOr the record, I was NOT the coattail rider, I was the leader of my team. Never, EVER was there an assignment that was not at least 85% my work. I put together all our presentations, my grade suffered because others in my group refused to speak or take part in some things, and I still graduated with an excellent GPA. I did say that I feel like the structure of UOP more fully supports people who ALREADY have jobs with companies where degrees stand between them and higher positions/salaries. I was not one of those people. I held the director of quality position in small company, and hoped to switch career fields as the industry we were in was already dead for the most part, and the company was set to just disappear as the owner was older and just wanted to retire.
I have seriously tried to sell myself to the tech industry for years. It just has not worked in my favor to the degree that I think a traditional degree would have.
Working one's way up to a director position in a small technically dead field didn't help me much either :-) but at least I loved it while it lasted.

by sdlnxgk

Did you actually learn anything while getting the degree??? Knowlege is power !!! I know plenty of techs who are self taught with no degree.. In the end it's how you apply yourself to what you have learned that gets you the job!!!

by jhogue1

If you don't get the interview, you have no chance to sell your skills and knowledge.

That is a prime reason that certifications and education are important. Degrees also show a potential employer that you can work within a rather rigid system and accomplish a long term goal.

by roger99a

You had to read it anyway. To satisfy your curiosity, this WAS a duplicate of my other post.

by navy moose

I received my MBA from UoP in 2004, my difference is I did mine on ground instead of online. My fiancee is studying for her MSCIS from UoP, this program is only online.

All things considered, we're both dissatisfied with UoP. Among my beefs were unqualified instructors for a number of courses. Textbooks which were out of date. Assignments which were long on pages written and short on material learned. I had a finance instructor who had decent written English and non-existent spoken English. The law instructor handed out assignments which had nothing to do with business law and were graded as if we were in law school.

Looking back, I should have gone to a local university, instead of UoP.

Would I hire someone from UoP, that would depend on their experience and certs.

If you're thinking of attending UoP, look elsewhere. Plenty of "real" universities have an online program.

Navu Moose

by secretgeekygirl

Thanks for your input Moose! It brings up some good points.

Another thing that I have just started back to -
the community college!

Now, when I was going to "regular" college back in the Dark Ages, community colleges were only places to go to get basic skills that were lacking, and to bone up on them if you were not ready for college level work. I went to a regular university, and had to leave due to a family crisis. I went to work full time while my father recovered from heart bypass surgery.

I will turn 48 this Sunday, and am currently attending my first semester taking courses at the local comm college! They have changed. I would not have even considered a comm college before, but when my daughter started going there last year after high school (no Univ near us, and she didn't want to leave home yet), I was amazed at the variety of courses and training now available.

Among them are associates degrees, various certifications, and preps for transfer to other univs for your bachelors.

Did I mention that I was taking ALL my courses online this semester? They have a fully integrated website that allows adult learners to take courses. And, I might add, they are not for sissies! Ha! I expected a little fluffier stuff online. Not sure if it is because my brain cells are older and used now, or because they actually are hard. The work was harder than I expected, and the grading requirements are tough.

The biggest complaint I have though is a faulty text in one class - the test answers (the tests are also online with immediate scoring results, and with two proctored tests per semester per class) are often "off". For example, one question from a test I took just yesterday asked (paraphrased) about what the program was called that provided icons to software programs. THis was a type-in response. I answered "Graphic User Interface (GUI)". I was counted wrong. Why? They wanted "GUI" or "graphicAL User Interface" or "graphical user interface or GUI". So, even though I was technically right, and had included the GUI, it was in parenthesis, and I left the "al" off the first word, it was counted as wrong. ARGH!!! A similar strange question and requirement on the first test - the answer did not correspond to the textbook's answer. (I even emailed the teacher, and quoted the text page, but did not get the test point credited for it. But, enough other people wrote to complain that she posted a note about how she would review the test results THIS time, but not on other tests! Geesh - just change the text!)

Well, all that mess was to suggest you check out your local community college for courses that are in your line of interest before doing an online place like UoP, IMHO.

by jhogue1

Community colleges can be wonderful places.

You do need to be aware that if you intend to pursue a 4 year degree not all CC courses transfer. For example, my university will not accept accounting courses from the local CC because they do not include all the topics we teach in our accounting courses.

by jhogue1

Most regular colleges that offer on line courses or degrees do not indicate on a student transcript whether a course was face to face or on line so an employer would have no way of telling how you took a course.

The university at which I work has the same faculty for face to face and on line courses so instructor quality is the same either way.

by suzitech

I graduated with a BS at Rutgers Univ. and experienced the same problems: instructors who couldn't communicate with the students because of language, outdated books and assignments (who the heck uses PASCAL anymore???), etc. Heck, we had instructors who were supposed to teach us "programming", yet had no idea how to do it in a UNIX-like environment, and the ENTIRE UNIVERSITY'S BACKBONE WAS UNIX BASED! I've walked out of a couple classes purely because the instructor introduced themselves on the very first day as "My name is so-and-so, I been in US for 2 month."

You'll have these same problems no matter where you go!

by falconeer

You won?t believe this. But a major program I did for the medical industry wanted it to be translated into ?Pascal?. Not a big problem, ?cept for time. Pascal is a great teaching language. Made no mess about things ?cept structure. Which, I guess, is the whole thing ?bout programming. Also, try try some non-bloating approaches. Whoops, wrong people...

by jcitron

I've had the same kind of professors at NECCO and U-Mass Lowell, and not at UofP. These guys and gals were definitely not qualified to teach. This was on campus, by the way, and long before the idea of distance learning.

In one of my computer science classes at Lowell, we never saw the professor. His assistant came in, administered the labs, and gave us the tests. The assistant did not speak a word of English, and rarely said anything at all.

At NECCO, I had an electronics professor that gave us exams that had nothing to do with the course work. You could study for months prior to the exam, and never pass because the two were so disconnected. I think he felt bad afterwards when everyone failed because he would scale the tests. Funny... Everyone got 16 points for their name, and then the points were weird for the rest of the exam so you'd still barely pass a lot of the time. The first question would be worth 65 points, and even though it was an essay, you'd get something like 35 points off if there was some slight error. After that it was down hill so you'd fail anyway no matter what.

I also had another teacher at NECCO evening class that treated the class as though she was teaching at Harvard full-time. We're working folks meeting two days a week, not full-time students on a campus with multitudes of time to devote to school work! I passed this class with a decent grade, but I was completely exhausted beyond anything I felt before.

So maybe I've been lucky so far. I've had better luck with my UofP instructors then with the ones I had at brick and desk colleges.

John

by secretgeekygirl

That will be interesting to see the responses, since so many places recommend UP. Even our local community college recommends them as an alternate way to obtain a BS/BA degree!

Not much point, if they are considered fluff. Of course, I haven't seen a whole lot of degrees that are worth very much! The last highly degreed goober my last company hired spent most of his time on the phone discussing his new puppy with anyone who would listen...

by too old for it

The school I'm looking to finish my degree (dual major: history & sociology) in has a stong percentage of people who actually have done what they profess to teach.

This is a rarity, since at most brick-n-mortars the tenured professors refuse to teach a class.

