Discussion Locked

I was interviewed for a long term contract

0 helpful
61 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Last week and I had an interview with the head of IT was not what I expected. They questioned me on alot of XP and server 2003 topics but then asked what I know about Ghost, cloning and other copying programs. I do get these questions sometimes but they wanted to know if I could copy protected CD's or DVD's!
I said yes I have done this before to help protect paid for programs. To copy one copy is ok to protect the original. I said I have no problem with this as long as they have the OEM with box or CD case with the OEM.
I have been a contractor for awhile and I know that some companies protect thier software and back up all of thier paid for software as much as they can.
The contracting company called me back the next day and asked if I would start on Monday.
I asked one question. What are they copying and why? I was never called back to the company or the contractor.
What do you think, should you copy software if the company has not paid for it? Or if the company you work for is using more software then they have paid for?
I was a shape goat once in 99 and will not be there a second time.

I know a person in the company he said they use every thing from Windows for work groups (that was the first Windows with a GUI) to Win98 and NT. But they have never had a true copy or Licence for any of those.
They needed a person to copy the copies they have and go to the other locations and ether reload or fix there problems.
I was reading the other posts about this and found one that said this was another post about doing what you should not, Well there are alot of companys that still do this and you still need to watch out for it!

61 replies

by stargazerr

If the company lands into trouble some day ... so will you, being a part of it.

It is unethical to copy software that has not been paid for. The debate about copying music could go on for ages .... but software should be legally bought ...

]:)

by gacain

Music is covered by the same laws as software. Why would you think violating copyright law is ok when it comes to music and NOT ok when it comes to software?

by stargazerr

at all the laws that concern copyrighted music, you will see the difference.

If you are sitting in your car and listening to music and a passerby happens to hear it ... that's copyright violation ..

]:)

by johnnysacks

If your principals are strongly against the issue, don't do it, otherwise, follow your orders, do what you're told, collect paycheck, feed family. Your superior knows the rules and would never require you to do anything illegal. If I was informed the software was stolen or illegitimate, I would decline.

In the words of a famous criminal attorney (I think it was Alan M. Dershowitz), "Deny, Deny, Deny!". Never back down, never relent, never change your story.

by unclerob

making illegal copies of software and not maintain software license compliance can get a network admin in deep trouble, SPA holds network admins as well as their bosses responsible and you can be prosecuted accordingly. Just remember, ignorance is not a defense. You can say you didn't know and it won't matter to them either way, and you won't get to stay at club fed like Martha did either!

by jamesrl

If they ask you to do something fishy in the interview, what will they ask you to do on the job?

James

by dr dij

to see if he would admit to stealing software from the company, either for sale outside, or his own use, etc. and perhaps to judge if he would do that would he be willing to copy company data files for sale, etc.

by linuxinlibraries.com

to see if he would admit to stealing software from the company, either for sale outside, or his own use, etc. and perhaps to judge if he would do that would he be willing to copy company data files for sale, etc.

I would think that if it was a test then when he questioned why they wanted to know they would have told him. He also mentioned in the interview that he told them he would only backup copy protected stuff if they had the OEM discs, etc.

by cynth113

Couldn't have said it better than James. Do you really want to work in an environment where the hiring criteria includes willingness to perpetuate software piracy? If they don't care about the legality or morality of this (or how it might impact you), what else won't they care about? If nothing else, think of your comfort and stress levels--is this even worth a second thought?!

by jesc

If you are an IT Professional, particularly if your background is in management or you have a degeree, you can be held to a high standard. Many assume that they can hide behind the fact that their boss told them to install illegal software, saying they were just following orders. That is not the case. You can be found personally libel for your actions. It is not worth going to prison or losing your house to take the chance and participate in illegal activity.

by faradhi

indemnify themselves by writing against the practice in their policies. That leaves you out in the cold.

