Discussion Locked

If this isn?t lunacy, I don?t know what is

0 helpful
832 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In the name of combating man-caused global warming - which is the biggest scam ever perpetrated upon mankind - the development of ethanol has been both encouraged and subsidized with tax dollars.

In the name of reducing dependency on foreign oil, the development of ethanol has been both encouraged and subsidized with tax dollars.

In the name of combating man-caused global warming - which is the biggest scam ever perpetrated upon mankind - the efforts to expand production of domestic oil supplies have been continually blocked.

As a result, we?re burning our food supplies and keeping our energy supplies buried in the ground.

The process of developing ethanol consumes just as much (or more) energy than it creates.

http://www.energybulletin.net/5062.html

[i]"The U.S. is wrestling with the worst food inflation in 17 years, and analysts expect new data due on Wednesday to show it's getting worse. That's putting the squeeze on poor families and forcing bakeries, bagel shops and delis to explain price increases to their customers."[/i]

http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/080414/inflation_squeeze.html?.v=4

[i]".....political leaders from poor countries (contend) that these fuels are driving up food prices and starving poor people.?[/i]

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/15/business/worldbusiness/15food.html?ei=5065&en=9e715f242c497f48&ex=1208923200&partner=MYWAY&pagewanted=print

[i]"Ethanol (is) driving up meat prices"[/i]

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2007/03/ethanol_chicken.html

We?re burning our food supplies and keeping our energy supplies buried in the ground. If this isn?t lunacy ? pure lunacy - I don?t know what is.

832 replies

by maecuff

That I've burned mine from time to time. A couple of times resulted in the smoke detector going off. Then, my husband reminds me that the smoke detector is NOT the same thing as a timer and we're okay again.

by mallardtooxx

My wife says I continue to use the smoke detector as a timer. Especially when the kids and I decide it is time to eat out! The problem is I think she is going to take the batteries out, take the kids out to eat at IHOP at 3am and forget to wake me up while the house is burning...maybe I should rethink the whole not listening to my wife thing...nevermind =)

-duck

Hell hath no fury like a meatloaf burned!

by dumphrey

that all these brilliant idiots would realize that we can not depend on a single source for energy to replace oil. Solar, geothermal, hydroelectric, wind, even ocean currents can be used. Hell, run the plants off of burning trash...
Another big scam are the hybrid cars, which consume more oil to create then a normal car, use more heavy metals, and actually get LESS mileage on the interstate then a comparable gas only version. For the average commuter, the savings on gas is minimal at best.

by notsochiguy

= lots of wasted $$$$

I need a small SUV for the stuff I lug around which wouldn't fit into the trunk of my old car. When I was looking up vehicle information, I considered going the Hybrid route (especially since the tax incentives were there to help defray some of the initial cost).

However, I learned that Hybrids are next to useless when it comes to gas savings in cold weather (Consumer Reports confirmed this), and despite the tax break, the cost of the vehicle would still outstrip a similarly equipped 'gas guzzler'.

I am all for ending our dependency on foreign oil (I'd go so far as to say that the best way to combat terrorism is to stop pumping money into the middle east...those 9/11 hijackers mostly came from our 'good ally' Saudi Arabia...not Iran, Iraq or even Afghanistan, after all). However, Hybrids, as currently constituted, are clearly not the way to go to achieve that end.

On a related side note, I have a buddy that is a fire fighter, and he said that hybrids also pose a much greater safety risk post-accident than does a regular auto, from what he has seen in the field.

by locrian_lyric

The batteries provide significant current, enough to shock rescue personel. I think there is also a significant hazard of chemical burns as well, but I am not sure.

by locrian_lyric

The batteries provide significant current, enough to shock rescue personel. I think there is also a significant hazard of chemical burns as well, but I am not sure.

by locrian_lyric

Not only that....

The amount of land used up to procuce corn, the amount of chemical fertilizers and water to grow it, the trucks to ship it to stills, the heat required to power the distilleries, the trucks required to ship the final product, the wear and tear it causes on engines, and the very inefficient production of energy from the final product all are reasons not to use it as well.

It is nothing more than a HUUUUUUUGE payoff to ARcher Daniels midland, the chief recipient of corporate welfare in the USA.

by forum surfer

Ethanol isn't the answer...BUT it doesn't promote extra wear and tear IF the engine is built to run on a specific ethanol mixture just like modern engines are configured to run on 80, 91 or 93. If you put ethanol in a motor that runs gas, you'll burn your rings up and have catastrophic piston/engine block contact.

The thing is the motor would run ethanol and ethanol only to be efficient. Race cars have run on it for years...but they aren't a good example as they are designed to run on the ragged edge of the performance envelope.

For ethanol to work you'd need to be able to run ethanol or gas as their simply won't be enough refilling stations for ethanol. You can't build a motor to run both comfortably, although it can be done...but this motor won't see 100,000 miles without a rebuild.

Not to mention the fact that corn is the most inefficient way to obtain ehtanol. Sugar cane is, but it won't grow properly in the heartland of the us where most of the crops would need to be in order to feed this gas hungry nation.

On a side note...if they don't ad poisonous chemicals into the ethanol vats after production...the ethanol company has to pay ABC taxes since it is technically consumable and will get you tipsy. I found that out after attending a local town council meeting once. E-85 was pursuing rights to build a plant locally. We asked why they added poisons in the end process and they told us that.

by danlm

to produce gasoline. The amount of land destroyed by the chemicals used to create it. And the amount of trucks to transport the final product.

I'm sorry... That is a two way argument... You do not take into account that the same can be said about gasoline.

Dan

by ed woychowsky

What really burns me is the hubris of believing that it is possible to say what's the normal tempurature for Earth with the information available. Let's see, 100 years of data goes into 4.5 billion how many times?

If they're so hot and heavy about reducing greenhouse gases they could always hold their breaths for the next week or two. :)

by jdclyde

verifying the accuracy of measurements from 100 years ago, and then comparing it to the data from today.

Cavemen driving SUV's caused the last cooling/warming/climate shifts?

by $$$$$$$$$$

How are old measurements that you didn't take any more a problem than recent measurements, which you also didn't take? Aren't you trusting somebody else in both cases to operate a simple device correctly, including the simple but boring task of calibration?

by deepsand

Present day causes need not bear any likeness to those of the past in order to yield like results.

