Discussion Locked

Is it me or has participation in Discussion gone way down

0 helpful
42 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Is it me - or has participation in general technology discussion gone way down...

Seeing loads of discussion topics with zero replys for long periods of time ... Is TR driving everyone away - are the political discussion killing the technical forum (I've gotten loads of good poop out of the tr forum)..

Just wondering if its me??And if not can we improve the response level.

42 replies

by oz_media

Well Jim what I see is MOST of the technical discussions are actually technical questions best suited for the Q&A section.

If we help people in the discussion forum, it then defeats the pupose of those who have posted correctly in the Q&A forum and play the points game.

A few other technical discussions that have been opened here are simoply old hat or just plain don't interest me so I have not responded.

I actually posted a topic the other day about the new Novell SUSe Live, I was thinking of you when I posted it as i know you are a Novell Linux fan.

SUSE Live (desktop OS with Open Office and everything else) can be downloaded as an ISO file. Burn it to disk and just boot with the CD ROM, it will attach all the drivers and boot the linux Kernel to start SUSE Linux (just like an upscale windows), when you remove the disk and reboot, everything is normal again, your OS isn't effected in any way. It's a great ay to test and demo the product if you haven't already.

NOTE: Open Office 1.1.1 (included with SUSE) will crreate Publisher, Excell and Word compatible documents but some Excell Macros aren't compatible with v.1.1.1 (the first release) gove them time.

Now look at the single HOME user cost of $29.99 USD (OS, Email, Browser AND Office included) and exp[lain how MS expects to keep market share. User learning cuve is now no longer an issue, any Windoze user can use ths without any effort.

by jamesrl

Its not necessarily about price or technical superiority.

The Mac OS used to be far more stable and powerful than Windows, up to and including 95/98. The new version OSX, based on a unix kernel, is better in many ways than Windows XP.

Its momentum and interia. Its hard to go up against a competitor with 95% market share. No matter how good the product is people will wonder about the long term viability. It takes a poweful movement to overcome 95%.

I remember selling Macs at trade shows in the late 80s. People would come up and say, I would love to buy a Mac, but you can't get as much software for it as you can for Windows(3.0).

I would pull out an Apple Catalogue of 3000 software products from Apple partner developers, and say - what are you looking for? It wouldn't phase them - they would name some relatively minor piece of software that was available for Windows only, which had a number of Mac compatible substitutes. Or they would mention that AutoCad on the Mac was alsways one version behind(not that they needed AutoCAD, but just in case). At the time by the way, there were some cool architectural rendering and fly through programs that weren't available on any other platform -partially because of Windows memory limitations, and partially because of the way the Mac handled math and vector graphics.

MS will have marketshare because only a few will dare to install anything except XP on new computers. .Net is attempt to cut JAVA out of the market and make web and other IP based apps MS based.

Sad but true, I have a hard time seeing anyone knock MS off the pedestal.

James

by oz_media

I am not referring to just those such as MSjiunnkies and home users but more for the Novell Market.

Even most MCSE's will agree that as a Network OS provider, Novell has always provided more bang for the buck than MS. It needs less to do more.

These users have been STARTING to get dragged down Ms avenue by new hires (generally MCSE's) that feel Windows is a better NOS (probably due to familiarity). Now that Novell on the Linux Kernel has taken flight, many are still unaware that Linux is not a DOS style text environment anymore where you need to mount and dismount drives manually etc.

This form of OS demo is a great way to show people just HOW user friendly linux as become, for a small organization of say 100 users, Novell is temting due to cost and stablity but people still shy away from using anything but MS on the desktop, 'users will find the learning surve too hard'.

Well now cost comes into play.

MS file server, Print server, Exchange server, Application server, SPAM server etc. etc. etc. All licensed and requring hardware to run them.

Novell= File, print, email, application and SPAM all on one server. Stable, less hardware required and more cost effective due to licencing, VERY resourceful and able to handle far more users per server and simultaneous requests from multiple users than MS servers.

OK, so the server is better.

desktops, 100 seat corporation needs 100 MS XP licences, AND 100 Office licenses.

