Discussion Locked

Is Microsoft directly responsible for declining salaries in IT?

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm no economist or financial analyst, but here is how I link Microsoft to declining salaries in IT:

Windows Vista requiring more expensive hardware and a complete desktop application overhaul will require IT departments to stretch their IT budgets thin for new equipment purchases, leaving less money for salary increases of the IT folks supporting these systems. IT departments are 99.9% of the times seen as cost centers and have to squeeze every dollar and cent out of the corporation to get anything done. With Windows Vista requiring serious hardware upgrades, we can surely see our salaries go down the toilet, as companies will allocate more money towards hardware instead of paying the folks that keep it all running.

39 replies

by onbliss

...companies could move away from Microsoft and evaluate/choose other operating systems. A demand for professionals who have mastered those operating systems would raise.

by why me worry?

and switch to open source, simple because the idea of running an O/S whose kernel source code can be easily modified, scares the crap out the CIO. Companies want a proprietary O/S that cannot be easily modified by the average Joe, even if the O/S is inherently insecure, as is Windows in this case.

by nsizelove

As soon as a new OS such as Vista is taught to the offshore support companies then the competition becomes noticeable. More help desks channel their support offshore these days, either part time for the lulls in the night or all day long. I think this is where the real salary crunch lies. The offshore companies always bid lower than a budgeted in-house staff.

by onbliss

Then it only means the companies need to be convinced even more about the benefits of open source or other operating systems. Companies, in general, want to get their business done.

by charliespencer

"the idea of running an O/S whose kernel source code can be easily modified, scares the crap out the CIO."

No, the idea of running an OS without a knowledgeable vendor support structure scares the crap out of a CIO. They want to know they can call a vendor and jump his case when there's a problem. They don't want an OS whose support structure consists of posting a question on a web site and waiting for an answer. RH and Novell SUSE don't scare CIOs.

Incidentally, your metaphor is mangled. Companies don't suckle from MS. But many apparently are willing to allow MS to continue feeding from them instead of weaning it off.

by neon samurai

They always gotta have a scapegoat to strangle if things go bad. "If our systems fail, we can sue the hell out of the support provider to get our losses back"

First, the idea is not to have your systems go down in the first place.

Second, the support contract or EULA more than likely specifies that no punitive actions can be taken in the even of a failure.

So, this is really ass-backwards thinking to get a false sence of security by purchasing a brand name rather than a quality product.

I've been re-reading alot of Eric Raymond the last few weeks though so this BS about not considering FOSS solutions because of blind brand loyalty to MS/Apple is pretty fresh in mind.

::Off Topic::
If you've not read them, I highly recommend any tech perso read a minimum of the following at least for personal interest.
- cathedral and the bazaar
- magic couldron
- hackers revenge
- homesteading the noosphere

by techbro

I think the long-term strategy for any IT person is going to be in the area of using the tools more than servicing the infrastructure.

With Vista (from what I can tell so far) and the 2007 upgrades of the MS suite of apps, if you become an expert in putting all of the MS technologies to work in a way that increases productivity (and maybe axes someone elses job) you will be employed for quite awhile.

For example, if you can tie SharePoint/Exchange/ and Outlook into some type of collaboration and knowledge management system for your company, you could get paid for developing the solution from the business side and managing it from the infrastructure side. Plus you can make good money on the side peddaling your expertise to the SMB market.

Just another viewpoint.

by neon samurai

And.. once you get them on a complete Micorsoft solution, you know they'll be calling you weekly for support issues, they'll be forced to upgrade at Microsoft's whim (can you say re-taxation? ChaaCHING) and they'll have a near impossible time ever considering a different solution because all user data files will be tied to a specific software tool rather than open and usable under any tool providing the same function.

k.. think I'm done on this comment stream.. anything more may be percieved as trolling which is furthest from my intentions.

by charliespencer

I'm only one voice, but I don't perceive anything you've said as trolling. I may not agree with you, but you're raising interesting points.

