Discussion Locked

Inflexible Contract Interfering with Career?

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I work for an upstart e-commerce business wearing a multitude of hats. Not only do I webmaster the site, and maintain the computer system, but I also have a knack for selling and supporting our products (I have a background in our products as well). My employer hired me on at a lower rate than what I initially would have accepted since we both understood the new online venture was unclear of how well it would do, and that we would renegotiate my salary at a later time if/when the site succeeded. Well, one year later, the site is doing quite well, and has been in the black for well over four months. My employer has now presented me with a ?Proprietary Information Agreement? which I view more like an employment contract. I?m fine with the Prop Info clauses with it, but the terms of a NCA clause are quite strict. It states that I cannot work for ANY e-commerce business for one year after the end of my employment! My attorney translated this as my career being crippled to the point that I couldn?t work for (or begin) an e-commerce business ANYWHERE in the US (since the internet is nationwide as the contract explains). To make matters worse, the amount offered in the raise is negligible? at best. To ice the cake, the contract has zero room for future negotiations once it is put into effect. I feel somewhat insulted at how what was a mutual ?back-scratching? work situation is apparently becoming a one-way street which I?m not much more than an undervalued/underpaid grunt tasked with filling the employer?s pockets, and to not (in their eyes) expect to pay my own bills with only this income.

With hindsight being 20-20, I understand that I made a major mistake taking a lower beginning rate, even with the good intentions of helping the business get off the ground. Understandably I have to deal with what I have sown now, but I?m unsure what to do next. Being tied to the geographic area I?m in now, and web mastering jobs not being in abundance here, I?m afraid that I could be severely crippling my IT career in the future just to keep my job now. If anyone has experience with this situation, or even an idea of how to counter-offer the contract without risking my job, I would greatly appreciate the advice. Thank you for any input at all.

23 replies

by tony hopkinson

Tell them the contract proposal is unacceptable, start looking for another job, ball is in there court.

You could say you made a mistake but it wasn't taking the initial low offer, it was trusting these buggers to keep their word.

Personally I'd cut my losses and get right out of there, no point in dealing with people with no ethics unless you want spend the rest of your time there guarding your back, which is what the good guys get shot in.

by rush2112

otherwise no non-compete will apply to YOU since you already had accepted a sub-standard contract rate which they are now attempting to make permanent.

This will put you looking for new work. You may lose your position, you may not, they may agree to your terms.
You never know till you ask.

by firstpeter

I'm not sure I would say it was a mistake to have taken the lower rate initially - you have a "clean slate" now where your past salary shouldn't matter.

Assuming your employer is "negotiating" I would say you should probably express your concern that you've done x, y, and z and expect the appropriate concessions ($$$, leniency in the contract, etc. - outline them).

I think you're right that you're risking your future IT career for something that may not be worth it - sometimes you just have to take that hard line or you end up get bullied.

by dc guy

Judiciaries in many states (typically the "Blue" ones like California) spit on such preposterous language. No company HQ'ed in those states could even get such a clause approved by their corporate attorneys. Unfortunately both you and your company clearly are based elsewhere. You could relocate to one of the safe states and get work there if work were available. But that is bviously not the best situation to be in.

I join the chorus: Don't sign the frelling thing under any circumstances. Try to negotiate, or simply stay and work under the terms of your existing contract.

I don't have much confidence in the job market so I personally wouldn't advise you to do something rash like walk out. Never burn a bridge, it's a small world and you don't know when and where you might meet these guys again. Find another job FIRST. Even if they're pushing you to sign, you should be able to stall these jerks long enough to do that. And if they're that eager for you to sign it means you have some bargaining leverage.

by systemsgod

with all the other posts. It definately sounds like your employer is lacking in the ethics department. I wouldnt trust them at all after what they have done, and neither should you. The warning signs are flashing big time.

Even if you manage to renegotiate the noncompete agreement out of the contract, that wont stop them from trying it again down the road, or, from going back on their word...again.

I would definately get out of there as fast as I could, so get that resume polished up. Once you get another job leave and dont look back. Just watch your back in the meantime.

by solonow

I understand your postion...but I will not sign that paper or they have to take out the part that says " you can not work for any e-business comapny"...Like the others side ..polish your resume, see what is out there for you and start applying. I do not see any future for you in this company. There is an old saying my country..if you do not roll, you will burn. It is time to roll...!!!

by royhayward

If you have any kind of relationship with them, you may want to have a sit down and talk. I have never tried to negotiate or counteroffer a raise, but if they don't have you under a non-compete now, but want you to sign, then you may be able to use that a lever to open negotiations. It sounds like they have offered you the nominal raise and requested the non-compete together, even if you have not, you might be able to turn them down together.

