Discussion Locked

I want to coach IT people...why don't they think they need it?

0 helpful
76 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm confused. I'm a former long-time IT person that has retrained as a trainer and personal coach. I've chosen IT people as my niche - Executives, Managers, and Professionals. As a former IT Manager myself, I used a coach for a year and it changed my life.

I'm on the West Coast of Canada and coaching of all kinds is very popular here - from life/personal to business to career to executive to relationship. Yet, I'm finding the IT people I approach either don't know what it is or don't think it can help them in any way.

Perhaps I'm explaining it poorly? I know IT people in general are very self-assured and analytical. It's difficult to explain the ROI in "real" terms. I had to be convinced that it was worthwhile before I started.

What advice can you give an aspiring IT coach to help connect to IT people that are looking for/needing coaching? Alternatively, how would you explain the benefits of coaching to an IT person?

76 replies

by oz_media

If I tol dyou I could teach you the ins and outs of IT and coach you in your new career, would you be interested?

IT people are, fo rthe most part, idiots and egomaniacs. They think they are too clever and get off on watching someone, that would normally not even give them the time of day, actually needing them.

Your approach requires a market with little confidence, IT isn't that market. You may want to offer your services as ADVANCED IT MANAGEMENT TRAINING or something that will make th eattendee actually feel superior to his/peers. If you can make your clients FEEL smarter than others, they will want your services.

Your one gain will be to stroke their egos, with IT egos, you can really get your fill that's for sure.

Nice to see a Chilliwacker on here, time for me to get the hell out of here and load the bikes for Chipmunk Creek, I'll wave on my way through.
:)

by plan b

I agree that marketing it as something other than Coaching is perhaps the way to go. I?ve struggled with the name ?life coaching? and always preferred ?personal coaching?, despite most of my coaching typically touching on a person?s whole life. As much as my clients have tried, they can't separate work from the rest of life.

by jmiguy

When I think of the word coach, I think of team captains and cheerleaders. It comes across as
a jock wanting to motivate a bunch of geeks to work on computers.

I agree with the other post about using a title more suitable to stroking the ego's of the IT people.

Make them feel like they're going to gain something, not get forced into doing something that they don't want to do.

by dave.leigh9

You say it's difficult to explain the ROI. Yet you had to be convinced yourself. Don't you remember what convinced you?? What sales job did your coach use on you? What made you think you were otherwise ineffective and needed a coach in the first place?

To be perfectly blunt, the IT managers you approach are probably right to question whether you can help them if you can't articulate the value of your services.

I don't say this to be mean in any way, and I'd say it's difficult for anyone to advise you based on the little you've written. Tell you what... I'm an IT person who doesn't see the need for a coach. Why don't you post your sales pitch HERE. Tell us why somebody needs to pay you to do whatever it is you do. What exactly is it that a personal coach IS. And what is it about you that makes you a more effective IT manager than your prospective customers?

(Just as I wouldn't take swimming lessons from someone who doesn't swim better than I do, I wouldn't accept management advice from a coach who's no more effective than I. Thus, I strongly suspect that if you lack success in selling your services, it's connected to insufficient bolstering of your own image.)

by dave.leigh9

Now, assume that you have the skills and can articulate them, and deliver on they hype (and there's always hype). How do you market your services?

You've noticed yourself that "IT people" are self-assured and analytical. In other words, they're a tough sell. Even a percentage of those who recognize that they're less than optimally effective will feel that they can fix that themselves through introspection and self-study.

How do you get somebody like that to buy? MAKE him do it. Few managers will feel the need for the services, but companies all want the most effective managers they can get. So I'd suggest targeting, not the managers themselves, but the HR departments of the companies that they work for. Use company-sponsored workshops to showcase your skills. Such "free to the manager" workshops give you paid exposure to many managers, some of which would take advantage of your personal coaching services, assuming the workshop was useful to them and you projected the proper air of confidence and success.

by plan b

I agree, it might be better to work the HR angle instead of going directly to the IT managers. It certainly worked on me. :)

Good idea about the company-sponsored workshops too.

by wayne m.

Determine what it is that you are providing and who your target audience is to be. Next create a series of presentations.

First determine your audience. I have a hard time believing that the same training would apply to executives, managers, and IT professionals. I would suggest to either narrow the audience or develop three distinct products. The content may overlap, but I do not think a one size fits all will fly.

Next create some presentation materials. I would create a 2 - 4 page white paper or brochure that you could leave with a potential client. Make sure to have at least one graphical element per page and have it in color. Also, generate a PowerPoint presentation of largely the same material. This is something you can present live, distribute as a set of hand-outs or e-mail as a meeting follow up. Finally, create a 3 - 4 sentence synopsis ("the elevator talk") that you can include in a e-mail or give over coffee at a chance meeting.

I'm afraid you failed to make your case in this forum (and I think several of the responses are evidence of that). Determine who your message is for, and determine a specific message for each target. Then create a series of vehicles to present your message.

by plan b

Thanks, I?ve done some of these things, but not all of them yet. A good reminder to have a full ?marketing? package that can be tailored to different audiences. I think a lot of it points back to me being comfortable as an IT person and still being somewhat new to the solo entrepreneur side of things and all the different roles one must play.

by plan b

Good questions for me to ponder and perhaps use some of the same phrasing and terminology. I think I was just at a point in my career/life where it was good timing.

by jaqui

corn ready? ;)

That is what Chlliwhack is best known for, corn on the cob. :)

You have to market your service as a specialist service, to improve top level performance to get anywhere, marketing as a coach isn't going to work.

by plan b

No corn until summer time. We?ll just have to make do with the cow manure (also what Chilliwack is known for).

