Discussion Locked

Is George W. Bush a murderer?

0 helpful
147 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.prosecutionofbush.com/video.php

About the book:

In The Prosecution of George W. Bush for Murder, Bugliosi presents a tight, meticulously researched legal case that puts George W. Bush on trial in an American courtroom for the murder of nearly 4,000 American soldiers fighting the war in Iraq. Bugliosi sets forth the legal architecture and incontrovertible evidence that President Bush took this nation to war in Iraq under false pretenses?a war that has not only caused the deaths of American soldiers but also over 100,000 innocent Iraqi men, women, and children; cost the United States over one trillion dollars thus far with no end in sight; and alienated many American allies in the Western world.

As a prosecutor who is dedicated to seeking justice, Bugliosi, in his inimitable style, delivers a non-partisan argument, free from party lines and instead based upon hard facts and pure objectivity.

A searing indictment of the President and his administration, The Prosecution of George W. Bush for Murder also outlines a legally credible pathway to holding our highest government officials accountable for their actions, thereby creating a framework for future occupants of the oval office.

Vincent Bugliosi calls for the United States of America to return to the great nation it once was and can be again. He believes the first step to achieving this goal is to bring those responsible for the war in Iraq to justice.

About the Author

Vincent Bugliosi received his law degree in 1964. In his career at the L.A. County District Attorney?s office, he successfully prosecuted 105 out of 106 felony jury trials, including 21 murder convictions without a single loss. His most famous trial, the Charles Manson case, became the basis of his classic, Helter Skelter, the biggest selling truecrime book in publishing history. Two of Bugliosi?s other books?And the Sea Will Tell and Outrage?also reached #1 on the New York Times hardcover bestseller list. No other American true-crime writer has ever had more than one book that achieved this ranking. His latest book, Reclaiming History: The Assassination of President John F. Kennedy, has been heralded as ?epic? and ?a book for the ages.?

Bugliosi has uncommonly attained success in two separate and distinct fields, as an author and a lawyer. His excellence as a trial lawyer is best captured in the judgment of his peers. ?Bugliosi is as good a prosecutor as there ever was,? Alan Dershowitz says. F. Lee Bailey calls Bugliosi ?the quintessential prosecutor.? ?There is only one Vince Bugliosi. He?s the best,? says Robert Tanenbaum, for years the top homicide prosecutor in the Manhattan D.A.?s office. Most telling is the comment by Gerry Spence, who squared off against Bugliosi in a twenty-one-hour televised, scriptless ?docu-trial? of Lee Harvey Oswald, in which the original key witnesses to the Kennedy assassination testified and were cross-examined. After the Dallas jury returned a guilty verdict in Bugliosi?s favor, Spence said, ?No other lawyer in America could have done what Vince did in this case.?

Bugliosi lives with his wife, Gail, in Los Angeles

147 replies

by puppybreath

and focus on "About the Publisher" :

Peter Osnos, who wrote Wednesday that he "worked very closely" with Scott McClellan on McClellan's new book published by PublicAffairs which Osnos founded, is a liberal whose publishing house is affiliated with the far-left The Nation magazine and the publisher of The Prosecution of George W. Bush for Murder. PublicAffairs has a roster of authors who are nearly all liberals and/or liberal-leaning mainstream media figures, including six books by far-left bank-roller George Soros. On Wednesday's CBS Evening News, Ari Fleischer related that "Scott told me that his editor did 'tweak,' in Scott's word, a lot of the writing, especially in the last few months." In an "Eat the Press" blog entry Wednesday, Rachel Sklar asked Osnos: "Did you work directly on the book with McClellan? (Who was his editor?)" Osnos replied: "The editor was Lisa Kaufman and yes, I worked very closely with them."

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]"George Soros has made his mark as an enormously successful speculator, wise enough to largely withdraw when still way ahead of the game. The bulk of his enormous winnings is now devoted to encouraging transitional and emerging nations to become 'open societies,' open not only in the sense of freedom of commerce but - more important - tolerant of new ideas and different modes of thinking and behavior."[/i]

Labels aren't taken seriously at all when you abuse them like that. He's arguably somewhat left of the United States' center [gun control & rational recognition of practical differences of real markets from Econ 101, but certainly not "far-left."

Whether or not he's eager to take as much credit as some offer him for the [b]effects[/b] of his actions, it is indisputable that he took actions in opposition to the Soviet Union. I didn't like their government, but to be honest, I'd have to describe most of my [b]actions[/b] as "neutral." Wouldn't you?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_soros#Opposition_to_the_Soviet_Union

by nicknielsen

What amazes me is that Bush hasn't been impeached. He lied to America so he could take us to war and nobody in Congress has even blinked. Clinton only lied about sex and even his own party deserted him.

That there's some serious hypocrisy.

by puppybreath

I'm all for an objective look into the claims against Bush. But I find it difficult to believe that this publisher could ever be objective about anything related to Bush or conservatives.

There are way too many people out there who develop an uninformed opinion based on emotions and then search far and wide for information to back up their opinion rather than looking for the actual facts to base their opinion on.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Did you catch George Soros yesterday on C-SPAN2? His comments suggested nothing "leftist" to me; not a peep about taking from the rich and giving to the poor, just some hard-headed analysis of whether speculation, or what all participants termed "market fundamentals" are responsible for the spike in oil prices.

Another member of the panel whose name I didn't catch had some even more interesting things to say, especially about Morgan Stanley. Price-fixing is not a term I remember hearing, but it is a concept strongly implied by the bare facts that were discussed. My impression of George Soros is less that he's a leftist than he is a reproach to many fascist-leaning investors.

by santeewelding

Look to the three posts just above you, ending with, "Stepping stone".

Puppybreath raises the issue. You remind him that he may "know that about exactly one person, yourself."

Only, you flaunt the rule in stating the rule.

Then you abandon the rule completely when you tell Tony what he "(doesn't) know," among other transgressions, in C02 Footprint.

While I'm comforted that you enunciate the given, selfsame betrayal is bothersome, both in enunciation and in execution.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I actually have no evidence that last night's Senate hearing had anything to do with this, but I wouldn't be surprised, either: gas prices have dropped from a high $135 to $121/barrel. Public radio attributed the change to a drop in demand, but really, I suspect it had more to do with speculators hearing one of the members of that panel recommend prison sentences, because no other punishment will dissuade speculators from the huge sums of money involved.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I'm curious about that claim. Does this guy really have the capacity to step so completely away from himself that he is capable of 'pure objectivity'? I tend to doubt that sort of claim.
fwiw

by nicknielsen

He is, after all, the man who won convictions for Manson and his followers. A prosecutor has to be objective to a great extent. I don't doubt that he's made a very strong case in his book.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I was around before Manson was ever arrested, and vividly remember the Tate murder in particular. Up until that point I had no clue that 'evil' was anything more than an abstract concept used by Sunday school teachers to denote 'sin' (another nebulous concept at that age).

It's the use of the word 'pure' in conjunction with 'objectivity' to which I object.

edit typos

by santeewelding

This one brims with it. You could earn a living here.

I used to, watching confiscated porn evidence at lunch in Inglewood with deputy DAs of the Los Angeles County Judicial District in 1968.

by santeewelding

You touch a bunch of stuff with your question, as did I remembering and relating my experience.

I quickly add that in no way do I make dark light of your observation re objectivity. The subject here do brim with it, along with the usual suspects: "fact" and "actual" and "honest," or not.

Quickly again, I did work with those people. I had to give them, what they did, and who they did it to, a hard look.

As you may imagine, I had to give myself at the same time as hard, or harder a look. Your acuity in these matters may signal, in terms of boundary, the unbounded.

by j-mart

History shows us how the right or wrong of warefare is handled. In the second world war the loosers, Germany and Japan had the perpertrators of war crimes taken to task and brought to trial. the victors, Britain, US etc. did not come under any scrutiny for any questionable acts during the war eg fire bombing of Dresden or the napalming of Tokyo, both operations that mainly targeted inocent civilians, women children etc. Past experience tells us that Bush and co. will only come to trial if the US is completely defeated by Iraq to the extent US mainland is ocupied by victorios Iraq, which won't happen so I would say this is not going to happen regardless of any right or wrong.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]There are way too many people out there who develop an uninformed opinion based on emotions and then search far and wide for information to back up their opinion rather than looking for the actual facts to base their opinion on.[/i]

Nice assertion. What facts are the right basis for opinion, in your opinion?

by puppybreath

is that you should base an opinion on facts and not emotions.

To do that, you need to look at all points of view and evaluate all of the available information. Many people refuse to do that.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]To do that, you need to look at all points of view and evaluate all of the available information. Many people refuse to do that.[/i]

You're able to know that about exactly one person, yourself.

by nicknielsen

The Bush administration lied to the American people to start a war. It has ridden roughshod over the Constitution and current law.

How can a different point of view change this?

by $$$$$$$$$$

You're a hoot, jdclyde!

OK, let's accept, for sake of discussion, your [i]ad hominem[/i] attack on the concept McClellan has presented, of a Presidency with a "permanent campaign" mentality. Let's accept that, for the sake of this discussion, because Scott McClellan is an opportunistic, amoral or even malicious liar, which we have accepted on the basis of his association with his current publisher.

I leave it as an exercise for the reader to apply the same "standards" to McClellan's previous employers. You'll find that they cannot escape their guilt.

by jdclyde

they have laws against insider trading.

amazing how you would confuse criminal law with political leanings.

As for the rest, you're putting words in my mouth that I never said, and drawing conclusions based upon that?

by j-mart

Though this is a bit off topic the Bush administration has gone to war on a lie. He should now front up to the US public and come clean with the real reason he has made this decission to go to war. Some will agree or disagree with how he realy saw it, if he thinks he was right at the time he made this choice, he has even said given what he knows now he would have still made the same choice, he should show the courage required by his position and come clean.

This may not bring him unversal aceptance of his position but standing up for what he beleives will at least gain some respect.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Had those occurred, the general American public's opinions would not have meandered so far toward the opinions of moveon.org as we have. Still, many are embarrassed to have been proven wrong by "them" and resist substantive discussion of who knew what, and when. The question I want to put to such people is, how many more soldiers are you willing to kill for your vanity?

by oz_media

Don't know if you want to hear that whine.

