Discussion Locked

How do I improve communication between different IT teams

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a dilema at the moment in trying to improve communication bewteen site IT people and regional engineers that support them. In my current role I am part of a technology team that is responsible for the support/direction of IT within numerouse sites in Europe. On a bi-weekly basis we, the regional team, have setup a 1hr con call to improve communications with site IT staff so that we can work closely together on projects and help solution problems they may have. The dilema I have is that hardly anybody from the site IT staff attend these calls. In order to overcome any cultural/language problems we decided to start 1-1 calls instead of the open bi-weekly's we had with all sites at the same time. Each week a site engineer personally receives a call from a regional engineer and is asked some questions from a predefined template that we use to document issues. In some cases this has helped build relationships but in other cases the same people that did not attend the bi-weekly calls do not participate in the 1-1 calls. Do you guys/gals have any ideas on how I can improve communication from site to region, while minimising the 1-1 calls as this takes up a lot of time when you have 17 sites to support. Keep in mind the communication is a 2 way street and both parties have to actively participate in order to be effective.

Thanks

17 replies

by bfilmfan

If they are failing to attend a meeting that has been scheduled, that is an issue for management to rectify. The management person responsible for supervising these folks needs to be made aware of the issue. Have your manager speak to their manager.

by fultonwilcox

People almost universally complainis a near-universal about the proliferation of meeting and conference calls, exception if the people involved sense that those meetings are directly relevant to succeeding at the job. The content not only needs to be relevant, it needs to seem relevant.

Calls are not very good for building new relationships. Also, what is critical is to define inter-team roles that are meaningful and realistic, as well as having a reward system (not necessarily money) for those who successfully build relationships.

We are all familiar with the "go to" person phenomenon - people respect and want to talk to the "go to" person (or people) relative to a given topic or problem. The effective communications paths within a team and between teams is not necessarily official. Are you leveraging natural lines of communication? Have these distant teams through previous experience even established "go to" relationships.

by house

It is most definitely a management issue. If someone in our organization refuses to attend a weekly meeting, then they are dealt with accordingly. It is very important for everyone to be on the same page whether or not their job titles are similar.

The department has to move as one entity or it will be anarchy. Enforce some new corporate policies and make this communication manditory. There is someone who is above both parties in question.

by awfernald

One of the major issues that I have had to deal with in working in international environments is that the people on each end of the phone don't "realize" that there is a live human being on the other end of the phone.

To the regional support, there's a problem at site 6, rather than "Jim in London is having a problem".

To the people at the local sites, it's "some guy from regional is supposed to be able to help if you can ever get hold of him", rather than "Pedro at the central office is going to help us work through this problem."

There are several ways to work around this problem:

1. Teleconferencing - Not a super plan, but at least you can see the people on the other end.

2. Regional meeting(s) - You can either:
a. Have regional support personnel who are active in providing support to the local sites, and send them at LEAST once a year to each site. This works unless you only have one or two regional support personnel.
b. Sponsor a regional conference where the regional IT management will finance each site to send 1 local manager and 1 TECHNICIAN to a 3 or 4 day regional conference. The purpose of this conference is to have each local site present what /how they are implementing regional polices/products and how they have worked around specific issues, and also for the regional managers to get the local site managers/technicians informed about what new systems/technologies are in the pipeline.

by hockeyist

International teams are hard to manage. I have had first hand experience and had similar results as you. The best thing that you can do is get the commitment from their supervisor/manager. Recalcitrants should be dealt with swiftly to stop the team falling apart. By "dealt with" I don't mean sacking etc.. just react appropriately and effectively to resolve the issue. There are plenty of books on the subject. Show some "wins" from the meetings, maybe others will be more eager to participate.

by lindahatton

Hi Vincent,

If you can change the situation yourself it comes off a lot better in the end, rather than involving management to force the issue. The old saying you get more with honey than vinegar stands true in this situation. Of course keep your communication open with management so to keep them informed of the situation.