If you don't have a relationship where you can have a sit down with your boss. This may be your opportunity to build one.

It may sound crazy, but I had a friend turn down a raise once. The company in question where we worked was having some labor relations issue, and they chose to promote a few of us to try to get us to help handle the mis-managment.

The next year they offered him a very small raise, but the rest of the techs were getting next to nothing. He looked at that, and then turned his raise down. They didn't quite know what to make of it. He still works there and this was one of the things that made them start to talk to us about decisions before making them.

It also sounds like you are not in doubt about your value to the company. They may not see the value at this time, but how replaceable are you to them? I an not advocating trying to play hardball with them, just that you consider your contributions as an employee while you consider your options.

You are not really putting your job at risk, that has already happened. If you previously made a decision that you now regret, this is a chance to try and correct that.

by rayjeff

I have a similar situation in December coming up. As it stands, with my current contact will revert back to the contract I was originally hired on. The bad thing is that I cannot negoiate with my boss. My contract and all inqueries on/about it go beyond here. The administration...THE ADMINISTRATION deals with that. The relationship I have with them is non-existant. I've had several grievances with them that they have overlooked, much less had a former meeting about them. So, as it stands I don't trust them.

But the thing about it is that I am like the original poster. I wear several hats. I became a project manager on a big project that's been going on (the reason for the temporary raise in work hours and pay). Because of the type of project it is, it;'s not a one time project. It's ongoing for the life of my workplace. So, all of the work I've done will never be done. So, they want to pay me less for the contiuned work I would be doing. Do I have any type of room to negoiate? I know that I do because of my unqiue skills and what I've already done, they won't be able to easily replace me because I am so interconnected into different areas. If I leave, the roof will fall.

by wayne m.

Rather than speculating on the "meaning" of the non-compete agreement, talk to your boss about what the company actually wants.

Though I am too far removed to know, I suspect that your company may have merely got a canned agreement from a book, web-site, or lawyer at an hourly rate. Remember, at a small company, time is always at a premium. The agreement may have been drafted in haste without due thought to the details of the contents.

Talk to your boss regarding the areas of concern in the non-compete agreement. If you can bring in alternate wording (hand-written on a copy of the document), it makes it easier for those higher up the chain to approve more favorable wording.

The company may choose not to budge and you may then want to seek new employment, but at least you will be better informed and can leave knowing you made your best effort to find a solution.

by !--!

Don't bother wasting your time talking to your boss. They will tell you WHATEVER you want to hear. Maybe they'll do it out of ignorance, maybe they'll do it knowing full well that a written, signed legal agreement trumps (and nullifies) a verbal agreement.

I learned this when my previous employer presented me with an employment agreement stating that I was authorizing them to take out a $1 MILLLION dollar life insurance policy on me. Can you believe it?!?! It's not like I was a CEO or anything.... I was a "lowly" contract web developer, one it turns out they didn't respect and undervalued (The company management, my supervisors, and coworkers were all middle eastern men who felt it was perfectly acceptable to assign female employees, like me, menial tasks below my skill level... what they construed as "womens' work"... but that's another issue).

When I spoke to my boss about about this taking a policy out on my life clause, he gave the "This is a standard employment contract! *insert incredulous look here* Everyone ELSE signed it!" speech, and tried to bully me into signing it. I refused to sign right then and there, and I told them that first, I'd like the opportunity to consult my attorney to get a legal system perspective on the terms. And wouldn't you know.... the very next day, my boss comes back to me with a new contract, without the life insurance policy clause, demanding that I return or destroy all copies of the previous contract they had presented me with.

While your contract issue wouldn't make you worth more to your employer dead than alive, it still addresses the matter of how much you are worth. It doesn't matter how nice an individual person in a company seems... the bottom line is that a company, as an entity, will look out of it's best interests to increase it's worth, no matter who they need to cheat, beat or step on. If I were you, I'd refuse to sign that agreement, and ask for one with terms that protect your career and would compensate you for what you're worth.