He'll go on about his god and the American people and his faith etc.

Religion makes a good crutch because it is hard to stop someone's actions of faith, without breaching the Consitutional rights of Americans.

We've seen it before, when he was against gay marriage. His decision was 100% faith based on his belief in god and he uses THAT to decide what is best for the American people, HIS god.

by jdclyde

when you make a desicion?

Everyone has some kind of moral standard that they live by, regardless of if organized religion factored in developing the standards or not.

It is people that don't HAVE moral standards that guide them that are a worry because what is it that DOES guide them?

When he was elected, it was known up front Bush's standards and where they came from. It is an issue for every elected official.

Just like many fear(ed) that Obama was/is a closet Muslim. He has chosen to wrap himself as a Christian (even if it is from a church of white hate).

You grow up thinking certain things are acceptable and certain things are not. We in the US and Canada believe it is unacceptable to have dogs fight for entertainment, but there are many countries that it is an accepted part of their cultures.

by puppybreath

if I started quoting information from Rush Limbaugh or Sean Hannity, you'd accept it at face value. Yeah, right.

by nicknielsen

If it's opinion, unsubstantiated, or carries circular references, into the trash it goes.

Rejecting data outright based on the source leads to fallacy, failure, and foolishness.

by puppybreath

That I rejected the information. I actually read the Huffington Post along with quite a few other sources both liberal and conservative. I agree that it has many valid points that have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt. But I wouldn't be foolish enough to present the information using such a biased source to try to convince someone. It immediately casts doubts on the validity of the information.

As I said before, many people refuse to look at all of the available information before forming an opinion. I don't happen to be one of them.

by nicknielsen

I suspect Bugliosi can probably come closer to "purely objective" than anybody else I can think of.

I was around for the whole Manson thing as well, but over on the east coast, we only got the high points with none of the in-depth coverage the trial would have gotten were it a local story.

My introduction to evil as something other than an abstract Sunday School concept was the Boston Strangler. Not at all like Manson, but still evil.

by $$$$$$$$$$

If I rejected information you quoted from Sean Hannity or Bill O'Reilly without examining it, I'd run the risk of disputing one of their rare true statements, and I would look sillier than you, who hypothetically had quoted Fox News.

Your first reply, titled "Huffington Post?" appeared to be your entire reaction to that URL. I'm pleasantly surprised that you actually read the editorial I linked. Of course an opinion piece is biased!

pupybreath: But I wouldn't be foolish enough to present the information using such a biased source to try to convince someone. It immediately casts doubts on the validity of the information.

I take that as a comment on my efficacy at influencing others' opinions using such sources. I just don't care to influence the opinions of people who believe that objectivity equals absolute neutrality. A person that dispassionate would decide on what basis, which stories are important enough to be "news"? To me, anybody who believes in the myth of the disinterested reporter is too stupid to be saved. I just post whichever perspective seems most interesting, knowing that anybody whose opinion I'd value will weigh what's written according to [b]their own opinion of the writer's bias[/b].

by santeewelding

What you propose to hold and inspect for symmetry about one axis or another while balanced on your fingertips is a juggernaut. You are indeed skilled.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]What you propose to hold and inspect for symmetry about one axis or another while balanced on your fingertips is a juggernaut. You are indeed skilled.[/i]

... as The Emperor has foreseen.

I'll accept your compliments and your money, but that's all.

by nicknielsen

[i]Had ["cakewalk" & "greeted as liberators"] occurred, the general American public's opinions would not have meandered so far toward the opinions of moveon.org as we have.[/i]

Like others, I supported the action in Afghanistan but opposed the invasion of Iraq. Now, all of a sudden, everybody is against Iraq and has been all along. It's the same rooting-for-a-winner mentality that creates a huge fan base for a successful sports team.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I remember thinking that I had seen credible reports of chem & bio, and trusting that the Vice President was not lying about nukes, but feeling a little odd about the contrary sources of info about nuclear weapons inspections.

I can relate to McClellan's feeling that his trust was betrayed.

by notsochiguy

I've said before, I thought Saddam should have been taken out far earlier (not necessarily first Gulf War...but about the 3rd or 4th time his militia took shots at coalition planes in the no-fly zones...he should have been done...hard and decisively). That said, when I heard the reasons for the way in Iraq, I was a little dubious.

The reason being that Israel had given no indication (at least that I can remember seeing or reading, anyway) that there was a threat out of Iraq. Israel is usually exceptionally pro-active in self-preservation, as evidenced by the statement that they'd level Iranian nuclear facilities the moment they went online (paraphrase).

Israel, and not the US or UK, would be the most susceptible to any high-end weapons the Iraqis may have had...but they didn't seem none too scared.

Admittedly, I am not privy to anything other than what the news agencies put out (which is spotty, I'm sure)...so it is very possible that the US had to talk down Israel in the event that there was something there. However, as is, I think history will refer to this as 'The Cheney War'; rightly or wrongly.

by puppybreath

"and I would look sillier than you, who hypothetically had quoted Fox News."

you admit that you looked pretty silly using the Huffington Post as a source. Or are only the people that quote conservative sources silly when they do so?

by nicknielsen

If the information is factual and can be separately corroborated, the source is not important except to fools, those of deficient intellect, and politicians. (Is that redundant?)

by $$$$$$$$$$

One source is "silly-looking" to liberals; the other is "silly-looking" to un-liberals.