Put a face to the voice, ask your manager to purchase a digital camera for the group and take pictures of each of your team members and post them on your intranet site, so the individuals offshore can follow suit.

I am currently writing a thesis on communication management strategy and there are three main points why projects are successful:
1) Executive Support
2) Buiding Lasting Relationships
3) Using the right media for communication.

I would always suggest creating a communication plan, and you can find some great articles on the subject at techrepublic, cio, and gantthead websites.

I wish you happy communicating on your project.

Linda Hatton

by jdclyde

I have seen there is always a form of rivalry between departments, shifts, locations.

If it is seen as the regional is looking over the locals shoulder because they can't do it alone is condensending and insulting to the locals and they will resent this.

You need to get people from both locations to "buy into" the idea and find a way to make it work.

The way I would approach this would be to (in person if possible) meet with the leaders at each location and ask them the following:

1) how can the other location help?
2) how do you get that help?
3) how often do you get that help?
4) is the help given as an equal or as the hero rushing in to save the day because the local tech couldn't hack it?

Get their feedback and ask them how you can help rather than telling them how you can help.

They will feel more a part of the team and doing something because they want to, not because someone at the end of a phone told them to.

Good luck.

by achin77

Well I can suggest following solutions:

a) Make atleast one person responsible at each location - as champions leaders. It would be easy for this champion to communicate with the local people and since it will be his/her responsibility/kra - he will make sure they listen to you.

b) The other alternative is to have a net meeting - this will also sensitize them to a great extent.

c) The last option could be a stick approach if the things are getting out of control and there is no other option.

I think there is no single solution to this and you have to use a combination of the above.

Achin

by ianr41

Vincent, this is always a challenge. I am the Group Consultant EBusiness/IT for the Vedior group, and my role is to facilitate communication, on a global basis. I also come into daily contact with our CIO's and I think there are some issues that are common.
First of all, the issue of language. I think having multilingual people on your team is essential. Second, is create bonding sessions, that is, bring leaders together for a couple of days...to hammer out issues and gain their buy-in. Third, is to use all the collaboration tools at your disposal. We have recently started to use Skype. Its great, free, and reliable. Fourth, make sure each member of the team has clear cut responsibilities. In our group it has taken some 4 years of effort to create the collaboration and understanding - and though far from perfect, it is working. We are also lucky in having the buyin of the company executive team. I live and work in Australia, but report to my boss in UK, and we are all members of a Dutch company. Virtual teams do work, but they take work.

by mengel

first of all know where people are coming from, what are motive to respond in a manner that they do. especially learining what they can loose by changes/cooperations. of course this is hard to get if you have little time.
this is interesting to know for you, so you can play the game of politics better, totally not interesting for the others concerned as you are the one to achieve a deadline/goal.

Secondly forget about e-mail, use e-mail for information and meetings/teleconference for communication. Make sure yhe meetings/teleconference have an agenda with discussion point and needed goals. Using the information you have learned in the first issue, you can better work on finding a compromise or mutual benefits for the parties concerned.

good luck

by d.schlotzhauer

Sounds like there aren't many incentives for the IT guys/gals to attend the con calls - or for that matter, the 1-1 calls. They will need to see the value in the relationship and what your engineers bring to the table. If you see the site IT guys/gals as your "customer" what are you doing to probe, discover the low hanging fruit and addressing issues of greatest needs for the site folks first?

by hotindia

I was also facing the same problem. Didn't get the right direction, but some how improved by concentrating with different departments people.
I love to hear from other experts..it will be really helpfull for lots of people.

by dwidlak

Try addign video (or web cams) to the calls. When a face can be added to the voice, it changes the quality of the calls. At a previous assignment, we used web cams so the players could "see" who the other team members are. Once the faces were identified, the calls became friendlier and more productive (you really don't want to see disappointment on another team members face).

by goingmobile

You may never know why the other side isn't participating. It could be that they are uncooperative (unlikely), that their day-to-day priorities are more urgent, or that there are numerous other departments trying to get them on conference calls too. I'm sure we all make decisions each day about which meetings to attend and which ones not to so we can get our work done and go home.