I have had something similar occur when I was working for my previous employer. They wanted me to give out the MS volume license key to an executive to install XP at home. I flat refused because the licensing forbids it. That was one of the reasons I left.

by jesc

I have had some evil enjoyment by writing an email to the manager stating that in my professional opinion it would be against our licensing agreement. On the other hand I am not a lawyer. If they are more qualified to interpret the law and wish to take a legal stand for the company based on their legal experise they could send me an email stating such and I would comply based on their authority. I would also keep a copy of their response in writing for my records. It was surprising how fast a bicycle can go in reverse when someone starts back pedalling.

by grimshiire

Only officers of the company are liable. Everyone else is not. Fact of the matter is that it is imoral, wrong & against the law to create or accept any copied material. We have all done it in the past, but continuing to do so shows poor morals.

by faradhi

When I stated that I would not refuse a direct order to give the VLK out but only if they put it in writing, I did not have to give the key to the exec.

by ruinit2

Asking for something in writing because you know it is illegal before you do it is not going to shield you from anything. It will probably only blow up in your face as they have proof that you knew you were doing something illegal.

To the court: Sure I knew I was doing something illegal but this order from my boss in writing makes me innocent as he is responsible.

Sorry but this does not work. Addmitting you knew you were acting illegally only makes things worse, you cannot claim ignorance after that.

In the original case one could have given out the VLK, assuming that the company would pay the license costs, making it leagal. Or just flat out refuse it.

Most company Execs usually earn enough to buy their licenses...

by faradhi

An exec is not going to put anything in writing instructing anyone to do anything illegal. I asked that to force him to drop the issue. It worked.

If the exec was monumentally stupid and gave me the instruction in writing, I would have forwarded the request to corporate legal and HR with a request for instructions.

The whole point of the exercise is to refuse without being insubordinate.

by michael_orton9

this is a very common thing, most senior people want the latest XP Pro at home.
Don't give it to them, just hint where the installation code is kept, third drawer down, in red envelope> He is satisfied, you are covered and the boss is happy.

It happens all the time.
however if the senior exec is so clueless that he cant get the key for 98se, it doesn't say much for his IT skills.

by m_a_r_k

I'm joking. Ask a stupid question, expect to get a stupid answer. I am astounded at all the knuckleheaded questions people ask. Yesterday it was about lying on a resume. Today it's one about stealing.

Would you assasinate the CEO of your closest competitor if your boss asked you to? Would you drive 80 mph through a school zone just to meet a deadline for your company? Would you break into a competitor's warehouse and steal a few crates of CD/DVDs for your company? I didn't think so. (Notice anything in common among all those questions?) So why in the world do you have to ask if it's OK to [b]copy[/b] CD/DVDs?

by m_a_r_k

The burglary thing would be pretty exciting. I'm not so sure about the assassination or rocketing through the school zone at 80 miles per hour. I'd rather kidnap the other CEO's 30-year old daughter than assassinate him or her. But darn it, I'm not sure if I can turn the school zone speeding idea into something that's still illegal but also a fun, crazy stunt. Why is doing something slightly illegal so much fun?

by mjwx

that it is for purely "educational purposes" that you want to learn such skills

by tfitzpatrick

I totally agree with Mark. There does not seem to me to be any question here. What the company is asking you to do, or potentially do, is not only illegal, it is also imorale. If the Exec wants to steal from the comapny, then let him or her do it themselves. I don't know about the rest of you, but I don't get paid enough to put my own butt on the line for some Exec who is not willing to fork over for software.

Always take the high road.

by ruinit2

Sloppy thinking and quite beside the point.

A lot of wars have been started because of lies. That does not change the fact that many people go to war to defend their homes and families. Not all wars are fought at someone elses doorstep as the US wars have been for the last 50 years.

