Discussion Locked

Is it time to get rid of anonymous comments once and for all?

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Read this piece from Slate:

Troll, Reveal Thyself: Why we need to get rid of anonymous comments.
http://www.slate.com/id/2287739/

This is a really hot topic among online publications right now. Inside TechRepublic we've been having conversations about this for a couple years. The Facebook phenomenon is moving the Web away from anonymous commenting and toward people representing themselves more transparently online.

There are good arguments to be made that when people have their own name and reputation attached to their comments then you have a lot fewer trolls and personal attacks. The flipside is that you sometimes get less-honest dialog, and you have people who have a lot of reputation on the line in the real world who would be less willing to participate.

What do you think?

53 replies

by martyn jones (uk)

Yes, if people have something to say, say it. They shouldn't hide behind an anonymous name. Facebook is not foot proof. These anonymous users could just create a fake account though.

by jasonhiner

There would certainly be people who would still use fake names (just like they do on Facebook), but if the default would be that a person's real name is used and that would drastically cut down on the general anonymity.

by emmess55

yes - if you have something worth saying, it's worth standing behind - if you can't stand behind it, it isn't worth saying

by deadly ernest

pressure to not be known to be talking can be hard and being anonymous is often the only way to let the truth out.

by jamesrl

I don't think it should be a "blanket" ban. But if your website is set up for serious discussions, then having a sign on should be manditory.

I do think that I wouldn't use my real name here, if you recall what happened to me here when I did. But my login is tied to a verified email address so there is some accountability.

by robo_dev

With anonymity, people really tell you what they think and feel, no holds barred.

Obviously, though, the issues with this are:

a) those who are 'a few fries short of a happy meal' can post some interesting and/or disturbing stuff.
b) trolls, and trolls who pretend to be somewhat insane.
c) sock puppets. Sock puppets are fake personas created to promote or defend a particular cause or point of view.

But of course, some of the above lunacy can make it interesting, as sometime it can be fun to watch two (alleged) people of very different opinions lock horns,

The 64 Million dollar question is if you make people post under their 'real names', how do you verify that they are not lying, or using someone else's account?

The challenge of verifying identity is a extremely difficult. The whole basis of everything from airport security to online banking security is all about how you identify a person with some degree of confidence.

At the same time, how do you make it easy to use without compromising privacy?

by xultan

Posting anonymous because there are sometimes a comment needs to be heard and the consequences of any identifiable information may cost the poster. No just whistle blowing, but negative comments against an company, employer or client may backfire. Discretion is always needed. Take the comments of city employees posting on Facebook.

by techrepublic

It really depends on the level of transparency that would be expected and what the topic of conversation is. If you're asking for the status of the IT staffing environment, it might make sense to allow more anonymity so that people can be safe to post an honest assessment without fear of a backlash from coworkers or employers.

That said, I'm in general agreement that there needs to be more transparency in general so that (at least some) people will think twice before engaging in a flame war or deciding to spew nonsense just to see how it turns out.

by seanferd

1. Solves nothing. Trolls will be trolls, regardless.

2. Exposes an endless number of people to trolls and more dangerous types, like stalkers. (If you are a privileged white, straight, Christian male, you probably won't get this - fie on you.) Did we all not just tell Blizzard how absolutely retarded this idea is?

by tech2734

The posters on Blizzard's forums are not completely anonymous. There is SOME accountability. I don't feel that someone should have the ability to track you down in real life from your posts.

by ansugisalas

Sounds more like an "Amen" to me... but then I haven't been going to church much since they stopped paying me to...

by jasonhiner

Trolls rarely show up when they have to use their real names. This has been shown in multiple instances in recent years, with Facebook being the most obvious. Look at TechCrunch. Since they switched to using Facebook for commenting, its trolls have almost completely disappeared.