SUSE, $99.00 Canadian for professional licence.
INCLUDES, Open Office (almost FULLY MS Office compatible in its first release) included. Over 2000 titles available through download portal that offers most programs for no cost or VERY minimal business licencing costs.

So the age old problem, 'users aren't savvy enough' or 'too much of a learning curve, is no longer an issue. Even the newest newbie to MS can use SUS Linux, it is almost identical to an XP/Mac cross.

It just shows what REAL companies are doing to offer a better value for money, whle MS works on it's next bug laden $800.00 offering that will be no use until two years in full production environments. Oh yes, then you need to buy Office.

Sure MS has made its way into people's hearts (somehow), but money talks and BS walks, the tide will turn unless Ms puls up the socks and gets their act together.

Once people start using Linux at work, they soon start using it at home. I know from a few Novell Linux installs, many of the staff have switched to Ximian Linux or SUSE or even Red Hat at home now. They are no longer intimidated by Linux, it LOOKS and ACTS friendly, MS LOOKS friendly but rarely ACTS that way.

Remember when the DOS users scoffed at Windoze 3.11?

by oz_media

You were saying something about helping techs in Indai with stupid help desk questions and how you don't want to help these people.

I neer agreed with your point until I saw this today;
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6239-0.html?forumID=56&threadID=156044

Now click on the user and see all the other 1 and 2 point questions this guy has asked!
I am surprised there isn't 2 points for how to press a power button!

Now look at the handle; Ingram Microtech India!

Very sorry Jim, I had no idea you guys were facing this. :-)

by gralfus

I have asked questions I thought were interesting, but got 0 to 1 replies. I guess others didn't find the issues interesting.

The political flame wars seem to draw the most activity, but those seem very out of place on a tech site, in my opinion. They amount to putting a bumper sticker on a car, it won't free Tibet and it won't solve world issues. Just a bunch of opinions flying back and forth. I typically avoid these and other threads that go beyond 12 or so posts.

Where's the tech issues (laws, trends, workplace, business, etc)?

by oz_media

On the Dicussions entry page, you can check off which discussions interest you so that you don't have to read the MISCELLANEOUS topics if they don't interest you.

I think the popularity is because there is little factual info hitting the mainstream and a lot of theory causing many more questions. We are just not hearing the full story, so everyone is interested in getting their own opinions cleared up by discussing the BS and propaganda that we are fed 24/7.

As the war in Iraq is probably the most important world issue right now, people here want to tae a break from the boredom of IT and we use the Miscellaneous discussion forum (anything NON-IT related) to discuss world affairs.

Again, there is no need to pore througth all that crap if it doesn't interest you just select your topics of interest from the entry page, instead of lookig through ALL NEW discussion or popular discussions, use the Browse by Topic feature.

by stress junkie

I made exactly the same point in another thread a week or so ago. Then I participated in several political threads. I agree that politics appears to be out of place on a tech support web site, but what can you do? I, too, have eaten of the off topic fruit and I know that I will do so again.

by oz_media

as for them not having a place on a technical site, I think you ae seeing TR the worng way.

yes this is a 'tech site', it has a technical Q&A forum for resolving problems (with great help!), it has technical discussion links for technical discussions and an excellent selection of downloadable whitepapers and articles on relevant subjects. THAN it has a Miscellaneous section, we have been encouraged in the past by TR staf to use this section for ANYTHING we choose to discuss, Music, Politics etc.

So while TR IS a tech site, the Miscellaneous discussions forum IS the correct place for such topics, and you're right, they are quite the LURE, so to speak.

by justmakingit

I have a problem with the Tech Q&A. If someone is to post a question there, it doesn't seem like anyone is rating them anyway. So if you are after the points, there really isn't much sense, as I see it. I know avoid the Tech Q&A because of this. I was really in it for the points but it was kind of nice to see who was going to "win" the question. But Since no one actually rates the question, no one really knows who has helped with the answer.

Therefore, I think that a lot of people avoid that section and ask questions in an area where they know people are going to answer and are even browsing.