I'll be hellbent if someone attacking my country is going to pillage, rape and kill family and friends of mine without me trying to stop them. It does not matter what sparked the war, I'll defend whats mine!

by vltiii

The decision to go to war for whatever reason right or wrong is a political one. Members of the military are not politicians nor do they have the option to pick and choose which battles they will participate in. They take an oath to among other things obey the orders of those appointed over them including the Commander In Chief. I respect the beliefs of those that are against war, but they need to consider what role their beliefs will play in their military career prior to joining the military.

by stargazerr

to speed through the school zone ... All it will need is a few more design changes :p

Kidnap CEO's 30 yeard old daughter?? Hmmmm ... Does he happen to have a 25 year old son who also happens to be a hunk ;)

Going home time ... but keep me posted whether or not the CEO has a son. That will decide whether or not I become party to the crime :D

]:)

by m_a_r_k

Funny how you picked up on the rocket reference. Even funnier how I managed to so easily slide it in there. :^O More design changes? Crap, I'd rather fly it to Tahiti than through a school zone. I wonder if I can make the new design flexible enough to do both.

The CEO does have a 25-yr old son. As far as being a hunk, that is not for me to decide. That reminds me, I am digusted that [i]Brokeback Mountain[/i] is up for so many Academy Awards. However, I have been told that the CEO's son bears a similarity to how I looked when I was 25. What am I saying? I still look 25. :| So yeah, I guess he is a hunk. :p

by stargazerr

We, in India, tie or paint something ugly to a new house, car or for that matter...... a new bride :D .... How about tying something ugly to the rocket to keep it safe??

CEO's son looks like you?? Cool ... Could you please make the rocket a three seater?? I would like to get married in Tahiti ... ;)

]:)

by paul.cook

M_a_r_k: "That reminds me, I am digusted that Brokeback Mountain is up for so many Academy Awards."

I'm wondering if you've even seen the movie.
IMHO it's not great, but it was good.

But you're disgusted? Why? It's just a love story. Get over it.

If a movie doesn't interest you, don't see it. King Kong got some nods, so did Memoirs of a Geisha, so did War of the Worlds. No interest to me. So i won't go see them.

But "disgusted?"
Live your life, let others live theirs.

Sorry, folks. Not very on-topic, I know.

**ON Topic**
Don't illegally copy software. Bad. Bad. Disgusting.

**OFF Topic**

BTW March of the Penguins is a phenomenal film. Well worth the $10.

by dr dij

there is a hardware block built into every cd / dvd drive except for certain licensed bulk replicators.

games in particular use this, and sdk's are available to write cds that put critical parts on the uncopyable sectors, e.g. macrovision.

maybe they weren't asking if you would copy but if you could copy?

or maybe was a moral question like you thought.

by zlitocook

The 90's called Clone that can copy most any CD/DVD even with protection. And if you look long enough and pay a small fee there are people who will give you programs that will disable most protection and other things. There is no safe software or computers, just people who try to protect thier selfs. I have copied most CD's and have no problem's and now I can dup, DVD's and leave out the water mark or Fed warnings if I want.
But I do not copy movies that I do not have or sell to others. I only use what I know to do what I need. But you need to think about this because there are alot of people out there who have no problem just sending every thing to any one who asks for it.

by x-marcap

Unix people can copy it and dump it in and out...

The moral question remains would I?

by dr dij

I think you're misinformed

regardless of what program you have or what operating system, the cd copy protection scheme is built into the cd-drive hardware. the sectors in question don't make it to the PC during a normal read.

you can read the rest of the sectors and try to hack the game / software to avoid the calls to determine if it is the original CD

if you are claiming you can copy protected computer CDs (not music as they don't use this scheme) I'd be interested in what program you claim you can do this with?

by dr dij

Snake, on the Simpson's is?

moneybag with $ sign? check
loaded gun? check
powerbar? check

Awlrite, let's go rob this... Bowlarama?

Snake's galfriend: I wish you would stick to something and learn a trade..

Snake reply: I dropped out of those telemarketing fraud classes because I hated to bother people at home in the evening..

by m_a_r_k

With a title like that, you might think this thread is heading for the gutter. No need for me to head that direction, though. I can turn a cat scurrying up an apple tree into a funny story if properly motivated.

You must have sissy criminals in India if all you have to do is tie something ugly around anything to keep it safe. An ugly something wrapped around the DVD warehouse isn't going to keep me from breaking in and looting the place. In some parts of the world, we tie a yellow ribbon around any stray object--house, tree, telephone pole, dog--as a symbol of hope for something to happen--missing loved to be found, soldier to come home from war, next chapter in a book to be written... All kinds of things. You may have heard the song "Tie a Yellow Ribbon". Speaking of apple trees, the chorus line is, "Tie a yellow ribbon around the ol' oak tree".