Anybody who ignores a fact, on the basis of an opinion, looks silly to honest, intelligent people of any ideology.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I knew that to some people, I would "look" silly for that, and they would dismiss the information out of hand. Frankly, I don't give a damn about their opinions.

by j-mart

Gw can't run for re-election and his political career is coming to a close it would show integrity and courage to come clean, he could finish his term as an honerable honest man or he can leave as a slimy cheating politician. It seems though universaly around the world politicans tend to be more inclined to dishonesty. This is GW's chance to be somthing special as a politician courageos and honest.

by nicknielsen

...but I'm not holding my breath. IMO, our President is missing two traits essential to those in high office: intelligence and integrity. But he's one helluva bullsh*t artist.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]But he's one helluva bullsh*t artist.[/i]

I became suspicious because his facial expressions were inconsistent with the gravity of the topic so often, especially when he talks about terrorism and terrorists. Now I follow his lead. I don't take terrorism seriously.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I caught the blunt force of the Tate story via a pictorial (Life maybe?) treatment of it when I was in 4th grade. I remember - though not as vividly - the Boston Strangler, and Richard Speck. Ugh. I guess we have to 'meet evil' somehow. Pity, that.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

GWB and B. Clinton both are major smirkers. I am amazed that so few appear to notice.

edit: clarify the Clinton

by forum surfer

While I do admit his actions in Iraq are without a doubt highly questionable, we are not talking about a man setting out to opress the world through tyranny and violence. His intentions in Iraq were good, but they are a people unwilling to help themselves, so there is nothing that can be done there by us. I think calling him a murderer and a tyrant as so many do is a way too extreme. I'm not defending him mind you...I'm just saying the man isn't evil, corrupt and hell bent on killing innocent men, women and children as so many have previously said.

by forum surfer

But I don't feel his actions are murderous or tyrannical at all. Unless you're complaining about innocent victims and non comabatants in the war. If that's the case let's cal every president who served in any office a murder, as well. British, Canadian and Italian Special Forces are over (Iraq and Afghanistan)there with us. Let's call them murders, too. I mean if Bush is a murderer, then obviously the other countriies' leaders have to be as well since they are beside us.

by forum surfer

He won't be charged as a murder because he isn't. We went into a country full of people that would rather live under a tyrant's boot than be liberated. It was a mistake. Saddam and the Bathe party should've been taken out, murdered if you will...and that should have been the end of it. That's always been a war torn section of the world for 1000's of years and no one is going to change that. Not through peacful negotiations, not through trade embargos and not through war. For most of my adult life I've thought the best solution in the middle east would be to keep good intelligence, let them fight amongst themselves and only strike with force once they leave their cozy little borders or threaten us in some form.

by santeewelding

You are entirely right, entirely caring, and entirely gracious for holding me to that higher standard of response.

Thank you. I do know the need.

But I have to beg off for now. The other class of learning accelerates and grows more demanding. Last night we were issued stethoscopes and sphygmomanometers. I need to land running with them immediately next.

I will attend in due time, I hope, to your call.

by $$$$$$$$$$

If that's the case let's cal every president who served in any office a murder, as well. British, Canadian and Italian Special Forces are over (Iraq and Afghanistan)there with us. Let's call them murders, too. I mean if Bush is a murderer, then obviously the other countries' leaders have to be as well since they are beside us.

Unless they decide to attack us.

by forum surfer

I feel Iraq was less of a threat than Iran or Afghanistan. Not neccessarily the countries themselves, but the group that hide within their borders. Had we have focused on Afghanistan, the groups would have fled to Iraq. Once we invaded Iraq, alot of these groups fled to Iran or scattered untill they can regroup another day.

The "war on terror" is going to be best won by a strong defense with sharp, decisive blows at specific targets IMO. We don't have to invade entire countries in that respect, just take out targets within their borders. This will be an ongoing threat and even if Iraq came out of this as a strong united country, which will never happen, threats will just arise from within other nations.

I say bring the troops home, finishing what we started in Afghanistan and move foward. None of the fundamentalists in those countries will ever sympathize with is or be our allies. We are viewed as evil and nothing will ever change that. They hated us before Bush and they'll hate us after Bush.

"Unless they decide to attack us. "

What about Bosnia? In operations there, lots of innocent people got caught in the crossfire. The things going on there were horribli and action needed to be taken, but they never attacked us. So does that make Clinton a murderer as well? We had no gain to come of it nor did anyone attack us.

by nicknielsen

[i]Had we have focused on Afghanistan, the groups would have fled to Iraq. [/i]

Saddam Hussein was a very repressive secular dictator. Al Qaida is a group of religious extremists. Do you honestly believe al Qaida would have fled Afghanistan to Iraq and Saddam's welcoming arms? They'd have gone to Iran (and some probably did), but [b]not[/b] to Iraq.

by forum surfer

So westerners, being the root of all evil started it. So what? Have they stopped fighting? Were the crusades to blame for the intense hatred of Israel throughout the region? Are westerners to blame for the Iran-Iraq war? What about the Arab-Israeli war? No. Christianity had it's peaceful moments, as well. Don't blame the crusades for everything, that horse has been beat to death. Not that our country hasn't comitted atrocities within our own borders, either. I'm just saying we should leave them alone. They are apparently content to live under oppressive leaders, why should we help? If a people genuinely rise up against a dictator like Iraq had in place then we should fund them or help them, otherwise leave them be.

