Discussion Locked

I found things on my bosses

0 helpful
273 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

273 replies

by charliespencer

I should have hung a 'smiley' on the end of that post. The comment was intended as light-hearted, not serious. I violated the prime rule of communications, that the sender is responsible for clarity of the message.

I agree with most of your points, especially regarding certs, degrees, and other paper.

Vancouver? Sorry, too cold for this southern boy. Also a serious lack of NASCAR tracks.

by baz_shaw

Really, that's what I would do (and have done in similar situation). Obscene photos, movies, whatever, just delete the lot. I mean, what's he gonna do, say "hey where's all my XXX stuff gone?"

You could cover your ass a bit by saying you think some files may have been corrupted during the transfer, give him some technowaffle about buffer overruns (assuming he's not technical) and could he check to make sure nothing important was lost.

That way he'll think you MIGHT have seen something, but can't be sure, and it will also make him realize what an idiot he was in the first place.

by danlm

I read almost all the way through the threads. And differences aside on company policy, everyone seems to be in agreement(thankfully). That if its child porn, turn the pig in.
Otherwise, your call.

by anniemae46

Not sure what you mean by "could really hurt his company". You need good instinct, a pair of balls and know your company's culture and mentality. I wonder if it is computer illiteracy or arrogance to ask the IT person for assistance and have them encounter someone's weird little world online.

I know an IT guy who was in the same situation. Turns out that some companies are more worried by lawsuits of violating some high-position user's rights. Well, my friend decided to 'oops' erase some of the illegal, sick s#&t he found on the system (it was a company laptop). That user did not come back to him to complain either.

by vltiii

The first thing that needs to be cleared up is how do you know that these things are illegal or that he obtained them illegally? Pictures of people doesn't sound illegal regardless the source. Of course if the pics are kiddie porn that's another story altogether, but you left out quite a few specifics.

by oz_media

As for cold, warmest climate in Canada (ona year round basis). VERY little snow, in fact I watched it snow all over the states when we had sunshine here.

Canada's a BIG place, there's some horribly cold provinces, cities etc., but Vancouver isn't one of them.

by raidon

Lawyer ? Did you view the offensive material?
Me ? No! ( Thinking of being fired for testifying to viewing illegal material during company time)
Lawyer ? Did you see Mr. ??????? put the material on his system.
Me ? No.

Long story short. I had made a backup of the material for my protection. My boss was suspended without pay for 2 weeks. I was fired.
I found out in my lawsuit that you can be let go without cause as long as the company pays you a proper settlement. In Canada it is 1 week per year of service. I found out that the powers that be did not want me looking at corporate documents. They drafted a new company policy that the it department was not allowed to view ?.. unless written authorization was obtained yada, yada, yada.

Have fun with this one as you may be left with the knowledge of doing the right thing as you look for a new JOB.

by thumper1

Discovered porn on one of the Attorney's systems while doing routine maintenance. The guidelines I worked under at the time dictated that I answer to the senior partner. I let him know what I found. That was the end of it.

by little-b

In reading most of the posts, I find that some people are just plain ignorant with their remarks. Some have accused and convicted Zlito of opening these files, but if you read in the initial post Zlito never opened a one---so quit your stupid condemnation of this tech! I have done file transfers and have seen suspicious files go by, too with bad names, but you don't have the right to view these personal files. Therefore, you do not have any authority to accuse any one, either due to the fact you do not have hard evidence, only suspicion. Zlito was correct in not viewing these files, so give him/her a break!

It is also true, especially in the case of a president who takes his laptop home, he may not have put files on his laptop, but he is responsible to follow company policy and it is his laptop. If the policy states there is to be no porn, software that is not approved, etc. then there should also be a method in place to report it.

With the various companies you can work for, there may be a range from no policy to very strict policies. As an employee of the company, the tech is REQUIRED to abide by the company policy or it could possibly result in reprimand or dismissal.

The solution is to abide by the stated company policy and watch your back. If there is no policy, you have to protect yourself and report obvious Federal and State offenses in the manner they prescribe. When this happens and it involves a CEO or President, take my advice and find a new job as it will not be pretty! Even if you get thru all the legal stuff and keep your job, you will not be wanted by that reported individual.

I'm not even sure what the Fed and States require in reporting something like CP, but Zlito has not actually seen the evidence, only file names and this is not actual evidence a wrong was committed.

If I was in Zlito's position, I would let the boss know that, although Zlito didn't open any, there could be some files on his latop that violated the stated policy and he may want to check and delete them. If I felt the president would take legal action against me because he felt threatened, I might cover my back by reporting it to HR, letting them know the president was warned, and start the process rolling and then look for a new job. Even if the boss deleted his data, knowing he was not very computer savvy, it can be recovered for evidence in court, although it is relatively expensive.