I'm not advocating for it (at least not yet), but getting rid of trolls is one of the main benefits of moving away from anonymous comments. The problem is the collateral damage (less participation in some cases, people aren't always as brutally honest, etc.).

by deadly ernest

of government identification to open an account on a forum, anyone can create a false identity. Hell, I recently created a false Internet identity for a friend so they could get in and do things without their ex being able to track them via their Internet activities. As far as everyone else is concerned the name on the 'confirmed' email address and forum membership is legal and valid - but it's totally bogus, and took me about two hours to create, mostly waiting for the confirmation emails to arrive before moving onto the next stage.

by keighlar

There are still those of us out there that do not have, nor do we ever want a Facebook account. So... in order to post on our favorite forums we would have to do so? I don't think so. There are enough regulations forced upon our persons no matter what direction we turn. This would be one instance, since it's still in my purview, where I would refrain from participation rather than being regulated into a corner. We have little enough latitude left to make our own decisions. Facebook is a privacy nightmare. I think even if one was living under a rock for the past few years, they would still be aware of that.

by tech2734

Definitely! I can only imagine how much better the ENTIRE internet experience would be if people were actually held accountable for the garbage they spew all over the place

by ansugisalas

Like the way the spammers and botmasters are held accountable for the garbage they spew all over the place?
Less protection of privacy is not the way to go... it will only make it all the more of a sport for malicious people to hack honest people's accounts. There's absolutely No Point in making that particular lane of crime even more appealing!

by jasonhiner

Some people will still create false identities, but if the default is to use your real name then it tends to change the overall atmosphere and expectations.

by deadly ernest

it possible for them to find any dissenters and for shutting the rest up. Goodbye freedom of speech, commerade.

by trotter516

I can see both sides of the coin on this one.

While Facebook uses real names (supposedly), it is a closed community where you choose who will be in your own little realm. Sharing your real name with only those you choose, while still a bit risky, is not a show stopper.

This changes when you step out of that closed garden into the Internet proper where any one can sign up and post away... or can copy and paste and steal your words as their own... or can somehow be upset at you and take it upon themselves to "get you". Identity theft is almost child's play nowadays and professionals have much more to lose than most in this area.

by deadly ernest

court orders to take down because they'd been created by people pretending to be the person named? I've heard of several in the news over the years.

by bbyrd

Represent yourself otherwise your opinion means less than what it should. Not saying that being anonymous doesn't have it place and not saying that I myself am tempted to leave anonymous comments. If I can't leave my name then I shouldn't leave the comment. That is what my 21st century mama taught me ;o)

by charliespencer

I can't see it being more than locally enforceable. There will always be people willing and able to set up forum sites where anonymity is allowed, regardless of what TR, Facebook, etc. choose to do.

by deadly ernest

Microsoft and Intel the help they need to force the full power of Palladium (Secured Computing) down people's throats and totally lock them into using proprietary software only via having to register their computer with the central agency they control. Once the law says you must identify, then it's a simple push to MAKE the computer do an identification on every post and document it makes or handles. Man, Bill first put that up back in 1995 and got howled at then and twice since, but this will help him get it through.

by charliespencer

Neither Jason's original article nor I mention any laws. I'm unaware of any pending legislation in this country. If web sites mandate this on their own, they could actually make the case that an industry's self-enforcement is already ahead of what the law currently requires (which is nothing). Congress here is big on not passing regulations on industries when they give even the appearance of being self-policing.

Requiring a name (and often a city and state) never kept people from writing letters to the editor.

by p.f. bruns

Bill Gates has retired from Microsoft. If anyone there would have to put this through a fourth time, it would be Steve Ballmer--and he's just the rat bastard to do it.

by tony hopkinson

(this may come as surprise), there are some things I won't say. :p

I don't value anonynimity in this forum, but I see no particular need to deprive those who do.

by ansugisalas

For example, there are very few people in the world with my first- and last name combination... I guess there's a German person with a PhD with the same name tag, but that's about it.
So, if I use my own name, and not this "hostage of the aesir" tweak of it, then it would be very easy for people to find me...
So, with my real name showing I would think twice about standing up to bad guys, like that nazi sympathizer of a few weeks back... they have social media too, you know.
If there were enough John Smiths to do the cleaning, then ok. But there isn't.

by hal 9000

Jason_Hiner I will continue to post as I please and not worry about being the victim of Attack or theft.

NBL and it's not going to happen any time soon. FB is only good for showing just how stupid that Idea actually was and is a perfect example of why not to go down that path since it's now being used to Attack people.

OH BTW Jason you won $750.000.00 just send me a Peer Mail or reply here and I'll arrange to start the process to transfer the money into your Bank Account.

Yea Sure like that's going to happen. :D

Col

by deadly ernest

I register with my real name, and Deadly has been my nickname for over 40 years. I use my real name on the forums, but advocate that people have the right to remain anonymous if they wish to. I know of many cases of cyber stalking and also of ex-spouses tracking people through their Internet activity. If I choose NOT to use my real name, that's my legal right. The only reason forum managers want people to register with legal names and use them is so they can save themselves some trouble by NOT having to moderate posts the way they should where they allow anonymous posts.

In a recent local news item, people were threatened with reduced severance payouts if they spoke to the media about the sackings going on. Plenty of anonymous comments in the papers and forums by employees, comments giving the dirty details on why the sackings, comments that are going to cost the big bosses in the way of cut backs in golden handshake payouts during the sell out. none of that would have been possible to make public if they could not have done so anonymously.

by bsharpe37

FIRST!! ... NOT!!!

Don't you hate seeing these? I would say It's time to give the trolls the boot.

by nelson.robert9

If people would actually be honest and count to 10(maybe 100 in some cases)before flaming someone they don't (more than likely)even personally know it would make things more pleasant on the web.

by tony hopkinson

is useful traffic generating technique. If we waited to know someone before burning them up, it wouldn't happen.
Course there's a difference beween playing the uproar game with a post like
Linux is the greatest OS ever, to a personal attack on someone who points out one or two flaws in your argument...
I don't have a problem with flaming as long the pople doing it are prepared to take what they give...

by p.f. bruns

Then we can dispense with anonymity.

Right now, the sad fact is that we can't, not everywhere.

by nicknielsen

Knowing they are getting attention. Even if it's only to be called "troll," trolls love responses.

I was anonymous on TR for 5 years. I don't think anybody reading my recent posts would have any difficulty seeing that the same person wrote those older posts. Maybe I'm the exception.

by deadly ernest

Microsoft and others won't jump on the band wagon to have it made into law?

Also, newspapers have been accepting anonymous letters to the editor for centuries, they simply moderate, and sometimes censor, them before publication. The current problems have come from, in mind, forum admins allowing anonymous posts on unmoderated boards leading to some nasty personal things being said - remember that discussion a couple of years back about the newspaper wanting to apply the reporter's shield law and not give up details of a poster on their board who'd accused a woman of a crime when she hadn't. I never did hear how that court case came out.

by nicknielsen

Most of the print media doesn't publish anonymous submissions; the writer of a letter must include name, address, and phone number, for verification. Writers may request that their letter be published as "Name withheld" or "Anonymous", but I don't know of any print media that will publish letters without first verifying the author.

by deadly ernest

attributed to an anonymous person. If the content is very contentious or borders on liable etc, then it doesn't even get printed. But I've seen anonymous letter and media forum posts down here for years. The issue comes in the forums that don't want to check or moderate the posts before display - I know of some that insisted on traceable contact details that have dried up as people do NOT always like being identified by strangers.

by deadly ernest

the general industry telling them to get lost. A general industry movement supporting this sort of thing will only make their case for heavy laws stronger - the same sort of laws now in place that allows the corporations to put a rootkit on a music CD and can get you sent to prison for using software to get around the rootkit.

by who am i really

so far all have good points,

however it always comes back to the person behind the keyboard

- I never use any real info on any site I sign up to
- I don't troll
- I don't post inappropriate content etc.

and it all comes back down to:

"You can't legislate or force Morality"

that's up to each individual person to become a reasonable and responsible citizen of where ever they live and whatever communities online or otherwise they participate in

There are trolls in real life who will spout off sarcasm, profanity etc. to your face

by dogknees

Until we can replace it with a mechanism that allows people under repressive regimes to post without fear of being identified. It's this ability that helped bring down the iron curtain, and other regimes.

Anonymity has valid uses. Don't desert these people.

by deadly ernest

The first three versions of Palladium were direct from gates, hell he spoke of them at conventions - he still pushes them and controls major corporate policy and policy direction as a board member.

by ansugisalas

There should be a civil disobedience campaign... hand out CDs with "tools of the crime" (even possession is a crime, you know) to everybody...
You got totc?
Yeah, you know me!

by nicknielsen

In the early days, everybody knew who you were on line. Now, not so much.

In my experience, print media has always required confirmatory data from the writer, or they don't publish the letters.

by deadly ernest

has always accepted and printed letters from anonymous authors as long as it didn't lead to a clear case of libel.

As to on-line, in the early days of the Internet the closest you got to a forum was a news group and about 95% of the people fudged their headers to hide who they were. People using true ID on the Internet has grown, but not at a fats pace. I suspect a lot of it has been more a case of too lazy to hide than a real intent to be upfront - especially with the social networks where you want to use them to reconnect with people.

This discussion is closed to new replies.