The whole situation pi$$es me off to no end that we are even there. We should have cleaned house in Afghanistan, tracked whatever terrorists we could, take them out and establish bases for intelligence operations, not occupations. I mean if we're really that concerned about dictatorships there are far worse problems in Africa that no one does anything about. There also happens to be no oil there, what a coincidence.

Don't promote Islam as not having it's own troubles, either. Ever heard of the Ridda Wars? (The War of Apostasy) It, like the crusades on the outside appeared to be over religous reasons...but was entirely political and all about expanding someone's empire. And no Westerners started that.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]So westerners, being the root of all evil started it.[/i]

Nick only refuted your characterization of the Middle East as violence-prone for thousands of years. He did not state nor imply any [u]general characterization[/u] of westerners or the west. He only mentioned that the Crusades were initiated by an outsider to the Middle East, namely, the West.

[i]The whole situation pi$$es me off to no end that we are even there. We should have cleaned house in Afghanistan, tracked whatever terrorists we could, take them out and establish bases for intelligence operations, not occupations. I mean if we're really that concerned about dictatorships there are far worse problems in Africa that no one does anything about. There also happens to be no oil there, what a coincidence.[/i]

I agree. Let's not waste our time arguing that the West is generally inferior to the Middle East, or vice-versa.

[i]Don't promote Islam as not having it's own troubles, either.[/i]

You misunderstood. Now back up, take your own advice, and don't misconstrue Islam [as having more of its own troubles than it really does or did]. Nick corrected your portrayal of the facts. Take it like a man.

by nicknielsen

I never suggested westerners started it all. I merely pointed out an approximately 400-year period that contradicted your assertion of "always been a war-torn section" of the world and noted that the only wars in that area during that period were started by Europeans.

That area, like the rest of the world, is tribal in nature and needs no outside interference for any kind of conflict to start. Europe was the same way (http://www.historesearch.com/earlyeurowarmil.html).

by forum surfer

Both countries would have set their differences aside to harbor militants. They may have different political views, but they share a common hatred of the west that outweighs their political differences. While Saddam may not have outstretched his arms to militants like that, he certainly wouldn't have lifted a finger to stop them unless they were hurting his primary concern...his income.

**edited because my wireless keyboard was dying and a few words were left out...that's what I get for buying batteries at the dollar tree :)**

by nicknielsen

Your response indicates a gross misunderstanding of:

a. Middle Eastern politics
b. Islamic schisms
c. Human nature

by forum surfer

I have a diffeerent opinion. We're talking what if's. Just because my opinion or my interpretation of the same facts differs from your conclusions doesn't mean that I "misunderstand" anything. I'm simply offering a different point of view.

by forum surfer

I respect his opinion and he's welcome to it. I've studied the middle east and I have my own interpretation of the facts. I still stand by my statement that it has been, and aways will be one of the most war-torn sections of the world. That is my interpretaion of the same facts we all have at our disposal. You can't sway my opinion and neither of us are 100 percent correct. That is why we have discussions.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Nick did correct your silly claim that the Middle East has been more violence-prone than other regions for "thousands of years" and in reply you falsely credited him with your own misunderstanding of his words:

[i]So westerners, being the root of all evil started it.[/i]

Are you Bill O'Reilly's fact-checker? Nick only pointed out the fallacy of an example you provided. He didn't go any further than that. He did not say one word of condemnation of the West. It's your habit to condemn one side in favor of the other, and you've projected that habit onto Nick.

You're entitled to your own opinion, not your own facts. This is not a difference of opinion.

by $$$$$$$$$$

The choice of word "militant" suggests he really doesn't distinguish, as the CIA does, against armed members of various factions. Everybody "over there" is "prone to violence." As a result, he can with a "clear conscience" support a decision to invade any place at any time and teach 'em a thingertoo about damockercy as soon as Karl Rove's political hacks and White House appointees cull the required "Intel" cherry-picked from 10-year old research. "My country, right or wrong." No point trying to educate that sort.

by oz_media

Will rewrite wording used, will recreate passages to offer a more dramatic effect, remove words they feel will bore the reader and add words that will entice the reader.

As for the book itself, it is the author, not the publisher.

If your car falls apart after 100miles to you blame the dealership or the manufacturer?

by nicknielsen

Although the "My country, right or wrong" crowd no doubt consider themselves patriots, I've more often thought of them as closet fascists. The height of patriotism is speaking out to expose the wrong.

by oz_media

And yuo were even the person I thought would say something. Too predictable.