Maybe they are browsing the Discussion Center looking for political battles to join in on and therefore they also answer the tech questions as they are by-passing.

This may be a lot of bull since I am still fairly new, but these are my observations.

by stress junkie

I posted a similar observation about a week ago and one of the TR support people replied as 'Yeah yeah we know...". What kind if response is that? It's the response of someone who has no intention of fixing the problem; someone who doesn't care.

I find it particularly irritating when I answer questions in the TQ&A and the original question is overwritten with my answer. I suppose this means that my answer was accepted but it is so stupid. It would probably be easier for the question poster to accept the correct answer rather than cut and paste the 'correct' answer into the question space. The question is still left open and it is obliterated by writing the 'correct' answer into that space. And I don't get my points.

If you look at my TQ&A track record you see that more than half of the questions to which I've contributed an answer are not rated. This is crap. The whole point system is not working because the people who post questions don't do their part when they get the correct answer. Most of them don't care about getting 1000 points because posting their question is a one time thing or they just don't care about the points game.

I've been contributing to both TQ&A and Discussions but I cringe when I click on TQ&A because of the things that I've just mentioned. It's just a level of stress for me that I don't need to buy into. Will this person rate my answer? Will this person ever close the question? More often than not the answer is no. So since the discussions forum creates no such expectations it is more enjoyable to participate in answering technical questions.

by oz_media

I used to take time to point people to tech Q&A when they posted in discussions but it just doesn't end, TR needs to resolve and simplify the navigation problems. Other sites use discussion groups for technical support, this is TR's mistake.

I have noticed people who say they have been postig over and over again and get no responses, they post to the correct forum and get the problem solved in no time.

points have no benefit to anyone, it's just a pissnig contest, but it is also a sign of gratitude and affords one bragging rights when he hits the top 5 scorers. The technical Q&A section is great of used properly, I have many outstanding and unclosed questions but they are time sensitie and get closed ater a certain amount of inactuvuty (supposedly).

But there IS a format and if we stick to it, it works. I use the discussion group as a way to get away from technical BS, I don't want to read people's IT problems here, when I do, I visit Q&A.

People provide solutions in the Tech Q&A forum, many of the same peope who participate in discussions, it's great to know you can have a major digfference of political opinion but then everyone becomes and ally or a friend when it comes to supporting each other.

by Jay Garmon

As you may or may not have noticed, TechRepublic has started highlighting discussions in our NetNotes e-newsletters and on the front doors. From a sheer pageviews standpoint, discussion participation is up significantly since April.

However, there is a very good chance that this practice is drawing casual discussion traffic out of the General Technology areas. As you note, political discussions are still going strong, and occasionally overwhelm even the featured discussion traffic numbers. However, I've been slotting in "soft skill" and broad topic items, in order to entice the widest range of IT participants, which I'm sure has had an impact on overall discussion traffic and user habits.

Which brings us, as always, to the Tech Q&A/Discussion Center split. As you all have no doubt noticed, discussion threads get a great deal more traffic than Q&A questions receive. The only reason we built a separate system for Tech Q&A was to accomodate TechPoints, but if no one is reading these posts, and posters aren't closing and rating the posts, is it still worthwhile to have a separate Q&A area?

Put simply, would people still answer explicit tech questions if the TechPoints incentive was removed? Could these questions be treated like normal discussion threads (as is the case on every other board out there) and still get a reasonable amount of response. Would you hardcore regulars still be willing to help out your IT peers, even if you didn't rack up a "score"?

I ask because I'm part of a group writing specs for a potential discussion center revamp, and the TechQ&A issue is one of our main sticking points. We really want a way to recognize our most active and helpful posters, but TechPoints doesn't seem to be the best method.

Any thoughts and suggestions on how we can make community easier (keep our "tree" view for threads, or go to a standard linear structure with quoting), more fun (enhancing and integrating http://geek.techrepublic.com into the site proper), and richer (link in more active user profiles, like Gamespot DLX or Orkut use) would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks

--Jay

by oz_media

I think it would be MUCH better if people ignored the need to earn points, unless TR steps up to the plate and actually starts ofering TR (or CNET parter) swag.

