Discussion Locked

I hate headhunters. Let's get rid of them.

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This isn't a sales pitch. I know you don't believe me. I'm (still) an IT person with an idea, and I want to talk to some other IT people about it. But it sounds like a sales pitch, I know. Maybe if I change the headline or something...

If you're a consultant who went through the highs of the 80's and the lows of the 90's, you might be interested in just exactly how we might stabilize our salaries against such wild market fluctuations. It is possible - and if you're interested in discussing it, I'm interested in talking to you. I don't have a company, I'm not a headhunter, I don't have a job to offer you. I don't even have an infomercial. I just have a solid idea and I need about 5 people to talk to about it. If you're in the boston MA area and you're intrigued, email me at j.penney@computer.org - I don't even have a mailing list, so you don't have to worry about me selling your information to anyone. If you're interested, send me an email and we'll continue the discussion.

If anyone wants to throw out some ideas on the board here as to how we can gain some bargaining power in this lovely economy of ours, have at it - I look forward to lively discusions.

JP

11 replies

by husp1

If you look carefuly, you may notice that this is a tech forum not a promotion site. peiple like you who abuse these forums only ask for others to humiliate and ridicule you. perhaps you should look elseware for your "consultants" any normal tech or consultant can see the cheap self promotion and most would not want to work with you!!!!

by j.penney

I swear. I'm not selling, or promoting. I'm interested in talking to people about how to get rid of headhunters. I'm sick of paying those guys to find me a job. Screw them - let's figure out how to keep the jobs ourselves.

You can look at my website - I'm a programmer and an IT veteran, I'm not a sales guy.

I know this looks like a bullshit sales pitch, but look at my website and then judge.

http://jpenney.yourwebsite.no-ip.info

See? I even use a dynamic dns for my website.
What sales person can set up his own crappy little webserver on a debian box at his house?

So if you are intrigued, you have my email.

JP

by jdclyde

That is a crappy site. Take all of five minutes to fully configure?

Not intrigued by bad web sites though. Seen enough of them that the novelty has plum worn off I guess.

by husp1

I wasn't all that impressed, I made better sites using trellix web! as for your not being a promoter then what else would you call it? if you can't sell yourself to me then how could your idea be of any use? guess you should go back to looking for a real job.

by j.penney

Headhunters get a percentage of whatever the employer pays for you - a finder's fee, whatever. You don't get that money. Why? Because the headhunter has access to the personnel department, and the personnel department knows the headhunter will push you to drop your price for them. I always hated the negotiation stage when going for a new job - I suck at negotiating, and I'd always do crappy.

So I tried to find jobs on my own - but I couldn't because even on Dice and Monster it's all headhunter companies putting the ads in - there are very few independent companies, and the truth is I'm not good enough to compete for those jobs.

And then I thought, well why am I competing? Big companies don't compete. They collaborate, "partner" and basically collude to drive up their prices. So why can't I?

And, of course, the answer is - because you're competing. I can't talk to all developers and get them to stop competing so we can hike the wages and split the loot, so we all lose. Too bad there isn't a way to get developers to keep their prices high.

Yeah, too bad.

I wonder if we could though.

Because if we could, then we'd be all set.

We could charge whatever we wanted, and everyone gets a piece of the pie if we could figure out how....

by secure_lockdown9

I don't see it.

If you lack at promotion and sales, and you don't have leads to get your own jobs and work - then you go through the HH's and/or Borks pay them the 30% commision and piggy back on their sales, promotion and leads to get jobs.

If you are competent at sales, promotion and have your own job leads - then bypass the HH's and Borks and do it yourself.

I am not trying to defend HH or Borks - but lets face it - they have to make their money as well and the hardest part of getting a job is the sales, self promotion and acquiring leads. We tend to think that they get paid to do nothing - which is not really the case.

by j.penney

Hi,

Good - someone who believes I'm not a promoter.

You're right - so that's my idea - for us to be the HH's. Yes, they need to have jobs too - but it's not my job to give them jobs. It's my job to get as much money as I can for my work. And there are lots of HH firms, which means they all cold call and work each others' territory, which means so can we. But they also have another advantage - large numbers of lesser-paid people doing the selling.

While I'm working on a job, I'm not able to sell another job, but if I'm working for an HH, they're out selling me and other consultants, which is good for me to a point. But there's money going to someone else for what I do - which doesn't have to happen - I can get that money. Also, my bargaining power is lowered when I sign up with an HH and give them all my info - if you've ever tried to hardball one, you know what I mean. And business is about being smart and tough and not giving anything away, so the question then is how do you get your bargaining power back?

If you talk to a hunter, they'll tell you straight up that they work for the company that you're working at (sometimes). But anyone can make phone calls and be personable and persistent - I've hired people for that and been trained to do it myself. If I was pulling down enough jobs, I'd hire someone and have them sell me, and then they'd be working for me. That, of course, is a private consulting firm. So no big secret there.

My twist on it is the big secret fancy thing that I need people to talk to about face to face (or email to email). It's not that big and secret, but it is different enough that I don't just want to throw it out there and have someone trash it - I actually want to try it out and see if it works or not, work out the kinks, get a firm going and then put the idea in the public (free software) domain.

So there's my idea - really just a smooshing together of a bunch of other ideas, nothing original.

JP

by j.penney

How about some ideas/complaints about headhunters? Or does everyone here love them and love paying them?

JP

by matthew moran

I didn't go to him, he called with an opportunity.

There is virtually no reason to use a headhunter if you don't want to. You just need to become proactive in your career and in job seeking strategies. Bolles had it right in What Color Is Your Parachute? What he outlined 30 years ago is still true today.

Most job seekers look for opportunity in the exact opposite way that employers look for talent. Think about it.

Employers want a known commodity. They go with:
- Internal
- people they know personally
- people who someone in the organization knows
- people referred to them by a trusted peer
- and finally, they put out a want ad or hire a placement firm.

The last option for them is highest risk proposition. They interview, run some assessment test, review resumes, but it is still far less reliable than the other sources for talent.

Job seekers, by and large, go first to job boards and want ads to assess what the job market is and to find opportunity. You are meeting the employer at their least desirable place and therefore are simply a commodity. In many cases they will look for the least expensive commodity and hope it works out.

You need to find a way to generate conversation/correspondence with those looking for talent. Networking and lots of it is a start.

One of my blogs from several months ago is titled, Create career coincidences. It covers this exact topic.
http://blogs.ittoolbox.com/pm/career/archives/001346.asp

Direct contact and referrals is the only way I've gone after work - and there is a lot of it to be had. Consider small business (between 35-200 employee companies) and departmental technologist (don't focus solely on the IT department). Business Analyst, Project Managers, Financial Analyst - are all titles where highly analytical technologist can create great opportunity.

by j.penney

That sounds about right. I'll tell you what got me started on this. I was recently back working on my BS and had no time for real work, so I took my truck and decided to do some small-time landscaping for some money and as a workout. One of the people I was estimating for went to another person and got a lower price - and the price war that ensued ended in him getting the job for much less than my original estimate. I knew the kid, and I drove to his house and asked him what the hell he was doing - if we had talked between us, we could have not only got the job, we could have kept the price high.

Translation, as if you needed it: competition is bad for everyone. Smart business people partner and keep prices high. The AMA keeps Doctor's wages high. The carpenter's union keeps prices high and benefits high.

We need to do similarly. Headhunters f up that whole process, so that's why I want to get rid of them.

Still accepting comments on this.

JP

This discussion is closed to new replies.