What's happening today is not dictated by what happened in the past.

by jdclyde

Isn't that the whole basis of science, the study of how things work, and then correctly predict future actions based upon past actions?

by the scummy one

However, I cannot say that the USA is on the 'right track' for production.

I think that the problem that you are mentioning may be due to where the oil is located. If it is in a protected environment, such as a national preserve, then there is reason that it is not being used.

But I do think that there is a big problem with the US and energy all together. Brazil is something like 99% ethanol, from sugar cane which is cleaner than corn. Also, Brazil is on the US's 'friendly' list. However actions would seem to say otherwise. I will look it up later, but I believe that I read last year sometime that Brazil offered to start growing sugar cane ethanol for US distribution. However the Bush administration turned it down and said that they would have to pay more in tariffs, and by the time it hit the consumer, it would cost more than corn ethanol grown in the states.

However, there may be some good news on the horizon. I believe that I read something else recently which said that Brazil also had found a large under the ocean oil patch. They estimate a few years before they can begin extracting the oil. But this is supposed to be one of the largest pockets of oil on the planet.
I will try to pull up links later today, however just typing this up right now has put me 'behind' in a few things.

by jdclyde

Sugar is a big crop in the US, and a MAJOR crop here in Michigan (sugar beats).

If you let third world countries flood our markets, it would put our people out of work, destroying our economy. Something the "Walmart generation" doesn't understand when they buy the cheap import crap to save themselves a few bucks.

by the scummy one

sugar IS a big item here, but more people are starting to move to alternatives for sugar as well. Items like Stevia and other sugar alternatives are finally making their way to US soil.

As for profit, heck yeah! This is surely the key factor. If we import ethanol cheaper than US companies can make it, it will hurt our homegrown crops. However, I think it has more to do with ties to the government persons rather than the good for the US in general.

by locrian_lyric

My SIL's husband is 3rd generation oil worker. There is so damn much oil in the US that you can't get to, it's not funny.

ANY energy source will change the environment, you can not walk without footprints. The energy yield for oil vs the amount of land required to extract it is enormous.

Displacing a few prairie dogs for what is underneath the ground is not a major concern.

Human life first.

by the scummy one

the Bush administration wont lift tariffs for importing cheaper/cleaner ethanol, but will pay for the ethanol production from corn instead, while also reducing our food supply for animal feed, etc..

lifting the 54 cent per gallon tariff instead of paying 51 cents per gallon from our already vulnerable economy seems a bit counter-constructive to me.

Just my almost 2 cents worth at least..

by hal 9000

But what is even more insane is Tax Dollars being used to encourage Farmers not to grow the food in the first place or Subsidies to farmers to grow some grain types that can not be used.

I seem to remember something about Food Subsidies by the US Government to get farmers to grow grains so that they can plow them back into the ground. To me that is even more insane to converting what is otherwise considered as Rubbish onto a fuel that may be able to be used by the masses.

When you are like us here in AU and paying in excess of $5.94 AU a Gallon for the lowest Octane fuel it makes a lot more sense to burn what would otherwise be plowed back into the ground than to plow it in. I'm from Queers-land where the Government gives us all a .08 Cent per Liter fuel subsidiary so in the other states you can add .36 cents per Imperial Gallon for fuel and in the country fuel is normally anything up to 20 cents a liter more expensive than in the Metropolitan Areas due to transport costs. So that is another .90 cents per Gallon added to the price of the fuel that everyone buys and this contributes to Inflation in the greatest possible way.

Governments attempting to minimize Fuel Costs are attempting to minimize Inflation no matter what spin they put on things. So it's infinitely better that they do this with our money that waste it like they normally do.

If they wish to say that they are doing this to combat Global Warming then so be it but any Educated Person will realize that they are not being exactly truthful in what they are saying. Though it may look great in the Headlines.

OH Good to see you back here Max. I'm going to bed now so I can get a couple of minutes sleep tonight. :D

Col

by the scummy one

the reason for the not growing crops has been due to drought mainly. However I sometimes wonder about other motives.

The reason to grow certain grains and plow it into the ground is to re-enrich the soils that have likely been depleted of a good amount of nutrients. It is better to do this than to add lots of chemicals.
However, I if I were a farmer, I would prefer the crop rotation rather than this, unless in dire need.

See, not so crazy afterall..

by deepsand

to that expected by so many for so long.

It seems that tilling disturbs the micro-biota in the soil such that the resulting decrease in nutrients is greater than those returned by tilling under organic material from crop waste.

While it seems, on the surface, counter-intuitive, it turns out to be better to not turn under crop waste, and to do the lightest amount of tilling necessary for seeding the new crop.

by notsochiguy

...as well as a propensity for the air bags to deploy without cause on a delayed basis: meaning that the accident has occurred, air bags don't initially deploy, firefighter puts head into car to ask if occupant is okay and POP goes the airbag.

That second part doesn't seem to make a lot of sense to me, but he said they had been warned/advised about it, and he is a straight shooter.

Maybe it is a case of it happening in a couple of hybrids, and due to the per capita numbers, it seems like a much larger issue than it really is...perhaps???

by locrian_lyric

could happen if they are stuck and the FF touching the auto jars them loose, or if he accidentially completes a circuit.

by charliespencer

"In the name of combating man-caused global warming ... the efforts to expand production of domestic oil supplies have been continually blocked."

Most efforts to expand U.S. production are blocked due to the potential of localized environmental damage from spillage. That's certainly the case in ANWR. Until the recent increases in the cost per barrel, the cost of obtaining and refining oil other than sweet light crude was unprofitable for the established oil companies.

by deepsand

of oil greater than is presently available.

We've not built any new refining capacity in decades; and, that which we have, has been so poorly maintained that it's falling apart.

by maxwell edison

Why haven't any new refineries been built in the USA over the past few decades? Have any been proposed? If so, why hasn't the construction gone forward? And if so, who or what is blocking it? Do you, personally, think that newer refineries should be built? And do you believe that those refineries, either new or existing, should refine oil obtained from American reserves or foreign ones?

by dawgit

Books are such wonderous things aren't they? This one written long before the present US crisis, by a fellow named Edward Gibbon (1737-1794) Tells a very simular story. And since he been dead for a little while, I can't see anyone crying paristion politics.

Prof. Horowitz(*), in her course notes on this subject, adds this: ?Then, in the third century, the tide turned. A deep and persistent crisis took hold. Prosperity faded; poetry and philosophy languished. The borders could be hold only by enormous efforts required the reorganization oft the army, the economy, and the machinery of the state. Thenceforth, until the final collapse of authority in the Western Empire in the late 400s, although Rome survived, it bled? (King, Western Civilization: A Social and Cultural History, Brief Edition, 2001, p. 119).

The book:
Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire
Author: Gibbon, Edward (1737-1794)
Language: English
Rights: Public Domain
CCEL Subjects: All; History;
LC Call no: DG311
LC Subjects: Italy
can be found here: [ http://www.ccel.org/g/gibbon/decline/home.html ] and here: [ http://www.ccel.org/g/gibbon/decline ]

(* Maryanne Cline Horowitz
Professor of History and Title IX Officer, Occidental College
Associate, UCLA Center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies )

Test tommorow :^0 -d

by the scummy one

I hope this Algae thing pans out. Predictions are more oil per acre than any other method so far (that I have read about).

by boxfiddler Hot topic

but I think that no matter what the eventual findings and use, corporate interests will f**k that up too. As long as profit remains the motive for the corporate entities that have the resources to finance the direction we take, we are all still screwed.
My primary indulging zone for cynicism.
Which of course equally applies to my earlier comment re: switchgrass.

etu

by mallardtooxx

"but I think that no matter what the eventual findings and use, corporate interests will f**k that up too."

The problem is, without corporate interests there will be no one to grow enough algae and there will be no benefit. I am not saying that corporate America is golden, but without it who has the capital and warewithall to actually carry it out?

On a side bar I found out Indiana is the #1 producer of ducks in the nation...at the risk of sounding cannibalistic, I would love it if they made duckanol. More money for my state, and the emissions smell and taste yummy!

-duck

by $$$$$$$$$$

http://money.cnn.com/2008/03/05/news/bush_ethanol/index.htm
[i]Bush acknowledged some of the problems with ethanol, particularly its role in pushing up the price of corn. The price of corn has doubled since 2006 which has pushed up the price of chicken, beef and poultry - livestock fed with corn.[/i]

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0876/is_n62/ai_12296628
[i][u]Beyond Beef[/u] offers these startling statistics: cattle and other livestock consume more than 70% of all grain produced in the United States, and at least one third of the world's total grain production is fed to cattle and other livestock while more than a billion people suffer from perpetual hunger and malnutrition.

Feeding grain to cattle and other livestock while people starve has precipitated revolutionary political struggles in several Third World countries, resulting in strife between northern industrial nations and the poor nations of the southern hemisphere.

Most people are unaware of the wide-ranging effects cattle are having on the ecosystem of the planet, damage that threatens the well-being of the earth and its population, Jeremy Rifkin predicts.[/i]

Don't wait for Curious George to get to the root of this, or any other problem. He's a dufus who walks heavily, with a [b]little stick[/b].

http://money.cnn.com/2008/03/05/news/bush_ethanol/index.htm
[i]Bush said his administration has spent over $1 billion to make cellulosic ethanol - which can be made from non-food plants like grasses or wood chips - cost competitive. He also highlighted the use of biodiesel, which is diesel fuel made from agricultural and food waste...

In the renewable field overall, Bush said his administration has spent $12 billion on research and development since he's been in office, all part of an effort to wean the nation off big oil and increase investment in solar and wind power.[/i]

He's funding research 12:1 over efforts "to make cellulosic ethanol - which can be made from non-food plants like grasses or wood chips - cost competitive," while the major obstacle to cheap & [b]energetically efficient[/b] ethanol production is infrastructure, not research.

http://www.wired.com/cars/energy/news/2008/01/ethanol23
[i]Making ethanol is one thing, but there's almost no infrastructure in place for distributing it. But the company's method solves that problem because ethanol could be made locally from whatever feedstock is available, Tobey said.

"You're not bound by location," he said. "If you're in Orange County, you can use municipal waste. If you're in the Pacific Northwest, you can use wood waste. Florida has sugar. The Midwest has corn. Each region has been blessed with the ability to grow its own biomass."

Still, consumers will need some way of getting that fuel into their vehicle. Less than 1 percent of the nation's 170,000 gas stations sell E85, said Mike Omotoso, senior manager of the global power train group at J.D. Power & Associates.

"Even if you produce it county by county, you still need an infrastructure," he said. "People aren't going to go to some remote location for fuel."

But with production set to ramp up quickly to meet the 36 billion gallon mandate, ethanol advocates believe it won't be long before E85 is widely available.[/i]

Reasons to write your Congresscritters, to fund this process, and ABSOLUTELY NO BUDGET to Archer Daniels Midland for corn:

* [i]A biofuel startup in Illinois can make ethanol from just about anything organic for less than $1 per gallon, and it wouldn't interfere with food supplies, company officials said.[/i]

* [i]Coskata, which is backed by General Motors and other investors, uses bacteria to convert almost any organic material, from corn husks (but not the corn itself) to municipal trash, into ethanol.[/i]

* [i]Besides cutting production costs to fire sale prices, the process avoids some key drawbacks of making ethanol from corn, company officials said. It wouldn't impact the food supply, and its net energy balance is high because the technique works almost anywhere using almost anything with great efficiency. The end result will be E85 sold at the pump for about a dollar cheaper per gallon than gasoline, according to the company.[/i]

* [i]Tobey said Coskata's method generates more ethanol per ton of feedstock than corn-based ethanol and requires far less water, heat and pressure. Those cost savings allow it to turn, say, two bales of hay into five gallons of ethanol for less than $1 a gallon, the company said. Corn-based ethanol costs $1.40 a gallon to produce, according to the Renewable Fuels Association.[/i]

by deepsand

the atmosphere, thus helping to reduce man's contributions to a greenhouse gas that contributes to radiative forcing to a greater extent than CO2.

Furthermore, they don't require an ongoing regime of antibiotics to combat the continual infections that plague corn fed cattle.

And, they taste better.

by $$$$$$$$$$

But until I know that they're not grazing in & along streams, increasing turbidity & erosion & killing fish, I would still rather abstain from the bovine altogether. Even the way they eat, pulling grass out of the Earth including the roots instead of biting through the leaves, seems Designed for maximum environmental damage. As if all the evil they do isn't enough, they have cloven hooves [b]and[/b] horns. You are what you eat!

]:)

by delbertpgh

Take the most grass fed, most spiritually and materially content cows you can find; no matter how sweet their lives and delicious their flesh may be in this near state of nature, once they get into the great economic food machine, they are put onto a special diet for their final month that will slam on the weight, and that diet is grain. The cows can't digest that much grain properly, suffering indigestion, upset stomach, and lots of gas; and would fall into serious ill health if they weren't slaughtered first. In that time in the feed lot they are crowded in with hundreds of other cattle, all standing in an ocean of crap, which breeds strands of e.coli that would kill them (or any human) without enormous doses of antibiotics. And then they die, and come to your kitchen. That is the unavoidable outcome of our taste for economical beef, and the only way you'll get something that really is grass fed is to go to Whole Foods and pay $12 a pound. Which I won't do; I stick with the cow I can afford, and try not to think about how its last month was spent.

by oz_media

1st of two issues
:
A UN member taking food to his comrades was carjacked in Haiti. In Africa, crime and assault has increased a great deal due to famine.

The problem they see now is a massive, global food shortage. Famine is at its highest level and crime in those underpriviledged countries has grown.

The US has been 'accused', if you can call it that, of segregating too much of its food crops and puttign an increased demand on imports from other countries, meaning less and less food is able to make it to countries in real need.

In essence, the story related to how this benefit to US agriculture has, in effect, blamed the US approach to grain development as being a detriment to the world. While prices have gone through teh roof, nobody can afford food and they are not gettign teh imports as the US is using extra food from other countries.

With respect to the great rock n roll swindle (from the GW naysayers, such as yourself), I am getting proetty tired of you using the same old bullsh1t that everyone (including yourself) knows is false to instantly discount what you view as global warming scam. It gets you some great press but even you are nto that stupid as to think people believe that MAN CAUSED global warming.

MAN DID NOT CAUSE GLOBAL WARMING, that is not an argument of any substance at all. I have heard many people discount global warming and many peopl esupport it, you are the ONLY ONE who actually keeps claiming that people think MAN CAUSED GOBAL WARMING, [b]THEY DO NOT THINK NOR SAY THAT ANYWHERE THAT I HAVE SEEN.[/b]

Global warming is a natural phenomenon, everyone agrees with that, whether for or against the whole GW issue.

2nd of 2 issues:

Man's emissions have added to the degenerative process that perpetrates global warming. Man has increased the speed of this natural phenomenon. Not only that but we are also responsible for eliminating other species from the planet that would not have been extinct for a great deal of time yet. We are the only life form on Earth that deems itself a superior king of the planet, yet we are the least able to adapt and conform to our surroundings. We have designed an economy that is modeled to offer constant growth. That economy is also reliant on fossil fuels.

The stupid part is that mankind actually believes that an economy designed to grow, would be possible when based on using a non renewable energy source.

That one just doesn't add up.

All in all, mankind has become a very stupid bunch of pu$$ies who can't make do without thier luxuries. The world would be a lot better off without mankind, but that's just a matter of time anyway, time that is now being reduced due to idiots and politicians (same thing isn't it?).

Conclusion: With an economy designed to grow, a growing population protected from early demise (many diseases curable now etc.)and resources that do not grow or replenish, how is it conceivable that we can continue on this path of without repercussions? our entire economy needs ot be restructured, redesigned and rebuilt. It is illogical to believe that more people wasting more resources will not see teh well dry up. Whether for GW or just self preservation, we need an alternate fuel system, and [b]no I don't think ethanol is the key either.[/b]

by oz_media

I haven't watched episode 5 yet, maybe tonight. It reminds me of the same production quality as the Rome Series, which was dropped after two seasons due to budget.

It's nice to see the HBO and the Discovery Channel specials replacing some of the old 'Masterpiece Theater' style of mini-documentaries, of which I think I Claudius was my fav.

by danlm

driving up the price of food products? Have you listened to the truckers(hear transportation of food supplies) lately complainging about the price of fuel???? Get it straight, more has to do with the cost of transporting the food then with ethanol producti9on.

Sorry... Ethanol is small stone in the pond... I don't believe it. Especially since there are many methods under review to produce ethanol. Please read absolutely's post.

And by the way, I would rather pay a farmer for my fuel then some scum bag foreigner who hates this nation. Cut to the chase, I use ethanol. 85 percent good old USA product, 15 percent from scum bags. Your the one that told me we only import 4? percent of our oil. Mutiply that by the 15 percent fossil fule to find out how much I contribute to this nations reliance on foreign supplies.

Look at it this way Max. I would rather use ethanol which was created in the USA then oil from some nation that we might have to go to war with to keep receiving our supply.

They can cut of the transportation of oil in multiple choke points through out the world. Ethanol created here would be extremely hard to stop. Considering how many plants are going up right now.

You keep bitching about ethanol, I'll keep buying it knowing that I am reducing this nations reliance on foreign supplies. Simple as that.... How are you reducing this nations on foreign energy supplies?

Dan

by the scummy one

Brazil is supposed to be a 'friendly' nation, and we seem to try taxing them more for trying to come to our aid. But we still keep buying from -- terrorist sponsored nations --

What kind of a joke is this?

by danlm

and the finding of a large deposit of oil off their cost... Don't remember where though... But they were talking 10 years to develope??

Who knows... Sorry if I repeated what you already said.

Dan

by $$$$$$$$$$

As much as the US presence around parts of the Mediterranean is hated, Red Scare policies in Central and South America could realistically have made even more enemies. The father of our current President got known in Washington D.C. after working in the CIA. Now each sibling is a career "public servant"?? It is not the national interest that he serves, but The Family.

by ontheropes

The price of corn/development of ethanol has impacted me because we have a small corn stove. Corn is an efficient, renewable heat source but the price has gone up so much we ended our heating season early to save money.

All of my information about corn/ethanol is, sadly, poorly remembered but I recall thinking that this picture was accurate at the time. My file record shows that I saved the image on 11/24/07. I don't have a link handy showing where I got it.

http://i201.photobucket.com/albums/aa12/sharewhat2/the-ethanol-effect-900.jpg

At least we don't have thousands of dollars invested into heating with corn as many people do. Some of my farmer friends sell corn, corn-stoves and installations. As you might expect, their heating business has fallen way off.

by deepsand

However, your post implies that now the kernels are also so used.

Am I correct in that deduction?

by ontheropes

After looking into alternative heat sources for the house I discovered that folks here in the US have been using corn kernels for heat for a long time, decades if I remember correctly.

by ontheropes

Seriously good.

I have a link for you but TR isn't the place for it.

Edited to clarify why I don't think it's a suitable link to post at TR. There is a lot of use of the f-word and some people find that offensive in the extreme. I don't. I also don't want to get the boot from TR.

I think the link is a great, humorous, manic, written rant/website on joblessness and think you might be able to use a laugh.

by $$$$$$$$$$

If every other member of TR spams me first, I'll keep accepting PMs at least until I get yours.

I still haven't found any better site for Computing/General and if I do I'll be sure to post it right here!

by ontheropes

Try sending me one then you can shut your PM off again if you want. I won't spam you. I'll only ever just reply to email you send to me and I won't use your email address to sign up for a free laptop or anything.

Trust me. :^0

I trust you.

by deepsand

Facts omitted and/or ignored:

1) Worldwide droughts, resulting in decreased production of food stocks.

2) Switch from grass fed cattle to corn fed cattle.

3) Wordlwide increase in demand for beef.

4) Dietary shifts in much of the world, from eating rice to eating other commodity grains, notably wheat.

5) Increased worldwide demand for food, particularly in China, as incomes rise.

6) Domestic refining capacities are inadequate for meeting demand.

Fallacies of drawing conclusion based on facts not in evidence:

1) Assumption that man's role in GW is minimal at best.

2) Assumption that lack of domestic oil production is responsible for high fuel prices.

3) Assumption that ethanol production is responsible for a major portion of the rise in food prices.

by j-mart

Requires an input of 6 times more energy than can be taken out of the finished product. Can't see this being a good move in the long run

by danlm

I don't think anyone considers corn being the long haul ethanol source.... It's just what is used, and only in the US right now.

Again, there is much research into other methods of producing it. And again, my point.

I use 85 percent US products, and 15 percent imported scum bag products.

I know where my priorities are. Has nothing to do with global warming either. Has everything to do with reducing reliance on foreign supplies.. And no, I am not calling Canadians scum bags. Nor our neighbors to the south, unless you travel much further south... Then they are total scum bags.

Dan

by $$$$$$$$$$

Production of corn ethanol gives back the energy used to produce it * 1.24 to 1.3, based on what I've read recently. Switchgrass gives a factor of 5!

http://www.wired.com/cars/energy/news/2008/01/ethanol23

[i]May Wu, an environmental scientist at Argonne National Laboratory, says Coskata's ethanol produces 84 percent less greenhouse gas than fossil fuel even after accounting for the energy needed to produce and transport the feedstock. It also generates 7.7 times more energy than is required to produce it. Corn ethanol typically generates 1.3 times more energy than is used producing it.[/i]

by deepsand

to the issue of capacity.

As for the rest, perhaps this will suffice as a beginning.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

New York Times

July 22, 2007

[b]Record Failures at Oil Refineries Raise Gas Prices [/b]

By JAD MOUAWAD

Oil refineries across the country have been plagued by a record number of fires, power failures, leaks, spills and breakdowns this year, causing dozens of them to shut down temporarily or trim production. The disruptions are helping to drive gasoline prices to highs not seen since last summer?s records.

These mechanical breakdowns, which one analyst likened to an ?invisible hurricane,? have created a bottleneck in domestic energy supplies, helping to push up gasoline prices 50 cents this year to well above $3 a gallon. A third of the country?s 150 refineries have reported disruptions to their operations since the beginning of the year, a record according to analysts.

There have been blazes at refineries in Louisiana, Texas, Indiana and California, some of them caused by lightning strikes. Plants have suffered power losses that disrupted operations; a midsize refinery in Kansas was flooded by torrential rains last month.

American refiners are running roughly 5 percent below their normal levels at this time of the year.

?You have a system that is taxed to the limit,? said Adam Robinson, an energy research analyst at Lehman Brothers. ?This is what happens when spare capacity is eroded.?

After Hurricanes Katrina and Rita disrupted the nation?s energy lifeline two years ago, oil companies delayed maintenance on many of their plants to make up for lost supplies and take advantage of the high prices. But, analysts say, they are now paying a price for deferring repairs.

As a whole, refining disruptions have been considerably higher than in previous years: they averaged 1.5 million barrels a day in the first quarter, compared with 700,000 to 900,000 barrels a day from 2001 to 2005. In the days after the hurricanes, refiners were forced to briefly halt as many as five million barrels of production.

In 2006, when refiners were still reeling from the impact of the hurricanes, disruptions in the first quarter averaged 1.35 million barrels a day.

Many factors have led to the rise in gas prices, including disruptions in oil supplies from places like Nigeria and Norway. But analysts say the refining bottleneck in North America has been one of the main drivers of higher energy prices this year.

The refining crunch has pushed wholesale gasoline prices up 35 percent this year and has contributed to a 23 percent gain for crude oil prices. Oil futures in New York closed at $75.57 a barrel on Friday.

Some critics of the industry have theorized on Internet blogs that the squeeze on gasoline and other refined products points to a deliberate effort among oil companies to bolster profits by keeping supplies tight. But experts point out that the companies have little incentive right now to hold back on fuel supplies.

?Every refinery would like to run as much crude as possible but they simply can?t,? said David Greely, senior energy economist at Goldman Sachs, who in a recent report compared the drop in domestic refining with an ?invisible hurricane.? ?These are more complex systems. There are more chances for things to go wrong. And when things go wrong, they tend to back up the system.?

Meanwhile, refiners have been scrambling to meet a raft of environmental regulations, phase out toxic additives, add ethanol to the fuel mix and introduce new ultralow sulfur standards for gasoline and diesel. Industry insiders attribute much of the fragility of refining operations to the difficulty of making these cleaner fuels.