As far as the TA's, they usually are just older students, fresh outta high school and wet behind the ears. Round that out with "I've been in US only two month", and you have what you have.

(Of course my daughter was bringing up subject matter and research in her HS history calss that the teacher didn't have a clue about. Guess it runs in the family.)

by tkagin

I don't have a degree and I've been in IT for 10 years. I did go to college, but left early. Granted, I started in the glory days of IT. It seems harder now to get a good opportunity for people new to IT.

I've worked for a 4 different companies throughout my career, and served the most senior level positions in every job I worked. I routinely interview people, and I'll be honest, once you reach senior level positions (technical positions), a degree is rarely, if ever, noticed on a resume...once you get past an HR person. Management on the other hand is a different story.

The best advice I can give is to just take a job where you can get your hands dirty with a lot of technology. Most of the successful college kids that are now in IT, were formerly summer interns. That's the easiest way to get a real position out of college. Small tech companies are usually the best for more exposure, as big companies relegate more inexperienced workers to specific job functions, and let the more experienced people "play" with the interesting technology. Small companies are usually understaffed, and need cheap help. They won't be scrutinizing your resume too much. They'd rather you have a sincere desire to learn and be self motivated. I was had my boss tell me before I interviewed someone, "If he doesn't drool on himself, hire him".

Get certifications! From a technical interview perspective, these are more important than a degree.

Network, Network, Network. IT is a small world, so keep in touch with the smarter, more successful people you meet. Eventually, you won't have to go through a staffing company to get a new job. You'll be able to bypass all of the other resumes, with a good recommendation.

Always keep your resume updated and out there. Tailor it to the job your applying for. A resume is not a chronological list of what you've done. It's a piece of paper used to market yourself.

Don't get too comfortable in a job that you put the blinders on. Solid skill sets are hard to find. If you keep up with the industry, read more than your co-workers (literally learn something new every day), you'll be in demand. Always keep your head out there for other opportunities. You'll make your biggest gains when switching jobs, not from annual reviews. At one point, you won't even be worrying about money, but will be more focused on other aspects of a job to make you happy.

After your first "get your feet wet" type of job, choose every other job by thinking about how it will affect your career. Will the position be leading a team through some large upgrade/migration process? Will you be meeting with senior management routinely for some high profile project? These are launching pads for other positions.

Finally, don't become specialized in a vendor or product. Become specialized in a technology and learn multiple vendors/products. Learn the other facets that interact with the technology you've specialized in. IT folks get religious over their technologies, however they usually can barely speak about the competing products. These people are not respected by management. An unbiased view, weighing the pros and cons and how it applies to the specific environment will always get you more respect.

Before you know it, what college you went to, what degree you had, etc, will become irrelevant.

by geeksquad

A DEGREE DOES MATTER, BUT IF YOU HAVE CERTIFICATIONS IN MCSE, CCNA, CCNE, or A+, it makes a world of difference.These are the certs that matter more than any other degree. My advice is get into a company on the bottom floor, learn as much as you can, no book or training lab can replace real world experience.

by domiller0550

Certs are fine for some companies and others do not care about the cert as much as the formal education. As HR told us when hiring the last few help desk people "formal education means that someone can learn".

by mblanton

I, as well as many of you am one of these stories of experience. I just graduated college with a degree in Physical Education, teacher certification. However 2 days after graduating, my summer/seasonal employer brought me on full time as Tech Support/Help Desk analyst. This is simply because I have a legitimate 6 years worth of hands on experience in the field as well as people skills. And being that I've been with the company for a long time, I know everyone up through the corporate ladder and that is networking.

Also, our Network Administrator just started a couple months before me and he graduated with a degree in Marketing and simply has Networking experience...again...a lot of it comes down to experience. Best of luck!

by suzitech

While I think you're right that certs will get you into places, you won't go too far without the extra "something". Being able to talk geek-speak over everyone's heads isn't going to get to a cushy C-level job, it's taking broader "business management" courses that will help with that. We're talking topping out at maybe $90K as a technical person versus possibly going into 6 digits as a CTO or CIO.

I'm currently doing the UOP online thing for an MIS degree (I'm a lowly tech monkey, though only 1 of 2 people in this company with a higher level degree), and I've been worried about the same exact thing. I got the same answers as were posted here, ranging from it's a bad move to it's fine. Ultimately, UOP IS a brick-and-mortar school in Phoenix, and online students are just taking their distance learning courses. Most "name brand" schools have the same kind of classes available, UOP just happens to have a larger variety of classes you can take.

by jr_hearty

I have an irrellevant degree from the University of Tennessee - Knoxville. When I decided to make a career out of IT, I started with getting a basic certification (A+) - I got a job at secretary rate pay because of that cert and with experience got an MCSE. I've been able to work my way into much better positions since then.

In entry level IT positions, you'll find that the certs tend to matter more than the degree. Some kcompanies, mine included, will only hire people with a degree, so that narrows down the competition a little bit.

It would be really valuable if some colleges would include a few certification programs in with there curriculum. I'm not sure why UOP wouldn't have already done this.

That said, I would definitely hire UOP graduates. I don't see any stigma attached.

by eddie n

It also mirrors my own experience. Been in and around the tech field for more than 15 years, starting from high school, into university and after. The biggest stumbling block nowadays is the clueless HR department: they are the gatekeepers and unfortunately they do not really know what sort of person is really needed on the shop floor, so to speak. Give me a choice between someone with a degree from the finest school in the land with no experience, and someone who (like the uber-geek Bill Gates) for some reason or other did not finish a degree but has experience to spare, and I will take the experienced person in a flash -- no matter how old s/he is.

To add to tkagin's advice, I would say that if possible, you should use your summers not only to intern at a smaller company (that helps your networking = meeting people, and you get more exposure to real-world problems = building up your real-world experience) but also do a cert or two during the summer as well. This way, when you graduate, you are the perfect storm: you have the degree (thus satisfying the paper chasers at HR), you have some real-world, hands-on experience (thanks to the internships), and you have an industry-sanctioned certification or two (which not only makes the HR people happy, it also makes the legal dept. happy too -- a nice piece of paper that shows that you are "qualified" to touch the company's precious hardware, thus saving the company from potential litigation).

