Discussion Locked

I hate the way the new Q&A section works

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I don't like anything about the way this new section looks or acts! I'll split points between all answers that support me or make a good case as to why I should like this.

Let me know what you think......

25 replies

by dmiles

One you did not state any dislikes to compare with as to why you do not like the new setup.
The basic changes are only cosmetic to wher they only changed the layout,I thought it to be a little difficult getting uswe to,but once you see how it worksit boils down to being open to change and that is.
The layout is generically simple and at first difficult to navigate around,yet I have found that it is not complex and it does take some getting use to,but I find that it grows on you as you get more familiar with the sight.
Consider that it is not that much different than the previous layout,which was more complex for a new user to navigate thru,now it gives you the different Topics,and you can rate your answer from your question,which you were not able to do and then to you can click on My Tech Republic and have access to all your tech email and other info that you have.
So,spend some time navigating around and then see how you like it.

by dmiles

Being objective is a form of opinion when ones knows the others thoughts,so that stating your likes or dislikes
Yes there are some bugs in the new format as it was in last years.
But now that I use it more and see some of the newer things such asMy TechRepublic,which you can access all your subscritions and questions asked and posted answers to,it is becoming likable,but I will wait and see how the bugs are being ironed out.
Have A Nice Day

by jereg

Thanks for the comments. You probably use this as much (more!) as anyone. While I think i like the new look, I'm just in a complaining mood since I liked the way the Q&A section worked better before. Guess what kind of cheese I'm having with my whine....

by jereg

I didn't say why I didn't like it because I wanted others opinions without being affected by mine. I will say that it has not carried over my Q&A statistics, i.e. number of questions asked, answered, etc. That won't change the quality of my life, but why did they go away?

by ann777

I tend to agree with jereg...

1) You have to go into the question in order to determine whether or not anyone answered
2) Responses or answers are not time stamped any more... so you cannot tell when a second answer was submitted when it essentially is a duplicate of the first
3) When the question is closed, you used to know how many points were allocated between the various answers... not now

The loooks of it does not bother me (but there was nothing wrong with the looks of the other either -- at least to me).

Everything else seems pretty much the same. I'd really like to see the number of responses before I enter into a question.

by ann777

Also the statistics are carried over... you just cannot see them from your login. Essentially, you needs to find a question you answered and then click on your name there. Then you'll see the stats. (I BELIEVE THIS IS A BUG -- I doubt they meant it to work this way).

by jereg

You echo my feelings exactly. For the new user, it may be easier, but I find it kludgy. Maybe it came from Microsoft. I still can't see my stats anywhere. I haven't answered nearly the questions you have, and as time consumming as I find itnow, I never will. Thanks for responding.

by maxwell edison

Greetings jereg,

There are both things I like and dislike about the change. More accurately, I suppose I should say that there are things I dislike, and then there are things that are merely different, but not necessarily better.

Q&A Section:

(I spend most of my time at this section, so most of my comments are related to this section.)

I don’t like the fact that the number of answers posted to a question isn’t included in the list. (I like to see how many people have answered without opening the question.)

I don’t like the fact that it’s now more difficult to navigate through older unanswered questions.

I don’t like the fact that we can no longer sort the list by point value. We can only sort by date. (I have to do something to catch up with Soulrider!)

I don’t like the fact that the time is no longer indicated along with the date of posting.

I don’t like the fact that the number of points awarded isn’t indicatedin the closed questions. (Ok, I know. I can do the math. 345 points divided by 4 accepted answers is ….. um, it is ….. , er uh, where the h*** is my calculator?)

I don’t like the fact that TechRepublic ignored literally EVERYBODY’s suggestion of allowing someone to award a percentage of points to those answering questions as he/she sees fit. For example, 50% awarded to one answer, and the remaining 50% divided between 5 other answers (10% each).

I don’t like the fact that a user is still timed out of he/she spends more than a few minutes of idle time. (I’ll most likely be timed out, and will have to log back in after I finish this “lengthy” answer, or suffer the consequence of being labeled as “User Deleted”.)

