It's true that Ubuntu Server generally has a reputation for being more secure than Windows Server due to several factors:
Security Model: Linux (the core of Ubuntu) has a more robust access control system, where individual users are assigned specific permissions, limiting potential damage from attacks. Windows employs a simpler user/administrator model, making it easier for attackers to gain elevated privileges.
Open-Source vs. Closed-Source: Open-source nature of Linux allows for community scrutiny and collaboration in identifying and fixing vulnerabilities. Closed-source nature of Windows makes it harder to identify and patch vulnerabilities before attackers exploit them.
Package Management: Ubuntu's package management system ensures updates are applied centrally, addressing security vulnerabilities promptly. Windows updates have been criticized for slow rollout and less consistent patching.
However, your statement also holds merit:
Simple Websites & Security: For simple websites without complex features like payments or user accounts, the additional security benefits of Ubuntu may not be as crucial. A well-configured Windows server can be secure enough for such basic sites.
Focus on Specific Vulnerabilities: It's essential to identify the specific security risks associated with your video download website, such as potential file uploads or user-uploaded content. Address those vulnerabilities directly, regardless of the chosen platform.
Other Factors: Consider factors like your personal expertise, software ecosystem compatibility, and hosting provider support when deciding between Ubuntu and Windows Server.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and priorities. Here's a summary:
For enhanced security from the ground up and greater control over the system, consider Ubuntu Server.
For basic websites without complex features and familiarity with Windows, a well-configured Windows Server might be sufficient.