Discussion Locked

Internet radio's bandwidth for Corporate LAN

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Does anyone recommend ceasing Internet radio like Windows Media Player on Corporate LAN's to reduce bandwidth? Or, does Internet radio not really pose problem or concern?
150 Users max on LAN.

30 replies

by oz_media

Most streaming audio is at a relatively low bitrate, thus doesn't suck a lot of bandwidth up.

If you have 150 people all listening to different stations wouldn't the office be a bit noisy?

It depends on how much bandwidth your ISP gives you each month 5 10 gigs or whatever. Did you ever go over before Internet radio was big in your office?

Do people not have actual radios or cd players at the office?

Sorry, but this is the most absurd thing I 've heard. Upwards of 150 users using internet radio?

Even if 50 used the internet radio I'd start raising eyebrows. Why wouldn't you invest in a small desktop CD player, better sound by far. Internet radio for the most part is horrible quality garbage.

I would shut it down just as an annoyance.Then scream "Buy a freaking radio and some headphones you cheap losers!!"

Hope that helped a bit. :)

by ntsysop

I would not restrict usage unless noise becomes a problem. The bandwidth usage is not near as bad as some streaming content websites. If you are having bandwidth concerns, I'd look elsewhere on the network. As long as management doesn't have a problem with listening to music at work and the people use a little common sense with the volume controls, I'd let it live on.

by johnnywatt

150 Users, but I cannot tell how many people are using the internet radio. I do know that some use it and when others see it, they start to use and so-on. People at their workstations use headphones or in their offices so noise is not much concern. The streaming of Internet radio from 8AM to 5pm is my concern.

by oz_media

Tell them to buy a walkman or bring a friggin' radio with headphones to work.

Are you running a corporate radio station?

by techjock

Why does the Corporation have the connection in the first place? E-Mail? WWW Access? ...

The other posters are correct in telling you that streaming audio doesn't consume much bandwidth, but it depends on how much bandwidth you have available and what it is supposed to be used for.

If you suspect that bandwidth is suffering, you could always investigate a QoS router to give higher priority to those services that are more important to the Corp.

At the point you are at, (~150 users) Internet Radio is most likely viewed as a perk by the people who use it. Turning it off without Corporate backing might create unwanted backlash.

True, most computers today have sound cards and CD-ROM drives, but people like variety during their boring Corporate grind days.

I'd say leave it alone and keep the users happy unless there is a business reason to limit it.

Now porn surfing on the other hand ...

by jamesrl

At my previous employer, we blocked all Internet streaming sites, kazaa clients warez sites and just about anything streaming - stock tickers included. But they were very clear that non business access to the net was a privelege, not a right, and that costs would be contained.

My current employer is similar - people use their CD drives and headphones to play music.

James

by oz_media

I use dot have surround sound speakers and I'd crank music all day. With the sub turned up you could turn the office into a night club, it was AWESOME!

I used to mix it up just to keep people on their toes. I would be playing heavy metal all day and then put on some Hindi music, smoky jazz, or classical. I love playing head games with peopel who think they figure you out! :D

No wonder they let me move and work from home for a year!

by dafe2

None of what you mention has a place in the office. Headphones & a radio don't cost that much. Infrastructure belongs to the corporation & most AUP's include these restriction. We've also included many restricted apps in GPO's up to and including Firefox lately.

** I just saw your (AECL) answer this afternoon.....I still maintain relashionships with many people at Chalk River & recently just finished some work with GE that involved some of the guys from AECL Mississauga........all good guys & easy to work with. I probably shouldn't ask her but are you still in the industry or have you move on to other things?

by williamrcastillo

I have been asking this same question. I users complaining about how slow the net work runs, but then about half of my 50 users are streaming radio, video weather info the news, gameswhat ever they want.

I am all for letting folks do stuff, but all this streaming has got to take a toll on net bandwidth. Any suggestions for easy to use tools that can be put in place to document this kind of activty?

by danlm

How many of your users listen to internet radio?

Put up a test machine, tune into internet radio and monitor it's bandwidth. Use that number as a bench mark. And multiply it by the total number of users that you think listen to internet radio. Then compare that number against total bandwidth used.

That would give you some hard numbers to base your decision on.