If there was one piece of advice I wish I had been given when I was a freshman, it would have been that. As it was, though, our dean of the faculty also gave us some spot-on advice: "Know that 80% of the stuff you learn in year one of your five year degree course will be rendered obsolete by graduation". Moral of the story: your learning doesn't stop once you get that sheepskin. Like the Carpenters sang, "It's only just begun" :)

Good luck!

by mr t-man

I earned my degree in Programming from one of the colleges that had the accelerated programs, I was working in just about every field except IT. 4 yrs ago I got a job at a company as benefits admin, a year later there were openings for helpdesk position and I jumped on it. Now I have been working in the desktop support, data analyst, and application support position for 3 yrs now,& come to think of it I am not even working in the field I went to school for(Programming). Most of the IT folks suggested that I work with, suggested I get one of Microsoft certification or certified in Programming.
hope this helps

by madtechgirl

Five years ago as a hiring manager the company I worked for then had an applicant with a PhD in Web Development from U of P! I had never heard of U of P at that time and I knew that no legitimate university had a PhD program in Web Development. I looked online to see what they were about and the classes listed were bullshit classes for the "degree" in question. We interviewed the applicant (because the recruiter was naive enough to be impressed) and needless to say she was no where near qualified for the position. She was a joke as far as the interview was concerned.
I consider degrees from online universities and tech colleges only for positions like network admin. If you want to be a programmer you need a legitimate 4 year college degree and you need to be able to write code in specific languages. If you want to be a DBA you need certification in the particular database of choice. If you want to be a systems analyst or project manager you need a legitimate 4 year degree, certification and years of experience. If you get an online degree make sure that it is an extension of a legitimate accredidated bricks and mortar college. That's my personal view, it does not reflect the policy of my current employer or any other employer I've worked with.

by sr10

What is a "legitimate" degree? And why does a programmer or analyst need two years of core courses having nothing to do with the subject of study?

by cajtech

When an IT professional finishes a task, he/she is often required to write a report on the work accomplished. He/she is also often required to quote services, understand DAQ enviroments, and report all of this to managers, engineers, quality assurance, purchasing, etc. This is why there are two years of "unrelated" education needed to be an IT PROFESSIONAL.

by projmanager

I have 38 years in IT so I can speak with a little experience. While you may be satisfied to just "write code" all day, most people wish to move up the ladder, make more money, etc. Well, to do that, you have to have a sense of what your customers need. They're not just looking for a tweak in the registry or the hotest .NET code around. They're looking for solutions to real business questions and you need to be smart enough to discuss in their terms. Have that accounting background, learn about project planning, know what how to talk like a business person and you'll be a success in IT. Oh, and brush up on those presentation skills, know how to use all the tools they use every day and it will make a difference.

by geoffrey.gerlach

If you really want an edge, get certified in the area you want, cisco for networking, microsoft for developement, or database.

by dmack58

I have one question, after receiving your degree from U of P do you believe you can do the work?

If so, the degree doesn't matter.
Our very BEST tech was a music major who didn't even bother to finish his degree.

Whatever you decide your next step is going to be, be sure that you pick significance over security. If you have to, pick a lower paying tech job with potential then a higher paying deadend job - and don't be afraid to job hop to build your skillset. You will find that if you REALLY love what you do the money will follow.

by jhogue1

Just being certified does not necesssarily prove that you can do the work. There are a lot of cram schools out there that spend a few days cramming you full of test answers. Certification only means that you can pass a test.

A few years ago I applied for a DB manager job with the certs they wanted. They shut me into an office with a PC and a big data base. I had one hour to produce a professional looking report that explained the data to their managerial level people.

by nesdog1122

I'm an instructor at UOP teaching in the IT track. I'm currently a network admin plus 25 years in IT.

Many of my students think they'll get the "big paying job" by completing this program. This is exactly what I heard when I was among the first wave of techies earning an MCSE in the 90's. And what I heard when I earned an M.B.A. in the 80's.

It doesn't work like that. As a hiring manager, I'm mainly interested in 1) how do you fit in with the culture of our organization? 2) what do you bring to the table IN EXPERIENCE?

Every organization is willing to invest in its staff, if they are a decent company however we don't have the time to spend months bringing you up to speed. Book learning is great but you need real hands-on background. That is what gets you hired. The degrees, certs, etc. are meaningless unless you can show some skills.

My first job after earning an MCSE was Helpdesk, and paid nothing. But I paid my dues and worked my way up.

Would I hire a UOP grad? Sure...provided you have more on the table than a piece of paper.

Good luck and hang in there.

by timofog

Hi,

The short answer to your question of would my company hire you is probably no. We have a requirement that technical people have a degree from an acredited program. As near as I can tell UOP's IT programs are not acredited, at least in CO. The school is acredited but that is not the same. We tend to use ABET as our criteria mainly because all the schools in our region have ABET acredited programs in Engineering and IT. One caveat is not all programs at a particular school may be acredited as it is by program not institution. One school's mechanical engineering degree may be ABET acredited while it's electrical engineering program may not be.

On another subject, it looks like you have discovered one of the best kept secrets in education - the community college system. I, my wife and daughter are all graduates of the community college system. We all have diplomas that say University of Minnesota on them and have successful careers in the medical and technical fields. All of our lower division and quite a few upper division courses were taken at a community college. My wife, at age 43, decided to return to school after being in the workforce (secretarial type jobs) for 25 years. She was able to do three years of her undergrad work at the community college before transfering to the UofM to finish a degree in the medical field. It was a long road but she is much happier in her new career.

Good luck on your journey!

by secretgeekygirl

I was amazed at how much was really available at the community colleges these days! Ours is small, but also offers certification programs, in addition to continuing ed, associates degrees and transfer degree programs.

I just started back last month for the first time in over 20 yrs. I am taking courses that are actually interesting to me and useful to me now. What I would have had a degree in way back when - when I atteneded college the first time, would have very little in common with my interests now.

I've worked in the accounting field for almsot all of those 20 yrs, and I really don't like it! LOL! So, taking courses in graphic design and desktop publishing, where my heart lies....

by alexander323

A college degree means only one thing; you can learn. There has been for the last half century hype around a degree mostly due to marketing. Most of the greatest minds in history were not formally trained or were drop outs. There are some areas that need formal training such as physics and design, but there are however some that do not like IT. The experience sets you apart. I went to a big 12 school and did not find what I was looking for after two years so I started working. Next thing you know here I am. I have several certifications; MCSA, Net+, CITRIX, A+, iSeries, etc. That has always got me in the door. I am going to UoP currently and will finish with my masters at UCCS just for the season tickets (lol). UoP is accredited and fast, whats the big deal. You get what you put in. I see a lot of people that just get by. The bottom line is that when you get a UoP degree you can read, write a coherent sentence and speak to a group. You may not be the best candidate but it is a start. You have to under stand that every degree is not an "I know it all" wall paper but an "I can be taught, please give me experience" wall paper. Take heart in knowing that you have accomplished something, easy or hard, it is an accomplishment. I have worked with several people who have a BS or MS from traditional schools and all of them ended up asking me to help with something. Can you pick up a book, retain the information in it, and then apply the information from it? That is what a degree says you can do; you have the paper to prove it. Anyone who would say they based a hire on where they went to school and not on what the person can offer the company is either from the ACC or narrow-minded and it is probably not a good idea to work for them any way. Any one who hires should look at your experience and what your accomplishments are. That should be the focus of your resume not your degree. Go get the experience as the others have said and you will be fine.

by islandittechie

Hi! I'm fairly new to IT (only been working IT for about 6 years now) and obtained my IT degree from UoP in 2004 while I was in the military. The degree itself did nothing to get me a job. What got me my first IT job is my past experience in the military and connections. As mentioned by a previous poster, I also agree that a BS/BA degree in the context of IT is simply an HR cutoff to slim down their list of candidates. Ultimately what gets you the job is the strength of your experience and the certifications you posess. I do want to add that there's one big thing that I've seen many IT folks overlook and that is communication. I was so paranoid about my interview because I'm not the best speaker in the world so I took speech and communications classes before I left the military. Those classes paid off as my first job interview went smoother than glass (and I got the job to boot) Being that it was a help desk position, I used that job to further improve my communication skills while I was studying and earning certifications. After a year, I was able to move on to a Systems Administrator position and I was fortunate enough to work with the guy who interviewed me for the position. I asked him not too long ago what made him choose me over the other candidates and he told me that there were three other guys that had pretty much the same level of experience and mix of certifications that I had and what made me stand out was that I was the easiest to speak and relate to during the interview. So to answer your first question, a degree from UoP shouldn't hurt your chances of getting a job more than it will help your chances as long as you don't forget to back the degree up with certifications and hopefully experience (even if it's just a simple help desk job; you'll be surprised how much you learn working helpdesk if you really try to do your best) And to answer your second question, I suggest tapping your local community college for speech and communications classes to improve your communicative skills. It's one thing to have the knowledge and another thing entirely to be able to communicate that knowledge to someone else.