There is a MASSIVE difference between basing your decisions on a set of morals and beliefs that are private to you, are YOUR rationale and hopefully DON'T involve religious faith.
What if he was a radical Muslim by faith and said Allah told him to destroy Christian Americans, I don't think you'd see such honor in his beliefs then, would you?
there's NOTHING in the US Constitution which says you must be of Christian faith.
To base your political stand on a specific religion's faith is not a good idea.

Here's the difference I see, if a person is guided and fulfilled by their faith that is completely expected and acceptable.

If a person supports or denies laws, due a specific religious belief, he belongs in the church not as president of a country which SUPPOSEDLY accepts all faith and religion as equal.

How can you claim to accept all religions equally and then say that your chosen religion does not allow such a thing and therefore you will not allow it to pass as law in the country?

It's hypocrisy and using religion in that manner has no place in politics.

If he had not supported gay marriage, that's fine (even if it was because his morals say otherwise) but to say as much in public is not acceptable.

But that's teh way it always works dow there it seems, just bend the rules to accomodate the moment.

People accept his constant screw ups because they are scared they will be shunned for supporting his opponent, that's just being irresponsible as a citizen.

It doesn't matter what religion someone does or does not support, that's not teh case here at all, but USING that religion as a reason for passing political judgement that effects Americans of all religions, is just wrong. If it was anything BUT Christianity, you would ALL be rioting over it.
"GWB is saying we can't allow gay marriage because he believes in Bhuddism! That's wrong, he shoud be impeached!"

Pure hypocrrisy, if you don't see it youself, that explains why Americans are so blind to how the world sees you all and why you are so shocked and personally offended when people point out flaws in America's politics.

by jdclyde

Is where your core beliefs come from is beside the point entirely.

A devout muslim is generations away from having a shot at election BECAUSE we know the core beliefs and disagree with them.

You elect people with core beliefs and you expect them to follow those core beliefs. It is called having Character. You do what you believe in, not what is the easy way out or politically correct.

Principles and conviction are considered good traits in the US. Someone that would go against their core beliefs has neither principles nor conviction. Says more about you than it does about us.

And Presidents don't write the laws or decide who does or doesn't get married. That is Congress that controls that. The President gets the face time, but is not the one that has the final say.

by nicknielsen

[i]A devout muslim is generations away from having a shot at election BECAUSE we know the core beliefs and disagree with them.[/i]

The core belief of Islam is the same as that of Christianity: treat others the same way you want to be treated.

What you call Islam, JD, is anything but. The "Islam" to which you refer bears the same relationship to actual Islam that the beliefs of the Westboro Baptist Church bear to actual Christianity.

edit: spel

by oz_media

At least I didn't mean to anyway.

Your core values are a very important part of such a position. They are also something people learn by watching your actions or believing on your purpose. You will automatically attract like minded people. Actions speak louder than words, and all that cliche stuff.

I object to his coming out and saying that he has no problem same sex couples, but doesn't believe that they should be entitled to the benfits and breaks of a "married" couple, as it goes against his religious faith. His religion (Christianity) illustrates marriage as a bonding between a man and a woman.

There are two issues here.
1) The term marriage is a religious reference as it is a bond made by a church. But that religious reference has been used politically to define state benefits for citizens. The definition was never set out in fine detail back then, it is just assumed the term 'marriage' was as used as defined in Christianity; which of course it would have been back then, I am sure that they were not having gay marriage issues.

2) George Bush said that while HE accepted it (defining to his core values) he was motivated by his religious definition of the term 'marriage' to deny state acknowledgement of same sex married couples and the same benefits as other opposite sex couples. (his religious values override his core values).

There's a difference there.

by forum surfer

This is my country, right or wrong. I'm not a self-proclaimed patriot. I'll stand by our leader's decisions if I support them and speak out against them if I don't. I expect the same of anyone. No point in making this personal by implying that anyone needs to educate anyone else. I do my own research. I don't take any of the rubbish spewing from the mouths of the far left or the far right at face value. If you guys feel the need to speak out then by all means do it. Speak your opinion, it's your God given right. I also have a right to politely and respectfully disagree. While my opinion may be wildly different than yours, I'm not going to assume you to be uninformed or not properly educated on the subject matter.
i was simply pointing out that Islam and Christianity, though both teach peace, loving and forgiveness at their core values...each has had a long past that at times were violent and bloody.

by nicknielsen

That's what ?My country, right or wrong? should mean. Unfortunately, those who employ the phrase the most (and its mate ?America, love it or leave it.?) tend to be more interested in stifling discussion or dissent than encouraging it.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]I also have a right to politely and respectfully disagree.[/i]

And you just exercised that right. I have to admit, I took your characterization of the Middle East as cultural chauvinism, and in the context of a justification to invade, I am still suspicious.

[i]While my opinion may be wildly different than yours, I'm not going to assume you to be uninformed or not properly educated on the subject matter.
i was simply pointing out that Islam and Christianity, though both teach peace, loving and forgiveness at their core values...each has had a long past that at times were violent and bloody.[/i]

Both have also displayed nobility, honor, civility, intelligence, just to name a few virtues. Both have safeguarded and expanded on knowledge developed by the other, in their respective Dark Ages -- not as a favor to the other, but for the inherent value of the knowledge that the other discovered. I still object to your argument that invasion could be justified, but I don't intend to dismiss you out of hand again.

by forum surfer

"I still object to your argument that invasion could be justified, but I don't intend to dismiss you out of hand again."