Dan

by jdclyde

With all the electronic noise and the building structure combined, I can not get a radio signal from but a very select few offices, and that is only if you put the radio in the window.

The main reason I have seen for limiting this, is that with many work PC's they now have everything on-board. (so much crap). Listening to internet radio on a system like this while doing all your business functions can be a big drain on resources and cause system crashes. With my sonicwall firewall it would show how much bandwidth was used by each of the top 25 users. The top user was only doing internet radio and had used more bandwidth than the other 24 combined. This printout came in real handy when she cried to her boss that she needed a new computer because her's was always crashing. When we showed this printout to the boss, as well as the documented cases of each tech telling her the cause was the internet radio, well, lets just say she didn't get a new computer.

But we don't block this. Just recommend against it.

Not the IT Nazi's to take it on ourselves to start blocking things their bosses don't have a problem with.

by tomsal

The radio reception isn't the greatest here either, personally as a bandwidth only issue - I don't see streaming radio as a big deal since we have dual t1's just for 'net access an our staff size just shrunk to below 100 over last year. The concern here is mainly two issues:

1) You give an inch, they take a mile. This saying is very true with my users. I'm afraid if we allowed radio streaming, that this will embolden them and then they'll start streaming other things, which will lead to a bigger case of "let's see how far I can push my luck" which will go to p2p networks, etc. etc.

2) The vast majority of the employees here are on the phone about 90% of their day, we aren't a telemarketing company but our business is HEAVILY dependent on being on the phone a lot. In fact aside from the upper execs and my department (IS) I think everyone's job here is on the phone most of the time.

by johnnywatt

It's kind of what jdclyde said. Can internet radio be such a problem that one user can top is Sonic Firewall traffic?
Again, I administrate roughly 150 users through 1) T-1 line for internet. This pipe is shared with Exchange traffic and other Internet browsers.
The general consensus seems to be, No big Deal.

by jamesrl

What would happen then?

What if you hade 150, or even 75 users using it at your peak time for exchange and browsing? Would it suck up all your bandwidth?

If you want to be fair, don't make rules based on the assumption that only a few users will use it.

James

by oz_media

Streaming an internet radio station all day doesn't use up much at all. Mulitply that by 150 and you have some usage on your hands. The line type is irrelevant really as it is not an issue of bandwidth as much as usage costs.

Most business class ISP's offer 5, 10 20 gig monthly usages packages, and they are not cheap at all.

SO if your ocmpany is paying for 10 Gigs/ month and uses 11 you get dinged BIG time for the extra usage. This COULD be costing the company several hundred dollars a month at least, depending on the package they use.

So rather than AVAIBLABLE bandwidth, server processes etc. one must look at the COST of that much streaming audio each month.

by johnnywatt

relax man, I'm not building rules and evil plans. I am simply asking the questions - good or not good. I'm not making any plans, so it's okay.

by jdclyde

If you can't/won't enforce a rule all the time, then you just undermine yourself.

I am not in a position to TELL the users anything.

I can make recommendations, but it is a fact in most companies that the users are your customers and the customer is always right.

This goes back the the CEO surfing porn.
No one in their right mind will get in the middle of that. You will be out of a job and they will be on to the next nudie site.

by roger99a

I've had problems with this on my network. The main campus could ignore it but it was particularly hard on the WAN conections and I was forced to block it. Proxy logs made it real clear who was doing it just by looking at bandwidth usage. Those animated weather maps that refresh every 2 minutes can pull a lot of data in a days time, too.

by nwkadmin

I am needing to block this more for an annoyance issue than network bandwidth. Does anyone have a list of effective port blockings to eliminate the streaming audio?

by jdclyde

It will show who is doing it, as well as what port they are doing it on.

They use many different ports, to keep people like you from blocking people like them.

This gets into the deny all, and only allow http/smtp/pop/ftp or any custom apps.

by jamesrl

I did try to get an in at the firm that provides IT services at Ontario Hydro, but it didn't pan out.

I enjoyed my time at AECL, but it was just 3 years. The IT staff is about half the size it was when I started. I really enjoyed spending time up at Chalk River - love the scenery and the pace of life.

James

by jdclyde

What I have seen is just getting a pipeline to the internet that is X big.

