Question Locked

I'm in the market for a laptop.

0 helpful
55 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

One of my primary wants is a heavy duty keyboard. I've used HP and Acer and am happy with both in relation to keyboard. I have lead fingers and both hold up well to them.

Gateway has a crap keyboard - it gives when I type.

I'd like to know what the other options re: keyboards are. How are those Dell, Lenovo, and whoever else keyboards?

Other experiences welcome. Tales and testaments, please.

Thanks! :D

55 replies

by oh smeg

But since Lenovo has taken over selling Think Pads the quality of the Keyboard isn't as good as it was previously.

I sell a lot of Clevo and MSI NB's both of which seem to work exceptionally well and I have yet to have a failed keyboard on any of them that I've sold. I personally like my Clevo over all other NB's on the market and I didn't get a Bottom of the range one but the Keyboards are all the same across the range.

http://www.clevo.com.tw/en/products/index.asp

The MSI units have a full Keyboard with a separate Number Pad just like a real Keyboard many end users find these better than the normal NB Keyboard as they like the Number Pad.

http://www.msicomputer.com/NB/index.asp

Besides some MSI come in a Red color so they are faster. :D

It may pay to add these to your List of To Look at.

Col

[i]Edited to add a Full Stop or as the Yanks say a [b]Period.[/b][/i] :D

by ---tk---

I thinks its all a matter of opinion, Both lappy's above are sweet. Peconet Tietokoneet's choice is VERY nice! but for me at work I use a Dell D630, its light, can take a beating, easy to take apart, reliable, and quick. I even run A couple VMWare machines and they run just fine.

If I were to purchase a personal laptop I would purchase the Dell D630... but one thing to consider its not meant to game on. http://www.dell.com/content/products
/productdetails.aspx/latit_atg_d630?
c=us&l=en&s=bsd&cs=04

by boxfiddler Hot topic

are Dell notebook keyboards?
Thanks.

by ---tk---

From all the Laptops that I have worked on Dells are better... Toshiba's are right up there, but they usually have a non-standard keyboard, like on the M2, and M3's (Toshiba) the WIN key is on the upper right, and some of the other keys are rearranged... which I didn't like, but their keyboards are nice... Both Dell and Toshiba's use supports under the keyboard, which will give it that sturdy feel. HP's often times will not make the support under the keyboard, which makes them flex a little.

Also Dell often will install with alot of generic drivers, V.S. Toshiba you have to get their drivers. By the time you are done with Toshiba you will have 50-60 processes running in the background Idle.... Dell you can get away with 30-35 Idle....

I have scene more HP keyboards break than Dell and Toshiba combined.. from there its a toss up... both are good...

by jdclyde

Other than keyboard, what are you going to use this for?

Mostly running MS Office and web browsing, right?

Does size matter? Some say it doesn't, others disagree.... ;\

Will you need a docking station?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Will be used primarily for work. I've been asked to teach Windows classes (Vista Business) and I need a Vista machine at home. I really don't want to build one, or have another tower taking up desk space.

I'll be grading homework, chatting with and emailing students, maybe some browsing and personal use.

Don't need a docking station. It will travel with me sometimes, and so it will need to utilize dialup.

I do prefer AMD over Intel. And I'd frankly like a more configurable BIOS than my current Acer has. I've had to resort to wireless mouse because it won't accept my Intellimouse software and there is no way in the BIOS to disable the touchpad when a mouse is detected.
Oh, and a button to disable the touchpad at the touchpad would be cool. My HP has that, my Acer doesn't.
I'd like a full keyboard with number pad. And one that does not 'give' when I type. I totally hate that.
Also, I hate those glassy monitor screens. A standard anti-glare screen would be too very cool.

Enough extra info I hope?

Thanks all! :)

by oh smeg

But the Touchpad Lock is a Software Lock not a Hardware Lock. Look at the MSI Mega Books Series of computers.

http://www.msimobile.com/nblist.aspx?screen=17.0

But I'll be quite honest the Centrino NB's work better, last longer on the battery and are just generally a better buy but if you want an AMD CPU they have that option and more of them than Intel. They also have a Bare bones NB System as well if you want to play but you can look for that one yourself.

While I personally don't use the AMD units I understand that they are quite good and fully featured. One of the Game Mags here ratted the Intel Mega Book the Best Buy for Gaming in a NB available. Though even they admitted it was Overkill for a NB and at under 2K Au it was a bargain.

But I'm sure others may be more to your liking if you want a Name Brand.

Just a word of warning avoid the Toshiba's and Sony's like the plague the Toshiba's do funny things ands set a BIOS Password without any help. Toshiba naturally doesn't want anyone but them to be able to clear the BIOS so when this happens you have to return it to Toshiba for services and they are not overly quick here at least. The Sony's just do not work at all well and have their own problems that you should avoid at all costs.