If I haul you and that studly younger version of the studly me to Tahiti in my rocket, where does that leave me? Still all alone... :( Remember I was asking if you knew of any 30-yr old stargazerrrr clones? If the CEO's daughter looks like you, I'll craft a 4-seater rocket out of the current 2-seater version and we'll all jet off to Tahiti together. :p

by stargazerr

I would blush but I dont like the blushing emoticon we have on TR ... So I will smile instead ... :)

After that, even if the CEO does not have a 30 year old stargazerr look alike, we can dump the idea of a 3 seater and make do with a 2 seater ;)

Now, all I need to do is buy a time Machine :D

]:)

by m_a_r_k

That's a flattering idea. Besides, a 4-seater rocket is a gas-guzzling monster that is hard to maneuver. If I can build a rocket, a time machine should be easy. You read H.G. Wells' book, didn't you? You could help with the design. But why go through that trouble. What's a few years one way or another gonna hurt? ;) While I'm on the subject of lookalikes, Tahiti has coconuts. If you stretch your imagination (which is easy for me to do), coconuts look like overgrown furry turnips. I'm sure we could work coconuts into the story somehow. :D

by stargazerr

You are right .... The inside of it even looks like melted plastic .... I bet it even gives off an acrid smell if you set fire to it ...

Building a Time Machine is a good idea ... We might even be able to go back in time and find that wretched iguana and get my torpedoes off its back (Need some fireworks for the big event in Tahiti ;) )

]:)

by m_a_r_k

That's a stimulating visual about the fireworks... ;) If we can't find that elusive iguana, we'll have another option. The Chinese invented fireworks. We'll have to fly over China to get to Tahiti (I'll have to take the long route to Tahiti because I'll need to go to the UK first :D ). We can make a quick stop in China, break into a fireworks warehouse and steal a couple of crates of fireworks. Breaking into the DVD warehouse before the trip will have been good practice.

by draxwayze

Lets be honest with ourselves here.

In the early days of the technology, there was an air of 'mystique' hanging around the computer world.

Then some smart operator realised that naive law-makers could be lulled into believing that PC CD-ROM programs were different to other recorded media. They saw they could have different copyright rules, for PC software, thereby securing a virtual monopoly on their products and their use. This arrangement would be advantageous and highly profitable to the PC Software companies. (And how!)

The truth is a PC CD-ROM is merely a recording. It's made in the same way as any other recording. Information is stored on or in a surface medium and this can be activated and read by the appropriate devices. (DVD player, Video player CD player or CD-ROM drive.)

So to CD, DVD, or video recordings:

If I buy, say a Madonna album or a Clint Eastwood VDV or Video, I can play these recordings on any appropriate device I own. Providing I don't use the recordings for public performances, I can play them on anyone else's device/s. I.e. I can visit a friend's home and take a DVD with me for an evening's private entertainment.

I can loan these recordings to friends to listen to on their own 'devices'.

After I have finished with the recordings, I may sell the recordings themselves, provided I do not keep a copy for myself.

I cannot copy the recordings, to give away to friends, or make multiple copies to sell. That's fair enough and I agree with that.

More importantly though, I don't have to tell the recording companies I have bought their product, nor tell them how many devices I intend to use them with, nor inform them when I sell the product on as used, along with registration details.

So, when I bought my legal copy of Windows XP Pro, why should I have to endure all this 'licence and registration' bull, just because years ago, someone convinced someone else that computers are mystical and magical, and the software is different to other recorded media?

In the beginning there was the PC and there were software companies! And behold, they propogated a myth that persists.