I would cringe at the thought of conbingin questions into the Discussion forum though, can we not get a break from people who need to know how to finish IT homework?

I find it MOST annoying to look for an interesting topic of discussion only to find myself wading through hoards of double ad riple posted problems by people who don't knwo how to navigate a website yet alone help themselves. I come here for a break from Q&A not to find more problems to help resolve. I want to be able to choose where I go ad what I see instead of being forced to answer questions, when I am looking to talk with peers.

I think even if the points were removed, the Q&A sections needs to be kept separate, or BOTH threads wil see less participation as people just don't wat to deal with the BS.

If you are talking about moderating TR from now on, and can't find a way to change the CSS sheet to reflect the differences between Technical Q&A and Discussions, have someone that removes the questions from Discussions and tells people to post in the right place, or simply 'this question as been moved to Technical Q&A (Get Help or whatever you rename it).

NEXT MOVE THE DAMN DISCUSSIONS LINK BELOW THE TECHNICAL Q&A LINK!! take the technical part out and call it 'Ask a Question' or 'Get Answers', then people will be more apt to post there than to skip past to th eDiscussions forum. On the entry pages, instead of a smal font paragraph that says what the forum is for, place a BOLD DISCLAIMER. THIS FOUM IS FOR DICUSSING TOPICS OF INTEREST, SHOUD YOU HAVE A QUESTION YOU NEED HELP SOLVING CLICK HERE.

DONE DEAL!

by Jay Garmon

Standard disclaimer: we're at the "wouldn't it be nice" stages of development, so none of the following should be construed as "The Trivia Geek promised us these features."

Right now, we're looking at a unified discussion/Q&A interface, where everything exists as a discussion thread, but that certain discussions could be flagged as questions. Discussion users could sort for or against "questions" (and probably open vs. solved questions), so you can locate the type of discussion you want pretty easily.

Solved questions would ideally get archived into a searchable FAQ section, so newbies with a standard question can be referred to a previous answer. Moderators (maybe including some empowered users) would police the newest posts to make sure we aren't repeating ourselves or posting in the wrong area.

That's what we're looking at, anyway.

--Jay

by stress junkie

Yes I think that changing the title of the TQ&A could
help people understand the purpose of it.

I would also like to see the ability to have something
like a thread so that one could have a 'discussion' to
clarify the questioners situation. Right now attempting
to do that results in many separate questions which
would negatively impact the answer ratios. In other
words if you need to ask four questions before
answering the question then you currently have a total
of five answers but only one has the answer.

I think the issue of doing someone else's homework is
something that we have to try to discern for ourselves.
I don't think TR people should try to do this.

So I say the points make no difference and make
answers like threads in a discussion so that a question
and answer dialog can happen with only one 'answer
posted' to a given problem.

by mlayton

...is very muddled at best. When people post a technical question in Discussions, they are sometimes chased off in unnecessarily nasty replies, or less than informative replies which don't tell them actually where they should be posting their questions, just they shouldn't post them here. If I was a newbie who had been treated that way, there is a good chance I would not return to the Discussions AT ALL. Then, in Technical Q&A these "not so technical" topics have cropped up like managing your career, careers, etc and these seem like more viable topics for Discussions - including threads warning about infected e-mails (a general interest discussion topic with no question) - and I am surmising that some of the posters there are people who have been put off from the Discussions for whatever reason. I myself sometimes have to leave for a week because of the inappropriate put-downs and personal attacks I have seen which offer nothing to the discussion topics at all. It would be nice if everyone could maintain a level of professional courtesy and at least a minimal level of civility, but I recognize that probably won't happen, so sometimes I just take a break until I can stomach it again. And then I just avoid those posters in the future.

by oz_media

You have made nothing but false accusations and slandered the participants of this furm who do not agree with YOUR personal agenda.