Col

by boxfiddler Hot topic

How easy is it to upgrade from Vista Home to Vista Business? I couldn't do that via the website.
Thanks.

by gadgetgirl

I've had a quick shufty but can't find the thread... but Tig had a similar question before she got her new Mac laptop. There were a lot of good points made on that thread (aarrgh! I wish I could find it, but I've run out of time!) If you do a search you may be able to get it, but if not, I'd bet my bottom dollar Tig has that saved somewhere!

BTW - Stay awaaaaaaaaaaaay from Sony! that's in the thread, too! If it's any help, jd, DMambo and I all posted in that thread as well as Tigs.

oh - and don't go for the Acer Gemstone range - the one I got for Ma - it's got a supersensitive keyboard, and the glass screen is quite glaring if you catch the sun in the wrong direction..... :(

HTH!

GG

by boxfiddler Hot topic

wanting to try a new brand. Thanks for the heads up.

by gadgetgirl

it wasn't Tigs who posted that question, it was Shellbot....

I'll have another look, now that the memory has re-booted....!

Sorry, my bad... in defence: brain hasn't had to work for three days so got outta the habit... :p

GG

by captbilly1eye

...based on my experience with Insurance Adjusters.
I worked with hundreds that used laptops while on the road. They were extremely brutal on their equipment and were known for dropping them, spilling things on them and generally treating them like a door stop.
The machines that seemed to stand up to all their abuse were the Panasonic Toughbooks.
http://tinyurl.com/3p6xqt

Personally, I've had excellent experiences using HP\Compaq and IBM PC laptops over the years. Of course, if it's warranty coverage that is a hot button, it's still pretty hard to beat Dell.

Once you've narrowed down the field, be sure to check out the reviews available through CNet.com and ZDNet.com.
Good Luck.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Will cruise Panasonic. Cursory glance looks interesting.
Looking for 17" display and full keyboard with number pad. Display size is key with all the hours at homework I'll be spending.

by cg it

drop em, kick em, in foul weather, they will work. they will however die if you drop em from a roof, or try underwater computing.

by cg it

the latitude keyboards stand up to some abuse but like most keyboards, they will die if you beat on em...

by oh smeg

Like everything related to a Toughbook they are solid and liquid proof though I don't think that will be an issue for you.

These things are designed to live a very hard life and they are nearly as good as the Ruggerized Think Pads that IBM used to sell. If that is of any help.

Col

by oh smeg

All you have to do is enter a different Product Key to get the different versions of Vista. I believe that M$ will even sell you a Product Key very cheaply as well. :p

But seriously you would have to go to a Wholesale or Retail Outlet for an answer to that. As I buy from a M$ Reseller it's not a problem and I'm sure that your Country's or State Supplier will have a deal with M$ on Upgrading from the Base Models or even be on selling a Bare Bones System that they build to suit the market in your area.

I've just sold 50 odd EX 600 the Burgundy ones with XP Pro loaded and that's how I bought them. I couldn't resist them as they are [b]Red[/b] and go faster. :D

But seriously with Anti Glare TFT Monitors and a small size they where ideal for the need where they went. Only complaint that I've heard so far is that they do things too quickly so the staff have to work harder. Naturally it's the staff who are complaining. These come with their own Color Coded Mouse with a short USB lead so they are ideal for those on the go and who don't want the bigger NB's. These 15 Inch weigh about the same as the 17 inch units but are far less bulky and there is nothing to buy out of the box they have everything that you need you only have to make sure that the battery is fully charged and load any Specialized Software Required and then throw everything into the supplied NB Bag and the customer is Up & Running.

This place had 2 MSI NB's both of the Owners got them and now that is all that they'll have in the place apparently they consider them as Ruggerzied NB and treat them as such. One has been there for 2 years now and the other just on a year, The only problems that I've had is one managed to Ghost a Blank External Drive to the NB and it needed to be reimaged and the other one managed to break off the DVD Burners drawer with a very heavy Coffee Cup I think. Neither where related to any problems with the NB's but I do sell every NB with a Cool Pad they last much longer & I will not sell a NB without one. I use the Antec's Black ones personally as they are nice light and not at all bulky

http://www.antec.com/us/productDetails.php?ProdID=75004

They just work and stop dust getting sucked into the NB. As these guys sell Heavy Earthmoving Equipment they are not at all gentle with things and if they can't break then I doubt that anyone will.

I've been selling these for about 4 years now without a problem and these where the first that I put into a place like this that where not something like the Toughbooks. I figured at the price they could destroy 2 over the 4 years that they would be getting used and still come out on top compared to one of the Ruggerized NB's that they used to use. In an office Environment they are unbeatable and just the best that I can find with the exception of the Clevo's which are for a different market.