Refiners spent $9 billion from 2002 to 2006 to make low sulfur diesel. But producing these cleaner fuels means processing crude oil more intensely through the refining process, at higher pressures and temperatures. This, in turn, leads to more chances for glitches or breakdowns, refiners say.

?It?s a marvel we can continue to run refineries the way we do these days given the many requirements and specification changes we have,? said Charles T. Drevna, executive vice president of the refining industry?s main trade group, the National Petrochemical and Refiners Association. ?There comes a time when the piper has got to be paid.?

This year?s problems have raised alarms about the safety of refining operations, especially after a deadly accident at a BP refinery in Texas two years ago that killed 15 workers. The federal Chemical Safety Board issued a highly critical report blaming a broken safety culture at BP. But the board?s chairwoman, Carolyn W. Merritt, who has spoken out about safety problems at refineries, said there was a pattern in many other refinery incidents that the board had investigated.

?There is a lack of investments in modern equipment,? Ms. Merritt said. ?The overwhelming preponderance is that if you have inadequate engineering and equipment, poor process safety management, and poor staffing, you?re set up for a catastrophe.?

Ms. Merritt, who was appointed by President Bush and will retire after her five-year term ends in August, also said the Occupational Safety and Health Administration does not conduct enough inspections. ?There is no enforcement,? she said.

OSHA defended its record and said it had inspected almost 500 refineries from 1994 to 2004. The agency also said it would inspect all refineries under its jurisdiction within the next two years. ?OSHA inspections of refineries have proven to be effective,? the agency said.

Meanwhile, demand has been rising relentlessly, providing little respite to the nation?s aging energy infrastructure. Even as consumers complain loudly about high prices, they show no signs of scaling back. Gasoline consumption reached 9.66 million barrels a day in the first week of July, the second-highest level on record.

?The cushion that used to be available five to seven years ago for these unplanned perturbations is no longer there,? said Jeet Bindra, Chevron?s president of global refining. ?When a refinery has a hiccup, there are consequences on supplies.?

Part of the problem, analysts and refiners said, stems from the hurricanes two years ago. In Louisiana and Mississippi, many refineries were flooded, and about a quarter of the nation?s refining capacity was shut for weeks.

?Since refining has become such a wonderful business, refiners have delayed maintenance,? Mr. Robinson said. ?But when they do go down, they stay down for longer and they discover all sorts of problems.?

In late March, for example, a fire at a large compressor at a BP refinery in Whiting, Ind., caused a hydrogen-treating unit that removes sulfur from some oil products to shut. That meant BP had to turn off a crude oil unit for early maintenance. Two weeks later, a brief power disruption damaged another distillation tower. And in July, a third crude oil tower was shut briefly so operators could fix a small leak. Since the first incident, the 405,000 barrels-a-day refinery has been running at about half its capacity.

Not all refining disruptions are the result of similar incidents. Refineries typically schedule yearly maintenance that sometimes requires them to halt production entirely. But even these long-scheduled shutdowns can now take longer to complete.

No refineries have been built in the United States in over three decades, because refiners say they are too costly. Instead, they have been expanding their existing refineries.

All this is happening as the industry goes through another golden age. After 20 years in the doldrums, the refining business has never been so good for oil companies. Refining margins ? the difference between the price of crude oil and the value of refined gasoline made from it ? have shot up as much as $25 a barrel for some types of crude oil, compared with about $5 a barrel just a few years ago.

But with a third summer of high gasoline prices, lawmakers are debating legislation they claim would punish oil companies for exploiting the tight supply situation and engaging in ?price gouging.? At the same time, they are pressing refiners to produce more fuel.

?Refiners want to keep running in today?s economic environment,? said Mr. Drevna of the refiners association. ?But when they shut down they are accused of gouging the system. When they don?t, they are criticized for overrunning their facilities.?

Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company

by ontheropes

Some people, like us, buy bushel bags. One bag lasts all day in a stove that's rated at 50,000BTU's so it's obviously supplemental heat only for us. Larger heating operations have silos for corn storage that feed right into the stove thru use of augers or belts and augers.

by deepsand

to the suburbs of a large city.

But, in my defense, I must note that economic opportunities for non-farmers were then scarce indeed where I hail from.

by ontheropes

I'm sure it hasn't changed much in some places.

I believe that the farmers around here were among the first in this area to turn to corn for heat, as you might imagine. With a modern, efficient furnace many people heat both their house and their barn(s).

by deepsand

And, oddly enough, it is owing to the matters on which we are at odds that leads me to such conclusion.

Organic fuels require carbon for their formation. Carbon is of a finite supply; and, when hydrocarbons are burned, yield CO2 which contributes to radiative forcing. Therefore, for long term sustainability, with respect to an energy supply and an acceptably livable habitat, we need to switch to inorganic energy sources.

Growing fuel does nothing to decrease our consumption of organically bound energy, serves to increase atmospheric levels of CO2, and cannot not result in increased deforestation.

And, increased consumption of oil suffers from the same or similar disadvantages.

As for the effect of the diversion of corn from the food supply to that of the energy supply on food prices, guesstimates of such range from 10-15% at the low end, to 25-30% at the high. Clearly, even if one accepts the highest figure, that alone fails to account for more than two-thirds of the observed increase in food prices.

Still, as it is the one factor that we can easily and quickly control, I would, along with the other reasons given for not relying on organics for fuel, advocate a reversal of policies designed to encourage the production of plant based ethanol.

by Member 25348569

The point about using biomass as the source of fuel is that the carbon is "reusable". What you burn this year makes the fuel for next year and so on. Oil, coal (and concrete, for that matter) is fossil carbon which hasn't been in the atmosphere for millions of years and won't be reused as new oil or coal for another few million.

Once the process is up and running, the nett carbon dioxide contribution from biomass fuels, assuming the process does not use any energy from other sources (OK, that's a big if), is zero when measured over a year.

The deforestation issues - to plant palms for oil, for instance - is another issue entirely and plainly not a good idea but as the price of oil keeps on going up, expect to see much more of it.

As for energy from "inorganic sources", the one huge advantage that carbon-based fuels have over anything else is the portability. You can carry a gallon of ethanol in a container that weighs a couple of ounces when empty. You can't do that with hydrogen or electricity.

THAT is the issue that will keep us all using oil and also biofuels.