Unless the tech had administrative rights and authority to examine possible contraband, I would never open up a user's data without their permission and I wouldn't try to copy it for legal purposes later---that's where you will get in trouble for stealing personal data. If it was stored on a company share, that's different.

Therefore, know your policy and abide by it and have your resume up to date unless you want to be someone with no backbone at all and not abide by policy. By reading this discussion, there are a lot of people like that out there who are very judgemental.

I think Zlito has some guts and did what was very hard to do if it followed his company policy, but will be able to sleep better at night because of it.

by keithmc

If I found images that were clearly illegal, I'd turn the guy in. I'd rather do what's right and get fired than do nothing at all. To ingnore them and take a "let someone else deal with it" attitude is a cop-out (imho).

If the images were simply offensive, and there was a company policy, I'd bring it to his attention. We used to scour our network for images and contraband and when we found some we would contact the user and inform them that "a scan of the network found images that are against company policy". 9 times out of 10, the files were off the network in seconds! They ALWAYS knew exactly what you were referring to.

by jschilb

If illegal software or documents are on a machine it is not IT job to remove it. HR is to be contacted and HR will do the investigation and have the software or documents removed. If IT does it on its own then someone in IT will lose their job.

by lwebb

Ok, blackmail wouldn't be the moral or ethical thing...but if he's aware that YOU'RE aware, there won't be any RGE's in the future for you.

Does he OWN the company?

Are the pictures REALLY illegal? (Morally,legally, ethically if the answer is yes, then you gotta turn him in.)

#1 thing to keep in mind is covering your own bottom. Will it look bad if someone else finds out, then finds out you KNEW and didn't say anything?

If they're NOT illegal and you really don't want to rat the guy out, then do what I do:

Block sites/IP addresses/yada yada...restrict his access. When he asks why...

Gently remind him that "nothing you do on this machine is private..."

"Please stop getting those javascript viruses."
"What javascript viruses?"
"Oh, I don't think you want me to go into that. Please just stop...you're making extra unnecessary work for the IT dept."

"If someone else notices the JS viruses (bandwidth consumption/DNS queries to pr0n sites/etc, etc, etc) I may be asked by management to investigate. Neither one of us wants that hassle do we?"

I've used each and every one of those (and other lines) and they work like a CHARM. I don't want to get the guy busted. I just want him to STOP surfing for porn on company time. It makes work for me.

Besides, if I busted everyone whom I found pr0n under their login, we'd have to fire 1/4th of the company including some VP's and department Supervisors.

If it's ILLEGAL though, I'm straight to the HR director's office with my laptop and I show him over the network via the magic of the C$ share... And yep, I've had to do that too.

by mlevitre

I was in a similiar situation not long ago where a top executive had porn all over his PC. So here is what I did, the first thing was too send an email from his PC to the Administrator telling them you need help on this PC, let them VNC or Remote Into the box telling them what you have found. Then if they run SurfControl or any type of Reporting software this person will get the real picture. They ended up finding more that they wanted and utilmately firing this person. Do the right thing it make your job easier later on when this person contuities to break company policy, he did sign an agreement from your company "Acceptable Internet Use Policy"?

by lvaquerano

absolutly, IT personnel is in no way,shape or form
Police or authority figure. you are assigned to an specific job/duty and have no right to open or browse around someone else's personal equipment.
Unless you are given instruction "specific instruction" by like glrudd says in his reply HR or Legal department or any other law enforcemtn agency or instructed by your local police department. YOU have no right to open files. no matter what they are. I totally agree with GLRUDD on this

by avid

must be nice to be able to earn so much for that position. here that position pays very little.

by mtufts

If it is company - go by the stated company policy for this discovery. Note: THE STATED COMPANY ADMINISTRATIVE POLICY/PROCEDURE...nothing more and nothing less.

If it is personal, leave it up to his own conscience and a higher power. Believe you me, when you turn the problem over to a "higher power" it gets results. Does your company policy cover personal equipment? I doubt it--so don't become the "private affairs lawmaker" at your company when it is a personal, private matter. Think what you might about this so-called "leader" in your heart and let a higher power deal with your bosses heart...and try not to smirk with the results.

by hal 9000

Provided that there is no Kiddy Porn involved you do absolutely nothing. He/She is the Boss and has the ultimate authority to do as they please as they are not liable to follow company policy but to make it and this is a good example of "Do As I Say Not As I Do!" ;)

Incidentally do you have so little to do that you can watch the data transfer instead of leaving it alone and getting on with other jobs?