Col

by captbilly1eye

... if you back your car over one.

I knew of two different adjusters that did that.
:)

I used to laugh when one would call in to complain that their laptop would no longer work after they "just used it for a while in the rain."

by oh smeg

So I have to ask what you where doing on a Roof with a Toughbook or what you where doing underwater with one? :D

Though to be fair I saw one that had been dropped overboard after it was retrieved but it only went in about 8 feet of water which was admittedly Salt Water but it wasn't turned on at the time the Person just dropped it as they where getting into the boat.

But I'm still at a loss to know why it was required in a 25 Foot Cabin Cruiser going out fishing. Naturally I just hosed it off with fresh Town water and left it in the sun to dry for the day while they went out fishing It worked perfectly OK when the returned that night and didn't have the Salt Residue on it. :D

But they certainly don't like being left on a Excavator Track while the Tech is doing a diagnostic and the excavator takes off. They do look quite nice once they have had a 40 Ton Excavators track sitting on one though while it's opened. A very modern Art type look with those lines of deep groves all over the thing. I wouldn't even try to pick one up after that I just used a shovel to move it to the rubbish bin. :^0

Col

by cg it

used to be the army had a couple of pickup trucks with the tech manuals on board. They following the tanks around so if one broke down they could fix em [remember this as I was working for a defense contractor that bid on the contract to supply laptops for maintenance manuals. Army though it a good idea but they figured out that to put all the data into the laptop would cost more than having a couple of pickups following the tanks around. This was before OCR scanners actually worked well. ]

Anyway, the military's need for a toughbook took off after OCR scanning became good enough. The toughbook is designed to some of the military's specs. Water, shock, resistant and figuring that army grunts will abuse the laptop, like leaving it on tank tracks or having hands covered in oil and typing on the keyboard, they stand up to some pretty abusive use.

As to being on a roof with a toughbook and ooops would you look at that, it fell... well fixing crap on the roof needs tech manuals and the toughbook had it.

underwater computing... hey well you need a laptop loaded with pics of all the fish species you'll see. Who can remember em all? :)

by oh smeg

On the deck of an Aircraft Carrier the Flight Guys where plugging into the Aircraft running the Diagnostics on one side of the aircraft then Clamming the NB dropping it to the deck and kicking it under the aircraft so that the guy the other side could pick it up and plug in that side to do the finial checks.

I don't think many footballs would have lasted long being treated like that but the NB's that IBM supplied seemed to take the punishment quite happily. Not sure that all of the Salt Spray that they where subject to finally did to them but they seemed to work well enough for the Flight Line guys to use.

After seeing how the Air force Aircraft Mechanics here treat their hand tools I wouldn't allow any of them near a Computer of any type let alone a NB. Knowing how they work they would probably throw a NB into a running Jet Engine to see if it broke the engine. :D

Col

by older mycroft

[i]"..they are nearly as good as the Ruggerized Think Pads that IBM used to sell.."[/i] ;)

by cg it

The engine was running so instead of risking getting sucked into the engine they kicked the laptop back and forth. Hilarious but a very good commercial for NBs .

Like John Cameron Swaze says about Timex watches...takes a licking and keeps on ticking. Now if they strap one onto an outboard and do a few laps and it still works, who wouldn't want that laptop?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

After a long and disgusting search, I found a local business supplier that found me what I want. Paid for the dang thing today, pick it up Tuesday. They had to special order it from HP, the only vendor they deal with that would build one. Geez. Cost me out the wazoo, too. WTF is wrong with manufacturers that they think that freaking glossy screen is useful?
Thanks everyone for your input. And Col, thanks for your help, too! You were a sweetie!
(Don't tell HAL I said so.)

by oh smeg

[b]SWMBO[/b] in bubble wrap along with a MSI NB and posted it off by surface mail yesterday. :(

When it arrives it might smell a bit bad but you can unpack the NB and just plug it in and go it has a Dual Voltage Mains Adapter.

Pity that [b]SWMBO[/b] didn't want to get packed up so I had to hit her with an Electric Cattle Prod repeatably till she passed out. After wrapping in Bubble wrap she went all limp and was hard to take to the Post Office. :0

Col

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Too funny. Have a thumb for the laugh! :D

by captbilly1eye

...Your wazoo?

That must be painful!
I would NEVER do that!

Ow Ow OW!

anyway... glad to hear you finally found what you were looking for. Have fun.

Just remember... we're always here when it starts acting up.
;-)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

once I dumped Me for W2k on my last HP laptop, I never had any problems. I'm still using that one to fiddle with Linux, even.
So, even though it cost too much, if it lasts like my first one, it will be worth it.