You are simply pointing the finger and instilling blame on others without actually providing ant proof that such rantingoes on, your disingenious and unwarranted attack of TR peers will not go unnoticednor will it be accepted by those who feel that the discussion centre make for a good bitch session.

If you have nothing relevant to say, just keep your mouth shut or find a different topic to reply to, moron!

;-)

Is THAT what you're talking about ??:-)

Of COURSE I am only joking with you and certainly do not mean any of the above comments, just figured I'd emphasize your point. :-)

Have a good one,
OM

by oz_media

We have always been complaining about the need for an edit feature, better still, why doesn'tTR place an online typing tutor on the site.

We can be scored on correct WPM and a top five list similar to the Tech Q&A pounts scorers would give everyone a target to go for.

Then guys like myself who can speel but not type can at least improve our skills and thank TR for the help. You guys could be responsible for rasing the bar and helping IT staff all over the world improve their typing skills! Show me another site that does that, for free of course. ;-)

by mlayton

...even Hitler had to have an occasional bitch session! But really, you didn't use nearly enough four-letter words. Good thing it's Friday, I almost took offense :-)

By the same token, maybe we can separate "Technical miscellaneous" from "off -topic miscellaneous" and allow for some people with valid technical miscellaneous discussion topics to not get buried in the onslaught of Moore or Bush rants, or whatever the WAY off topic du jour is.

by mlayton

Very much. Thus endeth the confusion and the bizarre separation that keeps "Discussion" followers from ever seeing some of the valid questions/discussions in Tech Q&A and lets those that are avid "Tech Q&A" skimmers participate in discussions they may never have seen before! Recognizing that some people do one or the other, and for whatever reason, don't do both (I myself find the whole point thing confusing, and just answer whatever questions I can without caring whether they are rated or not.) And honestly, I find the current divisions in Tech Q&A a little strange - so for a long time I stopped going there at all!

by oz_media

Well that's great idea Jay,I can't wait to see it, and remember you are being held to your word.

Jay said, and that's all there is to it. ;-)

Actually it does sound like it would work, as long as there is separation of topics and they are followed.

I won't hold you to it, but it sounds as if you are at least proactively seeking out a better resolution.

Thanks for the update,
OM

by stress junkie

A while back I was lurking in a site about television
shows. They had a button on the page to post a reply
that would spell check your post before you submitted
it. I hate it when a typo makes me loook ignorant. :-)

by oz_media

Just kidding. I really couldn't care less when typos go out on a forum such as this, it would be nice to hae an edit feature, as well as a preview post feature like 99.999% of all forums.

But the Typing Tutor would be a fun in house competition. It would be an absolute miracle if I ever managed to learn to type well enough to compete but it would be a lot of fu, a GREAT service for TR to provide and an excellet excuse for those who have bosses wonderig why employees spend time on TR, "Because it is making my typing SO much better!"

by stress junkie

Gack. I posted a reply to one thing and then saw this
post. This idea is great. Threaded answers.

This is the second time I've done this today.

by sleepin'dawg

Now we can all understand the derivation of your handle. Ha HA Hee Hee, They're coming to take me away HA HA HO HO HEE HEE

by thechas

Well Jim,

It is summer and many people are on vacation.

This not only takes people away from their PCs, but leaves less free time for those at work who end up covering for those that are gone.

Then, with the nice weather, some decide to participate in outdoor activities that (gasp) don't involve a computer.

Chas

by tomsal

From the context I gleamed from "The Trivia Geek"'s post it seems like he works for TR.

If I'm wrong it wouldn't be the first time....

Anyway... I ALWAYS thought it strange, particularly for it being 2004 and this is a "tech site", that TR seems to have one of the most plain, boring, feature limited discussion boards out there.

If they want to do things better with discussion boards, take a look at the Internet's vast gamer's community. The game sites and hardware tweaking sites (mostly gamers who over clock their systems for max game performance)...they do it right.

by Jay Garmon

I am in fact a cog in the CNET machine. And we recognize that TR discussions aren't living up to their potential, which is why I and several others are working to improve the system.