I like your line about marketing it as a specialist service and not as a coach. I think that?s been my biggest stumbling block. Despite coaching being (fairly) well known here on the West Coast, I do still have to explain what it is more than I would like. Perhaps it?s not as well known as I thought.

by lastchip

To market as a coach means people have to admit to being inferior, thus damaging ego's. You could argue, this is not the case, but it will be the perception. This is a huge stumbling block, particularly for senior managers, who are used to being always right - whether they are or not.

Although I haven't had time to read the whole of the contributions here, the best advice I've seen so far, is to market as a specialist service - the added value style of approach.

by oneamazingwriter

professional. I state that so I am not misrepresenting myself.
I do know that if I were to accept coaching, the person coaching me would have to be very self assured. As I see it, it's your job to make strong statements about what service you can render, and why there is a specific need for your service. Coaching is as much inspiration as it is perspiration. It requires confidence in one's own abilities that can help another to want to emulate that confidence. You need first to sell yourself on your ability if you are going to be pitching that sale to anyone else.

by plan b

For the most part, this is exactly when I got the client. You're right. It's probably more inspiration than perspiration. In fact, it should be easy (for the coach). The client is the one doing the work, because it's the client's life/agenda that is being worked on.

According to those that I have coached, I am a great coach; I guess I'm just not at as good at pitching a sale though. :)

by oneamazingwriter

coach you on that? I work cheap! :)
When we know our personal area of weakness we are at a point where we can turn it into a strength. It's a matter of turning it around. Instead of asking...make statements. At first it will feel like faking, but that's where the phrase "Fake it until you make it" comes in. Making positive statements about one's abilities is not bragging, if it's true, and what we have to sell are those same abilities. If you don't tell people what you are capable of, how else will they know?

A coach's job is to instill a sense of power into the other...an "I can do this" attitude. In your case that requires knowing the field in which you are coaching. Let others know that you have that knowledge. take the time to point out their strengths, before pointing out areas that they need to strengthen, and they will see the truth in your appraisal. There is a big difference between, "You do that well. I can show you a way to improve upon what you are doing if you like," and "You don't know what you are doing. I'll straighten you out." Coaching, as I see it, is helping someone to improve upon something that they already show an aptitude for. Those who could benefit through being coached, don't always realize that fact.

edit: misplaced quotation marks.

by desktroll

If you have satisfied clients ask them for written testimonials that you can use as part of your marketing package.

Also don't be scared to ask them for referrals.

by becca alice

...you have several steps that will help.

1) consider what sold you on it - make a list and prioritize what created the greatest immediate impact on your impression of the idea (cost savings? customer satisfaction?)
2) build a case - you say it's difficult to show ROI, and that's something we all face across the industry. Since IT is increasingly expected to be able to detail its deliverables, this is a great time to practice making a corporate-style paper on the value your service provides. Check out a technical writing manual or two as well as some on writing grants or proposals, both of which relate to how you'll need to write your ream of data
3) Boil the ream of data down to talking points - you can give them the material as backup, and it serves several purposes including reassuring them that you know what you're talking about, providing more information to those who will really read it, and in creating it helping to gel the ideas in your own mind so you're better able to give your talking points and respond immediately and confidently to any questions on them. Many people will never read the ream of paper, but it's good to have done anyway so you yourself completely understand what you're selling
4) Examine your talking points and revise the phrasing so it doesn't question the superiority of the IT person (some of us are very prickly) or their approach (some of us are very independent/stubborn) but does positively reflect how new skills can add to the strong foundation any IT professional should have, especially as the field evolves

My Opinion only... ^_^
B

by amcol

Most of the advice so far is themed on doing better marketing and exuding more confidence in your own abilities. Good stuff. But there's more to it than that.

What product are you selling? You talk about having a hard time quantifying ROI...how exactly are you articulating what service you're offering?

Do you want to coach me on how to be a better IT manager? No sale...I'm already a good IT manager and I don't need your help.

Do you want to coach me on how to be a better overall business manager? No sale...if I wanted that I'd go for some advanced formal training, up through and including getting an MBA (which I've already done, and believe me, it's served me a whole lot better than anything you could do for me).

Do you want to coach me on how to be more successful generally speaking? At life? Perhaps to find a whole new career, outside of IT? No sale, but that's just me...I'm already happy doing what I'm doing. But you might find your market niche here.

You need a better message that's specific to what you want to do for me. You can't quanttify it in dollar terms, so stop trying to do that. You're selling feel-good medicine...what's your spoonful of sugar that's going to catch my attention?

by absolutely

Exactly what was it that convinced you? It is impossible to advise without this information.

by plan b

Amongst other things:
- That is was a reward, not a punishment.
- That it was confidential and 'safe' to discuss any topic.
- That I controlled the agenda.
- That I could call it off anytime I wanted.
- That it could help me improve my work relationships.