There isn't a number you can't go over except for what the X per second is.

Is this an older standard that is going away or is it really still common?

by oz_media

Business class providers here still have bandwidth caps. Mind you Business services here are automaticaly offering QOS and guaranteed up time. My Sat and business ISP has never been unavailable in 6 years, everytime I have ever logged in, whether from the ferry, a hotel or the mainland I have had an instant connection.

I get 10 gigs for about $165.00/mo but it is more reliable and secure than any of my other services that are not capped and cheaper.

They actually only started capping about 2 yrs. ago, so rather than it going the other way it is now being capped. Even Telus, the local telco, is capping business service, not residential DSL though.

With my capped service, I get a 3 meg DSL pipe that is constant 3 megs without fail. Never had downtimee and never had access issues. SO you are paying for reliability, QOS etc. Even a proprietary VoIP PBX will accept the connection, which is RARE without dedicated QOS hardware inhouse.

by jdclyde

They were starting to boot customers that went over an un-named quota for downloading.

The provider wouldn't say how much downloading for a personal account is enough to get you kicked.

Never seen it in business, but then again haven't had a lot of contact with that aspect of having to pay the bills. I just make it work. The bills doen't come to me.

by jamesrl

But I have worked in a number of companies where the policy has been made and agreed to and enforced.

I guess I am not in my right mind.....but you wouldn't be the first to suggest that.

I stood in front of hundreds of users(made the same presentation 5 times at 2 sites) and told them our policies and our method/process of enforcement. Of course senior management, HR and the CIO were all involved in the decision.

If you don't have that kind of support, you are taking a risk.

James

by jdclyde

So if they are breaking their own rule, who is going to do anything about it?

Just seen too many places where IT can't just go in an take someone's computer because they are violating policy.

I also don't think I would function well in that ridgid of a work environment.
c a n ' t breath...chocking...(hairball)

by jamesrl

No you can't take away someone's computer, but you can block their internet access.

At a previous employer, we had a internet security system that would block sites - so if you see abuse, you ensure that they can't go back to the bad site. After they see enough warnings that they have attempted to reach a bad site, that the access has been noted and logged, and is reported monthly to HR, they tend to slow down and eventually stop.

James

by oz_media

Shaw Cable complains when you exceed 20 Gigs for 3Mb high speed and 50 Gigs for 5Mb extreme.

They usually don't do much but send a notification of excessive use, continuations well over the limit get you kicked.

Business class you don't get kicked you just get billed at a higher rate for the overage on a pr gig basis.

Here's an example of some Business Class rates and limits in BC: http://www.sohoskyway.net/barates.html

Rate I had quoted are a fair bit lower, but i have worked with them as a partner before so I get locked in at a dealer cost.

The service level can't be compared to residential or standard telco ADSL though.

These guys also provide Sat., Fibre3, T-1 etc.
Support staff is about as good as it gets, 4 or 5 REALLY knowledgable people that know you by name and treat you like a friend, not some guy in a call center that has no idea what he's doing or who he's talking to etc.

These guys have seminars once or twice a year, breakfast lunch etc. Get to know their custoemrs intimately etc. You really do get what you pay for! I have other services I use and they suck for the most part, even when they work well the support and staff is just ridiculous.

by chitchcock

I use NTOP as a management tool to recognize client connectors and bandwidth usage. I have noticed problems with the amount of bandwidth used. I have three domains with a total of 400 or so users. The user console clearly shows high bandwidth received usage in the range of 20-60 meg per hour for those using the standard internet radios. This spikes with certain connectors. I personally am looking at restricting internet radio usage altogether here. If I have 20 users using it, I am looking at 400 meg per hour wasted. NTOP is a great free tool as long as it set up properly before your firewall on a hub not switch.

by tech

I work in a small office--18 people with a t1. I've had 3 complaints about crawling internet lately. When I asked around, each time there was at least one person on pandora usually in combination with someone doing a legitimate work related webcast or file download. Our peak downloading capacity is 1450 kbps and when I tested pandora, it brought that down below 950. We are drafting a policy to restrict use to work related activities. I'm buying a new server which will allow me to track/throttle bandwidth use by each user.

This discussion is closed to new replies.