This should have been a simple job to do just connect both LT's with a crossover cable and then send the required folders across once you have started this running you should be able to walk away and not pay any attention until the job is finished at which point all you need do is drop the new unit on the Bosses desk and walk away knowing nothing. :)

If you look you have to be prepared to be responsible for what you may find so it is easier not to look in the first place. What you have to also remember is that what you personally might find offensive can be humor to someone else no matter just how sick you personally consider it to be. :D

Of course if there is any Kiddy porn involved you just have to report it to the proper authorities and do not wipe the HDD of the old LT just so that the chain of evidence remains unbroken. If you wipe the old HDD you could be held to blame for the images or whatever have ended up on the new LT as there is no evidence that they where on the old unit before you got it to work on. The old HDD has date stamps when each thing was added so if they existed long before you got your hands on it you can in no way be responsible for the contents of the drive but if you wipe the drive you can be blamed for adding the images in an attempt to get the Boss into trouble at the very least and in all likely hood will be fired as you have not protected yourself in any way.

There is a very old saying "The Boss is Always Right" so if it came down to a straight out bun fight you would be the sacrificial lamb lead to the slaughter. Might is always right no matter how wrong it appears to be. :(

Col ]:)

by ceja1

Let me get this straight, somebody who needs your services for which you get paid, and they trust you with their secrets, want to transfer files to the new machine he/she bought and you are thinking, should you turn him in? Unless it is murder, the only winners here will be the lawyers and nobody else. Everybody else will have a pocket drain and tomorrow it will be business as usual. Seems that you had too much time on your hand to be looking the file transfer as it goes. I do not have that luxury. Try to find something to do more productive as file transfer goes.

by oz_media

Again, I have not mentioned a position but an average wage, and you don't just get GIVEN a wage, you negotiate it if you want to earn real money.
Read the post again, from what I've seen in the industry, there aren't too many IT staff capable of properly selling themselves or findig work to begin with, if so everyone would make more money I suppose.

But in all fairness, you pay a lot of tax here, but you get what you pay for and then some.

by wizofkwaj

There was absolutely no reason for you to view -any- of the content of the files you were transferring. To do otherwise is an complete violation of ethical principles.

What your boss had as content on his computer is of no concern to you, unless you happen to be a law enforcement officer tasked with searching all computers you encounter for possible controversial or illegal content.

"Watching files go by" is first a watch of only the file names, not content, unless you are intentionally snooping. A file copy process does not show the contents of the file.

If you "did not dig into the files because I do like to bother other peoples info" then you would not known of the content. File names have many times no relationship to content. Unless you -do- dig into the files you have no idea what they contain.

Digging into the files takes a bit more effort than transferring them.

Quite simply you were an unconscionable spy on your boss's data. You violated his right to privacy to the ultimate. Asking you to transfer files implies, unless your boss is a complete moron, that you have been trusted to do so without concern for content.

Regardless of the file contents you violated that trust.

If I allow you into my house to move my belongings to another location does that give you the permission to read any and all papers and access any other informational material within the house?

You are nothing more than a thief yourself. You stole his information for your own purposes, be they nefarious or simply a 'check everybody that they do no wrong'. The wrong being what -you- define as wrong.

There was no reason to view any of the file contents in order to transfer them. I have over 37 years experience in all phases of computer technology and I have never had to view the contents of a file when moving it unless necessary to, if possible, correct a transfer error.

I have no knowledge, nor do I wish to have, what information you 'found'. Unless you are tasked with finding such you far exceeded your ethical boundaries.

by wizofkwaj

This is a simple case of someone snooping files on another's computer. No network was involved. The boss asked for files to be 'migrated'. Basically make my new laptop have 'the same stuff' as the previous.

In the case o the scenario of 'somebody else' loading objectionable material the law doesn't care how it got there, only that you have it in your possession. The mere act of acquiring it is considered manufacturing (yes, I know that is a ridiculous interpretation) which is in many jurisdictions a felony.

The mere fact that the files were copied could set the copier for charges.

by hal 9000

How can you tell what is on any HDD before you open it?

I do not know about you but I for one lack the luxury of time to waste looking at the contents of any HDD unless I'm paid to and even then it is the most cursory inspection I just keep the files in the more common folders and then proceed to erase the drive before reloading and then copy the files back across. The My Documents folder is an easy one even the Favorites is an easy one about the only ones that I'm ever close to looking at are the Address Book and stored E-Mails as they are imported in and even then I just leave the thing running while I do my work and come back a long time after it has finished.

Now this is where the Law at least over here is stupid it relies on you having "Intent" to break the Law so if you can quite rightly say that you have absolutely no idea of what was on a HDD then you have shown no Intent to break the Law and if there are any repercussions they do not fall on the IT person but the owner of the unit.