9 out of 10 times I beleive a swift, harsh response is best. There are, thankfully systems of checks and balances to keep people like me at bay and to keep pacifists on the other end of the spectrum (not say you guys) from letting the country be over-run.

(Coincidentally if you think my views in the middle east are extreme you should hear my views on welfare reform, gun control and child welfare!)

:)

I'm tired of whining about the Middle East, now. It's Friday and I'm looking foward to a few whiskey sours after work. Cheers!

by jdclyde

if He wouldn't have told you that it was against his beliefs and just opposed it?

This was just political reaching out for his base. the people that object to being religions standards are not the people that voted for him in the first place, so why would he care what they think?

Is it just posturing? look at me, I am a good Christian? Other than speculation about his "oil buddies", he hasn't been shown to have the same character flaws that many in office do, these days.

The Haliburton issues always are a joke because Clinton gave them the same no-bid contracts because they are the company that can handle the jobs, so it isn't like Bush brought in a new company at Dicks say so just because he used to work for them.

It comes down to, it doesnt' matter what he does or says, it will never be good enough for the Bushaphobes, with their irrational hate that they have had for him since the 2000 election when they were told that they were suppose to hate him.

Just because he has done a bad job of managing things is not a reason to hate. I don't hate Clinton, I think he would be the life of the party. I just wouldn't trust him with my daughter (if I had one).

by oz_media

I was referring to how he outwardly used religion to justify his decision.

His voters are Christian, great and they know he is a Christian and I don't have any issue with it either.

One would think that in order to grab the rest of voting America you would be a little smarter than that though.

Nobody told me to hate bush, I have simply watched and objected to most of his foreign actions, the rest doesn't effect me.

While you suggest there are people that will oppose him no matter what, you fail to recognize that there are those who support him no matter what. I think the latter is more dangerous to the American people and allied nation than the former.

Do I hate GWB? No, hate is a strong word. Do I think he's capable of being president of the USA? No, god help us all.

He's probably a guy I'd have a few Scotches with at a party, I'd hang with him and shoot the breeze for a bit but that's about his only place in my eyes. Politics? Why not, they are all a crooked and misguided bunch of thieves anyway, President? No bloody way!

One would hope that thier leader was clever and astute, his words on the subject were neither clever or astute, they were completely ignorant actually. If he was sharp, smart and astute he would have seen teh flaw in it and simply declined on other terms.

If you have convictions and faith, that's' applaudable, as president of a country the constantly tries to insist it is multicultural and open to religion, you simply shouldnt make a decision that effects Americans of all fsaith and then 'blame' it on your religion. 'Blame' because while he personally feels differently (or so he says), his religion leads him to act otherwise.

That's neither professional or responsible.

Woul di have objected to his decision if it was not blamed on his religion? Of course, it has no effect on me eitrher way, I am not a gay man trying to get married and recive benefits in the USA.

I just thought that with all teh ridiculous crap that he spews out, that this was just another example of his complete and utter incompetence to run a free and open nation.

by jdclyde

There are people that only see an R or a D, and if you are not the correct sneech with the star on your belly, then you are undesireable.

A large portion of the Democrats will not support Bush on this or anything else, so why would he waste his time worrying about them? Focus on why you are there, for the people that put you there.

This is why, no matter how good things get, approval rates NEVER get very high. Don't have te star on your belly, so I vote negative approveal no matter how good a job you are doing.

As for being open to other religions, what other main stream religon recognises anything but marriage as ONE man and ONE woman? Ok, some allow you to have more than ONE, but do they allow same sex? No, they don't, so that is not a valid arguement in this case.

Multicultural? No, we don't brag about being multicultureal. We brag about being a great country that people leave their home lands in home of a better life here. They assemilate into our solicity, learn the language and become Amercians. We had the difference between melting pot and Canadas multiculture. Both have good points, both have bad points. As far as betterment of the COUNTRY, I think melting pot is better. As for the individual coming in that are resistant to change, Canada is a good alternative.

If nothing else, a common language and set of laws is a benefit to everyone.

oh well. at least you see I wasn't INTENDING to imply hate on your part.

by oz_media

I am too used to people opposing my comments I guess.

The one place I beg to differ is that a multicultural society is one for people who don't want to change their ways.

This is not at all true in even the smallest way. Multicultural countries allow/encourage cultural difference, in that we don't expect people to assimilate other cultures.

You can still be multicultural and have your main accepted public language as English. People can still practice their faith of choice, just as in the USA, people can dreww how they choose, just like in the USA.

We just don't frown on those who choose to retain their culture, language and beliefs, the same way many Americans do.

I don't expect my East Indian neighbour to hang up the sari and speak with a Canadian accent. I think its actually kinda neat ot have a freindly relationship with someone who dresses in her country's attire, speaks with a thick Indian accent and practices her religious faith (far moreso than I do) in her own way.