Neil :)

The really, really insane thing is that we burn oil, not that we burn food.

by deepsand

A drive down Route 13, thru the Delmarva peninsula, with an eye toward the rusted railroad spurs that once serviced graineries, farm equipment sellers, etc., will suffice.

In central PA one can view the same and more. There, it's not merely the spurs that go unused, but entire lines that have been abandoned.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

the buffalo and other grazers around the world roamed and munched freely to their hearts content without screwing things up. It's only once a certain type of man rose to pre-eminence and prolific population that the grazing behaviors you mention 'became' an environmental problem.

Disclaimer:
This is not anti-anti-bovine commentary! ;)

by forum surfer

But what about my steak on Fridays in the summertime? Grilled on a good ol smokey charcoal grill the old fashioned way no less! Add in a few whiskey sours made with canada's finest import and a night of ethanol burning, tire smoking dragstrip fun what could be better?

by jackofalltech

Thanks for calling it the scam it is. For those of you who still don't get it, surf on over to http://www.andrebernier.com/
Andre is a certified Meterologist who gives us the real science that debunks the myth of global warming.

I wish I could find the original article (I think it was in Popular Science) that showed a new "oil well" site in Alaska. They flew everthing in, built most of the site underground and the place looks better than before they got there. The slight heat dissipation around the building actually provides year-round forage for the wildlife.
We need to open up more sites for oil wells and give the virtual finger to OPEC.

by Member 25348569

Or you could, and maybe I'm being provocative here, just use less oil. Smaller, more efficient cars?

All of the efficiency improvements in petrol engine manufacture in the US over the past thirty years have been matched by an increase in average engine size. All that gets you in your SUVs and trucks and lumbering great cars is the ability to spin your wheels at the lights.

As for your "certified meteorologist", he STILL doesn't answer the following question:

Given that the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has risen by 30% in the last 100 years and that carbon dioxide absorbs infra-red, where has that heat gone?

Neil :)

Anyway, dig up Alaska if you want. Waste the oil like you are doing at the moment and you've done for the last hundred years but don't start crying when you've not got any left at all.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Sacrilege! Heretic!

You might as well suggest 'be less wasteful' or 'be less extravagant' or 'be less invasive' or 'be less abrasive' or 'be less arrogant'.

What are you thinking? ;)

edit the usual

by jdclyde

like you do, we wouldn't NEED as big of vehicles to take so much with us.

And of course, public transit is not an option unless you live in a city like NY or chigago.

by jackofalltech

You can't blame any administration, let alone the current one, for pork barrel policies enacted by Congress.

by mallardtooxx

The President does not enact the 100mil save the spotted prairie spider bill. The president does not enact the 30mil research for a better tomorrow for the sea turtle bill. (both are made up as a point) He signs treaties and provides for the common defense. ANY President. If we are going to run in circles and blame the president of the day then we are doing exactly what congress wants us to do. Remember the President gets 2 terms tops, how long have Arlen specter and Ted Kennedy been in office? Even ole Hillary has been there for 8 years now. These are the people you should target your rage on not the president, because even if he is an Idiot he is not raising your taxes, nor is he spending your money on pork. I say give the congress back to the people, limit terms and cut spending and the country would snap back quicker than you can imagine. If you don't believe me look at our times of prosperity and compare the length of service of the average senator vs. now.

-duck

by Member 25348569

Leaving aside the "biggest scam ever perpetrated upon mankind" for the moment (I reckon both Christianity and Islam leaves it standing but that would be provocative and I don't do provocation as you well know), it is a bit stupid to burn food.

However, the process of biofuels is in its infancy and they have to start [b]somewhere[/b]. The efficiency of the processes will improve as the R&D money comes in and I would reckon that the feedstocks will change as different materials become viable. Once the enzymatic cracking of cellulose and lignin (wood) is perfected then just about any waste plant material is a viable ethanol source and simple economics will stop the use of foodstuffs.

Give it a chance!

Just my two gallons' worth. (UK gals cos they are bigger).

Neil :D

by Member 25348569

Maxwell usually rips me a spare. Be like old times if he spots this.

Less invasive would be good. Iraq was a mistake and Iran would be really, really bad. You can be as abrasive and arrogant as you want, you currently have the clout to back it up. Less wasteful and less extravagant would be good else you wont be able to be abrasive or arrogant.

Neil :)

Ah, well. Off to the w-word now. My train awaits...

by charliespencer

"Do you, personally, think that newer refineries should be built? And do you believe that those refineries, either new or existing, should refine oil obtained from American reserves or foreign ones?"

I personally think we'd have plenty of refinery capacity if people would stop driving any personal vehicles that get less than 30 miles per gallon. This would reduce the demand and make the second question about additional sources irrelevant.

I don't want to hear about the high cost of gas from anyone willingly operating a vehicle that gets 16 mpg. Shut your damn pie holes; you knew it was a gas hog when you bought it.

I don't wan to hear about the record profits the oil companies are making. Companies are in business to make money; why should they oil companies be treated any differently? No, they shouldn't get additional tax breaks, but you don't see Kellogg's being dragged before Congress regarding the cost of breakfast cereal.

The price of gasoline is strictly a supply and demand equation. If the demand goes down, so will the price. Econ 101.

by jdclyde

I have two cars, one gets 28 and the other 35. $3.55 for gas yesterday.

Question, if it really is supply/demand. Has the demand really increased by 300% in the last five years? No, it hasn't.

Has the price of gas gone up in the rest of the world by 300%?

If it hasn't, then we should have an answer why.

by charliespencer

I'm not sure where you get 300% increase in demand, but the Chinese and Indians are consuming far more than they did a decade ago. 300%? I don't know and am not motivated enough to research it. We're competing in a global supply market with countries with expanding economies. Part of the increase in the cost of oil is global uncertainty about the reliability of the supply due to questionable political stability in the Middle East, in part due to our unwarranted Iraqi adventure.

But it doesn't matter what the demand has done. If the oil companies what to increase their prices 300%, what's the problem? The answer as to "Why?" is because it's their job to make money. Buy some oil company stock and you'll get some of those profits. Geez, milk has gone up more than gas but nobody's lynching dairy farmers.