by kmellentine

Well, I do have hope, it would appear that my biggest problem is that I lack experience. I have learned that UOP is a wonderful program for people who are employed in their fields or have experience and need degrees to meet HR requirements. That however was not me. My experience is limited to tech support in small companies. BUT you all have given me a great deal of hope...I have checked into certifications, and ordered some self study books. I plan to rewrite my resume to capitilize on the experience I do have...(I have helped two companies chose entirely new database systems, helped them transfer information from the old to the new and get up and running including troublshooting and testing the new systems) although my title and main job responsibilities do not reflect this.
So: the plan

1. Get certified. (A+)
2. Explain my experience better on my resume.
3. Highlight how awesome it is that I can do both business AND IT, and that I LIKE working with end users.
4. Look for help desk and entry level positions.

Thanks all for your honesty. And your ideas. I had almost given up and decided to just head into high level secretarial :-(
Even though it would seem the obvious thing to do, I had avoided certs because I thought people would look at that the same way they look at my degree....I understand the cert program better now, and I do think it will be helpful.

It was really nice to see so many helpful answers, and y'all totally helped me out of a bit of a personal slump.

by matt

Even with 5+ years of experience as a Systems Administrator, I found it very, very difficult to get a callback for interviews.

When I got my BSIT from UoPhoenix, I was truly surprised at the amount of responses I got back. For me, getting a degree was one of the things that got me through the mechanical HR filter.

The other thing that helped was my MCSE. Some folks will tell you that certifications mean nothing. They mean exactly the same as a college degree: I can study, I can take tests, and I can at least spell "IT."

I believe that you're on the right track with chasing more certifications and looking for helpdesk positions (most of which *are* entry level). Almost every good Systems Engineer and Project Manager I've met has done time as a Helpdesk Technician or Support Analyst.

Just keep your head and make sure you're making decisions about education and job positions that make sense for your mid and long-term goals.

Good luck, it's a jungle out there.

by julian.tang

I know exactly how you feel. I went through the same experience at DeVry. I had classes where I knew more than our instructors and they were literally developing courses as we went through them. To me it was an expensive $20K piece of paper. As much as I am disappointed with my education from them, I did achieve what I wanted from them which was a BS in telecommunication.

I started going there with 5 years in IT industry and already working as a sys admin at one of the worlds largest architecture firm. I saw more technology than many of the instructors had seen their whole entire career. My girlfriend on the other hand, was new to the entire field, besides using her computer at home, she had never seen a network before. While she knew at a bigger university like UCLA, etc, the education would be different, she learned a lot there because she didn't have any knowledege of the field in the first place. I would rate Devry's education as beginner to intermediate, but the technology you learn there is definately dated.

As for Certifications, I agree they are just a peice of paper, I have several of them. What are they good for you ask? A few things, one is getting your foot in the door, ie through HR filtering, and showing your possibly qualified for the job. Two, if you don't know that subject area it is a good way of learning about it and showing you understand the subject. And three, I think it helps when justifying your salary.

My certs, degree and experience help justify why I should get paid a certain amount and its balanced by responsibilities on the job.

At the end of the day, I find my greatest competition are people who can self-teach themselves and also have degrees and certifications.

That's just my 2 cents.

by arthur.bonilla

It is about the skill that they bring to the job, yes!! a previous response said it is what they get and what they put into the class, absolutely yes!. A new hire must have some willingness to be humble and learn the new job. Lots of people that come in the door have their chests all pumped up that they can do this and that, but fall flat. It is a tough job trying to discern the overall skill level that a candidate brings. As a manager you have to be ready to ask the kind of questions that require a lot of research to properly identify a good candidate who will fit the particular position and run with the ball

by newby7718

As an IT Manager, I am more interested in accomplishments. Some college is essential, but certificates, experience and performance are the factors that make a difference in our shop.

by newby7718

As an IT Manager, I am more interested in accomplishments. Some college is essential, but certificates, experience and performance are the factors that make a difference in our shop.

by apotheon

These days, colleges in general are just degree mills (for the most part). I think college actually made me stupider.

Stupider? Is that a word?

by tig2

Like funner.

Agree completely with your point. All I got from education was how to think like the prof. What I didn't get was how to think for myself.

All in all, work has taught me the most and the best.

by jmgarvin

I tend to agree. Colleges, anymore, really put the onus on the student to put in a LOT more to actually walk away with a good eduction.

It's a sad commentary when schools like Stanford put out CS majors that have a hard time writing simple code.

by hiventur

I felt UoP was a mill when compared to Community College. Then I turned to the state University System for a MSIT. I had the same impression but the classes lasted longer. What really helped nail the new and better position was my persuit beyond the MSIT. Taking on Oracle and *nix honed skills not taught. Use of these skills in volunteer positions demonstates the ability. A good student does not make a good employee. A driven person will find and or make the opportunities open up. At job fairs no one seriously talked to me till I put PL SQL and that the MSIT was nearly completed on the resume.
Advice, leverage your position into training opportunities and persue a path and keep looking for side doors.
Keep Trying!

by mdhealy

I probably wouldn't but then I'm in an R&D environment where everybody has at least a master's degree or doctorate plus significant experience.

But I think what you need to do is first determine what somebody who went to a top-notch program in your field would know, then learn whatever you need that you don't have, then find a way to convince prospective employers you know it.

I can't help you much with the convincing part, but I do have a suggestion for determining how your knowledge compares with the level of knowledge the folks at a topnotch place would have: poke around the MIT website. MIT has put most of their course materials -- syllabi, lecure notes, audio lectures, etc., etc. online freely available to anybody. From that you should be able to compare your background with what MIT students are expected to know.

Good luck.

by dolcetta

I think it is odd that you wrote you were "enrolled there and graduated with a BSIT." You don't make it sound like getting the degree took much effort. I have had peers who worked their arses off to get a BS from UoP, so I know they are not a degree mill. While UoP has regional accreditation as an institution, they do not have programmtic accreditation. For example, their Information Technology degree is not accredited by the Computing Accreditation Commission of the Accreditation Board of Engineering and Technology. Such a lack may cause some people to question the rigor of the program. -Mike

by kmellentine

Well, I won't say it was not work, because it WAS. (Not only that, but we worked in groups, and traditionally I carried my group....) In terms of the business side, I would think that any traditional university would be hard pressed to meet the level of that education.