This was when executive coaching was just becoming more known. I had read up a bit about what execs had achieved and how execs responded to being coached and it seemed like it was worth a try.

by gwcarter

You note that IT people are very self-assured. This is prima facie evidence that they don't need coaching. The whole purpose of coaching is to put a band-aid on the self-doubt and insecurity that our modern "Political Correctness" is intended to render us prey to. Those of us who produce results have no need of a coach, and those of us who don't should leave the profession, as in fact you have. We know our worth in terms of what we produce or enable. We don't need a syncophant to play Wormtongue to our Theoden. Rather than muddy the waters in IT you should maybe find a different niche; say The Democratic National Committee.

by gwcarter

perhaps you should coach managers who believe a snappy resume or polished language or a congenial disposition are a substitute for skill, experience, and demonstrated results. I know of one manager who feels that object technology is not mature enough for corporate use. Perhaps he would be a marketing target?

by plan b

I'll have to disagree with you on this one GW. I think quite a few people in IT could benefit from coaching. It's not just about being self-assured and producing results - as good as these things are. It seems that the 'human' side of IT people is often absent or buried, and the thought that "because I'm producing, I should be left alone to do my thing" seems too common. I think a number of IT people can use help with their communication skills, their relationship skills, and leading more balanced lives.

I didn't leave the profession because I wasn't producing results. Far from it. My team won numerous awards and were amongst the most highly thought of and well-respected in the company - not an easy thing to do with most IT departments.

And sorry, I'm not a LOTR fan, so your analogy is somewhat lost on me.

by dave.leigh9

(kindly ignore punctuation errors... this is a long post typed into a little window with less time)

There ARE people who need coaching... both managers and lower-level employees. And one of the things that managers need to know is that coaching their employees (i.e. providing direction) is part of their job. However, that's only true to an extent (within reason and constraints), and it's beyond that limit that your services as a coach are valuable. Here's an example:

A project manager such as myself simply cannot (and should not) know every detail of every job under his control. A certain amount of trust has to be vested in the employees that will have to do the actual work. The project manager has to provide the direction and communicate the goals of the project. Specifically, he must clearly communicate specific goals to each employee. He has to elicit feedback to determine whether those goals are realistic, and then evaluate and act on the feedback if necessary.

One of my early projects involved some rather complex changes to a system. It doesn't matter what the changes were, except that they were specific, inflexible mathematical algorithms that were worked out by external subject matter experts. 'Bob' was a senior programmer/analyst assigned to the the team. Once he saw the math involved, 'Bob' had a very difficult time getting motivated to do the work. I worked out the overall structure I had in mind for the system asked him for his estimate on his portion of the work. I always include the team early in the design process if possible, especially if I have to make assumptions for areas with which I'm not familiar (which happens A LOT in this industry).

"Gee, I dunno, this is hard," he'd respond. Now, of course, I didn't know the programming language required for those particular components, but I am an accomplished programmer in other languages. So I described a possible approach made a quick estimate and asked, "Is this approach feasible? Can you do this part in 3 weeks?" 'Bob' replied again with, "Gee, I dunno, this is pretty hard." Several times, to the point where we had to table that part of the discussion and move on with the rest of the team's input.

Now, we have a finite amount of time for estimation and design, and the customer requires some fairly firm numbers for budgeting and SLAs. I'm one who likes to come in under budget, so I'm fairly conservative with estimates, so I'm pretty easy so long as I can still 'sell' the schedule to the client. It's another reason I include the team early if possible... I want THEM to be comfortable with the schedule, too. But repeatedly responding "this is hard" is no way to further the process, especially since everyone else in the team caught on pretty quickly. So my response was to say, "Bob, I know it's hard. You've told me it's hard, and I'm going to take your word for it. Now get past that. HOW hard is it? Is it three weeks worth of hard, or do you think you need more time?"

Now I'd asked for a senior P/A precisely because I needed a team that could work independently. It was pretty clear to me that if we ran into any roadblocks 'Bob' wouldn't even begin to solve them, and I as a manager unfamiliar with that system wouldn't be able to help him. I replaced him with an eager junior programmer from the pool who not only 'got' the design but who saw the task as a challenge rather than an boatload of work he'd rather not do. 'Bob' went on to another project and left the company not long after.

I suppose you could look at this as a 'pointy-haired boss' episode with me in the starring role, but the fact of the matter is that NO IT manager on a cross-platform project is going to know every aspect of every system. That's why we carefully select team members. That's why we hire programmer/analysts and not typists. And that's why we ask for input from the team early, to check assumptions, refine the estimates and the design, and make changes before we're locked into a budget. I absolutely HAVE to trust the team, and I don't have the luxury of blaming any one of them if they can't pull their weight. It's my job to recognize and fix those sorts of problems. But as a manager I'm in charge of delivering results... I have the time to provide direction, but I can't hold the hand of a team member who's job description clearly indicates he should be able to deliver to a certain standard. I have to direct and assess his performance in accordance with that standard.

