I have read through the comments thus far and as expected, find several theories on the subject. I can say from witnessing the technology explosion first hand (at least my 30 year window) we live in a very different work world than we did just a few short years ago. Our customer's needs are first, that hasn't changed much. I'm sure our respective companies didn't hire us because they thought we might like a job or solely for our own convenience. They had a need, and we were the ones chosen to fill that need.
As supervisors, aren't we responsible for getting the most out of what we have to work with? including all resources? Better productivity equals better customer satisfaction?
It quickly becomes a two way street. The organization is it's people, and it's people work best with less unnecessary stressors in their life. Flex times are a great way of reducing the everyday stressors as well as building good working relationships, especially if workload and coverages are discussed and concluded my the work force. Buy-in? Ownership? Responsibility? Of course, if there has to be a command decision...................
As supervisors, we can't hide behind things like "it makes my job harder" or that doesn't fit what's written on the stone tablet in HR. (I'm sure HR has a different view) We live in an extremely dynamic world where communication and information is our business. By adhering to what seemed to work OK years ago, probably because it was thought of as being a safe and proven practice, we sacrifice efficiency. Progress was still obtained, but not on a level that is required to be competitive by today's standards. With having to do more with less, we better start tweaking our methods accordingly and practicing what we preach. Has anybody heard of outsourcing?
Each of the 15 support people I manage are different, aren't we all? Why do we try to shoe-horn people into the exact same mold. Square pegs, round holes??? They do fit, after a bunch of kicking and screaming, get out the knife and amputate, by gosh we'll make'm fit even if we have to kill them to do it.
The real power of management is to leverage the strengths of our resources, in this case people. Hopefully we hired them because we saw some potential, something that our organizations could really use, not just another expendable warm body! Are they left brained? right brained? There is a place for both, hopefully that was a consideration when hiring.
What we really need to stay away from is our own subjective beliefs in what "justifies" some decisions. Day-care is OK but bowling is not? That opens up the door for quite an argument. Bill bowls, that doesn't seem to be a good reason for.....what................... flexing his hours? (that precedent has already been set, or has it been based on your version of what is worthy) or to not meet business needs? There is a difference.
Charlie has day-care obligations? Bill didn't tell him to hire that particular day-care place with the unaccommodating hours nor did Bill tell him he should have kids at all. How dare he have a personal life! Does someone with 6 kids get 6 times the flexibility? Sarcasm? maybe a little, but only to make my point. Decisions based on subjective matter only digs the hole deeper. And what if the boss is a bowler with no kids?
Stay on task as a supervisor. Maintain a clear view of the real objective. Don't get caught up in people's subjectively opinionated worlds when making decisions. If flexible time has been established, work is covered, organizational needs are met, then I don't care what they do when they aren't at work, it is their time and everybody has the same rules to play by. If they take advantage of that benefit, great. If not, it's there choice.
Granted, some employees would rather not or just plain can't see the two way street as such, and that can make things rough. One of the biggest ground rules that HAS TO BE SET in any employee conduct guide is... it is not their job to get in each other's business!!! I can't say that loud enough. If that can somehow be written on that stone tablet in HR, the rest will fall into place easier. If one disgruntled employee finds a sympathetic ear, you'll be in for a rough ride no matter what job efficiency you have established.