That is why I keep saying that if you don't look you'll never find yourself facing a dilemma such as this, a perfect case where ignorance is bliss. :)

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Released their 3 step VPN on 2003. For even the most basic security we now have to not only secure all of our workstations but the senior managements home PC's/LT's as well.

It is pointless having the best security possible when the Company President/Boss or whoever may have an unprotected PC at home that is capable of being used by anyone there. So we now go out and create user accounts and secure their home PC's or whatever so we don't have gapping holes in our security. It is amazing just how many of these computers have absolutely no security or AV installed but their owners still expect a direct connection into their work as they require it. We generally setup our own Internet connection and just allow them to use it as required it works out far cheaper in the short term and is a lot easier to control. It also limits any potential damage if their machine falls into the wrong hands. Currently we are slowly replacing every one of the senior managements home PC's with a company PC that we honestly never expect to see again until it gets brought back to be replaced with a new unit or breaks because some idiot game was installed.

Col

by rocket_scientist

you say that "I do like to bother other peoples info"

is this a typo or do you actually LIKE BOTHERING other people's information?

If it is just a typo (my guess) then pick a policy and stick with it. If you don't like messing with your user's data then stick to that motto and stop wasting our time with you wishy washiness.

by another canadian

Ah men too many moraliste in this world and not enough police to enforce the real abuse :)

Get the state out of my bedroom and get the beliver in the Church well they could pray for my soul.

If this is CP yes act on it and move on. If this is Paris Hilton distributing her porn well don't watch it. If this is Compagny property and he own the compagny you have to leave as you are obviously against any kind of luxure.

I when to the middle east and for a country that condone pornography and alchool there is plenty available so again the moralist freak are the worst behind close door.

Were there is no commensens there is none.

Have a nice day.

by technicallyright

I think that you have offered the most realistic advise here. I certainly wish someone had given me that piece of advise a few years ago!

by another canadian

Yes you should is this is child pornography because it is desctrutive to the child in question and that should be the main reason. But because your own morale of what should be the life style of everyone adult on Earth no.

Too many laws has been made because of morale that was by itself desctructive.

You have a policy for computer that is own by your corporation well use it.

You let personal computer been connected to your network, well that is not the same and I will further add that if I bought my own computer and my compagny ask me to connect with it to their network well I save them money and labour and maintenance so they have a no per say in what I have unless we both agreed in advance of what I should have and not have on my computer and in that case well they will partialy pay for my computer to fully pay for it.

Porno is just what is said porno period. You could download legaly Porno on the net as free in certain case after you gave them your sould of course and or pay for it same for MP3 especialy if you own a MP3 Player and that your rip your own CD.

You are a hard and dedicated worker, well this won't be a problem you will find another job and maybe at better condition but next time you will surely not do a transfer file of a personal computer to another personal computer unless you are a sado masochiste your self :) I think you will stay away from now on from "Personal" computer unless directed to do so.

Anyway we are putting to much people behind bars and not keeping the murder behind bars is my opinion, and most of the problems we have in this world right now is the religious freak, war freak, peace freak and moral freak remove them from the equalition and you are left with the real problem like child pornography and murderer.

Outside commonsens there is none. :)

Have a great day.

by another canadian

Never heard of that from the Mac enthousiast?

I heard it all the time from Executive Management.

They don't want to know how my financial system work for the input they want to see the result.

Don't expect a manager to be a clerk and don't expect a clerk to be a manager.

A General might be very bad at performing drill but he might be the best at strategies as long as he know what will be the result of using a 90 millimiter to hit a target it will let the calculation of the trajectory to the Artillery Officer, does that make him stupid? Would the Artillery Officer be better then him to lay the full battle strategy? I don't think so.

I don't expect my superior to know about everything I do even the programer will ask me what should I put in my program so that it make your work more efficient.

Of course you could have a programmer that have a fromation in finance and know most of the answer already but even then he will ask the clerk same for the IT.

Again outside of commensens there is none :)

Have a nice day.

by another canadian

I read all the post until this one and keeping reading and saw none condenining childpornography he said Porno is a morale issue child abuse is criminal and should be acted on it right away.

Too many people are behind bar because of morale and too many murderer are left free what is more morale.

9/11 was done by the Extreme moralist (read extreme fanatic religous) they are very morale person yet they hurt us, so don't give us the moral thing but give us the meat. Was it child pronography or not?? if not move on.

Outside of commensens there is none.