by slappymcnasty

From where I sit, overall IT salaries are not declining. Sure we took a hit back in the 2000-2001 time frame, but I think that was a good correction (remember the days of the 70k a year HTML writing job?).
Development tools, monitoring tools, networking tools are getting better. The first Network I ever set up was a 6 system token ring on Novell 3.1, that was just plain difficult. Now to get 6 computers talking you buy a hub, plug them in and bam, network done.
This simplification creates a commodity of entry level workers, thus lowering wages in that area. However, security is more complex so there is a new gig that pays a little better. Applications are getting more complex but the tools to write the pieces are better. The Jr Java Jocks writing each small piece are a commodity, but the senior guys wrapping it all together are expensive.
As each new tool simplifies some aspect of IT, it gets closer to a commodity. However, each new tool also introduces the need for the senior guy who really gets it.
You want a better salary, be one of those senior guys, the opportunities are boundless.

by jdmercha

As computer companies produce better products, they take less IT personel to maintain them. Less demand plus more supply from overseas results in lower salaries.

by charliespencer

"Windows Vista requiring more expensive hardware and a complete desktop application overhaul ... "

You're assuming IT departments are going to replace existing systems just to run Vista. Most IT departments will continue to run 2K or XP for another 12 - 18 months minimum. They'll continue installing those operating systems on new equipment, even equipment that comes with Vista pre-loaded, until some department needs an application that requires Vista.

You're also assuming companies care about putting the top-level version of Vista Pro on users' desktops, with all the eye candy many businesses will consider unnecessary. The new equipment will probably be compatible with the lowest version of Vista Pro since companies only require full multimedia capabilites on a minimum number of systems.

You also assume they'll feel compelled to load Office 2007. They'll continue to load Office 2003 since it will run under Vista and ignore 2007 until they've tested it and their enterprise license agreements are up for renewal.

In other words, they'll buy new hardware at the same annual turnover rate they've been buying it, with the same level of hardware capabilities, running the XP and the same software wherever possible. By the time they've tested Vista and the first service pack has been released, the hardware costs will have come down to levels considered reasonable by corporate check writers. No change in hardware or software spending habits, no change in the proportion of IT budgets spent on salaries as a result of Vista.

by neon samurai

Microsoft is the greatest thing to happen to independent tech support isn't it? As we used to say back at the value added reseller, if it wasn't for microsoft, w wouldn't be visiting the client weekly on billable time. We'd sell them a system and it would just work until the next hardware upgrade or office expansion.

by drowningnotwaving

It's a good point - salaries that is. Always worthy of discussion.

But I can remember reading the same thing about IBM's dominance in the 80's, with the decline of the 'bunch' and the increasing strength of Fuj and Amdahl.

Then in the '90s the emerging "open" environment with Unix and (in some small bits of the planet) Pick.

In both cases the argument was the dominance of one particular direction would result in commodity prices for salaries. See Slappy's discussion.

{And as an aside, wouldn't you hate your parents for naming you Dick Pick???}.

Easily remedied by new skills, keeping up certifications, or getting out of hardware/OS-centric positions (e.g moving upwards or sideways into project manager / director, business analyst).

That, and compromising photos of your boss. My salary never looked better.

by neon samurai

You'd think that more robust systems at 30% the cost of proprietary solutions (including staffing your own support staff instead of farming it out) would get more interest from CIOs.

It's unfortunate. Management repeatedly chooses the solution that competes with flashy marketing rather than the solution that competes based on quality.

But then, consider how many competing tech products have won based on marketing rather than quality; it's nothing new.

by neon samurai

If your IT structure goes down, you've already failed. Seaking punitive damages is reactionary and irrelevent.

Yes, they want a scape goat to point at but in reallity, they chose the scape goats marketing campain and are ultimately responsible for it's failing.

It's far cheaper to bring support back inhouse (you know, hire knowledable and experiences staff like most of us reading this site) or as you mentioned, look at RH or Suse rather than continue paying taxes to Redmond.

