13 replies
In TechTarget's "SearchSecurity.com" site, contributer Pete Herzog discusses the "serious issue, that of who really is an information security professional, and who may simply be masquerading as one."
Pete says "On-the-job success still comes down to ability. Through the ages, being a professional has always been about applying what you know. Two-hundred years ago, a blacksmith with only the knowledge of all the smithy best practices couldn't get a job if he didn't have the actual ability to smith what needs to be "smithed.""Everything Pete says in his article is absolutely correct. Generic security qualifications across multiple "domains" in which the practitioner may never have actually practiced are really quite farcical. Good memory skills in an exam do not in themselves equate to wisely applied information security skills in the field!
The fact that an exam applicant may be required to have worked in the InfoSec field for a minimum of 4 years does nothing at all to prove that their experience was wide-ranging!
However, an important and interrelated matter, which Pete did not mention, is the problem of the high cost of professional certifications. I don't know if this is a significant problem for people in wealthy countries such as the US or the UK, but for most of the information security practitioners in the world, these costs certainly are.
A Viable Solution
I believe the solution - to both the problem of prohibitive cost and that of meaningless certifications, is to return to the idea of the blacksmith Pete mentioned. The blacksmith served an apprenticeship under the close supervision of an approved "master" in the trade.
InfoSec Apprenticeships
Modern InfoSec apprenticeships should incorporate regular theoretical learning, together with daily application and testing of the apprentice's knowledge in a real -world work environment. Having reached a reasonable degree of skill, a board of "masters" should examine them . If the board agree that the apprentice is worthy of certification, the certificate should specifically mention the InfoSec areas in which the person has experience.
A Certificate Providing Useful Information
An employer will know with a fair degree of certainty what a prospective employee is already capable of, and where they will require further training and/or experience. They can be assured that the "blacksmith" really does know more than the mere principles of the trade.
This is a solution which...
- Will work in any country - rich or poor
- Will not be expensive for the apprentice while training... in fact they should expect a living wage
- Will provide employers or clients of the InfoSec professional a very reliable benchmark of their skill set
What do you think about this concept?
Copyrights and Patents
While many of you
will have read the enthralling, disturbing, thought-provoking,
but fictional book "The Da Vinci Code"... and it certainly is of topical
interest ? my own interest in the [April] Associated Press article ?Judge to Rule on 'Da Vinci Code? is especially concerned with copyright, and the closely related the issue of patents.
Good authors do research
Many authors of
fiction do a great deal of research before publishing their book. It
gives a veneer of 'reality' which helps to make the book more
believable. People like "new" and "different" ? just as long as they
are not too different!
Is use of research material a breach of copyright?
If basing the
bare outline of a book on facts or concepts, originally revealed through
someone else's research, qualifies as infringement of copyright, then
this has far-reaching ramifications indeed.
Not only will it
be possible for huge numbers of fictional works to be challenged, but
also non-fiction books will have claims of copyright infringement made
against them. Non-fiction is probably far more frequently based on
research originally performed by others. Yet none of these are the most
frightening aspect of the matter.
Death of innovation
If the mere
inclusion of facts gleaned from another person's research can open one
up to the likelihood of litigation, people will cease to innovate as
freely as they previously would have done.
Innovation is typically incremental
Innovation is
actually seldom totally "new", but is typically an important
incremental advance, or a lateral offshoot from something else which
the innovator has observed. From an historical perspective, before
literacy became almost universal in Europe and the European colonies,
there was very little innovation.
Invented today - gone tomorrow
Much of that
innovation was discovered and then lost again, sometimes repeatedly,
throughout the ages. And this was during a time when there were not any
restrictions of copyright or patents! There were no limits to the
things you could try ? based on what you had seen, read or heard about.
Literacy - a key to growth
Literacy is
probably the single most important means to power that the world has
ever known. For well over 1,000 years Europe possessed widespread
literacy, but that literacy was jealously guarded by the Church and
limited almost exclusively to the religious orders. This hoarding of
knowledge held the world in an intellectual and economic stasis until
the close of the Middle Ages.
Today excessive
regulation and control over innovation ? through the means of
overly-restrictive copyright and patent law, threatens to hold the
"Western" world in a stasis which is effectively similar to that of the
"Dark Ages" in Europe.
Giving away the advantage
You may be sure
that "less-enlightened" countries, who do not feel bound by these
artificial restrictions, will have the wisdom to take every advantage
they can to improve their lot.
Decline of the west
Meanwhile those
countries which were the original source for world economic growth will
enforce extreme limits on their own innovators, and in doing so, will
find that they are no longer leaders in the world economy. Their
social, military and political power and influence will decrease in
concert with this change. If copyright and
patent laws are strengthened, or indeed if they are not reformed and
loosened, "Western" civilization itself is under serious threat of
decline.
Judge to Rule on 'Da Vinci Code'
Judge to Give Ruling in Copyright Infringement Case Against 'Da Vinci Code' Publisher
By JILL LAWLESS
The Associated Press
LONDON
- Like a good thriller, "The Da Vinci Code" trial has had drama,
controversy and conflict. And it's ending with a cliffhanger which way
will a judge rule in the copyright infringement case against the
publisher of Dan Brown's world-conquering novel?
The most trustworthy software is open source
The most trusted cryptographic software are based on open source algorithms...
This applies equally to the personal, private or public sectors.
Hiding in public
Why should cryptography - an effort to conceal something, be more
effective, more trustworthy if it is open source? Surely it would
make more sense for the algorithm to be proprietary and a closely
guarded secret?
The advantage of peer review
When you have many of the world's best cryptographic
experts trying their utmost to find flaws or weaknesses in your
algorithm, and they are unable to find them - then you can be fairly
confident that a malicious individual will also have a serious problem
breaking into your data.
We all make mistakes.
But we may be the last person to see our own mistakes! Just as doctors, anthropologists, historians and many other
professionals submit their work for review by their peers, so does the smart cryptographer.
Open source makes sense!
"Paradoxically, the greatest threat to security is people's lack of knowledge.
Many computer installations are left vulnerable because of people's lack of understanding of security threats, and lack of awareness of readily available security mechanisms.
The more people understand security mechanisms, the more secure our systems will be."
[Martin N Brampton]
![]()