Have a nice day.

by oducille

You say that you didn't "dig" into the files. If you didn't "dig", then how do you know what they were? How do you know that they were not files left over in the ie cache from a legitimately subscribed service? Additionally, if you didn't "dig", then how do you know what they were, unless you recognized the filenames. If you recognized the filenames, then you have seen these pictures and mpg's before. Tell us. How exactly did you gain that experience? Is it possible that you have done the same that you are accusing your boss of doing? If you turn him in, then turn yourself in too, while you're at it.

You "think" you "have something on the boss" that could give you some sort of moral leverage in your own mind or in your job. Or, since you're asking us what you should do, you're looking for some "outside" support in making some decision that could affect you adversely for the REST OF YOUR LIFE, not to mention ruining someone elses life. You have absolutely no right to even make any moral assumptions about him, his character. Your job was to move files. And, since you are a service provider, there is such a thing as privelege. There are certain rights to privacy that are afforded you and your client (your boss). Such rights are even more acute than for everybody else. If you turn him in, you're relinquishing those rights. And when you do, every computer in the business, your home, your bosses home and at least everybody's home who could have had access to your bosses laptop. And, it's not gonna stop there! The spotlight is going to be on YOUR FIRST!

Call in an air strike on your own position and so obliterate the enemy because we have seen the enemy and the enemy is us.

Your moral responsibility is to do your job, keep your nose out of other people's business and keep your mouth shut. Go home and hug your family and thank the lord that you decided to ask for advice as opposed to executing a knee jerk reaction and call the authorities. I've seen this kind of think play out and it's not pretty. It ruined about 5 families and a thriving business. Gave teh FBI about $ 60,000 worth of computer equipment and software that the didn't return. It made the lawyers and the legal system a ton of money. ...Gave the news people thier "pound of flesh" to roast in the media...It gave the villiagers with their pitchforks and torches a feeling that the monsters were yet again rooted out and lynched. And the FBI someone to arrest and hold in jail without bound. Do you really don't need such "strange fruit" hanging from YOUR trees when you're not exactly sure, since you didn't dig - as you claim? Time passes, but the stench lingers there FOREVER!

by oducille

If his laptop is private and he took measures (like password the share, for instance) to make access to his computer private, it makes no difference whether it's on the company private network, the internet or connected to the company network over a vpn. It's private information. If someone cracks it after being passworded and it becomes accessable from the net. It can be proven that his rights were violated by the "cracker" and so the "cracker" is the criminal. Not him!

Here's a scenario. Person A and person B are standing in the town square along with lots of people and their children on a saturday morning. Subject B rips the clothes off of subject A. Who should be charged here? Subject A for lewd and disordly conduct? Or, subject B for assault? Sure, subject A is naked and it's unlawful to be in the town's square unclothed? That eveidence is in admissable because it was not A's intent to be unclothed. Subject B on the other hand perfomed an illegal action that caused A to be naked.

Enough said?

by Member 27332238

I checked all your posts and couldn't establish whether you
simply saw the names of the files while they were transferring,
or if you opened them up to look (a whole new ethical area). If
they were simply file names, there is a possibility that they were
put there by a virus.
I don't know how effective your anti-virus system is, but I know
I've checked a staff members PC before and found literally
hundreds of "Britney Spears does gross things to ducks.mpg"
files that after destroying the main virus were picked up
themselves as viruses. Perhaps your boss just has a badly
infected computer.

by theroyala9

The question of illegal files is determined by
unanimous decision.

What is and is not cp or copyrighted material
would probably suprise you. How these thing can
get on a disk probably shouldn't.

The question of slander, private property,
trespass and
how much a man career and reputation is worth --
decided by
simple majority.

by afhavemann9

You must be extremely careful here, consider all that could occur.

If you?ve seen contraband pictures/videos you must be extremely careful. First, if these are of minors, underage children, you have a legal responsibility to report it; IF YOU?VE SEEN IT! I emphasize here because an old adage comes into play from my Military days when I would occasionally observe infractions (fighting for instance) that, if I were to ?SEE IT? , I must act. I may however ?observe? something and not ?SEE IT?. You are in this position if there is no child pornography involved.

If you have not seen it (contraband, such as child pornography), I would stop NOW and return the laptop. Be discrete; indicate why without going into any detail at all; refuse to proceed.

Be aware that either of these choices may very well cost you your job. However, reporting the issue (if applicable) at least gives you a legal position to fall back on.

If you were to use your knowledge of what is on the computer to retain your position you may well be guilty of blackmail. Charges have been filed secussfully in the past.

A third alternative is to destroy the hard disk ?by accident?. However, depending on the content, you may well be contributing to the infraction.

I can go no further; this is all that can safely be said. Just be aware that you are in a precarious position that can easily lead to serious legal problems.

by charliespencer

Don't forget U.S. dollars and Canandian dollars do not trade "one for one". While the currency exchange rates change daily (hourly?), figure that $1.00 US exchanges to about $1.20 Canadian. That $80K Canadian is around $64K US.