As to what the rest of the world pays, I do know we have it cheap compared to most Europe. I made a trip to Italy last fall. After I did the Euro-Dollar and liter-gallon conversions, they were paying around $4.75 a gallon. Most of that's taxes, as opposed to supplier profits, but US prices are still less. Would you rather the government get it or a private company? Your call.

Ethanol from a non-food source would be even cheaper. Instead of building more oil refineries, we should be emulating the Brazilians. Instead of screaming about the oil companies, we should be screaming at Congress to quit knuckling under to the oil and auto industries and push legislation to subsidize the conversion. This could be funded by requiring the oil companies to use their tax breaks to make the conversion, and by using the billions we're blowing in Iraq. If we don't need Middle East oil we no longer have a political interest in that part of the world.

by the scummy one

I know it seems to all fit in your mind like this, however, not everyone has the same needs for driving.
I cannot get another car at this time, so I am stuck with 1 vehicle. Just to satisfy you, I should haul dirt/compost/sand/other and rock in the trunk of a fuel efficient car and make several more trips for the same amount of load capacity?
yes, it is true that the majority of my driving is commuting, however I am not about to rent a vehicle every few weeks either.
Not only that, not everyone can just run out and buy a new car because some think that everyone needs to be more fuel efficient. There is no 1 size fits all for driving, just look at the diversity in vehicles. are they getting more or less diverse?
As for driving it, I try to limit my driving, however sometimes that cannot be done. But, do you really think that if everyone had the means to go get a hybrid car, that prices would go down much?

by jdclyde

If not measured in similar ways, under similar conditions, there can be no comparison of the two.

by maecuff

Our smoke detectors are hard wired, so when they go off, you can't just knock out the batteries. We open the windows and the doors and stick our fingers in our ears until it stops. I live in a condo, I think the neighbors are used to it now.

We had two firetrucks outside of our building last night. And they weren't there for me. My husband and I were laying in bed, watching out the window. He said the neighbors probably thought that they were there for us. I told him that just because I set the smoke alarm off from time to time doesn't mean I set things on fire. And then he reminded me of the two (or maybe three) times that I've set the stove on fire.

They were just little fires.

by mallardtooxx

If the house is not burning down then you know, it is more like readiness training. "Honey get the fire extingusher I'm going in!" I mean how else can you teach your kids (or your hubby)to understand self reliance? I am SURE it will only take one more house before they get it! In my case maybe two =)

-duck

by maecuff

I understand. And it's not crazy at all. It's just good planning.

Now, when it comes to sharp knives, I've had to learn to limit my contact. After a couple trips for stitches, it's apparent that I can't be trusted with sharp things.

I even (recently) jabbed a pair of sharp tweezers into my finger while plucking my eyebrows. My husband is threatening to find me clothes made out of bubble wrap for my own protection.

Although, if he thinks about it, would that be safe? As far as the fire thing goes, I would think that melted plastic would be painful. Perhaps we should look into asbestos attire?

by the scummy one

I thought that I knew more about Mycorrhiza than I actually do. When I was reading about it (and I bought some to experiment with) I was under the impression that these spores were deeper underground, not closer to the surface. I wouldnt have expected regular tilling to destroy them much.

However, from what I thought I knew, they become inactive when dry and/or subjected to light. Then when wet and dark they become active again. I have used these spores on Palm seedlings in the past to test the difference in growth in potted palm plants.

Your second link is very interesting. Thank You, tis now bookmarked for future reading. I only glanced at a few items there, but it seems to have some good info.
:)

by Member 25348569

I lost a steak bet with Maxwell a couple of years ago. It was over just how much driving you guys did on your open roads and your vast distances and your cheap gas compared with us guys in our pokey little overpriced country. You - on a per person basis - don't drive that many more miles than we do.

Now, as for big vehicles, I've driven in the States quite a lot over the last few years and I have to say that [b]some[/b] of your cars are the most wallowing, heavy over-powered pieces of crap that are only stopped from being almost useless by the fact that you don't have any bends!

As for some of the bloody silly trucks of which there are SO many more than a few years ago (can someone say 'stupid tax system'), I rarely ever remember seeing more than one person in them or seeing anything in the back! I must admit that I was looking out for this in my last Florida trip so that I could rub someone's nose in it if we had a discussion like this. ]:)

Neil :)

by jdclyde

Always have been.

I miss my pickups, but had to get rid of the last one because I couldn't afford the gas with the number of miles I put on a week. [i] (short week is 700 miles) [/i]

that is why I have my piece of crap saturn. gets good mileage, but let me tell you, it is the last time I buy a saturn.

by the scummy one

"and I won't use your email address to sign up for a free laptop or anything." -- thats not what peer mail is for? :0

:^0

by maxwell edison

When you say that you use 85 percent US products, and 15 percent imported scum bag products, I assume you mean 85 percent ethanol and 15 percent oil. I further assume that you put all oil into the scum bag categoty.

Nonetheless, it takes 85 percent of that scum-bag energy (oil) to produce your 85 percent ethanol use. Therefore, it's a zero-sum situation. You still use it, but are a few steps removed.

by danlm

I thought most electricity in the US was generated from Coal? That is US bred and born.

Again I am using US products and helping pay US salaries. How many electrical plants use Oil Max? Hell, how much electricity is Hydropower. I'm sorry, but its so easy to come up with different energy sources from the farm to the actual plants that will not rely on imported energy. Again, domestic supply.

Max, there are so many ways that ethanol is more us bread then oil. From the energy used to produce it to to the actual product itself.

Again, I am using much more good old US home grown/mined products then any scum bag nations. And oil is not scum, just who we get it from.... Other then Canada and Mexico.

Dan

by $$$$$$$$$$

"Nonetheless, it takes 85 percent of that scum-bag energy (oil) to produce your 85 percent ethanol use. Therefore, it's a zero-sum situation. You still use it, but are a few steps removed."

Of all people, maxwell, I can't believe that [b]you[/b] would miss the fact that DanLM's activities have the effect of sending "demand" signals to the market!

by jdclyde

I am fairly certain that I am not paying over 3 times as much for milk as I was before this mess started. (that is 300%, by the way)

While I cring to hear that b1tch Hilary talk about "taking their winfall profits", it still looks like price fixing to me if the global price has not gone up at an equal rate. price fixing is still illegal.