Your employer certainly won't look out for your best interests, and if they found the opportunity to replace you with a grunt worker who'd work for less, they surely wouldn't hesitate to give you the boot. "It's just business, my friend...". They wouldn't care if you'd be unable to work for a year, anywhere, because of their restrictive terms, nor would they care that you could lose your house, your car, everything. Look out for yourself. Refuse that contract!

by macghee

I hope that you kept a copy of everything given to you while you were there, whether they demanded you return all of it or not.

by marionuke

Get out of there as fast as you can your right that contracts clauses could come back to ruin you if he doesn't agree to give you propper pay and you have to leave or he fires you and your under that contract it could realy hurt you you could possibly loose everything not being able to work for 1 year

by matthew moran

A non-compete that does not include dramatic compensation and that is overreaching in scope is non-binding. It won't hold up in court.

I don't know what it says and your attorney should recognize this. For instance, if I have a consulting company and I hire a tech, I can't have them sign an agreement that says they cannot start a consulting company or consult for any company.

However, I can stipulate that they not go to work for a competitor and pursue the accounts or direct markets that I am going after or that they have special knowledge because of their employment with me.

For a non-compete to have legal teeth - I must be able to show that working for my company provided my employee with inside information and that their departure and entrance into a particular market would/could damage my business.

Also, they are typically provided to higher-level executives and have some type of compensation tied to the non-compete.

However, I would first approach your employer. If you are valuable to them - as you indicate - I would simply have an open discussion about your concerns. Indicate that you enjoy being a part of their growth and are loyal but also feel that financial and profit sharing/sweat equity should be part of the compensation package.

If you are unable to have that type of discussion, I would look into other opportunities.

by datahook

Put it in a nice email or letter to the owner/boss, then wait, and get your resume polished.

by boston

First of all, do not sign anything. Sit down and talk to your boss. Discuss with him all of the "hats" you have worn for the past year and what a great job you have done. Make sure you can back all of this up with examples. Remind your boss of the deal you and he initially entered into. If he can not come up with a substanial raise that would make the difference for you to sign the contract just look else where. You obviously have gained a tremendous amount of experience over the past year. Use this experience to find a better position with a company that will appreciate your abilities. Good Luck!

by diana o

As someone who has worked as a contractor in IT off and on for over 20 years, I've heard this too: that extreme non-competes are not enforceable in court.

Let me tell you what my attorney told me about 6 months ago: "In today's political climate, courts are not finding for the employee, but are finding for the employer. Do not plan on prevailing in court, even if you signed an agreement that will prevent you from making a living--business holds all the cards now, with the current administration."

My advice: Get thee to an attorney, now!

Even $150 is worth spending if it saves your career. Plus, the attorney can modify the agreement in a way that is more friendly to you, and you can try to get the employer to take it *with* the changes. Give it a try. It's worked for me before.

And IMHO, second piece of advice: Vote for someone in the next election who gives employee rights as much weight as rights of a business.

-- End of Soapbox -- :-)

by jck

If you have an attorney, you've made a first good step. I've known people in many job situations (tech, television and radio broadcasting, etc.) who have agreed to these deals and gotten the shaft.

The advice I can give:

a) The one above was right: talk to you boss about the terms. Get a feel for how flexible he/she is. Explain how the non-competition agreement would cripple your career and force you into working at McDonalds or Wal-Mart for a year.

b) Ask about getting the term of the NCA either reduced or altered.

Just as an example for you:

I worked as a contractor doing software engineering at a power corporation under contract with a tech staffing firm. The terms of my contract (from the NCA aspect) were that if *I* left employment voluntarily, I could not go to work for that company or any of their sister companies or clients (other staff firms, subsidiaries, etc) for 90 days. If I was "let go", the contract relieved me of that obligation not to compete because the staffing firm was breaking the contract.

And, I was sort of like you in the fact that I developed the entirety of their work order system for switching and tagging of their power grid to do repair, maintenance and construction. I was the only fully-knowledgable person of the system. But when the project neared completion, the power corp decided to let the contract expire at the end of the year, but I left prior to that so I was held to 90 days.

But, try to work the terms out with your boss. One year is not a fair amount of time and would put almost anyone in financial distress considering the slow job market. And, you should not be held to those terms if the company were to let you go.

I would try to get those two issues modified in the agreement before I would even consider signing it.

Finally, start looking around at other jobs. If you're not under an NCA and NDA and PIA right now, you hold ALL the cards if you're the sole or primary developer of all their e-commerce systems. If they want to keep you, they will bargain. Otherwise, you can walk away with all that knowledge and leave them with trying to find someone to fill your shoes.

by plumley9

Some state have right to work laws and some don't. In either case enforcement of a Non compete clause or agreement is based on finacial depth for lawyers and will power to fight it out.
First you made it work and they owe you the prevailing top rate and a bonus for the growth, they would have to pay any salesman the same. Second, if they want exclusivity they pay for it get the salary ranges of equivalent positions nationwide and ask for 10 per cent more. If they don't want to pay national scale wages they don't get nation wide NCA. Third, if your supervisor isn't on your side then walk away. Go to their biggest competitor and get a job. A one year NCA nationwide should include 50% salary for that year plus health coverage and other benefits while you find another job. NEVER accept a NDA or NCA that doesn't scare the management as much as it scares you.

by jhamilton

I see that others have offered opinions on possible legal issues. With all due respect, the law on non-compete agreements is so variable that you need to rely on your lawyer's advice on what is and isn't enforceable in your jurisdiction and what your chances of beating it are in the grey areas.

You'll need to rely on your own sense of your negotiating strength in your case in deciding how to respond. Are you better off walking today than staying subject to the terms of their NCA?

Some say everything is negotiable. That would include the length and scope of the NCA (What's unique about what you do for them that they don't want you to do for anyone else and can you limit it to that? Who is their competition and can you limit the non-compete to them or that industry?), what they pay for it, whether and what they'll pay on a monthly basis to keep you off the market after separation, etc. (I understand that one Fortune 500 company hedges its bets on NCAs by paying a full or partial salary during the non-compete period.

Best of luck.

by web_weaver

First off, I would like to thank everyone who has replied to this thread. I truly am amazed at how many others have had this same issue. I would like to let everyone know where this situation has gone.
I have consulted an attorney (amazing what favors you can call on when you fix his wife?s computer a few times) His first though on it was how ludicrous the NCA was. After a long discussion and a quick review of the comments everyone left (he was impressed with what my piers had to say), he recommended that I refuse it as well. I did refuse the contract the other day, but I?m happy to say that I haven?t burned any bridges down? yet. I sat down with my employer and began telling him why I exactly wanted to refuse it. Kudos to Athenagrrl for her *insert incredulous look here* comment when I mentioned how destructive the NCA was to my career, not to mention the surprise that I actually consulted an attorney. I was quite beside myself when this occurred, especially when he couldn?t figure out how one year was too long, or nationwide sanctioning was too much. But, to make the long story short, I made a proposal that we both agreed to. Since attorneys are expensive, and we both know that no little change would make me sign, or arbitration between the two attorneys was asinine, we?re arbitrating the contract ourselves. Before the ?get the attorney to do it so it?s right? comments begin to fly, my employer will pay to have the final draft approved by our attorneys. I?m not exactly sure where this will end up, but I really don?t care. Like jck said (and I am trying to be humble) I do hold all the cards. I am not under a contract or NCA with the company, and I did build our internal systems and the site (and carry a FULL backup of everything in my back pocket). I could have a fully functional competitive site began within two weeks. Sorry, I got off course there. My point is that I think I may win with the arbitration, but I can?t loose either. Thank you again to everyone. And thank you for the ideas of items to add to the new contract.

by jpaullanier

From what you describe it sounds to me like you now realize your present employer does not support your career advancement in the manner you want.

If you're underpaid for what you have achieved, I suggest you consider working for someone else. Your success at your initial career steps should translate to the next step - just not where you are now.

regards, Paul

by macghee

First, don't sign it as it is currently written. Base a counter-proposal with the salary figure a good bit higher than you know you'll get. Leave the no-compete completely out; don't agree to that under any circumstance. My father agreed to one of those many years ago and got burned rather badly. Better to walk than to sign that piece of trash. Gather up copies of whatever you'll need for your personal files, for building your resume and / or portfolio. I'm not talking stealing, but copies of what you've done so that you can accurately portray yourself in resume or portfolio format. If you put their web presence together, copies of the pages you created, if you designed their network, a copy of the network map and it's specifications that you were responsible for. Having these for reference material will make putting together your paperwork much easier. You won't have to rack your brain trying to remember details late at night.
I don't know what area you are in, but the advice given to get a new job is good. The guy that handed that piece of garbage to you proved that you cannot stay there. Start looking and Good Luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.