Question Locked

Is Current Agentic AI Pentesting Just a Passing Wave?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I’ve been testing a few so-called agentic AI pentesting tools lately. On paper, they sound impressive. Autonomous recon. Multi-step exploitation. Self-reasoning workflows.

In practice, I’ve seen mixed results.

They provide me with the results really quickly. But when I manually validate the findings, many are shallow. Some miss obvious logic flaws. A few break the app in ways a real attacker wouldn’t even bother with. It feels like speed has improved, but depth is still questionable.

What concerns me more is the confidence these tools create. Clean dashboards. Smart-looking attack chains. It’s easy for teams to assume coverage is complete.

I’m not against the idea. I actually think agentic AI can help reduce repetitive testing and surface patterns faster than we can. But right now, it feels like we’re still in the demo phase more than the actual working model.

So I’m curious, are you seeing real depth from agentic AI pentesting, or does it still need a lot of manual validation to be trusted?

5 replies

by rosehale6868

I’m seeing the same pattern,strong at speed and surface-level findings, but still weak on deep logic flaws and business-context issues. It’s great for recon, pattern detection, and reducing repetitive work, but I wouldn’t trust it without manual validation yet.

Right now it feels more like a force multiplier for pentesters, not a replacement — useful assistant, not autonomous attacker.

by liuzeyan1204 edited

I think your read on this is pretty accurate, most agentic pentesting systems today are strong on automation of breadth but still inconsistent when it comes to depth of reasoning and real exploit validation

What you are seeing, fast results but shallow validation gaps, is actually a pretty common pattern right now

Recon and enumeration have improved a lot, agent workflows are genuinely good at chaining tools and expanding attack surface quickly

But exploit reasoning is still fragile, especially around business logic issues, auth edge cases, and multi step conditions that require real contextual understanding rather than pattern matching

The bigger concern like you pointed out is confidence, clean dashboards and smart looking attack chains can easily create a false sense of full coverage when that is not actually the case

In practice most teams still treat these tools as accelerators rather than final validators, they help you find more surface area faster but do not fully replace manual verification

One direction that feels more practical is hybrid agentic security testing, where AI is used for exploration and attack surface discovery, but every finding is backed by validation loops and reproducible attack steps instead of just one pass autonomous pentest outputs

For example PAIStrike.ai, developed by Scantist, is built around this kind of approach. Instead of just focusing on scan style or single pass autonomous results, it emphasizes agent driven attack chaining with verification steps so findings are meant to be reproducible and actually actionable rather than just high level detections

So overall I agree with your point, we are still in a phase where manual validation is necessary if you care about production grade assurance, the real shift will be when AI reliably handles repetitive discovery work while humans focus on verifying the harder contextual logic and business flow issues

by rproffitt edited

"There's always another edge case." - D. Black, Systems Master.

What's wrong with writing DETERMINISTIC CODE?

Example:

IF THIS DO THAT.
ELSE ASK THE HUMAN.

by neetu978 edited

You’re right ,Agentic AI pentesting delivers speed, but depth still falls short in many cases.
Most outputs need careful manual validation to filter false positives and missed logic flaws.
It’s promising, but still feels like an assistive tool rather than a fully reliable solution today.

This discussion is closed to new replies.