In fact, once you get used to her accent, she's sharp witted and VERY funny. The jokes about her lazy husband are no different than those I hear from other friends wives, she is just like yuo and me but has an accent, has her Hindi faith and wears the most beautiful sari's.

One things for sure, white women really look hot in some of the more colourful saris worn for special occasions.

While she still is Canadian, pays taxes, shops at Safeway, eats Western Food etc. She also has a really intersting side too, quite educational for everyone in th eneighbourhood and it opens your eyes to realize that foreigners are just from different places, not different worlds.

I think this is also why Middle Easterners are so readily understood and accepted globally, except in America where the culture is kept under wraps and not of interest to most Americans, they just want Americans living next door, not immigrants to America.

It's almost hypocrisy when you consider that ALL Americans (except native indians) are transplanted European immigrants who brought THEIR culture to North America and instilled it on the native with force.

Okay you can retain a bit of your culture, but only on this little piece of land we have reserved for you. Canadians at that time were no better, but we have grown as a nation since then and now welcome the diversity with open arms, without concern that we are sacrificing our own faith, culture or ideals. I find cultural diversity very educational, especially to the younger generations that will grow up in a 'global world' and not a 'national world' (meaning what were once fairly unrelated and disinterested nations have now become valuable trading allies as well as the way the world now works together more and more with the Internet expanding and dissolving our borders/limitations so).

There's one for you, I find that while a great deal of Americans see the border as a dividing line to separate the USA from others, many other countries prefer to see borders dissolve and open them up to greater opportunities and abilities.

by nicknielsen

The point I'm trying to make is that, just like in Christianity, the fundamentalists are a small fraction of Muslims.

The Bush administration painted all Muslims with the fanatic brush and that got us where we are today.

by jdclyde

where I am talking about something specific, but going from post to post, some of the important details get left out.

You do know one of the biggest Muslim populations in the US is less than 100 miles from me, right? They get harrassed, but it is by mostly black males, not white males. HUGE fights back and fourth and gets pretty ugly.

by oz_media

Vancouver has approx 1,200,000 Europeans, and well over 582,000 Aisans, about half of the cities population (the fourth largest city in Canada and with a population density higher than any US city except that of New York).

Richmond, a 1 minute bridge away from Vancouver and where the Vancouver International Airport is located, has the largest visible minority in Canada (from 2002 stats, recent stats show that it is no longer a minority but well over 60% now). Over 60% of Richmond's people are not caucasian or aboriginal. We had a government in teh early 90's that literally opened up the flood gates for Chinese immigration, in one year there were over 300,000 oriental immigrants to Richmond alone.

If you take a bus, go to the mall, visit a theatre or anywhere else, as a cuacasian you stand out like a sore thumb, EVERYONE around you is oriental. When I was younger, We used to joke about being the only white guy on the bus, but reality is it is true. You can get onto a packed full bus and be the ONLY white, native English speaking person on the bus. In fact the oriental chatter is usually so loud you just throw the headphones in and wait for your stop. Hearing English on a Richmond bus is quite a rarity, without exaggeration at all, I am not joking.

Just a few weeks ago, native English speaking caucasians in Richmond became a visible minority, with a Oriental population of over 60%.

East Indians dominate south Vancouver and Surrey (Surrey being the 2nd largest suburb), you csan't even understand half teh signs at the malls. as for Richmond, most former residents don't even recognize it anymore, airport laws were lifted to allow for highrise housing as demanded by the Asian influx during the 90's. Most caucasian, English speaking, Canadians in BC are all seeking to move to the interior and buy homes on acreage, that's the only way to escape the dense crowds.

by jardinier

[i]Just like in Christianity, the fundamentalists are a small fraction of Muslims.[/i]

You live in America and think fundamentalists are a small fraction of Christians?

I post to an American Christian website. Let me assure you that fundamentalists account for a majority of Christians in America.

I think about 50 per cent of Americans describe themselves as "born again Christians."

Try another analogy. That one doesn't work.

by nicknielsen

Shall we say "radical" instead of "fundamentalist?" Equating self-described "born again" Christians to fundamentalists such as those of the Westboro Baptist Church is simplistic at best and smacks of the same "they're believers, they're all radicals" mindset most Americans have about Muslims.

by jdclyde

Because it has been open season for Christian bashing for decades. Julian spends a lot of time on the Christianity sites, why? Not to further his belief.

As for Muslims/Bush, the radicals that have been attacking the US for the last few decades painted that picture, and Bush just took it and ran. When we hear about how honor killing STILL happen, how 12 year old girls are still married off, how young men are brainwashed by others (who don't do it themselves) to strap a bomb upon themselves and kill civilians in the hope for an orgy in heaven, yeah, they have given Muslims "a black eye".

by boxfiddler Hot topic

extremism is probably a better choice of word than is fundamentalism, re: both Christianity and Islam.

Fundamentalism - sticking to fundamentals - is not likely to cause the same sort of problems that extremism - going off the deep end with select bits and pieces of a thing - does.

edit the usual

by santeewelding

You would appeal thus, here, a site of, by, and for, the consummate technician?

Being half-awake Saturday, you might get away with it.

You have my blessing, if it means anything.