On the other hand, any advantage the US may have in the exchange rate may be offset by the Canadian health care system.

by ronny.powell

Unless this is a hidden sociology survey like a lot of these immature help me post appear. You have already blown it by not using an anonymous userid for the post.
It would not be very hard for me to discover who this person is you a maligning and blow the whistle for you. Is that what you are hoping?
Well, never fear I won?t but others may. Courage is courage you never know if you have it until you are dodging the bullets.
Good Luck growing?

by southpaw

Good Job Kevin620
Simple and to the point.

Unless you know the Boss well enough to ask him in a descreet manner about the unusual content. Maybe suggest he allow you to search the disk for spyware and files that could have been downloaded without his knowledge. If he says no thanks, drop it. If he says yes, treat it as a private matter to preserve his dignity and your job.

by synthetic

Wow kevin620 must be that one person out there that when someone says, let he without sin cast the first stone, kevin620 has already released a bolder. I find your manner and tact poor at best. Amazingly, when my clients need data migrated, it it up to me to verify the data has been consolidated from the usual places. Even though I state for the client to place all personal data in my documents or desktop, that rarely happens, and a great admin will do a verification first. How can one avoid tasteless files if they are in my documents and the system is set to thumb nail view. Just the process of consolidating and transferring the data leaves a person open to seeing file names which can be obvious and shocking. So, I guess you can either put down the hammer and help, or keep nailing yourself to that cross and living in a world very different than the one most of us in the field live in.

by tuffalan

First is it his laptop or the companys, if it his the answer is simple child porn you report to police "anomously", If not let it go this time and then push for policies and procedures to solve this problem next time through your legal and HR Departments, we only learn from mistakes and problems.

by jaymeta

During my years as a Network Manager, I learned that when I ran across these types of files on a "company" computer. I just deleted the files and went on about my business. I only remember one person asking what happened to his private pictures he had on the PC, I told him they were against company policy, but I'd be glad to go to his department manager about un-deleting his picture files for him. As you can guess, he declined the opportunity. You would be suprised how clean the other computers in his department were after this and I had no other problems out of his department.
I have deleted files on the Company CIO's PC down to the pc's in the sanatation department without any problems and no one even wanting to discuss them. I was lucky in that we had a well posted computer usage policy on what was appropriate and expected by the user's. I know this can be a tough situation to be in, but the important thing is to be consistent and make sure that everyone is familiar with the Company Computer Usage policy.

by gordon.rudd

What is it about doing the right thing the right way that makes you so afraid of following the rules and staying the course? Backbone and OT have nothing to do with he issue at hand. If you want to play fast & loose with the rules in this instance would you also say identify theft is the inalienable right of an It professional?

Your response fails to note he obvious?the company, not the employees, owns the network and all that is attached to it. Therefore, the company makes the rules and stands behind the enforcement of the rules. Not IT.

by phillologist

Is it a case that you have proof they are stolen? Could it he have purchase it? Also do you company have strict it policies?, if you do and it can be proven that it is stolen info then let him know the consequences if seen with such type of files/act. Is it that it turned your stomach on a morality issues?, if it is dont impose your belief/moral on anyone. Is the machine company or personal property? Deep down i think you will know what to do. Just be tactful.

by timmitchell

If it is not the job of the IT department to police the proper use of computers and other systems on the network, then whose job is it? Shall the lawyers browse the network for unauthorized files? Do we give the HR folks admin access so they can look for illegal software?

Anyone who has worked in this business for more than two days knows that we in IT, regardless of our specific role, must serve as the front line to defend our corporate infrastructure from threats such as viruses, hackers, and other illegal activity. Granted, the situation must be handled delicately, particularly when the suspected offender is a superior. Ultimately, we are responsible for what happens on our systems.

by gordon.rudd

Tim - You are correct when you say that it IT that is on the front line when it comes to protecting the corporate "infrastructure from threats such as viruses, hackers, and other illegal activity". I believe you stray when you confuse the IT role of protecting the infrastrucure with protecting the moral fiber of the community in which the comapny exists.

To answer your question:it is the responsibility of the legal and HR departments to create and maintain a safe working environement for all company employees. IF...P&P as well as your job description states it is part of our duties to police content, then yes it is. If not, then no.

by arjee63

Aside from issues of legality, you need to find out who the exceptions are to the electronic resource policy before you burn your boss. If he's in the "exceptions" group all you've done is sink your own career. Ask around - use your network to find out if the rules really do apply to everyone. Then, you should be able to tell if he's in the group to which the rules don't apply -and there's almost always an "untouchable" group, even if it's just the CEO.