IF the corporation had a coaching program, I'd have recommended 'Bob' for inclusion. Frankly, I don't think he should have been promoted to Sr.P/A without the ability to analyze the requirements he's given and to estimate his own ability to deliver. It's possible that he needed assertiveness training. It's possible he needed some exercise in focus or prioritization. Maybe he felt better suited to another career, or perhaps he had a bloody medical condition. I don't know. The fact is he didn't indicate anything of the sort even when asked, and once I get to the "throw me a bone" stage, I've got to move on with my own priorities and not feel guilty about his.

If you're a 'Bob' or you know a 'Bob' then it's possible that Plan B or something like it is just the ticket. Also, I might recommend seminars for people on a promotional track to help ensure that 'Bobs' don't get promoted above their abilities... or better yet, that they have gained the necessary abilities before they're promoted.

But consider this. If 'Bob' does lack assertiveness then he might just be too timid to do that on his own. If 'Bob' is a manager promoted through the Peter Principle, then he might be afraid to go to a 'coach' because his own manager might find out and wonder why a decision-maker has to go somewhere else to help him make decisions. That's where selling it to HR and trickling the idea down through upper management is a good idea. It may be that for some organizations a coaching 'leg up' is a more cost-effective investment than firing somebody and training a new employee from scratch.

by rayjeff

Going from the posts, working with non-IT IT persons would be a better area to coach/train in.
"non-IT IT" or any other term that has bene used in the posts means a person who has an IT position or does IT-type work but does not have the IT background. These are the persons who really need the coaching moreso than any other person who does IT-type work. They are the ones that really need the encouragement and the self-assuredness.

Not to say that there couldn't be a time when IT people may not need coaching, but non-IT persons are the ones.

by rob mekel

giving the "non-IT" IT person an IT training is what you seem to promote to me. In other words educate the "non-IT" employees in the IT-field.

That is not all what coaching is about, it can be part of coaching but there is more.
Coaching is about getting your goals straight, developing your skills as a person and professional, getting better at your job AND knowing why that is.

Rob

by rayjeff

whether it is "better" to coach IT persons. From what I'm reading (and understanding correctly) is that everyone isn't fully opposed to the idea of coaching IT persons, but how much would it actually benefit IT persons. Plan B, who composed the question wants to know how best to go about doing that in order to coach IT persons.

What I offered as an opinion and maybe one of two others is that Plan B coaches IT in a field outside of IT. My rationale for my post is that non-IT persons would be more receptive to a coach or coaching than persons who are in IT. It seems like Plan B is frustrated in the fact of trying to be coach IT persons. What offered was just an opinion.

"That is not all what coaching is about, it can be part of coaching but there is more.
Coaching is about getting your goals straight, developing your skills as a person and professional, getting better at your job AND knowing why that is."

So, are you saying that going into another field IT coaching isn't a viable alternative? Is not developing the non-IT person's skills not in trun helping to develop the IT coaches' skills as a person and a professional? Maybe I'm just seeing this in a different way.

by jkameleon

Horseback riding? Synchronized swimming? Waterballet?

If you are coaching something like leg wrestling, you shouldn't complain about the lack of interest.

by Member 34793965

Having worked in IT for a number of years now, including teaching programming, database theory, and analysis and design at the college level, here is the comeback to your tired old "those who can do, those who can't teach" truism.

"If you can't explain it to someone else, who don't really understand it yourself."

Sounds like you could use some coaching yourself.

by onbliss

We keep learning things each day, and sometimes life is an never ending learning saga. We learn from our Parents, family, friends, teacher, **Books**, nature and last but not the least personal experience.

We also learn from training institutes and forums such as this, where we get to know things from our peers.

So if you were going to offer something, then one certainly wants to know what is that you can offer that can not be learnt from the other sources.

Quite often we know what our Sales staff offer to our customers, we have seen several brochures that look all pretty and nice that we kno are part of the normal hype.

To be honest, the moment some one says "ROI", my internal defensive mechanisms are put on alert :). Some times the "buzz words" just puts me off. I just would like to read or hear about things in simple language:
1) What is it that is being offered?
2) How is it being offered?
3) How will it help?

Ofcourse some people are lured by the jargons and buzz words.

Also many technical people are quite comfortable in learning new things by reading technical books. And these days one gets the answer for almost anything from "Google University" :). So how is your coaching different from these sources?