Here is where I struggle, while it is a BSIT, it is tech "lite". As a newbie, I learned a lot about tech, but NOTHING compared to friends I know who did the traditional route. Our required programming class was limited to C++. The longest program I was required to write was a program for money conversion for travelers. I learned more in a single week long visual basic class in community college than I did at UOP.

My largest problem with my degree is that I can see where I fit beautifully, I just can not make HR people and hiring managers see where I fit, and the most COMMON thing I hear is that they typically do not hire UOP grads for technical positions.

Because I went to college later than most, unlike a lot of IT grads, I had experience as a USER on all types of systems, from cash registers all the way up to full scale manufacturing databases. I progressed in all my positions and I can see how the structure of the database can impact the company in all areas. I have experience in accounting, customer service, secretarial/admin, factory, and basically just about every other end user position where we have to deal with the database and its issues.
Essentially, what I am saying is that I have skills, they are just more soft skills....but I think they are valuable. It is clear to me however from everyone I have talked to that to get into the soft skill positions, I have to start out in the hard skill ones, where I find myself lacking. Hopefully studying for certs and doing some more practice programming can beef up my confidence in this area.
All I can say is that at least I excel over competition in the field I am in now. Not many secretaries can write little custom databases based on their bosses whim of the day.

by stan20

Bill Gates never went to college at all, and he did better than the idiots who don't base their hiring decisions on the INDIVIDUAL. All schools have some graduates who will excel, and some who aren't worth bothering with.

In this field, there are many stars who either never went to college at all or were in completely unrelated fields. The first president of US Robotics (and the best programmer in the company) was a high school drop-out. Only one of the other founders of USR had a degree in anything computer related. I know because I was one of the other original founders. And there are lots of other examples.

These places that judge people simply by their impression of the school applicants went to would never have hired many of the best people in IT.

I'd look at smaller companies that want someone who can perform and grow as the job grows.

As I said before, the hardest part when you are first starting out is getting the attention of the person making the decision and selling them on your ability.

by dolcetta

You can always work the Help Desk for a while to prove your technical skills and mettle. The Help Desk is a great way to get your foot in the IT door. Get some great certifications while you're there, maybe even with training and testing paid for by the company. Springboard from that to a tier 2 tech position, specialized topic of interest, or supervision/management (for which a BSIT should be of solid value). -Mike

by stan20

Over the years I've held most every position, from Junior Electronic Technician to Chief Technical Officer and Vice President for R&D, and now I have the final say on all technical hires.

Maybe its because of my own background (I went to the Univ. of Chicago, but dropped out after about 3 and a half years because I was learning so much more on my own), but I've never been impressed by either degrees or certifications.

Some of the best people I ever hired had no degree, or a degree in an entirely different field.

It?s very hard to tell which people will work out and which ones won't, but there are some things that I've learned that seem to increase the chances of hiring a developer who will be a great asset to the company.

The first thing I look for is a love of technology. I want people who get excited about new projects and hardly consider it work. People who can't wait to get to work in the morning and have to be told to go home at night. These people always outperform people who just consider it a job. If people working for me aren't happy, then they are less productive and I'm not doing my job.

Next, I look for someone who enjoys learning new things. Technology is always changing and people who don't enjoy learning will soon be obsolete.

And of course problem solving ability is essential.

Then I look at things like the ability to work with other people and communicate clearly, work experience, etc. I really don't care what school you went to, or if you have a degree at all, if you have the qualities I'm looking for. If you do, the odds are very good that you will learn anything that you need to know (on current and future projects), and that you will be a valuable addition to the company. Then, I see my job as transmitting the company goals, making sure you have everything you need to be productive (before you know you need it), and making sure that valuable employees would rather work here than anywhere else.

With my company degree from UOP wouldn?t hurt but it wouldn?t help either. But most other companies place more weight on a degree and I can?t say how much it might mean to them.

The way I see it, the biggest problem you will have starting out in IT will be standing out from the crowd enough to get an interview with someone high enough up to make a decision. Its not unusual to get a hundred applications for every opening and without experience or something on your resume that will stand out its very hard to get past the HR department or whoever has the job of selecting a small number of qualified applicants who will actually be interviewed. About all I can say is don?t get discouraged. Think of it as a test of your problem solving skills! After you get some experience it does get easier.

by mikebertie

Having had experience as a hiring manager for over 8 years, I can say emphatically that the college from which you obtained your degree doesn't count for as much as some may indicate. I believe part of your issue may simply be that you need to sell it bit more in the resume.

Sure, a degree from some other universities seems better on the surface, but there are other considerations. For example, you probably didn't finish your degree on a free grant from mom and dad, but held down a full-time position while accomplishing that goal. Nothing to sneeze at.

Also, I have some experience with that degree program itself....it is a lot of work. I don't know about yourself, but I spent countless hours interacting with fellow students, leading small (and sometimes poorly motivated) teams to success (never received less than a 96% on an assignment in 20 classes), researching my ass off, and most importantly...proving that I know how to learn on my own....which is the way it is done in the field.

I've hired more than a few software engineers over the years, and while it may not be obvious, the best, brightest, hardest working engineers didn't even have degrees. Give me a guy or gal with heart and a mega-work ethic with a GED anytime over someone who skipped through a degree while that was all they had on their mind.

It comes back to selling yourself better in my humble opinion. Key in on team leadership / collaboration skills, ability to quickly absorb new technologies and concepts (remember, we didn't have 16 weeks to absorb the material....only 5, and having been through both kinds of courses, the material's depth was pretty much the same), proven ability to successfully interact with remote team members to accomplish critical tasks (a growing need in our international world), and your personal drive to complete your degree.

Trust me, if a potential employer can't see the pluses in that...you don't really want to work for them.

by gibison

I completely agree that a well rounded education is necessary in a professional environment. Everyone seems to assume, however, that online degrees lack this. I have taken English, speech, business, literature all online. I have the unique perspective of having gone to 4 years of "brick and mortar" universities, as well as 3 years of online courses. I can tell you that I have received as good if not better education online then I did sitting in a class. It all comes down to the type of learner you are. Some people are auditory, while others are visual. An auditory learner would have difficulties with an online class. I think it's also important to point out that of the three different "brick and mortar" universities I have attended, all of them offered their fair share of online courses. An online class forces a student to, well, be a better student. If you don't read the material and do the homework you will not pass! At a traditional class the student sits in a room and listens to a teacher rehash the same information that is in the book. While the repetition may help some, in my experience this typically replaces having to read the book. Of course this is not always the case but it is the norm. In summation, don't knock it until you've tried it. Knowledge is power and I don't remember anyone ever saying "but only if it's acquired at a four year university."

by cajtech

By using the word Your in your heading, you have proven that English, and other related courses are needed for a career. This includes, not only IT, engineering, mathmatics, etc, it in needed for a career in any feild. "Your" is a possessive form of you. "You're" is the contraction of "You are" that you intended to use.