I have had extensive experience of a webfarm that was subjected to a huge number of attacks every day.?
My strong advice is not to get too fancy in hardening your servers.?
It is all too easy to try to lock down all sorts of obscure settings which will provide minimal increases in your security posture, but may adversely affect required functionality.
My advice for hardening Windows 2003...
When you install:
-
Use Web Server Edition whenever possible - the attack surface is greatly reduced (and it is much cheaper)
- Enable only required server functions
-
Wherever possible,? databases and application servers should run on a second server - connected to the web server by a second NIC with a totally different IP, and not connected to the rest of your network.?
-
Ensure no programs are installed which you do not absolutely require
-
All unneeded services should be disabled
-
Only use TCP/IP (without NetBios support)
-
Disable all ports and protocols which are not required - appropriately for each NIC! (TCP/IP filtering tab)
-
Make sure Service Packs and HotFixes are always up-to-date
-
Always have up-to-date AV protection - not Symantec/Norton!
-
Ensure that you have adequate, regularly tested, disaster recovery and backup in place.
Then your biggest risk is from any application programming errors - fortunately W2K3 will catch and prevent many of those.
At the risk of seeing like an InfoSec heretic - (and not giving a damn if I do, since I have the experience to back up my position!)...?
I will say that IDS
[by itself] will not enhance your security in any way and for a single server is a huge waste of effort.?? IDS is useful for detecting some attempted attacks, for informing you about possible new attack methods, for helping with forensics including trying to track perpetrators of an attack - whether successful or not.?
None of this makes your web server any safer.?
Additionally, IDS requires a lot of time to be spent on analysis.? Analysis is impossible if you don't understand what you are seeing, and you will still probably just waste your time if you only understand it poorly.
IDS is useful in certain circumstances - but is not a preventative measure.
And remember:
There is no such thing as absolute security
Do your best - more is not possible.
![]()

In the Windows Live Safety Center blog,?"CurmudgeonToo" worries that Microsoft doesn't support the ME operating system.
I would note that Ford has also stopped supporting the "Model T"!
Model T was not designed for the excellent roads and high crime levels we have today.? It was not designed securely by today's standards.?
There is no automatic door locking and the brakes are incredibly weak
and dangerous. It is slow and does not have the power to accelerate out
of hazardous situations.
ME has a very insecure file system, is vulnerable to a vast number of attacks, and is? very slow and unproductive.
Just like the Model T was great in its day, so was ME - but that day is long
past.? Today we need far more stable and secure systems than could
ever have been envisioned in the early days of motoring or computing.
IT security professionals such as myself have no honest option other than to tell clients: "The only way to secure the (obsolete) 95, 98, ME operating system is to get rid of it".
Any organisation which still uses these vintage operating systems on their network is
making the same sort of security error that they would if they left all
their doors open and unguarded every night!
I have collections of antique computers and various old operating
systems - I don't pretend to myself or anyone else that they are of
anything but? historical interest today.
![]()