Thing two - You didn't say whether it was stolen copyrighted material, or pornography, or what. Depending on how bad the material was may also help you in knowing whether you should pursue it. Is it bad enough to risk your job? If it is - do the right thing! The right thing may be to contact the proper authorities.

by robin.hunt

While it is not the job duty of IT to police users, invariably it is an IT person who accidentally "stumbles" into inappropriate and/or unlaw material on users machines. Anytime my techs stumble into something of that nature, we immediately report what we found to HR. It is then HR's responsibility to deal with the user and the company infractions.

by gordon.rudd

Jim - sounds to me like you are following your organizations P&P. What is wrong with that? Making sure your universe is safe from hostile aliens is always going to be OK...if P&P back you. If not, nice working with you.

You are NOT a cop.

-Gordon

by fp88

The title sums it up: I've seen all sorts of crap on people's computers - you name it, I've seen it.
I don't bite the hand that feeds me. I'm paid to make computers work, not to moralize about people's tastes or to be a stool pidgeon to the authorities, who are just as corrupt as the people they prosecute.

by nonamepipes

Depending on your job responsibilities and company policy you could be at risk, especially if there is a sexual harassment policy in your company. I can speak from experience in this area, and you better be a good documenter to cover your ass. Policies differ from company to company but the law is the same for everyone. I would check your local laws which govern your work place to see what you are responsible for. My current company had no porn policy when I got here, they do now, and it coincides with their sexual harassment policy. One of the reasons they dumped the last Admin is he spent to much time in the server room browsing porn. I sent a clear message to my end-users about porn. There is no place for it in this workplace, and when I do find end-users abusing the policy they get a policy lockdown on their desktop. I have had to do that to only 1 user so far.

by jim.allen1

Hi having read all the experts views _ I reckon the simplest way out do a search for all *.xls mdb and doc files ie MS office or the equivelent on the machine transfer them, then "Format C:" if anything said claim the hard drives crashed as you were transfering - president won't be happy but can hardly blame you for hardware failure - if he wants nasty pictures on his machine he'll have to load them himself.....

by the docman

Be careful here. If the company is publicly held, the policies will rule the President (especially since Sarbanes-Oxley). If, however, the comapany is private and the president is the majority shareholder (or can garner the support of the majority), then he answers only to himself. He wins, you lose, and you've got nothing to fall back on.

by g.m.bakker (cne, self employed)

Hmmm, the boss requested you to transfer his data, and as an IT pro, you do so, he'the boss. If you are there to also monitor morality, then do so, otherwise do not get involved. Some of this info is confidential and private so respect that. Snitching is mediocre behaviour and will eventually damage the trust peopl have in you, and also make you an impopular snoop and damage whatever career you plan to make. As an IT-pro you have accesss to all sorts of info stored on computers/servers, it may be confidential or not, and what ever it is, for the outside world it's confidential, so if you leak on what's on so and so's computer you ignore the confidentiallity rule, and cannot be trusted by your colleagues at first, and later on by the rest of th co-workers. Be smart and just do what is requested, keep it to yourself untill asked by the highest in rank to spill the beans, however, if you spill, you're on a tight rope. Just remember that. You can however tell the guy who's computer it is that you disagree with whats on the PC and let him dicide if he's going to trash it or keep it, it's his job and don't turn it it into a double whammy!

by kennethl

This is reply # two hundred and umpty-umpt to your original question.
I think that you need to consider something else, before sending your little love-note to Big Brother.
"He who lives in a glass house, shouldn't throw stones."
Might want to consider that, and check your own stuff for illegal material. Ever copied a CD of music from a friend? Ever rented a videotape and made a copy? Have you PAID for everything that you own that should really have been paid for?

If you send that letter, YOU will ALSO be investigated, to confirm whether you are a reliable informant. If you aren't squeaky clean, then don't send it. Handcuffs can hurt. But Bubba hurts worse.

by zlitocook

At this company! I was told that what ever the CEO wants is ok and what he keeps on his personal computer is his Property and what you see is company property. I had a family member who is a Lawyer and she suggestd leaving the company with out going to court. Because the CEO has more money in Lawyers then I could bring in. And I do not know why he could know what I posted here. I do not use my ID here as I use there.

by hal 9000

Job to go to. If not you have only cut off your nose to despite your face!

In IT you are going to see things stored on computers that you will find offensive but provided that there are no obvious laws broken you just have to live with it of find a job doing something completely different.

My Pet Peeve is the Old Folks Home where I do some volunteer work all the inmates attempting to show me the newest porn sites that they have found and the women giving me not only a look see but sound effects as well. :D

Col ]:)

by Former member

on what company policy states. In most corporations. Company data belongs to the company, it is therefore subject to random searches, which certain network personnel are required by policy to make, as part of security validation.