by gibison

I find it disheartening that through my post all you could focus on is my misuse of a single word. Had I in fact been writing a dissertation or applying for a job, perhaps I would have taken greater care to check my grammar. I should point out that you misspelled field with "feild". I would doubt that this has anything to do with a lack of intelligence on your part, but rather a hurried response. So maybe, just maybe I'm not ignorant because I didn't write a rough draft and proof read my post more toughly. It?s possible both of us are unintelligent and should resign from our positions immediately. Hold the phone; before we go crazy why not give each other the benefit of the doubt and concentrate on the issue at hand. Flaming accomplishes very little. I welcome any comments directed towards the validity of my post. I also don't mind being corrected, and you are correct I made an error and I feel foolish for making such a simple mistake. We are after all only human. Tell you what; I'll forgive your attempt to belittle me if you'll forgive my slight grammatical error. Deal? Moving on, my intention was to point out that I have yet to hear anything that suggests that an online school is inferior to the typical university. I was trying to give my own personal experience as a testament to the quality of an online education. While there exist varying strengths and weaknesses of both, I don't believe an online education can be dismissed as being substandard. It is my belief that you get out of an education what you put into it. How many people do you know that went to a traditional school, partied every weekend, didn't take it seriously, but managed to pass classes and get their degree? I've known far too many. Why must we place more value on where an education was received then we do on the knowledge of the individual? As far as any form of education is concerned, how often is book smarts a substitute for experience? College is learning about how it's supposed to work, experience teaches you how it really works.

by gpastorelli

You should run your post through a spell check. You spelled not one but two words wrong, I believe you meant "mathematics", not "mathmatics" and "field", not "feild". Before we go spitting proper forms and possessive words let's concentrate on the "I before E except after C".

Sorry I don't mean to go off topic but it pisses me off to no end when people get on their high horses because of grammer and try to invalidate someones intelligent reply to the original topic.

by apape

That's completely uncalled for, tmeche. You are not better than everyone else here.

by navy moose

I graduated with an AA in Business from a local community college. When I transferred to University of Massachusetts, they took credits for a lot of my courses but not the actual course itself. I had to re-take management, marketing, and an accounting course when I got to UMass.

Navy Moose

by scifiman

Yes, I would hire you, Karen. That is if you were otherwise qualified. Your original post however makes it sound like you are just entering IT. That is what makes it hard. IT is just now recovering to the point where people can start job hopping again. So you're up against some experienced people.

I didn't do the online courses as I happened to work at Motorola in Phoenix at the time and went to classes on campus. I was 15 years deep into IT by the time I went looking for another job. Since then I have never had anyone say UOP was a negative, and after graduation I went on to work for Billion dollar companies (Wickes Lumber, USR/3Com, etc.) as well as tiny companies.

I will tell you though that breaking into IT can be tough in this market. Offer to intern or work for free for a month to prove your value.

by suzitech

I'm currently pursuing an MIS degree at UOP and had the same concerns. According to the advisors I've spoken to, UOP is an accredited school that grades with the same grading criteria as Harvard. That means whatever grade you received at UOP should be the same grade you would have received at a corresponding class at Harvard. Whether that's true or not, who can know, but I know that for me to get out of this low-level tech grunt position, I need business skills.

UOP IS a brick-and-mortar school, and taking the online courses is part of their "distance learning" program. You're supposed to learn exactly the same things as you would sitting in a room with 300 other students. The bias is because it's an online course and that automatically constitutes the "slacker" idea in many people's minds.

You have the BS degree, but the IT field in general is so competitive that you need more just to get an entry level job. Get a few certifications (that seems to be the big ticket to get in the door, though everyone and their mothers now have MC-something or other), and keep pushing to up your education. The future of IT will require a Masters or MBA in addition to an IT related degree just for a basic entry level job, so just keep adding to your skill set. Not just the technical stuff, as every 12-year old now can program and troubleshoot, but the more intangible things, like project management skills, planning skills, etc. Trust me, you need a seriously well-rounded education in so many different areas to be able to progress.

I'd eye up the companies that won't hire you because you've attended UOP. That sounds like discrimination tactics to me, as you're supposed to have the same knowledge as any other college student. How can they discriminate someone who worked just as hard as someone who went to a "real school"?

by gibison

While some may see online learning as little more then a fad, there have been numerous studies conducted on the differences of a traditional education vs. online education. I encourage you to check out the links at the bottom of this post. Online learning is still in its infancy. Given the time to work out any kinks that may be present I believe most traditional schools will adopt online programs, if they haven't already. Take a look at the colleges in your area. I am willing to bet most offers a number of online classes. IT more then any other profession should be the one that welcomes this trend with open arms. We are on the forefront of the digital revolution. Isn't that why we got into this business in the first place?

A CNET article on online education vs traditional.
http://news.com.com/2100-1023-263035.html

A summary of multiple studies conducted on online education.
http://www.csbsju.edu/itservices/teaching/csic-summary.htm

by suzitech

Great articles. I do have to admit the teaching process, while needed some getting used to, has been effective so far. I've JUST started pursuing my MIS degree and am 4 weeks into it, and the collaboration and working together with my "classmates" is definitely qualitatively better than what I had experienced as an undergrad. Everything is put in writing and the discussions range into so many different areas. I find that I retain information better BECAUSE we are having critical thinking sessions as a group. I certainly didn't have as high a quality of discussion sessions living at school.

It may not be traditional, but I think it works. Too a lesser degree and scope, but related in my opinion, a recent study showed small children learn better while watching tv shows that mimic conversation directly to the child (think: Mr. Rogers asking you questions and acting like he got a response). That back-and-forth reply and response system seems to work well in a learning environment for any age.

by gibison

I completely agree that a well rounded education is necessary in a professional environment. Everyone seems to assume, however, that online degrees lack this. I have taken English, speech, business, literature all online. I have the unique perspective of having gone to 4 years of "brick and mortar" universities, as well as 3 years of online courses. I can tell you that I have received as good if not better education online then I did sitting in a class. It all comes down to the type of learner you are. Some people are auditory, while others are visual. An auditory learner would have difficulties with an online class. I think it's also important to point out that of the three different "brick and mortar" universities I have attended, all of them offered their fair share of online courses. An online class forces a student to, well, be a better student. If you don't read the material and do the homework you will not pass! At a traditional class the student sits in a room and listens to a teacher rehash the same information that is in the book. While the repetition may help some, in my experience this typically replaces having to read the book. Of course this is not always the case but it is the norm. In summation, don't knock it until you've tried it. Knowledge is power and I don't remember anyone ever saying "but only if it's acquired at a four year university."

by madtechgirl

I didn't say online learning was not acceptable. I said that online degrees, meaning something from UofP is not acceptable. There are plenty of "bricks and mortar" colleges that have online courses and you can in fact, get your degree by solely attending online classes.
My point is you need a well rounded education and the skills for the job.

by hadg

I have a UoP degree and am working as an IT Director. The UoP is accredited just like other schools. Having said that, though, I know that some schools have more prestige than others. So, it is assumed that graduates from those schools have a pedigree. However, like any education, it's what you put into it that counts. For example, I know someone who has an MIS degree from a 'reputable', traditional school. However, he could not turn on a computer if his life depended on it. On paper, a hiring manager would tkae them over me; but in an interview I would win out.

If questioned about the UoP's relevance I would use this argument:

*It is not a traditional school where kids out of high school attend.

*It is geared for working adults that are for the most part working in the field that they are studying.

*The teachers work in the field they teach.

*Typical UoP students don't need to learn the traditional theories that the typical 'college student' learns.

