Discussion Locked

IS/IT functions directly report to GM

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
With the current technology trend in driving and managing our core business, most corporates have structured their IS/IT dept. to be under the Finance dept. Shouldn't it be that IS/IT reports directly to the GM?

3 replies

by gavin jones

I've worked in both environments, where the IT director was a Board member, and where the IT director reports to the Finance Director (FD).

IT director on the Board.
We were a publishing house producing periodicals and books, and had a large IT department. The IT director was able to advise on ideas brought up at board meetings and champion IT.

IT director reporting to FD.
I now work for a company where the IT director reports to the FD. IT issues seem to filter through slower, and most of the time we don't find out about new projects until it's too late. No-one considers IT at the beginning of a project, but as an afterthought.

Of the two representations I think it worked a lot better with the IT director being on the Board.

by al macintyre

Every top level corporate manager has a different vision of corporate needs & a difficult balancing act between micro managing IS/IT priorities to properly serve the whole enterprise.

If you have a reasonably stable platform implementation where you do not have to be constantly fighting fires & can focus more on growing the computer services, then consider how it was handled where I worked several employers ago.

I was head of IT/IS & I reported to a different boss every 6 months to 2 years, in which all of these people were with the company the whole time, what the CEO was doing was rotating IT/IS to report directly to the head of a different department.

So I reported to the head of Sales & Marketing for a while, then to the head of Retail Chains for a while, then to the head of Academic Music Rentals for a while, then to the head of corporate music book publishing, and so on it went.

Value to me was a thorough education in the workings of various divisions that rarely requested computer support but I could see would dramatically improve their performance with a little bit of help from me, and also a strong need for better integration between the computer resources of all these departments.

Value from top management perspective to all these temporary bosses was education for them in how the whole company is tied together, should be tied together, that IT/IS is not a prize that will spend 6 months working exclusively for their needs, but rather a shared responsibility.

by yankeetom

I am an IT Director strongly in favor of IT reporting to the operational units. As you have stated, technology is being deployed to help define / create the business model. Finance is a staff division of the organization.

One option is to hire an IT Controller. We have done this and it has enabled us to perform all of the budgeting, capitalization, reporting, needs to the satisfaction of our CFO.

There are not too many critical IT decisions to be made with regards to finance -- everyone is running off of packaged solutions. Your operational units are the ones that will need to make critical decisions and are best positioned to decide where technology dollars should be committed.
Regards.

This discussion is closed to new replies.