In fact, the only difference is that DVDs, Video recordings and Audio CDs are used for entertainment. (Mainly)

PC Software is used for application and educational purposes. (Mainly)

And PC Games?:

My biggest bone of contention is Half-Life 2. I have to be online to play the game, even in single-player mode. My copy has to be registered to me, and with an online games site. The site will only allow me to play the game if it recognises that my personal details match with the 'licence number' on my copy. This means can't even sell the game on, when I have finished with it. (Which I have. I shan't be buying the next version unless this Draconian restriction is lifted.)

I paid money for this game on a legal disc and to me, I own that disc and the material on it. Within the confines of normal copyright laws, I should be entitled to do use it when I wish, wthout going online, and I should be able to sell it on to someone else who can't afford a new copy. So, as far as I am concerned, my civil rights are being breached.

It is time for a complete review of the copyright laws; time that recording companies across the board realised their prices are too high. That's what creates the market for 'Copyright Piracy'. By default they deny themselves sales of their product. After all, if I can't afford their program, I won't buy it, even if I couldn't find a pirate copy.

It's time all this was addressed. Only then will we break the strangle-hold of software and recording companies.

Draxwayze

by puterfx

It?s more a matter of integrity ? both yours and theirs.

I just got a job for a small firm doing their IT stuff about a week ago. Their previous IT guy was leaving so spent 3 days kind of ?training? me. We built a couple of desktops to replace 2 of their 20 systems. When I was ready to install the OS, I asked him where the new cd?s were. After some hemming and hawing, he finally told me that they were in the process of getting legitimate versions of XP, but that he was hesitant to tell me that. I found a couple good deals online and showed them to him and he said he?d take care of it. The next day, I had a meeting with the president who told me that he had met with the IT guy and they decided I wasn?t right for the job.

I asked him what he meant and got a flimsy response, but I really feel the underlying reason was that I didn?t want to install illegal software. I left with my integrity intact and, although disappointed that I?m searching for a job again, I wonder when his lack of integrity would have come back to bite me in the butt.

I guess it?s just a personal decision you have to make. Are the rewards greater than the consequences of the risk? Personally, I?m not willing to take the chance.

by snordha19

I've had some jobs where the way they treat software licensing is analogous to the way they treat their employees. Get what they can out of them, squeeze them, no loyalty. Why should their ethical views be confined to one small area?

I did get moved to an IT manager position at a small company that bootlegged everything. I asked if we could go legal and was told 'no way'. When our comptroller left on bad terms, I hinted that he said something about turning us in for the illegal software. The next day I had a budget and a mandate. Maybe a lie on my part but it was get them legal or hit the road for me.
Steve

by stargzer

. . . you can always turn them in to the Software Police. What used to be the SPA (Software Protection Association, I think, which I used to refer to as the Software Police) is now the Software & Information Industry Association's Anti-Piracy Division ( http://www.spa.org/piracy/ ). Quoting from their site ( http://www.spa.org/piracy/report.asp ):

"Report software piracy here by using one of our online reporting forms below. You may be eligible for a reward of up to $200,000."

I imagine it will all depend on how much and how long they have pirated. If it can be documented that they've been pirating since Windows 3.1 or earlier, hey, even Big Bill may kick in a few bucks himself! :-)

Beats having Virtue as its own reward!

Of course, if you were just recently interviewed, they may be able to make the connection, so just hope they don't have any muscle available. ;-)

There is a world of difference between making backup copies and pirating for commercial use. Even with Microsoft, if you have a kid in school you can get a deal on the student version of Office. Piracy's just not worth it in the long run. Even your spouse could turn you in in a nasty divorce action.

by puterfx

Actually, I was considering that and found another website http://www.bsa.org/usa/ that I guess does the same thing. I hate to be a rat but if I am paying for software, I think they should as well, especially when they are making money off of it. I'll have to give that some serious thought. Thanks for the other link.

by kbrugnani

Wether or not it may have been a test of trusting or just a resposability test, I would not make illegal copies unless it was to protect OEM copies. We are all guilty at one point, but to do it for a company is not a good idea.

Especially with the tough copyright laws today you are bound to get in trouble. So I think its best to just say sorry I don't make copies unless it is to protect the original licensed copy.

