Discussion Locked

How to justify infrastructure upgrades?

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

1. What are our options for upgrading our site & Wan?
2. How do we justify cost to upper management?

Our company justify's money spent on ROI.
We have 10Mb ethernet at our plant over many acres. It has 10 home run fiber segments to different buildings. We have 300 PC's. We use Novell 4.11 servers as routers & various hubs to connect to 1 Cisco router that goes out frame relay to east coast. We have 256k w/384 burst on frame. We are peaking our burst limit all day long on the frame becauseof internet usage. Users say that internet is slow. We have a throughput of 2.8Mbs to 5.8Mbs depending on location.

10 replies

by tbradley

You didn't mention any switches or the model of the cisco router, so I'll assume that you don't have any, and the router is a low end model.

You have 2 different types of bandwidth issues, internal, and if you are running 300 pcs on a pure 10mpslan, your network efficiency is probably about 20% due to collisions. Using servers as routers is not the best solution, and both time and resources must be expended to maintain them.
You didn't mention how many, but a properly configured Cisco 3620 router could easily handle 300-500 users, and give you room to grow. It would replace the servers you are using as routers, and would eliminate their broadcast traffic.

Adding Switches at your main hub and at the ends of the home runs, depending on the brand and model of the fiber converters would allow you a full 20mps of traffic, instead of the shared 10mps you are getting now.

This could be done in phases, as budget allows.

As for the frame relay, the most cost effective solution for you, along with the new cisco box would be to shift to fractional T-1, and use about half the channels. I am assuming you are using ISDN currently. The monthly fees for the T-1 would not be that much greater than the current Telco fees you arepaying, for double the bandwidth, with up to 4 times the bandwidth depending on what CIR you negotiate.

by dennis

We do not have any switches. We have 5 Chipcom 4124MH & 1 Chipcom 5006c. The Cisco that is on our Frame is a C2500 and we have a fractional T1. 300 users with IPX/SPX & TCP/IP protocols only. We have a mix of Fiber converters what ever was cheaper, some Black Box.

by jej1962

If I were your management, I'd respond by saying "Who gives a damn if the users think the Internet is slow, maybe they should stop looking up stuff on www.cnnsi.com."

You haven't given a reason to justify an upgrade, you've only listed technicaldetails of what the problem is, not the business problems.

by networker4

If you're using ROI calculations then you're going to have to justify the upgrades based on user productivity (or lack thereof). This isn't all that simple to quantify, of course. You could do something like get an average on the amount of time ittakes a web page to load today, the average cost/minute of a users time, and calculate the cost of users waiting for pages to load today. Then compare it to the cost savings you would expect if you performed the upgrade. For example, if you have 200 users who access an average of 20 web pages a day, it takes 20 seconds for a page to load, and the average cost/minute of user time is $0.60, you can calculate a cost of 200 * 20 = 4000 pages accessed, * $0.60 = $2400 a day. If you expect to cut this in half it will save $1200 a day. You have to be conservative on your projections, of course, because you can't really determine what the effect of an upgrade will be, given that you don't control the network end-to-end. Also, there are other intangibles that contribute to user productivity due to network latency that have to do with the user becoming distracted while waiting for the access to complete.

You might want to use a client based network management tool like Lucent's (formerly INS's) VitalAgent to get response time statistics. Of course, you would first have to calculate the ROI before you were able to buy that! Your best avenue might be to talk to your network equipment vendor of choice about the ROI calculations. I'm sure they would be more than happy to help you justify purchasing their equipment.

I remember back in the IBM days when we were making claims that users required sub-second response times for optimal productivity. Good luck on that today!

by networker4

Whoops! I just noticed that I missed a factor in my calculation. That would be 200 users * 20 pages = 4000 pages a day. 4000 pages a day * 20 seconds = 80000 seconds a day that users wait for pages to load. 80000 / 60 seconds = 1333 user minutesa day. Multiply THIS by the $0.60 to get cost per day.

by dennis

Much of what our users do is on our Intranet which uses IE5 and our Home page to link to Web servers on the east coast, along with regular Internet. I will time a few web pages to see the difference. The longest page MS.com 30 seconds most were 15 - 20s. This is off hours 5:00 pm Eastern. Some of our Intranet pages were slower that outside Internet pages.
Thanks for help

This discussion is closed to new replies.