The proprietary model they seel software under is fundamentally flawed against the end user in the first place. (I'd love to ramble on but it's not my personal conclusion; see Eric Raymond's Magic Couldron for a discussion of failures in the model).

For years it's been software engineers pushing up the chain of command to try and convince CIO to look away from Redmond (we may even see som real innovation and quality assurance from MS as a result). It's been very accurately observed that the push needs to go the othe way, CIO have to be asking there managers and engineers why better solutions where not included in the RFI.

So, how do we better the busnesses we work for and improve information systems by breaking through the MS colour classes so many CIO still wear?

by charliespencer

I wasn't implying CIO's were looking for someone to sue. I meant they were looking for someone with an organized support structure.

I'll check the Eric Raymond reference you gave, but I'm going to be hard to convince the proprietary software model is fundamentally flawed when MS and others are making lots of money with it. Don't take this to mean I think it is the only way to make money with software, just that despite its flaws proprietary software has apparently been a successful model so far.

As to your last question, there used to be an axiom, "No one was ever fired for buying IBM." Some have replaced 'IBM' with 'Microsoft' as a management principle.

by neon samurai

Isn't that the truth. Poney up to the favourite bar in town and no one will question you.

I'm also happy to see more "structured support" becomeing available outside of the proprietary markets. One interesting company recently in the news (name escapes me currently) is a service provider with broad base of FOSS vendors. They look at your needs then assemble and support a custom solution and OS distribution. For proprietary, the program is the product. For FOSS, the service is the product. I fully agree that a mature software market will be service based rather than product based.

There's no arguing that Microsoft hasn't robbed a fortune from the users. One of the arguments posed by Mr. Raymond goes like this:

With proprietary software, you ideally want a product that sells but does not get used; pretty on a shelf but usless once installed.

All profits to cover the expense of the product and ongoing support costs are generated by the initial sale. After that, it's all expense except for some short term support contracts (Is microsoft still supporging winNT4 or win2k? hense, short term.)

You make your big income peak then move your developers to "the new version" or next product in line when profit margins shrink. The new product goes out the door and you get another income peak.

But then, users see value in continued support not in buying a new version to replace the old unsupported version. As soon as you anounce a the new version, the old version sales drop. Vista is out, how are the winXP sales doing and for how long?

To get back to the second part of that the ideal product; usless in practice. You want it pretty on a shelf, you want customers to buy it but you don't want teh ongoing expense of supporting it in call centers. So ideally, it should be purchases and never used.

I don't due the argument justice by any means but that's part of the gist of it.

by abrunsvold

Do not forget to add the rest of the quote:
"...you can buy better, but you cannot spend more."

by der tommissar

Management wants to hear stuff like, "Ok, we've got the platinum ultra-secret VIP Dragon support contract. Within five minutes of us opening a level 1 ticket, five unwashed dudes will immediately break from their D&D game in mom's basement and airdrop to our site with replacement parts and patches and code fixes and whatever else it will take fix the problem.

They don't want to hear, "Well, I posted our problem on comp.sci.linfix.uberopensource, but I'm figuring we're going to have to wait for the discussion to die down on alt.scifi.battlestargalactica about who was a better Starbuck before we get a reply."

And yes, I know those are stereotypes. I play Twilight:2000 in mom's basement, for example.

Linux's marketshare has increased in direct proportion to companies like redhat offering some sort of support service.

by rrusson

Will any of us have decent salaries when employers shift from 386s and 486s to Pentiums? Or if they move from DOS to Windows NT? Run for your lives!!!

by neon samurai

I don't even agree with me fully but that's what keeps me learning. I woudn't say that the proprietary model in iteslf is the inherent flaw but the way in which it is implemented is not often in the end user's best interest.

I start to question my writting when I've replided to multiple threads, espectially with similar content. Cheers, for the peer review.

by charliespencer

"... the proprietary model ... is not often in the end user's best interest."

I question any business or business model that claims it does what it does because it's in the customers' interest. Companies should always be working for the shareholders / owners' profitability. Now the best way to do that is often to work to the customers' benefit, but pleasing the customer is just one technique to improve the shareholders' financial position.

Never trust a corporate mission statement that doesn't include some mention of making money.

by rrusson

Besides the laughable assertion that new systems and software hurt IT, there's another flaw in this illogic. Businesses feel no compelling need to move to Vista at the moment. The sky is obviously not falling.

by mpasaa

I don't think IT salaries will ever decline. However, I can see a time where the OS and Applications that M$ puts out experience less and less issues as they have since the WFW days.

What I see is more contractors and less employees. From a business standpoint it makes more sense to use contractors on a break-fix type of set up OR as an onsite person that doesn't have to have benefits and such.

I understand the value of IT but I am in IT. I don't care which road they take because there will ALWAYS be a need for competent, technical folks certified or not.

No worries people, we aren't going anywhere ;-)

Peace!!

by rkuhn040172

To compare today with days gone by.

Today's systems and networks are so much more complex and require much more attention.

In addition, it's hardly fair to place all the blame on Microsoft. With today's interconnected world, hackers have much more motivation including $ than they did say 10, 15, 20 years ago.

How many banking websites were there 10 years ago? And how many people used them?

How many corporate networks were connected to the internet compared to today? Of those, how many allowed more or less unfettered use to their employees?

How many handhelds, Palms, smart phones, etc did people have 10, 15, 20 years ago?

Give me a break. Poor comparison at best.

by pchatelle

Let me get this out, I love Microsoft, but I feel sorry for my users at the same time. All the cool stuff Vista was supposed to have (mainly the new file system) didn't happen. So it's a new shell, does it really take much more in resources? No, not really. But then again you get XP on a system that does stand-by properly, and it to can boot in seconds too. So I a pretty sure the salary dollars are safe, but it does make the outlook much brighter, for US based techs. I have been running at the top of my scale for years, it goes up 2%-4% a year. The few times I have had to look for a job, they are out there, but if you are a newbie be prepared to suffer. Coming up in the 80's as a newbie was great! Now not so much, because with India and the company sponsered "University Degrees", you've got a bunch of low-balling newbie's with "Masters" degree's.

Sorry and good luck.

by 50kilroy

It is not the cost of hardware that is causing I.T. salaries to decline. Hardware is cheap and is routinely upgraded on a two or three year cycle.
The problem with declining I.T. salaries is the Micro$oft toilet-paper MCSE certifications.
Anyone, and I do mean anyone including an eight year old kid a couple of years ago, can be a Micro$oft "engineer" just by learning how to pass one of their "exams".
Approximately $1500.00 US and six weeks in a
"MCSE boot camp" and you are an "engineer".
These paper tigers are inexperienced, know absolutely NOTHING about computers in general, NOTHING about troubleshooting, NOTHING about support for either hardware or user, but they will work for nothing.
A kid like that thinks $10.00 or $12.00/hour is great money, so the HR depts hire them, rather than someone who can actually do the job.

by rkuhn040172

So is that really MS's fault or the HR depts around the country who whore out their positions for an inferior employee?

by vrao

If the companies will spend so much money on New Hardware they will need people for the roll out. More roll outs means more people are required, higher demand equals higher price. I guess this is just a bit of MS phobia

by mr.newman

That will be foolish to serve expenicive equipments with law salaries. As a IT folk we should always convience people who control our salaries that "having expenicive equipments is half of the way the more important who will support it" so we should keep our mark high always.

by maxwell edison

You're no economist or financial analyst.

By the way, if your salary's going down, not up (and at least in the 3% to 5% annual range), it may be time for a self-evaluation. (No slam, we should all do one every year or two.)

by rkuhn040172

Apparently, he also believes that all this more and more expensive/complex equipment is going to self-manage, self-fix, and eventually not self-destruct.

Good god, I'm I the only one tired of listening to the IT field moan and groan and complain that they aren't getting the salaries and wages of 1998-2001?

You want the pay? Get off your arses and get the training, experience and dedication needed to get the job done and stop complaining.

This discussion is closed to new replies.