The important thing is to keep personal moral judgement out of it, and apply the policy.

by realaustech

I take it from your comments that these folders are his own personal property. As you also said this was a company laptop, therefore the contents of these folders are subject to the corporate IT policy. If the "Young" folder contains CP then the person should be reported to the authorities, simply because it is illegal, not only where you work, but almost everywhere in the world!

You were also said that you were told to let it go. This is a very dangerous situation to be in. I would be getting out of there, before you become implicated in distributing CP, as that appears to be on his computer. Sooner or later, someone else is going to find this illegal material, and then the cat will be well and truly out of the bag, and if you do nothing about it now, then you are just as liable to prosecution as your boss is.

by crb

The minute you said that some of the files were music types, you or your company cou;d run afoul of the Digital Mulenium Copyright Act (DMCA). If the music files are not orginal sources then the RIAA can and will sue the deep pockets( IE the company that owns the computer).

by cyber_daddy

I must say that i disagree with your sentiments that the admin in question is wrong.... at least to the extent that he should question the entry point of this information to his environmkent because part of the admin's role it to ensure data and information entering and exiting the company conforms to corporate policy. The reason that organization's invest in sophisticated filtering and content inspection suites is to preserve the integrity of the company's data and information and any breach of this is within his jurisdiction to account. I say run a scan on all users desktops for mpgs and jpegs anf forward to head of operations and let him and the compnay lawyers deal with it... will look worse when the auditors run into it and question your control systems..

by fnm48

Don't be so self rightous. Lighten up. If he is really doing something Illegal, it's none of your buisness ! He will eventually "hang himself" !
Do what you are hired for, migrate the data. That's all. It's not your concern, are you his Wife or Mother ? If not, stay out of his business.

by hal 9000

Firstly as the data is already migrated and I suppose the original HDD either has been wiped or overwritten you would be leaving yourself open to a claim that you placed it there for some reason best known to yourself.

If it is just copyrighted material I wouldn't bother as I'm not actually paid to look at data while it is being transfered, even hard core porn doesn't worry me overly but if it was Kiddy Porn totally different story and I would at the very least keep the original HDD to preserve the chain of evidence.

But if it is just pictures of naked children I for one wouldn't bother as they could be special photos of his kids/grandkids or whatever. I can still remember a case here where a chemist was charged with Child Pornography because he had a picture of his daughter {according to the complainant} naked and sitting on the floor. The child was actually a boy and just at the stage where he could sit up but other then the fact that there was no nappy on the child you could see nothing hence the mistaken identity of the child by the person who made the complaint.

It was a mess that eventually resulted in him selling the business and leaving the state just to get away from the stench of the allegations leveled against him.

This is an area where it is always better to step on the side of caution unless it is already known that the Boss is the only one with access to the computer and the images are down right wrong otherwise forget you ever saw the things! :)

Col ]:)

by sendbux

This is a legal question, and one of private property: the company has the right to decide what resides on its property. The issue regarding policies can easily be handled with a simple amendment to the employee handbook.

Additionally, if the company owns computers and there is illegal matter found on their computers, there is a very great danger that the company could be liable for its presence, if it doesn't take steps to prevent it.

by hadley.weir

The viewing of inappropriate or illegal images in the workplace can lead to criminal and civil claims, not only against the company but also it's directors and the managers they appoint if negligence is found. Organisations have a responsibility to protect there staff from harassment in the workplace. Most companies will have some type in gateway filtering in place but this only solves part of the problem, images can be introduced via USB ports, memory sticks, CD's, DVD's etc... if an image is imbedded in a work doc or PowerPoint it will get through your gateway. My company specialize in protecting organisations and there staff from illicit image abuse by monitoring in real time at the desk-top, if you have a concern about potentially damaging images on your network drop me a line.

by hadley.weir

The viewing of inappropriate or illegal images in the workplace can lead to criminal and civil claims, not only against the company but also it's directors and the managers they appoint if negligence is found. Organisations have a responsibility to protect there staff from harassment in the workplace. Most companies will have some type in gateway filtering in place but this only solves part of the problem, images can be introduced via USB ports, memory sticks, CD's, DVD's etc... if an image is imbedded in a work doc or PowerPoint it will get through your gateway. My company specialize in protecting organisations and there staff from illicit image abuse by monitoring in real time at the desk-top, if you have a concern about potentially damaging images on your network drop me a line

by rsears

The title says it all... Forget what you saw. Do you like your job? Is the stuff about making bombs? Does it exploit children? If not, leave it alone.

This discussion is closed to new replies.