For example, I had to learn plenty of new stuff when I ventured into Web Development. My company offered training allowance (which was way below than what most of the training institutes charged), so I chose to go for a simple course that introduced me to ASP.Net, and then I used the training allowance to buy books that I needed.

~~~My two cents

**Book: I encompass both electronic material and traditional books into this category.

by dc guy

For you to know what I need to learn in order to make a qualitative improvement in my career is not even half the battle. I might very well already know that myself. What you have to be able to do is impart it to me.

What kind of a coach are you? Do you keep your students interested, upbeat, receptive? Do they come out at every break full of enthusiasm and gratitude? Are you persuasive and easy to understand? How do you come across on a first impression--am I going to think about hiring you after just a few minutes of contact, so that the remainder is just closing the sale?

Most importantly, what's your track record? Do you have a list of highly satisfied customers who would gladly tell me how great you are? You will, of course, have to start out doing corporate seminars as several have suggested, and you'll probably have to start that with public sector clients. That's good experience, they can be a really tough bunch when it comes to accepting something new.

You have chosen a profession in which marketing is about 99 percent of the job. Are you that good at marketing?

I have to say--with the most sincere compassion and understanding--that you did not come across that way in your posting. You sound a little unsure of yourself. You don't have ready answers for the two most common questions self-employed people face: 1. Why should I hire YOU? 2. What do I get for my monety?

You spent quite a bit of time under the tutelage of a coach, yet you did not pick up some of the basics of her job.

YOU have to be able to explain the benefits of coaching to an IT person, and you have to be able to do that off the top of your head, in order to be a coach to IT people. There is no one answer to that question. You have to size up the questioner and give him an answer that speaks to his own issues. You have to read his facial expressions, body language, tone of voice, and all the other "tells" to exploit the full bandwidth of communication. (Obviously you can't possibly do this by e-mail. ^_^ )

These are "people skills" and they're skills that very few of us propeller-headed IT geeks have. Most of us went into IT precisely because we're more comfortable in the silicon world than the carbon world.

I have no doubt about your passion for what you want to do, and I'll take your word for it that you have the knowledge to do it. But I wonder whether you have the temperament. It's a rare skill.

by neillix

Just browsing through some of the repsonses, it's evident that a0 many IT folks don't know what "coaching" is unless it's used in terms of sports and 2) IT people are usually very self directing. If they want a new certification or knowlege in some other area, we'll teach ourself through self study, books, peers. You may want to target a dfferent audience, someone with less of a clue in what they want to acheieve-like a new college graduate, or a person who may need to change careers after age 40 or 50. I was approached by a "coach" last year. To be honest, she was wasting her time "holding me accountable, setting goals", etc. When I want something, I design my path and just go for it. There hasn't been much I havn't been able to accomplish on my own.

by plan b

I also have difficulty with some of the coaching jargon that is used. I think that this contributes to the lack of understanding to what a coach does.

I'm also starting to see that my most likely targets in the IT field will be in the 35-50 age range - those that have been through the battles for a few years and are now realizing they need help to get where they want to be.

I congratulate you on being able to design your path and go for it. Truly a unique skill. From my experience in coaching, I think most people are not built this way. We think of great plans and ideas, but we rarely follow through to complete them on our own.

by jamesrl

Where you might address a need is in targetting those going through a transition, from say, techie or project manager to department manager, or department manager to senior management.

Those are the make or break times in someone's career where they have the opportunity to learn and grow, and the challenge of trying to fit into a new environment.

James

by michaelemunson

I'm coming to IT from hardware service, and am fairly new. i can suggest things I've observed: First, alot of IT people I know (tragicly) fit the stereotype, being poor at face to face, or other direct communication with normal humans. Programmers are the worst. So it may simply be they are NOT resisting your offer to help, onyl giving an oblique replay.
second, here in the mighty US, alot of employees are both told to seek to improve, AND encouraged to claim they are already at the top of their game. They often fear to admit they might improve from coaching, in case the bean-counting management hears, and gives someone who refuses to admit teir need the next bonus/raise/continued employment.
so the two things I've seen in your way are
1:"Tech Psychosis"
2.Stupid Management (the modern most common oxymoron).

by plan b

Interesting points about having to improve yet expected to be at the top of their game. If this is truly the way (and I suspect you're mostly right), then of course people would be leery about admitting they need/want coaching. It might show weakness to their management/executives.

I think this reinforces an earlier point to go through HR to set this up. HR may have been approached by either the employee or management already and asked to look for ways to help while not punishing the employee.

by michaelemunson

I'm coming to IT from hardware service, and am fairly new. i can suggest things I've observed: First, alot of IT people I know (tragicly) fit the stereotype, being poor at face to face, or other direct communication with normal humans. Programmers are the worst. So it may simply be they are NOT resisting your offer to help, onyl giving an oblique replay.
second, here in the mighty US, alot of employees are both told to seek to improve, AND encouraged to claim they are already at the top of their game. They often fear to admit they might improve from coaching, in case the bean-counting management hears, and gives someone who refuses to admit teir need the next bonus/raise/continued employment.
so the two things I've seen in your way are
1:"Tech Psychosis"
2.Stupid Management (the modern most common oxymoron).
Oh... and try not calling it COACHING. use a more business-slang, snooty word or phrase.., like maybe "IT Process Optimization Assistance."

by rob mekel

Coaching isn't bound to any profession nor has it limitations to whatever field your activities are in professional or leisure time (to me leisure time is all the time not being on the job [[i]and actually time on the job is fun/leisure time for me as well[/i] :) ]).

