Discussion Locked

I am wondering if I had made a mistake in buying 4 GB

0 helpful
31 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Salutations and Greetings Ladies and Gentlemen, I bought a laptop that has VBB 4 GB PC2-5300 667 MHz 2DIMM but the laptop is only reading 3 GB. I was led to believe that buying the extra gigabyte would enable me to get 64--bit software. Is this true ? Based on the informative and helpful reply from Palmetto, this may not be a good idea. Is their a use of the 4 gigabyte with SBB Intel Core 2DUO Process T 7800 with Microsoft Vista, 32bit, Ultimate ? I am also planning, by virtual install if that is correct, on using Linux. Thank you. Ldxrunner

31 replies

by dr dij

of the mfgr, detailed specs for the pc
what is the max memory you can put in?

if only 3g then won't see the rest.
I don't think would be an odd size like 3g, most are 4g or 8g max nowadays, but some systems use system memory for video in addition to video memory or exclusively system memory on cheap machines.

also if 4 sticks then one could be bad. I had this happen and one memory stick didn't show. I took the stick out and still same so knew it wasn't working.

by ldxrunner

Salutations and Greetings Dr. Dij, The laptop was manufactured by Lenovo in Singapore. The web site for Thinkpad T61 6459 with 15.4 WUXGA TFT. still lists 4 GB as the maximun memory. What do you now know that I should do to either get the machine to read the 64 bit or send it back and let them remove the extra bit, refunding me my money, and moving onto to the next subject ? Thank you.

by Former member

you are using a 32 bit OS such as XP or Vista 32 then the most the OS will recognize is 3 gigs. This has to do with the limitations of how computers are built. A 32 bit OS can only use 2 gigs max. XP and Vista 32 do some tricks to allow that barrier to be exceeded.

Mathematically: 2^(32-1)-1 max memory for a 32 bit OS and (theoretically) 2^(64-1)-1 for a 64 bit OS.

If you do not have a 64 bit OS, then you are wasting money inserting more than 2 gig. If you have a 64 bit OS, then there are not yet a lot of "True" 64 bit apps out yet. MS estimates that it will be 5 years or more before "True" 64 bit apps are rolled out.

by Former member

Did you read this sentence:

XP and Vista 32 do some tricks to allow that barrier to be exceeded.

Norm

by ic-it

There is a 2 to the 0 equalling 1, however for memory you minus the 1 after the power because 0 is used as the lower bounds. Example 2 to the 8th and then minus 1 = 255 (but there are 256 including the 0). It does not mean 2 to the (8-1)-1 or 127.

The actual addressable memory on a 32bit OS 2 to the 32 = 4,294,967,296.
Traditionally this is used with 2GB available for applications and 2GB for the OS. The "trick" is in allocating 3GB for applications and 1 GB for the OS (actually 3Gb per process thread). Even then those applications must use Addressing Windows extensions.

Edited: here are a couple of nice links.
http://www.dansdata.com/askdan00015.htm
http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/000811.html

by maniacman

I doubt this will change the number that the OS is seeing. I'd opt for the /PAE switch instead.

by Former member

It has been a while since I had to learn this.

by dr dij

I saw a quad core 6600 intel pc (w/ xp or vista) advertized, looked up specs and at least one of them says 8gig max (tho comes with 4)

could it be 2 gigs per processor? or is the extra memory wasted?

by Former member

on the architecture of the motherboard and the CPU. I am not a fan of Intel and prefer AMD, so I cannot tell you specifics of the Intel.

Most likely, this is mis advertising in that while the MB can hold 8 gigs, the utilization of that ram is dependent on the OS used. A 64 bit OS would have no problem seeing and utilizing that amount or 8 times that (64 gig), but a 32 bit OS would have problems using that amount - unless each CPU had its own address space and was running its own copy of XP or Vista 32.

by dr dij

in a PC with a quad core. (intel).

PC specs - MB says it can hold 8 so I'd presume (possibly not correctly) that it could use all 8 gigs.

by tony hopkinson

for it to work properly. You'll still have the odd bit of fun with that, according to what I've read device driver wise.

