Discussion Locked

Help With FTP service in XP Pro

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Specs: XP Pro Corp. Machine, SP2 w/ all updates, Netgear M814 Router, firmware version 4.09, static IP from suscom, port foward on 21, windows firewal set to allow port 21 TCP:

heres the problem, I am trying to set up a ftp server using the basic IIS services with XP Pro. i checked port 21 using the tools found at www.no-ip.com and it said that port 21 was visible when i try to access the ftp server by typing in the ip in a browser window (ftp://x.x.x.x:21) it wont let me see the ftp server. however if i use ftp://192.168.0.6/ from any computer behind the router it works fine. i have tried to figure this prolem out for some time but cant quite get it. any help would be great
thanks, doug

12 replies

by djgreene44

also, would ftp://x.x.x.x:21 be the right command to access it from any ie browser, it seems like something is interfearing with the connection but i cant figure out what it is

by rob miners

Not real sure on this you could enable 21 with udp as well. I have also enabled 23 on both. If this doesn't work I am sure that someone with more knowledge will be able to give you a better answer.

by djgreene44

should i port foward 23 as well ? and open with UDP in windows firewall ? i dont know what that would do because i think FTP is a TCP service

by ntproenca

When you start the address line with FTP you are already declaring you want to user port 21.
No need to use ftp and then state port 21 in the end.

You must take into consideration that routers impement traffic filtering both ways, i.e. inbound and outbound traffic can be independently blocked/filtered.

You can access the ftp service from inside your network, but not from outside, right? My guess is that your router is accepting traffic on port 21 from the local network but not from outside.

by djgreene44

ok so basicly i have to open ports 20 and 21 in windows firewall using TCP. I then also have to port foward 20 and 21 in the router to the ftp server (192.168.0.6) and yes by typing in ftp://192.168.0.6 BEHIND the router there is no problems sharing. Another thing i noticed is that i AM able to access the router from an outside computer by using http://x.x.x.x:80 Like i said before, port 21 can be seen from an out side source using the no-ip detection tool. This makes me focous all my attension to the router itself. If there is any one fimiliar with the older versions of the Netgear M814 could you help me out. Also if this router is not compatible and you are fimilar with one that is please let me know.

by hopi

This is extracted from the Netgear M814 manual;
"Local Web and FTP Server Example
If a local PC with a private IP address of 192.168.0.33 acts as a Web and FTP server, configure the
Ports menu to forward HTTP (port 80) and FTP (port 21) to local address 192.168.0.33
In order for a remote user to access this server from the Internet, the remote user must know the IP
address that has been assigned by your ISP. If this address is 172.16.1.23, for example, an Internet
user can access your Web server by directing the browser to http://172.16.1.23. The assigned IP
address can be found in the Maintenance Status Menu, where it is shown as the WAN IP Address.
Some considerations for this application are:
? If your account?s IP address is assigned dynamically by your ISP, the IP address may change
periodically as the DHCP lease expires.
Reference Manual for the Model MR814 Wireless Router
8-4 Advanced Configuration of the Router
? If the IP address of the local PC is assigned by DHCP, it may change when the PC is rebooted.
To avoid this, use the Address Reservations feature in the LAN IP menu to make sure the local
PC always receives the same IP address.
? Local PCs must access the local server by its local LAN address (192.168.0.33 in this
example). Attempts by local PCs to access the server using the external IP address
(172.16.1.23 in this example) will fail."

Hope it helps.

This discussion is closed to new replies.