What I tried to say is that coaching is not only about your knowledge-expertise brought up to a higher level but also making you aware of what other skills you need to be a professional (co)worker in whatever field y're working on or of the job.

What I did gather from your first answer I made up that you meant it was "better? to coach "non-IT"IT persons then IT persons.
As Plan B has made a choice to be a coach for IT-persons (whether skilled at IT or not) it isn't the question who he wants to coach but how he can reach to those in the IT-field that want to be coached, make IT-workers (whether skilled at IT or not) aware of the possibility of being coached.

I agree with you that non-IT workers are maybe more open (more easily to reach) to the idea of coaching. This due to, generally spoken, the fact that IT-workers are more intro- then extravert and work from strong knowledge based skills.

In the strong changing field of IT (from technical/knowledge to business driven) customer(in- or external)relation and communication skills are getting more and more important ([i]and a lot of other skills as well [/i])
On training you get to know about those skills but there is more to them then knowing about the technics of the skills.
A coach can be helpful on determing and developing the minor developed skills you(generally spoken) have.

That is what I tried to make clear.

Rob

edited for format

by plan b

In explaining what you meant, I think you recapsulated my (non-expressed) thinking very well.

"In the strong changing field of IT (from technical/knowledge to business driven) customer(in- or external) relation and communication skills are getting more and more important (and a lot of other skills as well).
On training you get to know about those skills but there is more to them then knowing about the technics of the skills. A coach can be helpful on determing and developing the minor developed skills you(generally spoken) have."

THAT is why I want to help IT people. I KNOW they know the IT stuff. I don't want to help them improve that. I want to help with what I consider the strategic skills - better communication, better time management, better relationship management, help them be better leaders or team members, help them build a better team, etc.
Some people consider these things soft skills and therefore of lesser value than hard-earned IT skills.

But as IT moves more and more "into the business", these strategic soft-skills are becoming more and more vital to acknowledge and improve upon. Those that don't are leaving themselves open for customer complaints (at best) right through to outsourcing (at worst).

by dave.leigh9

Well, it's been about 5 days since a good-faith offer was made to provide feedback for Plan B. Since then, no response whatsoever. Not even, "I'll get back to your" or "give me a little time."

I don't know about anybody else, but that tells me everything I could want to know about Plan B Services (http://www.planbservices.ca/). Here's some free advice you may not have heard from your coach... if you aren't going to listen to the answers, don't ask the questions.

I suggest you start working on Plan C.

by jkameleon

I haven't noticed PlanB's website in his profile.

So, it's business & personal coaching allright, plus teamwork development. "Me team you work" kinda stuff, to quote venerable Scott Adams.

Well.. As I said before, I don't respond well to such psyshomechanics, and neither do guys I know & work with. Even if coaching is not just another management fad, it certainly looks like one.

There is only one thing that can make the team work: Integrity, and fair play. It's that simple. Alas, theese things are pretty much like mineral oil. Once it's pumped out, converted to cash and burned, it's gone, and no ammount of money will bring it back. Similarily, no ammount of coaching will bring back mutual trust once it's been violated.

by plan b

Thanks for all of the great feedback. I?ve learned a lot from this discussion already. The first lesson ? don?t post at the end of a challenging week. :) It doesn?t come across the way that I had hoped.

I took the weekend to recharge and have been busy with work and family activities since then (part of the whole work/life balance thing I encourage). I apologize for not answering some of your questions more promptly.

I'll try and leave comments/feedback to as many of you as I can.

by dr dij

Being IT people we 'know it all' already :)

and also being IT people, we are not 'people people' and would rather dink around with IT stuff than be in a meaningful career coaching session.

One last reason: I'm sure it isn't free, and we could use the money instead for a humongous hard drive (to impress the gal:), a new wizbang gadget, or the latest plasma/LCD TV that doubles as a computer screen. (or take the gal out to see an action / sci-fi movie! w/ dinner)

Did you see the daily show trendspotter bit on 'life-coaching'?

by plan b

Yes, I'm aware of the 'know it all' tendency amongst IT people. I used to be one myself. :)

I think that's one of the reasons why I want to coach IT people. I found a lot of them to be wildly creative and fun, but seemed to have challenges around dealing with customers (for instance). Because they're typically not 'people people' and could maybe use some help to become one. That's where I always felt I was different than a number of my IT buddies. The computers were fun; but working with the people was much more fun. I don't want to coach anyone to be better at IT - they know how to do that and there are plenty of courses, books, and certifications to help. I want to help IT people improve their relationships (with bosses, co-workers, customers, and yes even their family). I want to help them lead more fulfilling and balanced lives. And I want them to become that rare species - an IT person that knows technology and that people can relate to.

It's not free so that adds an additional challenge. A lot of people are more willing if the company picks up the tab.

I did see the Daily Show bit. A perfect example of why I don't like the title 'life coach'. I prefer 'personal coach'.

by dave.leigh9

If you don't want to help anyone be better at IT, then why bother to position yourself as a coach for "IT people"? Those "non-IT" skills are pretty important for anybody who's not a lone coder in a box. But I posted at length about that elsewhere.

As to what you want to help people become... who cares? Is that your job as a coach... to turn people into what you want them to be? Or is it to help them become what THEY want to be? There's nothing at all wrong with being machine-oriented rather than people-oriented unless it becomes an actual problem professionally or personally.

by xyza

I got my job largely because of my people skills. Yes, I have a solid background and fit the technical requirements for the position, but what got me my job was my outgoing personality, ability to translate IT jargon into something that non-IT people can understand, and the fact that I am approachable by non-IT people for IT related issues. In all my positions, I was always the person that people came to for help, even though I wasn't the help desk. It wasn't uncommon for people to come to me with a question or problem before going to the help desk. I heard all too often that the help desk techs talked down to them and acted like they were "God."

