Discussion Locked

How many servers?

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We are installing a new W2K network with the following characteristics:
- 25-30 max. users (concurrent)
- SQL Server - mid-to-large DB
- Exchange Server2K
- Small intranet
- rack-mounted (APC NetShelter)
- limited remote access

(answers worth 100+ points each)
1. How many physical servers should I get? Have a one-time-only shot at the hardware so want to get what I reasonably need.

I assume a seperate computer for SQL makes sense, but is there a MAJOR advantage in seperating file/print and Exchange?

2. Would dual processors (733MHz min) be most cost effective for the file/Exchange server?

3. How about storage? Is it worth the money to have the hard drives in an external array? Not concerned with RAID in that as muchas 24+48 hours downtime would be painful but not a catastrophy, given daily, RELIABLE backups.

Any other tips concerning this configuration, including links to HELPFUL sites, would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks.

14 replies

by jehorn

I can give you a contact that can answer these questions and provide tech support.
Email:eliwheeler@gateway.com
Please let him know that I sent you and get back with me.

Jeffrey Horn

by mservino

First off, there are a lot of variables to contend with.
1. How much will the SQL Server be accessed?
2. How much E-mail do you expect to move?
3. What will your intranet traffic be like?
4. How many concurent remote conections?
5. How much do you plan to expand?

As a general rule of thumb figure 20% expansion per year. So if you need 6 GB now you need at the very minimum a 9GB drive to last the next 2 years without having to upgrade. If you expect that you need a dual proccessor machine now, make sure it can go up to quad processing so you can expand.

For my personal preferences I try to break things up as much as possible.
1 server for a Primary Domain Controler
1 server for your back up domain controler - can alsobe your file server
1 server for the SQL Server
1 server to run Exchange
1 server to run your Intranet
as for RAS get a dedicated RAS box like the Shiva Lanrover or equivilant. Or you can go VPN if you have an always on internet connection likea T1. You can get a box to act as a Firewall, Proxy Server, and VPN all in one. Checkpoint makes some great software for this, then your users can dial a local ISP, or use a highspeed line at home to come in over a secure connection.

As far as an external array is concerned I would think about how much space you have and how much you'll need. If the server is small say 4 hot swap bays, and you only plan on putting in about 18 GB then, you'll only use 1 bay, or 2 if you go with 9s, still leaves you plenty of room. If you need 40 GB on one server, then you would be using 3 bays with 18s giving you 54 Gb plenty of room to expand, plus one slot left, almost enough to go to double what your current needs would be.

The real key is planning for future expansion. Don't underestimate what your future needs might be. Plan on 3 yrs before your next replacement. Expect to upgrade in 1 1/2 - 2 years. Leave the room

by dave butler

1. How much will the SQL Server be accessed? DIFFICULT TO ANSWER. PROBABLY NO MORE THAN 10 USERS, MOST FOR SIMPLE QUERIES ONLY

2. How much E-mail do you expect to move? ALSO DIFFICULT. APPLESHARE IP 'NETWORK' WORKS FINE NOW BUT WILL BE USING SHARED CALENDARS, ETC.
3. What will your intranet traffic be like? MINIMAL NOW - EXPECT TO EXPAND WITH DIGITAL DASHBOARD.
4. How many concurent remote conections? NONE - MAY ADD AS MANY AS 12 BUT EXPECT TO USE VPN.
5. How much do you plan to expand? DEPENDS ON REQUIREMENTS OF MS PRODUCTS MORE THAN BUSINESS FUNCTIONS. WILL USE 50% OVER CURRENT AS BASE THEN AT LEAST YOUR RECOMMENDED 20% AS RULE OF THUMB.

DUAL PROCESSOR DOES NOT SEEM TO ADD MUCH BANG FOR THE BUCK.

SEEMS LIKE A LOT OF SERVERS.

SINCE WE WILL HAVE ONLY ONE FILE/PRINT SERVER (NOT AN ENTERPRISE SETUP) DOES THE PDC COME INTO PLAY?

SEP
1 server for the SQL Server
1 server to run Exchange
1 server to run your Intranet

I AGREE WITH YOUR RECOMMENDATIONS FOR RAS/VPN. WILL LOOK INTO DEDICATED HW WHEN WE GET TO THAT POINT.

MY REASONING FOR AN ARRAY WAS SIMPLY BASED ON AN ATTEMPT TO LIMIT USELESS REDUNDANCY AND TO CONSOLIDATE THE DRIVES. UNLESS I AM MISSING SOMETHING THOUGH, I WOULD SAVE ONLY ONE DRIVE PER MACHINE (ASSUMING RAID 5) PLUS THE ADDITIONAL COST OF THE RAID CONTROLLER. LOOKS LIKE I WILL STAY WITH INTERNAL UNLESS I HEAR COMPELLING REASONS OTHERWISE.

I AGREE THAT PLANNING FOR EXPANSION IS IMPORTANT. THINK I HAVE THAT COVERED.

by dstante

1 running BackOffice
1 Running SQL with Internal Array
Dual Processors would be more advantageous for the SQL Server but not necessary

by w_dayton

Well, I admit I'm new to this site and am a beginner to intermediate level network/pc person.

BUT if I knew that I would only have a 1 time decent shot at purchasing some prime equipment I'd shoot for the moon.

Dual Processor SQL server
Dual Processor Exchange server
Dual Processor File and Print server
4 20 GB SCSI drives in each for Raid 5 plus plenty of storage room and redundancy
AND a tape back up box capable of backing them all up.
Don't forget the APC backups too.

I know inmy relative inexperience there are probably many out there who will say it's overkill, but heck, if this is the only time you may be able to get some decent equipment, do it now.

by ian.g.bonello

1. I think that get one high powered reliable server would be enough (No PC Servers). If the server would be heavily used, then you might need to seperate the servers. However with 25 users it should not be a problem.

2. It depends on the prices that you have. However a 733Mhz will probably be the most cost effective.

3. Also I would use Internal Raid. Almost all servers can be bought using internal Hot swappable disks as standard.

Ensure that you check the backups frequently.

by ian.g.bonello

1. I think that get one high powered reliable server would be enough (No PC Servers). If the server would be heavily used, then you might need to seperate the servers. However with 25 users it should not be a problem.

2. It depends on the prices that you have. However a 733Mhz will probably be the most cost effective.

3. Also I would use Internal Raid. Almost all servers can be bought using internal Hot swappable disks as standard.

Ensure that you check the backups frequently.

This discussion is closed to new replies.