Is it ever right to yell?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by gnlcs
by shawn_w
I only ask because I have seen this kind of comment from many managers and yet as a third year law student I have not been able to find a single law or even a case that protects workers from being fired; other than cases involving overt racial or gender discrimination. California (for example) is a right to work state i.e. you have no rights and can be fired at anytime with or without cause. If there are laws in other states that protects employment I would love to know about them.
In this case I suspect the screamer just has poor self control and his company hasn't given him the authority (wisely) to fire the worker in question. He also doesn't have the manners to apologize even though other people who were not slacking off were offended by his lack of professionalism.
by shawn_w
Of course you can tell them when they are not performing to expectation. Are you saying the yelling or cursing is the only way to do this? Is that how you want your boss to speak to you? Whats wrong with demanding that management learn how to communicate?
As for firing. Most companies could avoid their termination problems if they followed these three steps:
1. Polite warning where you tell the employee their current conduct is grounds for dismissal. If you dont use the word dismissal the warning does not count. "Knock it off" or "stop that" is not a warning.
2. As above, but this time in writing. Be very specific about dates, times, and witnesses. At this stage many employees will start seeking other employment and quit.
3. Wait a few months to see if the employee corrects there behavior. If then then politely terminate their employment.
Pretty simple but almost no company does it that way. They prefer to invite lawsuits by firing impulsively in anger.
by shawn_w
by and?
The law I would specifically cite is South African Labour Law - aka Labour Relations Act. I would be very surprised that a supposed 3rd world country such as South Africa would be ahead of the US (1st world) when it comes to Labour Law ? (PS we spell "Labour" with a "u" in South Africa).
In South Africa employees have rights - and can open a case for Conciliation, Mediation or Arbitration (http://www.ccma.org.za) and even take it as high as the Labour Court should they feel that they were party to an unfair dismissal aka they were fired for an arbitary reason. In South Africa - there are many procedures that need to be followed before someone can simply be fired. Procedural and Substantive reasons are taken into account when employees cite unfair dismissal. And this applies to any employee whether temporary, contract or permanent. There are immediate dismissable offences of course - but even these still have to follow correct procedures before someone can merely be fired, such as a disciplinary hearing etc.
If there is no such laws in the USA that protects employees - then I suggest you write your congressman !
by mgritz
Well is still a bit fuzzy, but here in Nevada each year I have Mandatory training regarding Sexual Harrassment. I'm told that sexual harrassment is the same as creating a hostile work envornment. I'm not en expert in this subject, but if one is treated differently than others to create a hostile work environment, the organization is at legal risk.
I'm not sure of the specifics though...
by server queen
I don't know what is. I don't think any manager with the slightest vestige of management skills needs to yell at anyone, male or female, unless they're about to step in front of a moving train or something. It's asinine to say that you can yell at a man with impunity. I can assure you that if I yell at my male employees, they will not only take offense, they will complain about me. And rightly so. Barring obvious issues of safety ("DON'T PUT YOUR HAND IN THE MOVING SAW BLADE!"), yelling is admitting your own inability to deal with a situation.
Your post sounds suspiciously like flamebait.
I found that raising your voice or changing your tone, never ever increase the possibility of resolving conflict or the situation.
Choose your words carefully.
I a situation as discribed above, I would recommend that you take the associate aside, and explain calmly that he/she is wasting your and the team's time.. and if required, maybe go as far as mentioning that it can not be tolerated, and if the situation does not improve, remove the associate from the project. It shows that you are in control under pressure, but showing emotion of any kind in these situations only count against you.
by pete1978
You have multiple issues here. There is "discipline" type of yelling (where you might not even raise your voice). There is "raising your voice" type yelling that may have nothing to do with discipline (see your average football fan). And then, of course, there is the "raising your voice while administering discipline" type of yelling. Don't know which you are supposed to have done but there are answers for each.
Discipline type yelling
If you did this yelling in front of the employee's peers, yes, you should apologize. But not for the content of the yelling. Instead, only for your poor choice in not keeping the matter private. Discipline of any sort should be kept private. Unfortunately for you in this situation, other employees do not have a need-to-know when you discipline an employee.
As for the content of your yelling...if the employee was not on task, you not only needed to take action, but if you failed to take action, you yourself would be "not on task." after all, it is your job to see to it that the employees do their jobs.
But, as I stated before, this should all happen in private conversations, not in a public forum.
Raising your voice yelling
Try not actually yelling (just in case you did raise your voice.) A person may be very strong in the words they select without having to become louder. You do or should have positional authority. That should be sufficient to put force behind your words if you select your word carefully.
Becoming louder tends to indicate anger and that will reduce the respect you receive from employees -- even those you didn't yell at.
The raising your voice with administering discipline yelling -- see all of the above.
Overall ...
There are many books and online articles on leadership theories and methods. Not one that I've read advocates ever raising your voice (even when the employee is yelling at you). All of them discuss methods for influencing the employee to do their work. And then, of course, there is the last resort that gets the attention of every other employee. If the one continues to be off task, remove them from the situation (fire or transfer them). When they are no longer a part of the team because of being off task too often, the other employees will realize that you are serious and that should help influence them to be on task.
Good luck.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending