Discussion Locked

Is Magic Jack worth $40? (have you used one?)

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm sure you've seen their irritating ads on TV. Ok, what product's ads are NOT irritating, except for the occasionally clever one?

It's a neat idea: a hardware device that hooks up to any broadband inet conx and is instantly ready to use, you can hook up a regular phone to it for your 'voice interface'.

They claim PC Week or some other major reviews positive,

=== but ===

a search for +"magic jack" +complaint
comes up with 13,100 hits
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%2B%22magic+jack%22+%2Bcomplaint&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=

Anyone used this?
should I just go with one of the free PC VoIP softwares?

I have a cell phone, and would just use it occasionally for really long calls. For example was talking to someone about website related matters for 40 minutes the other day, and almost ran down my cell phone battery to zero. Or for the occasional stupid webinar that DOESN'T do web streaming sound. (they are usually 40 minutes to an hour and some like to have people on phone so they can talk to them more easily as not everyone has a mic hooked up to their PC for voice)

1) have you used the Magic Jack?

2) are you STILL using the Magic Jack if you did get one?

3) one ocmplaint said 'staticy' - is the connection staticy all the time or just in some places?

4) does comcast or others try to sabotage it so they can sell their own VoIP?

5) do you need to install any software on a PC or does it just work 'as it' without PC booted?

6) I read some customer service horror stories online, are they apocrophyl (bogus) or real like dell due to their apparent huge volume?

7) anything else I didn't think of you want to say about it?

we're all trying to save money in this down economy, will this save me money or is it an utter waste?

6 replies

by .martin.

I have never used one but my thoughts on it are as follows:

I would NEVER buy anything that is advertised off the TV, unless it were stocked in a major store.

besides, most of the things advertised on the tv (other than being annoying - Go Duster, Ab King PRO, and FinallyFAst) don't seem to work as 'fantastically' as the ad would like you to believe

by dwerhart

I ordered one because I want to try it out. I will post back after I test it for a while.

by justmytwocents

1: so i have one---yes
2: do i still use it---yes
3: my connection is fine, no static
4: can't answer
5: the software is on the jump drive and if you move it to another computer, it installs off of the jump drive
6: can't answer about customer service, have not had to call them. I have had/used the magic jack since november 2008.
There has only been one issue and that is some of them disconnect after one hour. my sister also has one that i got her for Christmas. hers disconnects, mine does not. we only live a couple of miles apart. I do all the upgrades as they come out, I don't know if she does or not.
They have a money back guarantee if I remember correctly. I think different people in different areas have issues with it, mine works fine, i live in bay area of florida. Hope this helps.

by dr dij

I may get one as a back, 'landline'.

Like I said would cut my cell phone bills.
This last 40 minute call may cost me the price of one of these.

Great info!

by gandhawk55

I have used my Magic jack phone for 18 months and have nothing but praise for it. My wife and I both have cell phones and do not use a home phone very often. Magic Jack is a great compliment to people who primarily use cell phones. I got tired of receiving calls on my cell phone from companies that need a phone number but I do not need to talk to. Ex. Banks, Comcast, ect... Voice mails are automatically sent to my email address. The voice quality is excellent on both ends. I even gave a second cordless handset to my children who live next door. I do not have to worry about killing my cell phone battery on long calls since I installed the Magic jack. I have heard people complain that they have to leave the computer on all the time. When I am home my computers are on anyway. If I am not the computers are off and the voice message is emailed to me. I actually do not answer my Magic Jack phone. I use for outgoing calls only. I have read quite a bit of complaints from people about customer service and performance. I have had good customer service and the unit works perfectly. I plan on giving 2 or 3 as presents for Christmas this year.

This discussion is closed to new replies.