Instead of forcing the issue, look for a common goal or a problem you can help with and get one person from each site on it to solve it. You may be rebuffed at first, but keep the door open. There is nothing better to build a team than solving a problem or crisis together. Even so, it is unlikely that you will get all 17 sites to play along, and there is nothing that says your team is necessary for all the other sites. Over time, you should find the sites that work well with your team and vice versa will be more productive because they will only take each other's time to solve real problems; not just to attend conference calls.

I also agree with many of the other suggestions in this thread; especially about adding some of the human touches. This is particularly important for cross-cultural interaction. I've worked with virtual and geographically separated teams for many years and it takes work (like all team building) but it can be done.

by nduncan

Your problem is a tough one, Vincent, and coming from a team with 110 IT staff dotted all around the world, I understand your frustration. I'm assuming you don't have the luxury of a Communications Manager (which is my position here), but I can share some of the tactics we have used to improve communications. First, be clear about what you are trying to achieve. "Improving communications" is a vague goal and you will find it hard to measure any success if you don't have specific aims. Rather than tackling the whole issue at once, why not focus on one issue, start small, and try to find ways to engage the parties concerned. Start with things that have an effect on these site staff, things that concern them. If you drive things from that angle, they are more likely to come to meetings of their own accord, rather than feeling they are being imposed upon by office staff. And that leads me to the most crucial point. Quite a few of the replies I read here suggested coming down heavy on these people and making them attend meetings. Hmmm, that'll work - not! You have to understand the mentality of staff working remotely to the main IT hubs. Decisions are traditionally made at head office, or at main hubs, and site staff are often on the front line. The natural state of the relationship is that site staff are distrustful of office staff and feel that they foist their decisions on site staff without proper consideration for what really happens out there at the coal face. Whether it's a reality or not, I'll guarantee you that your site staff feel this way. So forcing the issue of meetings etc will push them further away and allow them to be proved right that office staff don't care about them!
I could spend all day on this topic because it has taken me 3 years to make major changes, so you will have to be patient. Here's something to get you started: try to think of some project or work coming up that could incorporate some input from your site staff, perhaps just one of them even. Get them involved on a concrete level by asking for their opinion, technical input, what fix would they suggest (what tech doesn't love to be asked how to come up with a technical solution), if you want to go further, ask them to act as a rep for all the other site staff, so they are talking amongst themselves and the message starts filtering round that they are being involved in decision making.
In general, try not to think about communication as a problem to be fixed. Engage your staff in the work that you all do as a team and you won't have a problem to fix!

by 4itmgrs

Vincent,
My first question to you would be, have you identified why the European staff does not want to participate in the conversations. Obviously there is a reason they don't want to attend. Often people feel that they are not gaining anything from attending these meetings. Have them draw up an agenda for the meeting to touchpoint on issues they consider most relevant to their situation and then point out small improvements each week to show you are making progress.

I have a similar situation since I am responsible for setting up global strategy within my organization. The European staff would prefer to manage all of Europe, but wants to complain when issues are not addressed or resolved from the US. So far, we have a stalemate. We have meetings every other week to discuss open incidents and to keep the European community informed of corporate office issues. This basically becomes a sounding board meeting for Europe to vent frustration and request items they want. It is a moving target, but over time I am sure we will make headway.

by wayne m.

I hate to sound brusque, but what precisely is the intent behind the meetings?

One of the strategies for effective meetings is to establish an agenda. This agenda needs to be something more than "to improve communications." What specifically are the problems being seen at the regional office that require bi-weekly discussions with all site offices? Are there more efficient ways to exchange this information, such as written status reports, e-mails, discussion lists, or web blogs? Remember, a meeting affects the scheduling on one's entire day.

I am not surprised that meetings intending to improve communication have a low attendance rate. Try to create a purpose for the meeting that has a tangible benefit and people will then have a reason to make the effort to attend. If the purpose of the meeting cannot be identified, then perhpas the best course of action is to discontinue the meetings.

This discussion is closed to new replies.