Speaking of which, I don’t like the fact that the “User Deleted” problem is worse, not better.

If I am automatically log

by maxwell edison

.
.
Articles Section:

Not much of a difference in this regard. But I do like the new “rating” window.

General:

The “hot discussions” is no longer indicated on the home page.

It may just be me, but it seems to navigate throughout the site much slower. And I’ve noticed much more down time for their servers.

All in all, I liked the old one better. I don’t see a whole lot of sense in making a change simply for changes sake.

However, in all honesty and fairness to those at TechRepublic who designed, built, and maintain this site, I am impressed with their skill. They have achieved a truly premier Web site.

I may post more in the comments section as other things come to mind.

(I just answered a similar question that Soulrider posted. OK, I admit that this is simply a pasted copy of the answer I posted there.)

And to address your initial comment. I agree with you. I don't think it's better. Just different.

Regards,

Maxwell

by maxwell edison

.
.
Another thing I don't like is the Technical Q&A statistics page(s). From time to time I like to look at the Q&A Stats for those asking/answering questions. Look at mine and you'll see that I have 0 points awarded for answering 0 questions, andthat I've asked 0 questions. All of that is, obviously, bunk, since I've answered hundreds and asked many - accepting well over 90% of answers posted to my questions.

Mine isn't the only one missing. Over half of those I've checked are missing aswell. Maybe they'll get arounf to fixing it some day.

Maxwell

by jereg

Yep, you've summed it up. You've spend enough time here, (and you've provided some excellent answers, I might add), that you're clearly feeling some of my pain! Thanks for another great answer.

by gary_w

The light grey lines behind the question text makes it hard to read. If anything, make it solid light grey for readability.

I prefer the old way I'm afraid.

by jereg

I'm not having too much trouble reading the screen, but you probably have ha better monitor than I do! Thanks.

by jereg

I like the replies. I generally like the LOOK, just not the way Q&A sections works, and several of the posters have summed up my feeling exactly. I'll leave this up for another day or two and see if there are any other posts. Thanks all.

by penguinsrule

Here's one reason you should like it. It is much more tree structured than it was before. It's kinda like Ebay where you can go up a level if you want, that's kinda nice. It also doesn't fail on you when you try to pull up a large amount of information like it did before.
Like when I would try to pull up all the information for all the open questions and then try a sort or whatever.

As far as the negatives, I won't go into those here, everybody has already covered those well enough.Techpoints are still worthless, so unless they become worth something, then it'll matter a lot more. Then all these issues will matter a lot more - for now this is all an inconvenience...

by jereg

I think some of the navigation is a bit more workable than before, my big complaint is with the Q&A section, but you know that! Thanks.

by penguinsrule

Here's something I like for sure - that I can click on the date column or whatever and it sorts that column. Take a look. I like that a lot. I can do that with the points column. so I can get the whole list, and then sort it myself. I can probably download everything into a spreadsheet or database if I want.

by jereg

A good answer, i just rejucted it to keep the points straight. I know that in the past, multiple answers would be divided between the person's replies, but I'm not taking any chances. Thanks.

by penguinsrule

I also like that I can search (at the top)
in Tech Q&A

I do like the new look, and that comments are in their own little boxes.

As I find more I like I'll tell you...

by penguinsrule

something else I like is that it's all in one place in one tree structure under one tab, instead of one at the top and one at the side.

I like it better, and think it's more user friendly.

What I don't like - is it doesn't show you the points like it did before. It doesn't allow you to designate the number of points per person.

by jereg

I don't know if this is part of the _new_ look or if this has always been a problem. In the Q&A FAQ, it says you can accept an answer and leave the question open, just be sure to click on the box. When I tried this, I got a dialog box telling me that if I chose accept, the question would be closed. Bug? Or just an undocumented feature?

by jereg

FYI: I tried a little experiment here. I threw out a lot of points hoping it would attract attention. It only got 5 people to respond, when every answer was a right answer, and everyone would get points. I've seen 6 or 7 answers on questions with 100 points. Interesting.

This discussion is closed to new replies.