Discussion Locked

how much responsibility should graphic designers have for accessibility?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK, today i am contracting at a (very) well known web design agency in London.
My role is a user interface developer... (read HTML coder), but with over 10 years in web development I am not just a code monkey. I am here because the client wants double A rated accessibility (and why not i am sure they are paying a fair price).

But the design i am looking at uses split tables (header row is split from data content) and i have had to use almost every hack in the (preverbial) css book to get this to be cross browser and compliant.

SO is it just me who thinks that graphic/web designers should have more responsibility for creating designs that are buildable and accessible?
I have a dim view already of creatives as they just draw pretty pictures and get paid almost as much as i do.... now accessibility is the buzzword should they have to bear this challenge like the rest of us?

5 replies

by tagmarkman

One department I'm in charge of is the usabability department. We have a high tech facility complete with eye tracking and a small staff of PhDs.

Graphic Designer really only create visual effects. They are not truly about usability, accessiblity, information, or interaction. So, be careful.

An information architect designs the structure of the website which includes localization and globalization and information flow, etc.

A interaction designer designs how a user will interact with the website (this include accessiblity). They also deal with page layout.

Accessibility is a huge issue in its own right. It's not just about control keys. It is so much more than that (depending on your client). If you haven't worked significantly with accessiblity, I'd recommend hiring an interaction designer that specializes in accessibility for the project.

by rmrenneboog

Accessibility is a huge issue, and far more than just a buzzword. Just how easy it is for someone to access the information on your site (hence the term accessibility...) covers far more than smooth navigation from one page to the next, or from one tag to the target. The user has to actually be able to access the information in accord with their own abilities. A very good approximation based on a lot of research tells us that something close to 20% of the people who will access your site as a matter of course will have problems interpreting the information (accessing it...) if it is in a certain font, or a certain colour, or set against a certain background, or if they can't hear the content as their eyes look at it, and so on. So define what you mean by 'accessibility'. Is the result of your work only supposed to be accessible to 80% of the general population? Or does accessibility mean that everyone has the same opportunity to access the information you presumably want them to have? All aspects of the design are involved. So the simple answer, at least for me, is that everybody who is involved in the design, graphic and otherwise, bear the same responsibility.

by tagmarkman

I agree those questions must be asked... no doubt about it. It certainly can make a difference in the design of the product...

However, (and I'm very glad you stated this as an opinion because it would vary depending on the company), I disagree about the responsibility in your statement:

"So the simple answer, at least for me, is that everybody who is involved in the design, graphic and otherwise, bear the same responsibility."

A program manager better bear more responsibility than the designers because it is that persons job to make sure that the people that are working on the project know accessiblility. Second, an accessiblity person (auditor, contractor, designer) should claim more responsiblity of accessible design than the graphic artist because that is their expertise. However, if the graphic artist knows better (been on other projects that had accessiblity issues), they better fess up when they know that something is bad for accessiblity.

It reminds me of when people say that security is everyones job. I agree, if anything people "know" that violates security they should do something about it, but it would be pointless to flog the receptionist for a overflow error.

This is part of the reason why we usually pay people more when take on larger responsibilities or have a specific area of expertise for a project.

by pixelsurge

Yes, graphic designers should know what the accessibility goals of the site will be, just as they need to know the business goals of the site in order to produce a design that successfully meets those goals. This doesn't mean that they need to know how to implement every accessibility feature, of course, but they need to be familiar with the issues so that they can design with them in mind. Every craftsperson needs to be familiar with his or her medium, and if a graphic design intends to design for the web, he or she needs to know how the web works. Although an architect is not responsible for building a structure that conforms to local building codes, he is responsible for knowing those codes and creating blueprints that can be built to code by the construction team. I see a graphic designer's responsibility as analogous to this.

by tagmarkman

I agree.. you must know the medium.

A graphic designer by trade works with the "Design" of "Graphics". This means that they must understand size issues of the web, speed, how it is view, how colors work on monitors, standard screen sizes, etc... it's a mix of some technical issues and a lot of creative work. And I agree the more they understand that medium the more valuable the person is (along as it doesn't interfere with their creative abilities).

What they are not (unless they put themselves out to be one) is an interaction designer. And they certainly are not accessibility people or localization people. (at least not the majority I've come across).

Ex: I've never met a graphic designer that knew that you put the label above the textbox (for localization issues). They usually are after a look and feel. I've also never met a graphic designer that could adaquately describe the main issues of accessibilty or what section 8 was...
(although, they tend to learn that over time with working on my teams).

Graphic Designers also tend to steer toward a flash style site and don't but a whole lot of deep though on the issues of maintainability, database interactions, or cross browser issues (although some do.)

In otherwords, this is not normal of a graphic designer's trade, although you will find a few gems that understand these issues.

This discussion is closed to new replies.