Discussion Locked

Is it harmful to not wire according to TIA/EIA 568 a/b ?

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I work at a highschool as computer technician and I was recrimping a cat5e ethernet cable and noticed that it wasn't wired according to the TIA/EIA 568 a or b wiring scheme. The scheme used at the school is orange, orange/white, green/white, blue/white, blue, green, brown, brown/white. I have notified the network administrator, but it doesn't seem to matter since our IT dept. doesn't do the cable runs/drops at the school. The electricians at our school do all the cabling, I would like to inform them, but I have a feeling a lot of people would look down at me and think less of me because I'm a young computer tech questioning the integrity of our network. However from the things I've read and have been taught from other respectable sysadmins is that mixing up the wiring scheme can cause cross talk and interference. This also causes a problem when we have outside people come in and install new equipment. My question is does it matter how its wired as long as it works? Would I be correct for questioning this?

2 replies

by mjd420nova

I guess if you want to volunteer to reterminate every one of the scrambled connectors, then there's really nothing wrong if they are all done to the same pinouts and wiring scheme. The cross talk and interference only results when things are done differently than what's already in use.

by hal 9000

And while I personally prefer to follow the standard wiring layout it's not really necessary provided that every termination is wired the same way or even if every single lead is wired the same at each end. For all intents and purposes they could all be wired differently and not introduce a single problem to the Network except when it comes time to replace a socket or the like.

If where you are does things one way provided that everything is done the same way there are no problems. You'll only run into problems when you start to connect the wires up differently to the existing wiring setup.

So in answer to your question [b]No It Doesn't matter how It's Wired provided that it works![/b] But if they are using a nonstandard wiring layout it could cause problems some time latter if someone new comes in and wires things differently.

Usually if they are replacing a single run it will not bring about any problems but if they are only replacing one socket it can be a problem, but for this reason when sockets are replaced most fitters cut the cable and leave a little bit connected to the socket so that they can see how it was wired previously and wire it the same way to prevent problems.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.