The most trusted cryptographic software are based on open source algorithms.?
Why should cryptography, an effort to conceal something -?be more effective, more trustworthy if it is open source?? Surely it would make more sense for the algorithm to be proprietary and a closely guarded secret?
The answer is simple - the advantage of peer review
When you have many of the world's best cryptographic experts trying their utmost to find flaws or weaknesses in your algorithm, and they are unable to find them - then you can be fairly confident that a malicious individual will also have a serious problem breaking into your data.
We all make mistakes. But we may be the last person to see our own mistakes!
Just as doctors, anthropologists, historians and many other professionals submit their work for review by their peers, so does the smart cryptographer.
Open source makes sense!
See also "Open Source and the Public Interest"
![]()

McAfee software causes havoc
According to TechWorld's Matthew Broersma, McAfee's antivirus products went haywire last Friday, deleting or moving a huge array of different file types from their customer's computers.? These included Excel spreadsheet files, which are typically used to hold important financial and planning information.
A person posting a message in the Internet Storm Center, claimed that the McAfee product was causing more destruction than a malicious program such as a virus would have done!
Was this incident "just" brought about through bad testing and poor quality control procedures in McAfee?? Or did it occur as a result of a hacker compromising McAfee's development servers?? I guess we'll never know, but either way it reflects very badly on this company's ability to help you secure your computers.
![]()

|
Software Patents are a "BAD THING"! |
|
? |
|
Software Patents make it impossible to legally do almost anything creative with computers, or the Internet, without being liable to pay a lot of different people a lot of money for each already patented part of your software or web site etcetera.? But finding out who all those people are may be all but impossible! ? Although you might be a ?good citizen? and pay the holder of the patents in the USA for the right to use "their" technology in your website, you can still fall foul of a foreign patent law when a person uses your web site in Europe, or in any other jurisdiction. ? For an example relating to the scenario of a web-shopping site, see this URL http://webshop.ffii.org.? But please remember that it deals only with some of the European patents ? there are additional patents in many other countries - such as the USA! ? ? Think about it? Software Patents: ?????????? Stifle commerce ?????????? Drive up the development costs ?????????? Increase the likelihood of litigation ?????????? Act as a serious brake on invention ? Software Patents are a BAD THING! |
?
![]()