I do know where to come for help, though! :D

by cg it

and they transfer you to India...and I have a picture of the India help lines....

Photobucket

by oh smeg

You know as well as I do CG IT that that photo of the Indian Help Lines was taken after the Bomb Blast. That is the new Help Line into the Indian Support Center for HP.

It's only been there for 3 weeks the old Lines into the building where far more messy. :p

OH here is M$ support service so Boxy should know exactly what to expect when she rings them. :0

Photobucket

And this is the support Service who deals with requests like this. They use the newest HP Products to answer your every need. :^0

Photobucket

Col

by cg it

gotta love it... HP send their support to India, all the others followed suit... now, they have premium service you pay a premium price to talk to someone in America....

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Picked up the new laptop today. It has a 160G hard drive. The recovery partition, the OS itself, and the HP bloatware consume 35G.

Um. That's a freaking lot of space. I have to say I was surprised as he// by that.
Cleanup coming on. And as soon as I have the moolah for an actual Vista OS disk, I'm hunting down the drivers, and wiping this thing to start again. Good grief.

Sweet little machine so far, outside of that.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

it came with recovery discs. For both XP, and Vista. Were it not for needing Vista for work, I'd dump it for XP.

What a nightmare that has been to fiddle in this evening. Good god.

I bookmarked a few sites that provide a variety of lists - what can I shut down via msconfig, and where the he// to find the things that have been moved. I'm going to have to use them, now.
Been tweaking with no prob until Vista. Uncle Billy is a butthead. :D

by jay217

yeah get it here http://www.pcdecrapifier.com/ it should take care of most of the extra junk HP puts on there. Since HP doesnt ship CDs, make sure you have one before you wipe the thing.

Also check your key, if you got the Win xp downgrade from HP you may already have gotten a vista License, I know that's how dell is shipping them now.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

the thing myself. But thanks. Did come with discs.

by oh smeg

Vista comes on a DVD not several CD's so that's 4.7 GIG before you actually install the OS. Easily double that amount of space for the installed OS and that is 14.1 GIG before you add any Applications so 35 GIG isn't unreasonable for the Recovery Partition, the Installed OS and software as well as the lost space due to formatting a HDD into several different partitions.

It after all only leaves 21 GIG for the Applications installed and to actually load them from the Recovery Partition. The greatest part of the mess is related to Vista. And you already knew that it is big consumes masses of System Resources so what are you complaining about?

As for wiping and reloading without a Recovery Partition all I can say is

[b]Sorry Davette I can not allow you to do that.[/b] After all you need the recovery partition so you can press the wrong keys and blow away all your Data don't you?

Boxy dump the Trial Version of 2007 Orifice as it's next to useless. You don't want it anyway as way too many people fail to remember to change the Native Format that it saves documents in so that they are readable by everyone. OO 3 is much more reliable honestly. :p

Col

by boxfiddler Hot topic

You cannot stop me. :D

No software but the bloatware that HP added. Special order unit. I'll add what I want.

I called 5 or 6 - don't remember anymore - small shops that cater to business. This particular shop was the only one willing to deal with me and attempt to find what I wanted. They got very, very close.
HP was the only manufacturer they deal with that was willing to provide a non-glare 17" inch screen. HP stays on my list of laptop folks I'm happy with.

The keyboard is firm. One of my primary reqs. I'm as happy as I can be, running Vista. Blech to Vista.

by oh smeg

In South Park when he was explaining just how much faster & Better Windows 98 was. :^0

Now if that happened in real life the person responsible at M$ firstly wouldn't ever consider taking the job in the first place and M$ would have a much better Funeral Plan after making sure that what they ship actually works. :p

Col

by rob miners

so now you can check the user manual to see if you will still need the recovery partition. If it's not required you can blow it away to give you a bit more space. You can also check to see if you can add another Hard Drive to the unit. If you can there will be lots of free space and you won't have to worry about space on the original Drive.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

just totally stunned at that 35G use with no other software installed.
What, Win2k wanted 4G? Two OS's later Windows is up to taking oh, say 14G? Boggling. Just boggling.

by rob miners

I am using 16GB. That includes Office 2003 and PSP9 which is all that I have installed so far. The joys of bloatware on modern propriatory PC's.

by oh smeg

I only have 1 TB of HDD Space on my new Desktop unit and the currently installed Software is taking up 121.7 GIG so I need to make room for all my Data. :p

As for HP being the only place that would sell to a Reseller something that is a common unit what can I say you get Pathetic Service in the US? That is just abysmal.

On the up side I've got a couple of customers waiting for the new Benq NB's when they come out in about 6 months time just the idea of 7 hours from a battery was enough to sell them on it. Now I wonder just how close to the listed Specs at the last trade show that I went to they will actually be.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.