What game sites, specifically, are you talking about, and what features would you like to see gleaned from their examples? We're paying attention, so speak up,

--Jay

by tomsal

On my other computer I could give you dozens of examples, but unfortunately that computer is down at the moment....

But the main feature I like (besides it just looks cooler) is how you are not limited by any kind of "max thread level" like the current TR board does. I like how you can create a profile, you can set a favorites list for threads you want to keep an eye on -- you have quick access to them just a single click. This is handy for threads that grow to be so popular they stay very active over many months. There is a thread at Gamespot (One of the gamer's sites I mentioned) that is over 900 pages (screens) long and includes well over 8000 posts for example. Another feature these boards offer is the ability to SEARCH. One thing about TR, again more an issue with the longer discussions, is you have to manually scroll to find someone's post that you saw before in order to reply to it.

There's also tons of "pretty features":

Custom color schemes
Custom Signatures (with graphics support)
Rich Text Format Compatible
HTML Compatible
Email Notification when someone replies to your post (VERY useful feature)

A list of the better done forums IMHO:

Checkout BioWare's community pages...

www.bioware.com

Gamespot (Granted some of their forum features have no place at a site more geared to be professional, but some features are useful)

www.gamespot.com

There's also www.guru3d.com, I like how their forum is as well.

There are so many examples I could provide....if only I had my other system up....but I think you'll get the drift from looking over at those sites.

Thanks for asking for feedback.

by oz_media

Beginfinite makes GWAVA (The bst network Anti-SPAM solution I've ever seen!).

Thier BBS is awesome, preview AND edit features!

It stacks nicely, is easy to follow and navigate.

I do like the tre view though, perhaps a tree view with the edit and preview features.

by oz_media

We have also had the suggestion of having a WATER COOLER section. Seeing as some peers are not North American we could call it the break room or something non North American.

by Jay Garmon

Thanks for the feedback TomSal. One of the most crucial issues we're dealing with right now is whether to use our current "tree" structure of threading (which you have correctly noticed has a max thread level nesting of 7), vs. a traditional linear structure like the phpbb system uses.

The tree structure does a great job of showing you the relationship between threads, but it's a bear to scroll through. The linear structure is very simple to read, but the post-reply relationships aren't very easily discerned, unless posters use quotations or we hyperlink back to the "referred" post.

Since we can't really decide, we'd love to know if there is an overwhelming preference among users, or if we should make this a toggle option, where users can switch between a linear and a tree view.

Any thoughts, gang?

--Jay

by oz_media

Now you're just teasing me!

You mean you would offer the best of BOTH worlds and let the users decide? Man, now there's a forum!

Sounds like you are being quite proactive Jay, I applaud your efforts and look forward to seeing ANY changes that improve TR's forums.

:-) Hey Jay, what other emoticons are working?

by sleepin'dawg

You're literally directing all the wishful thinkers and wannabees to the the places where the real techs hang out. Why, do you think its going to help them or confuse them further? What mad scheme is lurking at the root of your evil? Where is the method in this madness? Madness??? Yes, Madness I say!!!:) :( ;)

by Jay Garmon

Another reader posted this in a separate discussion, but it seemd fairly relevant.

"1. How do I send feedback to you? (I may have overlooked it, but I can't find a link anywhere.)

"2. Feedback: I might enjoy reading and participating in your discussions more (like the one on the ex-con who what to become a sysadmin) if they were easier to read. At home I'm on a dial up line, and having to fetch a new page for each comment (along with your format "overhead") is just not acceptable. How about an option to fetch some number of comments at once (like all, 10, 25, 50 or whatever)?

"(My style of browsing on the dial up line is to call up a page then go read some other page that I previously called up, then switch to some other page that I've previously called up. It is much better for me when a page calls up all the relevant comments.)

"regards,
"Randy Kramer

"PS: What, and no preview button?"

The new linear discussion view we've been developing would place five to ten posts on a single page, but would hide the post connections that are visible in the current tree view. Would this format make you more or less likely to use the discussion center, and if it is preferable, would it increase or merely streamline your discussion activity?

Thanks

--Jay

This discussion is closed to new replies.