What the UoP attempts to do is get a degree to those people who did not have access to a traditional education when they were younger. Personally, I did not have ready access to a traditional university, so the UoP was my best option. But, it was not easy. I also did not want to attend one or two classes per week for 18 weeks. And no, I don't work for the UoP, and no I was not fully satisfied with the whole program; but, which one is perfect? But like I said, you get what YOU put into it.

What you can do to get into the IT field is make sure that you do have technical skills. The BSIT, like mot UoP classes, is focused on the business end. It is not really a Computer science degree. So make sure that you do have the technical skills for the job. No longer can you have broad knowledge of technology. You need to select a skill path: networking, development, security, etc. and work from there. I hope this helps, and good luck.

by pancho_dba

Well said. Computer science grads still have to do a lot of OJT because their programs tilt toward the theoretical. Real life applications still have to be learned at the business site and few academic departments teach those.

by netposter

The best answer is that ?it depends? on many factors.

I am required to interview potential candidates and to participate in the hiring decisions for applicants targeting technology roles at our firm. A degree is not a first consideration, since the most valuable experience is actual and relevant work experience in the field. As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, a ?best fit? is for the company is sought since a candidate will have many responsibilities. A ?best fit? is a combination of being personable(we provide consulting services), a hunger for learning and keeping up with technology advancements, communication ability (written and oral), and the proverbial ?can do? attitude.

What a degree confers to me is that the applicant accepted a huge responsibility and ran through it to completion whether the degree was from Harvard or the University of Phoenix Online. Other than that, I consider degrees to be more important for other types of professions such as medical or legal. Computer science information is relatively easy to obtain from the local bookstore, library, or the Internet, and most persons with sufficient initiative can become quality IT professionals through self-teaching activities.

I am a 2005 UoP Online BSIT graduate, and I would like to provide an objective answer. In my personal experience with the university, about two-thirds of my fellow classmates were dedicated to the projects and to the program. In every class there were slackers and these slackers were discovered early on. Unfortunately, it is the slackers who tend to dilute the market value of a UoP degree. Since the university is for profit, there is incentive to reduce the admission standards to keep the enrollments up and the stockholders happy, and this allows a small percentage of students to receive a degree without contributing the same effort as more conscientious students. Should any of the slackers be hired and not work out, the university is blamed and could become a red flag for future applicants. I do not believe it is fair, but I do not blame employers either.

The UoP Online degree is not a right fit for everyone. It was a perfect fit for me and I enjoyed going ?beyond? the course objectives, since I had roughly seven years of IT experience under my belt. Some of the real benefits are not even tangible from a high-level perspective. The BSIT degree is really a business oriented program in that it provides mostly theory on how to best utilize and align technology to meet business goals. The real emphasis in on group projects, team dynamics, understanding organizational behavior, communication, and various approaches to conflict resolution. The entire UoP process was extremely beneficial and had upped my professionalism quotient by leaps and bounds. The president of our company has commented many, many times on my growth and transformation. I owe it mainly to the constant writing of papers and applying critical thinking skills (strongly emphasized by UoP).

As for hiring a UoP graduate, the answer is ?Yes,? based on what I had to go through to obtain my degree. However, the hiring decision is only one facet. Applicants will still need to prove themselves to ensure a good long term fit for the company.

by anniemae46

First of all, anyone who does not value your efforts to actually getting an education, may not be the best prospective employer anyway. You need figure out, where to apply your BSIT; i.e., sector, trend, etc. That may require more research. "IT field" is too broad. You may have to start at an entry level, and then work yourself into other departments at a company. What else you have on your resume, can also make a difference, along with your own goals. I've been enrolled in their BSIT program for a few years now, hopefully finishing next year. I've been working the entire time, and my employer has supported me financially with an annual bonus/tuition. I don't expect that new employers will run in my door next year-- but hey, I have worked hard(!!) and gained tremendously in knowledge and resources, and this has also given me a lot of confidence. The instructors I've had at UOP were all very qualified, and it has not appeared to me that you can just collect a degree without making real efforts. I'd say the majority of instructors have an academic degree, many a Ph.D. or are with reputable organizations (e.g., one was an engineer from Microsoft).

by anniemae46

First of all, anyone who does not value your efforts to actually getting an education, may not be the best prospective employer anyway. You need figure out, where to apply your BSIT; i.e., sector, trend, etc. That may require more research. "IT field" is too broad. You may have to start at an entry level, and then work yourself into other departments at a company. What else you have on your resume, can also make a difference, along with your own goals. I've been enrolled in their BSIT program for a few years now, hopefully finishing next year. I've been working the entire time, and my employer has supported me financially with an annual bonus/tuition. I don't expect that new employers will run in my door next year-- but hey, I have worked hard(!!) and gained tremendously in knowledge and resources, and this has also given me a lot of confidence. The instructors I've had at UOP were all very qualified, and it has not appeared to me that you can just collect a degree without making real efforts. I'd say the majority of instructors have an academic degree, many a Ph.D. or are with reputable organizations (e.g., one was an engineer from Microsoft).

by madtechgirl

It's not that I'm narrow minded, I'm open minded and have hired many people with NO degrees in their field. I don't put resumes with Stanford, etc. at the top of my list either. It's just that UofP has been bogus in the past and my experience in interviewing their graduates is that they don't have the knowledge or the skills. When I get 2000 resumes for 1 job, looking at schools as a starting place for getting through them quickly is an option. It's not great because I might miss someone incredible but we have to cut somewhere.

by too old for it

You have stated the problem in a nutshell. 2000 resumes for 1 position means that you are an employer of choice, and need to be creating more openings.

by apotheon

Why bother to sort by school, then? Why not just throw away every other resume? That would reduce your stack of resumes by 50%, and it would be no less rigorous and relevant a sorting method.

It'd be a heckuva lot quicker, too.

by drb0533

The degree itself is not worthless, however you may lack the hands-on experience that many hiring manager are looking for. You may need to get some certifications under your belt before they believe you know what you are doing. Additionally, try getting some experience by volunteering at your church or other non-profit organization. Good luck.

by metilley9

I don't think you have a worthless degree, but as others (here) have said, it is probably not up to par with others from better known universities, i.e. MIT, CalTech, Stanford, etc. Also as others have said, there is a LOT of competition. Are you willing to go outside the U.S., i.e. India or worse?

What kind of work do you want to do? IT covers a broad range. Do you want to program, manage, do networking type work, help desk?

I will assume you want to be a programmer. Have you ever heard of SAS? It is a data mining software that is widely used. You can get a decent amount of skills just by taking their software course (available from amazon.com for about $100). You can take other courses if you want to spend $2,000 per week or more.

I would suggest going to work in a help desk position. It may not pay a lot but it will teach you valuable skills. Ten years ago, I worked for IBM as a consultant. When that position was dissolved I didn't know what to do so I applied for a position with a 3rd party help desk company. This company supported Compaq and Hewlett-Packard PC's via telephone. It didn't pay much back then, but these companies pay a lot more now! I got valuable PC training that I still use today even though I am a programmer once again.

I wouldn't waste my time with certifications, although many companies require them or pay higher wages for them. I think they are a waste of time. I have worked with people that have a high school diploma (and nothing more) that could run circles around a Carnegie-Mellon grad with Java certifications. So it all depends on how much experience one has. Also, many companies are seeking mainframe experience. I don't know how you would gain this other than actual experience.

Good luck with whatever you do. As far as UOP being a "diploma mill", I can't answer that. I know I wrote to them several years ago asking for information and they hounded me for many months to make a decision to attend. I finally told them to leave me alone. That experience left a bad taste in my mouth. I would never attend a "school" like that! GOOD LUCK!

by the admiral

If you had the BSIT degree as of last year as I have, then you know not to confuse the issues.

Critical Thinking process would lead you to a heavy demand of off shored people and on shored people, where the off shored people win.

The UOP degree has helped me immensly in that now I can control my course, not any one else.

I think the problem here is the lack of feedback when you are sending out the resumes out the door. When you send out a resume and they determine that you are not a prospect, send them a survey and ask them why they believe that you are not a prospect. They and only they can tell you what is wrong - experience, education, fears, whatever - they are the best source to tell you, supposition is the enemy that rules all fears.

by apape

I wish I had survey replies from every job I've been turned down for. Fact is, I have ZERO. Have YOU EVER had someone return a survey that asks why were you NOT hired? As a hiring manager, I don't think I could fill out such a survey without putting the company in some kind of legal danger. I think getting results of the reasons you were NOT hired is a very, very tough job.

by apape

I'm suprised to see a lot of folks spouting preconceived notions and posting unresearched assumptions as if they were gospel.

Instead of posting more of my opinon, I will leave you with this link and a disclaimer: I attend UoP, and I do not work for them. I hold a neutral opinion, but I have a less-biased opinion after reading this:

http://www.futuremagonline.com/archive/2006/Spring/1.html

by suzitech

I should clarify that the issue was the main head instructor was teaching programming theory in terms of PASCAL, but the lesser student instructors required all of our assignments to be written in C++ or JAVA, without teaching us any of the C++ or JAVA syntax. Most of us had to scramble to teach ourselves these languages in the first few days of class, in between our already loaded coursework, without any help from the instructors. Made for an extraordinarily difficult freshman year in the College of Engineering!

by jcitron

Hi Karen,

I would definitely hire a UofP grad over a lot of other people. As a current student there in the BSIT program, I see a lot of potential from the people attending.

First of all, we have to learn to work and think independently and as a team.

We have to deal with people from not only in the US, but from around the world, scheduling meetings around different time zones, dealing with a lot of different personalities, etc.

Secondly, many of us have real work experience along with the degree. Geeze... There are so many little kiddies out there who just graduated, but have never worked a real job in their life. These kids are demanding too, and many of them want the benefits without the hard work that goes with them. They come to work with an attitude, and expect everything handed back to them on a silver platter.

The course work is work-related. The last three courses I have taken have helped me in my current job. The Database Concepts class, for example, opened up many doors for me, after I mentioned this course to the IT manager. All of a sudden he had me running reports and performing data downloads off the SQL server!

So I think, as probably a lot of others have said here, that your problem maybe experience more than anything else. If you had more work-time behind you, this may help a lot. I suggest that you look for a small company to work for, and try for a ground-up type position. I currently work for a company with around 16 employees. Yes I wear a lot of hats, but the work experience is worth its weight in gold because the different people have shown me different things that all relate back to the BSIT degree in one way or another.

Therefore, when I graduate, for example, I will not only finally have my BSIT degree, but more than 26 years in high technology with about 15 years in IT. I am sure my skills will be a lot more marketable than many students just graduating from any school. After I receive my degree (God willing), I plan to go back for my certificates in CISCO, Microsoft, and others. After that, I plan to possibly go back to school again for teaching. I figure with my degree, the many years of work experience, and certificates, my skills will be worth more than the little kid that just graduated from college.

So in summary, yes I would definitely hire a UofP person. We have a lot more to offer than a recent 20-something college graduate who has never set foot in a workplace in his or her life.

John

by unhappyuser

I'd have to see if they were accredited, what was your course study and how well you did.

Your cahnces to improve getting a job? Experience. Even if you have to volunteer somewhere or help seniors get connected, that will help.

by phranquelynne

The transferring of credits is at the sole discretion of the university/college to which you are attempting the transfer. It is not based on whether you are coming from a community college per se, but rather the type of accredidation they hold. If they are a regionally accredided(sp?) school you will have better luck, than one that is Nationally accredided(Sp again). There are some places that look beyond the type of accredidation and look to the substance of the classes as well. So always check with the school you are looking to transfer into, don't assume they have the same standards as any other school.

by swidup

Contrary to popular opinion there actually are well known brick and mortar institutions that offer online education, including a robust CS undergrad and graduate program. I'll cite Regis University in Colorado, a private Jesuit college as a prime example. Other well known institutions including Notre Dame, Tulane, Stanford, Villanova, Stevens Institute of Technology and others have been experimenting with online offerings as well. Would you discriminate against a degree from one of these institutions if it was completed online? Somehow I don't think so.

My point is that it isn't whether or not the program is online that matters, but the quality of the education. If you elect to short change individuals based upon the fact that their degree is online rather than 4 yr physical attendance then I believe you're short changing yourself and your organization.

I personally have worked with several folks who have come from this background as well as some who have no formal degrees, yet years of experience. A traditional 4 yr degree is *not* proof of anything except someones ability to pay and complete a program. I'd rather have someone with intelligence, drive and a desire to do a good job with or without a standard 4 yr degree.

I have worked in both IT and development for very large and well known software firms and have been involved in the hiring of new team members as both a team member and a team lead. I have found this viewpoint to be the same in both environs.

As far as certs, all they prove is a base level of knowledge. They're useful for a person attempting to enter a junior level position to prove that they at least understand some of the basics. Beyond that, they generally don't have a lot of advantages, however there are firms that will pay you more for them. I should note there are some certification exceptions to this rule: CISSPs, CCIEs generally indicate a strong level of skill and a PMP cert can be helpful.

by firstpeter

I don't know that I'll help your cause, but from my perspective that diploma is just a piece of paper. My experience has been that the diploma simply says "I was willing to spend the time to earn it" and really has no bearing on the success of someone.

I have folks that work for me with no degrees, period, that I'd put in charge of a project long before folks that I know that DO have degrees. The attitude of the person is generally a better indicator than the diploma. All other things equal yeah - I'd take a UoP degree over nothing, I suppose, but between Cal Tech, UoP, and Duke...doesn't matter.

by pancho_dba

I am a proud graduate of their evening degree completion program. I would hire anyone who could meet the demands of that 2-year, year-round program. We did a semester's work in 5 weeks, meeting one night a week in class and frequently on Saturday mornings in smaller study groups. My degree is a B.Sc. in Business Administration. It's enabled me to land progressively better jobs in IT. As for their online division, I think it is valid and is appropriate for our times and technology. The average age of a UOP student is 31 so they are motivated to accomplish things, and the degree is evidence. If you're concerned about credentialng, I suggest earning Microsoft or Cisco certification, or a cert. from other well-known technology companies. Security is a good one right now. Meanwhile, more inexpesively, check out brainbench.com. They have some free exams and vendor-specific exams, you can purchase a paper certificate for $25.00 and maintain an online transcript for free. Good luck and don't despair. Take care, Pancho