I'm umming and ahing about getting a 64 bit box now, with 4 gig and win64 for dual boot. The boys who do custom builds in the UK, specifically don't recommend going over 2 for win32.

by maniacman

It works on severs running 32 bit versions of Windows 2003 to see all 4GB, so give it a shot. At worst, it won't do anything and you'll still see 3GB. The PAE switch stands for physical address extensions which affect Intel Xeon processors primarily. AMD Opterons are not affected by this and will see the 4GB and beyond because they are 64 bit architecture, but you'll need the Enterprise Edition of Windows Server 2003, or Standard R2, which I have seen to register over 4GB.

by dr dij

If I get an AMD quad core and put win xp or vista 32 bit it will then see 4 gig if on an AMD?

by maniacman

To answer your question, it won't see all 4GB on an AMD, but will register about about 3.6GB or so. I know this because I've built AMD servers with 32 bit versions of Windows Server 2003.

by ic-it

My main contention was with the statement that more than 2GB (unless 64bit) are a waste and the flawed math. Xp will make use of "most" of 4GB even without either switch.
/3GB primarily does the ratio shift I discussed above.
/PAE will display more memory through system properties, but it will also allow the addressing of memory beyond that.

by ldxrunner

Salutations and Greetings Maniac Man, The laptop has Intel central processing unit in it.How do I tell who mades the memory ? Thank you.

by ldxrunner

Salutations and Greetings Oz_Media, The correct internet location for my laptop is http://www.307.ibm. com/pc/support/site.wss/MIGR-67883.html. I am very much a novice in understanding this technology. As I understand it the support, that is referenced at the internet location, means that the 4 GB will support a 64--bit OS system such as Windows Vista 64. Am I correct or not ? If yes, then the next question is do I need it, that is the 64 OS ? Thank you.

by oz_media

I own an IBM Thinkpad myself, while it does have a specific support page, it is still included as part of the R3 series product group.

T answer the 32 bit question, "Due to the limitation of the current 32-bit PC architecture, actual usable memory size is limited to 3 GB even though the physical installable memory size is 4 GB."

So yes, 3GB is a 32 bit limitation.

From various info found around the net.

"A 32-bit OS can only handle 3.2gig of RAM max. The rest of your 4gig wont show up without a 64-bit OS" - notebookreview.com

An interesting blog says 64 bit CAN support up to 128GB Ram.
http://blogs.msdn.com/hiltonl/archive/2007/04/13/the-3gb-not-4gb-ram-problem.aspx

Other forums indicate that this is common with Lenovo even on 64 bit OS's because Lenovo's motherboard chipset does not support 4 gigs.

HOWEVER: Becaue it uses Dual Channel Support, if you mix 2GB+1GB to get a total of 3 gigs, it will slow general processing down quite a bit, due to mismatched RAM.

With most notebooks you should always keep the RAM equal in each side. So to downgrade from 4GB you'd need to down all the way to 2GB (1GB on each side).

by ldxrunner

Salutations and Greetings ManiacMan, I am very much a novice in understanding this technology. Could you please elaborate as to what I am to do ? If it is not asking too much, could you read the other posts and give me some insight as to what I am to do ? Thank youi for your time and your consideration in this subject matter.

by ic-it

you have a nice setup, don't worry about it. You can try the /PAE switch, but really don't need to.
If you do and have any driver (or BSOD) issues, it will be because of the switch.
I would just set back and enjoy the notebook.

by maniacman

If the CPU can't take advantage of it, then the switch will basically be ignored altogether, but I have yet to see it blue screen anything. You stand to lose nothing by trying it.

by absolutely

ManiacMan's posts come closest to the impression I've gathered from various other knowledgeable-ish sources. I don't claim I was paying extremely close attention, but I'm also not claiming this is more than $0.02 worth.

by ldxrunner

Salutations and Greetings Oz_Media, How are the two groups the same ? How do I find out who made the RAM ? Thank you.

by ldxrunner

Salutations and Greetings ManiacMan, I am very much a novice in my knowledge and my experience of computer science. If ii is not asking too much could you elaborate as to what I should do ? If it is too complicated for me too do, how do I find someone who can do it ? Is their some way you or someone else that could talk me through via telephone, if I called them. If the PAE switch does not work, then what ? Return the machine and let them remove the extra RAM ? It cost me about $220.00. If the CPU cannot take advantage of the switch then which OS should I install the Vista or the XP plain or upgrade to professional ? Thank you ever so much for your time and your consideration in this subject matter.

by ic-it

I was reading that some workstations have 64bit drivers that can get confused by the reported memory and try to use those drivers by default, causing the BSOD. The article didn't feel it was a common issue. Likely earlier (cutting edge?)written device firmware/drivers.

by Former member

On the Motherboard and the OS.

If the MB has a 40 bit address/data path you can theoretically have 1^12 bits of ram. An mbyte is (1^6) * 8 bits. The rest just depends on the OS.

Before others correct me on this, this is one of the areas where things are not fixed and most often used is HD sales; some use a Kbyte as 1024 bytes and others 1 kbyte = 1^3 bytes. The error is mine in trying to simplify and doing this off the top of my head.

by pgm554

resource allocation required by the BIOS and OS.
That 1 gig is used for hardware address space allocation and drivers.

If you have a 256 meg video card,it will eat up 256 megs address space in that reserved address space,512 will do the same for 512 and so on.
Kinda like the old DOS 640K limitation where 384k out of 1 meg total was reserved for hardware address space.

This discussion is closed to new replies.