The penaties are huge for individuals and corporations so not worth it.

by pipil

In the long run the company or company officers would clean themselves with you. Always do the ethical, likewise in the long run you will be rewarded for this.

by chazr_99

I lost a job with a small consulting firm in Chicago for refusing to install unlicensed copies of an OS at a client site. I was fired for insubordination. When the owner tried to challenge my application for unemployment benefits on the grounds that I was terminated for cause, I sent him a letter asking if he was prepared to deal with the FBI when I spilled my guts to them about some of his business practices.

I think he was most concerned about the potential problems for his brother who works for a software company headquartered in Redmond, Washington, should it be learned that the software he was buying at the company store (at a huge discount) was being copied and installed on the workstations of my former employer's clients.

I don't believe in compromising my ethics for a paycheck and think that what goes around comes around.

Fortunately, the company I work for today has a policy of strictly monitoring software installations and complying with license agreements.

by slatesplace

I have worked for companies where they steal software before, and one question always comes to mind. If the company is not willing to pay a software company the proper value for it's work, why in the world would they pay you the proper value for your work?

by da philster

My sentiments exactly.
So the company didn't call him back.....that's his lucky day.
There are enough good companies to work for without wasting time with schlock outfits.
Good luck in your search.

by jc2it

... BSA

It only takes one disgruntled employee or prospective employee to report this company to the BSA. Then they would need to have all of those Licenses fast.

Although just because you copy a CD or DVD does not mean you are breaking the law? There is such a thing as Fair Use copying. This is particularly the case of volume licenses. I never use the media kit that I bought, I always use a copy of it. This way, if I scratch it I am not waiting for another one to show up.

Maybe the company was not on the up and up, and maybe it was. It is difficult to say from the post. We don't know what zlito's inside contact actually does for the company, and they may be greatly mis-informed. If they are right then I would get anoter job, because it is like playing russian roulette working for an employer like that. You are just waiting for the explosion.

by verd1

To copy a CD of legal software to protect the one that the software company sent. Sometimes if the CD-ROM is bad it can ruin the CD. Why would you not use a copy to be safe? I do this and do not have any illegal software running on the networks I am system admin for. I do not see a problem with this. In fact the originals are kept off site in case of a fire and can be obtained at anytime along with the licenses to prove they are legal. So the issue is not copying but licenses for software. I can just see using a disk only to find it has been scratched and now we have to wait for a new CD, meanwhile the production has stopped at the company because of it. Not a wise situation to be in.

by edge99

I think he passed the test, the one that really matters. Doing the right thing

by stargazerr

Sure ... Put it that way ...

but these things dont have to be learnt ... Everyone has an inbuilt devil in them ;)

]:)

by ibowie

I understand that there are probably still lots of companies out there doing this stuff. If you were to do this, if they did get caught, who do you think would be responsible? The technician who knew better and did it anyway.
If everyone did what you did and refuse to go along with this type of stuff, it would sure stop alot of illegal copying. Good for you!

by vltiii

I don't think that insubordination is an issue. No one can be compelled to follow an unlawful order. Your refusing to do so does not make you insubordinate and if any action had been taken against you--then you would have legal standing to sue the organization.

by tdeast

The correct thing to do would be to turn them in.
Not because they rejected you but because what they are doing will eventually reflect on others as well

by jt_hebert

Am I missing the obvious? This isn't a situation where the business is 'test driving' to see if accomplishes what they need and then either delete or buy it. They have essentially advertised their illegal activity during the interview and hiring process and they shouldn't be surprised when the software police showed up.

by jonathanpanza

I worked for a company that unofficially endorsed using pirated software. I was told in very roundabout ways to get certain copies of software and use it for testing. I did so like a good employee.

This company also installed versions of MS Office in many locations with fake serials instead of purchasing new seats for office. I was later fired for running a file sharing program on their network. Corporate offices tracked it and my boss came down on me. I ran this program to obtain software for work many times.

Bottom line...don't compromise your integrity. I compromised my own values and went with the trend in a corporate environment. You ultimately will hold yourself accountable to God for all these things. It's not worth compromising yourself to please others.

This discussion is closed to new replies.