Copyrights and Patents
While many of you will have
read the enthralling, disturbing, thought-provoking, fictional work "The
Da Vinci Code", and it certainly is of topical interest - my interest in
the Associated Press article "Judge to
Rule on 'Da Vinci Code" is especially concerned with copyright, and
the closely related the issue of patents.
Many authors of fiction do a
great deal of research before publishing their book. It gives a veneer of
'reality' which helps to make the book more believable. People like
"new" and "different" - just as long as they are not too
different!
If basing the bare outline of
a book on facts or concepts originally revealed through someone else's research
qualifies as infringement of copyright, then this has far-reaching
ramifications indeed.
Not only will it be possible
for huge numbers of fictional works to be challenged, but also non-fiction
books will have claims of copyright infringement made against them. Non-fiction
is probably far more frequently based on research originally performed by others.
Yet none of these are the most frightening aspect of the matter.
Death of innovation
If the mere inclusion of
facts gleaned from another person's research can open one up to the likelihood
of litigation, people will cease to innovate as freely as they previously would
have done.
Innovation is actually seldom
totally "new", but is typically an important incremental advance, or
a lateral offshoot from something else which the innovator has observed. From
an historical perspective, before literacy became almost universal in Europe and the European colonies, there was very little
innovation.
Much of that innovation was
discovered and then lost again, sometimes repeatedly, throughout the ages. And
this was during a time when there were not any restrictions of copyright or
patents! There were no limits to the things you could try - based on what you
had seen, read or heard about.
Literacy is probably the
single most important means to power that the world has ever known. For well
over 1,000 years Europe possessed widespread
literacy, but that literacy was jealously guarded by the Church and limited
almost exclusively to the religious orders. This hoarding of knowledge held the
world in an intellectual and economic stasis until the close of the Middle
Ages.
Today excessive regulation
and control over innovation - through the means of overly-restrictive copyright
and patent law, threatens to hold the "Western" world in a stasis
which is effectively similar to that of the "Dark Ages" in Europe.
To the Benefit of the Third World
You may be sure that
"less-enlightened" countries, who do not feel bound by these
artificial restrictions, will have the wisdom to take every advantage they can
to improve their lot.
Meanwhile those countries
which were the original source for world economic growth will enforce extreme
limits on their own innovators, and in doing so, will find that they are no
longer leaders in the world economy. Their social, military and political power
and influence will decrease in concert with this change.
If copyright and patent laws
are strengthened, or indeed if they are not reformed and loosened,
"Western" civilization itself is under serious threat of decline.
'Judge to Rule on 'Da Vinci Code'
Judge to Give Ruling in
Copyright Infringement Case Against 'Da Vinci Code' Publisher
By JILL LAWLESS
The Associated Press
LONDON - Like a good thriller,
"The Da Vinci Code" trial has had drama, controversy and conflict.
And it's ending with a cliffhanger which way will a judge rule in the copyright
infringement case against the publisher of Dan Brown's world-conquering novel?
http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/wireStory?id=1814642
In TechTarget's "SearchSecurity.com" site, contributer Pete Herzog discusses the "serious issue, that of who really is an information security professional, and who may simply be masquerading as one."
Pete says "On-the-job success still comes down to ability. Through the ages, being a professional has always been about applying what you know. Two-hundred years ago, a blacksmith with only the knowledge of all the smithy best practices couldn't get a job if he didn't have the actual ability to smith what needs to be "smithed.""
Everything Pete says in his article is absolutely correct. Generic security qualifications across multiple "domains" in which the practitioner may never have actually practiced are really quite farcical. Good memory skills in an exam do not in themselves equate to wisely applied information security skills in the field!
The fact that an exam applicant may be required to have worked in the InfoSec field for a minimum of 4 years does nothing at all to prove that their experience was wide-ranging!
However, an important and interrelated matter, which Pete did not mention, is the problem of the high cost of professional certifications. I don't know if this is a significant problem for people in wealthy countries such as the US or the UK, but for most of the information security practitioners in theworld, these costs certainly are.
A Viable Solution I believe the solution - to both the problem of prohibitive cost and that of meaningless certifications, is to return to the idea of the blacksmith Pete mentioned. Theblacksmith served an apprenticeship under the close supervision of an approved "master" in the trade.
InfoSec Apprenticeships Modern InfoSec apprenticeships should incorporate regular theoretical learning, together with daily application and testing of the apprentice's knowledge in a real -world work environment. Having reached a reasonable degree of skill, a board of "masters" should examine them . If the board agree that the apprentice is worthy of certification, the certificate should specifically mention the InfoSec areas in which the person has experience.
A Certificate Providing Useful Information An employer will know with a fair degree of certainty what a prospective employee is already capable of, and where they will require further training and/orexperience. They can be assured that the "blacksmith" really does know more than the mere principles of the trade.
This is a solution which...
- Will work in any country - rich or poor
- Will not be expensive for the apprentice while training... in fact they should expect a living wage
- Will provide employers or clients of the InfoSec professional a very reliable benchmark of their skill set
What do you think about this concept?
![]()
It seems appropriate after my last post that I should comment on the importance of credibility as an essential attribute of?the reputable security professional.
?
Information Security is?part of the discipline of Computer Science.? Computer Science is not?part of the Humanities, nor a Social Science, but an Exact?Science.
?
As professionals, it is vital that we adhere to the?scientific method if we are to gain?or retain credibility?with our clients and the general public.
?
For example:
- When performing research we must take great care that our methodology is sound
- Our tools must be?appropriate for the current task
- Observations must be performed with scrupulously
- Conclusions must be the result of considered judgement and based on existing scientific knowledge and our observations
- The process must be carefully documented if our research and conclusions are to be regarded with respect
- Use of language must accord with accepted definitions of words within our discipline, and we must define exactly what we mean when using ambiguous or new technical words
?
This aspect of credibility in the InfoSec professional is of inestimably greater value than any qualification or paper certificate.??
This should not be understood as meaning that I consider certificates or qualifications preclude credibility however! :-)
![]()

This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending After Hours posts
Sort by Trending