I considered leaving this industry because I felt like I didn't have the right personality. I never fit in with my co-workers because I wasn't this "sit in my cube and plug away at code for 10 hours" type. I got lucky for finding a position where my personality is an asset to the company. I think that IT needs are changing and we definitely need more IT folk with strong interpersonal skills.

by fpiuck

Do you cold call people, network, get referrals? Have you talked to all the IT professionals you already know? Have you asked them whether they are struggling with the same issues you were when coaching helped you? If you can get someone to tell you they need help, it is a lot easier to convince them you are a source of help, than to try to convince someone who doesn't feel the need for it.

by plan b

I do all of these - although I admit the cold calling is my least favourite. I also attend meetings that will have IT pros and/or coaches that I know already.

In retrospect, I haven't asked often enough whether people are struggling with the same issues I was and/or that I can help with. Thanks for the reminder.

by fpiuck

The question about prospecting was not actually a recommendation. I doubt that cold calling is going to help you much. We all are cold called too often, and are suspicious when we get such calls. Your best bet is referrals, if you can get them.

One other thought - some of the people most in need of your services are the ones on the cusp of management - either newly promoted, or striving for promotion. Offering seminars on the challenges facing the newly promoted might work. Any one who attends one is acting on at least a low level of anxiety.

by shraven

If you can't even articulate yourself what exactly it is you do and why exactly your prospective customers need your services, you're destined to fail.

You yourself had to be convinced. It sounds to me like you drummed up some idea for yourself and are surprised people aren't flocking to your vision. But you HAVE to have a dozen different ways of explaining the ROI to your prospective clients. Unless you're offering your experiences for free.

by dougscrm9

I used a business coach. It was like counseling, we discussed issues confronting me and he drew ideas from me to develop marketing, sales and financial improvements. The problem with selecting IT persons as your target is that their vocation is fraught with unexpected issues and a rate of change that is probably twice that of any other career. You need to catch them when they are receptive. Try attending monthly meetings such as SQL server meetings. Networking may be a good way to develop new clients.

by plan b

...is that coaching is present and forward looking. Counseling (at least in my opinion), is backward looking. Coaching is more about what you can do, not what caused your problems.

I agree that IT has a high rate of change, and as a former IT person, that's why I think I'm better equipped to coach IT people than other coaches. I understand what the IT lifestyle is like.

But catching them when they're receptive is obviously the key. I do attend monthly meetings for Help Desk groups. I'm looking for other IT-related in-person networking groups as well.

by Member 34793965

My experience in IT has been that every IT person (myself included, I suppose!) thinks they know best, so how could they possibly need coaching.

Even end users think they know it all. Do you know of anyone, no matter how dangerous they are, who would admit to being a bad driver? It's similar with computer users. There's a lot of defensiveness.

It's not clear exactly what you plan to coach -- business basics, inter-personal communication skills, computer skills -- but I am not surprised you are encountering resistance and/or indifference. A friend of mine set out to be a personal trainer for business executives who are computer-challenged. He gave up after a couple of years. Few executives were willing to admit they didn't have a clue. Most IT pros and end users will be no different.

by jdclyde

A big part is they don't feel they have the time to take to become more efficient. As long as they are "good enough", it is good enough. (speaking of the execs)

As for techs, I have learned that the more you learn, the more you realize how little you really know. Anyone that says otherwise is a moron and should be disregarded.

Education teaches us how much is left to be learnt.

There is no room for ego in a professional environment.

by ddegrazia

I am an IT professional of 20+ years and a coach of 5+ years. Very few of us realize we could benefit from coaching but we all know someone who could. Good coaches recognize this and use it as access to coaching a person. For example a seminar called "why don?t they get it" is better attended then one called "Why don?t I get it". The IT industry tends to attract more character disorders then neurotics (read M. Scott Peck - The Road Less Traveled). This gives us the phenomena of ?it?s not me it?s them?. While it may actually be ?them? in several cases, coach people that they can?t work on ?them? but they can work on their own approach. Removing as much of the personal and emotional from a situation gives people access to working from their commitment not their feelings. When working from commitment people are more willing to do things to succeed then when working from being right or being angry.

As for clients - look for people committed to advancing their careers and committed to being understood. If you coach them from those commitments you can have them see how changes in their style or approach will make a difference.

by algoa456

IT people - in the main - suffer from SECS - Stupdity through Excess Cleverness Syndrome and therefore honestly believe they are 'above' lesser mortals being able to train them or even provide guidance.

In general humility is not an IT persons strong point. (Woman are better at the humility thing than men in the profession.)

I would point out that an intelligent person needs to well rounded and that your coaching can provide more scope for advancement etc. (Many SECS plagued IT people are constantly puzzled and angered as to why - in their mind - 'less intelligent' people advance in their careers whereas they do not.)

by plan b

I think I've been bitten by the SECS bug myself once or twice. :)

And yes, humility isn't always an IT person's strong point - but I'm ok with that. I'd rather work with people that are good and know it than with those that constantly doubt themselves. A 'little' bit of doubt is ok too.

I also agree that intelligent people need to be well-rounded and that that's where I can help.

by rayjeff

SECS? Really, because I would really like to know. The reason why I want to know is that there's a SECS-plagued IT person that at one time I really wanted to work with.

by charliespencer

"I'm on the West Coast of Canada and coaching of all kinds is very popular here"

I'm from the southeastern U.S., and I've only heard the word "coach" used in a sports context. "Block this guy low and he'll go down." "He murders fast balls but he can't even see a curve." "Enter that corner a little later and you can cut half a second off your lap time."

What does "coaching" mean as you are using the word? What skills do you help me improve? How does what you do differ from an online class, any of the three-to-five day classes, or (gods forbid) cracking open a manual?

by plan b

And therein lies part of the problem. While it IS popular here, it's more popular amongst women then men. Men tend to think of coaching as sports coaching. Women tend to think of it as life coaching (i.e. Dr. Phil).

But just as an athlete uses a coach to improve their performance, so do my clients. I help them improve their communication skills, their relationship skills, their planning skills, and other strategic and business skills.

Coaching classes of this type are currently being offered online, through books, over the phone, and in person. IMHO, you need a real live body (whether in person or by phone) involved for coaching to be effective. A coach sees things from a different perspective than the client does. They can call the client when the client starts making excuses or hiding from reality.

by charliespencer

"...why don't they think they need it?"

Perhaps the question is "What other training are they putting ahead of the skills I'm offering?" I'm sure I don't have to explain "opportunity costs" to you. Change occurs so quickly in this field I must spend my available training opportunities on upgrading those skills I was hired for. If a prospective client asks, "Why should I take the time to learn what you're offering instead of attending a more traditional technical class?", do you have an answer?

by tr

I doubt that you are going to have much luck getting clients. In most IT shops it's technical skill that counts, and how does your coaching help with that?

I agree that there are an awful lot of people that would benefit from coaching in business skills, I want to see them taking control of the businesses they work in.

You would have more success selling yourself as a specialist trainer telling company directors how to use their IT resources more effectively. It really hurts to put together a superb business case and see it get blank looks from the people whose jobs it will save. We desperately need to change the business culture of senior management, to make it unacceptable to appoint anybody as a director if they don't have any IT knowledge.

by irhastings

IT people in general don't think that they need coached but more information. I don't always think I need a coach to coach me but maybe someone to give me more information on a program or application. that would get you in the doors of managers than trying to sell you know more than they do...

by frostbite

from the post it seems that most of the areas you are targetting is not really specific to IT.

If you really want to target IT people as a niche market, I think you need to sit back and think of the specific benefits you intend to provide to IT people.

I think moset IT people are relatively logical thinkers so if you can come up with the specific benefits... communicating it in a cause and effect or other logical means may be helpful.

by plan b

Yes, you're right that what I'm targeting is not IT specific. The reason I want to work with IT people though is:
- I feel there is a need.
- I have a background in IT and can 'speak the same language'.
- I understand the pressures of working in IT and how it's different than the business.
- I've worked in large corporations, so I understand 'the business' as well.
- All of my coaching peers strongly suggest to target a specific niche rather than be all things to all people.

But adding specific benefits that IT people alone can enjoy? That's something I haven't done. Thanks for the idea.

by matej.pisko

marketing your service is a crucial factor for every success.

1.) BLOG
2.) Website
3.) Showcase at the HR Dep.
4.) mouth2mouth propaganda (best way)
5.) network with trainers
....

by jmgarvin

What tangable "stuff" can you give them? CEUs? Professional development "time?" What?

Also, coaching, at least from my stand point, is a bad word. It means touchy feely and blowing sunshine up my butt. I'm not saying this is what you do, but I am saying that I'm not the only one with this perception of coaching.

If you call it something else, perhaps focus it into course that you can give a specific name, then you should get a lot more takers.

Good luck!

by tr

Try Personal-Development Consultant, I've used it reasonably effectively. Personal-Development Trainer sounds less pretentious but some people want their egos stroked more than others.

by finell

I am not in IT, but I have dealt with lots of IT people for a very long time. You may be an exception and I know that there are others, but, in general, the technologically oriented people who are drawn to IT generally do not have the best interpersonal or communication skills, especially with ordinary mortals. That is why many of them need coaching. That is also why so many of them cannot perceive that they need it. I suggest that you market yourself to managers who supervise a lot of end users, as a resource to improve the users' IT experience.

by dwrandolph

I get the impression you are talking about soft / fuzzy / people skills. Yeah, I do not have many of those. Whether I am a geek because of that, or if that is a side effect of nerddom, do not know, do not care. I get along with the machines much better than people, and see no reason to change. I am happy here, you may be happier there, no need for a crusade to "improve" people who are not exactly like you.

by tr

There's room for different types of people in the industry, but times are changing. Soft skills are getting to be more important to tech careers. Managers need to develop tech skills, and techies need to develop soft skills too. There are some high level tech jobs but in most industries there is a limit to how high you can get before how you interact with people becomes as important as how you interact with a computer. When you have a family to support that will be important.

by ot1

There are obviously a lot of different views of what coaching is/means. I see that as your biggest challenge. One thing that helps me with the coaching point is the athlete version. All professional athletes use coaches, not because they don?t know what they are doing or that they are doing it wrong but because they want to achieve the next level and they can admit outside assistance helps.
I want to acknowledge you for your coachability. Some of these posts I read as a bit harsh but you only took it as advice or opinion, which of course it is. Finding IT people that can be coached may be another test for you.
Anywho, good luck. You may be able to change the way IT sees coaching, access to something and not a fix of anything.

This discussion is closed to new replies.